Hydroxyl-terminated polybutadiene (HTPB)-based polyurethane (PU) networks play indispensable roles in a variety of applications; however, they cannot be reprocessed, resulting in environmental problems and unsustainable industrial development. In this work, recyclable HTPB-based PU vitrimer (HTPB-PUV) networks are fabricated by introduction of a cross-linker 2,2'-(1,4-phenylene)-bis[4-mercaptan-1,3,2-dioxaborolane] (BDB) with dynamic boronic ester bonds into the network. Meanwhile, the BDB can stabilize the HTPB unit in the network by elimination of double bonds. The novel HTPB-PUV networks are constructed by a thiol-ene "click" reaction and an addition reaction between HTPB and cross-linker BDB and isocyanates (HDI). The dynamic HTPB-PUV networks are characterized by dynamic mechanical analysis (DMA) and Fourier transform infrared (FTIR). The obtained dynamic HTPB-PUV networks possess superior thermostability. Moreover, due to the presence of dynamic boronic ester bonds, the HTPB-PUV network topologies can be altered, contributing to the reprocessing, self-healing, and welding abilities of the final polymer. Through a hot press, the pulverized sample can be reprocessed for several cycles, and mechanical properties of the reprocessed samples are similar to those of the pristine one, with the tensile strength being even higher. The self-healed sample exhibits almost complete recovery from scratch after the healing treatment at 130 °C for 3 h. Moreover, a welding efficiency of 120% was achieved.
Hydroxyl-terminated polybutadiene (HTPB)-based polyurethane (PU) networks play indispensable roles in a variety of applications; however, they cannot be reprocessed, resulting in environmental problems and unsustainable industrial development. In this work, recyclable HTPB-based PU vitrimer (HTPB-PUV) networks are fabricated by introduction of a cross-linker 2,2'-(1,4-phenylene)-bis[4-mercaptan-1,3,2-dioxaborolane] (BDB) with dynamic boronic ester bonds into the network. Meanwhile, the BDB can stabilize the HTPB unit in the network by elimination of double bonds. The novel HTPB-PUV networks are constructed by a thiol-ene "click" reaction and an addition reaction between HTPB and cross-linker BDB and isocyanates (HDI). The dynamic HTPB-PUV networks are characterized by dynamic mechanical analysis (DMA) and Fourier transform infrared (FTIR). The obtained dynamic HTPB-PUV networks possess superior thermostability. Moreover, due to the presence of dynamic boronic ester bonds, the HTPB-PUV network topologies can be altered, contributing to the reprocessing, self-healing, and welding abilities of the final polymer. Through a hot press, the pulverized sample can be reprocessed for several cycles, and mechanical properties of the reprocessed samples are similar to those of the pristine one, with the tensile strength being even higher. The self-healed sample exhibits almost complete recovery from scratch after the healing treatment at 130 °C for 3 h. Moreover, a welding efficiency of 120% was achieved.
With the 2020 worldwide
annual production estimated to be more
than 29 billion kg, polyurethanes (PUs) are the most widely used versatile
polymers.[1] PU is applied in the fields
of coatings, adhesives, and cross-linked thermosets because of its
high reactivity and flexibility in formulation, application technologies,
adhesion properties, superior viscoelasticity, tenacity, and abrasion.
Polyurethane-based binder systems consist of alternating soft and
hard segments. A very useful characteristic associated with urethane
binder systems in PU is that the ultimate properties can be varied
with good control by adjusting the formulations.[2] PU binders can provide the unique possibility of tailored
polymer topology by varying the composition and R-value (equivalents of NCO/OH groups).[3] On the other hand, hydroxyl-terminated polybutadiene (HTPB) having
a number average molecular weight (Mn)
of 1500–10,000 g/mol is a low-viscosity colorless liquid. The
HTPB with reactive functional groups can be applied to build ABA triblock
copolymers,[4] toughened resins,[5] cross-linked elastomers,[6] PB vitrimers,[7] and supermolecular polymer
gels.[8] Especially, HTPB-based PUs have
been extensively utilized as binders for solid propellants, explosives,
adhesives, foams, coatings, sealants, elastomers, unsaturated polyesters,
toughened polymers, and gas separation membrane applications.[8−13] HTPB as a soft segment of PU can react with isocyanate instead of
polyether or polyester, giving excellent properties, such as low surface
energy, low-temperature flexibility, superior abrasion resistance,
high electrical insulation properties, high viscoelasticity, tenacity,
and hydrolytic stability.[14−16] However, the presence of double
bonds results in the poor stability of HTPB-based PUs in the air.
