Over the past years, disposable masks have been produced in unprecedented amounts due to the COVID-19 pandemic. Their increased use imposes significant strain on current waste management practices including landfilling and incineration. This results in large volumes of discarded masks entering the environment as pollutants, and alternative methods of waste management are required to mitigate the negative effects of mask pollution. While current recycling methods can supplement conventional waste management, the necessary processes result in a product with downgraded material properties and a loss of value. This work introduces a simple method to upcycle mask waste into multifunctional carbon fibers through simple steps of thermal stabilization and pyrolysis. The pre-existed fibrous structure of polypropylene masks can be directly converted into carbonaceous structures with high degrees of carbon yield, that are inherently sulfur-doped, and porous in nature. The mask-derived carbon product demonstrates potential use in multiple applications such as for Joule heating, oil adsorption, and the removal of organic pollutants from aqueous environments. We believe that this process can provide a useful alternative to conventional waste management by converting mask waste generated during the COVID-19 pandemic into a product with enhanced value.
Over the past years, disposable masks have been produced in unprecedented amounts due to the COVID-19 pandemic. Their increased use imposes significant strain on current waste management practices including landfilling and incineration. This results in large volumes of discarded masks entering the environment as pollutants, and alternative methods of waste management are required to mitigate the negative effects of mask pollution. While current recycling methods can supplement conventional waste management, the necessary processes result in a product with downgraded material properties and a loss of value. This work introduces a simple method to upcycle mask waste into multifunctional carbon fibers through simple steps of thermal stabilization and pyrolysis. The pre-existed fibrous structure of polypropylene masks can be directly converted into carbonaceous structures with high degrees of carbon yield, that are inherently sulfur-doped, and porous in nature. The mask-derived carbon product demonstrates potential use in multiple applications such as for Joule heating, oil adsorption, and the removal of organic pollutants from aqueous environments. We believe that this process can provide a useful alternative to conventional waste management by converting mask waste generated during the COVID-19 pandemic into a product with enhanced value.
Plastic
waste is an increasing global concern, which has the generation
rate that is projected to triple by the year 2060.[1] Current plastic waste management practices involve multiple
steps of collecting, sorting, washing, and recycling. Strained by
the lack of efficient solutions and current mechanical recycling volumes,
it becomes more likely that these wastes can escape into the environment
where they slowly erode into microplastics over time. As a type of
severe environmental threat, microplastics are known to concentrate
pollutants, and the consumption of microplastics by animals can result
in their entry, along with the concentrated pollutants, into the ecosystems,
directly harming the human population.[1] Particularly, responses to the COVID-19 pandemic further intensified
this issue, leading to massive increases in the production and use
of personal protective equipment.[2−5] As these materials are typically designed
for single use, their extensive consumption has largely exacerbated
the global plastic waste issue, posing a significant strain on conventional
waste management practices (i.e., landfilling and incineration).[6] According to National Geographic magazine, greater
than 3 billion masks have been discarded daily during 2020, and this
elevated rate will likely remain throughout the following years in
response to various respiratory diseases.[7] In general, these disposable facial masks are produced from polypropylene
(PP), and a significant amount of them is now simply leaked into the
environment where they can directly threaten the wildlife and ecosystems
that are present. Undoubtedly, effective solutions are required to
address the global challenge of mask recycling and/or upcycling toward
the development of a sustainable environment and society.Over
the past years, many types of technologies have been demonstrated
for recycling the raw materials of disposable masks (i.e., plastics)
to extend their associated lifetime. For example, post-cleaning and/or
post-functionalization of used masks can be performed to improve their
performance, allowing their efficient reuse for at least several days.[8−10] Specifically, many methods of decontamination or sterilization have
been previously reported,[10,11] including the use of
γ and electron beam irradiation.[12,13] Additionally,
Menon et al. demonstrated that post-functionalization of PP masks
can result in effective sterilization through the use of zinc porphyrin
photosensitizers for enhancing the ability of the masks to protect
against influenza pathogens.[14] Alternatively,
masks can be collected and recycled through several processing steps,
such as granulation and pelletization. While such mechanical recycling
methods have been established in industry, they often result in downgraded
material properties and a less valuable product due to increased yellowness
and reduced melt viscosity from possible chain scission under high
shear.[15,16] As an example, Frache et al. reported the
mechanical recycling of PP-derived surgical masks using twin-screw
extrusion to compound comingled mask waste and form pellets.[17] These pellets can then be used to manufacture
new products through subsequent processing steps. While parts could
be processed from the recycled materials, they exhibited diminished
mechanical properties in comparison to virgin PP. Specifically, recycled
parts exhibited similar moduli but decreased elongation at break in
tensile experiments. Although it is challenging, establishing a robust
