Kai Cheng1,2,3, Mengxia Wang1, Sihao Wang1, Nanshu Liu2, Jinke Xu1, Han Wang3,4, Yan Su2. 1. School of Electronic Engineering, Xi'an University of Posts and Telecommunications, Xi'an 710121, China. 2. Key Laboratory of Materials Modification by Laser, Ion and Electron Beams (Dalian University of Technology), Ministry of Education, Dalian 116024, China. 3. Department of Physics, Applied Physics, and Astronomy, Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute, Troy, New York 12180, United States. 4. Chemical Sciences Division, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, California 94720, United States.
Abstract
Two-dimensional materials with excellent surface-volume ratios and massive reaction sites recently have been receiving attention for gas sensing. With first-principles calculations, we explored the performance of monolayer Sc2CF2 as a gas sensor. We investigated how molecule adsorption affects its electronic structure and optical properties. It is found that a large charge transfer quantity happens between Sc2CF2 and NO2, which results from the fact that the lowest unoccupied molecular orbital (LUMO) of NO2 is below the valence band maximum (VBM) of Sc2CF2. Moreover, the MD simulation shows that NO2 can adsorb on the Sc2CF2 surface stably at room temperature. We explored the effect of biaxial strain on the adsorption energy and charge transfer quantity of each system, and the results show that the biaxial strain can enhance both the adsorption energy and charge transfer quantity of the NO2 system and thus can improve the sensitivity of Sc2CF2 in detecting the NO2 molecule. Furthermore, we investigated the adsorption behavior and charge transfer of polar polyatomic molecules at the Sc2CF2 surface with h-BN as a substrate, and the results demonstrate that the h-BN substrate can hardly modify the main results. Our result predicts that Sc2CF2 can be a promising selective and sensitive sensor to detect the NO2 molecule, and could also give a theoretical guide for other terminated MXenes used for gas sensors or detectors.
Two-dimensional materials with excellent surface-volume ratios and massive reaction sites recently have been receiving attention for gas sensing. With first-principles calculations, we explored the performance of monolayer Sc2CF2 as a gas sensor. We investigated how molecule adsorption affects its electronic structure and optical properties. It is found that a large charge transfer quantity happens between Sc2CF2 and NO2, which results from the fact that the lowest unoccupied molecular orbital (LUMO) of NO2 is below the valence band maximum (VBM) of Sc2CF2. Moreover, the MD simulation shows that NO2 can adsorb on the Sc2CF2 surface stably at room temperature. We explored the effect of biaxial strain on the adsorption energy and charge transfer quantity of each system, and the results show that the biaxial strain can enhance both the adsorption energy and charge transfer quantity of the NO2 system and thus can improve the sensitivity of Sc2CF2 in detecting the NO2 molecule. Furthermore, we investigated the adsorption behavior and charge transfer of polar polyatomic molecules at the Sc2CF2 surface with h-BN as a substrate, and the results demonstrate that the h-BN substrate can hardly modify the main results. Our result predicts that Sc2CF2 can be a promising selective and sensitive sensor to detect the NO2 molecule, and could also give a theoretical guide for other terminated MXenes used for gas sensors or detectors.
