Nimisha Mohandas1, Lisa M Kent1, Allan Raudsepp1, Geoffrey B Jameson1,2,3, Martin A K Williams1,2,3. 1. School of Fundamental Sciences, Massey University, Palmerston North 4442, New Zealand. 2. MacDiarmid Institute for Advanced Materials and Nanotechnology, Wellington 6012, New Zealand. 3. Riddet Institute, Massey University, Palmerston North 4442, New Zealand.
Abstract
Streptavidin is a tetrameric protein that is renowned for its strong binding to biotin. The robustness and strength of this noncovalent coupling has led to multitudinous applications of the pairing. Within the streptavidin tetramer, each protein monomer has the potential to specifically bind one biotin-bearing moiety. Herein, by separating various streptavidin species that have had differing numbers of their four potential binding sites blocked, several different types of "linking hub" were obtained, each with a different valency. The identification of these species and the study of the plugging process used to block sites during their preparation were carried out using capillary electrophoresis. Subsequently, a specific species, namely, a trans-divalent linker, in which the two open biotin-binding pockets are approximately opposite one another, was used to concatenate two ∼5 kb pieces of biotin-terminated double-stranded DNA. Following the incubation of this DNA with the prepared linker, a fraction of ∼10 kb strings was identified using gel electrophoresis. Finally, these concatenated DNA strings were stretched in an optical tweezer experiment, demonstrating the potential of the methodology for coupling and extending molecules for use in single-molecule biophysical experiments.
Streptavidin is a tetrameric protein that is renowned for its strong binding to biotin. The robustness and strength of this noncovalent coupling has led to multitudinous applications of the pairing. Within the streptavidin tetramer, each protein monomer has the potential to specifically bind one biotin-bearing moiety. Herein, by separating various streptavidin species that have had differing numbers of their four potential binding sites blocked, several different types of "linking hub" were obtained, each with a different valency. The identification of these species and the study of the plugging process used to block sites during their preparation were carried out using capillary electrophoresis. Subsequently, a specific species, namely, a trans-divalent linker, in which the two open biotin-binding pockets are approximately opposite one another, was used to concatenate two ∼5 kb pieces of biotin-terminated double-stranded DNA. Following the incubation of this DNA with the prepared linker, a fraction of ∼10 kb strings was identified using gel electrophoresis. Finally, these concatenated DNA strings were stretched in an optical tweezer experiment, demonstrating the potential of the methodology for coupling and extending molecules for use in single-molecule biophysical experiments.
Single-molecule studies have continued
to grow in popularity as
technological capability improves and experimental platforms for their
application become more available. While typically challenging compared
to traditional bulk techniques, single-molecule studies offer unprecedented
access to the world of molecular biology and deep insights into the
functioning of molecular machines in the noisy thermal bath in which
they operate. Optical tweezers (OT) have provided a key experimental
tool for the pursuit of such studies, acknowledged recently by the
award of a Nobel prize.For several decades, DNA has been the
workhorse of single-molecule
experiments, especially those carried out with OT. This is not only
due to DNA’s intrinsic biological relevance but also due to
the facile control of its size and sequence and the simplicity of
attaching “handles” to the chain termini. DNA–protein
conjugates have also previously been employed to help understand the
behavior of proteins at the single-molecule level.[1−5] However, similar studies on other important biological
macromolecules, such as polysaccharides, have somewhat fallen behind.
This is despite the clear need for such experiments in samples where,
more often than not, subpopulations of heterogeneous samples exhibit
different properties that are masked in bulk studies. A generic strategy
that enables the generation of a “plug-and-play” string
format and facilitates the study of shorter molecules with more challenging
attachment chemistry would represent significant progress toward ameliorating
this difficulty.Streptavidin–biotin is one of the most
widely known noncovalent
binding pairs and can be used, among other things, to perform biomolecule
conjugation. With a dissociation constant, Kd, of ∼0.1–10 fM, streptavidin–biotin
conjugation has found wide versatility in biotechnology, including
in applications from biosensors to cell biology.[6] Streptavidin is a homotetrameric protein, with each monomer
able to bind one biotin-displaying molecule.[7] The binding of biotin to streptavidin has been found to be noncooperative,
but with every additional binding of biotin, the structural and thermodynamic
stability of the protein itself increases.[8−10] Being able
to control the number of active valencies that the tetramer displays
opens up potential pathways to further applications by allowing hubs
of known valency (1, 2, 3, or 4) to be formed. Previous attempts of
this type have largely involved using genetic modification techniques
to produce monomeric mutants that are not capable of biotin binding
but are still successfully incorporated into the tetramer.[11,12] Furthermore, designed modifications of the binding properties of
monomeric and dimeric streptavidin have also been carried out.[13−16] Other methodologies that have sought to reduce the possible number
of biotin-bearing molecules that can bind to tetramers have used preliminary
incubations of streptavidin with biotin-terminated “plugging
molecules”. In this way, by controlling the stoichiometric
ratios of components and the incubation time, partially filled monovalent,
divalent, and trivalent streptavidin species can all be formed.[17,18]A separation technique using anion-exchange chromatography
for
isolating different tetrameric “hubs” from streptavidin
samples with different amounts of the potential binding sites blocked
has previously been reported.[17] Specifically,
after incubating streptavidin with 12 bp double-stranded DNA (dsDNA)
molecules carrying a biotin moiety at one end, species with different
numbers of the binding sites filled were successfully separated using
an anion-exchange chromatography column. By incorporating a photocleavable
(PC) 2-nitrobenzyl linker between the 12 bp oligonucleotide and the
biotin, it was then possible to remove the separation-facilitating
DNA oligomers post fraction-collection, leaving just the “biotin
plugs”. This enabled the generation of a series of “preplugged”
streptavidin species with certain sites passivated and others available
for binding biotin-displaying species.Herein, we perform experiments
of this type but monitor the valency
of the different species and the site-plugging process, using capillary
electrophoresis (CE), in contrast to traditional gel chromatography.