and scalable technology to upcycle PP masks, converting them to higher-value
products, can not only complement existing recycling methods for addressing
a massive amount of plastic waste but may also stimulate interests
of broader communities to improve the corresponding infrastructures
for waste management.In the early 1970s, Horikiri et al. and
Postema et al. pioneered
the concept of using polyolefins [e.g., polyethylene (PE)] for carbon
fiber fabrication.[18,19] However, compared to polyacrylonitrile
(PAN),[20−22] pitch-based chemicals,[23−25] and lignin,[26,27] the efficacy of polyolefins as carbon precursors is still underexplored,
evidenced by a relatively limited number of reports regarding PE-derived
carbons.[28−30] It is important to note that efficient transformation
of polyolefins into carbonaceous products requires the development
of a process for thermally stabilizing the polyolefin chains through
crosslinking prior to carbonization. Currently, the most successful
stabilization/crosslinking of PE at large scales is achieved through
directly soaking them in sulfuric acid at elevated temperatures to
aromatize the polymer backbones. Younker et al. elucidated pyrolysis
pathways of sulfonated PE through the combined use of experimental
techniques [e.g., thermogravimetric analysis (TGA)] and computational
approaches (e.g., density functional theory and transition state theory).[31] They also found that two synergistic mechanisms,
including five-centered internal elimination and radical chain reactions,
are involved for detaching SO3H groups to provide reaction
sites for crosslinking. While, to date, PAN is still the most common
carbon precursor in carbon fiber production, it is significantly more
expensive in comparison to polyolefins which are the most widely used
commodity plastic, representing over 55% of total plastic production.[32] Therefore, manufacturing carbon fibers from
polyolefin precursors could potentially reduce production and material
costs, encouraging their broad use in more diverse applications, especially
when cost-effective manufacturing is strongly preferred. This approach
has been investigated in recent years for applications such as the
continuous production of PE-derived carbon fibers. For example, Barton
et al. performed a comprehensive study using aliphatic hydrocarbons
and multiple commercially available polyolefin resins as model precursors
with both concentrated and fuming sulfuric acid to elucidate the chemical
transformation during the sulfonation and carbonization processes.[33] This work informed several subsequent studies
associated with producing PE-derived carbon fibers from continuous
processes and comparing their performance to conventional PAN- and
pitch-derived carbon fibers.[28,34] It was found that PAN-based
fibers have higher moduli than those produced from the sulfonation
of PE due to their improved degree of crosslinking. However, one report
also suggested that PE-derived carbon fibers may be able to achieve
higher moduli than PAN-derived counterparts if the precursor chains
can be aligned prior to the crosslinking step.[28]Capitalizing on these efforts, several research groups
also extended
this sulfuric acid-crosslinking strategy to upcycle PE and PP waste
to carbon-based materials.[35] In 2018, Pol
et al. demonstrated the successful use of waste PE plastic bags for
fabricating carbon products through a thermal stabilization process.[36] The resulting carbons were inherently porous
with a relatively high surface area of 752.3 m2/g, which
can be used as anodes in lithium-ion batteries. This study also shows
that both PE and PP waste can yield amorphous carbons with approximately
50% conversion rate. More recently, researchers have studied the use
of the sulfonation crosslinking process to convert PP fibers from
facial masks into carbonaceous materials. Hu and Lin demonstrated
the synthesis of hollow carbon fibers for solid-state capacitors,
which was combined with a KOH activation step to enable microporous
structures.[37] Lee et al. characterized
the sulfonation process and elucidated the chemical transformation
mechanisms for converting linear PP chains to their crosslinked analogues.[35] While these inspiring works show the great potential
of chemical upcycling of plastic waste to functional carbons for practical
applications, their scope was primarily focused on energy storage
applications. To fully unlock the potential of mask waste, more diverse
applications should be developed, especially leveraging the already
existing, well-defined fiber structures of disposable masks for manufacturing
carbon products with improved functionality.Herein, we report
the use of sulfonation chemistry to thermally
stabilize PP-based surgical masks and their conversion into carbon
nanofibers without deconstruction of their defined structures. The
resulting products exhibit a greater than 50% carbon yield, while
retaining both the microscopic fibrous structures and macroscopic
shape and size. A suite of characterization techniques have been employed
to understand the nanostructures and properties of these mask-derived
carbon fibers. Furthermore, we demonstrate their potential use in
several practical applications, including oil sorbents, nanofillers
for imparting electrical conductivity, and Joule heating behaviors
of composites, as well as materials for the removal of organic contaminants
from water. We believe that this work provides important and timely
insights into an efficient method for upcycling mask waste, demonstrating
their versatile performance and providing a potential solution to
the global challenge of addressing massive facial mask waste generated
in response to the pandemic.
Experimental Section
Materials
98 wt % sulfuric acid was
purchased from Sigma-Aldrich. PP-based surgical masks were purchased
from Asia Masks Inc. and used throughout this study. Deionized (DI)
water was obtained by passing tap water through a Milli-Q IQ 7003
ultrapure lab water purification system from Millipore Sigma. Potassium
hydroxide (KOH) was purchased from Fisher Scientific. Powder-activated
carbons (PACs) used in this study were purchased from American Water
Solutions with a surface area of 712 m2/g.