Gas
sensors and detectors play an important role in environmental
protection and daily health safety applications. Because of the advantages
of low costs, metal oxides have been explored widely; however, they
require a high operating temperature.[1,2] With excellent
surface–volume ratios and massive reaction sites, a large number
of 2D materials including graphene,[3−5]h-BN,[6] phosphorene,[7−10] transition-metal chalcogenides,[11−13] and layered group III–VI semiconductors[14−17] have been reported with superior
performance for detecting gas.[18−21] Charge transfer happens when molecules are adsorbed
on 2D materials, and the charge transfer between molecules and 2D
materials will modify the electronic structures and/or resistance
of sensing materials by varying degrees. A copious amount of charge
transfer is required for high selectivity and sensitivity 2D sensing
materials.MXenes, including traditional metal carbides, nitrides,
and carbon-nitrides
with possible stoichiometric ratios of 2:1, 3:2, and 4:3, are a large
family of 2D materials,[22−24] which are usually synthesized
through chemical exfoliation from the MAX phase by etching the ″A″
atoms in acid solutions. Meanwhile, the intrinsic metallic surface
of MXenes is usually passivated or terminated by a function group,
and there consist four passivation models depending on function group
adsorption sites on both sides.[25−27] With a natural layered structure,
MXenes have been explored as high-performance electrode materials
in lithium-ion batteries.[28−32] For instance, bare Ti3C2 shows excellent theoretical
capacity and low Li-ion diffusing barrier,[30] and the rate performance of terminated Ti3C2 can be greatly enhanced after intercalation.[31,32] MXenes also find potential applications in other energy storage
aspects, like supercapacitors,[33−35] Li-S batteries,[36] and multivalent-ion batteries.[37−39] Owing to their
intrinsic metallic property, MXenes flakes, which have low average
resistivity and high electron mobility, also have been reported to
be used as a conductive channel in field-effect transistors, which
may construct an Ohmic contact.[40,41] Besides, low-thickness
Ti2CX2 films with a transmittance of about 90%
have been explored as transparent conductive electrodes.[42−44] It has also been reported that active sites for water redox exist
in MXenes, which also show suitable Gibbs free energy for hydrogen
adsorption and are electro-catalyst or photo-catalyst candidates for
water splitting.[45−47] MXenes have found promising application in various
fields.Besides, MXenes also have been explored as sensing materials
for
sensors or detectors. In terms of theoretical calculations, MXenes
have been widely explored for gas sensing. Density functional theory
(DFT) calculations demonstrated that bare MXenes are reactive, where
molecules’ dissociative adsorption happens at most surfaces,
and the selectivity is enhanced upon surface functionalization.[48] DFT calculations along with non-equilibrium
Green’s function (NEGF) method simulation predicted that O-terminated
Ti2C can detect NH3 sensitively with a strong
binding energy. A dramatic change of the I–V curve after NH3 adsorption determines the selectivity
of O-terminated Ti2C.[49] In addition,
applied strain can increase the binding energy and improve the sensitivity,
while releasing the strain or injecting an electron into MXenes will
weaken the strength and achieve reusability of sensing materials.[49,50] Similarly, it has been reported that SO2 can be detected
by Sc2CO2 with suitable adsorption energy. Moreover,
biaxial strain and external vertical electric field can help SO2 desorption from Sc2CO2.[51] In terms of experiments, Wang et al. have reported
that stacked Ti3C2TX molecular sieving
membranes exhibit excellent H2 permeability, which mainly
benefit from the sub-nanometer interlayer spacing between the neighboring
MXene nanosheets.[52] Stanciu et al. designed
a nanohybrid structure with MXene (Ti3C2TX) and transition metal dichalcogenide (WSe2), which
can adsorb oxygen species (O2– and O–) in air and exhibits good flexibility for O-containing
volatile organic compounds with low noise and fast response/recovery
speed.[53]To our best knowledge, MXenes
are potential candidates for gas
sensors. Here, we performed DFT calculations to explore the adsorption
of 11 common molecules on F-terminated Sc2C (Sc2CF2) and their charge transfer, which have not been studied
yet. We investigated how molecule adsorption affects their electronic
structure and optical properties. It is found that the largest charge
transfer quantity happens between Sc2CF2 and
NO2, which is because the lowest unoccupied molecular orbital
(LUMO) of NO2 is below the valence band maximum (VBM) of
Sc2CF2, although the adsorption energy is not
very large. The adsorption stability and sensitivity of Sc2CF2 sensing NO2 are demonstrated through molecular
dynamics simulation with an NVT ensemble, and applying biaxial strain
is claimed to be a promising method for enhancing the sensitivity
and selectivity. Besides, h-BN as a substrate can
hardly modify the adsorption energy and charge transfer at the polar
polyatomic molecules’ adsorption system and is a promising
substrate. These results indicate that F-terminated Sc2C is a good candidate for a NO2 gas sensor, and give a
theoretical guide for other terminated MXenes used for gas sensors
or detectors.
Results and Discussion
To simulate the Sc2CF2 monolayer exposed
in air, we place 11 common molecules on the surface of Sc2CF2, and several adsorption configurations, i.e., top,
bridge, and hollow sites of the three top F atoms, as well as the
vertical and parallel orientation of each molecule, are considered.
To characterize the interaction strength between the molecule and
the 2D sheet, we define the adsorption energy (Eads) as Eads= Etot – E2D – Egas, where Etot and E2D are the energies of the monolayer Sc2CF2 with and without adsorption of a gas molecule,
respectively; Egas is the energy of a
gas molecule in a cubic lattice with a lattice constant of 15 Å.
