Lu Gan1,2, Sharon Xiaodai Lim1, Chorng-Haur Sow1,3. 1. Department of Physics, National University of Singapore, 2 Science Drive 3, Singapore 117542, Singapore. 2. Jianqing Experiment School, No. 900, Guyang Rd, Shanghai 10312, China. 3. Center For Advanced 2D Materials and Graphene Research Center, National University of Singapore, 6 Science Drive 2, Singapore 117546, Singapore.
Abstract
With their special hierarchical fractal and highly symmetric formation, silver dendrites have a large surface area and plentiful active sites at edges, which have allowed them to exhibit unique properties ranging from superhydrophobic surfaces to biosensors. Yet, many suggested synthesis processes either require a long reaction time or risk contamination from sacrificial elements. Limited research in directing while enhancing the growth of these silver dendrites also hinders the application of these unique microstructures as site-selective hydrophobicity of surfaces and location-dependent SERS (surface-enhanced Raman spectroscopy). A possible solution to this is to utilize WO3 nanocubes as beacons to accelerate and conduct the growth of these silver dendrites through the electrochemical migration process. These nanocubes effortlessly altered the applied electric field distributed between the electrodes, depending on their orientations and positions. As the silver dendrites branched from the nanocubes, the dendrites themselves further concentrated the electric field to encourage the growth of more loose fractal silver dendrites. The combinatory effect successfully directs the growth of silver dendrites along the concentrated electric field paths. Both changes to the electric field and directed growth of silver dendrites are underscored using Multiphysics COMSOL simulations and time-lapse microscopy. This work provided insight into the possibility of designing microstructures to direct and accelerate the growth of silver dendrites.
With their special hierarchical fractal and highly symmetric formation, silver dendrites have a large surface area and plentiful active sites at edges, which have allowed them to exhibit unique properties ranging from superhydrophobic surfaces to biosensors. Yet, many suggested synthesis processes either require a long reaction time or risk contamination from sacrificial elements. Limited research in directing while enhancing the growth of these silver dendrites also hinders the application of these unique microstructures as site-selective hydrophobicity of surfaces and location-dependent SERS (surface-enhanced Raman spectroscopy). A possible solution to this is to utilize WO3 nanocubes as beacons to accelerate and conduct the growth of these silver dendrites through the electrochemical migration process. These nanocubes effortlessly altered the applied electric field distributed between the electrodes, depending on their orientations and positions. As the silver dendrites branched from the nanocubes, the dendrites themselves further concentrated the electric field to encourage the growth of more loose fractal silver dendrites. The combinatory effect successfully directs the growth of silver dendrites along the concentrated electric field paths. Both changes to the electric field and directed growth of silver dendrites are underscored using Multiphysics COMSOL simulations and time-lapse microscopy. This work provided insight into the possibility of designing microstructures to direct and accelerate the growth of silver dendrites.
For many decades, a wealth of nanostructures
such as nanoparticles,[1] nanowire,[2] nanorods,[3] nanoflower,[4] and nanodendrites[5−7] have been fabricated
from noble metals like copper,[8] gold,[9] palladium,[10] and silver.[6] By twitching
with the sizes, crystallinities, shapes, and compositions, researchers
have successfully coaxed unique properties out of these nanostructures.
