Sodium and potassium are biological alkali metal ions that are essential for the physiological processes of cells and organisms. In combination with small-molecule metabolite information, disturbances in sodium and potassium tissue distributions can provide a further understanding of the biological processes in diseases. However, methods using mass spectrometry are generally tailored toward either elemental or molecular detection, which limits simultaneous quantitative mass spectrometry imaging of alkali metal ions and molecular ions. Here, we provide a new method by including crown ether molecules in the solvent for nanospray desorption electrospray ionization mass spectrometry imaging (nano-DESI MSI) that combines host-guest chemistry targeting sodium and potassium ions and quantitative imaging of endogenous lipids and metabolites. After evaluation and optimization, the method was applied to an ischemic stroke model, which has highly dynamic tissue sodium and potassium concentrations, and we report 2 times relative increase in the detected sodium concentration in the ischemic region compared to healthy tissue. Further, in the same experiment, we showed the accumulation and depletion of lipids, neurotransmitters, and amino acids using relative quantitation with internal standards spiked in the nano-DESI solvent. Overall, we demonstrate a new method that with a simple modification in liquid extraction MSI techniques using host-guest chemistry provides the added dimension of alkali metal ion imaging to provide unique insights into biological processes.
Sodium and potassium are biological alkali metal ions that are essential for the physiological processes of cells and organisms. In combination with small-molecule metabolite information, disturbances in sodium and potassium tissue distributions can provide a further understanding of the biological processes in diseases. However, methods using mass spectrometry are generally tailored toward either elemental or molecular detection, which limits simultaneous quantitative mass spectrometry imaging of alkali metal ions and molecular ions. Here, we provide a new method by including crown ether molecules in the solvent for nanospray desorption electrospray ionization mass spectrometry imaging (nano-DESI MSI) that combines host-guest chemistry targeting sodium and potassium ions and quantitative imaging of endogenous lipids and metabolites. After evaluation and optimization, the method was applied to an ischemic stroke model, which has highly dynamic tissue sodium and potassium concentrations, and we report 2 times relative increase in the detected sodium concentration in the ischemic region compared to healthy tissue. Further, in the same experiment, we showed the accumulation and depletion of lipids, neurotransmitters, and amino acids using relative quantitation with internal standards spiked in the nano-DESI solvent. Overall, we demonstrate a new method that with a simple modification in liquid extraction MSI techniques using host-guest chemistry provides the added dimension of alkali metal ion imaging to provide unique insights into biological processes.
Alkali metal ions such
as Na+ and K+ play
essential roles in biological systems for maintaining cell homeostasis.
For example, in the case of ischemic damage, depletion of adenosine
triphosphate (ATP) results in disruption of the Na+/K+-ATPase, and thus, intracellular Na+ concentration
increases, while K+ concentration decreases.[1,2] Hence, accurate determination of Na+ and K+ alterations is important for understanding their role in homeostasis
maintenance and/or disturbance. For that purpose, atomic spectroscopy
techniques, such as atomic absorption or emission, have been established
for the quantitative determination of metal ions in biological samples.[3] However, these methods require homogenization
and digestion of the tissue before analysis, which leads to a loss
of spatial information.Spatially resolved information is of
particular importance in biological
systems to elucidate mechanisms of action involved in diseased states
that lead to homeostasis perturbations.[4] Imaging of elemental distributions can be achieved with techniques
such as time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectrometry (TOF SIMS),[5] laser ablation inductively coupled plasma mass
spectrometry (LA ICP MS),[6] X-ray fluorescence
microscopy,[6] and proton-induced X-ray emission
(PIXE).[6] For imaging of molecular distributions,
several techniques have been developed, including matrix-assisted
laser desorption/ionization mass spectrometry (MALDI MS),[7] desorption electrospray ionization mass spectrometry
(DESI MS),[8] and nanospray desorption electrospray
ionization mass spectrometry (nano-DESI MS).[9] Recently, DESI followed by PIXE has been applied on the same tissue
section in two experiments to obtain trace elements and molecular
information on a single tissue section.[10] The plethora of MSI and other available imaging techniques provide
many opportunities;[11] however, deeper insights
with fewer experiments are gained when elemental and molecular imaging
are combined simultaneously in one technique.One reason for
the limited availability of imaging techniques with
simultaneous imaging of Na+ and K+ and molecular
distributions is that molecular imaging in a positive ion mode requires
high mass resolving power to distinguish isobars due to adduct formations.