The most stable configurations and Eads for each molecule system are shown and listed in Figure and Table . The homo-nuclear diatomic molecules, like
H2, O2, and N2, will stay parallel
to the substrate, and the weakest interaction with Eads ranging from −0.07 to −0.09 eV per molecule
is found in these cases. The polar hetero-nuclear diatomic molecules,
like NO and CO, also remain parallel with Sc2CF2, and the Eads is also small; however,
it is a little stronger than that of the homo-nuclear diatomic molecule
(Eads = −0.13 and – 0.14
eV for NO and CO, respectively), which is due to the strong electronegativity
of the surface F atoms of the substrate. The CO2 molecule
has no polarity and contacts weakly with Sc2CF2. For polar polyatomic molecules (H2S, H2O,
SO2, NO2, and NH3), the adsorption
is much stronger. The Eads of H2O and H2S is −0.20 and – 0.18 eV per molecule,
respectively, and the H in both cases will favor staying at the top
of F, while the O in H2O tends to stay at the top of Sc
and S prefers the top of C. The NO2 is more likely to stand
vertically on the substrate, while SO2 prefers to lie parallel
on the surface. In the case of SO2 and NO2,
the O atoms favor to stay at the top or bridge of Sc. Actually, the
O atom from different molecules shares the same character in all cases.
The NH3 shows the strongest adsorption behavior with Eads of −0.39 eV and vertical distance
along the z direction of 1.54 Å. As shown in Figure , the NH3 molecule favors to stack parallel on the 2D sheets, with the N atom
staying at the top of Sc and three H atoms sharing symmetrically three
hollow sites of neighboring F atoms. The coupling between the nanosheet
and NH3 will change the bond angles of H–N–H
from 106.57 to 107.27°; meanwhile, the F atoms of nanosheets
near the adsorption site move slightly away from the original position
because the N partially shares the lone pair of electrons with Sc.
Figure 1
Most stable
adsorption configurations for 11 molecules (light gray
balls for Sc atoms, gray for C, light blue for F, white for H, dark
blue for N, red for O, and yellow for S). The upper panels are the
top view, and the lower panels are the side view of each molecule.
Table 1
Adsorption Energy per Unit Cell (Eads), Vertical Distances along z Direction (DZ), Average Distance to
the Parent Nanosheet (D), Charge Transfer (CT), Bandgaps
(Eg), Electron (me) and Hole (mh) Effective Mass, and Work
Function of Molecules Adsorbed on the Surface of Sc2CF2a
Eads (eV)
DZ (Å)
D (Å)
CT (10–3e)
Eg (eV)
me* (m0)
mh* (m0)
WF (eV)
bare
1.02
0.98
2.32
4.71
NH3
–0.39
1.54
2.53
–83.5
0.99
0.71
2.03
4.57
NO2
–0.21
2.33
2.93
100.3
0.99
0.90
2.13
5.17
SO2
–0.21
2.59
3.02
8.9
1.00
0.69
1.93
4.72
H2O
–0.20
1.81
2.24
–19.7
0.99
0.68
1.96
4.99
H2S
–0.18
2.28
2.38
–4.7
1.00
0.89
1.91
4.99
CO2
–0.16
2.57
3.04
4.6
1.01
0.90
2.18
4.73
CO
–0.14
2.66
3.13
–2.7
0.99
0.79
1.97
4.86
NO
–0.13
2.92
3.38
1.2
1.00
0.90
2.13
4.44
O2
–0.09
2.64
3.21
–1.7
0.99
0.81
1.92
4.99
H2
–0.07
2.28
2.64
–3.9
1.00
0.68
1.96
4.84
N2
–0.09
3.19
3.58
0.5
1.00
0.93
2.08
4.75
Negative CT values represent electron
transfer from molecules to the Sc2CF2 sheet.
