| Literature DB >> 35494548 |
Ulysses Gardner1, Shearwood McClelland2, Curtiland Deville1.
Abstract
Purpose: Major advances in radiation therapy (RT) for prostate cancer increase the importance of equity in the use of RT. We sought to assess the evolution of RT utilization disparities in prostate cancer to inform clinicians and health care organizations of persistent areas of need that can be addressed in their practices and policies. Methods and Materials: A comprehensive PubMed literature search was undertaken in June 2020 and subsequently in March 2021. Studies were excluded that were not based in the United States, did not examine health disparities or inequities, did not examine RT or related resource utilization, or did not examine prostate cancer. Discussion: Of 257 studies found, 32 met inclusion criteria. Health disparities were most prominently reported by race, socioeconomic status, geographic location, insurance status, practice characteristics, and age. Older men were less likely to receive definitive RT or prostatectomy. Black men were less likely to receive curative therapy or dose-escalated RT. Black, Hispanic, and Asian men were less likely to receive proton therapy. Lower income was associated with decreased prostate-specific antigen testing and treatment with proton therapy or stereotactic body RT. Medicaid patients were less likely to receive definitive treatments. Rural residents were less likely to receive RT. Minority-serving hospitals were less likely to offer definitive treatments for prostate cancer. Conclusions: Sociodemographic disparities and inequities in RT for prostate cancer persist. Robust efforts are imperative to eliminate disparities to improve outcomes for all patients with prostate cancer.Entities:
Year: 2022 PMID: 35494548 PMCID: PMC9046798 DOI: 10.1016/j.adro.2022.100943
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Adv Radiat Oncol ISSN: 2452-1094
Figure 1Flowchart of systematic review of publications identified after PubMed query with results showing 32 studies meeting inclusion criteria.
Radiation oncology health disparities studies meeting inclusion criteria grouped by specific disparity studied
| Reported disparity | Number of studies | Reference number |
|---|---|---|
| Race | 25 | [4,6-7,10,12-23,25-27,29,32-35] |
| Socioeconomic status | 8 | [5-6,19,21,22,24-26] |
| Geographic location | 7 | [8-9,21,27-30] |
| Insurance status | 5 | [6,19,25,31-32] |
| Practice characteristics | 5 | [19,32-35] |
| Age | 2 | [4,25] |
Summary of reported radiation therapy (RT) disparities in prostate cancer from 2017 to 2020
| • Black men have the highest incidence and prevalence of prostate cancer |
| • Low SES is associated with a decreased likelihood of receiving radiation therapy or radical prostatectomy |
| • Rural residents are less likely to undergo treatment with radiation therapy for prostate cancer |
| • Medicaid, Medicare, and uninsured patients are less likely to receive definitive treatments |
| • Black patients with high-risk prostate cancer are more likely to receive definitive treatment in a multi-disciplinary clinic versus a community cancer program |
| • Older age is associated with a decreased likelihood of receiving RT after prostatectomy in cN+ and pN+ patients |
List of the studies meeting inclusion criteria regarding health disparities in the utilization of radiation therapy for prostate cancer in the United States
| Reference no. | Author (year) | Study title | Study type | Sample size | Population | Key finding(s) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Moon et al (2017) | Patterns of Care of Node-Positive Prostate Cancer Patients Across the United States: A National Cancer Data Base Analysis | Population-based (NCDB) | 13,354 | Men diagnosed with prostate adenocarcinoma (PCa) from 2006 to 2011 | Older and non-Hispanic Black patients are less likely to receive definitive treatment. | |
| des Bordes et al (2018) | Sociodemographic Disparities in Cure-Intended Treatment in Localized Prostate Cancer | Population-based (Texas Cancer Registry) | 46,971 | Men diagnosed with stage T1 or T2 PCa between 2004 and 2009 | Low socioeconomic status associated with less likelihood of receiving RT. | |
| Friedlander et al (2018) | Racial Disparity in Delivering Definitive Therapy for Intermediate/High-risk Localized Prostate Cancer: The Impact of Facility Features and Socioeconomic Characteristics | Population-based (NCDB) | 283,135 | Men with biopsy confirmed intermediate/high-risk PCa from 2004 to 2013 | Significant facility-level variation in the utilization of definitive therapy for PCa among Blacks vs Whites exists. Lower income and insurance types associated with less likely to undergo definitive therapy. | |