Additionally, it requires the MSI technique to eliminate matrix effects
based on Na+ and K+ adducts.[12] To circumvent the limitations, Liu et al. utilized a MALDI-TOF/TOF
instrument, peaking at 40,000 mass resolution, first in the negative
ion mode to image metabolites and then in the positive ion mode in
a separate experiment for MSI of alkali metal ions.[13] However, even when performing two different experiments,
modern mass spectrometers with a high enough resolving power to resolve
many metabolite isobars (>100,000 m/Δm at m/z below 400), such
as Orbitrap or Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance, are not
capable of scanning below 50 Da, which makes direct detection of Na+ and K+ impossible. Therefore, indirect determination
of Na+ and K+ distributions through adduct formation
is a reasonable approach.Crown ethers are macroheterocyclic
compounds that form high-affinity
complexes with alkali metal ions. Ever since the discovery of the
first crown ether,[14] dibenzo-18-crown-6
(db18c6), the complexation properties of crown ethers with metal ions
have been exploited in various fields of chemistry.[15−17] Crown ethers
have also been used with mass spectrometry for studying complexation
properties and quantitation of guests.[18−20] For example, an active
pharmaceutical ingredient was complexed with crown ethers for its
direct quantitative analysis in tablets by doping the solvent in DESI
MS.[20] Similarly, the extraction solvent
can be doped in nano-DESI MSI with both internal standards and reagents
to eliminate matrix effects[12] from alterations
in Na+ and K+ and gain quantitative, sensitive,
and selective analysis.[21−29] In nano-DESI, the extraction solvent forms a liquid bridge between
two fused silica capillaries into which chemical species are desorbed
upon contact with the tissue for subsequent ionization.[30] By doping the solvent, endogenous molecules
will be ionized and/or complexed simultaneously with the dopant and
provide unique information even in the complex chemical matrix of
thin tissue sections.Here, we report the first use of crown
ethers in MSI by adding
them into the nano-DESI solvent for simultaneous elemental and metabolite
imaging. We show that in situ host–guest chemistry in MSI is
robust and enables quantification of Na+ or K+ in imaging of complex tissue samples. Additionally, we show that
simultaneous quantitative ion images are provided for endogenous molecules
by also doping the solvent with internal standards. We apply our method
to study the distribution of Na+, K+, lipids,
and metabolites in a middle cerebral artery occlusion (MCAO) rodent
stroke model and directly quantitatively correlate their accumulation
and depletion in the ischemic region.
Materials and Methods
Chemicals
and Biological Samples
All chemicals were
purchased from Sigma-Aldrich and used without further purification,
unless otherwise stated. Methanol was purchased from Merck (LC-MS
grade); 12-crown-4, 15-crown-5, and benzo-15-crown-5 from Fisher Scientific;
and dl-glutamic-2,4,4-d3 acid
from QMX Laboratories (Thaxted, UK).Flash frozen healthy Sprague–Dawley
rat brain tissue was purchased from Innovative Research Inc. (Novi,
MI, USA) and sectioned at 12 μm thickness using a cryostat (Cryostar
NX 70, Thermo 165 Scientific, Bremen, Germany). Flash frozen transient
MCAO (1 h MCAO and 2 h reperfusion) mouse brain tissue from one 8–10
week old male C57BL/6 mouse was purchased from Creative Biolabs (NY,
USA) and sectioned at 10 μm thickness (Leica CM1900, Leica Microsystems).
Tissue sections were thaw-mounted on regular microscope glass slides
and stored at −80 °C until the analysis of three consecutive
sections.
Preparation and Analysis of NaCl-Spiked Mimetic Tissue Model
A NaCl-spiked mimetic tissue model was prepared according to Barry
et al.[31] using rat brain homogenates spiked
with differential amounts of NaCl: 0, 20, 50, and 90 μmol g–1. The mimetic tissue model was stored at −80
°C until cryosectioning at 14 μm thickness and thaw-mounted
on regular microscope glass slides. Details on the preparation of
the mimetic tissue model are provided in the Supporting Information.A section of the NaCl-spiked mimetic tissue
model was imaged using conventional nano-DESI as previously described,[23] where 0.1 μM of dibenzo-18-crown-6 was
doped in the solvent (methanol/water 9:1 v/v). The solvent flow rate
was 0.5 μL min–1, and the sample moved at
0.06 mm s–1 in the x-axis direction
in steps of 200 μm along the y-direction under
the nano-DESI probe using a motorized X–Y–Z stage (Zaber Technologies Inc.,
Vancouver, BC) controlled by a custom-designed LabVIEW program.[32]
Determination of Na in Rat Brain Homogenate
Using ICP-AES
Two aliquots from a homogenate prepared from
a rat brain were analyzed.
For each sample, an amount of homogenate (19–25 mg) was dissolved
in a known volume of the same solvent that was used for the nano-DESI
MSI analysis of NaCl-spiked mimetic tissue model (see above). The
samples were sonicated for 60 min until a clear solution was obtained,
diluted 20 times using 10% HCl, and the sodium content was determined
using ICP-AES (PerkinElmer DV4300 Cirros CCD) by measuring emission
at 589.592 nm. Sodium was determined in blank samples that were prepared
by using the solvent used for dissolving the rat brain homogenate.
