| Literature DB >> 35494952 |
Ibrahim M Dighriri1, Khaled M Alhusayni1, Ahmed Y Mobarki2, Ibrahim S Aljerary3, Khalid A Alqurashi4, Fai A Aljuaid4, Khalid A Alamri5, Abeer A Mutwalli3, Nada A Maashi6, Alwaleed M Aljohani7, Abdulrahman M Alqarni7, Athbah E Alfaqih8, Sumiya M Moazam9, Muath N Almutairi10, Afnan N Almutairi11.
Abstract
Vaccinations prevented severe clinical complications of COVID-19. It was considered a vital component of living endemically with COVID-19. The Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine is the first mRNA-based vaccination that enhances immunity. Resulting in various adverse effects that may emerge after vaccination. This systematic review was undertaken to assess the Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine side effects by reviewing the previous studies. A total of 107 PubMed and Google Scholar publications were screened for Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 vaccine side effects. Fourteen articles met the study inclusion criteria. The included searching terms were a combination of "Pfizer vaccine and Side effects," "BioNTech vaccine and side effects," and "BNT162b2 vaccine and side effects," as well as all synonyms. The total number of participants in the 14 studies was 10,632 participants. Average of the most frequent side effects of 14 studies were injection site pain 77.34%, fatigue 43%, muscle pain 39.67%, local swelling 33.57%, headache 33.27%, joint pain 25.75%, chills 18.34%, fever 18%, itching 9.38%, lymph nodes swelling 7.86%, nausea 7.58%, dyspnea 7.86%,and diarrhea 6.36%. The average side effects after the first dose were 79% compared with 84% after the second dose. The average occurs side effects in females at 69.8% compared with males 30.2%. Our study reveals that side effects after the Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine are common, but they are usually mild and self-limited. Local reactions like pain at the injection site are the most common. Anaphylactic shock or severe reactions are rare. We hope that our results will reassure the public that the benefits of vaccination far exceed the dangers. Also, help reduce vaccine hesitancy among individuals worried about vaccine safety and possible adverse effects.Entities:
Keywords: allergic reaction; biontech covid-19 vaccine; bnt162b2 vaccine.; pfizer vaccine; side effects
Year: 2022 PMID: 35494952 PMCID: PMC9039171 DOI: 10.7759/cureus.23526
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Cureus ISSN: 2168-8184
Figure 1Study selection process using preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses (PRISMA).
Figure 2The number of participants in each study who received the Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine and reported at least one or more side effects.
The characterization of included studies in the systematic review.
| Author and publication year | Method | Result and main findings |
| Mohammed et al. [ | A cross-sectional study involving adults of various ages and genders. Between February and March 2021, a validated questionnaire was distributed via social networking sites to Saudi Arabian residents via a Google form. | The subjects were predominantly Saudi nationals (95.3 %) and were almost gender-balanced. Subjects had to be at least 18 years old. Local pain (79.3%), fatigue (42%), muscle pain (39%), local swelling (27.7%), joint pain (23.1%), headache (21.8%), fever (21.0%), chills (15.5%), local redness (14.8%), and nausea (7.3%) were the most frequently reported symptoms, with no reports of anaphylaxis, facial paralysis, or syncope. Following the second dose, there were more adverse events than following the first (p<0.001). Female gender more significant number of side effects following both vaccine doses. |
| Riad et al. [ | Between January and February 2021, a cross-sectional survey of healthcare employees in the Czech Republic was undertaken. A validated questionnaire with twenty-eight multiple-choice questions was employed in the investigation. | The mean age of respondents was 42.56 ±10.5 years old. The most frequently reported adverse events were pain at the injection site (89.8%), fatigue (62.2%), headache (45.6%), muscle pain (37.1%), and chills (33.9%). Adverse events were more common in the 43-year-old group, and their duration was mostly one day (45.1%) or three days (35.8%) after the immunization. Individuals who got two doses saw a statistically significant increase in adverse events. In terms of length, 45.1 % of all adverse effects lasted less than a day. By contrast, 35.8% lasted three days, 9.4 % lasted five days, 5.3 % lasted one week and 3% lasted more than a week. |
| Kadali et al. [ | The side effects of the BNT162b2 vaccine were investigated in a randomized, cross-sectional study using an independent online questionnaire distributed to healthcare workers (HCWs). | Of all HCWs, 64.5% (803/1245) received the BNT162b2 vaccine and reported side effects. localized symptoms, 719/803 (89.54%); generalized symptoms, 610/803 (75.97%). musculoskeletal symptoms, 428/803 (53.3%); gastrointestinal symptoms, 172/803 (21.42%); psychological symptoms, 133/803 (16.56%); neurological symptoms, 102/803 (12.7%); head/ear/eyes/nose/throat symptoms, 97/803 (12.08%); endocrine symptoms, 83/803 (10.34%); cardiovascular symptoms, 48/803 (5.98%); respiratory symptoms, 21/803 (2.61%) and urinary symptoms, 10/803 (1.24%). |
