| Literature DB >> 35200267 |
Humaid O Al-Shamsi1,2,3,4, Amin M Abyad1,2,4, Saeed Rafii4,5.
Abstract
The United Arab Emirates (UAE) is one of the fastest growing economies with consequent increase in non-communicable diseases including cancer. The number of reported cases and mortality have been increasing in the UAE over the years, despite screening and early detection efforts which appear to be far from target coverage of the intended population. In this work, we highlight key elements of a proposed national cancer control plan for the UAE. The plan is still a work in progress and has not yet been officially adopted. A comprehensive and effective control plan requires accurate data, a reliable cancer registry, and periodic monitoring and evaluation. The UAE cancer control plan is being prepared in line with the WHO and EMRO framework, with defined objectives and goals. The objectives are to combat cancer, reduce incidence, control mortality, and improve outcomes and quality of life for cancer patients. There is also a focus on improving public health education, prevention, early detection, prompt diagnosis, treatment facilitation, continuity of care, performance evaluation, training of workforce, and research.Entities:
Keywords: arab; cancer control; middle east; prevention; registry
Year: 2022 PMID: 35200267 PMCID: PMC8870909 DOI: 10.3390/clinpract12010016
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Clin Pract ISSN: 2039-7275
The most common primary malignant tumors in UAE for both genders, 2017 [3,5,6].
|
|
| ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Cancer Type | No. of Cases and % | Cancer Type | No. of Cases and % |
| Colorectal | 256 (13.67%) | Breast | 825 (36.67%) |
| Leukemia | 196 (10.46%) | Thyroid | 302 (13.42%) |
| Prostate | 155 (8.28%) | Colorectal | 166 (7.38%) |
| Skin | 134 (7.15%) | Leukemia | 118 (5.24%) |
| Lip, Oral cavity and Pharynx | 112 (5.98%) | Uterus | 111 (4.93%) |
| Thyroid | 110 (5.87%) | Cervix uteri | 82 (3.64%) |
| Non-Hodgkin Lymphoma | 107 (5.71%) | Skin | 74 (3.29%) |
| Bronchus and Lung | 103 (5.50%) | Ovary | 70 (3.11%) |
| Urinary bladder | 91 (4.86%) | Non-Hodgkin Lymphoma | 65 (2.89%) |
| Stomach | 59 (3.15%) | Lip, Oral cavity, and Pharynx | 39 (1.73%) |
Five commonest pediatric tumors in the UAE, 2017 [3,5,6].
| Cancer Type | No. of Cases and % |
|---|---|
| Leukemia | 61 (41.8%) |
| Kidney and Renal pelvis | 11 (7.5%) |
| Non-Hodgkin Lymphoma | 10 (6.8%) |
| Liver and intrahepatic bile ducts | 8 (5.5%) |
| Brain and CNS | 7 (4.8%) |
Screening targets and performance compared to the targets set nationally or by the World Health Organization (WHO), based on unpublished data from the Ministry of Health and Prevention.
| Type of Cancer | Target Age Group | Examination | % Of the Population Eligible for Screening Target Age Group | 2017 Investigated Result | Population Coverage Ratio for Target Groups |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Breast | Female ≥ 40 years | Mammogram every two years | 50% | 20,752 | 6.68% |
| Colon | Females and males ≥ 40–75 years | FIT Test after every 2 years | 50% | 18,399 | 1.6% |
| Cervix | Females All sexually active females, symptom free, aged 25–65 years | Cervical pap smear test should be after every 3 years | 33% | 39,281 | 7% |
Causes and reformatory actions to improve screening rates in the UAE.
