Derek S Wang1, Tomáš Neuman2, Susanne F Yelin3, Johannes Flick4. 1. Harvard John A. Paulson School of Engineering and Applied Sciences, Harvard University, Cambridge, Massachusetts 02138, United States. 2. IPCMS de Strasbourg, UMR 7504 (CNRS - Université de Strasbourg), 67034 Strasbourg, France. 3. Department of Physics, Harvard University, Cambridge, Massachusetts 02138, United States. 4. Center for Computational Quantum Physics, Flatiron Institute, New York, New York 10010, United States.
Abstract
While the emerging field of vibrational polariton chemistry has the potential to overcome traditional limitations of synthetic chemistry, the underlying mechanism is not yet well understood. Here, we explore how the dynamics of unimolecular dissociation reactions that are rate-limited by intramolecular vibrational energy redistribution (IVR) can be modified inside an infrared optical cavity. We study a classical model of a bent triatomic molecule, where the two outer atoms are bound by anharmonic Morse potentials to the center atom coupled to a harmonic bending mode. We show that an optical cavity resonantly coupled to particular anharmonic vibrational modes can interfere with IVR and alter unimolecular dissociation reaction rates when the cavity mode acts as a reservoir for vibrational energy. These results lay the foundation for further theoretical work toward understanding the intriguing experimental results of vibrational polaritonic chemistry within the context of IVR.
While the emerging field of vibrational polariton chemistry has the potential to overcome traditional limitations of synthetic chemistry, the underlying mechanism is not yet well understood. Here, we explore how the dynamics of unimolecular dissociation reactions that are rate-limited by intramolecular vibrational energy redistribution (IVR) can be modified inside an infrared optical cavity. We study a classical model of a bent triatomic molecule, where the two outer atoms are bound by anharmonic Morse potentials to the center atom coupled to a harmonic bending mode. We show that an optical cavity resonantly coupled to particular anharmonic vibrational modes can interfere with IVR and alter unimolecular dissociation reaction rates when the cavity mode acts as a reservoir for vibrational energy. These results lay the foundation for further theoretical work toward understanding the intriguing experimental results of vibrational polaritonic chemistry within the context of IVR.
Mode-selective chemistry—exciting
just a single bond in a molecule to control its chemical properties—is
a long sought-after goal that would allow selective control over chemical
reactivity and energy transfer.[1−6] Realization of this goal has generally been hampered, however, by
intramolecular and intermolecular vibrational energy redistribution
that limits the efficiency of a mode-selective excitation beyond cryogenic
temperatures.[7] Interest in this field was
revitalized recently with the emergence of the field of vibrational
polaritonic chemistry.[8−20] Changes of reaction rates of molecules inserted into optical infrared
cavities have been observed experimentally, demonstrating the influence
of the resonant coupling of molecular infrared-active vibrations with
the electromagnetic vacuum field of the cavity on the underlying reaction
dynamics. Despite intense efforts to understand why the reaction rate
changes,[21−28] the microscopic mechanisms underlying the experimental observations
are still under debate. Recent studies have hinted at the role of
intramolecular vibrational energy redistribution (IVR) in cavity-modified
chemical reactions studied via first-principles methods[26,29] or molecular dynamics simulations.[30−33] The role of vibrational strong
coupling on the chemical reactivity of 1-phenyl-2-trimethylsilylacetylene
(PTA) using quantum electrodynamical density functional theory[34−36] was able to replicate some of the effects observed experimentally
by Thomas et al.[37] However, due to the
computational complexity, these methods still face certain limitations,
such as in the number of simulated trajectories or possible reaction
pathways.Therefore, in this work, we theoretically study cavity-modified
unimolecular dissociation reactions with a simple classical model
of a molecule. We show that by coupling the infrared-active modes
of the molecule to the de-excited cavity mode, the rate of bond dissociation
in individual molecules can be selectively increased or decreased.
