| Literature DB >> 35077706 |
Vishal R Patel1, Sofia Gereta2, Christopher J Blanton2, Alexander L Chu2, Akash P Patel2, Michael Mackert3, David Zientek2, Nico Nortjé4, Anjum Khurshid5, Christopher Moriates2, Gregory Wallingford6.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: The COVID-19 pandemic has presented new challenges surrounding end-of-life planning and has been associated with increased online discussion about life support. RESEARCH QUESTION: How has online communication about advance care planning (ACP) and specific life-sustaining interventions (LSIs) changed during the pandemic? STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS: Conversations on Twitter containing references to LSIs (eg, "ECMO") or ACP (eg, "DNR/DNI") were collected between January 2019 and May 2021. User account metadata were used to predict user demographic information and to classify users as organizations, individuals, clinicians, or influencers. The number of impressions was compared across these user categories and the content of tweets analyzed by using natural language processing models to identify topics of discussion and associated emotional sentiment.Entities:
Keywords: COVID-19; decision-making; end of life; mechanical ventilation; medical informatics
Mesh:
Year: 2022 PMID: 35077706 PMCID: PMC8783527 DOI: 10.1016/j.chest.2022.01.023
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Chest ISSN: 0012-3692 Impact factor: 10.262
Figure 1Number of tweets and COVID-19 deaths over time. Daily global COVID-19 deaths (light red) and 31-day moving average of daily COVID-19 deaths (red) were obtained from World Health Organization Coronavirus (COVID-19) Dashboard Data Explorer (Geneva: World Health Organization, 2020). DNR/DNI = do-not-resituate/do-not-intubate; ECMO = extracorporeal membrane oxygenation.
User Demographic Characteristics
| Characteristics | ACP | LSIs | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Predicted sex (n = 35,464; 105,967) | < .001 | ||
| Male | 19,678 (55.5) | 71,952 (67.9) | |
| Female | 15,786 (44.5) | 34,012 (32.1) | |
| Predicted age, y (n = 35,464; 105,967) | < .001 | ||
| ≤ 18 | 4,871 (13.7) | 19,275 (18.2) | |
| 19-29 | 3,618 (10.2) | 12,451 (11.7) | |
| 30-39 | 7,952 (22.4) | 25,373 (23.9) | |
| ≥ 40 | 19,023 (53.6) | 48,868 (46.1) | |
| User type (n = 41,920; 125,693) | < .001 | ||
| Organizations | 6,456 (15.4) | 19,726 (15.7) | |
| Influencers | 383 (0.9) | 1,836 (1.5) | |
| Individuals | 25,099 (59.9) | 77,955 (62) | |
| Clinicians | 9,982 (23.8) | 26,176 (20.8) |
Data are presented as No. (%). P values were obtained from the χ2 test for independence. ACP = advance care planning; LSIs = life-sustaining interventions.
Sex and age were predicted for only nonorganization users.
Figure 2Comparison of contributors and impressions for users tweeting about ACP and LSIs. Box plots show the median value (horizontal bar), interquartile range (box), and 95% CI (vertical lines). Asterisks indicate a significant difference between content categories obtained from the Mann-Whitney U test with P < .001. ACP = advance care planning; LSIs = life-sustaining interventions.
Figure 3Violin plots showing the discrepancy in expressed sentiment in tweets about ACP and LSIs. The shaded areas represent the probability distribution of the emotional sentiment for each category of tweets. Box plots were overlaid to demonstrate the median value (horizontal bar), interquartile range (box), and 95% CI (vertical lines). ACP = advance care planning; LSIs = life-sustaining interventions.
