Zhuo Yang1, Wei Xu1, Bingdong Yan1, Baiqiang Wu1, Jinxin Ma1, Xiaohong Wang1, Bin Qiao2, Jinchun Tu1, Hua Pei2, Delun Chen1, Qiang Wu2. 1. State Key Laboratory of Marine Resource Utilization in South China Sea, College of Materials Science and Engineering, Hainan University, Haikou 570228, China. 2. Department of Clinical Laboratory of the Second Affiliated Hospital, School of Tropical Medicine and Laboratory Medicine, Key Laboratory of Emergency and Trauma of Ministry of Education, Research Unit of Island Emergency Medicine, Chinese Academy of Medical Sciences (No. 2019RU013), Hainan Medical University, Haikou 571199, China.
Abstract
Developing stable photoelectrochemistry (PEC) glucose biosensors with high sensitivity and a low detection limit is highly desirable in the biosensor field. Herein, a highly sensitive and stable enzymatic glucose PEC biosensor is rationally designed and fabricated using a TiO2NTs/Au/Pt/GOx electrode. First, we prepared one-dimensional TiO2 nanotube arrays which could realize the orthogonalization of the light-incident direction and the carrier diffusion direction via anodization. Subsequently, we used the method of photoassisted deposition for anchoring Pt nanoparticles on TiO2NTs after electrodepositing Au nanoparticles. Among them, Au nanoparticles promote light absorption via the surface plasmon resonance effect and the separation of photogenerated carriers through forming a Schottky junction. Moreover, the Pt nanoparticles on the electrode surface can react with hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) generated from glucose (Glu) oxidation by glucose oxidase (GOx), accelerating the electron-transfer process during glucose oxidation and greatly improving the sensitivity of the glucose biosensor. As a result, TiO2NTs/Au/Pt/GOx exhibited excellent PEC performance, achieving a high sensitivity of 81.93 μA mM-1 cm-2 and a low detection limit (1.39 μM), far exceeding the performance of TiO2NTs/M/GOx (M = Au, Pt). Therefore, the introduction of Pt nanoparticles as active substances to promote enzymatic reactions is important for designing high-performance enzyme biosensors.
Developing stable photoelectrochemistry (PEC) glucose biosensors with high sensitivity and a low detection limit is highly desirable in the biosensor field. Herein, a highly sensitive and stable enzymatic glucose PEC biosensor is rationally designed and fabricated using a TiO2NTs/Au/Pt/GOx electrode. First, we prepared one-dimensional TiO2 nanotube arrays which could realize the orthogonalization of the light-incident direction and the carrier diffusion direction via anodization. Subsequently, we used the method of photoassisted deposition for anchoring Pt nanoparticles on TiO2NTs after electrodepositing Au nanoparticles. Among them, Au nanoparticles promote light absorption via the surface plasmon resonance effect and the separation of photogenerated carriers through forming a Schottky junction. Moreover, the Pt nanoparticles on the electrode surface can react with hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) generated from glucose (Glu) oxidation by glucose oxidase (GOx), accelerating the electron-transfer process during glucose oxidation and greatly improving the sensitivity of the glucose biosensor. As a result, TiO2NTs/Au/Pt/GOx exhibited excellent PEC performance, achieving a high sensitivity of 81.93 μA mM-1 cm-2 and a low detection limit (1.39 μM), far exceeding the performance of TiO2NTs/M/GOx (M = Au, Pt). Therefore, the introduction of Pt nanoparticles as active substances to promote enzymatic reactions is important for designing high-performance enzyme biosensors.