Of these nanostructures, nanodendrites with a special hierarchical
fractal and highly symmetrical formation have rendered themselves
distinctive. The large surface area and plentiful active sites at
the edges of these nanodendrites allow them to form superhydrophobic[11] surfaces, produce surface-enhanced Raman scattering
(SERS),[5,12] initiate catalytic processes,[9] and serve as biosensors.[13] Coincidentally, these nanodendrites displays far superior performance
in SERS,[14] antibacterial ability,[15] and electrocatalysis[16] than their spherically shaped nanoparticles’ counterparts.Silver dendrites are highly sought after because of their excellent
electrical and thermal conductivities among these noble metals. Furthermore,
silver’s electronic and optical properties are readily controlled
by size and shape. So, to fabricate these silver dendrites, long-duration
processes such as photoreduction in the presence of ultraviolet irradiation,[17] and the use of sacrificial metals such as copper
and zinc in the galvanic replacement process,[5,18] has
been well established. Although these processes can produce large
amounts of silver dendrites, they cannot ascertain control over the
direction of growth. Such control is critical to add more functionalities
such as site-selective hydrophobicity of surfaces and location-dependent
SERS to these amazing nanostructures.Recently, some controls
over these dendrites were reported with
the implementation of templated-assisted growth during the galvanic
replacement process.[19,20] Leow et al.[21] discovered that by running a focused laser beam along specific
sites of the GO film, localized reduced GO (rGO) with higher conductivity
can be created, which then encourages the electrochemical migration
of silver dendrites along these paths. Regulated formation of Zn dendrites
were also achieved by Sun et al. with the help of TiO/Zn/N-doped carbon inverse opal.[22]With inheriting a large surface area to enhance the
absorption
of silver ions and concentrate aromatic molecules, a superior signal-to-noise
ratio of silver dendrites coupled rGO in SERS application has also
been reported.[23] GO is thus selected as
a potential candidate in our quest to develop a way to direct the
growth of silver dendrites while enhancing their formations through
electrochemical migration. This is an aim that has yet to be accomplished.
The decision to investigate with an electrochemical migration[24] process lies in the advantages that this procedure
has in creating a large scale, one-step synthesis process with good
morphological control of the silver dendrites via a simple process
of varying concentration of silver ions, current density, and deposition
time.Coincidentally, monolayer or few-layer tungsten disulfide
(WS2) has been discovered to form stable composites with
metal
nanoparticles[25] while improving the composite’s
overall electrochemical properties. These two-dimensional lamellar
transition metal dichalcogenide (TMD) microflakes have a similar microstructure
as GO, which will likely allow them to form a good composite with
the GO flakes. As a result, the composite can produce a hybrid thin
film with unique electric field distribution along the large surface
area. In the presence of silver ions and under an applied potential,
redistribution of these electric fields will encourage the formation
of silver dendrites through an enhanced electrochemical process and
direct the growth of these silver dendrites along these electric field
lines.In this work, WS2 microflakes are intentionally
mixed
with a GO microflakes’ suspension and deposited on silicon
dioxide wafers to form a thin composite film. The intended strategy
is to use these WS2 microflakes as nanopath-beacons to
guide the migration of the silver dendrites across the GO terrain.
The composite film is then subjected to an applied potential in the
presence of silver ions that are likely trapped between the microflakes.
Multiphysics COMSOL simulation is then used to form a deeper understanding
of how the redistribution of the electric field across the composite
film can affect the establishment of these silver dendrites.
Results
and Discussion
Formation of GO/WO3 Nanocubes’
Composite Film
First, 0.9 μL of a diluted GO and WS2 microflakes’
solution is deposited between the prefabricated gold electrodes. The
substrate with the solution is heated at 85 °C on a hot plate
in ambient conditions until dry (Figure a). The outcome of these processes results
in randomly scattered nanocubes on the composite thin film.
Figure 1
(a) Deposition
of GO/WS2 mixture across prefabricated
gold electrodes. (b, d) Optical images of (b) Pristine GO film and
(d) GO/WS2 mixture being deposited across the gold electrodes.
(c, e) SEM images of the (c) pristine GO film and (e) GO/WS2 mixture. Insets of (c) and (e) show higher magnification of the
GO film and nanocubes, respectively. (f) EDX elemental map of a single
nanocube.
(a) Deposition
of GO/WS2 mixture across prefabricated
gold electrodes. (b, d) Optical images of (b) Pristine GO film and
(d) GO/WS2 mixture being deposited across the gold electrodes.