| Fang et al (2018) | Racial disparities in guideline-concordant cancer care and mortality in the United States | Population-based (SEER Medicare data) | 37,369 | Patients age >65 years of Black or non-Hispanic White race with breast, lung, and prostate cancer | The adoption of evidence-based cancer treatments in Black patient cohorts lag behind that of White patients. There is an underuse of curative treatment and guideline-concordant care in Black versus White patients. | |
| Maganty et al (2020) | Under Treatment of Prostate Cancer in Rural Locations | Population-based (Pennsylvania Cancer Registry) | 51,024 | Men diagnosed with localized or metastatic PCa between 2009 and 2015 | Compared to urban residents, rural residents are less likely to undergo treatment. | |
| McClelland et al (2020) | The pervasive crisis of diminishing radiation therapy access for vulnerable populations in the United States-Part 4: Appalachian patients | Retrospective review/Meta-analysis | N/A | Literature review for studies investigating RT access disparities in Appalachian patients | Data is sparse, but it is likely the use of RT for cancer is less likely in this region. | |
| McClelland et al (2020) | The pervasive crisis of diminishing radiation therapy access for vulnerable populations in the United States, part 1: African-American patients | Retrospective review/Meta-analysis | N/A | Literature review to examine studies investigating disparities in RT access for African Americans (AAs) | AAs less likely to receive care proven superior to conservative management. AAs have the highest death rate and shortest survival for most cancers. Access to RT may contribute to disparities for AAs. | |
| Verges et al (2017) | The Relationship of Baseline Prostate Specific Antigen and Risk of Future Prostate Cancer and Its Variance by Race | Retrospective/single-institution | 994 | Men referred to the urology clinic for elevated PSA from 2007 to 2014 | Black men are more likely to be diagnosed with PCa than White men with comparable baseline PSAs. | |
| Mahal et al (2018) | Prostate Cancer-Specific Mortality Across Gleason Scores in Black vs Nonblack Men | Population-based (SEER Prostate AS/WW database) | 192,224 | Men diagnosed with localized PCa from 2010 to 2015 | Black men were younger at diagnoses. PCSM is higher in Black patients across all Gleason scores 6-10 in comparison to non-Black men. | |
| Williams et al (2018) | African-American men and prostate cancer-specific mortality: a competing risk analysis of a large institutional cohort, 1989-2015 | Single-institution | 7,307 | Men newly diagnosed with PCa from 1989 to 2015 | Black men are more likely to be diagnosed at an early age and have higher comorbidities. Black men have a higher risk of PCSM, especially >60 years of age. | |
| Riviere et al (2020) | Survival of African American and non-Hispanic white men with prostate cancer in an equal-access health care system | Population-based (longitudinal, centralized database) | 101,869 | Veterans diagnosed with PCa between 2000 and 2015 | In an equal-access health care system, AA men do not present with more advanced disease, demonstrate delays in diagnosis or care, or have higher mortality compared to the general population. | |
| Krimphove et al (2019) | Evaluation of the contribution of demographics, access to health care, treatment, and tumor characteristics to racial differences in survival of advanced prostate cancer | Population-based (NCDB) | 35,611 | Black and White men with metastatic or locally advanced PCa between 2004 and 2010 | OS significantly worse for Black men; however, after simulating equal-access to care, there is no significant difference in survival between races. | |
| Kodiyan et al (2020) | Race Does Not Affect Survival in Patients With Prostate Cancer Treated With Radiation Therapy | Population-based (NCDB) | 27,150 | African American and Caucasian men with N0M0 PCa diagnosed between 2004 – 2013 | No significant difference in survival between treatment and race with risk-appropriate definitive RT. However, younger Black men with unfavorable risk have poorer survival. | |