Biosensor
research has focused on the development of a simple sensing
technology with fast detection, high sensitivity, and low interference.[1] The photoelectrochemistry (PEC) process consists
of a photoelectric conversion (the main process) and an electrochemical
process, which produces a highly sensitive and accurate signal with
low background signal noise through the interaction of the optical
and electrochemical systems.[2] In addition,
PEC-based enzyme biosensors can solve the problem of poor selectivity
in traditional bioanalysis techniques.[3] Therefore, the photoactive material not only acts as an energy converter
to generate photogenerated carriers upon irradiation but also provides
a site for the target receptors in PEC to selectively identify and
capture the target analyte.[4]Titanium
dioxide is a common semiconductor material, which has
been widely used in various photoelectrocatalytic processes for its
strong oxidizing capacity and photostability. According to the unique
photoelectric properties of titanium oxide, researchers have developed
advanced optoelectronic materials for high-performance PEC biosensing
through forming heterojunctions,[5] introduction
of wide band gap semiconductors,[6] and defect
engineering[7] methods. The regular arrangement
of TiO2 nanotubes (TiO2NTs), which has proven
to be a good photoanode material,[8] prepared
by anodic oxidation can be used for the photolysis of water,[9] in purification,[10] as an antibacterial,[11] and for photovoltaic
power generation.[12] However, the rapid
recombination of photocarriers and the narrow light absorption range
severely limit the performance of PEC and their applications. It has
been proposed to extend the lifetime of photocarriers by controlling
charge transfer to achieve an enhanced PEC performance.[13] Noble metals can be introduced to augment the
rate of electron transfer. Melvin et al. supported the Au–Pt
alloy on the surface of TiO2 and used the bimetal as an
electron absorber to enhance the photocatalytic performance.[14] They found that Au and Pt supported on TiO2 can be used as electron absorbers to weaken the rapid recombination
of carriers. Wu et al. have reported that the modification of Au nanoparticles
on the surface of TiO2NTs can produce the surface plasmon
resonance (SPR) effect, increase the absorption of ultraviolet–visible
light, and enhance the photocatalytic activity.[15] In the above studies, the application of Pt mainly improved
the performance of PEC by changing the charge behavior of the material.
Few people have mentioned the strategy of improving the sensitivity
of the PEC enzymatic glucose biosensor by catalytically decomposing
H2O2 during the enzymatic reaction of platinum
nanoparticles. In the present study, we constructed a bimetal (Au,
Pt) nanoparticle-loaded TiO2NTs/Au/Pt/GOx biosensor for
glucose detection.In this study, ultrahigh sensitivity of the
TiO2NTs/Au/Pt/GOx
biosensor was obtained by the following design concepts. Au nanoparticles
are loaded to increase the conductivity and improve the narrow light
absorption range of the material and the serious problems of electron–hole
recombination.[16] At the same time, Pt nanoparticles
are deposited, and Pt is used as an important active substance to
catalyze the decomposition of H2O2 under the
enzymatic reaction,[17] resulting in the
accelerated consumption of hydrogen peroxide and the transfer of electrons
in the enzymatic reaction, thereby achieving ultrahigh sensitivity
for the PEC enzymatic glucose biosensor.
Results
and Discussion
The synthesis process diagram of the PEC biosensor
is exhibited
in Scheme . The Ti
foil was etched to prepare TiO2NTs. Subsequently, Au and
Pt nanoparticles were deposited on the TiO2 film through
electrochemical and light deposition, respectively. Next, glucose
oxidase and chitosan were dropped evenly on the electrode surface.
Scheme 1
Manufacturing Process of the TiO2NTs/Au/Pt/GOx Biosensor
Based on the scanning electron microscopy (SEM)
image in Figure a,
the prepared TiO2 nanotube film shows a vertical one-dimensional
tubular shape.
In Figure b, the diameter
and thickness of the nanotube are 80 and 20 nm, respectively. As shown
in Figure S1, because of the lower loading
of Au and Pt nanoparticles, no considerable change was observed on
the electrode surface before and after introducing precious metals
compared with other electrodes. The high-resolution transmission electron
microscopy (HR-TEM) image of TiO2NTs deposited with Au
and Pt is shown in Figure d. Figure c,d shows a large amount of Au and PtNPs with a size range of 6–12
nm attached to TiO2 nanotubes. The edge of the TiO2NTs/Au/Pt (Figure d) lattice fringe is 0.352 nm. The (101) crystal plane of
TiO2 corresponds to anatase. Lattice fringes of 0.223 and
0.233 nm are identified as the (111) crystal plane of Pt and Au, respectively. Figure e–i shows
the high-angle annular dark-field–scanning transmission electron
microscopy (HAADF-STEM) and element mapping results, in which Ti,
O, Au, and Pt are uniformly distributed, confirming that Au and Pt
NPs are homogeneously loaded on TiO2NTs. Figure j shows the EDS energy spectrum
of TiO2NTs/Au/Pt. The content of noble metals is less,
especially Pt. This also leads to the failure to show the 4f peak
of Pt in the subsequent XPS test.