In particular, when the cavity is initially empty, the dissociation
rate decreases, while when the cavity is initially hotter than the
molecule, the cavity can instead accelerate the reaction rate. We
observe a change in chemical reaction rate most strongly when the
cavity is tuned into resonance with particular vibrational modes,
as well as a strong dependence on the cavity strength. These results
help elucidate the role of IVR in vibrational polariton chemistry.We start by discussing the setup of the model system to demonstrate
the cavity-modified IVR dynamics. In this work, we use a classical
triatomic model with three degrees of freedom and anharmonic potentials.
This model was previously used by Karmakar et al.[38] to understand the onset of chaos in IVR processes and is
itself based on the approach pioneered by Bunker and others[39−42] who studied the ozone molecule in a series of computational studies
on unimolecular dissociation reactions. Importantly, this minimal
model demonstrates chaotic dynamics through an interconnected Arnold
web,[43,44] or network of nonlinear resonances, and
therefore serves as a fundamental starting point for IVR studies of
larger molecules. The Hamiltonian for the model system can be written
in terms of the local vibrational modes aswhere i ∈ {1, 2, 3}
corresponds to the local stretching mode between the left atom and
the center atom, the local stretching mode between the center atom
and the right atom, and the local bending mode, respectively. The
position coordinates q for i = 1 and 2 are in units of distance, while q3 is in units of angle, and p are their respective conjugated momentum
coordinates. A schematic of the model system and the coordinates is
depicted in Figure a. The coupling element between momenta p and p is due to the transformation
from normal mode coordinates,
where we consider collective motions of nuclei, to local mode coordinates,
where we focus on the movement of specific parts of the molecule.[45] To explore the effect of varying vibrational
mode–mode momentum couplings, this momentum–momentum
interaction is scaled by ϵ, roughly corresponding to, e.g.,
varying the mass of the center atom relative to the other two atoms.[39] For nonzero ϵ, the local vibrational modes q1, q2, and q3 do not correspond to normal (or eigen-) modes
of the system. In addition, note that the coordinate-dependent G in the original model of
Bunker[39] are approximated by their equilibrium
values, , and that this model is fixed in the x–y plane with dipole activity only
in the x- and y-directions, although
we note that the rovibronic couplings have also been shown to impact
IVR in certain circumstances.[46] For the
two stretching modes i = 1, 2, the vibrational potential
is approximated by a Morse potential, as shown in Figure b: where D is the dissociation energy, α controls the anharmonicity of the potential well and the number
of bound vibrational states in a quantum picture, is the equilibrium atom–atom distance,
and ω is the frequency of the potential
well under the low-displacement or harmonic approximation. For the
dissociation energies, we choose D1 = D2 = D. For the bending mode,
the vibrational potential is assumed to be harmonic: The numerical values for these parameters
are defined in the Supporting Information and in ref (38).
Figure 1
Model
of a cavity-coupled molecule. (a) Schematic of the model
triatomic model in a cavity. The local vibrational degrees of freedom
of the molecule are labeled q1 (stretch
length between left and center atoms), q2 (stretch length between center and right atoms), and q3 (bending angle between bonds of left-center atoms and
center-right atoms), while the cavity mode displacement is Qc. (b) Dipole moment function in the x-direction, or μ, when
θ = 0 and the anharmonic Morse potential V1 of local stretch q1.