Methods for Converting Masks to Carbon Fibers
Surgical
masks were cut to remove the elastic bands and metal nosepiece.
The resulting fabric was separated into three constituent layers,
including nonwoven fabrics (two outer layers) and a melt-spun mat
(inner layer). In this study, only outer layers were employed for
producing carbon fibers, which were cut into sections with a typical
size of 8 cm by 5 cm. These mask parts (∼1 g in total) were
then transferred into glass containers containing 25 mL of concentrated
sulfuric acid (98 wt %). In this step, a glass slide was placed on
top of the masks to keep the mask completely submerged in sulfuric
acid throughout the reactions. The containers were then placed in
a Thermo Scientific muffle furnace and heated to 155 °C (temperature
ramp: 1 °C/min) for various amounts of time. Upon sulfonation,
samples were removed from the muffle furnace and cooled down to room
temperature. To wash these samples, sulfuric acid is first removed
from the glass containers. Subsequently, the mask pieces were carefully
placed in a quartz funnel, where it is washed at least three times
with DI water in order to completely remove the residue acid. Neutralization
was confirmed by pH papers. Samples were then dried by placing on
a glass Petri dish in a vacuum oven for overnight. Carbonization of
the sulfonated masks was performed using an MTI Corporation OTF-1200×
tube furnace under a N2 atmosphere at a rate of 1 °C/min
to 600 °C and thereafter 5 °C/min to 800 °C or higher.
The holding time for carbonization temperatures is 3 h. The activation
process was performed by physically grinding the previously produced
carbon fiber product with potassium hydroxide (KOH) at a 1:2 mass
ratio. After activation at 700 °C with a ramp rate of 1 °C/min
for 1 h, the product was washed with DI water, centrifuged, and then
dried. This process was repeated six times.
Characterization
Methods
A PerkinElmer
frontier attenuated total reflection Fourier transform infrared (FTIR)
spectrometer was used to understand the changes in chemical compositions
of sulfonated mask samples as a function of time. The scan range was
4000–600 cm–1 with 32 scans and a resolution
of 4 cm–1. TGA was conducted using a Discovery Series
TGA 550 (TA Instruments) to understand the mass loss of polymer precursors
as a function of pyrolysis temperature. Sulfonated samples, approximately
10–20 mg in mass, were pyrolyzed under a N2 environment,
replicating the carbonization procedure used in the tube furnace.
Differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) was performed using a Discovery
250 (TA Instruments). An initial heating cycle to 200 °C with
a ramp rate of 10 °C/min was used to erase thermal history. The
sample was cooled to −90 °C at a rate of 5 °C/min
and then heated to 200 °C at 10 °C/min. Data analysis was
performed using Trios software. A Zeiss Ultra 60 field-emission scanning
electron microscope was used to understand the morphological changes
of the fiber structure both after sulfonation at different periods
of time and after the carbonization process with an accelerating voltage
of 10 kV. During these measurements, energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy
(EDS) was coupled for determining the content of different elements
within the materials after sulfonation and carbonization, respectively.
Additionally, fiber diameters were determined and recorded using ImageJ
image analysis software. X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) experiments
were performed using a Thermo Fisher ESCALAB Xi+ spectrometer equipped
with a monochromatic Al X-ray source (1486.6 eV) and a MAGCIS Ar+/Arn+
gas cluster ion sputter gun. Measurements were performed using the
standard magnetic lens mode and charge compensation. The base pressure
in the analysis chamber during spectral acquisition was at 3 ×
10–7 mbar. Spectra were collected at a takeoff angle
of 90° from the plane of the surface. The pass energy of the
analyzer was set at 150 eV for survey scans with an energy resolution
of 1.0 eV; the total acquisition time was 220 s. Binding energies
were calibrated with respect to C 1s at 284.8 eV. All spectra were
recorded using the Thermo Scientific Avantage software; data files
were translated to VGD format and processed using the Thermo Avantage
package v5.9904. In order to determine the pore textures within the
mask-derived carbon fibers, N2 adsorption and desorption
isotherms were determined using a Micromeritics Tristar II 3020. Specifically,
the pore size distribution of samples was estimated from the adsorption
isotherms using the Barrett–Joyner–Halenda (BJH) model,
whereas the surface area was determined from the typical Brunauer–Emmett–Teller
analysis. Raman spectrum of carbon was obtained using a Raman spectrometer
with a 532 nm laser as the excitation source (from HORIBA XploRA Plus,
Japan). The Joule heating capabilities of the carbonized mask fibers
were determined by connecting the fibers to a DC power supply (from
Dr. Meter) using a glass slide as a support. The voltage was increased
in increments of 1 V, and the temperature was measured using a thermal
camera (from HTI) until the equilibrium state was reached. Water contact
angle measurements were recorded and analyzed using a goniometer and
Contact Angle software from Ossila. Oil adsorption studies were performed
by submerging carbonized mask fibers into 20 mL of various organic
solvents for at least 5 min and recording the mass adsorbed immediately
after removing from the solvent. To investigate the dye adsorption
performance of the carbonized mask fibers, they were first activated
with KOH at a 1:2 carbon to KOH mass ratio. The adsorption performance
of the activated carbon fibers and commercially available PAC was
determined for a dye, basic blue 17, at concentrations of 0.07, 0.15,
and 0.3 mg/mL. 20 mg of the respective carbons was added to each solution
and shaken for 48 h. Aliquots were taken at multiple time points,
and the concentration of the dye was measured using a Genesys 30 visible
spectrometer (Thermo Scientific). The adsorption capacity, qe, of the carbons was calculated using the following
equationwhere C0 is the
initial concentration of the dye, Ce is
the final concentration of the dye, V is the volume
of the solution, and M is the mass of the carbon
sorbent.