Based on our results, different valency species were resolved much
more clearly in CE than in gels. Moreover, the trans-divalent streptavidin species collected here were incubated with
∼5 kb biotin-terminated DNA strands. Following the incubation,
concatenated ∼10 kb strings were detected using gel electrophoresis
and, furthermore, were successfully stretched between beads in a traditional
dual-trap dumbbell-style DNA-stretching experiment.
Results and Discussion
Observing
Streptavidin–dsDNA (12 bp) Conjugates with
CE
Streptavidin was mixed at varying stoichiometric ratios
with 12 bp dsDNA oligomers (functionalized with biotin at one end
via a photocleavable linker). Different ratios of dsDNA/tetravalent
streptavidin (approximately 1:1 and 4:1) were incubated overnight
and then analyzed by CE. The resulting electrophoregrams are shown
in Figure A. By considering
the different possible products of the incubation, such as free streptavidin
(N = 0) and streptavidin with one (N = 1), two (N = 2), three (N =
3), or four (N = 4) biotin-terminated DNA oligomers
bound and how the relative concentrations of these species would be
expected to change as more DNA is added, the five peaks in the electrophoregram
were preliminarily identified (see schematics in the figure). As shown
in due course (Figure ), there are three possible configurations (two trans-divalent and one cis-divalent) for the divalent
product. Considering the evidence that the cis-divalent
species is less stable due to steric hindrance,[19] the trans-divalent products were expected
to be dominant, with a minor quantity of cis-divalent
streptavidin. Both possible trans-divalent species
would be expected (i) to be populated similarly, as neither offers
steric advantage, (ii) to be indistinguishable by electrophoretic
techniques, and (iii) to stretch similarly in OT experiments. Statistically
in plugging trans sites, both interdimer and intradimer trans arrangements are equally likely. The presence of distinct trans species, resulting from substantial tetrahedral distortion
of the streptavidin homotetramer from the canonically depicted square-planar
arrangement, does not appear to have been considered in prior work
of tethering oligomers to streptavidin.
Figure 1
(A) Species formed when
biotin-terminated 12 bp dsDNA was incubated
with tetravalent streptavidin at different ratios (1:1 (top) and 4:1
(bottom)). Absorbance at 192 nm was recorded. (B) Separation of the
different tetrameric species formed after overnight incubation of
streptavidin with biotin-terminated 12 bp dsDNA, by anion-exchange
chromatography, permitting fraction collection. The weakest band is
tentatively assigned to a cis-divalent species. Absorbances
at 260 nm (black) and 280 nm (blue) were recorded.
Figure 6
Completely filled biotin–streptavdin
conjugate with the
S···S distances between the cis and
possible trans sites marked as 22.3 and 21.3 Å,
and 25.4 Å, respectively), and possible trans configuration of divalent streptavidin (solid indicates biotin “plugs”,
whereas the dotted renderings of the biotin indicate the potential,
currently vacant biotin-binding sites).
(A) Species formed when
biotin-terminated 12 bp dsDNA was incubated
with tetravalent streptavidin at different ratios (1:1 (top) and 4:1
(bottom)). Absorbance at 192 nm was recorded. (B) Separation of the
different tetrameric species formed after overnight incubation of
streptavidin with biotin-terminated 12 bp dsDNA, by anion-exchange
chromatography, permitting fraction collection. The weakest band is
tentatively assigned to a cis-divalent species. Absorbances
at 260 nm (black) and 280 nm (blue) were recorded.At the neutral pH of the CE separation, the streptavidin
(pI =
5) is slightly negatively charged.[20] Under
the CE conditions used, anionic species are dragged toward the cathode
by the electro-osmotic flow (EOF). The downward peak at around 3.5
min provides a neutral marker (formed here by the refractive index
change from injection plug solvent passing the detection window) and
monitors the value of the EOF.[21] Peaks
from positively charged species will migrate earlier than the EOF,
and peaks from negatively charged species will be observed later.