Sampling and Imaging with Pneumatically Assisted Nano-DESI
The pneumatically assisted nano-DESI probe was constructed based
on the design of Duncan et al.[33] Briefly,
two fused silica capillaries (50 × 150 μm, ID × OD,
Polymicro Technologies, L.L.C., Phoenix, USA) were positioned at a
fixed angle (≈90°) and nitrogen gas was supplied at ≈2.5
bar. The solvent was propelled using a syringe pump (Legato 180, KD
Scientific, Holliston, USA) at a flow rate of 0.5 μL min–1.For method development, the nano-DESI probe
was used to sample solutions from a small polypropylene cap for sampling,
ionization, and acquisition of ≈50 continuous scans of a stable
signal. The nano-DESI solvent was composed of methanol containing
0.1 μM dibenzo-18-crown-6 (db18c6), 0.1 μM 12-crown-4
(12c4), 0.1 μM 15-crown-5 (15c5), 0.1 μM benzo-15-crown-5
(b15c5), 25 μM d-glucose-6,6-d2 (glucose-d2), and 0.1 μM
acetylcholine chloride (N,N,N-trimethyl-d9) (acetylcholine-d9). For evaluation of total salt concentration,
the solution in the cap had the same composition as the nano-DESI
solvent with the addition of various concentrations of Na+ and K+ in the form of chloride salts. For evaluation
of crown ether concentrations, the solution in the nano-DESI solvent
and the cap was the same with different concentrations of crown ethers
(db18c6, 12c4, 15c5, and b15c5) and the cap also contained various
amounts of Na+ and K+.For surface sampling
from rat brain tissue, the nano-DESI solvent
contained 0.1 μM db18c6, 0.1 μM 12c4, 0.1 μM 15c5,
0.1 μM b15c5, 0.1 μM acetylcholine-d9, and 25 μM glucose-d2 in
methanol/water 9:1 v/v. The sample was moved at a speed of 0.02 mm
s–1 under the nano-DESI probe.Imaging of
MCAO mouse brain tissue with pneumatically assisted
nano-DESI was achieved using the following solvent compositions: 0.1
μM db18c6, 0.1 μM 12c4, 0.1 μM 15c5, 0.1 μM
b15c5, 1.5 μM lysophosphatidylcholine 19:0 (LPC 19:0), 25 μM
glucose-d2, 10.15 μM 4-aminobutyric-2,2-d2 (GABA-d2), 0.1
μM acetylcholine-d9, 1.5 μM
phosphatidylcholine 12:0–13:0 (PC 25:0), 9.94 μM dl-glutamic-2,4,4-d3 acid (glutamic-d3), and 12,000-times diluted cell free 15N-labeled amino acid mixture in pure methanol. Individual
concentrations of the 15N-labeled amino acids are provided
in Table S1. The sample was moved at a speed of 0.04 mm s–1 along the x-axis, and each acquired line was spaced
by 75 μm along the y-axis. Considering the
scan rate of the mass spectrometer (1.7 scans s–1), the final pixel size was ≈24 × 75 μm2.
Mass Spectrometry
All data were recorded using a QExactive
mass spectrometer (Thermo Fischer Scientific, Bremen, Germany) operated
at a resolution of 140,000 (m/Δm at m/z 200), orbitrap AGC target
of 1 × 106, S-lens RF level of 50, heated ion transfer
capillary temperature of 300 °C, and electrospray voltage of
3.2 kV.
Data Processing
Data files were converted from RAW
files to centroided mzXML using ProteoWizard MSConvert.[34] All data processing was done in MATLAB R2019b
(MathWorks, USA) using in-house scripts for obtaining the intensity
of molecules of interest by locating the closest peak that is within
a mass accuracy tolerance of 5 ppm. Region of interest (ROI) analysis
was conducted with in-house scripts using MATLAB. ROI analysis of
Na+-spiked mimetic tissue model was facilitated by using
a mask that enabled the selection of pixels corresponding to tissue
and exclude empty spaces such as holes. Details of this procedure
are provided in the Supporting Information. Furthermore, values of zero intensity were excluded from the analysis,
and to remove outliers, only the data between the 5th and 95th percentiles
were kept. Weighted least squares regression was conducted using R
in RStudio (The R Project for Statistical Computing, http://www.r-project.org). Statistical
significance of mean concentrations between the healthy and ischemic
areas of MCAO mouse brain tissue sections was assessed using the two-tailed
Student t test.