Besides, as a widely utilized thermoset, HTPB-based PUs, which originate
from petroleum resources, cannot be recycled, leading to environmental
pollution and unsustainable industrial development.The PU thermoset
with the incorporated dynamic covalent bonds can
rearrange its network chains under a proper stimulus, thus allowing
for network reprocessing. In terms of mechanism, the dynamic chemistries
involved in the dissociative reversible reaction include the Diels–Alder
addition[17,18] and the associative exchange reactions,
including the disulfide exchange reaction,[19] transamination reaction,[20] C–C
exchange reaction,[21] and dioxaborolane
metathesis.[22,23] Based on the associative exchange
mechanism, the recyclable PU thermosets are called PU vitrimers because
of their capability to flow like glass when heated; meanwhile, the
network integrity of PU vitrimers is maintained even after reprocessing.
Among the mentioned exchange reactions for PU, dioxaborolane metathesis,
as a type of B–O bond exchange reaction, can be simply adjusted
by temperature. Moreover, vitrimers based on the B–O bond exchange
reaction can provide high mechanical performance to the obtained PU.[24−27]HTPB-based PU vitrimers with disulfide bonds[28−30] are developed
for their striking self-healing performances. Herein, novel HTPB-based
PU networks with dynamic boronic ester bonds as linkages are prepared
by a facile one-pot reaction approach to obtain the reprocessing ability.
HTPB can react with the cross-linker 2,2′-(1,4-phenylene)-bis[4-mercaptan-1,3,2-dioxaborolane]
(BDB) and isocyanates (HDI) by the thiol-ene “click”
reaction and the addition reaction, providing a formation of the networks.
Double bonds in HTPB react with −SH groups in BDB, giving high
stability networks. Meanwhile, the obtained HTPB-PUv displays plasticity,
reprocessing, self-healing, and shape memory abilities since the dioxaborolane
metathesis reaction permits the PU network topology rearrangement.
The effect of the cross-linker BDB’s content on the properties
of HTPB-based HTPB-PUv is also investigated.
Experimental
Section
Materials
1-Thioglycerol (99%), 1,4-phenylenediboronic
acid (97%), DBTDL (95%), HDI, and 4-dimethylaminopyridine (99%) were
purchased from Aladdin. HTPB (Mw = 3000
g/mol) was purchased from Energy Chemical. Tetrahydrofuran (THF) toluene
and dichloromethane (DCM) were purchased from XiLong Scientific Co.,
Ltd.
Synthesis of Typical HTPB-Based PU Vitrimer
Network
The preparation of HTPB-based PU vitrimer networks
is shown in Figure . HTPB (3.000 g, 1 mmol) and HDI (0.168 g, 1 mmol) were dissolved
in THF, and then, a certain amount of BDB, which was synthesized in
a reported work,[31] was added and stirred
for 10 min before the reaction mixture was transferred to a release
paper mold. The temperature was increased to 140 °C with a 20
°C/6 h program to obtain HTPB-PUV networks. BDB contents
were 30, 35, 40, 45, 50, 55, and 60 wt % relative to HTPB, and the
abbreviation x%-HTPB-PUV refers to cured
PU with x being the wt % of BDB.
Figure 1
Synthesis of the HTPB-PUV vitrimer network.
Synthesis of the HTPB-PUV vitrimer network.