(c, e) SEM images of the (c) pristine GO film and (e) GO/WS2 mixture. Insets of (c) and (e) show higher magnification of the
GO film and nanocubes, respectively. (f) EDX elemental map of a single
nanocube.Figure b,c shows
optical and SEM images of the pristine GO film, with a distinct optical
contrast compared to the GO/WS2 composite film. While GO
film appears to be smooth with some crease (inset of Figure c), small white specks are
observed to be sparsely scattered across the GO/WS2 composite
film (Figure d,e).
Detailed SEM analysis shows a distinct cubic structure (inset Figure e) observed from
these sparks. EDX elemental map of one of these cubes suggests that
they are likely to be tungsten oxide (WO3) nanocubes.With only GO and WS2 as the precursors, it is important
to determine the chemical nature of the nanocubes and how they are
formed via the process illustrated in Figure a. A nondestructive optical analysis is first
carried out on these nanocubes using Raman spectroscopy (Figure a). The analysis
involved four different sample types of film. Namely, pristine GO
nanoflakes, pristine WS2, heated WS2, and heated
GO/WS2 films. Survey scan from 100 to 3200 cm–1 shows the presence of defects (D), graphitic (G), 2D and D+D′
peaks, all contributed by the GO flakes.[26] At the same time, samples with WS2 shows a few distinct
peaks below 600 cm–1 (highlighted by the blue oval).
Figure 2
(a) Raman
spectrum of pristine GO, pristine WS2, heated
WS2, and GO/WS2 mixture that has been heated
to 85 °C. (b) An expanded view of the Raman measurement range
between 150 cm–1 to 650 cm–1.
(c–f) SEM images of the samples used in the Raman measurement.
Insets are images with higher magnifications of the respective samples.
(g) XRD patterns of heated WS2 and GO/WS2 mixture.
(a) Raman
spectrum of pristine GO, pristine WS2, heated
WS2, and GO/WS2 mixture that has been heated
to 85 °C. (b) An expanded view of the Raman measurement range
between 150 cm–1 to 650 cm–1.
(c–f) SEM images of the samples used in the Raman measurement.
Insets are images with higher magnifications of the respective samples.
(g) XRD patterns of heated WS2 and GO/WS2 mixture.Figure b shows
an expanded view of the region highlighted by the blue oval in Figure a. Raman peak located
at 518 cm–1 is associated with the underlying Si
wafer.[26] The outcome suggests that strong
Raman signals at ∼352 and ∼417 cm–1 represent the E12g and A1g modes
in WS2[27] unheated nanocubes
in the absence of GO flakes. Evidently, after heating to 85 °C
in ambient, more Raman peaks are detected. These peaks include those
located at ∼295 and ∼323 cm–1, which
are associated with the 2E22g and E22g mode of WS2.[27] presence of more peaks are attributed to heat-initiated dissociation
of foreign molecules, which might have hindered the detection of pristine
WS2 Raman signals. As observed from the SEM images (Figure d,e), these occur
without significant changes to the nanocubes’ physical morphology. Figure c–f shows
SEM images of pristine GO nanoflakes, pristine WS2, heated
WS2, and heated GO/WS2 films taken at similar
magnifications. The insets of these show higher magnification SEM
images of the respective samples.Interestingly, with the addition
of the GO flakes to the WS2 nanocubes (Figure f), WS2 Raman peaks
are no longer detected. Instead,
two distinct peaks located at ∼257 cm–1 (W–O–W
bond) and ∼352 cm–1 (W–OH2 bond), representative of WO3·H2O elements,
are detected (Figure b).[28] The identified element, WO3·H2O, also corresponded to the XRD pattern obtained
from the GO/WS2 mixture (Figure g), where the peak at 2θ = 12.8°
corresponds to the (002) of GO sheets. The peaks at 2θ = 16.5°,
25.7°, 33.4°, and 51.2° are indexed to the diffraction
pattern of orthorhombic WO3·H2O (JCPDS
Card No. 43-0679). Because of incomplete conversion of WS2 to WO3·H2O, some XRD peaks associated
with WS2 are also identified at 2θ = 33.4°,
69.1° (JCPDS Card No. 35-06511). It is important to note that
the XRD peak with a value of 2θ = 33.4 is being associated with
both elements. Compared with heated WS2 samples, XRD patterns
highlights partial conversion of the WS2 elements to WO3·H2O. However, in this sample, only two out
of fours peaks identified in the GO/WS2 mixture are picked
up during the analyses. The result suggests that relative to the GO/WS2 mixture, by increasing the temperature of the GO and WS2 mixture to 85 °C (in ambient), the process encourages
W to be readily oxidized into WO3 and form bonds with water
molecules. These water molecules are present on the surface and trapped
between the GO flakes. As a result, S atoms will likely remain within
and on the surface of the GO-H2O film mixture. From the
above analyses, these nanocubes will now be termed WO3 nanocubes.
