| Literature DB >> 35492011 |
Emily M Klann1,2, Shannan N Rich1,2, Sabrina C Hendrick1, Alfeil Felipe1, Sneha Sathish1, Cindy Prins1,2, Michael Lauzardo2,3, Jerne Shapiro1.
Abstract
The coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic continues to present unique public health challenges both within the United States and across the globe. Institutions of higher learning are tasked with preventing and responding to COVID-19 on campus while also considering implications for the surrounding communities. The process of re-opening campus, whether at full or partial capacity, has tasked these institutions with overcoming complex challenges associated with balancing the resumption of campus operations while simultaneously protecting university affiliates and surrounding community members from COVID-19 through robust surveillance, contact tracing, and testing efforts. Here, we provide a concise outline related to the development and implementation of the comprehensive and sustainable COVID-19 surveillance program at the University of Florida. We also critically discuss the successes and pitfalls of this program while also providing recommendations for the development of similar programs in the future.Entities:
Keywords: COVID-19; college campus; disease surveillance; epidemiology; surveillance program
Year: 2022 PMID: 35492011 PMCID: PMC9253438 DOI: 10.1017/dmp.2022.109
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Disaster Med Public Health Prep ISSN: 1935-7893 Impact factor: 5.556
Key components of COVID-19 campus surveillance
| Surveillance component | Definition or explanation |
|---|---|
| Affiliated hospital data | University-affiliated hospital system provides data on COVID-19 admissions and deaths as well as the minimal health status of affiliates and employees. |
| UAA athletics testing | University-affiliated athletic programs are tested according to the Southeastern Conference (SEC) guidelines. Positive tests are reported by SEC testing coordinators if results are not automatically piped into the REDCap system. |
| Classroom monitoring | In-person classes are monitored weekly for a high proportion of students who were “withheld” as cases, contacts, or suspect cases, and assessed whether spread in the classroom was possible and identify mitigation strategies. |
| Greek life organizations | Greek life organizations take part in a novel sentinel surveillance program. Additionally, daily reports identify cases by house affiliation, in-house status, and include in all in-house roommate data. |
| High-risk groups | High-risk groups include individuals engaging in activities that may predispose them to a higher risk of transmission. Such groups include individuals living in congregated living facilities (undergraduate dormitories), Greek affiliates (in-house and out-of-house), teaching or taking face-to-face classes, or interacting with patients or research subjects in-person. |
| Molecular epidemiology | Molecular sequencing of SARS-CoV-2 samples is offered to select persons as approved by STP administration. This includes vaccine breakthrough cases (eg, individual has a positive COVID-19 test after being fully vaccinated) and individuals within transmission clusters of interest to determine strain information. |
| Occupational health | The university-affiliated hospital system and patient facing practitioners and students to handle health-care-associated COVID-19 cases. |
| Routine testing | Identified high-risk student groups are required to complete a health screener to report symptoms, exposures, and sign up for routine biweekly testing. |
| Health screener | A voluntary health screener is sent every week to all main campus UF-affiliates to report symptoms, exposures, and access testing appointments |
| Self-reporting | University affiliates are encouraged to self-report by means of the university portal or by calling STP for potential COVID-19-like symptoms, exposures, and contacts of COVID-19. |
| Sentinel surveillance | Members of Greek life organizations participate in sentinel surveillance. Occurrence of COVID-19-like symptoms are collected by the president or other point of contact and are reported weekly by means of an emailed survey. If symptoms are reported in the house, targeted testing is implemented. |
| State communicable disease database | The state communicable disease database (Merlin) is accessed at 3 scheduled times per day to identify university-affiliated and community cases of COVID-19 for investigations throughout the state of Florida. Using Merlin, it is possible to identify university-affiliated COVID-19 cases that may have otherwise been missed due to either out-of-county status (eg, using parental residence address) or being tested outside of the university program. |
