KowsalyaDevi Pavuluri1, Ethan Yang2, Vinay Ayyappan2, Kanchan Sonkar2, Zheqiong Tan2,3, Caitlin M Tressler2, Shaowei Bo1, Adnan Bibic4, Kristine Glunde2,5,6, Michael T McMahon1,4. 1. Division of MR Research, The Russell H. Morgan Department of Radiology and Radiological Science; The Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore, MD. 2. Division of Cancer Imaging Research, The Russell H. Morgan Department of Radiology and Radiological Science; The Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore, MD. 3. Department of Medical Laboratory, The Central Hospital of Wuhan, Tongji Medical College, Huazhong University of Science and Technology, Wuhan, Hubei, China. 4. F.M. Kirby Research Center for Functional Brain Imaging, Kennedy Krieger Institute, Baltimore, MD. 5. The Department of Biological Chemistry, The Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore, MD. 6. Sidney Kimmel Comprehensive Cancer Center, The Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore, MD.
Breast cancer remains a highly prevalent global disease, with nearly 2.3 million new diagnoses and more than 600,000 deaths in 2020 alone, making it the leading cause of cancer death worldwide 1. The standard-of-care diagnostic screenings rely on x-ray mammography 2, except for high-risk women who are monitored by magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) with gadolinium-containing contrast agents administered to highlight breast tumors in T1-weighted MRI through alterations in tumor perfusion 3. This method produces high-resolution images with exquisite soft tissue contrast and has long been recognized as an outstanding tool for characterizing breast cancer and other malignancies 4-6. However, there are concerns to apply this to patients with poor kidney function 7, 8, and several studies have pointed to the bioaccumulation of gadolinium-containing MRI contrast agents after years of injection on an annual basis, including in children 9-11, raising concern about their long-term effects.Chemical Exchange Saturation Transfer (CEST) MRI has emerged as a possible alternative to gadolinium contrast MRI. This important technology for molecular imaging indirectly detects low concentrations of compounds with suitable labile protons through the application of frequency selective radiofrequency (RF) saturation pulses on these protons. These RF saturation pulses result in a net loss in water longitudinal magnetization through transfer of saturation by chemical exchange 12-15. The chemical shift dependence is an important feature of CEST MRI, allowing discrimination among different agents through what has been described as multi-color 16-18 or multi-frequency CEST MRI 14, 19. To date, glucose (and analogs) CEST imaging has shown the most promise for tumor detection based on testing this technology on animal models and patients in clinical scanners 20-22. Similarly, we have recently discovered several salicylates that possess favorable properties for CEST MRI, allowing highly amplified and specific detection of these compounds 23-25. Of them, salicylic acid (SA) proved to be the most promising because of its large proton shift from water at 9.6 ppm and its suitable exchange rate, making its signal easily discernible among other metabolites 23.SA is an attractive CEST contrast agent owing to the potency of its parent metabolite, acetyl salicylic acid (ASA), better known as aspirin 26, 27. A popular non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drug (NSAID) 28, aspirin is the most widely used drug on the market with 44,000 tons consumed globally per year 29. Beyond its usefulness in pain management, several epidemiological studies have associated its use with chemoprevention from colorectal, breast and pancreatic cancers 30-36, including a 41% reduction for the risk of developing luminal A breast cancer associated with lifetime use of aspirin 31, 37. The therapeutic action of aspirin results from its irreversible inhibition of cyclooxygenase (COX)-1 and COX-2 through the acetylation of the serine residue in the catalytic site, which in turn lowers prostaglandin synthesis and reduces inflammation, pain, fever, blood flow, vascular permeability, and immune activation 38-41. This mechanism converts aspirin to SA, providing a direct link between aspirin metabolism and CEST signal.Several previous studies have explored the possibility of NSAIDs for MRI. For example, Kim et al. directly labelled NSAIDs with gadolinium chelates to detect their accumulation with standard T1 weighted imaging 42. While promising, this method suffers from the same limitations as other gadolinium-based techniques. In another example, Zacharias et al. used 13C-labeled aspirin and hyperpolarization to follow its biodistribution and metabolism with magnetic resonance spectroscopy for a short time period of a few seconds until the hyperpolarized signal had decayed 43. The short timespan makes this method challenging to implement on clinical scanners or provide spectroscopic imaging beyond minutes. CEST MRI with unlabeled aspirin overcomes the toxicity from gadolinium-based MRI and time limitations of hyperpolarization. In this study, we examined the possibility of injecting aspirin as an activable theranostic MRI agent for breast cancer. Specifically, we sought to study the effects of COX-1 and COX-2 expression levels on SA CEST contrast and prostaglandin E2 (PGE2) production. Our results showed strong and similar CEST MRI contrast for triple negative breast cancer cells in vitro and orthotopic breast tumor xenografts in mice in vivo, regardless of their COX-1/-2 expression levels, while PGE2 significantly decreased in the high COX-1/-2 model. The robustness of the SA CEST MRI contrast makes this novel method a viable contender for future cancer diagnostic applications.
