| Literature DB >> 35187224 |
Zoë Rubins1, Barry J Gibson2, Andrew Chantry1,3.
Abstract
In recent years, there have been major advances in treatment options for myeloma and an improved prognosis as a result. There is a wealth of literature that explores the experience of specific treatments from a clinical perspective but there is comparatively little known about the reality of living with myeloma. This research aims to explore the experience of a myeloma diagnosis, to map out key patient experience literature, and examine common themes to support both medical practice and the planning of further research. Following a scoping review methodology, PubMed, StarPlus (the University of Sheffield online database), and Scopus were searched and 15 studies identified for analysis and qualitative synthesis. The literature indicated that myeloma was increasingly being experienced as a chronic condition rather than an acute diagnosis and that there are challenges meeting the needs of patients, understanding the overall symptom burden and the role of the family. The paper identifies emotional and psychological adjustment and coping as a potential area requiring further exploration in the context of a whole team approach to care.Entities:
Keywords: myeloma; narrative; scoping review
Year: 2022 PMID: 35187224 PMCID: PMC8855462 DOI: 10.1177/23743735221079133
Source DB: PubMed Journal: J Patient Exp ISSN: 2374-3735
Figure 1.The process of searching the literature and identifying relevant studies.
Inclusion and Exclusion Criteria Used During the Search Process.
| Inclusion criteria | Exclusion criteria |
|---|---|
| Reported original data | Reported in a language other than English |
| Focussed on patient experience of Myeloma | Published before 2000 |
| Primary data from patient's own perspective | Primary focus on therapeutic regimes |
| Published between 2000-2021 | Primary focus on Quality of Life |
| Another haematological cancer was the predominant focus | |
| Primary data from carer's perspective |
| Primary author | Year | Title | Participants | Method | Key findings | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ( | Cormican and Dowling | 2018 | Living with relapsed myeloma: Symptoms and self-care strategies | Ireland | Focus groups that were audio-taped, transcribed, and thematically analyzed. |
− Main themes—symptom burden of peripheral neuropathy, fatigue, steroid-induced effects. Self-care (risky behaviors), feeling vulnerable, and needing continuity − Managing a relapsing condition is a difficult process, patients would benefit from continuity in being supported through the range of issues (outlined above), as this helps with patient education and empowerment − a more structured approach could help with this and prevent patients presenting with very severe relapses |
| ( | Cormican and Dowling | 2016 | Managing relapsed myeloma: The views of patients, nurses, and doctors | Ireland | Focus groups and individual interviews with thematic analysis |
Main themes—“shared decision making with the expert patient” and “unpredictable disease journey” relapsed patients tend to be more informed and makes the experience easier—this relies on personal background reading however talk about palliation earlier Need for comfort and support—but often not accessed as prefer to keep to themselves Trust results in better outcomes but takes time to build Referrals to palliative care aren't timely Good example interview questions |
| ( | Cuffe et al | 2020 | Patients’ experience of living with multiple myeloma | Ireland | Unstructured interviews |
Delayed diagnosis and difficulty in communicating with health professionals enough were prevalent. Disparities with different cancers could be attributed to a lack of widespread knowledge Severe side effects, especially peripheral neuropathy has a large symptom burden Support from doctor or family is a personal preference Relapses induce fear and anxiety, therefore a holistic approach needed |
| ( | Hulin et al | 2017 | Living with the burden of relapse in multiple myeloma from the patient and physician perspective | United Kingdom, France, Germany, Italy, and
Spain | Semistructured interviews that we analyzed with Verbal
Rating Scales |
First relapse seemed to be the most devastating and biggest burden on the family → large negative emotional impact Barriers to communication with doctor link to workload. May not have the time tools or training to address this Suggest self-tracking and patient advocacy groups |
| ( | Monterosso et al | 2018 | Living with Multiple Myeloma: A Focus Group Study of Unmet Needs and Preferences for Survivorship Care | Australia | Focus groups structured around themes from the literature and analyzed using codes and themes |
Information mainly found on the internet Results in advance to gain the most from appointments? Side effects were often not prepared for well enough and found peripheral neuropathy, fatigue, and hair loss most impactful Pressure to have a positive outlook Chronicity Nurse-led care was suggested as something to improve the link and dynamic relationship needed |
| ( | Howell et al | 2020 | “Unpacking” pathways to lymphoma and myeloma diagnosis: Do experiences align with the Model of Pathways to Treatment? Findings from a UK qualitative study with patients and relative | 55 patients interviewed | Semistructured interviews which made up the qualitative part of a mixed methods analysis |
Pathway to diagnosis was similar to the MPT but was more chaotic Hyperawareness of symptoms Self-help and alternative therapies were used commonly for side effects. Symptoms often attributed to self-limiting issues Often symptoms were put off, attributed to different things and it was friends/family that made the first seeking of help First presentation often didn't lead to diagnosis—potentially as symptoms are vague and commonly seen In representation, patients had to be more forceful and needed family to advocate to get tests etc. Lots of patients blamed themselves for the delayed diagnosis Chaotic pathways lead clearly to increased anxiety. Family input was substantial at all parts |
| ( | Howell et al | 2018 | Myeloma: Patient accounts of their pathways to diagnosis. | 20 patients | In depth, individual interviews that had a list of topics to explore but overall could be led by the patient |