As the negative charge density of the complexes increases as an increased
number of biotin-terminated nucleotides become bound, the migration
time increases. Any unreacted DNA oligomers present elute considerably
later owing to their high negative charge and small size and are not
seen here. Based on the electrophoregrams (Figure A), a roughly 4:1 ratio of oligonucleotide
species to streptavidin was adopted to produce an ideal distribution
of multivalent species and a high yield of divalent species for use
in further trials.The migration of species in the CE experiments
was monitored using
UV irradiation at several wavelengths including 192, 260, and 280
nm. DNA has a characteristic absorbance at 260 nm owing to its highly
conjugated purine and pyrimidine bases, whereas proteins have a characteristic
absorbance at 280 nm specific to the tryptophan and tyrosine moieties
in proteins.[22,23] Although using 260 and 280 nm
is advantageous in monitoring DNA and proteins, respectively, the
maximum UV absorbance over the wavelengths monitored was found at
192 nm (Figure A),
reflecting the presence of the peptide bonds in the amino acids at
∼205–220 nm.[24,25] Hence, the absorbances
at 192 nm were selected for rendering the electrophoregram figures
(unless specified otherwise). The electrophoretic mobilities of the
species observed in Figure A were calculated according towhere μep is the electrophoretic
mobility of species, Ltot is the total
length of the capillary (0.485 m), Leff is the distance between the point of injection and point of detection
(0.40 m), V is the applied voltage (25 kV), tmig is the migration time of species, and tEOF is the migration time of neutral species
(electro-osmotic flow) (3.35 min), as shown in Table :
Table 1
Electrophoretic Mobilities,
μep, of the Various Streptavidin/DNA Conjugates Shown
in Figure A (Uncertainties
Are Estimated at ∼5%)
species (N)
tmig (min)
μep/10–7 (m2 V–1 s–1)
0
3.68
–2.07
1
4.23
–4.82
2
4.93
–7.42
3
5.56
–9.21
4
6.32
–10.89
Fraction-Collecting Streptavidin–dsDNA
(12 bp) Conjugates
of Specific Valency
While CE requires only tiny amounts of
sample and resolves the differing species of interest well, in a relatively
short time, its application as a preparative technique is limited.
To collect specific partially plugged species types, anion exchange
chromatography was performed as described in Experimental
Procedures. The resulting chromatogram following injection
of the incubated sample is shown in Figure B.This result compares well with that
previously reported[17] and allowed known
partially plugged species types to be collected. As expected, there
are two peaks observed for the divalent species, and following the
original paper, the major peak is taken to be the trans-divalent species. The collected specific valency streptavidin–DNA
oligomer complexes were then run in CE experiments to confirm the
previous peak assignment shown in Figure A. A selection of these experiments is shown
in Figure , which
serves to highlight the utility of CE for the separation and monitoring
of these species.
Figure 2
Electrophoregrams of the fraction-collected divalent (N = 2), monovalent (N = 3), and fully filled
streptavidin
(N = 4) fractions (obtained from the HPAEC column
and labeled schematically), injected separately and co-injected (bottom)
into the CE setup.
Electrophoregrams of the fraction-collected divalent (N = 2), monovalent (N = 3), and fully filled
streptavidin
(N = 4) fractions (obtained from the HPAEC column
and labeled schematically), injected separately and co-injected (bottom)
into the CE setup.When comparing Figures A and 2, it is worthwhile to mention
a few points relevant to the interpretation of CE electrophoregrams.
First, it is not uncommon for the magnitude of the EOF to vary slightly,
even between runs with nominally identical conditions, owing to its
exquisite sensitivity to the zeta-potential of the capillary walls
that is difficult to regenerate exactly between successive runs.[26,27] This means that the migration times of peaks representing species
of interest (and thereby the observed resolution of different species)
may be slightly different between runs. It should be noted, however,
that the physical parameter distinguishing the electrophoretic transport
of the analytes, the electrophoretic mobility, is of course unchanged,
as can be confirmed by its calculation, which includes the migration
time of the EOF. Second, depending on the relative composition (and
thereby refractive index) of the sample and the background electrolyte
(BGE), the EOF-reporting peak can appear different in size and even
negative or positive.[28] Here, it is seen
negative-going in Figure A but positive-going in Figure , owing to the different solution conditions for the
diluted fraction-collected samples.