| El-Shitany et al. [ | A Google Form questionnaire gathered a cross sectional study conducted retrospectively. All participants were Saudi Arabia inhabitants. Adverse effects of the vaccine were reported after the first and the second doses. | The most frequent symptoms were injection site pain 63.8 %, headache 18.1%, bone and muscle symptoms 7.4 %, fever 4.3 %, and fatigue 3.2 %. These research findings indicated a substantial increase (p < 0.001) in the proportion of participants who were experiencing side effects after getting the second dosage of the vaccination (98.4 %) compared to those who reported side effects after the first dose. Additionally, the results indicated a significant increase (p< 0.05) in the proportion of participants reporting injection site side effects following the second dose of the vaccine (80.6 % ), compared to the proportion reporting local side effects following the first dose (70.5 % ) or both doses(63.8%). |
| Lee et al. [ | A survey performed a prospective and mobile based on healthcare workers' self-reported adverse responses after receiving both doses of the BNT162b2 mRNA vaccination | The study received 265 (77.5 %) responses. Adverse events occurred at a greater rate after the second dosage than after the first dose (89.1 % vs. 80.1 %, P<0.006). Muscle discomfort (69.1 %), fatigue (65.7 %), headache (48.7 %), chills (44.2 %), and fever (32.1%) were the most frequently reported systemic effects. The most common local symptoms were pain (80%), itching (9.4%), redness (9.8%), and swelling (10.2 %). Females experienced more adverse reactions than males (95% vs. 78%, P<0.001). |
| Cuschieri et al. [ | From 29/3/21 to 9/4/21, an online survey was sent to all caregivers through work email to collect side effects related to pain, redness, and swelling at the injection site, headache, fever, and diarrhea severity after each dosage. | The commonest side-effect was pain at the injection site 49.85 %, with the majority rating it as mild (51 %) and moderate (43 %). Fatigue was mentioned by 21.79 %, with 42 % describing it as mild and 41% as moderate. Headaches were recorded by 22 %, with 51 % mild and 34 % moderate. Younger people reported greater side effects than older persons. localized side effects were reported after both vaccination doses, unlike systemic side effects primarily reported with second dosages. |
| Riad et al. [ | A cross-sectional study was conducted to assess the adverse effects of vaccination on healthcare professionals in Slovakia. The research used a validated self administered questionnaire to elicit medical anamneses, COVID-19-related anamnesis, and adverse events associated with the vaccination. | This research included 522 individuals, 77% of whom were female and 55.7 % of whom were between the ages of 31 and 54. The most often reported local adverse event (85.2 %) was injection site pain, followed by injection site swelling (10.2 %) and injection site redness (8.4 % ). The difference between females (87.3%) and men (78.3%) in terms of injection site pain was statistically significant (χ2 = 5.926; Sig. < 0.015). Fatigue was the most often reported systemic adverse effect (54.2 %), followed by headache (34.3 %), muscular pain (28.4 %), chills (26.4 %), and malaise (20.5% ). Females showed a greater incidence of all requested systemic adverse events in this research. The gender differences in fatigue (χ2 = 14.215; Sig.< 0.001), headache ( χ2 = 7.089; Sig. < 0.008), and joint pain ( χ2= 4.950; Sig.< 0.026) were statistically significant. |
| Lim et al. [ | The Occupational Health Clinic at the National University Hospital in Singapore collected data on staff adverse reactions within 30 minutes after vaccination. In addition, cross-sectional research was undertaken among vaccinated Health workers utilizing an online survey. | The three most common symptoms listened to within the 30-minute observation period at the vaccination clinic were giddiness (32.7%), rashes/itch (23.5%), and palpitation/chest discomfort (17.2%). 196 staff requiring such care after vaccination, 16 (8.2%) of them had to be transferred to ED for further evaluation and management. Adverse reactions reported from the survey: 1,704 are complete surveys. Injection site reaction (rash, redness, swelling, pain) after the first dose is 57.2% compared with 70.1% after the second dose (OR: 2.8). Feeling unwell in general (fatigue, tiredness, weakness) after the first dose is 36.7% compared with 66.1% after the second dose (OR: 6.3). Aches and pains (joint pain, muscle pain, body ache) after the first dose is 30.1% compared with 51.9% after the second dose (OR:3.7). Headache after the first dose is 18.8% compared with 41.7% after the second dose (OR:6.1). Fever or chills after the first dose is 9.3% compared with 44.7% after the second dose (OR:22.5). |
| Ripabelli et al. [ | This retrospective research used data obtained anonymously from five private health clinics in central Italy. The the investigation aimed to look into each adverse event after vaccination with Pfizer-BioNTech between January and March 2021. | The 340 participated in the study. The enrolled subjects were aged 49.2 ± 13.4 years, and 209 (61.5%) were females. Most adverse events following the first dose: Pain, redness, and swelling at the injection site 265 (77.9%), Fatigue 66 (19.4%), Headache 52 (15.3%), Fever 5 (1.5%), Chills 20 (5.9%) and Sleep disorders 8 (2.4%). Most adverse events following the second dose: Pain, redness, and swelling at the injection site 223 (56.6%), Fatigue 135 (39.7%), Headache 89 (28.8%), Fever 46 (13.5%) and Sleep disorders 20 (5.9%). Adverse events were reported by 279 (82%) and 281 (82.6%) individuals as induced by the first and second dose, respectively. |
