| Literature DB >> 35206315 |
Yuwen Lyu1,2, Julian Chun-Chung Chow3, Ji-Jen Hwang4,5, Zhi Li6, Cheng Ren3, Jungui Xie7.
Abstract
China's migrant population has significantly contributed to its economic growth; however, the impact on the well-being of left-behind children (LBC) has become a serious public health problem. Text mining is an effective tool for identifying people's mental state, and is therefore beneficial in exploring the psychological mindset of LBC. Traditional data collection methods, which use questionnaires and standardized scales, are limited by their sample sizes. In this study, we created a computational application to quantitively collect personal narrative texts posted by LBC on Zhihu, which is a Chinese question-and-answer online community website; 1475 personal narrative texts posted by LBC were gathered. We used four types of words, i.e., first-person singular pronouns, negative words, past tense verbs, and death-related words, all of which have been associated with depression and suicidal ideations in the Chinese Linguistic Inquiry Word Count (CLIWC) dictionary. We conducted vocabulary statistics on the personal narrative texts of LBC, and bilateral t-tests, with a control group, to analyze the psychological well-being of LBC. The results showed that the proportion of words related to depression and suicidal ideations in the texts of LBC was significantly higher than in the control group. The differences, with respect to the four word types (i.e., first-person singular pronouns, negative words, past tense verbs, and death-related words), were 5.37, 2.99, 2.65, and 2.00 times, respectively, suggesting that LBC are at a higher risk of depression and suicide than their counterparts. By sorting the texts of LBC, this research also found that child neglect is a main contributing factor to psychological difficulties of LBC. Furthermore, mental health problems and the risk of suicide in vulnerable groups, such as LBC, is a global public health issue, as well as an important research topic in the era of digital public health. Through a linguistic analysis, the results of this study confirmed that the experiences of left-behind children negatively impact their mental health. The present findings suggest that it is vital for the public and nonprofit sectors to establish online suicide prevention and intervention systems to improve the well-being of LBC through digital technology.Entities:
Keywords: left-behind children; linguistic analysis; personal narrative text; psychological well-being; text mining; textual analysis
Mesh:
Year: 2022 PMID: 35206315 PMCID: PMC8871950 DOI: 10.3390/ijerph19042127
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Int J Environ Res Public Health ISSN: 1660-4601 Impact factor: 3.390
Classification of function words in LIWC Dictionary.
| Total Function | Pronouns | Other | Other Grammar | Affect | Social | Cognitive Processes | Perceptual Processes | Relativity | Personal Concerns | Informal Language |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| I | Articles | Verbs | Positive | Family | Insight | See | Motion | Work | Swear | |
| We | Prepositions | Adjectives | Negative | Friend | Causation | Hear | Space | Leisure | Net speak | |
| You | Auxiliary verbs | Comparisons | Anxiety | Female | Discrepancy | Feel | Time | Home | Agreement | |
| She and he | Adverbs | Interrogatives | Anger | Male | Tentative | Money | Non-fluencies | |||
| They | Conjunctions | Numbers | Sadness | Certainty | Religion | Filler | ||||
| Impersonal | Negations | Quantifiers | Difference | Death |
The three most popular questions posted about LBC on the Zhihu website.
| Questions about LBC on Zhihu |
|---|
| Q_1 What is the status of left-behind children when they grow up? |
| Q_2 What is the experience of left-behind children? |
| Q_3 What kind of psychological problems do left-behind children have when they grow up? |
Basic information on the three studied questions posted on the Zhihu website.
| Question | Questioner | Questioner’s Occupation | Time | Degree of Attention | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Question Followers | Number of Views | ||||
| Q_1 | ID1 | Art worker | 25 July 2014 | 3936 | 1,403,306 |
| Q_2 | ID2 | Parenting teacher | 3 November 2015 | 1627 | 712,961 |
| Q_3 | Anonymous | Unknown | 10 May 2014 | 551 | 334,302 |
Basic information on responses to the three questions about LBC.
| Question | Number of Responses | Time Frame | Gender of Responder | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Male | Female | Unknown | |||
| Q_1 | 776 | July 2014~December 2019 | 542 | 144 | 80 |
| Q_2 | 561 | November 2015~December 2019 | 345 | 137 | 79 |
| Q_3 | 138 | May 2015~January 2020 | 90 | 24 | 24 |
Figure 1Basic principles of a web crawler.