Results and Discussion
Crown
Ether Evaluation
Crown ethers generally have
a high binding affinity for Na+ and K+.[35] However, the specific affinities depend on the
individual crown ether’s structure, including their cavity
size, number of electronegative oxygen atoms, and inductive side groups.[36] For example, the larger cavity ring of db18c6
increases its affinity for the larger K+ over Na+, while the opposite is true for 12c4 with a smaller cavity size
(Figure A, Table S2). The applicability of the four crown
ethers db18c6, 12c4, 15c5, and b15c5 was evaluated in neat solutions
containing 550 μM NaCl, 550 μM KCl, and 0.1 μM of
each of the crown ethers using pneumatically assisted nano-DESI MSI,
and their experimentally obtained relative abundances of Na+ and K+ adducts were compared to the theoretically calculated
relative abundances (see the Supporting Information for details on calculations) (Figure B). The results show excellent agreement between the
experimental and theoretical data for db18c6 and 12c4, which indicates
that the theoretical binding affinities are sustained through electrospray
ionization. In contrast, 15c5 and b15c5 show quite large discrepancies,
which are due to isobaric overlaps between system peaks and the sodiated
crown ether adducts at m/z 243.12
and 259.12. These overlaps cause an increased intensity of the Na+ adducts and thereby shift the relative abundances of their
respective Na+ and K+ adduct, thereby excluding
them as hosts. Although this is not the case for the 12c4 crown ether,
it was instead excluded because its smaller ring cavity size enables
the formation of protonated adducts (Figures S1 and S2). The formation of protonated adducts, in addition to
Na+ and K+ adducts, will split the signal and
make the Na+ and K+ adduct formation sensitive
to pH changes. Consequently, db18c6 was selected as the preferred
crown ether host because no protonated adducts were detected (Figures S1 and S2) and there was a good agreement
between the experimental and theoretical relative abundances of Na+ and K+ adducts (Figure B), indicating minimal spectral overlaps
for these mass channels. Further, the addition of db18c6 to the nano-DESI
solvent neither interferes with the detection of endogenous metabolites
and lipids (Figure S3) nor disturbs the
alkali metal adduct distribution of lipids (Figure S4). Thus, db18c6 is suitable for use in nano-DESI MSI of tissue
sections.
Figure 1
Four crown ethers evaluated as hosts. (A) Structures and nomenclature.
(B) Experimental (black bars) and theoretical (gray bars) relative
abundances of Na+ and K+ adducts of the respective
crown ethers. The same concentrations of crown ethers, Na+, and K+ were used to obtain both experimental and theoretical
data.
Four crown ethers evaluated as hosts. (A) Structures and nomenclature.
(B) Experimental (black bars) and theoretical (gray bars) relative
abundances of Na+ and K+ adducts of the respective
crown ethers. The same concentrations of crown ethers, Na+, and K+ were used to obtain both experimental and theoretical
data.
Quantification at Varying
Salt Concentrations
Although
db18c6 is suitable, the host–guest method also needs to provide
quantitative results to determine the impact of Na+ and
K+ in biological systems. In particular, the acquired relative
intensities need to mirror the actual relative abundance of each cation,
and it needs to be independent of the total salt concentrations in
the sample. Therefore, first, neat solutions containing different
proportions of Na+ and K+, in equally spaced
increments of 20% ranging from 10% Na+–90% K+ to 90% Na–10% K+, were analyzed with direct
infusion ESI at a total salt concentration of 200 μM (Figure S5). These results show, both experimentally
and theoretically, that the higher binding affinities of db18c6 for
K+ (log Kb is 5.0 for K+ and 4.37 for Na+) cause nonlinear correlations
between the detected adduct intensities and the alkali metal ion concentrations.
These nonlinear correlations make it difficult to directly determine
the individual Na+ and K+ concentrations based
on their complexation with db18c6 (Figure S5A,B,D,E). Specifically, the higher affinity of db18c6 for K+ in
combination with the higher amount of K+ in the brain causes
the [db18c6 + K]+ signal to become saturated (Figure S6). Therefore, we use the adduct intensity
ratio, determined as [M + Na]+ divided by [M + K]+, to remove effects of equilibrium concentration saturation and allow
for comparison of Na+ and K+ using linear regression
(Figure S5C,F).Second, the complexation
of db18c6 with Na+ and K+ was evaluated using
five different total salt concentrations of 300, 500, 700, 900, and
1100 μM of [NaCl] + [KCl] and different proportions of Na+ and K+ (10% Na+–90% K+ to 90% Na–10% K+) at each total salt concentration,
using pneumatically assisted nano-DESI (Table S3). The results in Figure A depict negligible differences for the various total
salt concentrations studied on the Na+/K+ adduct
intensity ratio, showing that the ratio is not affected by differences
in the amount of salt. The increased residuals at higher proportions
of Na+ result from higher individual intensities and heteroscedastic
noise, as observed from larger standardized residuals at larger values
of the x-variable (Figure S7);[37] thus, the data were fitted using
weighted least squares. Third, we show that the obtained linear regression
can be used to determine unknown [Na+]/[K+]
at small biases of only 4–13% (Figure S8 and Table S4). Collectively, the results show that the crown
ether db18c6 can be successfully used as a host to quantitatively
determine various [Na+]/[K+] in total salt concentrations
ranging between 200 and 1100 μM.