| Alamer et al. [ | A retrospective, cross-sectional investigation to determine the adverse events experienced by children in this age range after delivering one or two doses of the Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine. Via way of an online survey that was self-administered. | The commonly reported adverse effects were pain or redness at the site of injection (90 %), tiredness (61%), fever (39%), headache (49 %), nausea or vomiting (21 %), and chest pain and shortness of breath (18 %) Statistics indicated that more female participants experienced side effects than male participants, with 52 % and 48 %, respectively. In addition, side effects were more prevalent after the second dosage. These adverse effects continued for 1–3 days in 65 % of the individuals, 3–5 days in 30 % of the research respondents. Findings demonstrated that side effects were often reported in individuals who got two doses compared to the singly dosed subjects. |
| Im et al. [ | Medical practitioners were examined at a university hospital immunized with the Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 vaccine. Seven days after each injection, the survey was administered using a diary card. For the first dosage, 75.1 % (1876/2498) responded to the questionnaire; 73.8 % (1840/2493) responded to the second dose. | No serious adverse events occurred after the first or second dose, such as anaphylaxis. The most common local adverse event was pain, which was reported in 84.9% (1592/1876) of responders after the first dose and 90.4% (1664/1840) of responders after the second dose, followed by swelling [16.5% (309/1876) and 35.5% (653/1840), respectively] and redness [14.1% and 31.9%, respectively]. Among systemic adverse events, fatigue was the most common [52.8% after the first dose and 77.0% after the second dose], followed by myalgia [49.0% and 76.1%, respectively], headache [28.7% and 59.2%, respectively], chills [16.7% and 54.0%, respectively], itching [12.0% and 22.7%, respectively], nausea or vomiting [11.4% and 22.6%, respectively], and urticaria [2.3% and 2.7%, respectively]. |
| Vanegas et al. [ | From March to May 2021, researchers conducted observational cross-sectional research to examine probable adverse effects of the Pfizer COVID-19 vaccination among a sample of healthcare professionals in Guayaquil, Ecuador. | The sample consisted of 1291 participants, 50.4 % female, and 41.6 % male. The sample's mean age was 39.3 years (SD, 13.5). On average, 79% (N = 1020) of participants had an unpleasant reaction after the first dosage, whereas 75.1 % (N = 969) experienced an adverse response following the second dose. Local adverse effects were more prevalent than systemic adverse effects. Most adverse events reported after the first dosage to 1020 individuals were as follows: Local side reactions included pain, erythema, edema, pruritus, and axillary edema in 896 (69.4 %). Fever, malaise, myalgia, and arthralgia are examples of systemic adverse effects 557 (43.1%). Most adverse events were reported in 969 individuals after the second dose: Local adverse reactions included pain, erythema, edema, pruritus, and axillary edema in 753 (58.3 %). Fever, malaise, myalgia, and arthralgia were 666 (51.6 %) systemic side symptoms. |
| Filipina Krótki et al. [ | An anonymous survey was conducted. People vaccinated with two doses of the SARS-CoV-2 vaccine (BNT162b2) was qualified for the study. One hundred twenty-three people were included in the study. | The most frequently reported adverse events were pain or swelling at the application site (91.6 %) after the first dosage, compared to (73.17 %) following the second dose. Muscles and joints ache (45.53%) after the first dosage, compared to (56.10%) following the second dose. After the first dosage, (57.72 %) reported feeling weak, compared to (74.80 %) after the second dose. Shivers (19.51%) after the first dosage, compared to (37.40%) following the second dose. Fever (18.70%) with the first dosage, compared to (40.56%) following the second dose. Headache (31.71%) occurred after the first dosage, while (46.34%) occurred after the second dose. Enlargement lymph nodes were (13.82 %) with the first dosage vs. (16.26 %) following the second dose. Dyspnoea (4.88 %) occurred with both the first and second doses. |
| Shailabi et al . [ | A investigation was done on healthy young people of both sexes. Eighty-one individuals were got two doses of the Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 Vaccine. A paper questionnaire was produced; the survey questions about the side effects of taking the Vaccine. All subjects completed the questionnaire twice, once after the first dosage and again after the second dose. | Participant's average age was (21.5 ±1.7 years). The study revealed a significant difference between the number of females (96.5%) and males (85%) who suffered from the side effects of the Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 Vaccine (P<0.033). Male had the highest incidence of muscle pain (70%) compared to females (66.1%). (62.6 %) of females reported feeling tired, compared to (50%) of males. For headache, the results showed a significant difference between females and males, Where the percentage of females was (60.9%), compared to (35%) for males (P<0.048). Finally, there were no clear differences in the percentage of fever between females and males, as it was (49.6%) for females and (50%) for males (P > 0.999). |
Most reported side effects of the Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine in 10,632 participants from 14 studies.