Model
of a cavity-coupled molecule. (a) Schematic of the model
triatomic model in a cavity. The local vibrational degrees of freedom
of the molecule are labeled q1 (stretch
length between left and center atoms), q2 (stretch length between center and right atoms), and q3 (bending angle between bonds of left-center atoms and
center-right atoms), while the cavity mode displacement is Qc. (b) Dipole moment function in the x-direction, or μ, when
θ = 0 and the anharmonic Morse potential V1 of local stretch q1.To incorporate the effect of light–matter coupling
between
the electric field of an infrared cavity and the vibrations of the
molecular model, we add the classical field Hamiltonian HF,[47] which becomes the Pauli–Fierz
Hamiltonian in its quantized form:[35]where ω, Q, P, and λ are the
frequency, displacement, momentum, and strength of
the cavity mode k; μ is the permanent
dipole moment of the molecule; and ξ is the unit
vector of polarization of the electric field. We note that a similar
approach has been taken in classical molecular dynamics studies of
polaritonic chemistry.[30,31] See the Supporting Information for a full derivation from the light–matter
Lagrangian. In the following, we will consider interactions with a
single cavity mode c. The permanent dipole moment
of the molecule, plotted in Figure b, is defined aswhere , , ,[48] θ is
the angle between the x-axis and the in-plane molecular
axis through the center of the molecule, σ = 1 bohr controls
the envelope width, and A = 0.4 e is such that the
equilibrium permanent dipole moment μ0 in the x-direction when θ = 0 is 1 e·bohr,
which is on the order of the permanent dipole moment for bent triatomic
molecules such as ozone.[49,50] Importantly, the dipole
moment μ approaches zero with increasing q1 and q2, physically
analogous to dissociation into neutral species or screening of ionic
fragments by solvent, to obviate challenges with the dipole approximation
after dissociation. In the Supporting Information, however, we also study cavity-modified rates of dissociation into
ionic (charged) species, where , and we find similar
results.For the full light–matter Hamiltonian in the
form of H = Hmol + HF, the equations of motion can be derived with
Hamilton’s
equations and stably propagated given a set of initial position and
momentum coordinates up to several tens of picoseconds using the eighth
order Runge–Kutta method.[51] To understand
the IVR dynamics of the molecule both outside and inside the cavity,
we calculate the dipole moment spectrum . This expression corresponds to the one-sided
Fourier transform of the permanent dipole moment μ as the displacements q and momenta p propagate under H and is directly related
to the dipole moment spectrum.[52] Because
the IVR dynamics are chaotic,[40,41] all results based on
dynamics shown in this study are averaged over tens of thousands of
initial states that are generated as described in the Supporting Information.We first describe
the molecule outside of the cavity. In the simplest
case, shown in the top plot of Figure , there is no mode–mode momentum coupling, i.e.,
ϵ = 0 in eq ,
and the initial energy of 1 kcal/mol is low compared to the dissociation
energy D = 24 kcal/mol of the local stretching modes
and of the same order of magnitude as their harmonic frequencies.
Therefore, the Hamiltonian effectively corresponds to three decoupled
local vibrations. Notably, the local bending peak at 632 cm–1 is sharper and brighter, while the local stretches at 1040 and 1112
cm–1 are broader and darker. The difference in peak
widths is a result of the anharmonic local stretching potentials.
In the second plot of Figure , we turn on the vibrational mode–mode momentum coupling
by setting ϵ = 1. As expected, we find that the local vibrational
modes are no longer the normal modes of the system—the normal
modes are now delocalized over the three local modes, shifting the
three center frequencies (ω1, ω2, ω3) of the normal bending, normal symmetric stretching,
and normal antisymmetric stretching modes to (1197, 1003, 528) cm–1 from (1112, 1040, 632) cm–1 in
the case of ϵ = 0. As the energy of the initial state is increased
to 10 kcal/mol in the third plot of Figure , such that q1 and q2 can explore more of the anharmonic
Morse potential, we observe the emergence of additional and broadened
peaks corresponding to anharmonic resonances. Nonetheless, we can
still identify peaks with frequencies below or above ∼800 cm–1 with the normal bending mode or normal stretching
modes, respectively. As the energy of the initial states is increased
to 23.9 kcal/mol in Figure , just below the dissociation energy D =
24 kcal/mol, the frequency spectra of the local stretching modes q1 and q2 have largely
delocalized across the entire frequency spectrum with a broad peak
near ∼500 cm–1 still corresponding to normal
bending mode-like character.
Figure 2
Dipole moment spectrum of the molecule outside
and inside the cavity
with varying vibrational mode–mode coupling ϵ and initial
energy in the molecule Emol relative to
the dissociation energy D. The size and direction of the arrows indicate the relative magnitude
and phase of local bond displacement in the normal modes. As the energy
increases and more of the anharmonic Morse potentials can be explored,
the peaks broaden. We couple the cavity mode to the bending-like modes
with the highest intensity and observe Rabi splitting indicative of
strong interactions between them.
