Tao Chen1,2, Guangjun Xiao1,3, Zhuo Wang1,3, Jian Zou1,2, Jian Wang4, Weibo Hu1, Yahu A Liu5, Hui Yang1,3, Ke Wen1,3. 1. Shanghai Advanced Research Institute, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Shanghai 201210, China. 2. University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, China. 3. School of Physical Science and Technology, ShanghaiTech University, Shanghai 201210, China. 4. School of Life Science and Technology, ShanghaiTech University, Shanghai 201210, China. 5. Medicinal Chemistry, ChemBridge Research Laboratories, San Diego, California 92127, United States.
Abstract
Integrating fluorescent chromophores in aromatic frameworks could not only prevent aggregation-induced quenching caused by the π-π stacking interaction between the chromophore components but also confer new fluorescence properties. Herein, we report the fabrication of s-tetrazine-bridged aromatic frameworks TzAF by the incorporation of the smallest aromatic fluorophore, s-tetrazine (Tz), into the skeleton of a tetrahedrally connected lattice of aromatic frameworks. The thin films of TzAF coated on silica gel plates were found to exhibit reversible photoswitching fluorescence characteristics under alternate UV and visible-light irradiations with excellent fluorescence stability and high on/off contrast. The repeatable "on/off"fluorescence photoswitchability of the TzAF thin films was mechanistically attributed to light-induced reversible transformation between TzAF's neutral and radical states.
Integrating fluorescent chromophores in aromatic frameworks could not only prevent aggregation-induced quenching caused by the π-π stacking interaction between the chromophore components but also confer new fluorescence properties. Herein, we report the fabrication of s-tetrazine-bridged aromatic frameworks TzAF by the incorporation of the smallest aromatic fluorophore, s-tetrazine (Tz), into the skeleton of a tetrahedrally connected lattice of aromatic frameworks. The thin films of TzAF coated on silica gel plates were found to exhibit reversible photoswitching fluorescence characteristics under alternate UV and visible-light irradiations with excellent fluorescence stability and high on/off contrast. The repeatable "on/off"fluorescence photoswitchability of the TzAF thin films was mechanistically attributed to light-induced reversible transformation between TzAF's neutral and radical states.
Stimuli-responsive
materials are able to reversibly change their
physicochemical states and distinguishable properties in response
to externally applied stimuli, such as stress, light, temperature,
moisture, pH, or electric or magnetic fields.[1−6] For example, photoswitchable fluorescent materials are photochromic
fluorophores whose distinct on/off fluorescence emission could be
controlled by light.[7−9] As light can be delivered instantly to precise locations
of light-responsive materials, such materials have thus found wide
application potentials in the areas of information encryption, anticounterfeiting,
reversible fluorescence imaging, ultrahigh-resolution bioimaging,
photocontrolled biological functions, rewritable printing, and so
forth. Photochromic fluorescence materials were usually obtained through
a suitable molecular combination of photochromism and fluorescence,
that is, chemical association between photochromic and fluorescent
molecular components.[7−9] Thus far, various diarylethene (DArE)-based photochromic
fluorescent materials have been well reported, thanks to the inherent
fluorescence that resulted from resonance energy transfer or intramolecular
electron transfer processes possessed by the DArE-based molecular
components and their excellent photoswitching properties, biostability,
and fatigue resistance.[7−10] Besides DArE, a few other photochromic fluorophores, including the
derivatives of spiropyran, spironaphthoxazine, imidazole dimer, dipyrromethene,
oxazine, hydrazones, and rhodamine, have also been unveiled.[7−12] Fluorophores emit bright fluorescence in solution, but their fluorescence
intensity is much weaker in the solid states as electronic coupling
in well-conjugated and planar aromatic structures quenches fluorescence
emission, preventing the reliable translation of fluorescence properties
to applications as solid materials.[13,14] To avoid such
aggregation-caused quenching (ACQ), fluorophores could be dispersed
into lattice porous structures[13] or incorporated
as building blocks in the structures of porous solid materials such
as metal organic frameworks (MOFs), covalent organic frameworks (COFs),[15] porous organic polymers,[16] or porous aromatic frameworks (PAFs).[17] Toward this end, Laursen, Flood, and co-workers allowed
cationic fluorophores cocrystallized into well-defined lattices of
ion-sequestering macrocycles to keep the fluorescent dyes from dulling
in the solid state.[13] Hill, Ladewig, and
co-workers developed photoswitchable fluorescent PAF materials using
DArE-based fluorophores as guest molecules.[18] Klajn’s group described two families of spiropyran-based
