| Literature DB >> 35160048 |
Manuela Bacanoiu1, Mircea Danoiu1, Mihnea Marin2, Mihai Robert Rusu1, Ligia Rusu1.
Abstract
Distancing and confinement at home during the Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19) outbreak has led to worsening of motor and cognitive functions, both for healthy adults and for patients with neurodegenerative diseases. The decrease in physical activity, the cessation of the intervention of the recovery and the social distance imposed by the lockdown, has had a negative impact on the physical and mental health, quality of life, daily activities, as well as on the behavioral attitudes of the diet. The purpose of this paper was to evaluate the impact of decreasing physical activity and the affected emotional status in healthy adults and patients with neurodegenerative diseases in conditions imposed by the stay at home mandate of COVID-19, along with new interventions, such as telemedicine and telerehabilitation. These interventions include online surveys carried out in multi-languages, semi-structured interviews, intervention smartphones and interventions through online platforms, for instance: Google, WhatsApp, Twitter, ResearchGate, Facebook and LinkedIn. For this study, we selected original papers that were intensively processed using characteristics co-related with physical activity, mental wellbeing, sleep quality, good eating behavior and healthy lifestyle. By searching the last two years of literature, our review presents and demonstrates the benefit of online technological interventions in lockdown, which promote physical exercise patterns and rehabilitation techniques, for healthy adults and patients with neurodegenerative diseases, and the need to develop new strategic directions and governmental measures, designed procedures and health services, which are expected to improve the quality of life, the progress of physical and cognitive functions, mental health and wellbeing for all.Entities:
Keywords: healthy lifestyle behaviors; neurodegenerative diseases; pandemic COVID-19; physical activity; public health strategies; telerehabilitation; wellbeing
Year: 2022 PMID: 35160048 PMCID: PMC8836374 DOI: 10.3390/jcm11030597
Source DB: PubMed Journal: J Clin Med ISSN: 2077-0383 Impact factor: 4.241
Figure 1Prisma 2009. Flow diagram.
Figure 2Type of physical activity (ADL: Activity of Daily Living) for healthy people [12,13,14,15,16,17].
Summary of the characteristics, physical exercise, main tools and interventions with healthy adults.
| Authors | Individuals | Characteristics | Age/Gender | Physical Exercise | Tools | Interventions | Conclusions |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ammar A. et al. (2020) [ | 1047 individuals |
ECBL-COVID-19—online survey multi-languages AHCL—Active and Healthy confinement lifestyle before and during COVID-19 | Adults |
ADL Exercise class Gym class |
SWEMWBS (1–35) SMFQ (0–26) SLSQL SSPQOL IPAQ-SF SDBQL PSQI STBQL |
Online platforms: ResearchGate |
Decreasing mental wellbeing in home confinement, Increasing depression symptoms (≥12) Changing in sleep quality, satisfaction life, physical activity, social participation, Enhancing mood and bad feelings. |
| Ammar A. et al. (2020) [ | 1047 individuals |
ECBL-COVID-19 -online survey multi-languages before and during COVID-19 | Adults |
Physical exercise with vigorous, moderate intensity training Walking activity |
SWEMWBS SMFQ SLSQL IPAQ-SF SDBQL (0–15) PSQI -STBQ-L |
Google online |
Declining of duration time for weekly physical activity, Increasing negative impact for diet behaviors in the sense of augmentingn snack consumptions between meals, enhancing alcohol intake, increasing the number of daily meals;an unhealthy diet is important indicator for sedentary lifestyle. |
| Ammar A. et al. (2020) [ | 1047 individuals |
ECBL-COVID-19 -online survey multi-languages before and during COVID-19 | Adults |
ADL |
SWEMWBS SMFQ SLSQL IPAQ-SF SDBQL PSQI STBQ-L SSPQ-L (14–70) SLSQL (3–21) |
Online platforms: ResearchGate |
Decreasing friends, neighbors direct intercommunication in lockdown period with strongly mental implication for individuals, Developing socialization on online communication platforms. |
| Ammar A. et al. (2020) [ | 1047 individuals |
ECBL-COVID-19 -online survey multi-languages before and during COVID-19 Cardiovascular risk | Adults |
Outdoor or indoor physical activity |
SWEMWBS SMFQ SLSQL IPAQ-SF SDBQL PSQI STBQ-L SSPQ-L SLSQL |