Results and Discussion
Scheme A depicts
our simple process to convert PP from surgical masks to carbon fibers
through steps of sulfonation and carbonization. Through heating in
a concentrated sulfuric acid, thermal stabilization of PP occurs,
enabling such commodity plastics to become efficient carbon precursors.
Subsequently, the stabilized PP is exposed to high temperatures (800–1400
°C) under a N2 atmosphere for its pyrolysis to the
final carbon product. Key advantages of this method include its cost-effectiveness
and high scalability. Particularly, both PP and sulfuric acid are
inexpensive raw materials, and a recent review article already suggested
the potential cost benefits of polyolefin-derived carbon fibers compared
to those of their PAN-derived counterparts.[38] Throughout this process, the initial fibril structures of the masks
can be completely retained, resulting in a carbon fiber mat with mechanical
flexibility. It is important to note that several studies suggested
that a broad temperature range (at least above 120 °C) can be
employed for crosslinking polyolefins, including both PP and PE. A
very recent study from Lee et al. successfully characterized the sulfonation
reaction of PP using combined techniques of FTIR and solid-state 13C nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy.[39] The simplified stabilization mechanism of this PP crosslinking
reaction is shown in Scheme B.
Scheme 1
(A) Schematic Illustration of Thermal Stabilization
and Carbonization
Processes of PP Fibers from Surgical Masks; (B) Crosslinking Mechanism
of PP Is Initiated through a Sulfonation Step Which Is Followed by
Olefination and Subsequent Addition/Rearrangement; PP Chains Can Then
Crosslink, Followed by Ring Closure and Degradation of Functional
Groups at Elevated Temperatures
To briefly describe the thermal stabilization mechanism, the initial
sulfonation reaction of PP proceeds by reacting with the secondary/tertiary
carbons along the polymer backbone, followed by the homolytic dissociations
of sulfonyl groups, which results in unsaturated bonds within the
polymer chain. These double bonds from sulfonation can continue to
react through a secondary addition, rearrangement, and dissociation,
leading to the formation of radical species that can directly couple
with other reactive groups from surrounding polymer chains, effectively
producing crosslinked network structures.These crosslinked
polymers can then be converted to carbons upon
pyrolysis, potentially stripping away functional groups upon exposure
to elevated temperatures in inert atmospheres. In our process, the
progress of the sulfonation reaction was monitored by two different
approaches, including tracking mass gain as a function of sulfonation
time, as well as through FTIR spectroscopy, which are both demonstrated
in Figure . At short
time scales, the PP mass gain as a function of time increases rapidly
as the sulfonation reaction progresses (Figure A). After 4 h, the mass gain reaches a plateau
value of 51%, which remains nearly constant even after extending the
reaction time to 12 h (∼52%). FTIR spectra in Figure B also confirm that the sulfonation
reaction results in the formation of double bonds and sulfonic acid
groups in PP. Specifically, pristine PP fibers from masks exhibit
peaks indicative of C–H stretching at 2920 cm–1, which diminishes as the sulfonation/crosslinking reaction progresses
and completely disappears after 4 h of reaction time. Additionally,
the appearance of three separate peaks can be attributed to the progress
of the reaction. The broad −OH stretching peak at 3300 cm–1 emerges after 30 min, and its peak intensity increases
with the increasing reaction time. Peaks from 1250 to 1000 cm–1 are attributed to the presence of sulfonic acid groups.
The addition of alkenes into the PP backbone is demonstrated by the
emerging peaks at 1600 cm–1. Although the masks
do not gain further mass after 4 h of the reaction time, the FTIR
traces suggest that the reaction continues to progress until 12 h.
Compared to previous reports, the kinetics of the reaction is slightly
slower, where Lee et al. demonstrated that the peak at 2920 cm–1 represents that the crosslinkable polyolefin units
diminish after 2 h of the reaction time.[39] Their work utilized a sulfonation process at lower temperatures
(120 °C) but separated the waste masks into very small pieces.