WO3 Nanocubes as Beacons for Enhancement of Silver
Dendrites’ Formation
In a bid to determine the potential
use of the WO3 nanocubes as beacons to facilitate the formation
of silver dendrites in the presence of an applied potential, 8 μL
of AgNO3 solution is deposited across the hybrid film for
20s in a dark environment, with minimum light being introduced onto
the sample. The choice of a dark environment minimizes any chances
of photoreduction of AgNO3, thus allowing results from
subsequent electrochemical processes to be more accurately presented.Subsequently, the sample is rinsed with deionized water and blown
dry with nitrogen gas. The seemingly dried sample is then connected
to a source meter to study Ag dendrites formation via electrochemical
migration process across the composite film. The fabrication process,
as mentioned above, is depicted in Figure a.
Figure 3
(a) Schematic of the fabrication process in
which the AgNO3 solution is deposited on GO/WO3 film. (b) COMSOL
simulation of electric field lines between two T-shaped electrodes.
Optical time-lapsed images of Ag migration under a constant voltage
1.5 V across GO film in the (c–f) absence and (g–j)
presence of WO3 nanocubes.
(a) Schematic of the fabrication process in
which the AgNO3 solution is deposited on GO/WO3 film. (b) COMSOL
simulation of electric field lines between two T-shaped electrodes.
Optical time-lapsed images of Ag migration under a constant voltage
1.5 V across GO film in the (c–f) absence and (g–j)
presence of WO3 nanocubes.When a constant potential is applied between the electrodes, the
growth of Ag dendrites takes place from both corners of the T-shape
negative electrode Figure c through an electrochemical deposition process. In general,
Ag+ ions electrolytes provided by AgNO3 solutions
are trapped between the GO flakes. These Ag+ ions then
take in electrons from the cathode in the presence of an applied potential.
The process results in the formation of Ag nanoparticles at the interface
between water and the cathode. Ag+ ions are continuously
being reduced, and the Ag dendrites are formed by maintaining a constant
potential, hence a constant supply of electrons. A detailed study
of Ag dendrites’ formation on pristine GO flakes has been reported
by Leow et al.[21] The growth of Ag dendrites
begins from the corner of the T-shaped electrodes due to the presence
of a stronger electric field present at these locations. The above
statement is justified by the COMSOL simulation of electric field
(indicated by the white cones) across parallel electrodes under an
applied potential of 1.5 V, as presented in Figure b.Pristine GO flakes are replaced
with the GO/WO3 film
while maintaining a similar electrode design and applied potential.