Self-Healing, Welding, Shape Memory, and Reprocessing
A blade-made scratch in the 55%-HTPB-PUv strip was used for the
self-healing test. The sample with the scratch was placed in an oven
at 130 °C for 3 h. Polarizing optical microscopy (POM) equipped
with a heating stage and a UCMOS05100KPA (P/N: TP605100A) microscope
camera was utilized to observe the scratch and record its sizes.Two pieces of 55%-HTPB-PUV samples (30.0 mm × 8.0
mm × 1.0 mm) were held together with a superimposed length of
10 mm at 130 °C with a holding time of 30, 60, or 120 min for
the welding treatment. To evaluate the welding efficiencies, mechanical
properties were determined by conducting a uniaxial tensile test,
and it was quantified by the ratio of the tensile strength or elongation
at break of the welded sample to the one of the pristine sample.The 55%-HTPB-PUV spline for checking the shape memory
capability was heated at 130 °C, bent into different shapes with
external force, and then cooled to room temperature; finally, the
deformed spline was heated at 130 °C to observe the recovery
of the spline shape.A hydraulic plate vulcanizer (ZS-406B-30-300,
Dongguan Zhuosheng
Machinery Equipment Co., Ltd.) was used as the reprocessing equipment,
and the 55%-HTPB-PUV sample was ground into powder and
added into the mold for reprocessing, under 5 MPa pressure. The reprocessing
was carried out at 130 °C for 1, 2, or 3 h, and the samples were
repeated three generations.
Characterizations
Fourier transform
infrared (FTIR) spectrometry data were recorded on a Nicolet 205 FTIR
spectrometer between 500 and 4000 cm–1 by the KBr
tablet method, and a resolution of 4 cm–1 and a
scanning number of 32 times were employed during the measurements.
The thermal decomposition behavior of the HTPB-PUV series
was examined by means of thermogravimetry analysis (TGA) at a heating
rate of 10 K/min in a nitrogen atmosphere from 35 to 800 °C on
a TA Q500. Differential scanning calorimetry (DSC 204, NETZSCH, Germany)
was performed at a heating rate of 5 °C/min from 25 to 300 °C
in a nitrogen gas atmosphere. Using a TA Q800 instrument for dynamic
mechanical analysis (DMA), stress relaxation experiments were conducted
by monitoring the stress decay at a constant strain of 5% after equilibrating
at required temperatures for 20 min. A TA Q800 instrument was used
for dynamic mechanical analysis (DMA) and stress relaxation experiments.
The 55%-HTPB-PUV (20.0 mm × 5.0 mm × 1.0 mm)
was measured by a TA Q800 from 25 to 200 °C (heating rate = 3
°C/min) with a frequency of 1 Hz. The glass-transition temperature
(Tg) was obtained from the first inflection
point of the curve. The mechanical performance test employed the UTM4503SLXY
universal tensile testing machine of Shenzhen Sansi aspect Technology
Co., Ltd., with a 5 mm/min tensile rate. The width and thickness of
the specimens were 8.0 and 1.5 mm, respectively. Toughness, elongation
at break, and tensile strength were obtained from the stress–strain
curves. Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) was performed with a field
emission scanning electron microanalyzer (HITACHI, S-4800) at an acceleration
voltage of 10 kV. The samples were frozen by liquid nitrogen and then
fractured in the middle. Before observation, the fracture surfaces
were gold-sputtered for 20 s.Equilibrium swelling experiments
were employed to determine the sol fraction and the swelling ratio
according to the Flory–Rehner equation as shown in eqs 1and 2. The vulcanizate
was immersed in toluene, THF, or DCM refluxing for 12 h; then, the
solvent was wiped with a filter paper, and the samples were weighed
immediately and dried in a vacuum oven at 60 °C until constant
weight. Three specimens were measured for each sample. The initial
mass was assumed as m0, the mass after
swelling was m1, and the mass after drying
was m2.Moreover,
equilibrium swelling methods were used to determine the
cross-linking density (Cd) of the obtained
polymer, where THF was used as the solvent. One polymer strip was
cut into five samples (20 mm × 10 mm × 0.5 mm), weighed,
and immersed in separate bottles containing 50 mL of THF for 5 days.
After reaching the equilibrium swelling, the sample strips were taken
out and the surface solvent was absorbed by a filter paper with the
mass weighed; then, the sample strips were placed in a 60 °C
oven to dry and weighed again. The Cd of
the HTPB-PUV series was calculated by the Flory–Rehner formula .[32,33]where m0 is the
initial mass of the sample, m1 is mass
of the sample after the swelling equilibrium, ρc is
the density of the THF, ρ0 is the density of the
polymer, Vr is the volume fraction of
the polymer, χ is the interaction parameter between the solvent
and the polymer, and Vs is the molar volume
of the solvent.