Dipole moment spectrum of the molecule outside
and inside the cavity
with varying vibrational mode–mode coupling ϵ and initial
energy in the molecule Emol relative to
the dissociation energy D. The size and direction of the arrows indicate the relative magnitude
and phase of local bond displacement in the normal modes. As the energy
increases and more of the anharmonic Morse potentials can be explored,
the peaks broaden. We couple the cavity mode to the bending-like modes
with the highest intensity and observe Rabi splitting indicative of
strong interactions between them.For the spectra including the optical cavity mode in Figure , we couple the molecule to
a single cavity mode c that we assume is x-polarized. The photon mode is then initialized with vanishingly
small energy. We resonantly tune the cavity mode to the frequency
with the largest intensity in the spectrum that corresponds to a bending
mode and choose the cavity strength λc = 0.05 au
leading to an estimated Rabi splitting ΩR = 45 cm–1 or 1.35 THz. This Rabi splitting is the border between
the strong and ultrastrong coupling regimes. (We describe how the
Rabi splitting can be estimated in the low-energy harmonic case in
the Supporting Information.) Note that
this cavity strength implies a much smaller mode volume V than experimental values to compensate for the lack of N molecules in this single-molecule model, since . The peak splitting
is clear evidence of
interactions between the cavity mode and vibrations, suggesting energy
can be transferred between the cavity mode and vibrational modes,
and the magnitude of the splitting is similar regardless of ϵ
and Emol.Dissociation Dynamics. Next, we study the dissociation
dynamics of the molecular system. The molecule can dissociate when
it is initialized with energy exceeding the dissociation energy D = 24 kcal/mol. We define successful dissociation when
either q1 or q2 exceeds a bond length of 5 bohr from the equilibrium value or . Setting Emol = 34 kcal/mol, we show
an example trajectory that leads to dissociation
of the molecule inside a cavity in Figure a, where we plot the deviation of the molecular
coordinates q from their
equilibrium positions . The trajectory exhibits anharmonic oscillations
of the internal coordinates of the molecule resulting finally in the
divergence of the bond length q1 and,
therefore, dissociation of the molecule.
Figure 3
IVR-mediated dissociation.
(a) Single trajectory of a molecule
initialized with energy of 34 kcal/mol that is greater than the dissociation
energy D = 24 kcal/mol. Local mode displacements are in atomic units. The molecule
dissociates
at ∼3.4 ps, marked by the green region, when exceeds dissociation length rdis = 5 bohr. (b) Dipole moment spectrum of
short-lived
(dissociation time tdis < 0.5 ps) and
long-lived (tdis > 4 ps) trajectories
of the molecule outside the cavity. Long-lived trajectories exhibit
sharp resonances, suggesting that strongly coupling the cavity mode
to these particular modes can influence dissociation dynamics.
IVR-mediated dissociation.
(a) Single trajectory of a molecule
initialized with energy of 34 kcal/mol that is greater than the dissociation
energy D = 24 kcal/mol. Local mode displacements are in atomic units. The molecule
dissociates
at ∼3.4 ps, marked by the green region, when exceeds dissociation length rdis = 5 bohr. (b) Dipole moment spectrum of
short-lived
(dissociation time tdis < 0.5 ps) and
long-lived (tdis > 4 ps) trajectories
of the molecule outside the cavity. Long-lived trajectories exhibit
sharp resonances, suggesting that strongly coupling the cavity mode
to these particular modes can influence dissociation dynamics.We generate a statistical understanding of the
dissociation dynamics
by studying tens of thousands of trajectories with identical energies.
