| Literature DB >> 35153995 |
Ane Mínguez-Olaondo1,2,3,4,5, Sonia Quintas6, Noemí Morollón Sánchez-Mateos7, Alba López-Bravo8,9, Marta Vila-Pueyo10, Vesselina Grozeva11, Robert Belvís7, Sonia Santos-Lasaosa9,12, Pablo Irimia5.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: In the present work, we conduct a narrative review of the most relevant literature on cutaneous allodynia (CA) in migraine.Entities:
Keywords: cutaneous allodynia; migraine; migraine chronification; risk factors; treatment
Year: 2022 PMID: 35153995 PMCID: PMC8830422 DOI: 10.3389/fneur.2021.831035
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Front Neurol ISSN: 1664-2295 Impact factor: 4.003
Most relevant studies regarding different epidemiological aspects of CA in migraine.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Han et al. ( | 2021 | 289 | Korea | Cross-sectional study | PM | Not specified | >18 years | 17% | ASC-12 |
| Akarsu et al. ( | 2019 | 871 | Turkey | Nationwide population-based study | Migraine | Not specified | >17 years | 57.5% | Not described |
| Munjal et al. ( | 2019 | 6,045 | U.S. | Cross-sectional observational | Migraine | Not specified | 18–65 years | 61.1% | ASC-12 |
| Lipton et al. ( | 2019 | 8,658 | U.S. | Longitudinal, internet-based panel | EM | Included, 19% | >17 years | 36.7% | ASC-12 |
| Young et al. ( | 2019 | 716 | U.S., Australia and South Korea | Multileft, open-label, prospective study | CM | Icluded, 11.9% | Not described | 44.4% | ASC-12 |
| Seo et al. ( | 2019 | 312 | South Korea | Cross-sectional study | Migraine | Independently assessed, 20.7% Vs 11.9% in those with allodynia | Not described | 39.9% | ASC-12 |
| Lipton et al. ( | 2018 | 18,353 | U.S. | Longitudinal, internet-based panel | Migraine | Not specified | >17 years | 40.4% | ASC-12 |
| Lipton et al. ( | 2018 | 12,810 | U.S. | Longitudinal, internet-based panel | CM and EM | Included | 15–70 years | 18.6% | ASC-12 |
| Levinstky et al. ( | 2019 | 119 | Israel | Retrospective transversal study | Migraine 3 – 18 years | Included, 2.8% | >17 years | 39.9% | ASC-12 |
| De Tommasso et al. ( | 2017 | 151 | Italy | Observational cross-sectional study | CM, EM 8 - 15years | Included, 15% | Not described | 47% | ASC-12 |
| Kim et al. ( | 2016 | 140 | South Korea | Prospective consecutive patients | CM, EM | Not specified | 3–18 years | 31.1% | ASC-12 |
| Mathew et al. ( | 2016 | 44 | US | Consecutive patients | CM | Not specified | 8–15 years | 96.6% | ASC-12 |
| Mendonça et al. ( | 2016 | 98 | Portugal | Cross - sectional study | EM | Included, 19.5% | 15–75 years | 14.5% | ASC-12 |
| Baykan et al. ( | 2016 | 871 | Turkey | Population-based nationwide, home-based prevalence study in adults | Migraine | Not specified | Not described | 91% | Standard questions |
| Lovati et al. ( | 2015 | 673 | Milan, Italy | Prospective consecutive patients | CM and EM | Not specified | Not described | 77% | Standard questions |
| Park et al. ( | 2015 | 220 | Korea | Cross-sectional study | CM, EM and MOH | Independently assessed, higher in those with allodynia (10.3% Vs 4.7%) | Not described | 61.1% | ASC-12 |
| Raieli et al. ( | 2015 | 202 | Italy | Retrospective study | Migraine Children and teenagers | Not specified | Not described | 50% | Brief questionnaire |
| Baldacci et al. ( | 2015 | 200 | Italy | Cross-sectional study | Migraine | Included, 23.6% | 15 - 73 years | 47.3% | ASC-12 |
| Louter et al. ( | 2013 | 2,331 | The Netherlands | Population-based nationwide survey | Migraine | Not specified | Children and teenagers | 37.1% | ASC-12 |