Figure 2
Intensity ratio is independent
of total salt and crown ether concentrations.
(A) Weighted least squares of Na+/K+ adduct
intensity ratio of db18c6 vs [Na+]/[K+] with
1/σ2 used as weighting at various total salt concentrations.
The fitted line has the linear equation y = 0.112x + 0.028 with R2 = 0.9738.
At each concentration ratio, three replicates for each total salt
concentration condition were acquired. Error bars show the standard
deviation of each sample (scan-to-scan variation). (B) Na+/K+ adduct intensity ratio of db18c6 vs [Na+]/[K+] at different crown ether concentrations. The fitted
line has the linear equation y = 0.077x + 0.001 with R2 = 0.9603. At each individual
concentration, three replicates were acquired. Error bars represent
one standard deviation of each replicate (scan-to-scan variation).
Intensity ratio is independent
of total salt and crown ether concentrations.
(A) Weighted least squares of Na+/K+ adduct
intensity ratio of db18c6 vs [Na+]/[K+] with
1/σ2 used as weighting at various total salt concentrations.
The fitted line has the linear equation y = 0.112x + 0.028 with R2 = 0.9738.
At each concentration ratio, three replicates for each total salt
concentration condition were acquired. Error bars show the standard
deviation of each sample (scan-to-scan variation). (B) Na+/K+ adduct intensity ratio of db18c6 vs [Na+]/[K+] at different crown ether concentrations. The fitted
line has the linear equation y = 0.077x + 0.001 with R2 = 0.9603. At each individual
concentration, three replicates were acquired. Error bars represent
one standard deviation of each replicate (scan-to-scan variation).
Independence of Crown Ether Concentrations
The independence
of amenable crown ether concentrations on quantification using the
host–guest method is necessary for robustness and flexibility,
both for sample types and mass spectrometry operating conditions.
Therefore, neat solutions at a total salt concentration of 500 μM
and with varying proportions of Na+ and K+ (10%
Na+–90% K+, 50% Na+–50%
K+, and 90% Na+–10% K+) were
analyzed with four different db18c6 concentrations: 0.05, 0.1, 0.5,
and 1 μM. The results show that the Na+/K+ adduct intensity ratios are conserved for all crown ether concentrations
(Figure B), demonstrating
that any db18c6 concentration between 0.05 and 1 μM could be
used to monitor [Na+]/[K+] changes. This displays
the flexibility and robustness of the host–guest method to
be used in different applications and with a range of instrumental
conditions that may require higher or lower crown ether concentrations.
Compatibility with High Molecular Complexity
The molecular
complexity of samples such as tissue could cause interferences and
produce artifacts during ionization, ultimately affecting the accuracy
of quantification.[12] To assess this, a
mimetic brain tissue model was constructed and spiked with increasing
amounts of Na+ in different segments. Quantification of
the non-spiked segment was then performed by standard addition using
pneumatically assisted nano-DESI MSI with 0.1 μM db18c6 doped
in the solvent (Figure A,B). Then, the Na+/K+ adduct intensity ratio
data were extracted from each segment of the mimetic tissue and plotted
against the Na+ concentrations of the respective segments.
The results show a linear correlation between signal and Na+ concentration despite the high chemical complexity (Figures C and S9), indicating the feasibility for quantification with our
method. Furthermore, by considering the obtained data as a standard
addition curve, we could determine the Na+ concentration
in the non-spiked layer to be 70 ± 6 μmol g–1 (Figure C). The
accuracy of this result was further assessed by parallel analysis
using ICP-AES. Specifically, we established an external calibration
curve and analyzed the Na+ in two aliquots of a rat brain
homogenate with ICP-AES. The ICP-AES analysis determined the Na+ concentration to be 55 ± 14 μmol g–1, which is in good agreement with the results from our new host–guest
method. Similar results obtained via the two extremely different analytical
approaches demonstrate the feasibility of our host–guest approach
to indirectly determine the concentration of Na+ in chemically
complex tissue sections using MSI.