| Cause/Factor | Root Causes | Reformatory Actions |
|---|---|---|
| Access to the service |
Difficulty in access to service Cost The location of examination centers Health insurance does not include screening Population growth and change in the population pyramid Younger population not in recommendation or guidelines |
Mass education/campaign on screening and early detection Address the target groups at educational institutes, media, etc. Launch mobile screening services, such as Mammogram, Cervical Examination, Stool Examination (FIT test) medical and advice Covering the cost through health insurance, or delivering it free Develop discounted rates for screening packages Setting unified cost and quality for cancer screening Establish specialized center for cancer detection |
| Mechanism and quality control of cancer screening services |
The dedication and commitment of health authorities and political leadership to the targets and indicators of screening and early detection programs The need of a unified national program for cancer screening Non-existent cancer screening programs Poor compliance in application of the national screening guidelines The absence of a dedicated team to monitor the quality of services Lack of human resources for auditing, and lack of audit to assess quality of services |
Activating a national program for early detection of cancer that includes a central call system and text messaging to call the target high risk groups Establishing a mechanism and unified targets to measure the coverage rate Linking the Emirates ID to cancer screening record Committing all service providers in achieving the target percentage Activating the national registry for screening and early detection Integrating primary care and screening Building capacity and logistical resources Assigning coordinators for quality assurance Establishing screening services Establishing a Quality Assurance and monitoring department for screening services Integrating screening and early detection in insurance coverage Monitoring impact of screening on outcome mortality |
| Community awareness for the importance of early examination and Detection of Cancer |
Lack of awareness campaigns Lack of education and understanding of cancer Lack of integration of information about cancer into the educational curricula Lack of availability of smart awareness applications Lack of awareness about early detection programs Lack of awareness of global awareness days for different types of cancer |
Conducting a Cancer Awareness Measurement assessment by questionnaire in the community Intensifying awareness campaigns on the importance of early detection Information about the availability and locations of services Involving prominent and famous figures to disseminate awareness Emphasize the importance of early detection of cancer Develop a public information website Incorporating cancer information into educational programs, and campaigns in universities/schools Include representatives from the relevant authorities Conducting free campaigns to detect cancer during ambulatory care Smart awareness campaigns and applications to help community members make the right decisions and get early detection tests |
| End User factors influencing the screening and detection service |
Emotional factors
Fear Shyness Anxiety about the outcome Hospital Admission Practical factors
Absence from Work Transportation Understanding and education
Lack of knowledge Misconceptions and Stigma Confidentiality of the information Awareness of the importance of examination The Cultural differences in society affecting concepts of prevention and early detection | |
| Capacity Building in Human Resources and Logistic Support |
Lack of competencies Inadequate distribution of human resources Lack of logistical resources and modern equipment |
Increasing the budget allocation for early detection programs Increasing the logistical and human resources to increase the coverage rate by training and manpower Linking the annual performance of general practitioners in primary healthcare centers Hosting independent international experts regularly to evaluate the program and staff Raising the level of efficiency of employees through training courses |
Vision, objectives, and strategy of the UAE cancer control plan.
| Vision | To reduce deaths through multiple interventions including early detection of cancer in the UAE |
| Message | We fight cancer in the UAE hand in hand with our partners and work with innovation and exercising best practices. We are embarking to assemble comprehensive competencies and human resources for a disease-free UAE society |
| Objectives of the Strategy | 1. To strengthen the planning and implement it at the national level to combat cancer in the United Arab Emirates |
Recommendations of WHO and EMRO for cancer control plans.
| 1. | Governance: Focus on developing a strategy and a multi-sectoral committee for the prevention and control of cancer; while ensuring the availability of a sustained budget, adequate national cancer rates, setting costs for care and treatment packages, and determining a mechanism to cover treatment expenses with equity |
| 2. | Prevention: Focus on adopting healthy life by combating smoking, encouraging physical activity, and healthy food in line with the Non-Communicable Disease control framework/plan. The focus should include vaccinations against hepatitis and HPV |
| 3. | Early detection: The strategic directions in this area are based on four axes: Awareness of the population about early warning signs and symptoms of cancer, education, continuing education for health staff on the early signs and symptoms of the common cancers, prompt diagnosis and referral for patients, screening programs, and a continuous evaluation of the effectiveness of these programs. The focus should also be employed on accessibility and the affordability of diagnostic tests for suspected cases. |
| 4. | Treatment: Focus on developing and implementing protocols and best clinical practices based on evidence-based guidelines. Assess human resource needs and focus on accessibility and affordability of cancer care services and extend affordable treatment packages. This must also include the development of integrated, coordinated and prompt referral systems to avoid delays in diagnosis and treatment. |
| 5. | Palliative care: There is a need to develop integrated multidisciplinary palliative care services including pain care and psychological support, available in hospitals and primary healthcare centers. Developing and implementing protocols for best evidence based clinical practice and integrated care, and a swift and early transition. Palliative care should be included in medical academic programs. |
| 6. | Research and Surveillance: Develop a population based national cancer registry, hospital registries, and monitor these with an accredited quality assurance program. The area includes focusing on developing and implementing an integrated plan for research according to the priorities of the country. |
Strategic axes of the UAE cancer control plan.