Results and Discussion
Covalent Cross-Linking of HTPB-PUV
The HTPB-PUV networks with boronic ester bonds
are fabricated based on the chemical reactions between −SH
of BDB and C=C double bonds of HTPB and between −N=C=O
of HDI and −OH of HTPB, with BDB as the curing agent. The facts
are confirmed explicitly by FTIR spectra in Figure . In the spectrum of HTPB, the absorptions
at 2915 and 2844 cm–1 can be attributed to the C–H
vinyl group asymmetric and symmetric stretching vibrations,[34] the bonds at 1440 and 3436 cm–1 are ascribed to the C–H deformation in the methylene groups
and the stretching vibration of −OH, respectively, and the
bands at 966 and 912 cm–1 correspond to the out-of-plane
bending vibration of C–H from the trans-butadiene
component.[35] In the BDB spectrum, the peak
at 2568 cm–1 corresponds to the stretching vibrations
of −SH.[36] In the case of HDI, the
absorption peak at 2275 cm–1 results from the −N=C=O
group.[37] Meanwhile, in the typical spectrum
of 55%-HTPB-PUV, the new peaks at 1700 and 1639 cm–1 are assigned to free C=O and H-bonded C=O,
respectively,[38,39] indicating the occurrence of
a reaction between −N=C=O and −OH to give
the formation of NHCOO– and the hydrogen bond (NH···O=C),
and the absorption at 1517 cm–1 is attributed to
the distortion vibrations of N–H. Compared with the spectra
of BDB/HDI and 55%-HTPB-PUV, the absorption related to
−SH/–N=C=O in the 55%-HTPB-PUV spectrum completely disappeared, implying that all of the −SH
and −N=C=O groups react with HTPB. The peaks
at 2915, 2844, 966, and 911 cm–1 appear in the spectrum
of 55%-HTPB-PUV, implying the framework of HTPB present
in the 55%-HTPB-PUV. Besides, the strong absorption of
the −OH group in the spectrum of 55%-HTPB-PUV probably
comes from water in the sample and the atmosphere, rather than −OH
in HTPB. The above observations suggest that the HTPB-PUV networks are successfully prepared. Moreover, the covalently cross-linked
architecture of the HTPB-PUV can be further confirmed by
the fact that it is insoluble in common organic solvents.
Figure 2
FTIR spectra
of HDI, HTPB, BDB, and a typical 55%-HTPB-PUV.
FTIR spectra
of HDI, HTPB, BDB, and a typical 55%-HTPB-PUV.Equilibrium swelling tests display that the HTPB-PUv series
cannot
completely dissolve in toluene, THF, or DCM and only swell to some
degree due to the nature of covalently cross-linked networks. With
the BDB content increasing from 30 to 60%, the swelling ratio and
sol fraction consistently decrease from 6.1 to 3.1 and from 45 to
16%, respectively, as shown in Figure , resulting in an increase in the cross-link density
(0.35–2.43 mol/cm3, in Table ), which reveals a denser network at a higher
BDB content.
Figure 3
Swelling ratio, sol fraction, and cross-linking density
of the
HTPB-PUV series with different BDB contents.
Table 1
Mechanical and Thermal Properties
of HTPB-PUV Series with Different BDB Contents
sample
Tg (°C)
Cd (mol/cm3)
elongation
at break (%)
tensile strength
(MPa)
toughness (MJ/m3)
30%-PUV
9.0
0.35 × 10–3
79.0 ± 1.8
0.7 ± 0.09
0.3 ± 0.08
35%-PUV
9.4
0.36 × 10–3
78.3 ± 1.4
0.9 ± 0.08
0.5 ± 0.07
40%-PUV
9.7
0.31 × 10–3
83.2 ± 3.1
1.1 ± 0.05
0.6 ± 0.04
45%-PUV
10.9
0.47 × 10–3
93.1 ± 2.7
1.3 ± 0.11
0.8 ± 0.10
50%-PUV
11.2
1.09 × 10–3
101.9 ± 3.0
1.4 ± 0.09
1.1 ± 0.09
55%-PUV
12.0
1.42 × 10–3
86.6 ± 2.7
2.5 ± 0.11
1.8 ± 0.12
60%-PUV
13.5
2.43 × 10–3
61.7 ± 2.5
2.6 ± 0.10
1.4 ± 0.09
Swelling ratio, sol fraction, and cross-linking density
of the
HTPB-PUV series with different BDB contents.