fluorescent photoswitchable frameworks in which the spiropyran units
were incorporated in the framework skeleton.[17] Zhu’s group has developed photoswitchable fluorescent PAF
materials by decorating the frame of PAF-5CF with DArE fluorophores.[19] However, it is challenging to integrate large
fluorophores covalently into the aromatic framework skeletons. We
envisioned that it could be more straightforward to incorporate covalently
smaller photochromic fluorophores into the skeletons. In our search
for small non-DArE-based fluorescent photoswitchable materials, we
were intrigued by 1,2,4,5-tetrazine (s-tetrazine, Tz), the arguably smallest and electron-poorest aromatic fluorophore
in which the presence of four sp2 nitrogen atoms makes
the ring an exceptionally strong electron acceptor, comparable to
tetranitrobenzene.[20−22] With a low-energy π* lowest unoccupied molecular
orbital (LUMO), the π-aromatic system of Tz can
be reversibly reduced to a stable radical anion which possesses a
distinct different fluorescence property from that of Tz.[20,21] For instance, chloromethoxyltetrazine is
highly fluorescent in its neutral state, but its radical anion is
nonfluorescent.[23,24] Although Tz is photochemically
unstable, the stability of a substituted Tz increases
as the size of the substituent(s) increases.[20−22] Therefore,
it was reasonable to speculate that incorporating Tz units
into a PAF skeleton could form a stable porous photochromic fluorescent
material. In fact, Tz has already been used as a building
block in copolymers[25−27] and porous MOFs.[28] Very
recently, Ghosh, Abe, Seki, and co-workers stitched Tz building blocks into COFs.[29] Nonetheless, Tz has not yet been used as a skeleton building unit in PAFs.
With previous experience in covalent triazine frameworks (CTFs),[30−32] we therefore embarked on a task of integrating Tz units
and tetraphenylmethane units to create new aromatic frameworks bearing
unique photochromic properties. Herein, we report our work on the
development of photoswitchable fluorescent Tz-bridged
aromatic frameworks (TzAF), which demonstrate repeatable
“on/off” fluorescence photoswitchability under alternate
UV and visible-light irradiation.
Results
and Discussion
Synthetic Procedure
Previously, we
have developed a method for the synthesis of CTFs through an aromatic
nucleophilic substitution reaction (SNAr).[30−32] We therefore first tried to synthesize the designed TzAF through SNAr of 3,6-dichloro-1,2,4,5-tetrazine with Grignard
reagent 3a or organolithium reagent 3b (Scheme ). Unfortunately,
the reaction did not yield the desired product probably due to the
poor solubility of organometallic precursors (3a and 3b). Thus, instead of using Tz-containing building
blocks, we decided to try a de novo synthesis during which dihydro-s-tetrazine (dihydro-Tz) units were built from
nitrile and hydrazine and then oxidized to aromatic Tz units. As illustrated in Scheme , the attempted reaction of tetrahedral symmetric aromatic
nitrile (4) and hydrazine catalyzed by sulfur powder
yielded the nonconjugated dihydro-Tz-bridged cross-linked
frames 6,[33−35] but the sharp heat and gas release of the reaction
prompted us to explore a stepwise approach (Figure S7, Supporting Information). Therefore, nitrile 4 was first transformed to amidine 5, which then
reacted with hydrazine to furnish the dihydro-Tz-bridged
frameworks 6.[33−35] The transformation of nonrigid 6 into the desired target TzAF was realized through
the oxidation of the dihydro-Tz units into aromatic Tz rings in the frameworks.[33]
Scheme 1
Synthesis of TzAF
Characterization
The as-synthesized TzAF was characterized by suspended-state 1H nuclear
magnetic resonance (NMR) and solid-state 13C cross-polarization
magic angle spinning (13C CP-MAS) NMR spectroscopies, Fourier
transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy, ultraviolet–visible
(UV–vis) spectroscopy, solid-state UV–vis–near-IR
(UV–vis–NIR) spectroscopy, X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy
(XPS), thermogravimetric analysis (TGA), powder X-ray diffraction
(PXRD) analysis, field-emission scanning electron microscopy (FE-SEM),
and field-emission transmission electron microscopy (FE-TEM). The
aromatic protons were obvious in the suspended-state 1H
NMR spectrum of TzAF dispersed in DMSO-d6 (Figure a), while no amidine NH proton signals in the range of 9–10
ppm were observed, indicating the complete conversion of 6 to TzAF.[36] The signals at
around 65 ppm, 127–155 ppm, and 160–165 ppm in the 13C CP-MAS NMR spectrum (Figure b) could be assigned to the carbons of tetraphenylmethanes,
the benzene, and the Tz units, respectively. The peak
at 42.7 ppm (7.5 kHz) should be attributed to the spinning sideband
of the C–H carbons of benzene, which have a large chemical-shift
anisotropy (Δδ = 127.7 ppm) (22.5 kHz); thus, the chemical
shifts of the benzene C–H carbons and the sideband differed
by ∼15 kHz, which is the frequency of MAS. Other spinning sidebands
and the artifacts of magic-angle spinning (MAS)[37,38] are shown in Figure S6 (Supporting Information).