Most stable
adsorption configurations for 11 molecules (light gray
balls for Sc atoms, gray for C, light blue for F, white for H, dark
blue for N, red for O, and yellow for S). The upper panels are the
top view, and the lower panels are the side view of each molecule.Negative CT values represent electron
transfer from molecules to the Sc2CF2 sheet.Once the molecule is adsorbed
on the surface, the electronic structures
of whole systems change and charge will redistribute between the molecule
and nanosheet. Bader charge calculations are performed to determine
the electron on each single atom so that we can see the charge transfer
quantity induced by the gas molecule adsorption. As shown in Table and Figure a, small amount of charge transfer
(0.0005–0.0046 e) has been found in diatomic
molecules and non-polar cases (N2, H2, O2, CO, NO, and CO2), and more charge transfer can
be found in polar polyatomic molecules. The H2S, H2O, and NH3 act as electron donors and transfer
0.0047, 0.0197, and 0.0835 e to Sc2CF2, respectively, while SO2 serves as an electron
acceptor and obtains 0.0087 e from Sc2CF2. Especially, the largest charge transfer happens at
the NO2 system, and NO2 takes 0.1003 electron
from 2D materials, although the vertical distance between NO2 and Sc2CF2 is larger than that of the NH3 system. Furthermore, we calculated the charge density difference
and projected it along the z direction as shown in Figure b. It can be seen
that the polar polyatomic molecules’ adsorption systems show
obvious oscillation at the interface region, especially the NH3, NO2, and H2O systems, which is consistent
with the result from Bader analysis. To show the details, the spatial
charge density difference for NO2 and NH3 adsorption
on the Sc2CF2 surface is plotted in Figure c,d, respectively.
In the case of NO2, all atoms at NO2 and even
the O atoms, which correspond with the three immediate neighboring
positive peaks at about 13.5, 14, and 14.5 Å in Figure b, will accept electrons from
the substrate and even from Sc atoms, which are located far away from
the interface (see Figure c). The adsorption of NO2 will induce a large interface
dipole at the interface region, with electron accumulation at the
NO2 molecule side and electron depletion at the substrate
side. As NH3 attaches on Sc2CF2,
electrons from the NH3 molecule orbital, which are mainly
from the three H atoms in Figure d and correspond with the large valley near 14 Å
in Figure b, transfer
into Sc2CF2 and mainly into F atoms at the interface
(see Figure d). Meanwhile,
the adsorption of NH3 will induce a surface dipole at Sc2CF2, with electron accumulation near the surface
of F atoms and electron depletion near Sc atoms at the subsurface.
In the case of H2O, H atoms still prefer to donate electrons,
which correspond the valley near 14.5 Å, and O atoms still like
to accept electrons, which correspond the peak near 13 Å in Figure b. In total, few
electrons will transfer from H2O into the substrate, which
also produces a small surface dipole at the surface of Sc2CF2. According to the transferred charge quantity, we
can see the selectivity of Sc2CF2 to detect
the NO2 molecule.
Figure 2
(a) Charge transfer from molecules to Sc2CF2 (calculated from Bader charge analysis). (b)
Planar average charge
density difference projected along the z direction.
Spatial charge density differences of (c) NO2 and (d) NH3 adsorbed on Sc2CF2 with an isosurface
of 0.05 e/Bohr3. The purple and magenta
regions indicate electron accumulation and depletion, respectively.
The arrow specifies the direction of electron transfer.
(a) Charge transfer from molecules to Sc2CF2 (calculated from Bader charge analysis). (b)
Planar average charge
density difference projected along the z direction.
Spatial charge density differences of (c) NO2 and (d) NH3 adsorbed on Sc2CF2 with an isosurface
of 0.05 e/Bohr3. The purple and magenta
regions indicate electron accumulation and depletion, respectively.
The arrow specifies the direction of electron transfer.To explain the physical causes of charge transfer, we calculated
the band structures and density of states (DOS) of the adsorption
system and extracted individual contributions of the molecule and
substrate. Figure show the results for NH3, SO2, NO, and NO2 adsorption systems. Several flat bands appear after adsorption,
whose position has a close relationship with the alignment of frontier
molecular orbitals of molecules and bands of pristine Sc2CF2. The isolated NH3 molecule has a HOMO–LUMO
gap of 5.4 eV from DFT calculation. Both the HOMO and LUMO of isolated
NH3 are far away from the VBM and conduction band minimum
(CBM) of pristine Sc2CF2; thus, the flat bands
of the NH3 adsorption system stay away from the Fermi level.
However, the shortest vertical distance between NH3 and
Sc2CF2 makes the strongest wave-function mixing
or electronic state coupling, which induces the large peaks at the
energy range from −2.5 to −0.3 eV at the partial DOS
plot in Figure a.