Post Fraction-Collection
Cleavage of dsDNA (12 bp) from Streptavidin
Conjugates
Once the fractions were successfully collected,
the oligonucleotide tails were cleaved off the separated species by
UV irradiation to avoid any possible undesired interactions of subsequent
molecules targeted for binding with those used in passivating the
other sites. Figure A shows the products expected to be formed during the time course
of UV radiation exposure when starting with the divalent species (a,
top), the monovalent (b, middle), and the fully filled streptavidin
conjugate (c, bottom). On cleaving the linkage between the biotin
and the DNA, this process leaves each streptavidin binding site that
was originally occupied by the 12 bp dsDNA oligomer with only the
biotin stub in the pocket. This essentially plugs the binding site
so that it is not available for further interaction. The figure shows
the possible mixture of species that would be expected to be found
during the cleavage process before its completion. For example, as
the oligonucleotide is shaved off the divalent streptavidin species
(Figure A(a,top)),
a maximum of three species can be present (specifically, the original
streptavidin carrying two biotin–12 bp dsDNA tails; streptavidin
carrying one biotin–12 bp dsDNA tail and one biotin plug; and
streptavidin carrying two biotin plugs). Similarly for monovalent
streptavidin, a total of five possible products are expected (Figure A(b), middle), and
for the initially fully filled streptavidin, there are six (Figure A(c), bottom). All
of the species that could possibly be obtained upon UV irradiation
are labeled as N*, where N is the
number of 12 bp dsDNA oligomers still present in each species, and
* denotes that UV was instrumental in the generation of the species.
Figure 3
(A) Multiple
species expected to be formed during UV irradiation
of the different starting streptavidin–12 bp dsDNA conjugates.
(B) Electrophoregrams monitoring the species present after 60 s UV
irradiation of different starting streptavidin–12 bp dsDNA
conjugates (solid line represents the electrophoregram of reactants
before UV, and dotted line represents the electrophoregrams of products
after UV).
(A) Multiple
species expected to be formed during UV irradiation
of the different starting streptavidin–12 bp dsDNA conjugates.
(B) Electrophoregrams monitoring the species present after 60 s UV
irradiation of different starting streptavidin–12 bp dsDNA
conjugates (solid line represents the electrophoregram of reactants
before UV, and dotted line represents the electrophoregrams of products
after UV).Figure B shows
the results from the corresponding experiment, using CE to monitor
the species present and their relative concentrations after irradiating
the sample for 60 s, as described in Experimental
Procedures (electrophoregrams of starting and irradiated samples
are shown as solid and dotted lines, respectively). As alluded to
earlier, the electrophoretic mobility of the species along with the
electro-osmotic flow determines the migration time in CE, depending
primarily on the ratio of the charge to the hydrodynamic friction
coefficient of the analytes. Once the 12 bp dsDNA is removed, the
streptavidin binding site it once occupied simply contains a neutral
biotin stub, which is not expected to significantly affect the electrophoretic
transport behavior of the complex in which it resides. Hence, when
cleavage of all the oligonucleotides is complete, all the streptavidin
conjugates, no matter how many plugged sites they contain, would be
expected to migrate past the detection window at the same time, with
a mobility comparable to pure streptavidin (position 0). Similarly,
species that at some point during the cleavage process only possess
one nucleotide tail (and any number of biotin plugs in other sites)
would be expected to have the same electrophoretic mobility as the
starting trivalent streptavidin (position 1) species, and so on and
so forth. The experimental results shown in Figure B indeed follow the expected progression
mapped out in Figure A, confirming the generation and correct identification of the starting
species, as well as the UV-induced removal of the oligonucleotides.
It is worth noting that the irradiation of fully filled and monovalent
streptavidin yields an additional peak intermediate between those
designated 1 and 2. Based on the position of the peak, it seems likely
that this is a cis-divalent streptavidin species,
which could not be distinguished on a traditional gel.
Time Course
of Removal of dsDNA (12 bp) from Streptavidin Conjugates
Figure B still
shows a variety of different streptavidin–biotin–dsDNA
conjugates present in samples after 60 s of UV irradiation, indicating
that this reaction time was insufficient to cleave all oligonucleotides
from the conjugates. Differing UV exposure times were subsequently
applied to find the time required to remove all oligonucleotide tails
and thereby generate the sought-after streptavidin species with known
numbers of biotin-plugged or available biotin-binding sites. The oligonucleotide
removal is illustrated further in Figure A for the HPAEC-collected monovalent streptavidin
species (the tetramer with three biotin–dsDNA oligomers initially
bound). The complex was subjected to UV irradiation for a total of
30 min, and the progress of the photocleavage of the DNA tails was
monitored by taking 30 μL aliquots of the sample at different
time intervals and running the sample in the CE. Figure A clearly shows how the peaks
move to lower charge density as time progresses, and the 12 bp nucleotide
tails are removed, with the expected progression through the intermediate
species. After 5 min, the majority of the oligonucleotides has been
cleaved, and the streptavidin itself (now containing three “passivating”
biotin plugs) still remains intact (as inferred from the similarity
of the peak shape to that obtained with unadulterated streptavidin).