The smaller mask pieces likely enhanced reaction rates compared to
the system presented here due to the increased surface area exposed
to the sulfuric acid-crosslinking agent.[35]
Figure 1
(A)
Mass gain of PP masks as a function of sulfonation reaction
time (at 155 °C). (B) FTIR spectra of sulfonated mask pieces
at various reaction times where peaks at 2920, 1600, and 1250–1000
cm–1 are highlighted to monitor reaction progression.
(A)
Mass gain of PP masks as a function of sulfonation reaction
time (at 155 °C). (B) FTIR spectra of sulfonated mask pieces
at various reaction times where peaks at 2920, 1600, and 1250–1000
cm–1 are highlighted to monitor reaction progression.The fiber structures of pristine and sulfonated
masks (including
after 2 and 12 h) were investigated using scanning electron microscopy
(SEM). As shown in Figure a, the outer layers of masks were composed of PP fibers with
a relative uniform diameter of 25.7 ± 0.7 μm. After our
sulfonation reactions, these fibral structures were completely retained.
This result is consistent with previous reports of crosslinking PE
fibers using acids. Notably, even a slightly higher crosslinking temperature
was employed in our systems, which approaches the onset of melting
in the PP fibers (156 °C, Figure S1) but does not lead to structural collapse. After the reaction for
2 h, the fiber diameter slightly changes to 21.6 μm and remains
relatively constant after 12 h of sulfonation. Interestingly, our
result varies from a recent work studying a variety of PE-based fibers
under similar chemical treatments, which observed that all low-density
PE fibers exhibited increases in the fiber diameter at increased reaction
times up to 25% of the original diameter.[40] Other works also demonstrate a similar phenomenon in PE fibers under
proper reaction conditions.[41,42] We attributed this
difference to the use of sulfuric acids with different concentrations,
where the diluted ones are known to be significantly more reactive
than their concentrated counterparts. Nevertheless, throughout the
sulfonation process, the pre-existed fibrous structures are completely
maintained. It is also found that extending the reaction time to 12
h does not alter the fiber diameters and yet can result in slight
distortion and curving of the fibers, as shown in Figure c. Furthermore, as shown in
the insets of Figure , the macroscopic structures are retained after each processing step. Figure a demonstrates the
neat PP mask and its initial macroscopic structure, while the inset
in Figure c shows
that the shape is maintained throughout the sulfonation process. We
then employed TGA to determine the char yield of sulfonated masks
after two distinct crosslinking time, 2 and 12 h. For our control
sample (unsulfonated PP), all organic components are completely degraded
with 0% mass retention after exposure to 800 °C under N2. For sulfonated PP, it is found that the lower reaction time leads
to a higher mass loss upon carbonization (Figure a), which is probably due to the incomplete
crosslinking of PP throughout the entire fiber structure. Specifically,
2 h of sulfonation results in a carbon yield of 51%, while 12 h of
sulfonation increases the yield to 58%, both derived from the sulfonate
state. As our sulfonation reaction is a diffusion-limited process,
the center part of the fibers could remain unreacted after a relatively
short time, which is susceptible to decomposition or degradation.
Figure 2
SEM images
of fibers within the mask (A) prior to sulfonation and
(B) after 2 and (C) 12 h of sulfonation. The average fiber diameter
within the image is included in the bottom left-hand corner of the
corresponding SEM image. The inset images show the macroscopic structures
of these masks.
Figure 3
(A) TGA thermograms of pristine PP and sulfonated
PP (from masks)
after different crosslinking times where longer reaction times increase
the carbon yield. (B) SEM image of carbonized fibers after 2 h of
sulfonation, leading to the decomposition of the unreacted center
portions of the fiber. The inset image depicts a hollow fiber which
results from insufficient crosslinking. (C) SEM image of carbonized
fibers after 12 h of sulfonation which results in complete crosslinking
and continuous fibers. EDX analysis highlighting (D) carbon and (E)
sulfur contents in carbonized mask fibers. (F) XPS spectrum of carbonized
fibers after 12 h of sulfonation.
SEM images
of fibers within the mask (A) prior to sulfonation and
(B) after 2 and (C) 12 h of sulfonation. The average fiber diameter
within the image is included in the bottom left-hand corner of the
corresponding SEM image. The inset images show the macroscopic structures
of these masks.(A) TGA thermograms of pristine PP and sulfonated
PP (from masks)
after different crosslinking times where longer reaction times increase
the carbon yield. (B) SEM image of carbonized fibers after 2 h of
sulfonation, leading to the decomposition of the unreacted center
portions of the fiber. The inset image depicts a hollow fiber which
results from insufficient crosslinking. (C) SEM image of carbonized
fibers after 12 h of sulfonation which results in complete crosslinking
and continuous fibers. EDX analysis highlighting (D) carbon and (E)
sulfur contents in carbonized mask fibers. (F) XPS spectrum of carbonized
fibers after 12 h of sulfonation.Additionally, for 12 h samples, the TGA thermogram exhibits no
secondary thermal decomposition after 100 °C, which is present
in the 2 h sulfonated sample that has been attributed to the decomposition
of unreacted polymer chains within the fiber. As shown in Figure B, carbon fibers
with hollow structures were observed from samples with only 2 h of
sulfonation. For PP fibers after 12 h of sulfonation, an identical
carbonization condition results in carbon fibers with completely solid
cores (Figure C).