| Kao et al. ( | 2014 | 434 | Taiwan | Cross-sectional study | Migraine | Excluded | >17 years | 79% | ASC-12 |
| Menon et al. ( | 2013 | 422 | India | Cross-sectional study in medical students | Migraine | Included | 18–74 years | 70% | Not described |
| Lovati et al. ( | 2013 | 456 | Italy | Prospective consecutive patients | CM and EM | Not specified | Not described | 48.4% | Semi-structured ad hoc questionnaire |
| Misra et al. ( | 2013 | 448 | India | Prospective consecutive patients | Migraine | Included, 27% | Not described | 23% | Own check list |
| Güven et al. ( | 2013 | 168 | Turkey | Prospective consecutive patients | EM | Excluded | Not described | 54.4% | ASC-12 |
| Díaz-Insa et al. ( | 2011 | 1,036 | Europe | Randomized placebo-controlled trial | Migraine | Not specified | 10–62 years | 71.4% | Not described |
| Chou et al. ( | 2010 | 100 | Taiwan | Cross-sectional study | CM and EM | Not specified | >18 years | 61.3% | Self-reported brushing allodynia |
| Tietjen et al. ( | 2009 | 1,413 | U.S. | Cross-sectional study | Migraine | Not specified | Not described | 39% | Questionnaire |
| Friedmann et al. ( | 2009 | 182 | U.S. | Multileft ED-based clinical trial | Migraine in the emergency department | Not specified | 17–65 years | 17% | BA |
| Bigal et al. ( | 2008 | 11,094 | U.S. | Population-based nationwide survey AMPP | TM and EM | Included, 6% | >17 years | 60% | ASC-12 |
| Lipton et al. ( | 2008 | 11,388 | U.S. | Population-based nationwide study | Migraine | Not specified | Not described | 14% | ASC-12 |
| Lovati et al. ( | 2007 | 221 | Italy | Consecutive patients | EM and CM | Not specified | >17 years | 68.3% and 63.25 | Not described |
| Ashkenazi et al. ( | 2007 | 151 | U.S. | Cross-sectional study | EM | Not specified | >17 years | 63% | QST |
| Ashkenazi et al. ( | 2007 | 89 | U.S. | Cross-sectional study | CM | Included | Not described | >40% | BA |
| LoPinto et al. ( | 2006 | 55 | U.S. | Cross-sectional study | Migraine | Not specified | 12–60 years | 77% | Cutaneous stimulation (BA) And pressure alllodynia (PA) |
| Raieli et al. ( | 2005 | 55 | Italy | Cross-sectional study | Migraine 6 - 18 years | Not specified | >15 years | 42.7% | Not described |
| Mathew et al. ( | 2004 | 295 | U.S. | Cross-sectional study | Migraine | Not specified | Not described | 32.7% | Semi-structured ad hoc questionnaire |
| 14.5% | |||||||||
| 53.3% |
ASC-12, allodynia symptom checklist; BA, brushing allodynia; CM, chronic migraine; EM, episodic migraine; PM, probable migraine (fulfills all but one criterion of migraine); QST, quantitative sensory test; TM, transformed migraine.
Figure 1Schematic representation of the sensitization of central trigeminovascular neurons in the thalamus believed to mediate the extracephalic CA trigeminal and nucleus caudalis believed to mediate cephalic CA during migraine. NR, Neuron. Adapted from Noseda and Burstein (72). Biorender.com
Summary of the studies analyzing the prevalence of CA in Episodic Migraine (EM) vs. Chronic Migraine (CM) (in %) and those identifying CA as a risk factor for migraine chronification (NA, Not Applicable; TTH, Tension Type Headache; HTTH, Chronic Tension Type Headache).
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Russo et al. ( | 2020 | 50 | Italy | YES | Migraine | NA | NA |
| Mathew et al. ( | 2016 | 44 | U.S. | YES | CM | – | ~90% |
| Louter et al. ( | 2013 | 3,029 | Netherlands | YES | Migraine | – | – |
| Tietjen et al. ( | 2009 | 1,413 | U.S. | NA | Migraine | – | – |