Furthermore, the protein seems relatively stable even after 10 min
of UV irradiation. Some modification of the protein itself is, however,
evident at 30 min, as changes in the peak shape indicate. An interesting
feature is seen ∼4.6 min in the electrophoregrams recorded
after 60 and 90 s UV irradiation. A peak manifests as a slight shoulder
toward the 2* peak and is presumed to be the cis-equivalent
of the double tail. This peak is only visible during a short time
frame in the process of cleaving the tails and is not clearly observed
in the formation of the different valencies, confirming that cis-configuration is much more unstable than any of the
other configurations as previously suggested.[29]
Figure 4
Electrophoregrams
monitoring the species present (A) with different
times of UV irradiation of monovalent streptavidin–dsDNA (12
bp) (N = 3) conjugates (* indicates presence of cis-divalent species), (B) after 5 min UV irradiation of
divalent streptavidin-dsDNA (12 bp) (N = 2) conjugates.
Electrophoregrams
monitoring the species present (A) with different
times of UV irradiation of monovalent streptavidin–dsDNA (12
bp) (N = 3) conjugates (* indicates presence of cis-divalent species), (B) after 5 min UV irradiation of
divalent streptavidin-dsDNA (12 bp) (N = 2) conjugates.As the primary interest here is producing divalent
streptavidin
species that can be used as linking molecules, the fraction-collected trans-divalent streptavidin (N = 2) sample
was subsequently exposed to UV irradiation for 5 min. Figure B shows the pre- and post-irradiation
electrophoregrams, again confirming that, under these conditions,
the oligonucleotides are removed, leaving simple biotin stubs plugging
two sites and with the protein intact.
Using Divalent Streptavidin
as a Linker
The results
of the CE experiments performed on incubations of streptavidin with
12 bp dsDNA and on the fraction-collected samples and their subsequent
UV-generated species provide confidence that specific divalent streptavidin
species can be generated in large amounts and investigated for their
potential as a linker molecule as described below.
Investigating
the Yield of Concatenated 10 kb DNA
Initial
tests of this linking functionality were carried out by incubating
the trans-divalent streptavidin species with biotin-terminated
DNA that could be visualized straightforwardly using a standard agarose
gel, as described in the Experimental Procedures. For this purpose, ∼5 kb DNA that would, upon successful
concatenation, effectively result in the formation of a ∼10
kb DNA strand was selected. Figure does indeed show the presence of a ∼10 kb band
post-incubation. The visualized band is relatively faint, however,
suggesting that the yield of the concatenated species was lower than
might be expected (∼12%) for the ∼2:1 ratio of streptavidin/DNA
used in this experiment. To investigate the hypothesis that the first
of the ∼5 kb DNA strands binding to the streptavidin obscures
the remaining binding sites, the sequential filling of the streptavidin
sites with biotin-terminated DNA oligomers of different lengths was
investigated. While cis-divalent streptavidin attachment of one DNA molecule
has previously been shown to sterically and electrostatically hinder
the binding of another moiety,[29] it seems
less likely with the trans-divalent streptavidin
used here.
Figure 5
Gel electrophoresis experiment showing a standard size ladder (Invitrogen
1 kb + DNA ladder) in lane 1, the 5 kb biotin-terminated DNA in lane
2, and the results of an incubation of the divalent streptavidin with
the 5 kb biotin-terminated DNA in lane 3. Background-corrected integrated
intensity profiles for lanes 2 and 3, between the pairs of vertical
white lines indicated on the image of the gel, are shown to the left.
Integrated intensities along these profiles, between the red lines
indicated, are reported in the figure. Schematics of the species observed
are also shown on the right.
Gel electrophoresis experiment showing a standard size ladder (Invitrogen
1 kb + DNA ladder) in lane 1, the 5 kb biotin-terminated DNA in lane
2, and the results of an incubation of the divalent streptavidin with
the 5 kb biotin-terminated DNA in lane 3. Background-corrected integrated
intensity profiles for lanes 2 and 3, between the pairs of vertical
white lines indicated on the image of the gel, are shown to the left.
Integrated intensities along these profiles, between the red lines
indicated, are reported in the figure. Schematics of the species observed
are also shown on the right.The distance between the two biotin binding faces of a streptavidin
tetramer is ∼2.0 nm[19] (Figure ). Two different lengths of biotin-terminated DNA oligomer
(12 bases (∼4.0 nm) and 28 bases (∼9.5 nm)) were used
briefly to investigate the role that steric and electrostatic effects
might play in the consecutive binding of biotin-terminated DNA into
potential valencies (data not shown). It was found that when tetravalent
streptavidin was incubated with 12 bp biotin-terminated DNA, the DNA
oligomers seamlessly filled the open valencies until nearly all of
the sites in the streptavidin conjugate species were completely filled.