The sulfonation-crosslinking step also imparts additional functionality
into the carbon fibers, such as inherent incorporation of sulfur heteroatoms
into the carbon framework. Sulfur doping can enhance the functionality
of associated carbon-based materials in many applications, including
energy storage,[43] catalysis,[44] and CO2 adsorption.[45] EDS was performed to determine the elemental composition
of the final carbon fiber product. Figure D,E depicts the elemental maps that correspond
to both carbon and sulfur produced through EDS. The sulfur-doping
content was found to be 5.6 wt % for carbonized PP masks with 12 h,
and the overlayed elemental map demonstrates that the heteroatoms
are uniformly distributed within the carbon fibers. The presence of
heteroatoms in the carbon framework of our mask waste-derived carbon
fibers was further investigated using XPS. Figure F depicts the survey scan of carbonized fibers
after 12 h of sulfonation, indicating the presence of carbon (284.09
eV), oxygen (532.20 eV), and sulfur (163.79 eV) atoms within the carbon
framework at 96.7, 2.9, and 0.4 at. %, respectively. This lower doping
content from XPS measurements compared to EDS results suggest that
the fiber surface might have much lower sulfur content than the inner
parts. Additionally, high-resolution XPS scans for each element can
be found in Figure S2, which describe their
chemical environments. Interestingly, the results of the sulfur high-resolution
scans differ from the recent work from Lee et al. where most of the
sulfur content was bonded to oxygen.[39] In
this work, the peaks at 163.5 and 164.7 eV suggest that the sulfur
atoms are directly bonded to carbon as part of the framework rather
than being bonded to oxygen which would be illustrated by the presence
of peaks at slightly higher binding energies. Furthermore, Raman spectroscopy
was employed to characterize the degree of graphitization of these
carbon products. In general, carbon materials with higher degrees
of graphitization can exhibit better electrical and thermal conductivity
through facilitating the electron transport along the in-plane direction
as opposed to the amorphous carbon counterparts. The ratio of the
intensities of the disordered (at 1370 cm–1) and
graphitic bands (at 1597 cm–1) is 1.21 (Figure S3). The N2 adsorption–desorption
behavior of the mask-derived carbon fiber was characterized using
gas physisorption measurements, which can determine pore volume, pore
size distribution, and surface area of the carbon samples. As shown
in Figure A, our carbon
fibers exhibit a typical type-II isotherm, suggesting the presence
of both macropores and mesopores, with a surface area of 295.46 m2/g. Furthermore, the pore size distribution is relatively
uniform and centered around 12 nm (Figure B). We want to note that the generation of
pores occurred during the carbonization process when portions of the
polymer chains are thermally degraded and gases (CO, CO2, H2O, and SO2) are evolved, which can potentially
react with the carbon framework. From our control experiments, we
found that sulfonated fibers prior to carbonization possess no micropores
(Figure S4).
Figure 4
(A) Nitrogen adsorption–desorption
isotherm with the inset
highlighting the hysteresis that occurs at the partial pressure range
from 0.6 to 0.98 and (B) the associated pore size distribution determined
using the BJH method.
(A) Nitrogen adsorption–desorption
isotherm with the inset
highlighting the hysteresis that occurs at the partial pressure range
from 0.6 to 0.98 and (B) the associated pore size distribution determined
using the BJH method.To further demonstrate
the use of these carbon fibers in practical
applications, we investigate their performance for Joule heating,
oil absorption, and water remediation. The ability of a material to
reach elevated temperatures upon the application of low voltages through
Joule heating provides great potential in several applications, including
thermotherapy,[46,47] crude oil recovery,[48,49] and thermochromics.[50,51] Joule heating is a result of
electrons colliding with atoms within a conductor and which generates
heat in regions where current transmits. Equation simplistically depicts the Joule heating
of a current density j in an electrical field E in a material of electrical conductivity σ.[52]This relationship demonstrates that the thermal energy produced
from Joule heating is directly dictated by the conductivity of the
material where enhanced conductivity results in increased output of
energy in to the form of Joule heating. Figure A shows a simple demonstration confirming
the electrically conductive nature of our carbon fibers, which can
illuminate the light-emitting diode (LED) bulb intensely in the circuit.