| Kodiyan et al (2020) | Race Does Not Affect Survival in Patients With Prostate Cancer Treated With Radiation Therapy | Population-based (NCDB) | 27,150 | Black or White men with PCa diagnosed between 2004 and 2013 | There is no significant interaction between treatment and race for Black versus White men treated with risk-appropriate definitive RT. However, a significant interaction between race and age with less OS in younger (≤60 years) Black men with unfavorable risk versus their White counterparts. | |
| Lee et al (2018) | Contemporary prostate cancer radiation therapy in the United States: Patterns of care and compliance with quality measures | Population-based (SEER & Cancer of the Prostate Strategic Urologic Research Endeavor database) | 926 | Men <80 years with clinically localized PCa and a PSA <50ng/mL | Black and minority men were less likely to receive EBRT that was compliant with quality measures (dose-escalation, image-guidance, ADT appropriate use, and targets) | |
| Bagley et al (2020) | Association of Sociodemographic and Health-Related Factors With Receipt of Nondefinitive Therapy Among Younger Men With High-Risk Prostate Cancer | Population-based (NCDB) | 70,036 | Men aged ≤70 years with high-risk PCa and Charlson Comorbidity Index scores of ≤2 between 2018 and 2019 | Men with no insurance, Medicaid or Medicare, and Black and Hispanic are most likely to receive systemic or no therapy in comparison to Caucasian patients or those with private insurance or managed care. | |
| Lee et al (2018) | Racial variation in receipt of quality radiation therapy for prostate cancer | Population-based, prospective cohort | 3,708 | Men with clinically localized PCa from 2011 to 2012 | Black men are less likely to receive EBRT compliant with all quality measures, dose-escalated EBRT, and pelvic RT for low-risk disease; more likely to receive EBRT from lower-quality providers. | |
| Woodhouse et al (2017) | Sociodemographic disparities in the utilization of proton therapy for prostate cancer at an urban academic center | Single-institution | 633 | Men with low- and intermediate-risk PCa treated with definitive RT between 2010 and 2015 | Older, Black men with close access to facilities, living in poverty with higher PSA and larger prostate volumes are more likely to receive IMRT vs proton therapy in comparison to White men. After adjustment for demographic and clinical factors, race and distance remain significant determinants of receiving proton therapy. Authors suggest explanation is provider implicit bias. | |
| Parikh-Patel et al (2020) | A population-based assessment of proton beam therapy utilization in California | Population-based (California Cancer Registry) | 2,499,510 | Persons with diagnoses of all types of cancer types from 2003 to 2016 treated with any type of RT | The racial distribution of proton beam therapy was disproportionately White compared wo any other forms of RT. Blacks, Hispanics, and Asian patients have significantly lower odds of receiving proton therapy. The odds of receiving proton therapy were higher in patients in the medium and high SES. | |
| Wang et al (2017) | Racial Disparity in Prostate Cancer-Specific Mortality for High-Risk Prostate Cancer: A Population-Based Study | Population-based (SEER) | 28,956 | Men diagnosed with clinically localized PCa and Gleason score 8-10 from 2004 to 2013 treated with EBRT, EBRT with a brachytherapy boost, or RP | Black and Asian Americans do not demonstrate a significant decrease in PCSM with dose escalation compared to non-Hispanic White men. | |
| Mahase et al (2020) | Trends in the Use of Stereotactic Body Radiotherapy for Treatment of Prostate Cancer in the United States | Population-based (NCDB) | 106,926 | Men diagnosed with PCa from 2010 to 2015 who underwent definitive RT | Black men and those with lower incomes are less likely to receive SBRT. | |
| Muralidhar et al (2017) | Disparities in the Receipt of Local Treatment of Node-positive Prostate Cancer | Population-based (NCDB) | 9,771 | Men with clinical N1M0 PCa diagnosed from 1998 to 2012 | Black, lower income, older, and Medicaid beneficiary or no insurance patients are less likely to receive local treatment for node-positive PCa and are associated with reduced OS. | |
| Pollack et al (2017) | A multidimensional view of racial differences in access to prostate cancer care | Survey-based | 2,374 | Men diagnosed with localized PCa between 2012 and 2014 | Black men with PCa are younger and more likely to have Medicaid insurance, lower income, and a high school education or less. Black men report less availability to care and a lower level of perceived quality of care and doctor-patient communication. | |