Figure 3
Sampling and imaging of Na+ and K+ from tissue
sections. (A) Optical image of the Na+-spiked mimetic tissue
model section, starting with a blank and then increasing Na+ concentrations from left to right. (B) Image showing the db18c6
Na+/K+ adduct intensity ratio (from 0 to 50%
relative intensity ratio) obtained after nano-DESI MSI of the section
shown in (A). (C) Extracted ROI data from each layer of the analyzed
section of the mimetic tissue model showing the average Na+/K+ adduct intensity ratio of db18c6 vs the spiked Na+ amount in each layer. Error bars show one standard deviation
of each ROI. The red line indicates a linear fit through the data
points with equation y = 0.00127x + 0.089. (D) Optical image of the analyzed rat brain tissue section
where the red line indicates the acquired line scan. (E) Na+/K+ adduct intensity ratio of db18c6 (left axis, black
line) and relative intensity of endogenous [PC 34:1 + K]+ (right axis, orange line) measured during the sampling of the line
shown in (A) after using a moving average algorithm (n = 3). Gray shaded areas indicate sampling from gray matter regions,
while the lighter gray area indicates the white matter region of the
brain tissue section. Areas with no shading indicate sampling from
the glass surface. Scale bars in (A,D) show 1 mm, and the color scale
in (B) refers to relative intensity ratio.
Sampling and imaging of Na+ and K+ from tissue
sections. (A) Optical image of the Na+-spiked mimetic tissue
model section, starting with a blank and then increasing Na+ concentrations from left to right. (B) Image showing the db18c6
Na+/K+ adduct intensity ratio (from 0 to 50%
relative intensity ratio) obtained after nano-DESI MSI of the section
shown in (A). (C) Extracted ROI data from each layer of the analyzed
section of the mimetic tissue model showing the average Na+/K+ adduct intensity ratio of db18c6 vs the spiked Na+ amount in each layer. Error bars show one standard deviation
of each ROI. The red line indicates a linear fit through the data
points with equation y = 0.00127x + 0.089. (D) Optical image of the analyzed rat brain tissue section
where the red line indicates the acquired line scan. (E) Na+/K+ adduct intensity ratio of db18c6 (left axis, black
line) and relative intensity of endogenous [PC 34:1 + K]+ (right axis, orange line) measured during the sampling of the line
shown in (A) after using a moving average algorithm (n = 3). Gray shaded areas indicate sampling from gray matter regions,
while the lighter gray area indicates the white matter region of the
brain tissue section. Areas with no shading indicate sampling from
the glass surface. Scale bars in (A,D) show 1 mm, and the color scale
in (B) refers to relative intensity ratio.In addition to monitoring Na+/K+ changes
in homogeneous tissue sections, the method needs to be accurate in
dynamic molecular compositions. Two morphologically different brain
tissue regions are white matter, which has a high abundance of glycolipids,
and gray matter, with a high abundance of phospholipids.[12] Therefore, a tissue transect was performed using
pneumatically assisted nano-DESI MS with 0.1 μM db18c6 doped
in the solvent over both gray and white matter areas in a brain tissue
section (Figure D).
In Figure E, the Na+/K+ adduct intensity ratio for db18c6 is shown
(black line) along with the intensity of the endogenous phospholipid
[PC 34:1 + K+] (orange line). Three different regions are
highlighted in Figure E; white areas are glass, gray areas are gray matter, and the light
gray area corresponds to the white matter. Further, it was observed
that as the nano-DESI probe comes into contact with the tissue surface,
the individual mass spectrometric signals of [db18c6 + Na]+ and [db18c6 + K]+ are suppressed due to the high abundance
of phospholipids present in the gray matter (Figure S10). As can be seen in Figure E, the intensity of the endogenous phospholipid PC
34:1 decreases when the white area is sampled as expected. Importantly,
despite the alterations in molecular composition between the white
and the gray matter, the Na+/K+ adduct intensity
ratio remains consistent (Figure E). This was expected considering that the matrix,
that is, tissue environment, would affect the sodiated and potassiated
adducts to the same extent, and therefore, monitoring the Na+/K+ adduct intensity ratio when Na+ and K+ are in vast excess conveniently removes such matrix effects.
However, a simultaneous decrease in both ions would be difficult to
distinguish using the ratio. Collectively, these results demonstrate
that the method is also applicable in tissue samples with a highly
dynamic chemical environment.