Figure 1
b) SEM images of TiO2NTs/Au/Pt;
(c,d) TEM and HR-TEM
images of TiO2NTs/Au/Pt; (e–i) HAADF-STEM and mapping
of Ti, O, Au, and Pt of TiO2NTs/Au/Pt; and (j) EDS spectra
of TiO2NTs/Au/Pt.
b) SEM images of TiO2NTs/Au/Pt;
(c,d) TEM and HR-TEM
images of TiO2NTs/Au/Pt; (e–i) HAADF-STEM and mapping
of Ti, O, Au, and Pt of TiO2NTs/Au/Pt; and (j) EDS spectra
of TiO2NTs/Au/Pt.Based on XRD tests on the electrodes, we analyzed the material
structure of the electrode material. As shown in Figure a, the peak of the Ti foil
is indexed to the JCPDS database (44-1294), and the peaks located
on 25.28, 37.8, and 48.05° are assigned to the (101), (004),
and (200) crystal facets of anatase titanium dioxide (JCPDS 21-1272),
respectively. Moreover, after loading precious metal NPs on the TiO2 film, the XRD peaks of TiO2 did not change. This
indicates that the crystal structure of titanium dioxide has not changed
to form an alloy after loading precious metals. At the same time,
because the precious metals are highly dispersed and the particle
size is small, their XRD peaks are not detected.
Figure 2
(a) XRD patterns of TiO2NTs, TiO2NTs/Pt,
TiO2NTs/Au, and TiO2NTs/Au/Pt; (b) XPS spectra
for Ti 2p; and (c) Au 4f core level for TiO2NTs/Au/Pt.
(a) XRD patterns of TiO2NTs, TiO2NTs/Pt,
TiO2NTs/Au, and TiO2NTs/Au/Pt; (b) XPS spectra
for Ti 2p; and (c) Au 4f core level for TiO2NTs/Au/Pt.To further investigate the electronic interactions
of TiO2 with Au and Pt, we carried out the XPS test. Figure b shows that the
peaks located at 458.9 and
464.6 eV represent Ti 2p 3/2 and 1/2, respectively, indicating that
only tetravalent titanium ions for TiO2 nanotubes are present.
Meanwhile, the signals of Au 4f 7/2 and Au 4f 5/2 at 83.4 and 87.1
eV, respectively, are the characteristic peaks of Au (in Figure c), while its 83.7
eV spin energy separation is consistent with the published results
on the spin energy separation of Au NPs.[18] In addition, the poor S/N ratio reflects the lower content of AuNPs
deposited on the surface of TiO2 nanotubes, accounting
for only 3.6% of the content. Moreover, compared with the characteristic
peak of the standard Au,[18] the apparent
negative shift of Au 4f indicates that the Au surface is in an electron-rich
state. This suggests that in the contact between metallic Au and TiO2, considering that the Fermi energy levels of Au and TiO2 are different, the energy level difference can be balanced
through the migration of electrons from the surface of TiO2 to Au, causing part of the metal–semiconductor contact to
bend the Fermi surface and form a Schottky junction. Similar results
were reported by Melvin et al.,[14] in which
a low amount of Pt with a relatively scattered distribution was loaded
on the sample surface, and the signal of Pt 4f was not found by XPS
detection.UV–visible absorption spectra were measured
for all four
systems (TiO2NTs, TiO2NTs/Pt, TiO2NTs/Au, and TiO2NTs/Au/Pt) and are shown in Figure a. All four photoelectrodes
show an obvious absorption cutoff edge near the anatase maximum absorption
wavelength of 387 nm. This finding confirms that the load of the noble
metal does not change the inherent absorption of TiO2.