Online platforms: ResearchGate Smart phone Watch |
Disrupting wellbeing and satisfaction life, communication, Developing mental disorders, anxiety, sadness, mood, states of accentuated nervousness during quarantine. Increasing tensions for individuals which were retired or unemployment comparative with before lockdown period when they were workers, Encouraging wellbeing for promoting a healthy lifestyle by participating in physical activities at home or in organized groups keeping the rules of distance imposed by the pandemic and hygiene. |
| Kilani H.A. et al. (2020) [ | 1723 participans |
Arabian communities Health status Mental wellbeing Dietary behavior PA Sleep quality | 32.2 years |
Walking Moderate physical activity Vigorously activity MET |
lower mental score female good dietary quality sleeping score FFQ IPAQ WHO-5 PSQI |
Online Google ResearchGate |
Decreasing mental wellbeing at female against male, Increasing sleep quality at both gender corelated with good quality diet, Significant improving mental health, cognition functions in the conditions of maintaining a sustained physical activity such as: walking, moderate and vigorous physical exercise. |
| Salzano G. et al. (2021) [ | 1860 youth |
Lower secondary school Upper secondary school | 12–18 years |
Physical activity (1 h-6 h/week) ADL (cooking, gardening, household activities) |
Average number of text or chat messages/100 day |
Web-based survey Personal computers Smartphones Tablets Tik Tok Snapchat |
Increasing physical activity indoor during lockdown Good mental resistance in stay-at-home mandate with skills acquiring of new skills Altering circadian rhyme sleep/wake due to intense use of media platforms for intense global socialization and the maintenance of friendships and emotional status on social networks Increasing anxiety, depression and other psychological disorders through excessive use of social networks that can promote cyberbullying and sexting In terms of eating, no unhealthy eating habits were acquired due to the lack of training in the communities and the consumption of small meals, snacks, sweets, excess juices; on the contrary the promotion of cooked meals and healthier foods at home was observed. |
ECBL: Effects of Home Confinement on multiple lifestyle behaviors; SWEMWBS: Short Warwick–Edinburgh Mental Wellbeing Scale; SMFQ: Short Mood and Feelings Questionnaire; SLSQL: Short Life Satisfaction Questionnaire for Lockdowns; SSPQOL: Short Social Participation Questionnaire for Lockdowns; IPAQ-SF: International Physical Activity Questionnaire Short Form; SDBQL: Short Diet Behaviors Questionnaire for Lockdowns; PSQI: Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index; STBQL: Short Technology-use Behaviors Questionnaire for Lockdowns; SSPQ-L: Short Social Participation Questionnaire-Lockdowns; SLSQ-L: Short Life Satisfaction Questionnaire for Lockdowns; EQ-5D-5L: Euro QoL-5 dimensions; ADL: Activity of Daily Living; HADS: Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale; FFQ: Food Frequency Questionnaire; WHO-5: World Health Organization—wellbeing score.
Figure 3Type of physical activity for patients with neurodegenerative diseases [9,13,26,30,31,32,33,34,35,38,39,41].
Summary of the characteristics, physical exercise, main tools and interventions for patients with neurodegenerative diseases.
| Authors | Individuals | Characteristics | Age/Gender | Physical Exercise | Tools | Interventions | Conclusions |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ammar A., et al. (2021) [ | 12 individuals |
MCI (mild cognitive impairment) | Older adults |
8 weeks fitness training dance training 2 sessions/90 min/week DIADEM training program |
HR-Heart Rate MMSE (24–27) PAR-Q GDS CERAD Plus |
Polar heart rate sensor (H10) Wireless polar team |
Improving performance cardiac at patients with MCI after physical exercise training, Increasing physical performance regarding speed gait and length of step, Continuing home-based physical training in social distancing rules during lockdown with important benefits for mental and physical functions. |
| Balci B., et al. (2021) [ | 88 individuals experimental group ( control group ( | Parkinson’s Disease (PD) | Older adults | ADL |
Increasing: Tremor Dyskinesia Rigidity Freezing of gait Instability postural Sleep impairments Muscle pain PASE HADS PALs |
Phone interview |