Because of the replacement, a unique growth path for the Ag dendrite
is observed over such film (Figure g). The first instant potential is applied across the
electrodes; no dendrite growth is observed to form between the parallel
portion of the electrodes on the GO film (Figure c). However, in the case where WO3 nanocubes are present on the GO film, short dendrites have already
started to form under the same circumstances. As Ag dendrites migrate
across the composite film, they travel along a preferential path toward
the WO3 nanocubes, which likely serve as beacons (Figure h) to guide the formation
of Ag dendrites. Upon coming into contact, these nanocube beacons
triggered the formation of more Ag dendrites. By maintaining a constant
applied potential of 1.5 V, more bunching of Ag dendrites from the
WO3 nanocube beacons is observed Figure i,j. In the absence of the WO3 nanocubes (Figure c–f), the duration of the applied field required to achieve
the same distance of the migration process is much longer. The observation
further highlights the directive role of the WO3 nanocubes.The role of WO3 nanocubes in enhancing Ag dendrites
formation is verified by covering the bottom half of the electrodes
with a PDMS polymer layer (region highlighted by the black dotted
line in Figure a)
before allowing the top half to be decorated with WO3 nanocubes.
The nanocubes are enclosed by the white circles in Figure a. For the same amount and
duration of applied potential, it is noticeable that the growth of
these Ag dendrites (highlighted by the red arrows in Figure a–f) takes place primarily
within the region where WO3 nanocubes are present, and
these dendrites are “attracted” toward these WO3 nanocubes. The observation thus affirms the above-proposed
role played by these WO3 nanocubes. By changing the design
of the electrode, replacing one of the T-shaped electrodes with a
pointed edge, the distributions of the electric field are changed.
As a result, the effect of WO3 on the growth of the Ag
dendrites becomes more substantial. Figure g–h shows the growth of Ag dendrites
from the pointed electrode across pristine GO film. These dendrites
branch out from the pointed tip, as well as the edges of the pointed
electrode. In the presence of WO3 nanocubes, it is evident
that the Ag dendrites grow from the pointed growth of Ag dendrites
along the edges of the sharp electrode. In the presence of WO3 nanocubes, it is evident that the Ag dendrites grow from
the pointed growth of Ag dendrites along the edges of the sharp electrode.
Figure 4
Time lapsed
optical images of preferential growth of Ag dendrites
in the presence of WO3 nanocubes across (a–f) two
T-shaped electrodes and (g–j) a combination of pointed and
T-shaped electrodes. Red arrows and white circles in (a–f)
demarked the Ag dendrites’ growth and location of the WO3 nanocubes, respectively. The black dotted line encloses a
region with only pristine GO film in (a–f). (g–j) Time-lapsed
optical images of Ag dendrites on (g,h) pristine GO film and (i,j)
in the presence of WO3 nanocubes. Yellow dots in (i) and
(j) indicates the position of the WO3 nanocubes.
Time lapsed
optical images of preferential growth of Ag dendrites
in the presence of WO3 nanocubes across (a–f) two
T-shaped electrodes and (g–j) a combination of pointed and
T-shaped electrodes. Red arrows and white circles in (a–f)
demarked the Ag dendrites’ growth and location of the WO3 nanocubes, respectively. The black dotted line encloses a
region with only pristine GO film in (a–f). (g–j) Time-lapsed
optical images of Ag dendrites on (g,h) pristine GO film and (i,j)
in the presence of WO3 nanocubes. Yellow dots in (i) and
(j) indicates the position of the WO3 nanocubes.
Proposed Mechanism of WO3 Nanocubes’s
Role
in Directing Ag Dendrites’ Formation
The electrochemical
method for controlled synthesis of silver dendrites is a well-established
process.[17,21,29] It involves
tuning the applied electric potential to create an inequilibrium thermodynamic
environment that favors the reduction of Ag+ ions, resulting
in the formation of Ag dendrites. In a similar context, Figure a–d illustrates how
Ag dendrites are readily formed in this work. In the absence of an
applied electric potential, low concentrations of Ag+ ions
in water are trapped between the GO flakes.[21] Applying an electric potential across the T-shaped electrodes generates
a stronger electric field around the corners (a claim supported by
COMSOL simulation of electric field lines between two T-shaped electrodes
(Figure b and Figure f). Consequently,
a combinatory effect of strong electric field coupled with low concentrations
of Ag+ ions, resulted in the free-roaming positively charged
Ag+ ions to become more strongly attracted to the corners
of the negative electrodes and become reduced.[30] The process then results in the formation of Ag dendrites,
branching out from the electrode corners more readily than other parts
of the electrodes (Figure b,e) through an ion diffusion limited growth process.[30,31] With sustained applied electric potential, a continuous reduction
of Ag+ ions to Ag NPs takes place, extending these Ag dendrites
toward the positive electrode (Figure c).
