| Literature DB >> 35126289 |
Regan G Harrell1, Michael C Schubert2, Sara Oxborough3, Susan L Whitney4.
Abstract
During the COVID-19 pandemic, physical therapists transitioned to provide telehealth in the United States. We sought to determine the experiences of physical therapists delivering telerehabilitation for vestibular disorders including barriers, preferences, and concerns. A survey was created using the results of a focus group and previously published studies. The survey was distributed across social media sites and through email- the link was sent to the orthopedic, neurologic, and geriatric academies of the American Physical Therapy Association list serves. The email was also shared with each of the 50 state chapters of the American Physical Therapy Association. The survey was broken down into five sections: demographic information, physical therapists' general impressions of telehealth, physical therapists' comfort level treating various vestibular diagnoses, and common barriers physical therapists experienced during telehealth sessions. There were 159 completed surveys. More than 80% of physical therapists surveyed agreed that telehealth was an effective platform for vestibular physical therapy. When asked whether physical therapists felt the patient had similar health outcomes with telehealth versus clinic care 68% of physical therapists agreed. For the physical therapists who treated posterior or horizontal canal benign paroxysmal positional vertigo via telehealth, more than 50% were comfortable treating these conditions via telehealth. In analyzing common peripheral vestibular diagnoses treated via telehealth including bilateral vestibular loss, Meniere's disease, and vestibular neuritis more than 75% of the physical therapists reported comfort treating these diagnoses. Similarly, more than 75% of physical therapists who treated central vestibular diagnoses- including mild traumatic brain injury and vestibular migraine- via telehealth reported being comfortable treating these diagnoses. Physical therapists reported several barriers to tele healthcare ranging from concerns about testing balance with no caregiver present (94%) to challenges with providing a written home exercise program (33%). Physical therapists report that telehealth is a viable mechanism for providing rehabilitation for persons with balance and vestibular disorders. For common diagnoses, most physical therapists were comfortable treating vestibular disorders via telehealth. While barriers remain including maintaining patient safety and being able to complete a thorough vestibular exam, telehealth for vestibular physical therapy services holds promise for the delivery of virtual care.Entities:
Keywords: balance; dizziness; physical therapy; telehealth; vertigo; vestibular rehabilitation
Year: 2022 PMID: 35126289 PMCID: PMC8811028 DOI: 10.3389/fneur.2021.781482
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Front Neurol ISSN: 1664-2295 Impact factor: 4.003
Demographic data from the physical therapist who completed the telehealth survey.
|
|
|
| |
|---|---|---|---|
|
| |||
| Female | 133 (84%) | 83 (92%) | 25 (89%) |
| Male | 22 (14%) | 6 (7%) | 1 (4%) |
| Prefer not to say | 4 (2%) | 1 (1%) | 2 (7%) |
|
| |||
| 20–34 | 58 (36%) | 58 (64%) | – |
| 35–54 | 82 (52%) | 32 (36%) | 9 (32%) |
| 55–85+ | 19 (12%) | – | 19 (68%) |
|
| |||
| Outpatient clinic | 135 (85%) | 81 (90%) | 23 (82%) |
| Home health | 6 (4%) | 2 (2%) | 3 (10%) |
| Skilled nursing facility | 2 (1%) | 1 (1%) | – |
| School based | 2 (1%) | 1 (1%) | – |
| Acute care/hospital | 4 (3%) | 2 (2%) | 1 (4%) |
| Other | 10 (6%) | 3 (4%) | 1 (4%) |
Other includes research clinic and academic settings.
Figure 1(A–C) Percentage of agreement from physical therapists on general impressions of telehealth physical therapy for vestibular physical therapy services.
Figure 2(A,B) Rating by physical therapists (PT's) with 0–10 and 15+ years of vestibular experience who treated persons with posterior (PC) and horizontal canal (HC) benign paroxysmal positional vertigo (BPPV) via telehealth.
Figure 3(A–C) Ratings by physical therapist (PT's) with 0–10 and 15+ years of vestibular experience who treated persons with common peripheral vestibular diagnoses: bilateral vestibular loss (BVL), Meniere's disease (MD), and vestibular neuritis (VN) via telehealth.
Figure 4(A,B) Ratings by physical therapists (PT's) with 0–10 and 15+ years of vestibular experience who treated persons with common central vestibular diagnoses: mild traumatic brain injury/concussion (mTBI) and vestibular migraine (VM) via telehealth. visits were as effective as in-person visits?” (n = 159).
(A,B) Percentage of physical therapist respondents who reported that they could effectively provide vestibular examination techniques and specific exercises via telehealth (n = 159).
|
| |
|---|---|
|
| |
| Cervical range of motion | 137 (86%) |
| Symptom provocation with VORx1 | 132 (83%) |
| Smooth pursuit | 125 (77%) |
| Romberg testing | 118 (74%) |
| Saccades | 118 (74%) |
| Home environmental assessment for safety | 102 (64%) |
| Observation of nystagmus in room light | 94 (59%) |
| VOR cancellation | 92 (58%) |
| Clinical test of sensory integration and balance | 85 (53%) |
| Vergence | 84 (53%) |
| Cranial Nerve Function (3,4, & 6) | 81 (51%) |
| Dix Hallpike | 81 (51%) |
| Head shake test | 25 (42%) |
| Hearing screen | 25 (42%) |
| Dynamic visual acuity | 25 (42%) |
| Roll test | 62 (39%) |
| Dynamic gait index | 53 (33%) |
| Cover/uncover test | 51 (32%) |
| Cross cover test | 42 (26%) |
| Gait speed | 41 (26%) |
| Other | 16 (10%) |
| Sensory testing | 14 (8%) |
| Head impulse test | 10 (6%) |
|
| |
| Habituation exercises | 149 (94%) |
| Standing balance exercises- flat surface | 147 (93%) |
| VORx1 | 147 (93%) |
| Walking with head turns side to side | 121 (76%) |
| Gaze shift between two targets | 118 (74%) |
| Walking with head turns up/down | 114 (72%) |
| Standing balance exercises- complaint surface | 101 (64%) |
| Saccades | 97 (61%) |
| VORx2 | 82 (52%) |
| Walking with dual task | 72 (45%) |
| Walking with quick turns | 67 (42%) |
| Virtual reality exercises | 67 (42%) |
| Remembered or imaginary target exercise | 63 (40%) |
| Walking with eyes closed | 39 (25%) |
| Walking with an obstacle course | 35 (22%) |
| Walking on uneven surfaces | 35 (22%) |
Other includes assessing for ataxia on finger to nose testing and testing for rapid alternating movement.
Barriers physical therapists reported when completing telehealth vestibular therapy sessions.
|
|
|
|---|---|
| Concerns about testing balance with no caregiver present | 149 (94%) |
| Bad/inconsistent internet signal | 146 (92%) |
| Equipment set up limiting ability to view patient' body during exam or intervention? | 146 (92%) |
| Patients were not familiar with how to use technology platform | 141 (89%) |
| Difficulty walking with their telecommunications device | 130 (82%) |
| Patient/client had technology incompatible for the visit | 125 (79%) |
| Lack of a caregiver in the home | 124 (78%) |
| Concerns about testing balance with a caregiver present | 117 (74%) |
| Lighting- glare on glasses during the eye exam | 104 (66%) |
| Challenging to provide a written home exercise program | 52 (33%) |
All responses except “never” included in the reported percentage below (n = 159).
Figure 5Percentage of physical therapists' responses when asked about “do you have a sense that your telehealth visits were as effective as in-person visits?” (n = 159).