| Literature DB >> 35334613 |
María Dolores González-Gutiérrez1, Álvaro López-Garrido2, Irene Cortés-Pérez3,4, Esteban Obrero-Gaitán3, Felipe León-Morillas5, Alfonso Javier Ibáñez-Vera3.
Abstract
Background andEntities:
Keywords: capacitive–resistive therapy; diathermy; dielectric; pelvic floor disorders; pelvic floor dysfunction; pelvic pain; radiofrequency
Mesh:
Year: 2022 PMID: 35334613 PMCID: PMC8951766 DOI: 10.3390/medicina58030437
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Medicina (Kaunas) ISSN: 1010-660X Impact factor: 2.430
Bibliographic search strategy used in each database.
| DATABASES | SEARCH STRATEGY |
|---|---|
| PubMed Medline | (radiofrequency therapy [mh] OR radiofrequency therapy [tiab] OR “radiofrequency” [tiab] OR hyperthermia, induced [mh] OR hyperthermia, induced [tiab] OR induced hyperthermia [tiab] OR diathermy [mh] OR diathermy [tiab] OR capacitive–resistive therapy [tiab] OR dielectric radiofrequency [tiab] OR dielectric radiofrequency therapy [tiab]) AND (pelvic floor [mh] or pelvic floor [tiab] OR pelvic floor disorders [mh] OR pelvic floor disorders [tiab] OR pelvic floor diseases [tiab] OR pelvic floor dysfunction [tiab] OR urogenital diseases [mh] OR urogenital diseases [tiab] OR female urogenital diseases [tiab]) |
| SCOPUS | (TITLE-ABS-KEY ((“radiofrequency” OR “diathermy” OR “capacitive–resistive” OR “hyperthermia”)) AND TITLE-ABS-KEY ((“pelvic floor” OR “pelvic floor disorders” OR “pelvic floor diseases” OR “female urogenital diseases” OR “pelvic floor dysfunction”))) |
| Web of Science | TS = ((* radiofrequency * OR * diathermy * OR * capacitive–resistive * OR * dielectric * OR * hyperthermia *)) AND TS = ((* pelvic floor * OR * pelvic floor disorders * OR * pelvic floor diseases * OR * female urogenital diseases * OR * pelvic floor dysfunction *)) |
Figure 1Flow diagram of the study search.
Summary of the randomized controlled trials selected.
| Author, Year | Study | Disorder |
| Outcomes | Intervention | Results | PEDro |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bretelle et al., 2020 | RCT | Postpartum perineal pain | 60 EG(29) CG(31) | Perineal Pain (VAS), discomfort while walking and sitting (yes/no), analgesic intake | EG: 15′ of RFD (range 300–500 KHz) 1st and 2nd day of postpartum; CG: the same but sham therapy | Improvements in discomfort while walking and analgesic Intake in favor of experimental group, not in perineal pain (VAS) | 5/10 |
| Krychman et al., 2017 | RCT | Sexual function | 186 EG(123) CG(63) | Sexual function (FSFI, FSDS-R) | EG: cooled RFD (90 J/cm2); CG: RFD (1 J/cm2) | Improvements of 1.8 points in FSFI ( | 6/10 |
| Pavone et al., 2017 | RCT | Peyronie’s disease | 96 EG(64) CG(32) | Erectile function (IIEF-5), quality of life (SF-36), pain during erection (VAS), penis curvature (°) | EG: 3 sessions (in 3 days) 5–8′ CAP (45%W) and 3′ RES (40%W); CG: the same without energy transfer | 2-point (VAS) reduction in pain during erection ( | 5/10 |
| Lordelo et al., 2016 | RCT | Sexual function | 43 EG(21) CG(22) | Sexual function (FSFI) | EG: 8 sessions of RFD (7 days between session). RFD applied until tissue reached 39–41 °C, then 2′ more of treatment; CG: previously heated gel with no emission | 3.51 points (FSFI) of improvement for experimental group ( | 7/10 |
| Leibaschoff et al., 2016 | RCT | Menopausal Urinary Symptoms | 20 EG(10) CG(10) | Stress urinary incontinence (UDI-6, ICQ-SF UI), dyspareunia and dryness (VAS); Vaginal Health (VHI) | EG: 3–5′ RFD 40–45°; CG: sham RFD (the same without any heat) | Improvements in ICQ-SF UI and UDI-6 ( | 5/10 |
Abbreviations: n: sample size; RFD: radiofrequency diathermy; RCT: randomized controlled trial; EG: experimental group; CG: control group; VAS: visual analogue scale; FSFI: Female Sexual Function Index; FSDS-R: Revised Female Sexual Distress Scale; °: goniometer degrees; IIEF-5: International Index of Erectile Function; SF-36: SF-36 Health Survey; UDI-6: Urogenital Distress Inventory; ICQ-SF UI: International Consultation on Incontinence Questionnaire—Urinary Incontinence Short Form; VHI: Vaginal Health Index; KHz: kilohertz; ′: minutes; CAP: capacitive; RES: resistive.