The strongest wave-function coupling opens a charge transfer channel,
which results in a large amount of charge transfer between NH3 and Sc2CF2. For the SO2 adsorption
system, the LUMO of the molecule is located at the forbidden band
region of Sc2CF2, while the HOMO is located
at the deep valance band region as seen from Figure c. The vertical distance is longer than that
of the NH3 system; thus, there is less wave-function mixing,
demonstrating much less charge transfer. For open-cell NO, the half-filled
doubly degenerated antibonding HOMO (2π orbital with spin-up),
together with its spin-split partner unoccupied LUMO (2π orbital
with spin-down), becomes non-degenerated because of the symmetry breaking
after contacting with the substrate. We named the non-degenerated
HOMO orbital at the higher energy as HOMO1 and the other
as HOMO2, and the non-degenerated LUMO at the lower energy
level as LUMO1 and the other as LUMO2 for convenience.
The two HOMO orbitals are mid-gap states after adsorption, and the
initial empty HOMO1 stays above the Fermi level. As a polar
hetero-nuclear diatomic molecule, the Eads of NO is pretty small, which means weak wave-function mixing and
is consistent with the small amount of charge transfer from the Bader
calculation. It should be noticed that HOMO1 is still contributed
from electrons of spin-up while HOMO2 is contributed from
electrons of spin-down, which is totally different from the isolated
NO molecule, indicating the large decrease of magnetic moment after
adsorption (from 1 to 0.06 μB). The case of the NO2 adsorption system is very different from the three cases above,
where the LUMO (6a1 molecule arbitral with spin-down) of
NO2 is located below the VBM of Sc2CF2; thus, a large amount charge will transfer from the substrate to
NO2 to fill the LUMO orbital of NO2. The valance
band at some K points of the NO2 adsorption
system is partially occupied or even unoccupied, and metal behaviors
indicate a total change of the electronic structure after NO2 adsorption. Besides, the charge transfer between the Sc2CF2 substrate and paramagnetic NO2 also reduces
the magnetic moment of the whole system by 0.91 μB.
Figure 3
Band structures
and projected DOS of (a) NH3, (b) NO2, (c) SO2, and (d) NO adsorption systems. In the
left panels, the gray lines are the band structure of the whole system,
and the Fermi level is set as 0. The blue spheres correspond to the
states with valid contribution from molecules, and the radii of spheres
are proportional to the weight. In the middle and right panels, the
dark gray lines filled with gray solid pattern are the total DOS of
systems, and the blue lines are the PDOS of the molecules.
Band structures
and projected DOS of (a) NH3, (b) NO2, (c) SO2, and (d) NO adsorption systems. In the
left panels, the gray lines are the band structure of the whole system,
and the Fermi level is set as 0. The blue spheres correspond to the
states with valid contribution from molecules, and the radii of spheres
are proportional to the weight. In the middle and right panels, the
dark gray lines filled with gray solid pattern are the total DOS of
systems, and the blue lines are the PDOS of the molecules.The rest electronic structure information of the molecules
is summarized
in Table . The bandgap
after adsorption does not change much according to Table ; however, the effective mass
changes because of the wave-function mixing. For instance, the orbital
of SO2 couples more strongly with the conduction band of
Sc2CF2 (Figure c), and the effective mass of the hole changes by 0.39 m0. Besides, the effective mass of both electrons
and holes decreases for each adsorption case, which means the increasing
of carrier mobility. It is worth noting that the work function after
NO2 adsorption increases by 0.46 eV, which is even larger
than what has been reported for graphene.[58]Furthermore, we explored the optical properties for each system,
which may be useful in optical chemistry gas sensors. The imaginary
part of dielectric function and adsorption coefficient are plotted
at Figure . At the
range of visible light, little change can be found except for a slight
intensity decrease and negligible red-shift of the main peaks. However,
a clear difference occurs at the ultraviolet range. There are two
major absorption peaks (located at 5.3 and 9.4 eV) at the ultraviolet
range for pristine Sc2CF2. The intensity of
the peak located around 5.3 eV is greatly enhanced after molecules
adsorbed at each adsorption system, especially for the case of NO2. Meanwhile, an evident blue-shift happens, and the corresponding
peak at the NO2 system moves into around 5.7 eV. The other
peak around 9.4 eV changes little except for a slight red-shift. More
importantly, the adsorption of each molecule induces a new peak around
9.9 eV, and the NO2 system shows the strongest absorption
intensity here. It should also be noted that the adsorption of NO2 induces two additional peaks, which are located around 0.1
and 7.0 eV, respectively. The peak of 0.1 eV has a direct relationship
with the partial occupied or unoccupied states near VBM. The quite
different optical properties after NO2 adsorption indicate
the potential application of Sc2CF2 as a NO2 optical chemistry sensor.