Figure 5
(a–d) Illustrates the formation process of Ag dendrites
through the electrochemical method, and how the presence of WO3 nanocubes can further encourage while influencing the formation
and paths of these Ag dendrites. (e) Time-lapsed optical image of
Ag dendrites formation across T-shaped electrodes after applying 1.5
V for 8 s. (g) SEM image of four WO3 nanocubes highlighted
by yellow dotted lines and the red arrows indicates the growth direction
of Ag dendrites from the WO3 nanocubes. (f, h, i) COMSOL
simulation of how the electric field distribution across the electrodes
is affected by the WO3 nanocubes and the growth of Ag dendrites.
The location of the nanocubes and Ag dendrites in the simulation matches
those in (e) and (g), respectively. (j) A higher-magnification SEM
view of the loose fractal formation of Ag dendrites obtained through
our process.
(a–d) Illustrates the formation process of Ag dendrites
through the electrochemical method, and how the presence of WO3 nanocubes can further encourage while influencing the formation
and paths of these Ag dendrites. (e) Time-lapsed optical image of
Ag dendrites formation across T-shaped electrodes after applying 1.5
V for 8 s. (g) SEM image of four WO3 nanocubes highlighted
by yellow dotted lines and the red arrows indicates the growth direction
of Ag dendrites from the WO3 nanocubes. (f, h, i) COMSOL
simulation of how the electric field distribution across the electrodes
is affected by the WO3 nanocubes and the growth of Ag dendrites.
The location of the nanocubes and Ag dendrites in the simulation matches
those in (e) and (g), respectively. (j) A higher-magnification SEM
view of the loose fractal formation of Ag dendrites obtained through
our process.Previous work by Leow et al.[21] underscored
the ability to direct and control the migrating path of Ag nanoparticles
across GO by using a focused laser beam to tune the electron affinity
of the GO film and directing the electric field across the GO film,
while You et al.[30] showcased how in situ studies of growth modes of silver crystals are induced
by the presence of a concentrated field in an aqueous solution. Both
works highlight the critical role electric field distribution has
in shaping the direction in which Ag nanoparticles migration can occur.Single-crystal WO3 is an n-type semiconductor,[32] which means that the positively charged Ag+ ions will naturally be attracted to these negatively charged
beacons. Under the influence of a constant applied electric potential,
these WO3 nanocubes then readily reduced the Ag+ ions, allowing Ag dendrites to start branching out from these WO3 nanocubes.Not only so, in the presence of an applied
potential, electric
field distribution will also be affected by both the orientations
and locations of these nanocubes (Figure h). The above statement is justified through
COMSOL simulation. A time-lapse optical image of Ag dendrites growth
across T-shaped electrodes under an applied potential of 1.5 V for
8 s was captured, and the positions of the nanocubes, appearing as
white specks, are recorded in Figure e. The geometry is then duplicated in COMSOL simulation,
and an electric field distribution under similar applied potential
is presented in Figure f. In Figure f, magenta
arrows indicate how localized electric field lines are redistributed
around the WO3 nanocubes. A close-up SEM image of typical
Ag dendrites growth (red arrow) around the WO3 nanocubes
(yellow dotted box) is depicted in Figure g. Running similar COMSOL simulation reveals
how the Ag dendrites’ growth direction from the WO3 nanocubes accords with the alterations to the electric field distributions
(Figure h). As the
Ag dendrites extend from the WO3 nanocube, the surface
and contour plot of the potential from the simulation emphasized how
the concentrated potential field around the Ag dendrites can further
encourage the formation of more bunches (Figure h,i). A higher magnification SEM view of
the Ag dendrites formed through this process shows loose fractal formation.