| Wong et al (2017) | Racial Differences in Geographic Access to Medical Care as Measured by Patient Report and Geographic Information Systems | Population-based (Pennsylvania Cancer Registry) | 2,136 | Men diagnosed with localized PCa between 2012 and 2014 | Patient-reported travel times are generally longer than GIS-calculated times. Patient reported travel times were 2.11 minutes longer for Blacks than Whites for urologic and radiation oncology care | |
| Ghali et al (2018) | Does Travel Time to a Radiation Facility Impact Patient Decision-Making Regarding Treatment for Prostate Cancer? A Study of the New Hampshire State Cancer Registry | Population based (New Hampshire State Cancer Registry) | 4,731 | Men with newly diagnosed localized prostate cancer from 2004 to 2011 | Travel time is not associated with receipt of radiation therapy in this cohort. | |
| Vetterlein et al (2017) | Impact of travel distance to the treatment facility on overall mortality in US patients with prostate cancer | Population-based (NCDB) | 775,999 | Men with prostate cancer in all stages who received RP, RT, observation, ADT, multimodal treatment, and/or chemotherapy between 2004 and 2012 | Blacks and Medicaid beneficiaries are less likely to travel long distances for treatment. Patients are less likely to travel far for RT vs RP. Patients who traveled long distances are associated with less OM as travel to academic/research or high-volume centers is likely. | |
| Fletcher et al (2020) | Geographic Distribution of Racial Differences in Prostate Cancer Mortality | Population-based (SEER) | 229,771 | Men with biopsy-confirmed PCa between 2007 and 2014 from 17 geographic locations with SEER | The greatest survival difference between Black and White men with PCa is in low-risk PCa. Men who present to hospitals that primarily treat minority groups are less likely to receive definitive treatment and are more likely to experience delays in treatment. | |
| Mahal et al (2018) | Prostate cancer outcomes for men aged younger than 65 years with Medicaid versus private insurance | Population-based (SEER) | 155,524 | Men, aged <65 years, who were diagnosed with PCa from 2007 to 2014 | Men with Medicaid present with metastatic disease at a higher rate, are less likely to receive definitive treatment, and have a higher risk of PCSM. | |
| Gerhard et al (2017) | Treatment of men with high-risk prostate cancer based on race, insurance coverage, and access to advanced technology | Population-based (NCDB) | 60,300 | Men diagnosed with high-risk PCa from 2010 to 2012 | Non-white men with Medicaid or no insurance and those treated at low-quartile technological facilities with high-risk PCa are most likely to receive non-definitive management. At high-technological hospitals, these disparities are diminished. | |
| Krimphove et al (2019) | Quality of Care in the Treatment of Localized Intermediate and High Risk Prostate Cancer at Minority Serving Hospitals | Population-based (NCDB) | 536,539 | Men aged ≥40 years old with intermediate- and high-risk PCa in the US between 2004 and 2015 | Patients have lower odds of receiving definitive therapy and a longer time to treatment for localized intermediate- and high-risk PCa at minority serving hospitals. | |
| Agrawal et al (2021) | Active Surveillance for Men with Intermediate Risk Prostate Cancer | Population-based (NCDB) | 176,122 | Men with intermediate risk prostate cancer from 2010 to 2016 | Active surveillance use has increased significantly in recent years in patients with intermediate-risk prostate cancer. Use is associated with factors such as older age, lower Gleason score and tumor state, and treatment at an academic center. | |
| Tang et al (2020) | Reply to Multidisciplinary clinics: A possible means to help to eliminate racial disparities in prostate cancer | Single-institution | N/A | Men with intermediate- and high-risk PCa | Black patients with high-risk PCa are more likely to receive definitive treatment if seen in a MultiD clinic | |
| Dess et al (2019) | Association of Black Race With Prostate Cancer-Specific and Other-Cause Mortality | Multi-cohort (SEER, VA health system, NCI RTOG) | 306,099 | Men with clinical T1-4N0-1M0 PCa diagnosed from 1992 to 2013 | After adjusting for nonbiological differences, notably access to care and standardized treatment, Black race does not associate with inferior PCSM. |
Abbreviations: NCDB = national cancer database; PCSM = prostate cancer–specific mortality; RT = radiation therapy; RTOG = radiation therapy oncology group; SEER = surveillance, epidimiology, and end results program; VA = veteran affairs.