Results
The salicylates are particularly well suited for detection by CEST MRI owing to the presence of an intramolecular hydrogen bond between the carboxylate anion at position 1 on the phenyl ring and a labile hydroxyl proton at the adjacent position 2 which is not present in aspirin (Figure ). We have previously discovered that replacements of this carboxyl group could remove the contrast at ~9.6 ppm 14, 15. The metabolic pathway for aspirin and SA is depicted in Figure . Downstream aspirin metabolites display perturbed hydrogen bonding arrangements through deacetylation, or addition of glucuronic acid, glycine or hydroxyl groups 44-46. We first sought to isolate these metabolites in phantoms based on their CEST MR spectra at various saturation powers. In humans, three conjugates of salicylate are formed directly: the main metabolite salicylurate (SU), and two glucuronides, i.e. salicyl acyl glucuronide (SAG) and salicyl phenolic glucuronide (SPG) 47.As seen from and Figure , the free -OH group in SA produces CEST contrast, while SAG and SU do not display CEST contrast at ~9.6 ppm. Because SPG does not contain an -OH group at position 2 (Figure ), there is no signal for this metabolite at 9.6 ppm either 24. Contrast is retained but shifted to 8.5 ppm for 2,5-dihydroxybenzoic acid (2,5-DHB), which is a minor metabolite, constituting less than 5% of eliminated drug 47. We analyzed our CEST MR data to measure the exchange rates (k) of the main SA metabolites at a range of pH values between 6.3 and 7.2 (). CEST MTRasym spectra of these metabolites for pH values between 6.3 and 7.2 at RF saturation power (B1) = 6 μΤ are shown in . We have also determined that the free -OH group in SA retains its contrast in blood serum (). We have thus identified conditions that isolate SA from other metabolites when the saturation pulse is placed at 9.6 ppm, with aspirin (ASA) and SPG not being detected at all by CEST MRI due to the absence of a hydroxyl group.Aspirin permanently inhibits COX-1/COX-2 through serine acetylation in the active site, producing SA as a result 26. Given that COX-1 and -2 enzymes catalyze the rate-limiting step of prostaglandin synthesis and that the COX-PGE2 pathway in particular promotes carcinogenesis and tumor progression 48, 49, we hypothesized that noninvasive CEST-MRI monitoring of SA accumulation in cancer cells and tumors could provide a readout of COX-PGE2 pathway blockage. To test this hypothesis, we first determined the COX-1/-2 expression levels of four candidate breast cancer cell lines, MDA-MB-231, MDA-MB-468, SKBR3 and SUM159, by gel electrophoresis and Western blotting. From our results (Figure ), SUM159 displayed the highest COX-1 level, while MDA-MB-231 had the lowest COX-1 expression. SUM159 was the only cell line with detectable COX-2 expression. Consequently, we selected SUM159 as our high COX model and MDA-MB-231 as our low COX model for further experimentation. An ELISA PGE2 assay of these cells revealed an approximately 50% higher PGE2 level in the SUM159 cell line compared to the MDA-MB-231 cell line (Figure ), which was 14.08 ± 1.04 ng/10 million cells compared to 10.75 ± 0.38 ng/10 million cells for SUM159 and MDA-MB-231 cells, respectively. Treatment of both cell lines with 25 mM aspirin for 20 minutes led to an approximate 50% drop in PGE2 levels to 10.16 +/- 1.28 ng/10 million cells and 5.71 +/- 0.26 ng/10 million cells for SUM159 and MDA-MB-231 cells, respectively. Finally, we measured the CEST MR signal to detect SA buildup by measuring MTRasym at ~9.6 ppm. Despite the significant differences in COX-1/-2 expression and PGE2 levels, the overall SA CEST MRI signal was similar in the two cell lines, with MDA-MB-231 cells at an average of 3% (Figure ) and SUM159 at an average of 2% (Figure ). This suggests that the COX-PGE2 pathway is not solely responsible for converting aspirin to SA and thereby generating the CEST MR signal.We proceeded to further evaluate aspirin as an activatable contrast agent for detecting SA CEST MRI in vivo. First, we assessed the feasibility of detecting SA buildup in vivo by monitoring the clearance of SA and aspirin through the kidneys in healthy mice. We injected 100 µL of 300 mM solutions of either injectable aspirin (DL-Lys aspirin) or sodium salicylate and collected CEST MR images of both kidneys, which are known to be the main clearance route for aspirin and its metabolites. While direct injections of sodium salicylate led to approximately 5% CEST MRI contrast throughout the kidneys, injection of DL-Lys aspirin resulted in an about 3-fold higher contrast (~15%) as shown in Figure . Dynamic SA