Pathway to diagnosis was never linear. There was a large range of reported symptoms, namely back pain. These all tended to be gradual and subtle Normalization and adaptation to symptoms were common → often felt it was only family who made them seek help. Often felt it was their fault the diagnosis was delayed. Others felt GPs didn't have a full understanding of myeloma Mixed opinions of continuity of GP Overall the nature of myeloma and plausibility of initial diagnosis is the issue—might make people feel regretful and silly |
| ( | Molassiotis et al | 2011 | Living with multiple myeloma: experiences of patients and their informal caregivers | Purposeful selection of those who had filled out a
survey on supportive care needs. 20 were
selected | Cross-sectional design using semistructured interviews. Analyzed on the principles of grounded theory. Used qualitative and quantitative methods |
Difficult to cope with the sudden label of being “ill” Big impact on daily life due to fatigue and back pain. Large impact on work Coping mechanisms include overreading, ignoring the issue, keeping active, concealing so as not to burden others Unmet needs didn't surround information but more access to support services and adapting to life with myeloma |
| ( | Potrata et al | 2010 | Understanding distress and distressing experiences in patients living with multiple myeloma: an exploratory study | Manchester | Semistructured interviews with a retrospective view and cross-sectional using qualitative methods. Some ethnic minorities were purposefully selected. |
Distress from symptoms tended to touch on briefly or attribute to other causes Body changes such as shrinking and hair loss had a big impact—visually obvious Family and friends constant inquiry into health can be distressing although were also spoken of very positively Not knowing whether some information was true was distressing for the “expert patient” Stem cell transplant was seen as very traumatic—seen as temporary destruction of the self which can cause considerable anxiety Overall it's not the symptoms that cause distress but the complex threat and change of lifestyle they cause |
| ( | de Wet et al | 2019 | “It is a journey of discovery”: living with myeloma. Supportive Care in Cancer | 15 participants | Qualitative phenomenological study—semistructured interviews that continued to the point of saturation | - Lifestyle changes mainly due to fatigue and physical symptoms—unable to function normally - Affected the family and caused a lot of relationships to break down or lose friends - Loss of sense due to physical capability, appearance, etc - Lots of different approaches to adjusting. Do you just get on with it or do you make changes? - A new outlook on life mainly centered around family - Very little mention of needing support from healthcare professional—some found this depressing - Tablet burden - Suggests more screening tools to check physiological and psychological coping mechanism |
| ( | Kelly and Dowling | 2011 | Patients’ lived experience of myeloma. | 11 participants | Hermeneutic phenomenological approach |
Lived body—inability to hide once hair had fallen out and fatigue Living in limbo as not much is known about myeloma and not commonly heard of—stigmatizing and isolation loss of sense of self but some felt lucky due to advances and treatability Fear of recurrence. Nurses would be vital here for psychological support Limited time with healthcare professional Family and talking to others with myeloma was spoken about widely. All welcomed participating in the study because of this Similar to other cancers by the unknown nature adds to distress and potentially feel more time needed for questions |
| ( | Maher and De Vries | 2011 | An exploration of the lived experiences of individuals with relapsed multiple myeloma | 8 participants | Hermeneutic phenomenology was used after conducting open-ended, unstructured interviews |
Feeling of uncertainty was overarching and present in all parts of life Intuitive knowledge about their body which kept them constantly on high alert Maintenance of normality and adjustment was constant and fluid—links to the Shifting Perspectives model of Chronic illness (Paterson 2011) Spirituality was something positive to come out of it along with hope Often wary of wasting doctor's time and having to put a lot of trust in healthcare professional |
| ( | Schaepe | 2011 | Bad news and first impressions: Patient and family caregiver accounts of learning the cancer diagnosis | United States | Semistructured guided interviews took place at 4
intervals |
The diagnostic process was made into a narrative by patients and focussed much more on the multiple interactions with healthcare than the diagnosis itself Many only deeply understood the diagnosis after a period of time had passed Acute or subacute onset makes a big difference to the experience The ability to cope with news is strongly linked to the execution of disclosure |
| ( | Stephens et al | 2014 | The work of living with rare cancer: multiple myeloma | Australia | In depth interviews carried out 3 times in a 12-18 month period |
Creates work through calculating risk (to well-being, injury, infection and to carers well-being) and also emotionally (changed a lot around appointment times when anxiety and sadness was often reinforced) The fact that people are living longer changes the approach Chronic illness is well known to intrude into everyday life and demands a lot of self-management Constantly working to manage the risk while decreasing the impact on their own and their carers well being |
| ( | Vlossak and Fitch | 2008 | Multiple myeloma: the patient's perspective | 20 patients | In depth, open-ended interviews focusing on
demographics, personal experience in treatment and
diagnosis, and impact |
All found the diagnosis shocking and felt their lives changed almost instantly Treatment options depended a lot on age and responsibility in family Dramatically changes the family dynamic—often changes self-image Fatigue was very prominent for all and one of the other strongest feelings was that of a loss of independence Uncertainty and obsession around recurrence Almost all were satisfied with the medical care they received but it was their emotional and psychological needs that required and due to that lack of cure, sometimes this is difficult to address in the more mainstream ways as hope is related to healthy prolonged life rather than cure |