Figure 1
(a) Suspended-state 1H NMR spectrum of TzAF dispersed in DMSO-d6 (400 MHz, 298 K);
(b) solid-state 13C CP-MAS NMR spectrum of TzAF; (c) normalized UV–vis spectra of 5 (black)
and TzAF (red) in a mixed solvent of water and ethanol
(1:1, v/v) (insert: UV–vis–NIR spectrum of TzAF as a solid-state thin film); (d) TGA of TzAF under
a N2 atmosphere (insert: detailed view in the range of
180–300 °C).
(a) Suspended-state 1H NMR spectrum of TzAF dispersed in DMSO-d6 (400 MHz, 298 K);
(b) solid-state 13C CP-MAS NMR spectrum of TzAF; (c) normalized UV–vis spectra of 5 (black)
and TzAF (red) in a mixed solvent of water and ethanol
(1:1, v/v) (insert: UV–vis–NIR spectrum of TzAF as a solid-state thin film); (d) TGA of TzAF under
a N2 atmosphere (insert: detailed view in the range of
180–300 °C).In the UV–vis
spectra of amidine 5 and TzAF dispersed
in a water and ethanol solution (1:1, v/v)
(Figure c), the broad
absorption peaks in the range of 250–270 nm could be attributed
to the π–π* electron transition of the benzene
rings.[39] As the benzene units in TzAF were covalently connected to the electron-deficient Tz units, their π–π* electron transition
absorption peak blue-shifted by 7 nm with respect to that of 5 (TzAF, 257.5 nm; 5, 264.5 nm)
(Figure c). TzAF also showed weak absorption in the range of 300–500
nm, which could be attributed to the n–π*
and π–π* electron transitions of the Tz units.[40] In the UV–vis–NIR
spectrum of the solid TzAF thin film (Figure c, the insert), an absorption
peak at ∼257 nm (π–π* transition of the
benzene rings) and an absorption band ranging from 300 to 600 nm (n–π* and π–π* transitions
of tetrazine units) were observed. The similarity between the UV–vis
spectra of TzAF dispersed in the solution and TzAF film implied that TzAF is in homologous chemical environments
in both the solution and solid state. TGA under a nitrogen atmosphere
indicated that TzAF started to decompose at 245 °C
(extrapolation, the insert of Figure d) probably due to the decomposition of the Tz units,[41,42] and ∼35% weight remained at 1000
°C.The X-ray photoelectron spectrum of TzAF (Figure ) showed
three peaks
at 532, 400, and 285 eV, corresponding to O 1s, N 1s, and C 1s signals,
respectively (Figure a). The O 1s peak mainly arose from molecular oxygen or water molecules
absorbed on the surface or in the pores of the frameworks, which is
typical for most carbon-based materials.[30,31,43] The N 1s peak with a binding energy of 400.1
eV was from the −C=N– of Tz rings
(Figure b).[44] Since the charge distribution on carbon atoms
in the Tz rings was influenced by the electron-deficient Tz N atoms, the C 1s peak of TzAF was deconvoluted into Gaussian–Lorentzian
shapes (Figure c),
among which the peak at 284.7 eV was assigned to quaternary carbons
and phenyl carbons, the one at 285.5 eV to the carbons in the Tz units,[43−46] and the weak broad peak at 291.6 eV to the characteristic shake-up
satellites of the aromatic carbons (π–π* transition).[43,47−49]
Figure 2
X-ray photoelectron spectrum of TzAF: (a)
survey spectrum;
(b) N 1s scan; (c) C 1s scan.
X-ray photoelectron spectrum of TzAF: (a)
survey spectrum;
(b) N 1s scan; (c) C 1s scan.In the FTIR spectrum of TzAF (Figure ), the disappearance of the amidine −C=NH
peak at 1676 cm–1 indicated no residual amidine
left in the sample.[36,50,51] The IR bands at 1560, 1412, and 1072 cm–1 could
arise from the C–N stretching vibrations of the Tz units,[52−55] and the peaks at 1609, 1493, and 1448 cm–1 corresponded
to the C=C breathing vibrations of the benzene rings. Due to
the effect of electron deficiency of the Tz units, the
characteristic peak for the benzene rings red-shifted from 1500 cm–1 to 1493 cm–1, with its intensity
reduced to a level lower than the peak at 1609 cm–1.[56] Additionally, the absorption band
at 830 cm–1 was attributed the characteristic C–H
out-of-plane bending vibrations of the benzene units.