Moreover, considering that the bimetal does not have light absorption
in the characteristic absorption range of titanium dioxide, after
the bimetal was loaded, the absorption peak near the characteristic
absorption wavelength of titanium dioxide decreased. In comparison
with the curve of titanium dioxide, TiO2NTs/Au exhibited
a strong visible light absorption near 550 nm, which is attributed
to the SPR absorption of AuNPs.[19] Therefore,
gold could act as an effective light collector in terms of the characteristics
of UV–vis plasma (collective and strong oscillation of delocalized
conduction electrons)[20] and enhance the
photoelectric catalytic activity of the material.
Figure 3
(a) UV–vis absorption
spectra and (b) PL spectra of TiO2NTs, TiO2NTs/Pt,
TiO2NTs/Au, and TiO2NTs/Au/Pt in the powder
form at 350 nm excitation.
(a) UV–vis absorption
spectra and (b) PL spectra of TiO2NTs, TiO2NTs/Pt,
TiO2NTs/Au, and TiO2NTs/Au/Pt in the powder
form at 350 nm excitation.The photoluminescence spectrum (PL) was obtained to further study
the four different materials. At an excitation wavelength of 350 nm,
a series of emission characteristic peaks were obtained for the material
appearing between 400 and 500 nm. Based on Figure b, the emission intensities were obtained
and can be arranged as TiO2NTs > TiO2NTs/Pt
> TiO2NTs/Au > TiO2NTs/Au/Pt. The pure
TiO2NTs have high PL intensity, indicating the serious
recombination
of photogenerated electrons and holes. Considering that the level
of emission intensity determines the degree of photogenerated electron–hole
pair compounding, PL tests have demonstrated that the formation of
a Schottky junction can store a certain number of electrons, thus
effectively separating electron–hole pairs and avoiding charge
compounding. The bimetallic-loaded electrode greatly reduced the PL
intensity compared with the electrode loaded with noble metal nanoparticles
alone, suggesting that the loading of Au and Pt NPs resulted in a
synthetic effect. Therefore, the recombination of electron holes was
greatly reduced.The electrochemical and PEC experiments were
carried out to examine
the PEC performance of the TiO2NTs, TiO2NTs/Pt,
TiO2NTs/Au, and TiO2NTs/Au/Pt electrodes. In Figure a, the results of
PEC show that the values of photocurrent density are in the following
order: TiO2NTs/Au/Pt > TiO2NTs/Au > TiO2NTs/Pt > TiO2NTs. The results confirmed that
precious
metals are beneficial for the photovoltaic performance. The SPR effect
of Au can increase the light absorption of TiO2, thus intensifying
the photocatalytic activity of the material. Second, the loading of
Au and Pt can form a Schottky junction on the surface of TiO2NTs and promote the separation of photocarriers, thereby improving
the photocurrent response. However, considering that a few PtNPs are
present on the electrode, the findings were not proved in XPS. However,
Guo et al. found that the Schottky junction can be formed by loading
Pt on the surface of TiO2, thus promoting the photocatalytic
activity.[21] This finding confirms why Pt
can synergistically reduce the electron–hole recombination
rate in the PL test.
Figure 4
(a) Photoelectric response of TiO2NTs, TiO2NTs/Pt, TiO2NTs/Au, and TiO2NTs/Au/Pt
under
simulated sunlight (bias voltage = 0.4 V, 0.1 M PBS, pH = 7.4); (b)
electrochemical impedance spectra of Nyquist plots; (c) electronic
lifetime measurement determined from the decay of the open-circuit
potential in the absence of light; and (d,e) Mott–Schottky
plot in the dark at a fixed frequency of 5 kHz.