Augmentation of non-motor and motor functions at PD patients during quarantine, Increasing anxiety and depression through distancing, detraining and worse socialisation during confinement home. |
| Chen Z.C., et al. (2021) [ | 105-AD |
MCI Alzheimer’ disease (AD) DLB-dementia with Lewy body disease | Older adults |
ADL |
MMSE MOCA NPI HAMD ESS |
CT scans MRI PET-positron emission tomography |
During lockdown and stay at home, caregivers should help patients with cognitive impairment and dementia to maintain exercise routines training home based of a certain intensity and frequency and to maintaining socialisation with friends and relatives by phone and another network. Telerehabilitation should be one of the most advantageous interventions during quarantine to prevent the evolution of mental and physical impairment in patients with MCI. |
| Kalita J., et al. (2021) [ | 38 individuals with MG (myasthenia gravis) non COVID-19 |
MG Treatment with prednisolone and azathioprine | 45 yrs | Physical exercise training: yoga walking moderate physical activity |
MGFA MGQOL15 (0–4) MGADL HADS (0–21) PSQI |
Phone interviews Whats app. |
Decreasing quality of life through detraining of physical activity, Aggravation of physical and mental dysfunctions of patients with MG in the conditions imposed by lockdown. |
| Kumar N., et al. (2021) [ | 832 individuals |
PD-Parkinson disease ˃7 years Home confinement questionnaire Sleep disturbance Features suggestive of RLS Features of REMBD Sleep disorders Worsened motor features Worsened non-motor features | >50 years |
walking moderate physical activity ˃1 h/day |
RLS REMBD NOWS Likert Scale I-CVI S-CVI S-CVI-UA VAS SDB |
Phone Screen time |
During COVID-19 pandemic, quarantine determined the worsening of sleep disorders at all PD’ patients, Increasing motor and non-motor impairments due to lacking physical activity, poor life quality, sleep disorders. |
| Suzuki K., et al. (2021) [ |
experimental group- ( control group-caregivers ( |
Parkinson’s disease HY (2/3) Comorbidities Motor and cognitive impairments | >72 years |
physical activity |
PGIC (1–7) QOL HADS PCS MCS SF-8 | Online platform with delivering questionnaires |
Increasing severity signs and symptoms of PD’ patients regarding pattern gait, rigidity, tremor and disturbances sleep, Enhancing anxiety, depression, mood, attention impairments at PD, Decreasing physical activity in lockdown had negative impact for daily and walking activities, being associated with important motor disorders. |
| Templeton J.M., et al. (2021) [ | 28 patients—self-questionnaire |
Parkinson’s disease Self-reporting Functional assessment | >52 years 46.4%—male 53.6%—female |
Physical activity/week number of active days on week average time physical activity |
Number of active days Number of active minutes Number of activities Average temporal metrics Likert Scale (1–5) MMSE MCA MTA SWCT NFI |
Self-reporting questionnaire Mobile -based neurocognitive measurements |
Decreasing controlled physical activity in stay at home mandate (SaHM) caused worsening, moderately or higher, of at least one PD symptoms individuals (80%), Increasing interval by at least two times in which the objective actions are completed, Reducing wellbeing lifestyle, motor and speech neurocognitive tasks in home confinement. |
| Trabelsi K., et al. (2021) [ | 517 individuals |
Parkinson disease International online survey (64 items)—12 week in 14 languages PA Diet Sleep Social participation Psychosocial support | >55 years |
-Weekly physical activity (walking training low, moderate and vigorous physical exercise, MET) |
SWEMWBS (7–35) PSQI IPAQ-SF |
Online platforms |
Keeping constant on mental wellbeing during stay at home mandate, whereas elderly patients with PD are more emotionally resistant being more accustomed to stressors than young counterparts, Decreasing level homework activities because of lack of physical exercise, which means worsening motor functions, Declining sleep quality in lockdown and the appearance of other disturbances which induced negative emotions and more frustration. |
| van der Heide A., et al. (2020) [ | 358 individuals |
PD Collection blood, stool and cerebrospinal fluid MRI | >53 years Male (62.5%) Female (38.5%) | ˃4 h PA/week |
UPDRS anxiety stressor load personality features PPP PSS PAS RRS BRS CERQ MoCA SCOPA-sleep STAI BDI-II |
Google platforms Online survey (motor, cognitive and psychological measurements) |