Figure 3
FTIR spectrum of TzAF in the range of 1800–600
cm–1.
FTIR spectrum of TzAF in the range of 1800–600
cm–1.From the nitrogen adsorption–desorption
measurement at 77
K, a type IV adsorption isotherm, typical for mesoporous materials,
was obtained (Figure c).[57] The Brunauer–Emmett–Teller
(BET) surface area of TzAF was calculated to be 16 m2 g–1, and the pore size distribution calculated
by the Barrett–Joyner–Halenda method showed that TzAF is a mesoporous material with the pore diameters ranging
between 1.8 and 2.5 nm. The PXRD measurement (Figure b) of TzAF showed no apparent
sharp peaks in 1–10° (2 theta), declaring its non-long-range
ordering nature. The BET surface area of TzAF was obviously
smaller than what we expected for such PAFs.[58,59] One possible reason could be structural interpenetration, which
is hard to avoid in the formation of PAFs. In addition, we believe
that incompletion of the formation of the ideal diamond-shaped lattice
of the frameworks could be another reason. The nonaromatic dihydro-Tz is a nonplanar twisted ring, as illustrated by a model
compound 3,6-dimethyl-1,4-dihydro-1,2,4,5-tetrazine (Figure S8, Supporting Information),[60] and twisted nonaromatic dihydro-Tz should cause structural
twists in the intermediate frameworks 6. Therefore, frameworks 6 could be semiporous, which could hinder NaNO2 from diffusing freely into the mesopores of 6, resulting
in the incompletion of the oxidation of dihydro-Tz by
NaNO2. As a result, the aromatic frameworks TzAF could also be semiporous with mesopores (pore size ∼2 nm),
which is consistent with a low BET surface area value.
Figure 4
(a) FE-SEM image of TzAF (5 μm scale); (b) PXRD
pattern of TzAF (2 theta = 0.8–10°); (c)
nitrogen sorption isotherm of TzAF at 77 K; (d) pore
size distribution of TzAF; (e) FE-TEM image of TzAF (50 nm scale).
(a) FE-SEM image of TzAF (5 μm scale); (b) PXRD
pattern of TzAF (2 theta = 0.8–10°); (c)
nitrogen sorption isotherm of TzAF at 77 K; (d) pore
size distribution of TzAF; (e) FE-TEM image of TzAF (50 nm scale).Plots
of the calculated molecular orbitals of DTTz (blue, O;
gray, C; white, H).The morphological details
of TzAF were studied by
FE-TEM and FE-SEM. The FE-SEM images of TzAF revealed
particulates in the microscale (Figure a and Supporting Information), while the FE-TEM images with a relatively small thickness contrast
indicated that the pore sizes were about 2 nm, which was consistent
with the result of nitrogen adsorption–desorption measurement
(Figure e and Supporting Information).
Fluorescence
Properties
In order
to get a better understanding of the fluorescence property of TzAF, 3,6-di-p-tolyl-1,2,4,5-tetrazine (DTTz) was prepared as a model structure of the TzAF skeleton unit. The quantum chemical calculations of DTTz revealed an absence of imaginary frequencies, which meant a true
energy minimum, consistent with its crystal structure (CCDC 202204).[61] Based on the optimized geometry of DTTz, the optical transition energies and oscillator strengths were obtained
using time-dependent density functional theory (TD-DFT) calculations
with the same basic set. The results of the TD-DFT calculations (Figure and Table S1, Supporting Information) agreed well with the
experimental UV–vis spectrum (Figure b).
Figure 5
Plots
of the calculated molecular orbitals of DTTz (blue, O;
gray, C; white, H).
Figure 6
(a) 3D-fluorescence spectrum of DTTz (5 × 10–4 M in MeCN) in the range of 500–700
nm (excited
by 300–600 nm). (b) UV–vis spectrum of DTTz in MeCN (red, 5 × 10–5 M; blue, 5 ×
10–4 M). (c) 3D-fluorescence spectrum of TzAF (in a mixed solvent of Et3N/MeOH, 1:10, v/v) in the range
of 300–800 nm (excited by 270–800 nm). (d) PL spectra
of the solid-state TzAF excited at 254 nm (black), 340
nm (red), and 365 nm (blue). (e) Fluorescence time profile of TzAF (λexc. = 340 nm and λdec. = 484 nm): the experimental data (red), fitting curve (black), and
residuals (blue). (f) Fluorescence time profile of TzAF (λexc. = 340 nm and λdec. = 587
nm): the experimental data (purple), fitting curve (black), and residuals
(blue).