(a) Photoelectric response of TiO2NTs, TiO2NTs/Pt, TiO2NTs/Au, and TiO2NTs/Au/Pt
under
simulated sunlight (bias voltage = 0.4 V, 0.1 M PBS, pH = 7.4); (b)
electrochemical impedance spectra of Nyquist plots; (c) electronic
lifetime measurement determined from the decay of the open-circuit
potential in the absence of light; and (d,e) Mott–Schottky
plot in the dark at a fixed frequency of 5 kHz.As is known, electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) is one
of the most commonly used methods to study the characteristics of
the photoelectrode interface. The equivalent circuit (the inset in Figure b) is used for the
Nyquist plots recorded from different samples. Among them, Re represents
the system resistance, CPE represents the capacitance phase of the
interface between the electrolyte and the photoelectrode, and Rct
represents the transfer resistance of the charge carriers on the interface.
The Nyquist plots of the TiO2NTs/Au/Pt electrode in Figure b show the smallest
arc diameter, indicating the lowest charge-transfer resistance and
the fastest electron migration rate for this electrode.[22]Figure c shows
the open-circuit photovoltage decay (OCPVD) experiments, which were
executed to further investigate the electronic behavior and to estimate
the electronic lifetime generated under light according to the following
equation[23]In this equation, τ indicates the photoelectron
lifetime, kB represents the Boltzmann
constant, T is the temperature, VOC represents
the open-circuit voltage at the corresponding time, and e represents the charge of an individual electron. As shown in Figure c, the electrode
TiO2NTs/Au/Pt has the longest carrier lifetime, which contributes
to its PEC performance. In addition, to determine its carrier density
(ND), we performed electric capacity analysis
on the electrode/electrolyte with the following equation[24]In this equation, C represents the space charge
capacitance in the semiconductor interface, ND represents the density of carriers in the semiconductor, e refers to the charge of a single electron, ε0 represents the vacuum dielectric constant, ε represents
the relative dielectric constant of the semiconductor, US is the applied potential, T represents
the temperature, and kB represents the
Boltzmann constant. ND is determined from
the MS plots as 1/C2 versus potential
in Figure d,e by using
the following equation[24]Finally, we obtained
the following carrier concentration relationship:
TiO2NTs < TiO2NTs/Pt < TiO2NTs/Au < TiO2NTs/Au/Pt. The significant increase of ND and τ confirms the deposition of Au
and Pt NPs by forming Schottky junctions, thereby decreasing the recombination
of photogenerated electrons with holes and increasing carrier concentration.
Hence, the carrier lifetime improved PEC performance.To demonstrate
that Pt has a catalytic effect for H2O2, during
the testing of glucose sensitivity, we performed
cyclic voltammetry (CV) tests under light-free conditions. As shown
in Figure S3a,b, the current density of
TiO2NTs and TiO2NTs/Au electrodes without PtNPs
were only elevated by 2 and 2.7 μA cm–2 at
0.4 V (vs Ag/AgCl), respectively, when we added 1 mM hydrogen peroxide
to the buffer. The current was enhanced probably caused by the electrolytic
reaction of hydrogen peroxide. However, considering that Pt could
decompose hydrogen peroxide in the solution and generate a number
of electrical signals under the applied potential of the catalytic
oxidation, the current densities between the TiO2NTs/Pt
and TiO2NTs/Au/Pt electrodes modified with PtNPs differed
with values of 12.7 and 13 μA cm–2 at 0.4
V (vs Ag/AgCl), respectively (Figures S3c, 5). Therefore, PtNPs can catalyze hydrogen
peroxide to enhance electron transfer in enzymatic reactions.
Figure 5
CV comparison
in 0.1 M pH = 7.4 PBS solution with and without a
H2O2 chart of TiO2NTs/Au/Pt.
CV comparison
in 0.1 M pH = 7.4 PBS solution with and without a
H2O2 chart of TiO2NTs/Au/Pt.Generally, the capability of a biosensor is evaluated
in terms
of its sensitivity, limit of detection (3S/N), and linear range. As
shown in Figure a,
the photoelectric response of the TiO2NTs/Au/Pt/GOx electrode
was tested at stepped glucose concentrations under continual churning,
and the photocurrent increased with increasing glucose concentration,
indicating the sensitive response of the electrode to Glu concentration.