| Author Publication year | Mohammed et al. [ | Riad et al. [ | Kadali et al. [ | Shitany et al. [ | Lee et al. [ | Cuschieri et al. [ | Riad et al. [ | Lim et al. [ | Ripabelli et al. [ | Alamer et al. [ | Im et al. [ | Vanegas et al. [ | Krótki et al. [ | Shailabi et al. [ | Average | |
| Number of participants | 1149 | 877 | 803 | 94 | 265 | 1480 | 522 | 1704 | 340 | 298 | 1876 | 1020 | 123 | 81 | ||
| Side effect % | Injection site pain | 79.30% | 89.80 % | 88.04% | 63.80% | 80 % | 49.85% | 85.20% | 57.20% | 77.90% | 90% | 84.90% | 68.40% | 91.06% | NA | 77.34% |
| Fatigue | 42% | 62.20% | 58.89% | 3.20% | 65.70% | 21.79% | 54.20% | 36.70% | 19.40% | 61% | 52.80% | 6% | 57.72% | 56.80% | 43% | |
| Muscle pain | 39.10% | 37% | 45.70% | 7.40% | 69% | 24.16% | 28.40% | 30% | NA | NA | NA | NA | 45.53% | 70.40% | 39.67% | |
| Local swelling | 27.70% | 25.60% | 5.48% | NA | 10.20% | 36.44% | 10.20% | NA | 77.90% | NA | 16.50% | NA | 91.06% | 34.60% | 33.57% | |
| Joint pain | 23.10% | 27.80% | 16.56% | NA | 30.60% | 11% | 17.60% | 30% | NA | NA | NA | NA | 45.52% | 29.60% | 25.75% | |
| Headache | 21.80% | 45.60% | 45.48% | 18.10% | 48.70% | 22% | 34.30% | 18.80% | 15.30% | 49% | 28.70% | NA | 31.71% | 53% | 33.27% | |
| Fever | 21% | 21.70% | 22% | 4.30% | 32.10% | 10.11% | 15.30% | 9.30% | 1.50% | 39% | 1% | 11.50% | 18.70% | 43% | 18% | |
| Chills | 15.50% | 34% | 36.60% | 1.10% | 44.20% | 10.20% | 26.40% | 9.30% | 5.90% | 19% | 16.70% | 3.50% | 19.51% | 14.80% | 18.34% | |
| Nausea | 7.30% | 13% | 15.94% | 1.10% | NA | NA | 9.40% | 4.30% | 2.10% | NA | 11.40% | 2.70% | NA | 8.60% | 7.58% | |
| Itching | NA | NA | 5.35% | NA | 9.40% | NA | 1.50% | 3.50% | 0.60% | NA | NA | 0.60% | NA | 24.70% | 9.38% | |
| Diarrhea | NA | NA | 4.61% | NA | 12.50% | 13.75% | NA | 4.30% | 2.10% | NA | 7% | 2.90% | NA | 3.70% | 6.36% | |
| Dyspnoea | NA | NA | 1.99% | NA | NA | NA | NA | 2.50% | NA | 18% | NA | NA | 4.88% | 7.40% | 6.95% | |
| Lymphadenopathy | 2.80% | 16.20% | 3.36% | NA | NA | NA | 7.50% | NA | 2.40% | NA | NA | NA | 13.82% | NA | 7.86% | |
Onset of the side effects after receiving of Pfizer COVID-19 vaccine among 1,634 participants.
| Percentage (%) | Frequency (N) | The onset of side effects |
| 8.2 | 134 | <1h |
| 69.8 | 1,140 | <24 |
| 18.1 | 297 | 24-48 |
| 3.9 | 63 | >48 |