(a) 3D-fluorescence spectrum of DTTz (5 × 10–4 M in MeCN) in the range of 500–700
nm (excited
by 300–600 nm). (b) UV–vis spectrum of DTTz in MeCN (red, 5 × 10–5 M; blue, 5 ×
10–4 M). (c) 3D-fluorescence spectrum of TzAF (in a mixed solvent of Et3N/MeOH, 1:10, v/v) in the range
of 300–800 nm (excited by 270–800 nm). (d) PL spectra
of the solid-state TzAF excited at 254 nm (black), 340
nm (red), and 365 nm (blue). (e) Fluorescence time profile of TzAF (λexc. = 340 nm and λdec. = 484 nm): the experimental data (red), fitting curve (black), and
residuals (blue). (f) Fluorescence time profile of TzAF (λexc. = 340 nm and λdec. = 587
nm): the experimental data (purple), fitting curve (black), and residuals
(blue).The leading configuration of the
first excited state is an n–π* transition
(S0–S1), that is, from the nonbonding
orbitals of the nitrogen atoms highest occupied molecular orbital
(HOMO) in DTTz to the antibonding π* orbitals of
the Tz ring (LUMO). The oscillator strength is low as
a result of this forbidden transition, which is also in agreement
with the experimental result where the corresponding absorption band
is weak (centered at 543.5 nm, ε = 354 L mol–1 cm–1). The shoulder-type peak range of 350–420
nm in the experimental spectrum is a weak π–π*
transition (Figure b) which might involve π-orbitals delocalized over the DTTz molecule (HOMO – 1 → LUMO). Meanwhile,
an intermediate transition which involves n–π*
transition (HOMO → LUMO + 1) is calculated to be with a zero
oscillator strength. The absorption band at around 300 nm arises from
the combination of two π–π* transitions: one from
the orbitals of the Tz ring and the other from the orbitals
of the benzene-ring.Upon excitation at the first absorption
(500–600 nm) of DTTz, weak fluorescence was observed
in the region of 575–620
nm (Figure a). In
addition, a higher absorption energy leads to a higher excited (S) state, which could be transformed
to the S1 state through vibrational relaxation
and internal conversion, accompanied by emitting S1 → S0 or S → S0 fluorescence.[38] As a consequence, the
excitation of DTTz by a 330–400 nm light resulted
in fluorescent emission at 560–630 nm. The inconspicuously
weak fluorescence peak at around 580 nm might be due to the intermolecular
orbital overlap between the electron-deficient Tz ring
and the two electron-rich benzene rings in DTTz. Nevertheless,
the orbital overlap between Tz units and benzene units
in the frameworks TzAF was prohibited due to the blockage
of quaternary carbons. Consequently, solvent-dispersed TzAF emitted fluorescence at 400–650 nm at a higher intensity
with two broad excitation wavelength ranges of 270–310 nm and
350–600 nm (Figure c). In addition, the PL spectra of the solid-state TzAF excited at 254, 340, and 365 nm showed two broad emission peaks:
one centered at 456, 478, and 484 nm and the other centered at 590,
583, and 587 nm, respectively (Figure d). The fitted lifetimes of TzAF’s
fluorescence at 484 and 587 nm (excited by 340 nm) were 2.278 ns (τ1 = 0.9157 ns, 81.13%; τ2 = 8.1241 ns, 18.87%)
and 249.853 ns (τ1 = 2.3733 ns, 23.18%; τ2 = 324.5291 ns, 76.82%), respectively, indicating that the
emission at 587 nm needs more time to be vibrationally relaxed and
internally converted to its S state.
Fluorescence Switching
The π-aromatic Tz ring can be reduced to a radical
anion which has much weaker
fluorescence emission than its neutral state, as exemplified by chloromethoxytetrazine.[16,17,19,20] Thus, in TzAF, the electron-deficient Tz units conjugated to the benzene units should be able to be readily
reduced to Tz radical anions by light-generated electrons,
resulting in a significant decrease in the fluorescence intensity.
The fluorescence intensity could be able to be regained once the Tz radical releases an electron to resume the neutral state.
Therefore, we envisioned that this neutral ↔ radical state
interconversion should make TzAF a good photochromic
fluorophore with distinct on–off fluorescence emission.Based on the above assumptions, we set out to explore the fluorescence
photoswitchability of the TzAF thin films coated on silica
gel plates. As shown in Figure d, TzAF emitted fluorescence under UV light irradiation
at 365, 340, or 254 nm. To our delight, it was found that the TzAF thin film emitted bright fluorescence under a 254 nm
UV light irradiation (Figure a), but its emission could be turned off by the irradiation
of a 405 nm laser light, as was exemplified by “writing”
the number “254” on a 254 nm UV-excited TzAF thin film using 405 nm laser beam (Figure b and S13, Supporting Information). The mark“254” on the TzAF thin film started to fade when exposed to 254 nm UV light and disappeared
thoroughly within 10 min (Figure c–h).