Quantitative Imaging
One such environment is ischemic
stroke, and it is well known that ischemic stroke significantly alters
the tissue distribution of Na+, K+, and small
molecules.[1,38−41] Quantitative distributions of
Na+ and K+ can be obtained with microdissection
followed by ICP-AES; however, this does not provide simultaneous metabolite
information. Here, an MCAO mouse brain tissue section, with the ischemic
region circled in red, was imaged with both db18c6 and internal standards
included in the nano-DESI for simultaneous quantitative elemental
and molecular imaging (Figure A). The Na+/K+ adduct intensity ratio
of db18c6 is clearly elevated levels in the ischemic area (Figures B and S11). Note that the ion images in Figure B–J depict only those
pixels that are correlated with endogenous PC 34:1 because the Na/K
adduct intensity ratio of db18c6 is also visible outside the tissue
(Figure S11). Interestingly, the distribution
of Na+/K+ is heterogeneous in the ischemic area
with a higher ratio in the center compared to the edges, which mirrors
our previous observation of the distribution of LPC 18:1 in the damaged
area and suggests a deeper damage in the center.[39] By applying the obtained regression line (Figure B) to each pixel, the Na+/K+ adduct intensity ratio of db18c6 was converted
to [Na+]/[K+]. The average [Na+]/[K+] was 0.84 ± 0.06 in the ischemic ROI and 0.29 ±
0.08 in the healthy ROI, showing that the concentration ratio is about
3 times higher in the damaged area than in the corresponding healthy
hemisphere (Figures C and S12). Further, because both the
Na+ concentration and the extraction efficiency of the
mimetic tissue model (Figure A–C) and the mouse brain tissue section (Figure A) are expected to be similar,
the previously quantified concentration of 70 ± 6 μmol
g–1 of Na+ can be used as a measure for
the healthy tissue. Thus, the Na+/K+ adduct
intensity ratio can be further converted to [Na+] to show
that the ischemic region has around 150 μmol g–1 of Na+ in the center (Figures D and S13). Using
the average Na+/K+ adduct intensity ratio of
db18c6 for the ischemic and the healthy region obtained after analysis
of three tissue sections, we determine that the average Na+ concentration in the larger ischemic area is 96 μmol g–1, while in the healthy area, it is 48 μmol g–1 (Table ). Subsequently, we can also determine the [K+] because
the [Na+]/[K+] and the [Na+] are
known. In the ischemic region, we determine the K+ concentration
to be 115 μmol g–1, and in the healthy region,
we determine it to be 169 μmol g–1 (Table ), showing that [Na+] is increasing and [K+] is decreasing in the ischemic
region of the MCAO mouse brain. Notably, according to previous studies,
[K+] is around 10 μmol g–1 higher
in the gray matter than in the white matter, but this is below our
sensitivity (depicted as the standard deviation of our measurement
in Table ) and therefore
not observed.[42,43] The results of our concentrations
were further verified using ICP-AES analysis, in which the concentrations
in healthy rat brain tissue were determined to be 55 ± 14 μmol
g–1 of Na+ and 99 ± 29 μmol
g–1 of K+. Our findings are consistent
with the expected stroke pathophysiology[1,2] as well as
previous reports.[44,45] In particular, Mulder et al.
observed increased Na+/K+ in the ischemic region
using SIMS in a transient MCAO mouse model,[44] and Young et al. reported quantitative alterations of sodium and
potassium ions in different rat brain regions at various time points
after MCAO.[45] Specifically, Young et al.
determined 53 μmol g–1 of Na+ and
112 μmol g–1 of K+ in brain tissue
of unoperated rats.[45] Although there is
a small discrepancy between the potassium concentrations for the healthy
region determined with our method compared to Young et al. and our
ICP-AES, this may be the result of comparing rat and mouse brain tissue.
Furthermore, rat brain homogenates were also used to construct the
calibration sample and report results of mouse brain tissue in our
method; thus, potential differences among the animals might have contributed
to accurate concentration discrepancies. Overall, the results show
that quantitative elemental MSI is possible in the complex stroke
model using our developed host–guest chemistry.
Figure 4
Combined molecular and
elemental information obtained with nano-DESI
MSI. (A) Optical image of the MCAO mouse brain section, where the
ischemic region is marked with a red circle, images of (B) Na+/K+ adduct intensity ratio of db18c6, (C) concentration
ratio Na+/K+ obtained using the regression line
of Figure A and data
from (B), (D) Na+ concentration obtained using the regression
line of Figure S13 and data from (B), (E)
[PC 38:6 + K]+ normalized to [PC 25:0 + K]+,
(F) [LPC 16:0 + K]+ normalized to [LPC 19:0 + K]+, (G) acetylcholine normalized to acetylcholine-d9, (H) [GABA + H]+ normalized to [GABA-d2 + H]+, (I) [glutamine + Na]+ normalized to [glutamine-15N2 + Na]+, and (J) [phenylalanine + K]+ normalized to [phenylalanine-15N + K]+. Scale bars show 1 mm. The maximum color
scale has been adjusted to increase the clarity of less intense features.
Table 1
Averagea Detected
Concentrations (±1 Standard Deviationa) Extracted from ROI Analysis of Three Independent MCAO Mouse Brain
Tissue Sections Showing Differences among the Ischemic and the Healthy
Areas
detected
concentration
ischemic
area
healthy area
μmol g–1
[Na+]b
96 ± 5
48 ± 7
[K+]b
115 ± 2
169 ± 17
μM/pixel
PC 38:6b
1.56 ± 0.10
1.86 ± 0.12
LPC 16:0b
0.47 ± 0.03
0.33 ± 0.03
acetylcholineb
0.0097 ± 0.0013
0.0134 ± 0.0009
GABAb
11.41 ± 0.52
7.95 ± 0.48
glutamine
12.85 ± 1.74
17.32 ± 1.70
phenylalanineb
0.28 ± 0.01
0.15 ± 0.01
Means of each ROI
from all technical
replicates (n = 3) were combined, and standard deviations
were calculated from the pooled ROI means.
