| Literature DB >> 35156084 |
K S Rathan Shetty1, Vinayak Kurle1, P Greeshma1, Veena B Ganga1, Samskruthi P Murthy1, Siddappa K Thammaiah1, P Krishna Prasad1, Purushottham Chavan1, Rajshekar Halkud1, R Krishnappa1.
Abstract
More than half of patients with oral cancer recur even after multimodality treatment and recurrent oral cancers carry a poorer prognosis when compared to other sites of head and neck. The best survival outcome in a recurrent setting is achieved by salvage surgery; however, objective criteria to select an ideal candidate for salvage surgery is difficult to frame, as the outcome depends on various treatment-, tumor-, and patient-related factors. The following is summarizes various tumor- and treatment-related factors that guide our decision-making to optimize oncologic and functional outcomes in surgical salvage for recurrent oral cancers. Short disease-free interval, advanced tumor stage (recurrent and primary), extracapsular spread and positive tumor margins in a recurrent tumor, regional recurrence, and multimodality treatment of primary tumor all portend worse outcomes after surgical salvage. Quality of life after surgical intervention has shown improvement over 1 year with a drastic drop in pain scores. Various trials are underway evaluating the combination of immunotherapy and surgical salvage in recurrent head and neck tumors, including oral cavity, which may widen our indications for salvage surgery with improved survival and preserved organ function.Entities:
Keywords: decision making; oral cancer; outcome; recurrent; salvage surgery
Year: 2022 PMID: 35156084 PMCID: PMC8831824 DOI: 10.3389/froh.2021.815606
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Front Oral Health ISSN: 2673-4842
Studies evaluating survival outcomes after salvage surgery for recurrent oral cancer in the recent decades.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2010 | |||||
| Agra et al. [ | 41 | NA | Salvage surgery ± adjuvant therapy | 3-year cancer specific survival 20% | • <6 months of disease free interval |
| Kernohan et al. [ | 77 | Surgery, Radiotherapy, Surgery ± Adjuvant therapy | Salvage surgery ± adjuvant therapy | 2-Year disease specific survival 78% for local recurrence and 20% for regional recurrence treated with multimodality treatment | • Initial combined modality treatment |
| 2016 | |||||
| Goto et al. [ | 69 | Surgery, Radiotherapy, Surgery ± Adjuvant therapy | Salvage surgery ± adjuvant therapy | 5 year Overall survival | • No recurrent nodal disease Vs > 2 recurrent nodal metastasis |
| Horn et al. [ | 32 | Surgery, Radiotherapy, Surgery ± Adjuvant therapy | Salvage surgery ± adjuvant therapy | 2-year Overall survival and disease free survival 37.8% and 30.9% respectively | • Microscopic positive margins at salvage surgery |
| Liu et al. [ | 27 | Surgery alone | Salvage surgery ± adjuvant therapy, radiation therapy | 5- year overall survival and Disease specific survival was 50% and 61% respectively | • Regional recurrences |
| 2017 | |||||
| Tam et al. [ | 59 | Surgery ± adjuvant therapy | Salvage surgery ± adjuvant therapy, radiation therapy, no salvage therapy | 5-year overall survival after salvage surgery 43% | • Multimodality treatment for primary tumor |
| 2018 | |||||
| Matsuura et al. [ | 46 | Surgery ± adjuvant therapy | Salvage surgery ± adjuvant therapy | Overall survival and Disease free survival was 31.7 and 35% respectively (Follow up maximum 61 months) | • Presence of regional recurrences and positive surgical margins during salvage surgery |
| Mizrachi et al. [ | 1,302 | Surgery for primary tumor. Neck dissection vs observation | Salvage surgery± adjuvant therapy, Chemoradiation therapy | 1-year disease specific survival 72% for Salvage surgery with adjuvant therapy, 40% for surgery alone and 27% for non-surgical salvage | • Non-surgical salvage modality of treatment |
| Subramaniam et al. [ | 25 | Surgery ± adjuvant therapy | Salvage surgery ± adjuvant therapy | 5-year overall survival 12% | • Previous adjuvant therapy |
| 2019 | |||||
| Weckx et al. [ | 159 | Surgery ± adjuvant therapy | Salvage surgery, radiotherapy, chemoradiotherapy, palliative chemotherapy, palliative radiotherapy, supportive therapy | 5-year and 10-year overall survival 66 and 56% respectively | • Early time to recurrence |
| 2020 | |||||
| Chung et al. [ | 73 | Surgery ± adjuvant therapy, Chemoradiation therapy | Surgery + chemoradiation therapy, others | 5-year overall, locoregional failure free and disease free survival were 54.8, 58.9 and 49.3% | • Advanced nodal stage of primary tumor |
| 2021 | |||||
| Szewczyk et al. [ | 108 | Surgery ± adjuvant therapy | Surgery, palliative care | 5-year overall survival 58% | • Positive surgical margins after salvage surgery |
| Nandy et al. [ | 168 | Surgery ± adjuvant therapy | Surgery ± adjuvant therapy, Neoadjuvant chemotherapy followed by Surgery ± adjuvant therapy | 2-year and 3-year overall survival were 37.6 and 21.8% respectively and 2-year and 3-year disease free survival were 26.2 and 14.7% respectively. | • Advanced stage and multimodality treatment of initial tumor |
| Yosefof et al. [ | 55 | Surgery ± adjuvant therapy | Surgery ± adjuvant therapy, chemoradiotherapy | 5-year disease specific survival 46.7% and overall survival 35.3% | • <10 months of disease free interval |
| Chen et al. [ | 556 | NA | Salvage surgery, radiotherapy, palliative chemotherapy, palliative radiotherapy. | 2-year disease free survival with/without pathological risk factors 32.4% and 77.2% respectively and 2-year overall survival with/without pathological risk factors 58.4 and 89.2% respectively | • Pathological risk factors i.e. positive margins and extra capsular spread of recurrent tumor |
Rerecurrent oral cancer.
Nodal recurrent tumor in oral cancer. NA, not reported. ±, with or without.
Illustrative listing of clinical trials examining impact of combining immunotherapy in salvage surgery setting in recurrent head and neck cancers.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | NCT04754321 | Pembrolizumab and Radiation therapy before and during surgery for treatment of persistent or recurrent head and neck cancer | I | Incidence of adverse events | Not yet recruiting |
| 2 | NCT04671667 | Testing what happens when an immunotherapy drug is added to radiation or given by itself compared to usual treatment of chemotherapy with radiation after surgery for recurrent head and neck squamous cell carcinoma | II | Incidence of adverse events | Recruiting |
| 3 | NCT04188951 | A pilot study of immunotherapy as consolidation therapy for patients with recurrent head and neck cancer | I | Toxicity rates | Recruiting |
| 4 | NCT03565783 | Cemiplimab in treating participants with recurrent stage III-IV Head and neck squamous cell cancer before surgery | II | Overall response rate | Recruiting |
| 5 | NCT03003637 | ImmunoModulation by the Combination of Ipilimumab and Nivolumab Neoadjuvant to Surgery In Advanced or Recurrent Head and Neck Carcinoma | I / II | Phase I: number of patients that will endure a delay in surgery due to immunotherapy related toxicity | Completed |
| 6 | EudraCT 2017-0012711-17 [Gustave Roussy- France] | Adjuvant immunotherapy after salvage surgery in head and neck squamous cell carcinoma : phase 2 trial evaluating the efficacy and the toxicity of nivolumab alone, and of the combination nivolumab and ipilimumab | II | Toxicity profile | On going |
RECISTs, response evaluation criteria in solid tumors; FDG-PET, fluorodeoxyglucose-PET.