Rie Tanaka1, Shiho Nozaki2, Futa Goshima2, Junji Shiraishi3. 1. Kanazawa University, College of Medical, Pharmaceutical and Health Sciences, Kanazawa, Japan. 2. Kanazawa University, Graduate School of Health Sciences, Kanazawa, Japan. 3. Kumamoto University, Faculty of Life Sciences, Kanazawa, Japan.
Abstract
Purpose: The necessity of image retakes is initially determined on a preview monitor equipped with an operating system; therefore, some image blurring is only noticed later, on a high-resolution monitor. The purpose of this study is to investigate blur detection performance on radiographs via a deep learning approach compared with human observers. Approach: A total of 99 radiographs (blurry 57, nonblurry 42) were independently observed and rated by six observers using preview and diagnostic liquid crystal displays (LCDs). The deep convolution neural network (DCNN) was trained and tested using ninefold cross-validation. The average areas under the ROC curves (AUCs) were calculated for each observer with LCDs and by stand-alone DCNN for each test session and then statistically tested using a 95% confidence interval. Results: The average AUCs were 0.955 for stand-alone DCNN and 0.827 and 0.947 for human observers using preview and diagnostic LCDs, respectively. The DCNN revealed a high performance for image motion blur on digital radiographs (sensitivity 94.8%, specificity 96.8%, and accuracy 95.6%), along with the capability to detect a slight motion blur that was overlooked by human observers with a preview LCD. There were no cases of motion blur overlooked by the stand-alone DCNN, of which some were incorrectly recognized as nonblurry by human observers. Conclusions: The deep learning-based approach was capable of distinguishing slight motion blur that was unnoticeable on a preview LCD, and thus, is expected to aid the human visual system for detecting blurred images in the initial review of digital radiographs.
Purpose: The necessity of image retakes is initially determined on a preview monitor equipped with an operating system; therefore, some image blurring is only noticed later, on a high-resolution monitor. The purpose of this study is to investigate blur detection performance on radiographs via a deep learning approach compared with human observers. Approach: A total of 99 radiographs (blurry 57, nonblurry 42) were independently observed and rated by six observers using preview and diagnostic liquid crystal displays (LCDs). The deep convolution neural network (DCNN) was trained and tested using ninefold cross-validation. The average areas under the ROC curves (AUCs) were calculated for each observer with LCDs and by stand-alone DCNN for each test session and then statistically tested using a 95% confidence interval. Results: The average AUCs were 0.955 for stand-alone DCNN and 0.827 and 0.947 for human observers using preview and diagnostic LCDs, respectively. The DCNN revealed a high performance for image motion blur on digital radiographs (sensitivity 94.8%, specificity 96.8%, and accuracy 95.6%), along with the capability to detect a slight motion blur that was overlooked by human observers with a preview LCD. There were no cases of motion blur overlooked by the stand-alone DCNN, of which some were incorrectly recognized as nonblurry by human observers. Conclusions: The deep learning-based approach was capable of distinguishing slight motion blur that was unnoticeable on a preview LCD, and thus, is expected to aid the human visual system for detecting blurred images in the initial review of digital radiographs.