Key words for data extraction.
| Lexical for Searching LBC’s Text | |
|---|---|
| Negative words | Get out, nightmares, quarrel, bullying, sexual assault, self-abasement, depression. |
| Death-related words | Suicide, taking drugs, die, despair, cut wrist. |
Text information of control group.
| Questions of Control Group | Number of Answer |
|---|---|
| How do you spend your day? | 297 |
| What’s your daily routine like? | 66 |
| Total | 363 |
| Total number of words | 209,119 |
Count results of four types of vocabulary between the LBC group and the control group.
| Four Types of Vocabulary | LBC | Control Group | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Counts | Proportion of | Counts | Proportion of | |
| First-person singular pronoun | 39,723 | 3.92% | 1530 | 0.73% |
| Negative words | 46,655 | 4.60% | 3212 | 1.54% |
| Past tense verbs | 12,351 | 1.22% | 959 | 0.46% |
| Death-related words | 3049 | 0.30% | 311 | 0.15% |
| Total | 101,778 | 10.40% | 6012 | 2.88% |
Figure 2Histogram of four types of vocabulary between the LBC group and the control group.
Bilateral t-test results of personal narrative text differences between the LBC group and the control group.
| First-Person Singular Pronouns | Negative Words | Past Tense Verbs | Death-Related Words | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
| −20.0929 | −15.8535 | −14.0989 | −9.65936 |
| 2.76 × 10−81 | 5.90 × 10−52 | 2.19 × 10−42 | 3.36 × 10−21 |
p < 0.05.
Five representative personal narrative texts of LBC related to child neglect.
| LBC_1: Every time I call [my parents], their first sentence will always be: “What happened?” I said nothing. “I just wanted to talk to you.” The rest of the conversation would be, they would answer whatever I asked, and then there would be no follow-up. Now when I call them, it’s mostly because I went out of money. It’s not often, once a month. It’s like having a period, which sometimes it’s early but sometimes late. |
| LBC_2: What I heard most since I was a child is, “Your parents work hard for you to make money, so you have to be obedient and don’t disappoint your parents.” “Your parents don’t want you anymore, so you need to live in someone else’s house.” “Get out of here, who wants your parents’ rotten money?” “Your parents have done a lot of evil in their previous life to have a child like you, just like a debt collector.” “If you hadn’t been born, your brother would have been the only child. How happy your parents would be.” … It’s really like a nightmare. |
| LBC_3: Although my parents sent letters and made phone calls from time to time, they never sent me a penny. All I remember is that my grandmother had a bad temper and used to quarrel and fight with my grandfather. Every day I took a lunch box and rice to the school dining room with steamed rice, and then I took some pickles and ate them. Occasionally, my grandmother gave me a dime to buy food at school (I vaguely remember the food provided by the school is 1-3 dimes). The child does not understand the hardships of life at all (my grandmother recalled that I hadn’t eaten any sugar for three years). Then such days continued until nearly 6th grade. |
| LBC_4: When I was bullied at school, other children had parents supporting them, but I didn’t, so I could only endure sexual abuse. I had nowhere to ask for help when I was sexually assaulted (let me be anonymous). I am good at studying. My relatives like me and my teachers also like me, but I am still an introverted and self-abasement person. |
| LBC_5: There are still many drawbacks since I was little without my parents around me. For example, I haven’t developed good study habits since I was young. There was very little homework in the countryside, so I could get first place casually in primary school. I have never studied seriously, and my grades were very unstable when I went to school in the city. Before I went to school in the city, I never knew that I needed to take notes in class, because no one took notes in my countryside school, and the teachers would not tell you to do so as well. I never studied English in the rural elementary school for six years (there are English classes, but you know that). |
Five representative personal narrative texts of LBC related to depression and suicide.
| LBC_6: When I first entered college, I felt low self-esteem so that I shed tears in the middle of the night. I like to put pressure on myself, hoping to make myself better. I don’t care about people in relationships and don’t know how to socialize with opposite-gender friends. Apart from genetic inheritance, the main reason for that is the experience of left-behind children. No matter what I can achieve in the future, I will not be happy inside. |
| LBC_7: Now I am inferior, sensitive, and insecure. I feel that my parents are terribly unfamiliar, and sometimes I feel embarrassed to stay with them. I hated them, why they gave birth to us but don’t care about us. |
| LBC_8: As a senior left-behind child, I lack of love, insecure, strong defensive heart, not talkative, and love to be alone. |
| LBC_9: I had severe depression five years ago. At that time, I had auditory hallucinations and committed suicide twice, and I am still taking medication. I was rescued by my parents. The first time I used a pair of tweezers in the toilet to stab my chest, and the second time I used underwear to strangle my neck in the hospital. Later, my mother called 120 (emergency) for me. I don’t know if everyone who wants to die has such despair as me. It just feels that in this world, there is really no love and no meaning in life. |