In Figure b, we plot
the dipole moment spectrum for molecules initialized with energy 34
kcal/mol > D = 24 kcal/mol, sufficient to dissociate
the bond. Binning trajectories by their lifetimes, we compare the
dipole moment spectra of short-lived trajectories (tdis < 0.5 ps) and long-lived trajectories (tdis > 4 ps). For the short-lived trajectories
we observe uniform spectral densities that hint at statistical decay
dynamics in which the many anharmonic resonances of the local vibrational
modes are explored quickly and at random. In contrast, the Fourier
spectra of the long-lived trajectories feature a number of peaks;
especially prominent ones are at ∼520 and ∼580 cm–1. These peaks represent modes robust against dissociation,
where the molecular energy is largely stored in the local bending
motion and not local stretches prone to dissociation. Therefore, we
suggest to alter the dynamics of IVR-mediated dissociation by coupling
the cavity to these resonances.Cavity-Modified Dissociation. We explore whether
coupling the molecule to the cavity can modify reaction dynamics.
In our model, we initialize the molecule with Emol = 34 kcal/mol and couple it to
a single cavity mode initialized
such that the total field energy EF resulting
from eq is 0. Again,
θ = 0 and the cavity is x-polarized with frequency
ωc and cavity strength λc.First, we calculate the change in reaction rate for varying cavity
strength λc. To set ωc and θ,
we note that is largest around 520 cm–1 in Figure b. Therefore,
we presume the strength of light–matter coupling for a given
λc can be maximized by polarizing the cavity field
along the x-direction and setting ωc = 520 cm–1. We vary the cavity strength λc and plot the (natural logarithm of) the survival probability S(t), or the proportion of initial states
that have not dissociated as a function of time in Figure a, as well as the time required
for 95% of the molecules to dissociate in Figure b. A lower survival probability S(t) corresponds to a faster reaction rate. Importantly,
the dissociation slows monotonically with increasing λc, even toward the ultrastrong coupling where λc ≳
0.05 au.
Figure 4
Cavity-modified unimolecular dissociation rate with survival probability
as a function of time (top) and time required for 95% of molecules
with initial energy of 34 kcal/mol (bottom) for an initially empty
cavity. In (a) and (b), we vary the cavity strength λc for ωc = 520 cm–1 and the x-polarized cavity mode, resulting in the dissociation rate
slowing down with increasing λc. In (c) and (d),
the cavity frequency ωc is varied for λc = 0.02 au and the x-polarized cavity mode;
the dissociation rate slows down between ωc ∼
520 and ∼600 cm–1, close to the same frequencies
of the peaks in in Figure b.
Cavity-modified unimolecular dissociation rate with survival probability
as a function of time (top) and time required for 95% of molecules
with initial energy of 34 kcal/mol (bottom) for an initially empty
cavity. In (a) and (b), we vary the cavity strength λc for ωc = 520 cm–1 and the x-polarized cavity mode, resulting in the dissociation rate
slowing down with increasing λc. In (c) and (d),
the cavity frequency ωc is varied for λc = 0.02 au and the x-polarized cavity mode;
the dissociation rate slows down between ωc ∼
520 and ∼600 cm–1, close to the same frequencies
of the peaks in in Figure b.We further explore the cavity-coupled triatomic model by varying
cavity frequency ωc from 100 to 1100 cm–1 with constant cavity strength λc = 0.01 au. From Figure c, we see that for
much of this frequency range, the survival probability S(t) curves are nearly identical to the case of λc = 0 in Figure a. Around 500 cm–1, however, the reaction dynamics
are strongly changed. To study them with a finer frequency resolution
in this range, we plot the time required for 95% dissociation t in Figure d, where we observe peaks at
∼520 and ∼600 cm–1, close to the
frequencies of the peaks in Figure b and
therefore serving as direct evidence of a resonant
effect. In the Supporting Information,
we sweep the cavity frequency at higher cavity strengths as well and
notice that the two peaks broaden and shift in frequency. We also
show results for the cases of molecules with weak vibrational mode–mode
coupling ϵ, where we observe rate acceleration for low ϵ,
and molecules initialized with different energies Emol, where we observe qualitatively similar results.To develop a qualitative understanding of how the cavity changes