Statistically significant means
(p < 0.05) among the healthy and ischemic areas
using the two-tailed Student t test.
Combined molecular and
elemental information obtained with nano-DESI
MSI. (A) Optical image of the MCAO mouse brain section, where the
ischemic region is marked with a red circle, images of (B) Na+/K+ adduct intensity ratio of db18c6, (C) concentration
ratio Na+/K+ obtained using the regression line
of Figure A and data
from (B), (D) Na+ concentration obtained using the regression
line of Figure S13 and data from (B), (E)
[PC 38:6 + K]+ normalized to [PC 25:0 + K]+,
(F) [LPC 16:0 + K]+ normalized to [LPC 19:0 + K]+, (G) acetylcholine normalized to acetylcholine-d9, (H) [GABA + H]+ normalized to [GABA-d2 + H]+, (I) [glutamine + Na]+ normalized to [glutamine-15N2 + Na]+, and (J) [phenylalanine + K]+ normalized to [phenylalanine-15N + K]+. Scale bars show 1 mm. The maximum color
scale has been adjusted to increase the clarity of less intense features.Means of each ROI
from all technical
replicates (n = 3) were combined, and standard deviations
were calculated from the pooled ROI means.Statistically significant means
(p < 0.05) among the healthy and ischemic areas
using the two-tailed Student t test.In addition to Na and K, selected
molecular ion images are displayed
in Figure E–J.
Note that all color scales are quantitative and individual for each
ion image by use of internal standards[46] and summarized in Table . Figure E
depicts the distribution of PC 38:6, which exhibits minimal impact
by the stroke event and therefore mainly shows different morphological
regions of the mouse brain section. On the contrary, ischemia-mediated
molecular alterations, such as the increased production of LPC 16:0,
is visible in the damaged area (Figure F), which is consistent with previous reports.[39,40,47,48] In addition, alterations in neurotransmitters and amino acids distributions
are observed. Specifically, in the ischemic region, acetylcholine
showed decreased levels (Figure G), GABA was increased (Figure H), glutamine was decreased (Figure I), and phenylalanine was increased
(Figure J). These
findings support our method’s capability of quantification
of metabolites clearly perturbed by ischemia and simultaneous quantification
of spatially resolved individual concentrations of Na+ and
K+. We envision that the depth of information that can
be acquired through the combination of our developed host–guest
method and quantitative spatial metabolomics will provide new insights
into metabolic pathways even in severely chemically altered tissue
environment like ischemia.
Conclusions
Here,
we present a simple method for visualization and quantitative
determination of changes in [Na+] and [K+] using
host–guest chemistry with crown ethers doped in the solvent
for nano-DESI MSI of thin tissue sections. We evaluated the use of
different crown ethers for revealing quantitative changes in [Na+]/[K+] and found db18c6 to be the most robust.
The crown ether db18c6 was doped in the nano-DESI solvent along with
appropriate internal standards for simultaneous quantitative elemental
and molecular MSI. The main advantage of our method is the combined
and simultaneous quantification of Na+, K+,
lipids, neurotransmitters, and amino acids, which enhances the information
obtained from each tissue section. The method was demonstrated using
a MCAO mouse stroke model and revealed that [Na+]/[K+] ratios are increased up to 2.9 times in the ischemic region.
Further, individual concentrations of Na and K were determined, and
a 2 times increase in [Na+] and 1.5 times decrease in [K+] were determined in the ischemic region. In addition, accumulation
and depletion of several classes of metabolites in the ischemic region
were detected, when compared to the healthy brain region. We envision
that our method will be easily adapted for future MSI applications,
where disease progression and identification-associated metabolic
pathways are monitored for basic understanding and for future treatment
targets.
Authors: Son N Nguyen; Jennifer E Kyle; Sydney E Dautel; Ryan Sontag; Teresa Luders; Richard Corley; Charles Ansong; James Carson; Julia Laskin Journal: Anal Chem Date: 2019-08-27 Impact factor: 8.008
Authors: Elizabeth K Neumann; Katerina V Djambazova; Richard M Caprioli; Jeffrey M Spraggins Journal: J Am Soc Mass Spectrom Date: 2020-09-04 Impact factor: 3.262
Authors: Leonidas Mavroudakis; Susan L Stevens; Kyle D Duncan; Mary P Stenzel-Poore; Julia Laskin; Ingela Lanekoff Journal: Anal Bioanal Chem Date: 2020-10-19 Impact factor: 4.142