| Literature DB >> 35103123 |
Kartik Sonawane1, Saisrivas Dharmapuri1, Shlok Saxena1, Tuhin Mistry1, J Balavenkatasubramanian1.
Abstract
The clavicle is a frequently fractured bone with an infrequent bilateral occurrence. Regional anesthesia (RA) for clavicle surgeries is always challenging due to its complex innervation arising from the two plexuses (cervical and brachial). Various RA techniques described for clavicle surgeries include plexus blocks, fascial plane blocks, and truncal blocks. Plexus blocks are associated with undesirable effects, such as phrenic nerve blockade and paralysis of the entire upper limb, limiting their application for bilateral regional clavicle surgeries. The clavipectoral fascial plane block (CPB) is a novel, procedure-specific, phrenic-sparing, and motor-sparing RA technique that can provide anesthesia or analgesia for clavicle surgeries. The decision to use the CPB and/or other RA techniques may depend on the site of clavicle injury or variations in clavicular innervation. We report a case of single-stage bilateral clavicle surgery successfully managed with a bilateral CPB alone using ultrasound guidance and landmark guidance separately. The patient was kept awake and comfortable throughout the surgery. In conclusion, CPB can be an effective alternate RA technique in avoiding undesired side effects of more proximal techniques such as phrenic nerve involvement and motor blockade of upper limbs. Landmark-guided CPB can be an alternative with equianalgesic efficacy as of ultrasound-guided CPB in resource-poor or emergency settings.Entities:
Keywords: awake clavicle surgery; bilateral clavicle fracture; clavicle surgery; clavipectoral fascial plane block; fascial plane block; modified clavipectoral fascial plane block
Year: 2021 PMID: 35103123 PMCID: PMC8768890 DOI: 10.7759/cureus.20537
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Cureus ISSN: 2168-8184
Figure 1Radiographic and clinical images of the bilateral clavipectoral fascial plane block and bilateral clavicle fracture surgery
A1, A2: Radiographic images of right and left clavicle fracture; B1, B2: Performance of ultrasound-guided clavipectoral fascial plane block; B3: Performance of landmark-guided clavipectoral fascial plane block; C1, C2: Surgical fields of bilateral clavicle surgery with implants in situ; D1, D2, D3: Patient positioning during surgery and intraoperative radiographic pictures; E: Smiling patient able to lift both upper extremities immediately after surgery
Descriptive comparison between ultrasound-guided and landmark-guided clavipectoral fascial plane block
CPB: Clavipectoral fascial plane block, LA: Local anesthetic
| Ultrasound-guided CPB (US-CPB) | Landmark-guided CPB (LM-CPB) | |
| Local anesthetic (LA): | 20 ml of 2% lignocaine with epinephrine + 20 ml 0.5% of bupivacaine + 20 ml of normal saline + 8 mg dexamethasone | |
| LA volume: | 10 ml for medial and lateral injections 10 ml around the fracture site (in modified approach) 10 ml for the skin infiltration around the incision site (if required) | |
| Patient position: | Supine with head turned to the opposite side | |
| Probe/Landmarks: | High-frequency linear probe kept, Sagittally over the medial and lateral ends of the clavicle, OR Transversely along the length of the clavicle | Palpating medial and lateral ends of the clavicle using fingers |
| Needle: | 1.5 inch 23G hypodermic needle | |
| Needle direction and LA deposition: | With the probe in the sagittal plane: The needle is inserted in-plane from caudal-to-cranial direction depositing LA between clavipectoral fascia and periosteal collar. OR With the probe kept transversely along the clavicle: First moving probe medially towards the medial end, the needle is inserted in-plane from medial-to-lateral direction depositing LA above periosteal collar from medial end to the midpoint of the clavicle. Then, moving probe laterally towards the lateral end, the needle is inserted in-plane from lateral-to-medial direction depositing LA from lateral to the midpoint of clavicle above the periosteal collar. Third injection is required in a modified approach where the probe is kept over the fracture site, and LA is deposited around it under vision. | First injection: Medial end of the clavicle is palpated using a finger. LA is deposited over the medial end from the medial-to-lateral direction after hitting the bone. Second injection: Lateral end of the clavicle is palpated using a finger. LA is deposited over the lateral end from the lateral-to-medial direction after hitting the bone. Third injection: LA is deposited around the fracture site after hitting the bone on either side of the fracture site |
| Analgesic coverage: | Osteotomal innervations of the whole clavicle due to LA distribution over periosteum and dermatomal innervation may get involved due to the diffusion of the LA. | |
| Rescue technique: | Separate skin infiltration is required if supraclavicular nerves are not covered | |
| Advantages: | Completely motor-sparing technique; simple to learn, administer, or teach Less painful due to hypodermic needle | Completely motor-sparing technique; simple to learn, administer, or teach; economical as no requirement of special equipment like ultrasound or special skills; suitable for remote, poor resource, or emergency setting; less painful due to hypodermic needle |