| State vaccine database | During the contact tracing process FLShots is used to verify vaccine information for university affiliates. |
| Targeted testing | Targeted testing is implemented for groups deemed to have possible active transmission occurring. A text/email is sent recommending testing within 48 h. Examples of targeted testing include detection of SARS-CoV-2 in wastewater samples, clusters of cases in Greek houses, dormitories, and classrooms. |
| Wastewater surveillance | Wastewater from potential high-risk locations (eg, undergraduate dormitories and Greek Houses) is routinely tested for COVID-19. Detection by means of wastewater surveillance results in targeted testing. |
COVID-19 case and contact definitions
| Symptoms | Type of test | Definition | Isolation/quarantine | Campus clearance | Exceptions | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Confirmed case | Acute onset of cough, shortness of breath/difficulty breathing, or new olfactory/taste disorder OR acute onset of 2 or more of other symptoms such as fever, chills, rigors, myalgia, headache, sore throat, nausea or vomiting, diarrhea, fatigue, and congestion or runny nose OR asymptomatic | NAAT (PCR) | An individual with a laboratory-confirmed positive NAAT test for SARS-CoV-2 who is either experiencing symptoms or is asymptomatic | Isolation for 10 d following the date of symptom onset, or date of NAAT test if asymptomatic, with the end of isolation contingent upon absence of fever for 24 consecutive hours before day 10 as well as improvement of all other symptoms | Withheld from campus for the entirety of the isolation period | None |
| Probable case | Acute onset of cough, shortness of breath/difficulty breathing, or new olfactory/taste disorder OR acute onset of 2 or more of other symptoms such as fever, chills, rigors, myalgia, headache, sore throat, nausea or vomiting, diarrhea, fatigue, and congestion or runny nose OR asymptomatic | Rapid antigen/none | An individual with either no test results or a positive result by means of a rapid antigen test who is either experiencing symptoms or is asymptomatic who has known and documented contact with a confirmed or probable case (within 6 feet for 15 cumulative minutes) | Isolation for 10 d following the date of symptom onset, or date of antigen test if asymptomatic, with the end of isolation contingent upon absence of fever for 24 consecutive hours before day 10 as well as improvement of all other symptoms | Withheld from campus for the entirety of the isolation period | Fully vaccinated probable cases may end isolation if they receive 1 negative NAAT test result between 1-5 d of symptom onset. Partially vaccinated or unvaccinated probable cases may end isolation if they receive 2 negative NAAT test results between 1 and 5 d of symptom onset that are taken more than 24 h apart. |
| Suspect case | Acute onset of cough, shortness of breath/difficulty breathing, or new olfactory/taste disorder OR acute onset of 2 or more of other symptoms such as fever, chills, rigors, myalgia, headache, sore throat, nausea or vomiting, diarrhea, fatigue, and congestion or runny nose | None | An individual with no test results who is experiencing symptoms and has no known or documented contact with a confirmed or probable case (within 6 feet for 15 cumulative minutes) | Isolation for 10 d following the date of symptom onset with the end of isolation contingent upon absence of fever for 24 consecutive hours before day 10 as well as improvement of all other symptoms | Withheld from campus for the entirety of the isolation period | Fully vaccinated suspect cases may end isolation if they receive 1 negative NAAT test result between 1 and 5 d of symptom onset. Partially vaccinated or unvaccinated suspect cases may end isolation if they receive 2 negative NAAT test results between 1 and 5 d of symptom onset that are taken more than 24 h apart. |
| Close contact | NA | NA | An individual who is within 6 feet of a probable or confirmed case of COVID-19 for a total of 15 cumulative minutes during the case’s infectious period (beginning 48 h before symptom onset or positive test) | Quarantine for 14 full days following the last day or contact with the case (if the individual has ongoing contact with the case, the 14-d quarantine period does not begin until the end of the case’s isolation period) | Withheld for the entirety of the quarantine period | Fully vaccinated close contacts are not required to quarantine if asymptomatic. |
Abbreviation: NAAT, nucleic acid amplification test.