CEST MRI contrast maps were obtained with a saturation pulse at 9.6 ppm at various time points following administration of DL-Lys aspirin or SA and are displayed in Figure . At 6 min following administration, <2% CEST MRI contrast was observed for both aspirin and SA. After 6 min, the renal contrast uptake rate was faster for DL-Lys aspirin compared to that of SA, with both peaking at 30-40 min following administration. At this time point, the CEST MRI contrast was 3 times higher for aspirin compared to that of SA. These observations demonstrate that deacetylation of injectable aspirin generates larger SA CEST MRI contrast than direct injection of SA.After confirming the SA CEST MRI contrast in healthy mouse kidneys, we applied this approach in the low COX-1/-2 MDA-MB-231 (n=4) and high COX-1/-2 SUM159 (n=4) breast tumor xenograft model in mice. In MDA-MB-231 tumor bearing mice, sixty minutes after injecting the mice with 100 µL of 300 mM DL-Lys aspirin, we observed about 1/3 of SA CEST MRI contrast buildup in tumor compared to that of kidney, with control muscle tissue displaying no change in contrast (Figure ). CEST MR images acquired from kidney and tumor of representative mice pre- and post-aspirin injection are shown without masking in . Compared to the low COX-1 and COX-2 model MDA-MB-231, the SUM159 tumor xenografts (n=4) contained slightly elevated levels of SA initially after DL-Lys aspirin injection, which continued to build up to comparable contrast levels in both tumor xenograft models at around 6% irrespective of their COX-1/-2 expression level (Figure ). CEST MRI images acquired at 60 minutes post aspirin injection without tumor mask and dynamic SA CEST MRI images of all biological replicates for both SUM159 and MDA-MB-231 tumor xenografts are presented in , respectively. The overall enhancement pattern in the two orthotopic tumor xenograft models was similar (Figure ). In some cases, we observed elevated SA CEST MRI contrast near the tumor rim, most likely representing vascularized, metabolically active cells in the rim of tumors with respect to a hypoxic or necrotic tumor core 50. We compared gadolinium enhanced MRI (Gadoteridol) with SA CEST MRI results in three MDA-MB-231 and three SUM159 mice, where gadolinium enhanced MRI was acquired 2 days prior to their CEST MRI acquisition to ensure complete clearance of gadolinium-containing contrast agent prior to aspirin injection. These comparative measurements revealed contrast enhancement in both breast tumor xenograft models with both types of contrast enhanced MRI (). Intra-tumoral PGE2 levels of the two tumor models were significantly different. SUM159 tumor xenografts contained a more than five-fold increase in PGE2 compared to MDA-MB-231 tumor xenografts (Figure ), measuring 89.2 ± 7.1 µg/g and 54.9 ± 16.8 µg/g in SUM159 tumors treated with 0 mM and 300 mM aspirin, respectively, versus 14.5 ± 7.8 µg/g and 7.9 ± 2.7 µg/g for the MDA-MB-231 tumor xenografts. Western blot analysis of the tumor xenograft protein lysates consistently showed much higher COX-1/-2 levels in SUM159 tumor xenografts compared to MDA-MB-231 tumor xenografts (Figure ). While PGE2 levels did decrease as a result of aspirin treatment in both tumor models (Figure ), Western blot data did not indicate a significant difference in COX-1/-2 expression level following treatment (Figure ).While SA CEST MRI signal buildup in tumors was not indicative of COX-1/-2 expression level or COX-PGE2 pathway activity in the tumor, the overall contrast did align with the concentration of the injected aspirin. Intravenous injection of 300 mM of aspirin in mice growing MDA-MB-231 tumor xenografts resulted in 7% CEST MRI contrast at 60 minutes following injection, while mice treated with 200 mM and 150 mM displayed ~3% and ~1.5% tumor CEST MRI contrast at the 60-minute time point, respectively (Figure ). The overall SA distribution and the resulting CEST MRI enhancement pattern was similar for the three different injected doses of aspirin (Figure ). The PGE2 levels consistently decreased with increasing aspirin dose, which was not significant in the low COX-1/-2 model of MDA-MB-231 tumor xenografts (). Finally, we orthogonally confirmed the observed aspirin metabolite levels in SUM159 tumor xenografts by using matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization (MALDI) time of flight (TOF) mass spectrometry tissue profiling. MALDI-TOF showed that in SUM159 tumors, the only detected aspirin metabolite was SA with no detection of 2,5-DHB in these spectra as compared to MALDI-TOF mass spectra of pure standard compounds and matrix background ().