Based on Figure b,
the linear regression equation between glucose concentration and photocurrent
is shown, where j = 81.93x + 202.06
at glucose concentrations between 0 and 0.8 mM and j = 6.39x + 261.38 when the glucose concentration
is in the range of 0.8–4 mM. Thus, at glucose concentrations
of 0–0.8 mM, the sensitivity was 81.93 μA mM–1 cm–2, and the LOD was 1.39 μM. At glucose
concentrations of 0.8–4 mM, the sensitivity was 6.39 μA
mM–1 cm–2. The segmentation of
the test results is mainly attributed to the adsorption of intermediates
by the electrode. At lower concentrations of glucose, the linearity
shows a good relationship with a higher slope as a result of the free
pervasion of glucose molecules toward the electrode at lower concentrations.
At higher concentrations, the interaction between the glucose molecules
intensifies, resulting in a less linear curve with a lower slope.
Accordingly, two different sensitivities are observed at different
linear ranges.[25]
Figure 6
(a) i–t responses of TiO2NTs/Au/Pt
toward Glu at concentrations of 0–4 mM in
the supporting electrolyte of 0.1 M PBS (pH = 7.4); (b) linear calibration
curve (glucose concentration vs photocurrent density); (c) stability
after addition of 1 mM glucose under light conditions; and (d) anti-interference
performance test performed in 0.1 M PBS (pH = 7.4) at concentrations
of 0.1 mM chloride (NaCl), sucrose (Suc), ascorbic acid (AA), uric
acid (UA), galactose (Gal), and fructose (Fru).
(a) i–t responses of TiO2NTs/Au/Pt
toward Glu at concentrations of 0–4 mM in
the supporting electrolyte of 0.1 M PBS (pH = 7.4); (b) linear calibration
curve (glucose concentration vs photocurrent density); (c) stability
after addition of 1 mM glucose under light conditions; and (d) anti-interference
performance test performed in 0.1 M PBS (pH = 7.4) at concentrations
of 0.1 mM chloride (NaCl), sucrose (Suc), ascorbic acid (AA), uric
acid (UA), galactose (Gal), and fructose (Fru).To stress the advantages of TiO2NTs/Au/Pt/GOx biosensors
more intuitively, we conducted the same condition test on TiO2NTs/Au/GOx, TiO2NTs/Pt/GOx, and TiO2NTs/GOx. The test results at the same concentration are shown in Figure S2. The sensitivity of the TiO2NTs/GOx biosensor without Au and Pt NPs is only 8.53 μA mM–1 cm–2, and the linear range is 0–1
mM. Besides, the detection limit increased to 61.1 μM. The TiO2NTs/Pt/GOx biosensor loaded with Pt has a sensitivity of 20.9
μA mM–1 cm–2, a linear range
of 0–1 mM, and a detection limit of only 3.07 μM. The
TiO2NTs/Au/GOx biosensor loaded with Au only has a sensitivity
of 39.58 μA mM–1 cm–2, a
linear range of 0–0.7 mM, and a detection limit of 13.5 μM.
In the linear range of 0–0.8 mM, the TiO2NTs/Au/Pt/GOx
biosensor had the highest sensitivity and the lowest LOD. This finding
was observed because the SPR effect of Au enhanced light absorption,
which is conducive to the generation of more photogenerated holes.
In addition, the Au and Pt NPs synergistically promoted the valid
separation of photogenerated electron–hole pairs through the
formation of Schottky junctions between the metal and the semiconductor.