the reaction rate, we study the change in the form of the decay curves
as the reaction time t increases for both varying λc and ωc. For λc = 0 corresponding to complete decoupling
between the molecule and the cavity, the survival probability S(t) can be described with a monoexponential
decay process,[38] corresponding to statistical
distribution of vibrational energy where the space of nonlinear frequency
resonances between vibrational modes is widely explored before the
molecule dissociates. The reaction slows as a secondary, slower decay
channel becomes more dominant, veering the survival probability S(t) away from monoexponential statistical
decay. This slower decay channel has been shown to correspond to IVR-limited
dissociation, where the molecule vibrates along particular modes—a
bending mode in this case—before dissociating,[38] as shown by the dipole moment spectrum of short- vs long-lived
trajectories in Figure b.We demonstrate that the cavity increases the number of trajectories
that decay via the IVR-limited decay channel by serving as a sink
for vibrational energy, lowering the probability that one of the stretch
bonds acquires enough energy to break. In Figure , for different cavity strength λc ∈ {0, 0.02, 0.05} au, we plot the time-dependent energy
distribution up to the first 0.5 ps in the molecule–cavity
system for shorter-lived (0.5 < tdis < 1 ps) and longer-lived (tdis >
4 ps) trajectories inside and outside the cavity averaged over ∼200 000
initial states. The distribution comprises energy in the entire molecule
as Hmol, the field HF (including matter-photon coupling), and each of the local
vibrational modes i as . Note that for clarity, we do
not show
the vibrational mode–mode coupling, which is generally unaltered
by the presence of the cavity.
Figure 5
Time-dependent energy distribution of
the first 0.5 ps in the molecule–cavity
system for short-lived (0.5 < tdis <
1 ps) and long-lived (tdis > 4 ps)
trajectories
where λc ∈ {0, 0.02, 0.05} au. The resonantly
tuned cavity mode couples efficiently to molecules with highly excited
local bending modes and functions as a reservoir of molecular vibrational
energy.
Time-dependent energy distribution of
the first 0.5 ps in the molecule–cavity
system for short-lived (0.5 < tdis <
1 ps) and long-lived (tdis > 4 ps)
trajectories
where λc ∈ {0, 0.02, 0.05} au. The resonantly
tuned cavity mode couples efficiently to molecules with highly excited
local bending modes and functions as a reservoir of molecular vibrational
energy.At λc = 0 corresponding
to the molecule being
outside the cavity, for the shorter-lived trajectories, energy is
initially distributed approximately evenly between the local bending
and local stretching modes and is gradually redistributed from the
local bending to the local stretching modes. In sharp contrast, for
the longer-lived trajectories the initial states are more highly excited
in the local bending mode. Importantly, the energy oscillations indicate
localization in frequency space within the sharp resonances of the x-polarized dipole moment spectra around 500–600
cm–1.Inside the cavity with λc = 0.02 au, for both
shorter- and longer-lived trajectories, we see that the cavity mode
strongly couples to the local bending mode, as the field energy increases
while the molecular energy decreases. Notably, the local bending mode
is more excited for the longer-lived trajectories. The strongly coupled
cavity mode is then able to absorb more energy from both the local
bending mode and local stretching modes, in turn extending the average
lifetime of the molecule. With larger cavity strength λc = 0.05 au, the reaction slows down further because the cavity
couples more strongly to the molecule and is better able to absorb
vibrational energy.The cavity mode, initially vanishingly empty
in Figure and Figure , appears to slow
down the dissociation rate
by absorbing energy from the vibrationally excited molecule. In the
case of chemical reactions at thermal equilibrium, however, the cavity
mode is likely to be thermally occupied. Therefore, in Figure , we present the effect of
a “hot” cavity on dissociation dynamics, where the total
molecule–cavity energy is 34·4/3 ∼ 45 kcal/mol
and the initial states are sampled from the microcanonical ensemble.
The factor of 4/3 takes into account the additional degree of freedom
by the cavity mode such that the average energy per degree of freedom
is the same for the molecule inside and outside the cavity.