The observation is in good agreement with the proposal by You et al.,[30] given our work also utilizes low concentrations
of Ag+ ions and a concentrated field by both the WO3 nanocubes and newly formed Ag dendrites.
Unique Function
of S Atoms
Previously, Raman analysis
suggested the formation of WO3·H2O elements
upon thermal annealing of GO and WS2 mixture to 85 °C
(in ambient). Coupled with electrical measurements and COMSOL simulation,
the role of the WO3 nanocube as a guiding beacon is now
better understood. However, that leaves an unsolved puzzle about the
role played by S atoms. With the oxidation of W to form WO3, S atoms from WS2 precursors are believed to have likely
remained within and on the surface of the composite film.Thorough
SEM and EDX elemental maps of these nanocubes insinuate the possible
formation of AgS on the surface of the nanocubes (Figure a–e). A more comprehensive
analysis of these nanocubes after the migration process is conducted
using HRTEM (Figure f–i). The TEM image presented in Figure f shows the formation of small NPs on a single
nanocube. SAED characterization of the cube produces a cubic atomic
structure with an interplanar distance of 0.387 nm (inset of Figure f). The result corresponds
to that of WO3,[33] which is in
good agreement with the Raman results.
Figure 6
(a–e) EDX elemental
maps of one WO3 nanocube
after applying an electric field. (f) TEM image of a WO3 nanocube decorated with AgS NPs. Inset is a SAED of the WO3 nanocube. (g–i) HRTEM of (g) orange, (h) blue, and (i) green
regions highlighted in (f). d1, d2, and d3 represent the interplanar distance of Ag2(HSO4)2(H2SO4), AgS, and WO3.
(a–e) EDX elemental
maps of one WO3 nanocube
after applying an electric field. (f) TEM image of a WO3 nanocube decorated with AgS NPs. Inset is a SAED of the WO3 nanocube. (g–i) HRTEM of (g) orange, (h) blue, and (i) green
regions highlighted in (f). d1, d2, and d3 represent the interplanar distance of Ag2(HSO4)2(H2SO4), AgS, and WO3.To determine the nature of these
NPs atop the nanocube, HRTEM reveals
lattice structures corresponding to two different compositions. From
the region enclosed by the orange square in Figure f, the lattice spacing (Figure g) of 0.712 and 0.498 nm matches
the (002) and (200) plane of silver hydrogen sulfate, Ag2(HSO4)2(H2SO4).[34] From the smaller region in the blue square (Figure f), these nanoparticles
are identified as silver sulfide, AgS composites with the lattice
spacing of 0.207 and 0.188 nm (Figure h). These spacings correspond to the lattice planes
(220) and (222). From the third region enclosed in the green square
(Figure f), the nanoparticle
is identified to be AgS with the lattice plane (220), while the surface
on which the nanoparticle formed is WO3 with lattice plane
(004) (Figure i).Results from the HRTEM analysis suggest that under an applied electric
potential, Ag ions react with S ions on the WO3 nanocubes
to form AgS NPs. At the same time, these Ag ions could also be intercalated
within the WO3 nanostructure. The intercalation process
is highly dependent on the crystal structure of the WO3 nanocubes. In general, the higher symmetry of the crystalline will
bring about a greater possibility for ion intercalation.[35] Since the WO3 nanocubes are identified
to have a cubic phase crystal structure (inset Figure f), it provides a favorable condition for
this process.Despite the formation of AgS NPs atop these WO3 nanocubes,
SEM and EDX analysis suggest that the dendrites branching out from
these WO3 nanocubes beacons comprise mainly Ag NPs. Figure a shows an SEM image
of the dendrites formed between the electrodes after applying an electric
potential. EDX spectra (Figure b–d) obtained from the dendrites, indicated as I, II,
and III in (Figure a), suggest that these dendrites mainly comprise Ag NPs. This result
is further verified by the elemental map of silver and sulfur (Figure e–g).