Strengths and weaknesses of key COVID-19 campus surveillance components
| Surveillance component | Description | Strengths | Weaknesses |
|---|---|---|---|
| Affiliated hospital data | Data pertaining to COVID-19 among health-care workers or HSC patient-facing students. | Important for identifying health-care workers that work both within the hospital and on main campus. | NA |
| Athletics testing | Routine testing of student-athletes and coordination across athletic administration (eg, communication between athletes, athletic trainers, other staff, and disease investigators). | Essential to minimizing risk for sport-related outbreaks. Routine tests ensure comprehensive surveillance and quick detection of positive cases. | NA |
| Classroom monitoring | Information pertaining to in-person classes is automatically uploaded into each university-affiliated case when applicable. All individuals in each class are listed as potential contacts. | Useful for identifying potential contacts in the classroom setting. The individual case, associated contacts, and instructor for the course may provide helpful information. | Without adherence to a seating chart, it is difficult to identify potential contacts for large in-person classes. Cases may not know the individuals near them or have their contact information. |
| Greek life organization monitoring | Disease investigators collaborate with the president and house director of each Greek house to identify potential cases or contacts and implement targeted testing when applicable. | Collaboration with Greek house presidents allows STP to actively monitor Greek houses for symptomatic individuals that may benefit from targeted testing. | Utility of this component is dependent on collaboration with each president or house director. Targeted testing is voluntary and may not be used by all in-house members when recommended. |
| High-risk group monitoring | Groups with increased risk of transmission (eg, students living in dormitories, Greek houses, athletics teams, etc.) are directly monitored. Targeted testing is implemented when applicable. | Similar to Greek houses, other high-risk groups are monitored to quickly detect any potential cases in these populations. Targeted testing may be implemented. | Utility of this component is dependent on collaboration with the high-risk group of interest. Targeted testing is voluntary and may not be used by all individuals in these groups. |
| Molecular epidemiology testing | Molecular testing identifies the genetic lineage and strain/variant designation of SARS-CoV-2 within samples of interest. Genetic lineage and strain information allows STP to identify outbreak clusters associated with a particular location or identify strains associated with vaccine breakthrough cases. | Useful for identifying or confirming outbreaks on campus or in the surrounding area; also provides variant information when assessing vaccine breakthrough cases. | Information on the strain or variant is not necessary for surveillance or contact-tracing. Strain/variant identification is not useful without indication of potential new strains of interest in the region. |
| Occupational Health | Occupational Health Department through the university-affiliated hospital handles all COVID-19 cases among health-care workers and some patient-facing HSC students. | Enables a comprehensive investigation for health-care workers in which Occupational Heath focuses on workplace and STP focuses on community and campus transmission. | Occupational Health focuses on information pertaining to the workplace (hospital). STP/FDOH is responsible for collecting information and providing guidelines pertaining to the community. Therefore, most health-care workers will need to be interviewed twice. |
| Routine testing | NAAT testing at routine intervals to detect cases of COVID-19 and prevent spread on campus. | Essential for preventing and identifying potential outbreaks on campus. | NA |
| Self-reporting | University affiliates can self-report positive COVID-19 test results, contact with a COVID-19 case, or symptoms of COVID-19 by means of a 1-way online portal directly to STP. | Essential for the identification of many suspect or probable cases. In many cases, self-reporting allows STP to monitor these individuals before reporting of valid test results in the state system. | Self-reported information is not always accurate. Some self-reported positive test results are from at-home tests that cannot be verified in the state database. |
| Sentinel surveillance | Passive reporting of COVID-19 cases from hospitals, urgent cares, and the student health-care center. | Useful for preventing and identifying potential outbreaks on campus. | Passive nature of sentinel surveillance renders it less useful than other program components. |
| State communicable disease database | Merlin | Essential for identifying cases who did not receive testing through the university. It is also essential for collaboration with the local health department as all case data are uploaded to this system following investigation by STP. | NA |
| State vaccine database | FLShots | Essential for verifying vaccination status for university affiliates; impacts potential quarantine periods and testing recommendations. | Information pertaining to vaccines received outside of Florida will not automatically be uploaded. Individuals who received vaccines outside of Florida are asked to send their vaccine information to STP by means of confidential email. |
| Targeted testing | Targeted testing is indicated for certain groups through results from wastewater epidemiology, sentinel surveillance, and monitoring of high-risk groups (eg, students living in dormitories, Greek houses, athletics teams, etc.). | Useful for early identification of COVID-19 that may result in an outbreak. Early detection allows for implementation of isolation/quarantine protocols to reduce transmission to others within the high-risk group. | This is most actionable when case prevalence is very low. Otherwise, SARS-CoV-2 is almost always detected and is less informative. |
| Wastewater surveillance | Wastewater from campus buildings is routinely testing for the presence of SARS-CoV-2. When detected, targeted testing may be implemented. | Useful for early identification of COVID-19 that may result in an outbreak. Early detection allows for implementation of isolation/quarantine protocols to reduce transmission to others within the high-risk group. | Wastewater manholes are not always specific to 1 building on campus. Detection of SARS-CoV-2 in 1 manhole servicing multiple different buildings is less actionable. This is most useful when case prevalence is very low. Otherwise, SARS-CoV-2 is almost always detected and is less informative. |