Discussion
In this study, we have demonstrated the use of commercially available aspirin as an activatable theranostic CEST agent for breast cancer imaging and have developed an innovative CEST MR imaging strategy for monitoring aspirin metabolism. We determined the feasibility of detecting SA CEST MRI contrast at ~9.6 ppm following aspirin addition to human breast cancer cells and set up optimized protocols for in vivo CEST MRI contrast monitoring of SA after intravenously administering aspirin. Systemic administration of aspirin generated up to 6% CEST MRI contrast in orthotopic triple-negative MDA-MB-231 and SUM159 breast tumor xenografts. This level of contrast was, on average, three times greater than that from directly injecting SA in the form of sodium salicylate. The higher contrast seen for aspirin injections than SA could be due to several factors including SA having a much greater affinity for albumin than aspirin and the differences in metabolic stability, pKa and lipid solubility which have been described previously 51. Also, in this study, we did not take into account differences in T1 as part of the analysis. T1 changes between different tissues or samples can have an impact on the amount of CEST contrast. Bloch simulations have shown that 20% reduction in T1 reduce the CEST contrast by 1% 52. Since aspirin has low toxicity, is used in cancer chemoprevention 53, and readily available worldwide, CEST MRI with intravenous aspirin injection may be a viable dynamic contrast-enhanced imaging approach for detecting breast cancer with theranostic effects. The tumor CEST MRI contrast detected following aspirin injection was specific to SA, as confirmed by MALDI-TOF analyses of treated versus untreated tumor tissues from our study. These MALDI-TOF experiments ruled out any presence of 2,5-DHB in the tumor tissues from aspirin-injected mice, which would generate CEST MRI signal close by at ~8. 5 ppm if it were present.Since aspirin is a well-known inhibitor of COX-1 and COX-2, both of which deacetylate aspirin to form SA, we tested if the amount of in vivo SA CEST MRI contrast generated would be affected by COX-1 and COX-2 expression levels of the breast tumor xenograft models used. However, our results revealed no such correlation, as both the low COX-1/-2 model MDA-MB-231 as well as the high COX-1/-2 model SUM159 contained similar levels of in vivo SA CEST MRI contrast. These results suggest that most of the injected aspirin was already metabolized to SA prior to arriving at the tumor xenografts. This can be explained by the active hydrolysis of aspirin in the blood and liver by aspirin esterases such as cholinesterases and carboxylesterases in humans, within minutes upon intravenous injection, as well as the presence of COX-1/-2 enzymes in blood serum and liver 27, 54. Despite this, the PGE2 levels in both tumor xenograft models decreased following aspirin injection, particularly for the high COX-1/-2 expressing SUM159 tumor model, aligning with previous studies on the mechanism of action of NSAIDs on prostaglandin production and indicating a therapeutic effect from the aspirin injection that generated in vivo SA CEST MRI contrast 26. This observation suggests that the concentration of injected aspirin was at a sufficiently high dose such that enough unbound intact aspirin successfully reached the tumor to produce the inhibitory effect. Based on this proposed mechanism, this new aspirin-enhanced CEST MRI method can be successfully applied to other cancer models with varying levels of COX-1/-2 expression as well 55-57.Our new approach of SA detection by CEST MRI using aspirin injection for contrast generation could be translated into a powerful tool for cancer imaging with possible future applications in breast, renal, liver and brain imaging. Currently, colorimetric methods 29, 44, and chromatography-based approaches, such as high-pressure liquid chromatography (HPLC) 44, 45, 58, are routine for aspirin quantitation. HPLC is particularly powerful for identifying and quantifying the amount of drug and metabolites in blood or urine. Unfortunately, these chromatography-based methods are limited to the analysis of body fluids and cannot accomplish in vivo characterization of drug activity. Moreover, radioactive labeling of