Dynamic Property Analysis, Mechanical Properties,
and Thermal Performance
To determine the rearrangement of
the HTPB-PUV network topology and the rate of exchange
reactions, DMA measurements are employed to investigate the time-
and temperature-dependent stress relaxation modulus. The normalized
relaxation modulus of G/G0 of the 55%-HTPB-PUv at different temperatures is shown in Figure a. When the temperature
is elevated to 60 °C, relaxation the stress become quickly; which
is in agreement with the law of temperature rise and stress relaxation
time shorten. Following Maxwell’s viscoelastic fluid model,
the relaxation time τ is defined as the time required for the
initial modulus to decrease to 1/e.[40] The τ of HTPB-PUV is 104 s at 40 °C,
54 s at 60 °C, and 35 s at 80 °C due to the faster exchange
rate of dioxaborolane metathesis at higher temperatures. Besides,
the activation energy (Ea) of dioxaborolane
metathesis reactions can be calculated via Arrhenius’ law,[41] following eq , where τ is the relaxation time, τ0 is the characteristic relaxation time at infinite temperature, T is the testing temperature, and R is
the universal gas constant. The Arrhenius relationship of the characteristic
relaxation time τ versus 1000/T for 55%-HTPB-PUv
is shown in Figure b. The Ea (25 kJ/mol) is calculated,
and the value is in the range of 7.7–76.7 kJ/mol for the vitrimer
with boronic ester bonds.[42,43]
Figure 4
(a) Stress relaxation of the 55%-HTPB-PUV. (b) Arrhenius
plot with linear fitting. (c) Storage modulus and tan δ
curves of the 55%-HTPB-PUV.
(a) Stress relaxation of the 55%-HTPB-PUV. (b) Arrhenius
plot with linear fitting. (c) Storage modulus and tan δ
curves of the 55%-HTPB-PUV.The topology freezing transition temperature (Tv) is an important characteristic parameter for the vitrimer
at which the viscosity becomes higher than 1012 Pa·s.[44,45] In our system, the Tv = −105
°C is determined by extrapolating from the Arrhenius’
fitted line, which is similar to the reported boronic ester vitrimers[46,47] (in Figure b) to
the relaxation time τ = 4.2 × 105 s. When the
temperature is above Tv, the 55%-HTPB-PUv
network softens and its strain increases sharply due to the more facile
occurrence of the exchange reactions. However, below Tv °C, the network exhibits a similar performance
with ordinary thermosets, for the cross-linking network would be frozen
due to the low exchange reaction rate. These results illustrate the
excellent heat-induced malleability of the 55%-HTPB-PUv. Moreover,
the storage modulus and tan δ plots of the 55%-HTPB-PUv
are shown in Figure c. Tan δ curves of the 55%-HTPB-PUV show
two peaks at 54 and 103 °C, as shown in Figure c, due to the network dissociation of soft
and hard segments,[48] respectively, giving
a Tg of 54 °C. Moreover, a rubber
platform (E′ = 7.15 MPa, storage modulus at Tg + 30 °C) is obtained from the storage
modulus plot.Another significant parameter for network movements
is the glass-transition
temperature (Tg), below which the network
chain is frozen,[49] and is determined by
DSC analysis. DSC plots of the HTPB-PUv series with different BDB
contents are shown in Figure . It is found that the Tg of the
HTPB-PUv series gradually increases from 9.0 to 13.5 °C with
the BDB contents increasing from 30 to 60% because with the cross-linker
BDB content increasing, a higher cross-linking density, which is calculated
using eq by the equilibrium
swelling experiment in Table , is achieved. Therefore, the higher Tg is mainly attributed to the higher cross-linking density.[50,51] The low Tg (below 14 °C) of the
HTPB-PUv networks indicates that the networks show fast movements
at room temperature, contributing to the dioxaborolane metathesis
reaction of boronic ester linkages. Besides, the Tg (54 °C) of 55%-HTPB-PUv obtained from the tan δ
plot is higher than the Tg (12 °C)
from the DSC results due to the different measurement approaches.[52]
Figure 5
DSC plots of the HTPB-PUv series with different BDB contents.
