| Literature DB >> 35296478 |
Harbinder Kaur Sandhu1, Jane Shaw2, Dawn Carnes3, Andrea D Furlan4,5, Colin Tysall6,7, Henry Adjei8, Chockalingam Muthiah8, Jennifer Noyes2, Nicole K Y Tang9, Stephanie Jc Taylor3, Martin Underwood8,10, Adrian Willis8, Sam Eldabe2.
Abstract
OBJECTIVES: To describe the design, development and pilot of a multicomponent intervention aimed at supporting withdrawal of opioids for people with chronic non-malignant pain for future evaluation in the Improving the Wellbeing of people with Opioid Treated CHronic pain (I-WOTCH) randomised controlled trial.Entities:
Keywords: clinical trials; medical education & training; pain management; primary care; rehabilitation medicine
Mesh:
Substances:
Year: 2022 PMID: 35296478 PMCID: PMC8928279 DOI: 10.1136/bmjopen-2021-053725
Source DB: PubMed Journal: BMJ Open ISSN: 2044-6055 Impact factor: 2.692
Figure 1Stages of Improving the Wellbeing of people with Opioid Treated CHronic pain (I-WOTCH) intervention development. NIHR, National Institute for Health Research; RCT, randomised controlled trial.
Figure 2Reducing opioids for people with chronic non-malignant pain.
Feedback from PPI informing intervention development
| Discussion topic | Feedback informing intervention development |
| Behaviour change | Agreed aims should be a reduction in opioid consumption and engagement in the I-WOTCH programme. |
| Understanding motivation to change behaviour | Changing medication and reducing medication can be motivated by: (i) a trade-off to fill the deficit of the effect of the drug (something else needed that is as effective as the drug they would lose) (ii) reduction in side effects |
| Content and topics to be covered | The intervention would benefit from being informative (opioid education, especially long-term consequences, pros and cons of opioid use and managing withdrawal). What is pain Acceptance—pain and learning to live better with pain Impact of pain – and integrate this information with taking medication (Opioids), why and how? The importance of hobbies and having a distraction to manage the pain Offer alternative non-pharmacological ways of coping, for example, mindfulness and relaxation Incorporate movement Guidance on posture and exercise/activity Pacing—not over doing things |
| Dependency versus addiction | It was felt important to distinguish between dependency and addiction, as some were concerned about the stigma and labels attached to long-term opioid use for chronic pain. |
| Delivery of I-WOTCH Intervention, who? | Feedback favoured the course to be delivered jointly by a HCP and a lay facilitator (someone who had experience of long-term pain and opioid use/tapering). |
| Structure of intervention | Group and individual care approaches were valued. |
| Communication during study | Volunteers welcomed the idea of having a study website to give participants an opportunity to be updated about the study as a whole and progress. |
HCP, healthcare professional; I-WOTCH, Improving the Wellbeing of people with Opioid Treated CHronic pain.
Behaviour change taxonomy and opioid tapering
| I-WOTCH group based sessions day 1 (week 1) | Aims | Theoretical underpinnings | Behaviour change taxonomy |
| Introductions, group work, aims | To allow participants to introduce themselves to the group, encourage participation in a safe and relaxed environment, explore expectations and discuss the I-WOTCH course aims | Social cognitive theory | Improve bonding and group cohesion. |
| What causes pain? (pain information) | To increase understanding about long-term pain | Biopsychosocial theory | Credible source |
| Living with pain (Opioid education I) | To increase understanding about use of opioids for long-term pain and encourage participants to start questioning their own knowledge and beliefs about opioids and why they take them | Biopsychosocial theory | Information about health consequences |
| Acceptance | To understand and start to accept pain, with a view to implementing self-management strategies as reduction of opioids occurs | Acceptance and | Goal setting |
| Attention control and distraction | To learn how to focus the mind away from pain thoughts and use of opioids | Cognitive–behavioural change | Distraction |
| Distraction activity—drawing | An opportunity to practise distraction activity and socially interact with group informally | Cognitive–behavioural change | Behavioural practice |
| Good days, bad days—pain, bearable or not? | To reinforce that pain is not just physiological, it is a psychological, social and an emotional phenomenon | Biopsychosocial theory | Information and antecedents |
| The pain cycle (including opioids) and breaking the pain cycle | To explain and identify unhelpful factors in the pain cycle and learn strategies to break the cycle | Biopsychosocial theory | Behaviour substitution (adding in other behaviours to break cycle) |
| Posture and movement | To promote body awareness, posture and muscle weakness | Theory of planned behaviour and reasoned action | Guidelines on exercise, physical therapy principles |
| Relaxation and breathing | To reduce muscle tension and introduce breathing as a relaxation technique | Cognitive—behavioural change | Behavioural practice |
| Summary of the day | To consolidate learning of the day and outline aims for group day 2. | Acceptance and principles of self-efficacy | Action planning |
Feedback and changes pilot phases I and II: training
| Feedback (pilot phase I and II)—training and facilitator feedback | Changes implemented |
| Facilitators agreed it is useful to go through the manual step by step, to gain familiarity with each component and navigate through the different stages. They preferred this rather than going through generic topics. | We incorporated this information into the training and prior to a group being delivered, if needed the study team helped to arrange meetings between the facilitators. |
| Facilitators felt it would be useful for all material to be emailed prior to the training to allow time for familiarisation with the manual. | Throughout the I-WOTCH study all course materials were sent to facilitators prior to training. |
| Facilitators suggested that during the training it would be useful to actually practice some of the sessions. | Where possible during the training days we incorporated case studies and role play, as well as experiential learning of mindfulness and using the tapering app to calculate opioid reduction doses. |
| Facilitators suggested that it would be useful if the course slides were numbered in correspondence to the sections in the manual. | All course slides were numbered and added to the manual for reference. |
| Facilitators also suggested that it would be useful to include the rationale for each topic into the manual, as it helped with their understanding of each topic and with their explanation to participants. | The rationale for each topic was included in the manual. |
I-WOTCH, Improving the Wellbeing of people with Opioid Treated CHronic pain.
Feedback and changes pilot phases I and II: course content and structure
| Feedback (pilot phase I and II) participant feedback | Changes implemented |
| During pilot phase I, feedback favoured spreading the group sessions over 3 weeks (one group day per week). This was to help with consolidation of information and learning between sessions and also felt less burdensome. | In the I-WOTCH study, groups were delivered with this format (every Monday where possible for 3 weeks). |
| It was suggested the balance session worked well after the session on posture, to allow more understanding and connection with body. | This was changed in the I-WOTCH programme: balance and stretch was introduced on day 2 of the programme and posture and movement on day 1 of the programme. |
| Day 1 presented a lot of educational information on opioids and it was suggested to split this over 2 days to help support consolidation of understanding | The educational information was split over 2 days (day 1 and day 2 of the programme). |
| It was also suggested to move the session on pacing to after the pain cycle has been discussed, to help with the understanding of why pacing is important and can help break the unhelpful cycle. | The pain cycle was introduced and on day 1 of the programme and pacing was moved to day two of the programme. |
| During pilot phase I, patients welcomed an educational DVD to help with the learning. | As part of the I-WOTCH study, we produced an I-WOTCH education DVD which is used in the delivery of the programme, participants are able to then take this home and watch with their family and friends or keep as a resource for themselves. |
I-WOTCH, Improving the Wellbeing of people with Opioid Treated CHronic pain.
Figure 3Final model of Improving the Wellbeing of people with Opioid Treated CHronic pain (I-WOTCH) intervention.