| Literature DB >> 35264237 |
Erika Yue Lee1,2, Stephen Betschel3,4, Eyal Grunebaum5,4.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Non-infectious complications have become a major cause of morbidity and mortality in patients with Common Variable Immunodeficiency (CVID). The monitoring of patients with CVID prior to the development of non-infectious complications is not well defined.Entities:
Keywords: Adults; CVID; Children; Common Variable Immunodeficiency; Monitoring; Screening; Uncomplicated
Year: 2022 PMID: 35264237 PMCID: PMC8908590 DOI: 10.1186/s13223-022-00661-7
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Allergy Asthma Clin Immunol ISSN: 1710-1484 Impact factor: 3.406
Fig. 1Flowchart showing search strategies and selection of studies
Fig. 2Levels of Evidence for Prognostic Studies (top) and Grade Practice Recommendations (bottom) [14]
Frequency and modality of monitoring in patients with uncomplicated CVID by studies
| No | Study and Level of Evidence | Clinical assessment | Laboratory testing | Chest imaging | Abdominal imaging | PFT |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Quinti et al. [ Expert’s opinion Level V. Grade D | Not mentioned | Every 3 months: Ig, CBC, lymphocyte subsets, chemistries, culture tests | Every 4 years: CT chest and sinus | Every 1 year: AUS Every 2 years: upper endoscopy | Not mentioned |
| 2 | Cunningham-Rundles [ Expert’s opinion Level V. Grade D | Every 12 months | Every 6–12 months: Ig Every 12 months: CBC, chemistry, albumin, creatinine, liver enzymes | Baseline then as needed: HRCT is preferred | Not mentioned | Every 1 year |
| 3 | Abolhassani et al. [ Expert’s opinion Level V. Grade D | Every 3–6 months | Every 3–6 months: hematologic testing Every 12 months: TSH Regular check: HCV PCR | As needed | Every 1 year: AUS Every 2 years: upper ± lower endoscopy | Every 1–2 years |
| 4 | Maarschalk-Ellerbroek et al. [ Cross-sectional cohort study (N = 47) Level II. Grade B | Not mentioned | Every 6–12 months: Ig | Baseline: CT | Not mentioned | Baseline |
| 5 | Buckley [ Guideline Level V. Grade D | Not mentioned | Every 6–12 months: Ig, creatinine, liver enzymes Every 12 months: HCV PCR | Baseline: CT | Not mentioned | Every 1 year |
| 6 | Bonilla et al. [ Consensus Level V. Grade D | Scheduled follow-ups (frequency not specified) | Every 6-12 months: liver enzymes Regular check: Ig, CBC, creatinine, urea (frequency not specified) | Baseline: HCRT | Not mentioned | Every 1 year |
| 7 | Caliskaner et al. [ Retrospective cohort study (N = 25) Level II. Grade B | Every 3–4 weeks | Every 3–4 weeks: CBC Every 3 months: Ig, lytes, urea, creatinine; urinalysis; stool O&P Every 6 months: total protein, albumin, glucose, LDH, liver enzymes; C3, C4; ANA, dsDNA, thyroid autoantibodies Every 12 months: TSH, T4, T3; CEA, AFP, CA19-9 | Every 2 years: HRCT | Every 2 years: AUS | Every 6 months |
| 8 | Janssen et al. [ Prospective cohort study (N = 55) Level II. Grade B | Not mentioned | Not mentioned | Every 5 years: CT | Not mentioned | Baseline then as needed |
| 9 | Bethune et al. [ Consensus Level V. Grade D | Every 6 month: weight; every 12 month: LN and abdomen exams | Every 6 months: Ig, CBC, liver enzymes | Baseline: HRCT Every 5 years: HRCT (if ongoing respiratory tract infections^) | Every 1 year: AUS (no consensus) | Every 1–3 years (no consensus) |
| 10 | Our centre Expert’s opinion Level V. Grade D | Every 1 month | Every 6 months: Ig, CBC, LDH, albumin, creatinine, liver enzymes; urinalysis | Baseline: CT chest As needed: CXR or CT chest | Every 1 year: AUS | Every 1 year |
| 11 | Summary of suggested frequency and type of monitoring | Every 1–12 months | Every 6–12 months: Ig, CBC, creatinine, liver enzymes | Baseline: CT Every 2–5 years or as needed: CT or CXR | Every 1–2 years: AUS, endoscopy (expert’s opinion) | Every 1–3 years |
LN lymph node, Ig immunoglobulin, CXR chest X-ray, HRCT high-resolution CT, AUS abdominal ultrasound
^ to monitor for bronchiectasis
Fig. 3Recommendations on monitoring patients with uncomplicated CVID
| 1. Marked decrease in IgG (at least 2 SD below the mean for age) and in at least one of the isotypes, IgM or IgA, AND | |
| 2. All of the following criteria: | |
| a. Onset of immunodeficiency greater than 2 years of age | |
| b. Absent of isohemagglutinins and/or poor response to vaccines | |
| c. Secondary causes of hypogammaglobulinemia have been ruled out |
| Clinical phenotypes | Common manifestations | Possible evaluation |
|---|---|---|
| I. Infection only | Sinusitis, otitis Pneumonia, empyema Diarrhea Arthritis | CBC Cultures: sputum, nasal swab, stool, joint fluid X-ray or CT of sinus, chest |
| IIa. Non-infectious complication: | ITP AIHA Neutropenia | CBC, blood film Bone marrow aspirate and biopsy to rule out malignancy |
| IIb. Non-infectious complication: | Malabsorption Chronic diarrhea | Iron study, vitamin B12 Celiac screen Stool cultures Endoscopy |
| IIc. Non-infectious complication: | LIP LAD Granulomatous disease | Bronchoscopy ± biopsy Biopsy of LAD or granuloma |
| IId. Non-infectious complication: | Bronchiectasis Hepatomegaly NRH Splenomegaly Other autoimmunity Malignancy | Chest imaging Pulmonary function test Abdominal ultrasound Biopsy of spleen, liver |
aFor the purpose of monitoring, Others refer to the non-infectious complications that are also part of CVID monitoring and thus included in this table
ITP immune thrombocytopenic purpura, AIHA autoimmune hemolytic anemia, LIP lymphoid interstitial pneumonitis, LAD lymphadenopathy, NRH nodular regenerative hyperplasia