However, substantially more valencies remained unfilled when the same
experiment was repeated with 28 bp DNA oligomers. This observation
does suggest that, as the length of the molecules targeted to be coupled
increases, steric and/or electrostatic effects will limit the yield
of the concatenated species derived.[29] It
is worth noting that, despite the low yield, two large (micron-sized)
DNA pieces can be successfully concatenated in this way in sufficient
quantities to undertake single-molecule stretching experiments, for
example, by optical tweezers.Completely filled biotin–streptavdin
conjugate with the
S···S distances between the cis and
possible trans sites marked as 22.3 and 21.3 Å,
and 25.4 Å, respectively), and possible trans configuration of divalent streptavidin (solid indicates biotin “plugs”,
whereas the dotted renderings of the biotin indicate the potential,
currently vacant biotin-binding sites).
Stretching Streptavidin-Linked Strings in a Dual-Trap Optical
Tweezers Setup
DNA concatenation via the divalent streptavidin
linker (ss) was additionally verified by stretching the formed DNA
string using optical tweezers. The setup for the experiment is illustrated
in Figure A,B. Initially,
standard samples, nominally 5 or 10 kb DNA, terminated by either biotin
(B) or digoxigenin (D) at the termini, are bound to streptavidin (S)-
or anti-digoxigenin (A)-coated beads, which are optically trapped
in the tweezers. This bound DNA can be stretched by separating the
beads (Figure A).
By tracking the position of the beads, as shown in Figure B, a force F = k(xb – xb0) can be determined (where k is the optical trap stiffness, with extension d = xs – xb – rs – rb, and rs and rb are the radii of the beads, and the subscripts
s and b relate to the small(er) and big(ger) of the beads, respectively).
Figure 7
Optical
tweezers experiments: Stretching control and concatenated
DNA. (A) Micrograph of the setup showing a big (b) and small (s) bead
tethering DNA, their separation using OT, and the consequential movement
of the left-hand bead in response to moving the right-hand one of
the pair. (B) Displacements of the beads as they are made to approach
and retract from each other. (C–F) Derived force–extension
curves for the four samples described in the text are illustrated
in the respective panes.
Optical
tweezers experiments: Stretching control and concatenated
DNA. (A) Micrograph of the setup showing a big (b) and small (s) bead
tethering DNA, their separation using OT, and the consequential movement
of the left-hand bead in response to moving the right-hand one of
the pair. (B) Displacements of the beads as they are made to approach
and retract from each other. (C–F) Derived force–extension
curves for the four samples described in the text are illustrated
in the respective panes.Four samples were examined:
(1) A-D-10kb-B-S (reference DNA) (Figure C); (2) A-D-5kb-B-S
(Figure D); (3) A-D-10kb-D-A
(Figure E); and (4)
A-D-5kb-B-ss-B-5kb-D-A (concatenated DNA) (Figure F). Sample 1 is a standard DNA stretch with
the two DNA strands terminated by biotin at one end and digoxigenin
at the other; where one streptavidin-coated and one anti-digoxigenin-coated
bead are utilized in the experiment. Sample 2 is a standard 5 kb stretch
of the same nature as 1. Sample 3 is similar to 1 but has both bead-facing
ends terminated with digoxigenin, as a prelude to sample 4, in which
the biotin-displaying ends of both chains are free to couple to the
divalent streptavidin linker. Typical single-duplex force–extension
curves for the four samples are shown in Figure C–F, repectively. These force–extension
curves were fitted to the wormlike chain model (WLC):to determine the chain’s persistence
length, lp (the length over which the
chain might be considered straight), and the contour length, lc (the end-to-end length along the chain). The
statistics of the fitted parameters are shown in Table . Note that a single trap stiffness k was assumed for all measurements; this value was chosen
so that the mean lp value for the D–10
kb–B measurements matched that previously found for this reference
sample.[30,31]
Table 2
OT Experimental Results
for the Samples
Described in the Text and Illustrated in Figure C–Fa
sample
stretches
mean lp (nm)
mean lc (μm)
bp
A-D-10kb-B-S
28
59 (±10)
3.425 (±0.047)
10 051
A-D-5kb-B-S
9
54 (±9.8)
1.588 (±0.066)
4682
A-D-10kb-D-A
23
72 (±12)
3.342 (±0.066)
10 051
A-D-5kb-B-ss-B-5kb-D-A
13
75 (±12)
3.069 (±0.075)
9364
Individual stretches were independently
fitted to the WLC model, and means and standard deviations of the
fitted lp and lc for each DNA sample were calculated.