DSC plots of the HTPB-PUv series with different BDB contents.Static tensile measurements are employed to study
the mechanical
properties of the HTPB-PUv series with different BDB contents; the
static tensile measurements are conducted at a strain rate of 5 s–1. All of the stress–strain curves are shown
in Figure a, and the
mechanical properties are summarized in Figure b and Table . It is found that BDB contents have a remarkable effect
on the mechanical properties. As the BDB content increases from 30
to 60%, the tensile strength also increases from 0.7 to 2.6 MPa because
the tensile strength is closely related to the cross-linking density,
as shown in Table , consistent with an increasing Tg.[53] Meanwhile, both the values of elongation at
break and toughness first increase to the maximum and then decrease
with BDB contents increasing because a high cross-linking density
makes the network hard, leading to a decreased elongation at break
and toughness at a high BDB content. The maximum values of elongation
at break and toughness are 101.9% and 1.8 MJ/m3 at BDB
contents of 50 and 55%, respectively. Obviously, the 55%-HTPB-PUV shows the best mechanical properties, with elongation at
break, toughness, and tensile strength of 86.6%, 1.8 MJ/m3, and 2.5 MPa, respectively.
Figure 6
Mechanical properties of HTPB-PUV series with different
BDB contents: (a) curve of stress–strain, (b) mechanical properties
of x-HTPB-PUV series with different cross-linker
contents.
Mechanical properties of HTPB-PUV series with different
BDB contents: (a) curve of stress–strain, (b) mechanical properties
of x-HTPB-PUV series with different cross-linker
contents.The thermostability of the HTPB-PUv
series with different BDB contents
is studied by TGA at a heating rate of 10 °C/min under a nitrogen
atmosphere, and the TGA and DTG curves are shown in Figure . For all of the HTPB-PUv series,
the thermalgravimetric profiles are similar with two weight loss stages
around 350 and 470 °C. The HTPB-PUv series show excellent thermal
stability with the onset decomposition temperature around 300 °C,
which is much higher than the thermal processing temperature (∼130
°C), demonstrating thermal stability during thermal processing.
The decomposition temperature of the first stage is ∼350 °C,
which is attributed to the thermal decomposition of the urethane bond
in polyurethane.[48,54] The second stage is the main
decomposition stage, in which the temperature can reach ∼450
°C due to the collapse of networks. Thermal stability of the
HTPB-PUv series is comparable, which is slightly affected by BDB contents.
Figure 7
TGA and
DTG curves of HTPB-PUV series with different
BDB contents.
TGA and
DTG curves of HTPB-PUV series with different
BDB contents.
Self-Healing,
Welding, and Shape Memory
At elevated temperatures, network
rearrangement can occur across
the interfaces of fractured surfaces; thus, covalent bonding can be
re-established at the same place due to the dioxaborolane metathesis
reaction between two boronic ester bonds. For proof of the self-healing
performance, the 55%-HTPB-PUv strip sample is cut with a thickness
of 1.5 mm using a blade. The sample with a width of 96.7 μm
scratch is treated with heating at 130 °C for 3 h in an oven
for healing. It was considered that the network could be frozen when
the temperature decreased below Tg; therefore,
a temperature higher than Tg was chosen
as the reprocessing temperature. Figure a displays optical microscope images of the
55%-HTPB-PUV after and before healing. It is found that
the scratch after healing almost completely disappears, indicating
an excellent self-healing behavior. However, for the HTPB-PUv sample
without BDB, it is observed that the width of the scratch after healing
at 130 °C for 3 h is only slightly decreased, as shown in Figure b. Therefore, the
self-healing behavior of the 55%-HTPB-PUv can be mainly attributed
to the presence of the dynamic bionic ester bond in the network. Moreover,
the schematic illustration of the self-healing mechanism in HTPB-PUv
based on the dynamic bionic ester bond is shown in Figure c. Due to the dioxaborolane
metathesis reaction of boronic ester bonds, covalent bonding can be
re-established across the interfaces of fractured surfaces, giving
rise to reconstructing of the network topologies, similar to the reported
polyurethane vitrimer based on boronic ester bonds.[22]
Figure 8
(a) Optical microscope images of self-healing behaviors for 55%-HTPB-PUV at 140 °C. (b) Self-healing performance of the HTPB-PUv
sample without BDB at 140 °C. (c) Schematic self-healing mechanism
of the dioxaborolane metathesis reaction of boronic ester bonds at
140 °C.