Figure 4
Imaginary part of dielectric function
for the polarization vector
perpendicular to the surface and absorption coefficient of Sc2CF2 systems with and without molecules adsorbed
on the surface.
Imaginary part of dielectric function
for the polarization vector
perpendicular to the surface and absorption coefficient of Sc2CF2 systems with and without molecules adsorbed
on the surface.In the aspect of electronic and
optical structures, we have found
the selectivity of Sc2CF2 to detect NO2. To explore the adsorption thermal stability of NO2 at
the Sc2CF2 surface, we performed ab
initio molecular dynamics (MD) simulations with an NVT ensemble
at a temperature of 300 K for about 11 ps. The time evolution of vertical
distances between each atom of NO2 and the top F atom layer
of Sc2CF2 is summarized in Figure a, in which two O atoms of
NO2 are labeled as O-1 and O-2 to distinguish them. During
the MD process, the Sc2CF2 layer prefers to
contact with O atoms (O-1 or O-2) of the NO2 molecule,
and the smallest vertical distance is maintained at the range of 2–4
Å. Compared with the initial structure, the system changes most
at time 5.1 ps, when the vertical distance of N, O-1, and O-2 reaches
up to 4.35, 5.49, and 3.72 Å, respectively. However, the NO2 molecule bounces back rapidly, and the vertical distance
of N, O-1, and O-2 becomes 3.18, 3.11, and 2.33 Å at time 5.7
ps, respectively. From the MD simulation, it can be seen that the
NO2 molecule only vibrates around its equilibrium positions,
revealing that NO2 can adsorb on the 2D surface stably
at room temperature.
Figure 5
(a) Evolution of vertical distances for each atom of NO2 with the top F layer of Sc2CF2 at first-principles
molecule dynamics simulations. Snapshot of the NO2 adsorption
system at time of (b) 0 ps, (c) 5.1 ps, (d) 6.9 ps, and (e) 11.1 ps,
respectively.
(a) Evolution of vertical distances for each atom of NO2 with the top F layer of Sc2CF2 at first-principles
molecule dynamics simulations. Snapshot of the NO2 adsorption
system at time of (b) 0 ps, (c) 5.1 ps, (d) 6.9 ps, and (e) 11.1 ps,
respectively.Strain modulation is reported
as an effective method to improve
the performance of 2D materials. A uniaxial strain can be applied
through bending, rolling up, and elongation in experiments, and a
homogeneous biaxial strain can also been applied into 2D materials
through a substrate that has a different thermal expansion coefficient
with 2D materials or a substrate that is a piezoelectric material.[59−62] Most 2D materials have a fracture strain value over or about 10%,[63−66] and we enlarge the lattice of the Sc2CF2 substrate
by 1–9% to explore the strain effect on adsorption energy and
sensitivity. As shown in Figure , the adsorption of NO2, NH3,
and H2O changes the most, and other systems are not sensitive
to biaxial strain. As biaxial strain increases, the Eads’s of NH3 and H2O increase
monotonously. For the strained NO2 system, the Eads’s start to increase with strain up
to 4%, and the increase rate is much larger than that of both NH3 and H2O. As we all know, the adsorption energy
can be influenced by the polarity of the molecules at gas molecule
adsorption systems, and the polar molecule usually shows a larger
adsorption energy than the nonpolar molecules as we discussed above.