Figure 7
Images of the TzAF thin film coated
on a silica gel
plate. The nonfluorescent “254” was written using a
laser beam (405 nm, 50 mW, 80 millisecond per point, and 5 dots per
millimeter) and then exposed to 254 nm UV light (1.81 mW/cm2). The photographs were taken under a 254 nm UV light before writing
(a) at various time points: time = 0 (b), 10 s (c), 30 s (d), 1 min
(e), 2 min (f), 5 min (g), and 10 min (h).
Images of the TzAF thin film coated
on a silica gel
plate. The nonfluorescent “254” was written using a
laser beam (405 nm, 50 mW, 80 millisecond per point, and 5 dots per
millimeter) and then exposed to 254 nm UV light (1.81 mW/cm2). The photographs were taken under a 254 nm UV light before writing
(a) at various time points: time = 0 (b), 10 s (c), 30 s (d), 1 min
(e), 2 min (f), 5 min (g), and 10 min (h).UV light at 365 nm functioned similarly in restoring the bright
fluorescence emission of the TzAF thin film (see Figure
S16 in the Supporting Information). In
the repeatability test of the TzAF thin film’s
fluorescence photoswitching capability, the “writing”
and “erasing” with 405 and 254 nm (or 365 nm) light
irradiation were conducted for consecutive cycles without resulting
in any identifiable difference in the behaviors of the thin film (Figures and S17–S18, Supporting Information). It is worth noting that
the mark written on the TzAF thin film by 405 nm irradiation
did not last for 24 h under natural room light illumination (300–1000
nm) but lasted for no less than 70 days in the dark (Figure S15, Supporting Information).
Figure 8
Repeatability of TzAF thin film’s fluorescence
photoswitching. The numbers 1–5 were written using a laser
beam (405 nm, 50 mW, 80 millisecond per point and 5 dots per millimeter),
and the numbers 1–4 were erased by exposure under 254 nm UV
light (1.81 mW/cm2) for 10 min.
Repeatability of TzAF thin film’s fluorescence
photoswitching. The numbers 1–5 were written using a laser
beam (405 nm, 50 mW, 80 millisecond per point and 5 dots per millimeter),
and the numbers 1–4 were erased by exposure under 254 nm UV
light (1.81 mW/cm2) for 10 min.We postulated that the on/off fluorescence emission of TzAF is attributed to the interconversion between TzAF′
neutral ↔ radical states: Tz units in the neutral TzAF were reduced to radicals by 405 nm light-generated electrons,
and the radicals lost electrons to get back to the neutral form under
254 nm UV light. In order to provide evidence to support this postulation,
electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) measurement was conducted. As
shown in Figure a,b,
a clear EPR signal was observed for TzAF irradiated by
405 nm light (red curve), and such a signal could not be seen in the
dark or before light irradiation (black curve). The g-factor spectrum
(Figure b) of TzAF after 405 nm light irradiation was derived from Figure a and indicated that
the experimental g-factor was 2.00429, typical for
nitrogen-centered radicals.[62] Therefore,
the shutting off of the fluorescence emission of TzAF can be attributed to the transformation of fluorescent neutral TzAF to its nonfluorescent radical state. The photogenerated
electron in the TzAF radical is considered in its singly
occupied molecular orbital excited by a higher energy 365 or 254 nm
light irradiation, followed by de-excitation to its ground state accompanied
with the reproduction of fluorescence.
Figure 9
(a) EPR/ESR spectra of TzAF (black: in the dark; red:
after 405 nm irradiation). Microwave (MW) frequency 9.852 GHz; MW
power, 19.10 mW; modulation amplitude, 1.00 G; time constant, 10.24
ms; and sweep time: 30.72 s; (b) g-factor spectrum of TzAF in the EPR/ESR test. (c) EPR/ESR spectra of solid-state DTTz (black: under the dark; blue: after 405 nm irradiation). (MW frequency
9.855 GHz; MW power, 19.61 mW; modulation amplitude, 1.00 G; time
constant, 10.24 ns; and sweep time, 60.42 s; (d) g-factor spectrum of solid-state DTTz in the EPR/ESR
test. (e) The “on/off” fluorescence emission of TzAF and the reversible transformation between its neutral
and radical states.