(a) Optical microscope images of self-healing behaviors for 55%-HTPB-PUV at 140 °C. (b) Self-healing performance of the HTPB-PUv
sample without BDB at 140 °C. (c) Schematic self-healing mechanism
of the dioxaborolane metathesis reaction of boronic ester bonds at
140 °C.To check the welding ability of
the 55%-HTPB-PUV networks,
the specimen is cut into half, and the two parts (30.0 mm × 8.0
mm × 1.0 mm) are overlapped by 10 mm. After holding together
for welding at 130 °C for 30, 60, or 120 min, the two parts are
welded tightly, as shown in Figure a, due to the dioxaborolane metathesis reactions of
the boronic ester bond. Lap-shear testing is applied to evaluate the
welding efficiency by carrying out tensile tests at 25 °C with
a cross-head speed of 5 mm/min. The welding efficiency of the 55%-HTPB-PUV can be determined as the proportion of the welded sample’s
tensile strength or elongation at break with respect to the original
one’s. Stress–strain curves of the samples with different
welding treatment times (30, 60, or 120 min) are shown in Figure c. It is observed
that the original sample displays a typical ductile fracture, whereas
the welded sample exhibits a less ductile fracture, as shown in Figure b. Moreover, with
the welding time extending, mechanical properties are improved. The
best mechanical properties were obtained from the welded sample with
120 min of heating, which shows a tensile strength of 2.9 MPa, elongation
at break of 35.7%, and toughness of 0.6 MJ/m3, and the
recovery ratio of the tensile strength reaches 120%. The above results
demonstrate that the HTPB-PUV network with the dynamic
boronic ester bonds possesses an attractive thermal welding capability.[55]
Figure 9
(a) Optical images of before and after welding of 55%-HTPB-PUV. (b) Fractured specimens of welded (left) and pristine (right)
samples after lap-shear testing. (c) Tensile curves and (d) recovery
ratios of the mechanical properties of 55%-HTPB-PUV welding
at 130 °C for different treating times of 30, 60, and 120 min.
(a) Optical images of before and after welding of 55%-HTPB-PUV. (b) Fractured specimens of welded (left) and pristine (right)
samples after lap-shear testing. (c) Tensile curves and (d) recovery
ratios of the mechanical properties of 55%-HTPB-PUV welding
at 130 °C for different treating times of 30, 60, and 120 min.The typical thermosets are inherently difficult
to reshape because
of the permanent cross-linking networks. In this work, the boronic
ester bonds can undergo dioxaborolane metathesis reactions in the
obtained networks, which gives network rearrangements and results
in a gradual Arrhenius-like viscosity dependence, leading to a shape
memory ability of the network in the solid state. The 55%-HTPB-PUv
with dynamic boronic ester bonds can be healed and welded at elevated
temperatures. Similarly, the 55%-HTPB-PUv can undergo dioxaborolane
metathesis reactions to achieve topological rearrangements above Tg and Tv, giving
a shape memory ability.[40,56]Figure shows the optical images for the shape
memory performances. First, the sample is heated to 130 °C, which
turns it into an oblique or heart shape, and which could be fixed
upon cooling down to room temperature. Subsequently, the temperature
is elevated to 130 °C again, and the oblique or heart shape reverts
to its original flat state quickly and then recovers by following
the same procedure of “heating–cooling”. It is
reported that the thermal-responsive shape memory property presenting
in the polymer needs chemical or physical cross-linked networks and
an appropriate ratio of flexible and stiff segments.[57] Herein, the networks of the 55%-HTPB-PUv contain chemical
cross-linking networks with bionic acid linkage, consistent with FTIR
measurements. Besides, boronic ester bonds in the network undergo
dioxaborolane metathesis reactions, which result in a gradual Arrhenius-like
viscosity dependence, providing the network reshaping in the solid
state.