Summary of the other design of studies considered of interest.
| Author, Year | Study | Disorder |
| Outcomes | Intervention | Results | NOS |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fortún et al., 2022 | Case series | Endometriosis-related pain | 5 | Sex interference (EHP), MTP, pain (VAS), allodynia, neuropathic pain component (DN4) | 25 RFD sessions along 3 menstrual cycles, 30′ per session | Improvements in sex interference, dysmenorrhea intensity, myofascial and referral pain. | *** |
| Razaghi et al. 2021 | Case series | Stress urinary incontinence | 28 | Urinary incontinence (I-QOL, Q-tip test, 24 h pad test) | Once a week for 3 weeks, 10′ heating at 40 °C the vaginal wall (pulsed emission at 20–40 w and 1000–300 kHz) | Significant improvements in I-QOL score and the pad test | ** |
| Fernández-Cuadros et al., 2020 | Prospective study | Women chronic pelvic pain and dyspareunia | 37 | Pain (VAS), pelvic floor muscles strength (mmHg) | 8 session of pelvic floor muscles therapeutic exercise and 15′ RFD (5′capacitive +10′resistive) | Improvements in pain (3.52 VAS points) and muscle strength (both | *** |
| Dayan et al., 2019 | Case series | Postpartum restoration | 50 | Pelvic muscle tone and maximal contraction (biofeedback device) | 2 ( | Improvement in maximal pelvic floor contraction, no changes in tone | *** |
| Sodre et al., 2019 | One-arm clinical trial | Men urinary incontinence after radical prostatectomy | 10 | Pelvic floor muscular strength unidigital introduction (OGS), urinary incontinence (ICIQ-SF and ICIQ-OAB) | Endoanal RFD at 1 MHz and 3–4 kilojoules, 41 °C temperature (once temperature was reached, application stayed for 2′) | Decrease in urinary loss ( | *** |
| Wilson et al., 2018 | Non-randomized trial | Women stress urinary incontinence and orgasmic dysfunction | 10 | Sexual satisfaction (MSSQ and FSFI) | 3 RFD at 4-week intervals, 30′ per session at a temperature of 42–45 °C | Non-significative Improvements in stress urinary incontinence nor orgasmic dysfunction | * |
| Caruth et al., 2018 | Case series | Women urinary incontinence | 30 | Urinary incontinence (ICIQ-UI and IIQ), pelvic floor impact (PFIQ-7) | RFD in vaginal canal: Group 1 (16–20′), Group 2 (10–12′), Group 3 (6–8′), 43 °C maximum | Improvements for all outcomes at two months follow-up ( | * |
| Lordelo et al., 2017 | Case series | Women stress urinary incontinence | 10 | Pelvic floor muscular strength unidigital introduction (OGS), urinary loss (pad test) | Urethral meatus RFD, once per week along 5 weeks, 39–41 °C temperature (once temperature was reached, application stayed for 2′) | General improvement ( | *** |
| Vicariotto et al., 2016 | Case series | Premenopausal and postmenopausal symptoms | 25 | Urinary incontinence (PISQ-12) | Four 10′ sessions of RFD, one each 10 days | Improvements in self-perceived dysuria/urinary incontinence and sexual function | * |
| Alinsod et al., 2016 | Case series | Women orgasmic dysfunction | 25 | Self-perceived time to orgasm | Three 25′ sessions of RFD in a month, elevating temperature between 40 and 45 °C on clitoris region | Reduction of 50% in time to orgasm | - |
Abbreviations. n: sample size; NOS: Newcastle and Ottawa Scale; EHP: Endometriosis Health Profile; MTP: myofascial trigger points; VAS: Visual analogue scale; ICIQ-SF: International Consultation on Incontinence Questionnaire Form; PISQ-12: Urinary incontinence sexual questionnaire; ICIQ-OAB: International Consultation on Incontinence Questionnaire Overactive Bladder; ICIQ-UI: International Consultation on Incontinence Questionnaire—Urinary Incontinence; OGS: Oxford Grading Scale; MSSQ: Millheiser Sexual Satisfaction Questionnaire; FSFI: Female Sexual Function Index; PFIQ-7: short version of Pelvic Floor Impact Questionnaire; IIQ: short form of Incontinence Impact Questionnaire; *: number of stars obtained in NOS.