Besides, the atoms at the surface and subsurface should also have
an effect on the adsorption energy. For instance, the well-saturated
surfaces usually prefer to adsorb no molecule or adsorb molecules
weakly, while the surfaces with unsaturated bonds usually like to
adsorb molecules more strongly. When biaxial strain is applied, the
symmetry of Sc2CF2 is destroyed to some degree
and becomes not so well-saturated, and the adsorption of molecules
will be enhanced. Thus, strain modulation is an effective method to
improve the adsorption energy and sensitivity. We also explored the
effect of biaxial strain on charge transfer, as shown in Figure . Different from
the adsorption energy, the charge transfer is not sensitive to strain
even for the NO2 system with strain less than 3%, and it
seems that the charge transfer has no direct relationship with the
adsorption energy for each molecule adsorption system. The charge
transfer is on one hand affected by the distance between them, and
a smaller distance usually results in a large charge transfer. On
the other hand, the electron state coupling will also make a great
contribution, and the molecular orbitals of gas molecules, which have
a similar energy level with the electron states of Sc2CF2, are the charge transfer channel. The biaxial strain can
hardly change the molecular orbitals; thus, we can see that the charge
transfer is not sensitive to biaxial strain for most systems. However,
in the case of NO2 adsorption, the LUMO of NO2 is very close with the VBM of Sc2CF2. To demonstrate
the effect of strain on charge transfer in the case of NO2, we further explored the band structures of the NO2 adsorption
system with a biaxial strain of 1, 4, and 7%, as shown in Figure S2 of the Supporting Information. It can
be seen that the band structures, mainly the band (molecule orbital)
alignment, are modified much with biaxial strain. When there is no
strain, the alignment is type III, with the LUMO of NO2 below the VBM of Sc2CF2. The alignment becomes
type II with the LUMO of NO2 moving up above the VBM of
Sc2CF2 once strain is 1% at Sc2CF2. The band structure of 4% biaxial strain is similar with
that of 1%; however, the band structure is altered much when strain
continues increasing. When strain is 7%, the alignment reverts into
type III with the LUMO of NO2 below the VBM of Sc2CF2, which is due to the large biaxial strain breaking
the lattice symmetry of the Sc2CF2 substrate
and thus modifying the electronic structure of Sc2CF2 near the band edge. In total, biaxial strain can enhance
both the adsorption energy and charge transfer for the NO2 adsorption system and is an effective method to improve the sensitivity
and selectivity of Sc2CF2 to detect the NO2 molecule.
Figure 6
The transferred charge and adsorption energy of each system
when
applied with biaxial strain from 1 to 9%.
The transferred charge and adsorption energy of each system
when
applied with biaxial strain from 1 to 9%.Under real situations, 2D materials are typically supported by
a substrate, which influences their electronic properties as well
as the adsorption of molecules on their surface. SiO2 is
a common substrate for 2D material applications in electronics or
optoelectronics, which is cheap, flat, and chemically inert. However,
SiO2 really can give a great effect on the properties of
2D materials, and some researchers try to use h-BN
as a substrate or use h-BN as a substrate on top
of SiO2/Si, which will reduce the effect of SiO2.[67,68] Here, we considered h-BN
as a substrate for Sc2CF2 and explored the effect
of h-BN. The lattice constant of h-BN after optimization is 2.41 Å. We used a 3 × 3 Sc2CF2 supercell to match with 4 × 4 h-BN vertically as shown in Figure a, and the mismatch is about 1.43%. After
optimization, Sc2CF2 is still flat and there
exists some buckling in h-BN, which however still
maintains the honeycomb structure from the top view. It can be seen
from the projected band structure of Sc2CF2/h-BN heterostructures in Figure b that the electronic structure of Sc2CF2 can be hardly affected by the h-BN substrate, and a type III band alignment is found. Then we considered
four polar polyatomic molecules, that is, NO2, NH3, SO2, and H2O, adsorbed at the surface of
Sc2CF2/h-BN. The calculated Eads and charge transfer from Bader charge analysis
are also plotted in Figure c. Here, we used a 3 × 3 supercell, which is a little
different from the model before and may have an effect on the value
of Eads and charge transfer. However,
the trends of both the adsorption energy and charge transfer are not
modulated. The NH3 shows the largest adsorption energy,
and the Eads of NO2, NH3, and SO2 is about 0.21 eV. The largest charge
transfer occurs in the case of NO2, and NH3 shows
more charge transfer than both H2O and SO2.
Furthermore, we calculated the projected band structures for four
adsorption systems with the h-BN substrate as shown
in Figure S3 in the Supporting Information.
In total, the relative position of the molecular orbital with bands
of Sc2CF2 changes little, and the LUMO of NO2 is still partially occupied after absorption, which induces
a large amount of charge transfer. These results demonstrate that
the h-BN substrate can hardly affect the main results
from calculations with a free-standing Sc2CF2. Also note that we considered a pristine Sc2CF2 layer here and the charge transfer will always enhance the carrier
density. However, the defect is inevitable in experiments. If the
presence of defects makes Sc2CF2 show n-type/p-type
conductivity, the carrier density and conductivity do not depend on
the charge transfer only. The electron/hole transfer into Sc2CF2 will improve/decrease the n-type conductivity, and
the hole/electron transfer into Sc2CF2 will
improve/decrease the p-type conductivity. Thus, the predicted obvious
selectivity and sensitivity of Sc2CF2 to detect
NO2 still need to be confirmed by future experiments.