Figure 10
Optical images of shape memory performance of the 55%-HTPB-PUV sample.
Optical images of shape memory performance of the 55%-HTPB-PUV sample.
Reprocessing
The most significant
reprocessing capability is researched since the HTPB-PUV networks can arrange their topology by the exchange reaction of
boronic ester bonds. The dioxaborolane metathesis reaction can take
place between boronic ester bonds in the network; thus, the network
has rearrangement, leading to reprocessability of the network.[58] First, the 55%-HTPB-PUV sample is
cut into powder and then is reprocessed by hot pressing at 130 °C
under 5 MPa with different treating times (1, 2, or 3 h) for three
cycles. Homogenous well-shaped samples are obtained as shown in Figure , with the generation
increasing the color of the recycled sample to become slightly dark.
Moreover, the reprocessability of the HTPB-PUv is examined by the
mechanical properties’ measurements. Stress–strain curves
of the samples with different welding treatment times (1, 2, or 3
h) and generations (1st, 2nd, or 3rd) are shown in Figure b,d, and recovery ratios of
the mechanical properties for the recycled samples are exhibited in Figure c,e. From the stress–strain
curves, it can be easily observed that a more rigid network is formed
after reprocessing, while the original 55%-HTPB-PUV shows
a clear transition of elastic–plastic deformation. The tensile
strength of all of the reprocessed samples increases compared with
the original one. It is found that the cycled samples show brittle
fracture with decreased elongation at break and increased tensile
strength in comparison with the original sample. Possibly, because
the macroscopic phase separates into soft and hard regions in the
pristine PU sample, after high-temperature reprocessing, the phase
structure is improved in the cycled samples.[31,59−61] Moreover, it is confirmed by SEM images, as shown
in Figure f–i,
that the original 55%-HTPB-PUV shows coarse fracture; however,
the recycled samples display more smooth fractures. With treatment
times prolonging from 1 to 3 h, the recovery of tensile strength is
increased from 112 to 141%. Therefore, different generation samples
are obtained from 3 h hot pressing; the mechanical properties reasonably
decay for more cycled samples, and the recovery of tensile strength
decreases from 140 to 111%. All of the phenomena indicate that the
HTPB-PUv networks with dynamic boronic ester bonds possess excellent
reprocessability.[62,63]
Figure 11
(a) Optical images of thermal recycling
performance of 55%-HTPB-PUV by hot pressing. (b) Tensile
curves and (c) mechanical properties
of samples with different treating times at 130 °C. (d) Tensile
curves and (e) mechanical properties of the samples with different
generations of reprocessing. SEM images of (f) the original, (g) the
first generation, (h) the second generation, and (i) the third generation
of the 55%-HTPB-PUV.
(a) Optical images of thermal recycling
performance of 55%-HTPB-PUV by hot pressing. (b) Tensile
curves and (c) mechanical properties
of samples with different treating times at 130 °C. (d) Tensile
curves and (e) mechanical properties of the samples with different
generations of reprocessing. SEM images of (f) the original, (g) the
first generation, (h) the second generation, and (i) the third generation
of the 55%-HTPB-PUV.
Conclusions
In this work, HTPB-PUv networks
with dynamic boronic ester bonds
were successfully synthesized using a facile one-pot reaction approach,
with BDB as the cross-linker, which were characterized by FTIR and
DMA measurements. The 55%-HTPB-PUv network (Ea = 25 kJ/mol, Tv = −105
°C) possesses superior malleability due to the fast dioxaborolane
metathesis reaction of boronic ester bonds. The HTPB-PUv networks
exhibit distinct reprocessing, self-healing, welding, and shape memory
capabilities. Through hot pressing at 130 °C, for 3 h, the recycled
samples display excellent reprocessability because of the introduction
of dynamic boronic ester bonds into PU networks. Meanwhile, the tensile
strength of reprocessed samples is higher than the original one due
to improvement in the phase structure in the recycled samples with
reprocessing treatment. The scratches on the healed sample completely
disappear. The welded sample shows a welding efficiency of 120%.
Authors: Max Röttger; Trystan Domenech; Rob van der Weegen; Antoine Breuillac; Renaud Nicolaÿ; Ludwik Leibler Journal: Science Date: 2017-04-07 Impact factor: 47.728