The number of photogenerated holes in the material is dominant for
the improvement of sensitivity. Therefore, the increase of photogenerated
holes and the decrease of electron–hole recombination can improve
the sensitivity to glucose. Moreover, the sensitivity of the PEC enzymatic
biosensor was improved by the enhanced electron transfer in the enzymatic
reaction catalyzed by the loaded PtNPs with hydrogen peroxide. Notably,
the linear range of TiO2NTs/Au/Pt/GOx at low sensitivity
increased by 0.1 mM compared with TiO2 NTs/Au/GOx, precisely
because the catalytic effect of Pt accelerates the consumption of
hydrogen peroxide on the electrode surface and reduces the molecular
interactions, thus increasing the linear detection range of the electrode
at low sensitivity.Furthermore, we demonstrated the stability
of the biosensor on
the TiO2NTs/Au/Pt/GOx electrode by switching i–t response by 10 times. Figure c shows that the photocurrent response increased rapidly and
remained stable for a few seconds after the light was switched on,
while the magnitude of the photocurrent remained stable after 10 repeated
switches, with negligible changes in the photocurrent at each period.Considering that the molecular interferents such as sodium chloride
(NaCl), sucrose (Suc), ascorbic acid (AA), uric acid (UA), galactose
(Gal), and fructose (Fru) normally coexist in human serum, we investigated
their effects at certain concentrations of the biosensing response
of the electrodes.As shown in Figure d, the PEC test was performed under the same
conditions of detecting,
and the selectivity of the TiO2NTs/Au/Pt/GOx electrode
was investigated based on the photocurrent response plots after the
addition of different interferents (0.1 mM). By comparing the biosensing
response of the interferer with that of glucose to the electrode,
almost no change was observed in photocurrent after the addition of
the interferer. Hence, the TiO2NTs/Au/Pt/GOx biosensor
maintained its high selectivity for glucose.As shown in Table , the TiO2NTs/Au/Pt/GOx biosensor has higher sensitivity
and better detection limits than the other PEC glucose biosensors.
Table 1
Comparison of the Analytical Performance
of PEC Glucose Biosensors
PEC biosensors
dynamic range (mM)
LOD (μM)
sensitivity (μA mM–1 cm–2)
ref
TiO2-CNT-Co3O4
0–4
0.16
0.3
(26)
FTO/Fe2O3-NB-PDA-GDH
0–2
25.2
7.36
(27)
Nafion/GOx/Ag-Pdop@CNT/GCE
0.05–1.1
17
3.1
(28)
GOx/TCS-TiO2/chitosan/GCE
0.005–1.32
2
23.2
(29)
TiO2 NTs/GOx
0–1, 1–4
61.1
8.53,
2.98
this work
TiO2 NTs/Pt/GOx
0–1, 1–4
3.07
20.9, 5.40
this work
TiO2 NTs/Au/GOx
0–0.7, 0.7–4
13.5
41.73,
4.73
this work
TiO2 NTs/Au/Pt/GOx
0–0.8, 0.8–4
1.39
81.93, 6.39
this
work
We tried
to explain the mechanism for PEC detection of glucose
at enzyme modification electrodes as shown in Scheme . The modification of the electrode by Au
and Pt NPs has an important effect on the PEC generation of photogenerated
electrons and holes on the external of TiO2. The SPR effect
of AuNPs enhanced the absorption of light; meanwhile, high-energy
charge carriers are generated during the plasma decay process,[30] thereby improving the catalytic activity of
the electrode. Moreover, Au and Pt NPs can form a Schottky junction
with TiO2, which could reduce the recombination of photogenerated
electrons and holes and increase the carrier lifetime. After loading
GOx, glucose was present in the PBS electrolyte solution, glucose
oxidase gradually oxidized glucose into gluconic acid and H2O2 (formula ), and the holes in the TiO2NTs/Au/Pt/GOx electrode could
capture the enzymatic products for redox reactions and generate a
photocurrent (formula , photoelectrocatalytic reaction). Besides, the PtNPs loaded on the
surface of TiO2 promoted the decomposition of hydrogen
peroxide because of their strong catalytic activity, which enhanced
the transfer of electrons in the enzymatic reaction and further enhanced
the current response to glucose (formula , electrocatalytic reaction). Therefore, when the glucose
concentration was varied, different electrical signals were generated.