| First Area |
|---|
| 1. Education and understanding |
| Enhancing health awareness about the knowledge of cancer, risk factors leading to cancer and correction of misconceptions about the disease |
| 2. Prevention |
| Launching awareness campaigns and prevention programs against cancer and known causes |
| 3. Early detection |
| Detecting cancer in the early stages to increase the patients’ survival and outcome. It involves periodic clinical assessments and reduces the delays in appropriate treatment referrals to receive treatment promptly |
| 4. Rapid diagnosis |
| A healthcare center should assess condition of the patient promptly in a systematic integrated way and take appropriate medical decisions based on a developed pathway |
|
|
| 5. Treatment |
| Provide appropriately validated clinical practices in line with international guidelines for treating cancer according to disease stage to improve outcomes |
| 6. Ongoing care |
| Provide timely transition to post-treatment and palliative care services for cancer patients and educating them about the appropriate ways to live with the disease and directions to avoid disease recurrence |
|
|
| 7. Performance measurements |
| Establishing national records including all data sources in a central place and assemble comprehensive data of high quality, accuracy, and to record information about a disease |
| 8. Workforce capacity building |
| Providing a qualified and appropriately trained team to deliver prevention, treatment, continuity of care for patients; and provision of suitable training facilities for the workforce |
| 9. Research |
| Cancer research improves the diagnosis, treatment, outcome, and enhance quality of life by translating quality research and clinical trials for improvements in personalized care |
Detailed strategic and executive framework of the UAE cancer control plan.
| Strategic Axis | I. Education and Understanding | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Main objectives | Application mechanisms | Measurement indicators | The executing agency | Follow-up |
| Raising health awareness about cancer and associated risk factors and correcting the misconceptions | Conducting a national survey on awareness in society assessing knowledge of risk factors and opinions about access to services and early examination | Survey completion rate | Ministry of Health and Protection | Ministry of Health and Protection |
| Raising health awareness about cancer risk factors Inclusion of cancer in scientific curricula The initiative of the researcher/young intellectual which aims and implements the cancer awareness campaigns in school and university | Number of awareness campaigns | Stakeholders | ||
| Awareness campaigns synchronized with designated international days for each cancer type | Number of awareness campaigns | Stakeholders | ||
|
|
| |||
| Main objectives | Application mechanisms | Measurement indicators | The executing agency | Follow-up |
| Monitoring of risk factors between different groups in society and encouragement to adopt healthy lifestyles | Physical activity Inclusion and intensification of physical activity compulsory in schools Campaigns to encourage exercise and walk in the community Creation of more tracks for walking and parks within reach of people | The number of awareness programs | Ministry of Health and Prevention | Ministry of Health and Prevention |
| Healthy foods Develop educational programs on healthy diet | The number of awareness programs | |||
| Assessment of the presence of carcinogenic factors in the environment and highlighting the environmental pollution and exposure to radiation | The number of awareness programs | |||
| Awareness campaigns about the harms of smoking and shisha in young people | The number of awareness programs | |||
| Providing preventive vaccinations | Hepatitis B vaccination for prevention of liver cancer for high-risk population | Hepatitis C vaccination coverage rate | Ministry of Health and Protection/All health authorities | |
| HPV vaccination in schools and society for girls aged 13–26 years to prevent cervical cancer | Coverage rate of the targeted category | |||
|
|
| |||
| Main objectives | Application mechanisms | Measurement indicators | The executing agency | Follow-up |
| Create a national program for early detection of cancer | Development of a central public electronic recall system for early detection services and identification by e-mail |
Completion rate Population coverage rate in target groups | Ministry of Health and Prevention | Ministry of Health and Prevention |
| Create a national platform or program for registration of cases that underwent early examination for cancer | ||||
| Increase the capacity of logistical and human resources to increase population coverage | ||||
| Health insurance and financial coverage for early disclosure |
Insurance coverage for early diagnostic examinations Discounted packages for early detection and uniform prices in the private and public sector | Completion rate | ||
| Increase awareness about the importance of |
Awareness campaigns on the importance of early screening Facilitate visitors to healthcare centers Target age and annual performance linked for health workers in early examination centers The rate of turnout to early examination. Appointing clinical nurse specialists to educate and support the team |
Number of awareness campaign Percentage of cases from categories of target age transferred for early examination Number of specialized workforces that was redundant | Ministry of Health and Prevention | Ministry of Health and Prevention |