(a) EPR/ESR spectra of TzAF (black: in the dark; red:
after 405 nm irradiation). Microwave (MW) frequency 9.852 GHz; MW
power, 19.10 mW; modulation amplitude, 1.00 G; time constant, 10.24
ms; and sweep time: 30.72 s; (b) g-factor spectrum of TzAF in the EPR/ESR test. (c) EPR/ESR spectra of solid-state DTTz (black: under the dark; blue: after 405 nm irradiation). (MW frequency
9.855 GHz; MW power, 19.61 mW; modulation amplitude, 1.00 G; time
constant, 10.24 ns; and sweep time, 60.42 s; (d) g-factor spectrum of solid-state DTTz in the EPR/ESR
test. (e) The “on/off” fluorescence emission of TzAF and the reversible transformation between its neutral
and radical states.With the mechanism of TzAF’s “on/off”
fluorescence emission elucidated, we wanted to find out whether a
single unit of TzAF possesses such fluorescent photoswitchability.
Thus, we conducted EPR analysis of DTTz, the model compound
of a single unit of TzAF, in its solid-state (Figure c,d) and in CH3CN solution (Figure S21, Supporting Information). The intensity ratio of characteristic signals obtained was 1.34:4.41:9.88:16.07:18.63:16.38:10.34:4.04:1.59
(Figure c), consistent
with the theoretical value calculated for Tz-type radicals
(1:4:10:16:19:16:10:4:1).[63] However, there
was a significant difference between the frameworks TzAF and the monomer DTTz: neither the DTTz thin film nor DTTz solution (in CH3CN) showed
such a switchable “on/off” emission property (Figure
S20, Supporting Information). In TzAF, the Tz radical anion was stabilized by
delocalization of the electron over the Tz ring and the
two conjugated phenyl rings. In addition, Ph-Tz-Ph type-radical
anion units in TzAF were isolated by the quaternary carbons,
which further improved the stability of the radical anions in a similar
way to the encapsulation strategy reported by Flood’s group.[64] A naked DTTz radical anion does
not have such a protection; thus, it lacks such fluorescence switchability.
Conclusions
s-Tetrazine
(Tz), arguably the smallest
fluorophore was incorporated in the skeleton of PAFs for the first
time, resulting in photochromic aromatic frameworks TzAF. A thin film of the as-synthesized TzAF was found to
possess a consecutive “writing/erasing” property through
the irradiation of 405 and 254 nm (or 365 nm) light, respectively,
which could be mechanistically attributed to the “on/off”
fluorescence photoswitchability resulting from reversible transformation
between fluorescent-neutral and nonfluorescent radical states. The
rigid skeleton of TzAF provided a protective environment
for stabilization of the photogenerated Tz radicals,
while aggregation-caused quenching (ACQ) resulted in the loss of fluorescence
photoswitchability for DTTz in the solid state. The unique
fluorescent photochromic TzAF should have potential in
various optoelectronic applications, including optical memories, bioimaging,
and photoswitches with high sensitivity.
Experimental
Section
General
Unless otherwise noted, the
reagents and solvents were purchased from commercial sources and used
as received. The 1H and 13C NMR spectra were
recorded on a Bruker AVANCE III HD 500 NMR spectrometer or a Bruker
AVANCE NEO 400 spectrometer. 13C cross-polarization MAS
NMR (13C CP/MAS NMR) spectra were recorded on a Bruker
AVANCE Neo 700 MHz spectrometer. Electrospray ionization mass spectrometry
analysis was conducted on a Thermo Scientific Q Exactive Focus mass
spectrometer with an UltiMate 3000 RSLC high-performance liquid chromatography
system. TGA was carried out on a Mettler Toledo TGA/DSC 3 + thermogravimetric
analyzer, and the samples were heated to 1000 °C at a heating
rate of 10 °C/min under a N2 atmosphere. The PXRD
measurements were carried out on a Bruker AXS D8 ADVANCE X-ray diffractometer
with Cu Kα as the radiation source (λ = 1.5418 Å)
and operated at 40 kV and 40 mA. The surface area, nitrogen adsorption
isotherms (77 K), and pore size distributions were measured using
an ASAP 2020 HD accelerated surface area and porosimetry system, and
the sample was degassed at 90 °C for 6 h prior to analysis. The
Fourier transform IR (FTIR) spectra were obtained on a Thermo Scientific
Nicolet iS5 FTIR spectrometer using the attenuated total reflection
technique, and the sample was dried in an IR oven equipped with two
275 W lamps prior to the test. The UV–vis spectra were recorded
on a UV-8000S Double Beam UV/vis spectrophotometer (Shanghai Precision
Instruments) and the UV–vis–NIR spectra on an Agilent
Cary UV–vis–NIR spectrophotometer. EPR/electron spin
resonance (ESR) spectra were obtained on a Bruker EPR A300 spectrometer.
The morphological details were studied using FE-SEM (on a FEI Inspect
F50) and FE-TEM (on a JEM-2100F field emission electron microscope).