Worsening motor symptoms such as tremor, rigidity, pattern gait, pain and postural instability, Increasing change in emotional status induced by stressor load related COVID-19 outbreak, Enhancing neuropsychiatric symptoms such as: depression, anxiety, mood, ruminations through decreasing physical activity. |
| Zucca M., et al. (2021) [ | 4710 (2355-pairs) Caregivers Patients with dementia |
Mild dementia (AD, DLB, VaD, FTD) Stress symptoms (anxiety, irritability, overwhelmed, anguish, abandonment) | >46 years | ADL |
CDR |
Phone semi-structured interview |
Increasing stress symptoms (one symptom—90% or more symptoms—30%) of caregivers with dementia patients linked of consequences COVID-19, Enhancing conflicting relationship and discontinuity in assistance for female caregivers with dementia patients in time lockdown. |
| Yogev-Seligmann G., et al. (2021) [ | 142 individuals |
PD Lockdown Community dwellings | >63 years |
ADL walking training |
Current functional status Health Medical care Wellbeing in quarantine PAM-13 (0–100) Four-point Likert Scale |
Web-based survey |
Decreasing walking ability in 37.3% of cases, Worsening of motor and cognitive disfunctions at PD’ patients (43%), increasing the need for care assistance for ADL (24.8%), Enhancing neuropsychiatric symptoms such as depression, anxiety, tired, moody and loneliness (42%) Discontinuity of rehabilitation treatments. |
| Müller P., (2020) [ | ˃40% Latin America women |
Vascular dementia (AD) | >40% women |
150 min moderate intensity effort physical/week 75 min vigorous intensity effort physical/week strength training/week |
MET WHO | App-based training with online partners |
Worsening physical activity during isolation at home imposed by COVID-19 with negative results about primary and secondary vascular dementia, Decreasing outdoor physical exercise represent a major problem of health public for people with Alzheimer’ disease. |
SWEMWBS: Short Warwick–Edinburgh Mental Wellbeing Scale; SMFQ: Short Mood and Feelings Questionnaire; SLSQL: Short Life Satisfaction Questionnaire for Lockdowns; IPAQ-SF: International Physical Activity Questionnaire Short Form; SDBQL: Short Diet Behaviors Questionnaire for Lockdowns; PSQI: Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index; STBQL: Short Technology-use Behaviors Questionnaire for Lockdowns; SSPQ-L: Short Social participation questionnaire-lockdowns; MMSE: Mini-mental Scale Examination; PAR-Q: Physical activity Readiness Questionnaire; GDS: Geriatric Depression Scale; CERAD Plus: Consortium to Establish a Registry for Alzheimer’s Disease; MOCA: Montreal Cognitive Assessment; NPI: Neuropsychiatric Inventory; HAMD: Hamilton depression rating; ESS: Epworth sleepiness scale; EQ-5D-5L: Euro QoL-5 dimensions; ADL: Activity of Daily Living; PASE: Physical Activity Scale for the elderly; HADS: Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale; PALs: Physical Activity Level; MG: Myasthenia Gravis; MGQOL15: MG Quality of life; MGADL: MG Activity of Daily Living; MGFA Scale: Myasthenia Gravis Foundation of America staging; FFQ: Food Frequency Questionnaire; WHO-5: World Health Organization—wellbeing score; MET: Metabolic equivalents minutes/week; RLS: restless legs syndrome; REMBD: REM sleep behavior disorder; NOWS: New-onset/worsening of sleep; I-CVI: Item content validity Index; S-CVI-Scale Content Validity Index; S-CVI-UA: Scale Content Validity Index Universal agreement; VAS: Visual Analog Scale; SDB: Sleep Disordered Breathing; PGIC: Patient Global Impression of Change Scale; QOL: Quality of life; PCS: Physical Component Summary; MCS: Mental component summary; SF-8: Short form; HY: Hoehn and Yahr stage; Likert Scale; MCA: Montreal Cognitive Assessment; MTA: Menu Task Assessment; SWCT: Stroop Word Color Test; NFI: Neurobehavioral Functioning Inventory; PPP: Personalized Parkinson Project; PSS: Perceived Stress Scale; UPDRS: Unified Parkinson’s Disease Rating Scale; PAS: Parkinson Anxiety Scale; RRS: Ruminative Response Scale; BRS: Brief resilience Scale; CERQ: Cognitive Emotion Regulation Questionnaire; STAI: State Trait Anxiety Inventory; BDI-II: Beck’s Depression Inventory; SCOPA -sleep: Scales for Outcomes in PD; MoCA: Montreal Cognitive Assessment; BFI: neuroticism; VaD: Vascular dementia; CDR: Clinical Dementia Rating Scale; FTD: Frontotemporal Dementia; DLB: Lewy body disease; PAM-13: Patient’s Activation Measure.
Figure 4Dynamic of motor and cognitive impairments in healthy adults and patients with neurodegenerative diseases.