| Disadvantage: | Limited extent of field block; may be ineffective in revision surgery, implant removal surgery, comminuted fractures, or nonunion/malunion surgery; not economical due to requirement of equipment like ultrasound and special skills in regional anesthesia | Limited extent of field block; may be ineffective in revision surgery, implant removal surgery, comminuted fractures, or nonunion/malunion surgery |
Literature analysis of clavipectoral fascial plane block between the years 2019-2021
CPB: Clavipectoral fascial plane block, GA: General anesthesia, RA: Regional anesthesia, SCPB: Superficial cervical plexus block, ISB: Interscalene block, SCNB: Supraclavicular nerve block
| Study | Year | No. of cases | Age/Sex of patient | Fracture site/ surgery | Anesthesia | LA type and Volume | Conclusion |
| Ince I. et al. [ | 2019 | 01 | 51/M | Left midshaft clavicle fracture | CPB + Local infiltration over the incision site | 30 ml of LA mixture (1:1 0.5% bupivacaine+2% lidocaine) | CPB can be an alternative to interscalene block |
| Ueshima H. et al. [ | 2019 | 01 | 57/M | Emergent percutaneous coronary intervention + fixation of right distal end clavicle fracture | GA + CPB | 20 ml of 0.25% levobupivacaine | CPB can provide effective analgesia and also can be alternate to brachial plexus block |
| Yoshimura M. et al. [ | 2019 | 02 | 37/M and 71/F | Fixation of the clavicle fracture | GA + RA (CPB +SCPB) | 15 ml of 0.375% levobupivacaine | CPB can be simple and safe for analgesia/anesthesia in clavicle fractures |
| Atalay Y. et al. [ | 2019 | 01 | 47/F | Fixation of the clavicle fracture | GA + RA (CPB +SCPB) | 20 ml of 0.25% bupivacaine | CPB can be suitable for anesthesia, postoperative pain management, emergency pain management, biopsies, or curettage of the clavicle bone tumors |
| Atalay Y. et al. [ | 2020 | 05 | 18-37/M | Fixation of the clavicle fracture | GA + RA (CPB +SCPB) | 20 mL of 0.25% bupivacaine | CPB can be an alternative to interscalene block with analgesic effectiveness in clavicle fracture |
| Kukreja P. et al. [ | 2020 | 03 | 32/F, 14/M, and 19/F | 1. Right distal clavicle excision 2. Implant removal right sternoclavicular joint 3. Left midshaft clavicle fracture fixation | 1. CPB + continuous right ISB 2. GA + CPB 3. GA + CPB | 1. 15 ml 0.5% ropivacaine for CPB 10 cc 0.5% ropivacaine bolus and 0.2% ropivacaine solution at 8 ml/hr 2. 15 ml 0.5% ropivacaine with 2 mg of dexamethasone 3. 10 ml 0.5% ropivacaine | CPB can be an effective alternative in avoiding motor-blockade and phrenic nerve paralysis due to proximal techniques and it does not carry the risk of pneumothorax |
| Magalhães J. et al. [ | 2020 | 04 | ? | Midshaft clavicle fracture fixation | GA + CPB | 10 to 15 ml of levobupivacaine 0.4% | For combined anesthesia, a single puncture approach of CPB constitutes an excellent analgesic option |
| Tulgar S. et al. [ | 2020 | 01 | 72/F | Breast-conserving surgery for right breast tumor | GA + Modified CPB | A total of 40 mL LA (20 mL bupivacaine 0.5%, 10 mL lidocaine 2%, and 10 mL normal saline) | Adequate sensorial block was achieved at the outer quadrant of the breast with modified CPB |
| Metinyurt H. et al. [ | 2021 | 02 | 64/F and 37/M | Cardiac Implantable electronic device (CIED) implantation | CPB | 15 ml of 0.5% bupivacaine for medial and lateral injections | CPB can be considered an alternative to other anesthesia techniques for CIED implantation |
| Rosales A. et al. [ | 2021 | 07 | ? | Midshaft clavicle fracture fixation | 2 patients with CPB only and 5 patients with CPB + SCPB | ? | CPB with or without SCPB provided effective and safe anesthesia and analgesia in clavicle surgery under GA or intravenous sedation |
| Gonçalves D. et al. [ | 2021 | 01 | 25/M | Implant removal right clavicle | CPB + SCNB | 20 + 5 mL (1:1 - 0.75% ropivacaine+ 2% mepivacaine) | A combination of CPB + SCNB is safe and easy to perform and reduces risks of phrenic nerve block and upper limb paralysis |
Figure 2Innervation of the clavicle and injection pattern of landmark-guided clavipectoral fascial plane block
A: Osteotomal innervation of the clavicle; B: Injection pattern of landmark-guided clavipectoral fascial plane block; C: Complete innervation of the clavicle
(Source of A and C: Sonawane K, Dixit H, Balavenkatasubramanian J, Gurumoorthi P (2021) Uncovering secrets of the beauty bone: A comprehensive review of anatomy and regional anesthesia techniques of clavicle surgeries. Open J Orthop Rheumatol 6(1): 019-029. DOI: https://dx.doi.org/10.17352/ojor.000034)
Choices of available RA techniques as per the type of the clavicle surgeries
A: Interscalene block + Superficial cervical plexus/supraclavicular nerve block, B: SCUT block (Selective supraclavicular nerve block + selective upper trunk block), C: Clavipectoral fascial plane block
LA: Local anesthetics
| Clavicle surgery | First choice RA | Second choice RA | Third choice RA | Comments |
| Unilateral clavicle fracture without scapula fracture | C | B | A | For medial end fracture surgery: An additional LA infiltration over the medial end periosteum and subcutaneous tissues is required. |
| Unilateral clavicle fracture with scapula fracture | A | B | C | |
| Unilateral comminuted fracture/ Revision surgery/ Implant removal surgery/ Non-union, mal-union surgery | B | A | C | |
| Bilateral clavicle fractures | C (bilaterally) | B (on one side) C (on another side) | B >A (on both sides) with low LA volume (5-7 ml). Staged block: one side block for first clavicle surgery followed by second side block for second clavicle surgery. |