The reaction formula is as follows
Scheme 2
Mechanism of Action of the TiO2NTs/Au/Pt/GOx PEC Biosensor
for Glucose Detection
Conclusions
In summary, we have successfully designed
the high-performance
PEC biosensor for glucose testing based on TiO2NTs/Au/Pt
nanocomposites. Gold nanoparticles enhanced the conductivity of the
electrode and promoted the absorption of light via the SPR effect
and the separation of photogenerated carriers in the material through
forming a Schottky junction. Subsequently, the catalytic activity
of the electrode was greatly improved. At the same time, PtNPs can
catalyze the decomposition of H2O2 in the enzymatic
reaction to enhance the transfer of electrons in the enzymatic reaction
and further enhance the PEC performance of the sensor. Finally, the
obtained TiO2NTs/Au/Pt/GOx PEC biosensor has good stability
and selectivity in the linear range of 0–0.8 mM and from 0.8
to 4 mM, where the sensitivities are 81.93 and 6.39 μA mM–1 cm–2, and the detection limit is
low at 1.39 μM. Inspired by demonstrating the excellent performance
of the TiO2NTs/Au/Pt/GOx PEC biosensor for glucose detection
performance, the introduction of active substances will promote the
process of enzymatic reactions, possibly resulting in the quick transfer
of electrons in enzymatic reactions to further improve the performance
of the sensor, which will be a new approach for building other high-performance
PEC enzymatic biosensors.
Experimental Section
Fabrication of TiO2NTs
Before the anodizing
treatment, the pretreated titanium foil sample
(10 × 20 × 0.25 mm) was polished for 30 s and then washed
in acetone, ethanol, and deionized water for 5 min by ultrasonication
and dried in air at 50 °C. Afterward, anodic oxidation was performed
in an electrochemical cell with titanium foil as the working electrode
and a stainless-steel sheet as the counter electrode. The electrolyte
consists of a glycol system containing 0.5 wt % ammonium fluoride
and 6 vol % deionized water. Under magnetic stirring with a direct
current power supply, anodization was carried out for 30 min under
a 60 V bias. Then, the sample was sonicated with deionized water for
30 min (smooth surface) and anodized again for 90 min under a bias
of 20 V. Subsequently, it was cleaned twice with ethanol ultrasonically
and dried naturally. Finally, the specimen obtained by anodization
was placed in a crucible and annealed at 400 °C in air for 3
h with a heating rate of 2 °C/min.
Deposition
of AuNPs on the TiO2NT Photoelectrode
Chloroauric
acid was used as the precursor,
Ag/AgCl was used as the reference electrode, and the Pt sheet was
used as the counter electrode. Gold nanoparticles were electrochemically
deposited in 0.1 M phosphate buffer (PBS, pH = 7.4). The traditional
three-electrode system adopts the CV method, and the voltage range
is from −1.25 to −0.7 V (reverse) with different cycles
(0, 5, 10, 15 and 20 cycles). Afterward, the prepared TiO2NTs/Au was washed with deionized water and dried in a vacuum oven
at 70 °C for 12 h.
Deposition of PtNPs onto
the TiO2NTs/Au Photoelectrode
Platinum nanoparticles
were loaded
on TiO2NTs by UV lamp deposition. Chloroplatinic acid was
added to 30 mL of deionized water containing 10 mL of methanol. Then,
the prepared TiO2NTs/Au electrode was placed in the above
solution and irradiated with a UV lamp for 0, 5, 10, 15, and 20 min.
Subsequently, the prepared TiO2NTs/Au/Pt was washed with
deionized water several times and dried in a vacuum oven at 70 °C
for 12 h.
Deposition of GOx onto the TiO2NTs/Au/Pt Photoelectrode
Glucose oxidase is loaded on the
target electrode by the drop coating method. Glucose oxidase was first
coated on the electrode surface and kept at 4 °C for 24 h. Subsequently,
chitosan solution dissolved in acetic acid was applied dropwise to
immobilize GOx and kept at 4 °C for 72 h. The target biosensor
TiO2NTs/Au/Pt/GOx was finally obtained.