aspirin with 14C-labeled carboxyl and 14C- or 3H-labeled acetyl groups and scintillation radiography have been used extensively to understand the pharmacokinetics and inhibitory mechanism of aspirin/SA in both animals and humans 59-61. However, the need for radiochemical synthesis and difficulties with accurate quantification are limitations of scintigraphy-based methods. Given that this SA CEST MRI approach is noninvasive and does not require radiolabeling, it could be used for quantitatively studying and identifying the biodistribution and pharmacokinetics of aspirin and salicylates, with clear applications in cancer detection.An important question remains on the clinical feasibility of SA CEST MRI. In our current preclinical mouse study, we have observed tumoral SA CEST MRI contrast with as little as 100 µL of 150 mM aspirin administered intravenously, which was roughly 120 mg/kg. This concentration is similar to daily high dose aspirin treatments currently administered in patients: 80-100 mg/kg orally or intravenously in children during the acute stage of Kawasaki disease 62 and ~67 mg/kg orally or intravenously per day in adults for migraine, as determined by the German Migraine and Headache Society and the German Society of Neurology 63-66. For comparison, a typical adult tablet is 325 mg or ~4 mg/kg. It is possible that these high aspirin dosages currently administered in the clinic may be sufficient for SA CEST MRI. In terms of safety, an even higher dose of 143 mg/kg would be required to develop even mild poisoning from orally administered aspirin 67. We also expect that the contrast generated by SA should be lower at 3T than 11.7T based on the reduced saturation powers available for 3T body transmit coils, and this will be the subject of future studies. In our previous human trial we employed D-glucose as a CEST contrast agent, with chemical shifts and exchange rates that are significantly less suitable for CEST imaging than those of SA. Nevertheless for D-glucose, sufficient contrast was observed for detection of uptake on a 7T instrument, with the prior mouse tumor study showing similar contrast as we observed here at 11.7T 68. Furthermore, given that aspirin toxicity in humans will not become severe until more than 140 mg/kg is ingested 67, there remains a wide window for further studies to determine the adequate aspirin dosage for aspirin enhanced CEST MRI for patients in clinical settings.Like all drugs, aspirin is not without its own safety concerns. While low dosage of aspirin has been attributed to protective effects against numerous ailments including cataracts, cardiovascular diseases and multiple cancers 26, 27, 69, continued oral intake of aspirin at therapeutic doses has been associated with hepatotoxicity and a reversible decline in renal function, with a 10-fold increase in risk attributed to patients with rheumatoid arthritis and children with Reye's syndrome 7, 69. It also leads to increased bleeding events, though rarely have these led to fatal outcomes 69. At high doses employed in our SA CEST MRI study, aspirin has been linked to tinnitus and anemia 69. Despite this, injectable aspirin remains an attractive CEST MRI contrast agent because it does not accumulate in the body like gadolinium-based MRI contrast agents (GBCAs) 7. With an elimination half-life of 90 minutes in patients with normal kidney function, GBCA has been shown by several studies to accumulate in the brain, skin, liver and bone for both linear and chelated gadolinium compounds, possibly leading to erroneous interpretation of future MRI results and eventual toxicity 70. Therefore, we believe that SA CEST MRI through intravenous aspirin administration remains an attractive and promising avenue.
Authors: Katja Pinker; Fuki Shitano; Evis Sala; Richard K Do; Robert J Young; Andreas G Wibmer; Hedvig Hricak; Elizabeth J Sutton; Elizabeth A Morris Journal: J Magn Reson Imaging Date: 2017-11-02 Impact factor: 4.813
Authors: Michael T McMahon; Assaf A Gilad; Marco A DeLiso; Stacey M Cromer Berman; Jeff W M Bulte; Peter C M van Zijl Journal: Magn Reson Med Date: 2008-10 Impact factor: 4.668
Authors: Luis A García Rodríguez; Montse Soriano-Gabarró; Susan Bromley; Angel Lanas; Lucía Cea Soriano Journal: BMC Cancer Date: 2017-09-07 Impact factor: 4.430