In Joule heating experiments, the carbonized mask fibers were subjected
to different voltages and then allowed to be equilibrated. As shown
in Figure B, with
the application of increased voltage from 1 to 10 V, the mask-derived
carbon fibers can reach a broad temperature range from 29 °C
to greater than 300 °C with the application of 10 V. The thermal
image in Figure C
further clearly demonstrates that the temperature of the mask fibers
was at ∼248 °C (at 9 V). The Joule heating capability
of these mask-derived carbon fibers is much more robust than that
of other carbon products from waste resources, specifically coal tar
which required 60 V to achieve the maximum temperature demonstrated
here.[53] Furthermore, the heating happens
rapidly due to the high conductivity of the carbon fibers, equilibrating
in a matter of seconds. After the voltage is removed, heat dissipates
quickly, and the fibers return to room temperature in less than 10
s. While it may be challenging to directly use these carbonized masks
for making products due to their shape and brittleness, these results
suggest that carbon fibers derived from mask waste could still be
employed as fillers in preparing Joule heating composites.
Figure 5
(A) Portion
of a mask-derived carbon fiber mat completing a circuit
and illuminating an LED light as a demonstration of the conductivity
of the carbon. (B) Temperature of the carbon fiber increases with
increasing voltage, achieving greater than 300 °C after the application
of 10 V. (C) Image from the thermal camera demonstrating the excellent
Joule heating performance of the carbon fiber mat at 9 V.
(A) Portion
of a mask-derived carbon fiber mat completing a circuit
and illuminating an LED light as a demonstration of the conductivity
of the carbon. (B) Temperature of the carbon fiber increases with
increasing voltage, achieving greater than 300 °C after the application
of 10 V. (C) Image from the thermal camera demonstrating the excellent
Joule heating performance of the carbon fiber mat at 9 V.The hydrophobicity of carbon materials enables their use
for oil
adsorption. The favorable interactions between organic solvents and
hydrophobic carbon drive the adsorption of oils to the carbon surface.
The carbonized mask fibers exhibit high water contact angles (Figure S5A) but are easily wet by organic solvents,
such as chloroform (Figure S5B). Figure A–C depicts
a demonstration of the carbonized mask fibers being used to absorb
organic solvents which act as surrogates for oil-based pollutants.
Acetone (red) and chloroform (blue) are easily absorbed by simply
placing the carbonized fibers into the solvent droplets. This behavior
is consistent for many organic solvents, as demonstrated in Figure D. The carbon mask
fibers exhibit varied adsorption capacities for different organic
solvents, with a maximum amount of up to 14 g of mineral oil per g
of carbon fiber. The difference in the uptake capacity against different
solvents is primarily associated with the surface energy of carbon
surfaces and the interactions between the surface functional groups
and solvent molecules, which has been commonly observed in various
oil sorbent systems.[54,55] Additionally, this performance
is highly cyclable, where the sorbate can be efficiently removed,
and the mask can be reused in further adsorption. This advantageous
property is confirmed in Figure E where chloroform has been repeatedly adsorbed by
a carbon fiber mat, recovered, and adsorbed again. We wanted to note
that while the oil adsorption capacities are much lower than other
sorbent technologies such as porous foams due to their limited porosity,[56] conventional methods for preparing porous sorbents
require multiple steps for functionalization. Alternatively, carbon
foam can be derived from direct pyrolysis of melamine foams; however,
this approaches only produce 2–5% carbon yield,[57,58] restricting their scalability. Our materials exhibit carbon yields
which are an order of magnitude higher, through very simple processing,
making them competitive from a scalability-focused perspective. These
performances demonstrate the potential applications of the hydrophobic
carbon fibers to act as an efficient mechanism in oil sorption and
oil/water separation applications.
Figure 6
(A–C) Demonstration of carbon fibers
being used to adsorb
oil represented by acetone (red) and chloroform (blue). (D) Oil uptake
capacity of the carbonized mask fibers given as gram of sorbate per
gram of sorbent. (E) Cycling performance of oil adsorption performed
by adsorbing chloroform, heating to remove the sorbate, and repeating
this process for five cycles.