Summary of Content Found in Tweets About ACP
| Topic | Topic Key Words | Representative Tweet | Sentiment |
|---|---|---|---|
| Calls to establish ACP | wish, decision, life, talk, think, power, attorney, choice, important, need | “PLEASE FOR THE LOVE OF GOD establish an advance directive for if you’re incapacitated. Choose someone who will respect your wishes to be power of attorney!! Do NOT leave it up to chance…” | 0.46 (0.03 to 0.73) |
| National Healthcare Decisions Month | learn, resource, national, #nhdd, talk, #acp, webinar, april, importance | “Today is National Healthcare Decisions Day, a day designed to educate the public and healthcare providers about the importance of advance care planning… #NHDD2021” | 0.60 (0.36 to 0.77) |
| Research | support, discussion, research, service, study, improve, work | “Just published in #jqps: New study on communication tool for engaging patients in #advancecareplanning during the #covid19 pandemic…” | 0.13 (–0.48 to 0.51) |
| Personal experiences | hospital, patient, die, sign, death, treatment, form, require, family | “My mother had a DNR and when she had end of life hospice care I prayed for God to take her for days because of her suffering before I held her hand as she took her last breath….” | –0.27 (–0.66 to 0.38) |
| Legal advice | decision, right, consent, legal, choice, against, decide, power, attorney | “The law does not require the patient’s or next of kin’s permission to put a DNR on someone. A doctor or medical professional can put one on a person without even informing them, this is as the UK law stands right now.” | 0.08 (–0.49 to 0.48) |
| Discrimination | home, death, disabled, old, notice, send, government, vulnerable, many | “… We have likely prevented few if any deaths and the govt has created far more with DNR orders on the old and disabled and by sending sick old people out of hospitals to care homes.” | –0.51 (–0.79 to 0.08) |
| COVID-19 precautions | mask, wear, please, sick, risk, worker, resource, waste, virus | “… If you don’t wear a mask be sure to carry a copy of your DNR with you at all times. You don’t deserve a hospital bed if you won’t wear a mask.” | –0.05 (–0.51 to 0.44) |
Sentiment is presented as median (interquartile range). ACP = advance care planning; DNR = do-not-resuscitate.
Individual user; predicted age, 19 to 29 years; predicted sex, female.
Organization account.
Nurse user; predicted age, 30 to 39 years; predicted sex, female.
Individual user; predicted age: ≥ 40 years, predicted sex, male.
Figure 4Topics of advance care planning tweets over time. Topics without appreciable temporal correlations were omitted for better visualization. NHDM = National Healthcare Decisions Month; WHO = World Health Organization.
Content Domains of ACP Tweets and Retweets According to Type of User
| Topic | Organizations | Influencers | Individuals | Clinicians | All Users | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tweets | Retweets | Tweets | Retweets | Tweets | Retweets | Tweets | Retweets | Tweets | Retweets | RT:T | |
| Calls for action | 1,430 (11.9) | 1,471 (3.9) | 42 (7.5) | 245 (1.3) | 1,978 (4.9) | 1,263 (1.3) | 788 (5.5) | 849 (4) | 4,238 (6.3) | 3,828 (2.2) | 0.9 |
| NHDM | 1,591 (13.3) | 2,065 (5.5) | 19 (3.4) | 77 (0.4) | 844 (2.1) | 846 (0.8) | 397 (2.8) | 789 (3.7) | 2,851 (4.2) | 3,777 (2.1) | 1.3 |
| Personal experiences | 2,295 (19.1) | 5,025 (13.4) | 134 (24.1) | 7,988 (41.4) | 11,807 (29.2) | 68,875 (69.1) | 4,121 (28.9) | 4,934 (23.2) | 18,357 (27.3) | 86,822 (48.8) | 4.7 |
| Legal advice | 1,271 (10.6) | 1,649 (4.4) | 66 (11.8) | 356 (1.8) | 6,251 (15.5) | 4,672 (4.7) | 2,184 (15.3) | 1,625 (7.6) | 9,772 (14.5) | 8,302 (4.7) | 0.8 |
| Discrimination | 1,400 (11.7) | 9,811 (26.1) | 64 (11.5) | 2,046 (10.6) | 8,366 (20.7) | 14,189 (14.2) | 2,731 (19.2) | 6,726 (31.6) | 12,561 (18.7) | 32,772 (18.4) | 2.6 |
| COVID-19 precautions | 1,135 (9.5) | 2,412 (6.4) | 59 (10.6) | 5,830 (30.2) | 7,178 (17.8) | 5,027 (5) | 2,264 (15.9) | 2,115 (9.9) | 10,636 (15.8) | 15,384 (8.7) | 1.4 |
| Research | 2,867 (23.9) | 15,102 (40.2) | 173 (31.1) | 2,744 (14.2) | 3,953 (9.8) | 4,839 (4.9) | 1,754 (12.3) | 4,253 (20) | 8,747 (13) | 26,938 (15.1) | 3.1 |
| Total | 11,989 | 37,535 | 557 | 19,286 | 40,377 | 99,711 | 14,239 | 21,291 | 67,162 | 177,823 | 2.6 |
Data are presented as No. (%) unless otherwise indicated. Statistically significant cells representing values greater than expecteda or less than expectedb when comparing across different user types at Bonferroni-adjusted P < .001. ACP = advance care planning; NHDM = National Healthcare Decisions Month; RT:T = retweet:tweet ratio.