Figure 6
Dissociation
time t inside a
hot cavity with varying (a) cavity frequency ωc and
(b) cavity strength λc at the resonant
cavity frequency ωc = 520 cm–1.
The total molecule–cavity energy is 34·4/3 ∼ 45
kcal/mol, where the factor of 4/3 accounts for the additional degree
of freedom by the cavity mode. As a guide to the eye, we also plot t for the bare molecule
with 34 kcal/mol (segmented yellow). The resonance is broader for
the hot cavity than for the empty cavity in Figure , and the reaction rate for a given λc is fastest at the resonance. The reaction rate decreases
toward a plateau that is faster than the rate outside the cavity beyond
λc = 0.05 au. At off-resonant cavity frequencies
and when cavity–molecule interactions are weak, energy localized
in the cavity cannot be efficiently transported to the molecule.
Dissociation
time t inside a
hot cavity with varying (a) cavity frequency ωc and
(b) cavity strength λc at the resonant
cavity frequency ωc = 520 cm–1.
The total molecule–cavity energy is 34·4/3 ∼ 45
kcal/mol, where the factor of 4/3 accounts for the additional degree
of freedom by the cavity mode. As a guide to the eye, we also plot t for the bare molecule
with 34 kcal/mol (segmented yellow). The resonance is broader for
the hot cavity than for the empty cavity in Figure , and the reaction rate for a given λc is fastest at the resonance. The reaction rate decreases
toward a plateau that is faster than the rate outside the cavity beyond
λc = 0.05 au. At off-resonant cavity frequencies
and when cavity–molecule interactions are weak, energy localized
in the cavity cannot be efficiently transported to the molecule.Below the cavity strength λc <
0.05 au, the
reaction rate is slower inside the cavity for all cavity frequencies,
reaching its fastest rate close to the resonant frequency found in Figure d. As the cavity
strength λc increases beyond 0.05 au toward the ultrastrong
coupling regime, the reaction can be even faster inside the cavity
than outside. These results can be understood as follows: off-resonant
and weak cavity–molecule interactions can prevent energy localized
in the cavity from transporting to the molecule. To control for the
effects of initial states where the molecule energy is too low to
dissociate, in the Supporting Information, we fix the energy of the molecule to be the same as it is outside
the cavity and study how increasing cavity energy affects the reaction
rate. We find that hotter cavities generally increase the reaction
rate, although the exact phase of the cavity state relative to the
molecule’s can drastically affect the reaction rate.In summary, we study the dissociation dynamics of a classical model
of a triatomic molecule in an optical cavity based on a Bunker model,
where the potential of the two local stretches are anharmonic Morse
potentials and the local bending mode is harmonic. We extend this
model by resonantly coupling the vibrational states with large optical
dipole moments to a single electromagnetic mode of an infrared cavity.
Importantly, we observe that the effect of the cavity is strongest
when it is tuned into resonance with the frequencies of dissociation-resistant
vibrational modes. In addition, we find that the reaction rate monotonically
decreases even as the molecule–cavity system enters the ultrastrong
coupling regime. The reaction is maximally slowed down when the cavity
is able to absorb energy from the molecule without returning it too
quickly to the molecule, lowering the probability that one of the
stretch bonds acquires enough energy to break.When the energy
of the molecule–cavity system is increased
such that the energy per degree of freedom is equivalent to that of
the bare molecule, the reaction rate is generally slowed down as energy
initialized in the cavity is unable to be transferred to the molecule
without resonant and strong cavity–molecule interaction. To
control for this localization effect, we also fix the molecule energy
and study dissociation as a function of the cavity energy. We find
that cavity-modified reaction rates are generally only observable
when the cavity is “cooler” compared to the molecule.