Individual stretches were independently
fitted to the WLC model, and means and standard deviations of the
fitted lp and lc for each DNA sample were calculated.Based on these statistics, the following can be concluded:
(1)
All DNA tested has the same lp. (2) The
ratio of the extracted contour lengths of the 5 and 10 kb dsDNA samples, lc(D-5kb-B)/lc(D-10kb-B)
= 0.46 (0.438–0.490) is consistent with the known ratio of
their base pairs 4682/10051 = 0.466. (3) The ratio of the extracted
contour lengths of two 10 kb dsDNA samples, with different termini, lc(D-10kb-D)/lc (D-10kb-B)
= 0.98 (0.943–1.01), is consistent with the known ratio of
their base pairs 10051/10051 = 1.00. (4) The ratio of the extracted
contour lengths of the string resulting from the incubation of 5 kb
DNA with trans-divalent streptavidin, and the 5 kb
DNA, lc(D-5kb-B-ss-B-5kb-D)/lc(D-5kb-B) = 1.93 (1.81–2.07), is consistent with
the expected ratio of base pairs, 9364/4682 = 2.00, if concatenation
occurs. This observation confirms that the concatenated structure
with the intervening biotin–streptavidin bridge (D-5kb-B-ss-B-5kb-D)
was formed and is robust enough to run intact in an agarose gel and
to be held in an OT experiment.
Conclusion
CE
provides a rapid methodology for studying the results of incubating
streptavidin with biotin-terminated DNA oligomers, requiring minimal
amounts of sample and consumables. Using HPAEC to collect fractions
and UV irradiation to remove separation-facilitating DNA oligomers,
specific divalent streptavidin species can be generated and have the
potential to be used as linker molecules to create “plug-and-play”
strings for single-molecule experiments. This divalent streptavidin,
when incubated with ∼5 kb biotin-terminated DNA, produces a ∼10
kb concatenated species which can be observed on an agarose gel. Furthermore,
in optical tweezers experiments, the ratio of the extracted contour
lengths of the string resulting from the incubation of ∼5 kb
DNA with divalent streptavidin and the ∼5 kb DNA, lc(D-5kb-B-ss-B-5kb-D)/lc(D-5kb-B)
= 1.93 (1.81–2.07), is consistent with the known ratio of base
pairs, 9364/4682 = 2.00, which is to be expected if concatenation
occurs. This observation confirms that the concatenated structure
D-5kb-B-ss-B-5kb-D was formed. Moreover, the force–extension
curve of the concatenated string was experimentally indistinguishable
from that which would be expected from a single DNA chain of the same
length, showing that, at least at these forces, the tightly bound
divalent streptavidin linker does not modify the stretching behavior
significantly. It is hoped that as an extension to this work, using
two streptavidin linkers, any biotin-terminated polymer might be inserted
between two sections of DNA of substantial length to facilitate single-molecule
experiments on molecules that are currently difficult to address by
other means.
Experimental Procedures
Streptavidin–DNA
Oligonucleotide Binding
DNA
oligonucleotides (Integrated DNA Technologies, Inc., Coralville, Iowa/Singapore)
and streptavidin (PRO-283, ProSpec-Tany TechnoGene, Ltd., Rehovot,
Israel) were purchased and used following the protocols described
in detail in Sun et al.[17] Briefly, a primer
with a photocleavable biotin moiety attached via the 5′ end
(biotin-PC-AGC-ACA-TCC-CCC) was annealed to its complement (GGG-GGA-TGT-GCT)
in 10 mM sodium phosphate buffer, 50 mM NaCl pH 7.5 at 94 °C
for 2 min and then cooled slowly for a final concentration of 450
μM double-stranded DNA. We combined this 12 bp DNA (40–160
μM final concentration) with streptavidin first dissolved in
water (40 μM final concentration) overnight at room temperature
in 100 mM sodium phosphate buffer pH 6.5. We tested various concentrations
of 12 bp DNA with streptavidin to determine the optimal ratio for
a maximum yield of streptavidin species with exactly two bound DNA
oligomers. A ratio of 4:1 DNA to streptavidin (equivalently the total
number of DNA oligos equal to the total number of binding sites on
streptavidin) was used for sample preparation for running through
the anion exchange column. Throughout, primer with photocleavable
biotin was kept in the dark.
Anion-Exchange Chromatography
To
separate the streptavidin
with different numbers of DNA oligos attached, we used a Uno Q column
5/50 (GE Life Sciences/Cytiva, Marlborough, Massachusetts) anion exchange
column run in a NGC Quest 10 Plus chromatography system (Bio-Rad Laboratories,
Inc., Hercules, California). Following the protocol in Sun et al.,[17] we used a linear salt gradient beginning with
100% buffer A (20 mM Tris/HCl pH 8) and ending with 100% buffer B
(buffer A with 1 M NaCl) over 400 mL at a rate of 2 mL/min.