(A–C) Demonstration of carbon fibers
being used to adsorb
oil represented by acetone (red) and chloroform (blue). (D) Oil uptake
capacity of the carbonized mask fibers given as gram of sorbate per
gram of sorbent. (E) Cycling performance of oil adsorption performed
by adsorbing chloroform, heating to remove the sorbate, and repeating
this process for five cycles.Porous carbon sorbents are established technologies for the removal
of pollutants such as small-molecule dyes from water. Commercially,
PAC is broadly employed in the treatment of wastewater because it
is inexpensive to manufacture and widely available. PAC is typically
produced through carbonization of biomass, containing micropores with
a surface area ranging from 500 to 1500 m2/g. The presence
of micropores provides sorption sites for facilitating the adsorption
of pollutants from water. Herein, we used a KOH-based activation technique
(Figure A). Specifically,
the carbonized masks were activated through reacting with KOH to enhance
the porosity of the carbon fibers and increase surface area. From
the N2 isotherm in Figure B, it is evident by the large increase in the quantity
of N2 adsorbed at low relative pressures (p/p0: 0–0.1) that micropores have
been generated in the fibers. The activation process significantly
improves the surface area of these carbon fibers from 295 to 600 m2/g. Commercially available PAC has a very similar isotherm
(Figure S6), with a slightly higher surface
area of 712 m2/g. As shown in Figure S7, the grinding process during blending of the activating
agent disrupts the macroscopic structure of the mask, but the microscopic,
fibrous shape is maintained, albeit at a shorter scale. It was also
found that the oxygen content of carbon fibers increases from imperceptible
amounts to 25.6 wt %, determined by the EDX measurements. To gauge
the performance of the activated mask in water remediation applications,
dye adsorption studies were performed with a water-soluble dye, basic
blue 17, and compared to the performance of a commercially available
PAC. The adsorption capacities as a function of time in three different
dye concentrations were investigated, which were 0.07 mg/mL (Figure S8A), 0.15 mg/mL (Figure C), and 0.30 mg/mL (Figure S8B). Across all of the dye concentrations, the two sorbents
exhibit very similar adsorption capacities after 48 h of exposure
to the dye solution. Both PAC and the activated mask fibers had adsorption
capacities of roughly 0.033, 0.09, and 0.19 mg/mg for the 0.07, 0.15,
and 0.30 mg/mL solutions, respectively. At higher concentrations (0.15
and 0.30 mg/mL), our activated carbon fibers exhibit much faster adsorption
kinetics than the PAC, as demonstrated in Figure S8. The dye adsorption kinetics was fit to a pseudo first-order
model using the following equationwhere qe is the
amount of dye adsorbed at equilibrium, q is the amount of dye adsorbed at time t, and k1 is the first-order equilibrium
rate constant. At 0.15 and 0.30 mg/mL, the rate constant of the dye
adsorption by the activated fibers (0.649 and 0.213 h–1, respectively) is significantly higher than the adsorption by the
PAC (0.076 and 0.075 h–1, respectively), which can
be attributed to the combined effects of the fibrous structures of
our surgical mask-derived carbons (Figure S9) and the enhanced surface functionality through KOH activation.
Previous studies suggested that these fiber structures can improve
the contact between sorbent and sorbates, facilitating the sorption
process.[59,60] Our activated carbon fibers, with a diameter
of approximately of 21 μm, can provide enhanced contact areas
and improved transport and diffusion of dye molecules as opposed to
powder samples with an average particle size over hundreds of micrometers.
Additionally, the functional groups on material (e.g., polymers, carbons,
and metal oxides) surfaces can also alter their performance in different
applications.[61,62] In this study, the oxygen groups
introduced through KOH activation can facilitate the interactions
between carbon fibers and basic blue 17 for improving the sorption
kinetics. These results demonstrate that the activated carbon fibers
fabricated from waste products and scalable production methods are
competitive with current commercially viable materials for water remediation.
Figure 7
(A) Schematic
illustration of KOH activation of already carbonized
mask fibers to induce microporosity and increase the surface area.
(B) N2 adsorption isotherm of carbonized mask fibers after
the activation process. The isotherm indicates the increased surface
area compared to the neat, carbonized fibers. (C) Dye adsorption study
at a concentration of 0.15 mg/mL investigating the adsorption capacities
as a function of time of activated carbon fibers compared to PAC.
(A) Schematic
illustration of KOH activation of already carbonized
mask fibers to induce microporosity and increase the surface area.
(B) N2 adsorption isotherm of carbonized mask fibers after
the activation process. The isotherm indicates the increased surface
area compared to the neat, carbonized fibers. (C) Dye adsorption study
at a concentration of 0.15 mg/mL investigating the adsorption capacities
as a function of time of activated carbon fibers compared to PAC.
Conclusions
As the
Covid-19 pandemic continues to spur the production and consumption
of single-use plastics, including PP masks, efficient methods are
required to repurpose materials to mitigate their negative effects.
This work depicts a facile and scalable approach to thermally stabilize
PP masks and convert them into multifunctional carbon fibers. The
thermal stabilization process imparts additional functionality into
the fibers through sulfur doping the carbon framework and generating
pores upon carbonization. The performance of the fibers for Joule
heating materials, oil adsorption, and dye removal from aqueous solutions
is demonstrated, suggesting the practical applications of these carbonaceous
products derived from waste materials.
Authors: Bryan E Barton; Michael J Behr; Jasson T Patton; Eric J Hukkanen; Brian G Landes; Weijun Wang; Nicholas Horstman; James E Rix; Denis Keane; Steven Weigand; Mark Spalding; Chris Derstine Journal: Small Date: 2017-07-24 Impact factor: 13.281