| Establish a framework and governance policy for quality assurance and |
Develop a framework for standardization and best of practices Clinical pathways for early cancer examination For early screening of breast, cervical, and colon cancer among the target age groups in the population | Percentage of policy completion and frameworks | Ministry of Health and Prevention | |
| Raising awareness of common symptoms of cancer in society | Awareness campaigns about the symptoms of the most common cancers in the community | Number of awareness campaigns | All participating parties | |
|
|
| |||
| Main objectives | Application mechanisms | Measurement indicators | The executing agency | Follow-up |
| Establish an effective referral system between different levels of care for cancer patients |
Implementing the Service Access Policy so that access time for diagnostic and therapeutic services is reduced every year |
Average waiting time from the time of onset to GP referred to the specialist Average waiting time from doctor’s appointment till the diagnosis Average waiting time from diagnosis time until start of the treatment Average waiting time from GP appointment to time received treatment | Service providers, | Ministry of Health and Prevention |
| Rapid lung cancer diagnosis initiative | Launch of rapid mobile investigation clinics for early detection of lung cancer using X-ray, CT scan, and breath examination for people susceptible to lung cancer | Number of beneficiaries | Entities involved in cooperation | |
|
|
| |||
| Main objectives | Application mechanisms | Measurement indicators | The executing agency | Follow-up |
| Covering the cost of cancer treatment | Adopt a Pay for performance model (Personalized reimbursement model). Dubai health authority is providing therapeutic services where the treatment is covered by insurance and pharmaceutical companies. The results are then evaluated on treatment response/efficacy | Number of beneficiaries | Healthcare service providers | Ministry of Health and Prevention |
| Accreditation of centers of excellence for cancer treatment | Preparing for specialized centers of excellence (third level) in cancer treatment and its complications and rehabilitation centers | Number of accredited centers of excellence | Stakeholders | |
|
|
| |||
| Main objectives | Application mechanisms | Measurement indicators | The executing agency | Follow-up |
| Development of palliative care services |
Studying the work on adding the palliative service in health centers with easy access of services and develop a guide for implementing a palliative care program |
Percentage of completion of the guide | Ministry of Health and Prevention | Ministry of Health and Prevention |
|
Creation of teams to support cancer patients. The team consists of patients who have recovered or are under-treatment The team meets periodically for psychology support among patients |
Team achievement percentage Number of beneficiaries | Stakeholders | ||
|
|
| |||
| Main objectives | Application mechanisms | Measurement indicators | The executing agency | Follow-up |
| Annual evaluation for anti-cancer performance indicators |
Establishing a registry for early detection of cancer Preparing and developing a registry for early detection and development Early detection data collection | The percentage of completion of the national registry, population coverage for early cancer screening among the targeted age groups | Ministry of Health and Prevention | Ministry of Health and Prevention |
|
Create a unified national electronic registry for cancer | The percentage of completion of the national cancer registry | Ministry of Health and Prevention | Ministry of Health and Prevention | |
| Measuring indications: The rate of detection of positive cases by early cancer examination Average number of cases detected in late stages of cancer Waiting period, since the case was referred before to the general practitioner to complete the early examinations | Report completion percentage rate of time commitment | Ministry of Health and Prevention | Ministry of Health and Prevention | |
|
Measurement of the KAP index (knowledge, attitude, and practice-to assess acceptance) for the community’s understanding of cancer screening | Report completion rate | Ministry of Health and Prevention | Ministry of Health and Prevention | |
|
|
| |||
| Main objectives | Application mechanisms | Measurement indicators | The executing agency | Follow-up |
| The priority for epidemiological and clinical research of cancer | Research work to discover concepts, knowledge and opinions about cancer, risk factors, and screening | Research completion rate | Ministry of Health and Prevention | Ministry of Health and Prevention |
| Develop a research agenda for the three most common cancers (breast, colon, and thyroid) | Agenda completion rate | Ministry of Health and Prevention | ||
|
|
| |||
| Main objectives | Application mechanisms | Measurement indicators | The executing agency | Follow-up |
| Providing qualified human resources in the developing field of cancer | Complete medical team specialized in treatingcancer in secondary and specialty care Specialized doctors Clinical nurse specialist X-ray technicians | The percentage of increase in workforce | Ministry of Health and Prevention | Ministry of Health and Prevention |
| Raising the efficiency of employees, healthcare professionals | Creation of training programs for healthcare workers in the field of cancer and assess the risk factors such as: Awareness and health education Early detection Palliative care | The number of training programs | Ministry of Health and Prevention | |