Nevertheless, even a “hot” cavity can slow down reaction
dynamics. As an example, we show that particular cavity states are
more prone to initially absorbing energy from the molecule, while
others with the same initial energy are more prone to transferring
energy to the molecule, both of which are a result of the initial
sign of the light–matter interaction term. These results highlight
the importance of dynamical effects in vibrational polariton chemistry.Here we briefly highlight similarities to and differences from
previous studies.[20,21,24,53] While earlier studies did not find a resonance
effect of the optical cavity,[21,53] recent work using quantum
transition-state theory has demonstrated a dynamical solvent-caging
effect[24] when the photon mode is in resonance
to the curvature of the reaction barrier. An extension[20] also finds a resonance effect for vibrational
excitations for certain parameter regimes. In our paper, we study
the effect of cavity modification on chemical reactions via intramolecular
vibrational energy redistribution, which requires at least a second
vibrational degree of freedom. Our work, although fully classical,
finds a resonance effect when the photon mode is tuned in resonance
to the vibrational excitation.This study lays the foundation
for further theoretical and experimental
work toward understanding the intriguing experimental results of vibrational
polariton chemistry. We emphasize that the cavity strengths necessary
to substantially influence the reaction dynamics, or λc ≳ 0.01 au, are orders of magnitude larger than those in many-molecule
experiments of vibrational polariton chemistry. We, however, emphasize
that single-molecule strong coupling can already be reached experimentally.
For instance, recent experiments in picocavity setups have demonstrated
effective volumes ∼1 nm3 [55−58] that lead to sizable Rabi splittings
of the same order as those in this study. Alternatively, other strategies
to achieve single-molecule strong light–matter coupling in
optical cavities have been proposed recently[59] that seem promising. Such setups may be able to reproduce the cavity-modified
IVR pathways discussed in our manuscript. To bridge the gap between
single-molecule studies and many-molecule experiments, where the latter
exhibit significant dark state populations, we expect molecular dynamics
studies of many molecules inside an optical cavity that also include
molecular translational and rotational degrees of freedom and intramolecular
interactions[30−33,60,61] with a particular focus on IVR dynamics to be fruitful. In addition,
in cases when the dissociation energy becomes comparable to a quantum
of vibrational energy, quantum effects can play an important role
in the dissociation dynamics.[37] In such
cases a quantum description, e.g., via first-principles method such as quantum electrodynamical
density functional theory[26,34−36,62,63] is necessary. Because many reactions studied under vibrational strong
coupling are under thermal equilibrium at ∼25 meV with activation
barriers far in excess of thermal energy,[64] reactions are incredibly rare events and thus challenging to study
computationally. In this study, the molecule energy is set at 30–36
kcal/mol or 1.4–1.6 eV to react in a reasonable amount of simulation
time. Future studies may also include the effects of cavity loss via,
for instance, Langevin approaches, additional cavity modes representing
the other fundamental modes of Fabry–Pérot cavities,
and line width broadening of each cavity mode by the nonzero-incidence
wave vectors. While for computational feasibility and ease of interpretation,
we consider only a triatomic anharmonic model that serves as a minimal
viable model for chaotic dynamics, molecules studied in experiments
are considerably more complex. They can contain ∼100 vibrational
degrees of freedom. These many degrees of freedom may exhibit vibrational
mode–mode couplings that span several orders of magnitude.
Future studies should therefore determine whether the observed cavity-modified
chemical reactivity in this study is robust to these factors. Finally,
experimental studies that consider reactions limited by IVR that therefore
do not abide by the standard assumptions of transition rate theory
and where the initial states of the intramolecular vibrational and
cavity degrees of freedom can be controlled will help to further clarify
the role of IVR in vibrational polaritonic chemistry.
Authors: A Thomas; L Lethuillier-Karl; K Nagarajan; R M A Vergauwe; J George; T Chervy; A Shalabney; E Devaux; C Genet; J Moran; T W Ebbesen Journal: Science Date: 2019-02-07 Impact factor: 47.728
Authors: Abhijit Sau; Kalaivanan Nagarajan; Bianca Patrahau; Lucas Lethuillier-Karl; Robrecht M A Vergauwe; Anoop Thomas; Joseph Moran; Cyriaque Genet; Thomas W Ebbesen Journal: Angew Chem Int Ed Engl Date: 2021-02-01 Impact factor: 15.336