The XPS analysis was conducted on a Thermo Fisher ESCALAB 250 Xi X-ray
photoelectron spectrometer. Structural simulation was performed using
BIOVIA Materials Studio Forcite (geometry optimization: energy, 2
× 10–5 kcal/mol; force, 0.001 kcal/(mol Å);
stress, 0.001 GPa; displacement, 1.0 × 10–5 Å). Control software in fluorescence photoswitching was obtained
from VigoTec, and calculations were performed at the B3LYP/6-311+G(d)
level using Gaussian 09 Revision E.01.
Tetra(4-iodophenyl)-methane
(2)
A suspension of iodine (9.23 g, 36.0 mmol),
tetraphenylmethane
(3.92 g, 12.0 mmol), and bis(trifluoroacetoxy)iodobenzene (13.2 g,
30.0 mmol) in CCl4 (180 mL) was refluxed under N2 for 10 h, cooled to room temperature, and filtered to collect the
solid which was washed with petroleum ether and dried at 100 °C
under reduced pressure for 1 h to afford 2 (6.4 g, 65%)
as a light-pink powder. 1H NMR (500 MHz, DMSO-d6): δ 7.69 (8H), 6.91(8H).
Tetra(4-cyanophenyl)-methane
(4)
A mixture of tetra(4-iodophenyl)-methane
(2) (1.32 g, 1.6 mmol), K4Fe(CN)6·3H2O (1.40 g, 3.3 mmol), K2CO3 (0.68 g,
4.92 mmol), and Pd(OAc)2 (35.9 mg, 0.16 mmol) in dimethylformamide
(25 mL) was purged with N2, heated at 150 °C for 18
h, cooled to room temperature, poured into DCM (50 mL), and filtered
to remove the solids. The filtrate was concentrated to result in a
residue which was subjected to chromatography (petroleum ether/DCM
= 1:1) to afford 4 as a white powder. 1H NMR
(500 MHz, DMSO-d6): δ 7.83 (d, 8.4
Hz, 8H) 7.42 (d, 8.3 Hz, 8H); 13C NMR (125 MHz, DMSO-d6): δ 149.6, 132.9, 131.5, 118.8, 110.3,
65.9.
To a solution of tetra(4-cyanophenyl)-methane
(4) (353 mg, 0.84 mmol) in dry THF (20 mL) under N2 was added a solution of LiHMDS in THF (1.0 M, 7.5 mL, 7.5
mmol) at—84 °C (EtOAc-liquid nitrogen bath). The resulting
mixture was warmed to room temperature and stirred for 18 h to form
a yellowish-orange solution which was then cooled to 0 °C. After
an ethanolic HCl solution (12 mL, 32 mL, freshly prepared by adding
acetyl chloride to ethanol) was added, the precipitate collected by
filtration was suspended in 10 mL of ethanol, sonicated for 1 h, filtered
to remove the solvent, and dried under reduced pressure to afford 5 as a cream-colored solid (525 mg, 98%). 1H NMR
(500 MHz, D2O): δ 7.77 (d, 8.5 Hz, 8H) 7.62 (d, 8.6
Hz, 8H); 13C NMR (125 MHz, D2O): δ 165.9,
150.7, 131.3, 127.8, 126.2, 65.4.
TzAF
To a suspension of 4,4′,4″,4‴-methanetetrayltetrabenzimidamide
tetrahydrochloride (5) (64 mg, 0.1 mmol) in water (2.0
mL) was added hydrazine hydrate (46 μL, 85%, 0.8 mmol, 8 equiv),
resulting in a mixture which was heated at 40 °C using MW for
1 h. The faint yellow precipitate was collected, suspended in an aqueous
NaNO2 solution (0.5 M, 2.0 mL), sonicated for 5 min, and
cooled down to 0 °C in an ice-water bath. After glacial acetic
acid (3 × 35 μL) was added portionwise under vigorous stirring,
the pale-yellow precipitate disappeared, resulting in a pink solution
which gradually became cloudy pink. After water (16 mL) was added,
the reaction mixture was transferred into a regenerated cellulose
dialysis bag for water dialysis three times and dried under reduced
pressure at 120 °C to afford TzAF as a pink powder
(33 mg).
Authors: A Comotti; F Castiglioni; S Bracco; J Perego; A Pedrini; M Negroni; P Sozzani Journal: Chem Commun (Camb) Date: 2019-07-10 Impact factor: 6.222
Authors: Alexander V Polezhaev; Nicholas A Maciulis; Chun-Hsing Chen; Maren Pink; Richard L Lord; Kenneth G Caulton Journal: Chemistry Date: 2016-08-18 Impact factor: 5.236
Authors: Christopher R Benson; Elisabeth M Fatila; Semin Lee; Matthew G Marzo; Maren Pink; Michelle B Mills; Kathryn E Preuss; Amar H Flood Journal: J Am Chem Soc Date: 2016-11-04 Impact factor: 15.419