Figure 7
(a) SEM image
of silver dendrites formed across electrodes. (b–d)
EDX spectra of regions I, II, and III indicated in (a). (e–g)
EDX elemental map of the dendrites showing that the dendrites comprise
Ag atoms.
(a) SEM image
of silver dendrites formed across electrodes. (b–d)
EDX spectra of regions I, II, and III indicated in (a). (e–g)
EDX elemental map of the dendrites showing that the dendrites comprise
Ag atoms.
Conclusions
Herein,
we report success in utilizing WO3 nanocubes
as guiding beacons to encourage the synthesis and direct the growth
of Ag dendrites. Using a simple mixing and low-temperature heating
process, WS2, in the presence of GO suspension, formed
W–O–W and W–OH2 bonds. These bonds
are representative of WO3·H2O elements.
When dispersed together with GO microflakes to form a thin composite
film, these WO3 nanocubes readily alter electric field
distribution under an applied potential. Depending on their location
and orientation, the site-specific concentration of the electric field
initiates Ag dendrites’ growth from these sites. This claim
is justified through Multiphysics COMSOL simulation. At the same time,
the WO3 nanocubes also serve as path-guiding beacons, encouraging
more growth of Ag dendrites within a shorter time. Simultaneously,
sulfur from the dissociation of WS2, when left to interact
with the Ag ions, resulted in the formation of AgS and Ag2(HSO4)2(H2SO4) nanoparticles
atop the WO3 nanocubes. Because of the cubic phase of WO3, there is also a likelihood of intercalating these nanoparticles
within the nanocubes. Thus, our work presented a new and straightforward
approach to encourage and direct the growth of Ag dendrites through
an electrochemical migration process.
Experimental Methods
Sample
Preparation
Graphene Oxide and Tungsten Disulfide Mixture
Highly
concentrated graphene oxide (GO) microflakes (6 M L–1, Graphene Supermarket) are diluted to 2 M L–1.
The diluted solution is mixed with tungsten disulfide microflakes
solution (WS2, Graphene supermarket) to a 1:5 volume ratio.
Oxygen Etching of SiO2/Si Substrate and Preparation
of Silver Nitrate Solution
Patterned SiO2/Si substrates
undergo reactive ion etching at 200W for 1 min with 50 ccm of oxygen
to enhance the substrate’s hydrophilicity for better GO deposition.
A silver nitrate solution is obtained by dissolving silver nitrate
crystals (Sigma-Aldrich) in deionized water to a concentration of
0.1 M L–1.
Fabrication of Gold Electrodes
on SiO2/Si
The electrodes’ fabrication
was achieved using UV lithography
and sputtering metal deposition. Soda-lime blank (Nanofilm, Wetlake
Village, California) with 100 nm thick chromium and 530 nm thick layer
of AZ1518 photoresist is patterned by a direct-write laser system
(Heidelberg Instruments uPG 101) to fabricate the initial UV photomask
with electrode patterns. Next, a 1 μm thick AZ1512 resist is
deposited by spin coating and being exposed to UV light in a Mask
& Bond Aligner (Karl Suss, MA8/BA6). After resist development,
two layers of Cr/Au (10 nm/50 nm) are sputtered on the SiO2/Si substrates as an adhesion and electrode base, respectively. Finally,
lift-off is carried out using acetone, leaving the electrodes on the
SiO2/Si wafer (Nanyang Equipment Pte Ltd.).
Further Characterizations
Further characterizations
are carried out using an optical microscope (OM) (model: Olympus BX51)
under bright field illumination. Surface morphology, crystallinity,
and chemical composition are characterized using SEM-EDX (JEOL JSM6700-F
with Oxford Instruments X-MaxN 150 EDX detector) and TEM
(JEOL JEM-2010F). Raman measurement is carried out using a Renishaw
System coupled with a 532 nm laser. Electrical measurements are conducted
using the Keithley 4200-SCS Source-meter unit attached to the OM.