Capillary
Electrophoresis
Experiments were carried
out using an automated Agilent CE system (HP 3D), equipped with a
diode array detector. Electrophoresis was carried out in a fused silica
capillary with an internal diameter of 50 μm and a total length
of 48.5 cm (40 cm from inlet to detector), unless otherwise stated.
The capillary incorporated an extended light-path detection window
(150 μm) and was thermostated at 25 °C. All new capillaries
were conditioned by rinsing for 30 min with 1 M NaOH, 30 min with
a 0.1 M NaOH solution, 15 min with water, and 30 min with BGE. A total
of 50 mM sodium phosphate buffer at pH 7.0 was used as a CE BGE and
filtered through 0.2 μm filters (Whatman) before use. Between
runs, the capillary was washed for 2 min with 1 M NaOH, 2 min with
0.1 M NaOH, 1 min with water, and 2 min with BGE. Detection was carried
out using UV absorbance typically at 192 or 260 nm with a bandwidth
of 2 nm. Samples were loaded hydrodynamically (various injection times
at 5000 Pa, typically giving injection volumes of the order of 10
nL) and typically electrophoresed across a potential difference of
25 kV. All experiments were carried out at normal polarity (inlet
anodic) unless otherwise stated.
UV Irradiation
UV-induced cleavage of the 12 bp oligonucleotides
from their biotin termini was performed using a multiband (254/366
nm) Mineralight UV lamp (Ultra-Violet Products, Inc., San Gabriel,
California). Samples in a quartz cuvette were subjected to UV irradiation
for different times, and the photocleavage was monitored by capillary
electrophoresis.
DNA Gel Electrophoresis
To produce
∼5 kb DNA
with biotin attached at one end, we performed PCR according to the
manufacturer’s recommendations (PCR Extender System, QuantaBio,
Beverly, Massachusetts) using Lambda phage DNA as a template (New
England Biolabs Inc., Ipswich, Massachusetts), a biotinylated primer
and an unmodified primer (forward 5′-biotinTEG-CTGATGAGTTCGTGTCCGTACAACTGGCGTAATC-3′,
reverse 5′-GTTTGTACTCCAGCGTCTCATCTTTATGCGCC-3′,
Integrated DNA Technologies). This produced a single band in a conventional
agarose gel electrophoresis experiment at the expected 5031 bp. The
cleaned PCR product was combined with biotin-plugged divalent streptavidin,
where the oligonucleotides of the two plugging molecules had been
cleaved off with 5 min UV irradiation, and incubated overnight in
100 mM sodium phosphate buffer pH 6.5. Products of the incubation
were visualized on a 0.5% agarose gel using staining with ethidium
bromide.
Optical Tweezers
DNA stretching experiments were carried
out on an inverted microscope (Nikon Eclipse TE2000-U) equipped with
holographic optical tweezers (Arryx, Chicago, USA). The setup includes
a fixed 5 W (1032 nm) infrared laser, a spatial light modulator steered
(SLM, Boulder NLS phase only) 2 W (1064 nm) infrared laser, and a
high-speed camera (Andor NEO). A high numerical aperture water immersion
objective (Nikon plan apo, magnification = 60×, NA = 1.2) was
used for focusing and trapping. The DNA studied here comprised ∼10
kb (10051 bp) pieces,[32] ∼5 kb (4682
bp) pieces, and ∼10 kb assemblies of two of the 5 kb pieces
concatenated with trans-divalent streptavidin. Each
strand of the double-stranded duplex was terminated by either biotin
or digoxigenin (preattached to the primers used in the PCR production
process, 5′BiotinTEG or 5′DIGN, Integrated DNA Technologies)
that bind to streptavidin- or anti-digoxigenin-coated beads, respectively,
by physisorption. DNA was incubated in TSB (50 mM Tris, 150 mM NaCl,
1 mM EDTA, pH 7.6) with 1:26 μm diameter streptavidin-coated
beads (SVP-10-5, Spherotech, Lake Forest, Illinois) for at least an
hour and combined with 2:12 μm diameter anti-digoxigenin-coated
beads (DIGP-20-2, Spherotech) in TSB in a well slide.
Authors: Ciro Cecconi; Elizabeth A Shank; Frederick W Dahlquist; Susan Marqusee; Carlos Bustamante Journal: Eur Biophys J Date: 2008-01-09 Impact factor: 1.733
Authors: Derek N Fuller; Gregory J Gemmen; John Peter Rickgauer; Aurelie Dupont; Rachel Millin; Pierre Recouvreux; Douglas E Smith Journal: Nucleic Acids Res Date: 2006-02-01 Impact factor: 16.971