Figure 7
(a) Atomic
structures of the Sc2CF2/h-BN
supercell: top view (upper) and side view (lower);
pink balls are B atoms, and blue balls are N atoms. (b) Projected
band structure of the Sc2CF2/h-BN supercell: gray parts are the contribution from Sc2CF2, and orange parts are the contribution from h-BN. (c) Charge transfer and adsorption energy of NO2, NH3, SO2, and H2O adsorbed
on the surface of Sc2CF2 with h-BN as a substrate.
(a) Atomic
structures of the Sc2CF2/h-BN
supercell: top view (upper) and side view (lower);
pink balls are B atoms, and blue balls are N atoms. (b) Projected
band structure of the Sc2CF2/h-BN supercell: gray parts are the contribution from Sc2CF2, and orange parts are the contribution from h-BN. (c) Charge transfer and adsorption energy of NO2, NH3, SO2, and H2O adsorbed
on the surface of Sc2CF2 with h-BN as a substrate.
Conclusions
In summary, we have studied several molecules’ adsorption
behaviors on Sc2CF2 and explored the charge
transfer between molecules and Sc2CF2. Using
first-principles calculations, we have investigated the structural,
electronic, and optical properties of adsorption systems. The results
show that the largest charge transfer quantity happens between NO2 and Sc2CF2, and optical properties
of the system are modified by the NO2 molecule obviously,
both of which are due to the special electronic structure, where the
LUMO of NO2 is below the VBM of Sc2CF2. Thus, Sc2CF2 can detect the NO2 molecule selectively. Moreover, the MD simulation shows that NO2 can adsorb on the Sc2CF2 surface stably
at room temperature. Besides, we explored the effect of biaxial strain
on the Eads and charge transfer quantity
of each system, and the result shows that the biaxial strain can enhance
both adsorption energy and charge transfer and improve the sensitivity
of Sc2CF2 to detect the NO2 molecule.
Furthermore, we investigated how h-BN will affect
the adsorption behavior and charge transfer, revealing that the h-BN is a potential substrate for Sc2CF2 sensors. Our result predicts that Sc2CF2 can
be a promising selective and sensitive sensor to detect the NO2 molecule.
Computational Details
All first-principles calculations were carried out using the Vienna
Ab initio Simulation Package (VASP)[54] based
on DFT with a plane-wave basis set. To treat the exchange–correlation
interaction of electrons, we chose the Perdew–Burke–Ernzerhof
(PBE) functional[55] within the generalized
gradient approximation (GGA). The electron–ion interactions
were described by the projector augmented wave (PAW) potentials.[56] The energy cutoff for the plane-wave basis was
chosen as 600 eV, and the Brillouin zones (BZs) were sampled by k grids with a uniform spacing of 2π × 0.02 Å–1. Convergence criteria of 10–4 eV
for total energy and 0.01 eV/Å for force were adopted for self-consistent
calculation and geometry optimization, respectively. We chose a 4
× 4 supercell to simulate the periodic structure of Sc2CF2 monolayers, and a vacuum spacing of 20 Å was
added along the direction perpendicular to the 2D sheet (z direction) to avoid interaction between adjacent layers. To properly
describe the van der Waals interaction between gas molecules and the
Sc2CF2 sheet, we adopted the semi-empirical
dispersion-corrected DFT-D3 scheme proposed by Grimme.[57] Spin polarization was included for the systems
adsorbed by paramagnetic molecules like NO, NO2, and O2. Dipole correction was added in the average potential calculation
for the system adsorbed by polar molecules. Various initial configurations
with different adsorption sites and molecule orientations of the gas
molecules were considered here. The initial distance between the gas
molecule and 2D nanosheet was chosen to be 2.0 Å.
Authors: Joseph Halim; Maria R Lukatskaya; Kevin M Cook; Jun Lu; Cole R Smith; Lars-Åke Näslund; Steven J May; Lars Hultman; Yury Gogotsi; Per Eklund; Michel W Barsoum Journal: Chem Mater Date: 2014-02-28 Impact factor: 9.811