| Literature DB >> 35034252 |
Abstract
The COVID-19 pandemic is continuously causing serious effects on the mental health of college students due to the series of lockdowns and sudden shifting of face-to-face classes to fully online. The study aims to determine and explore the various themes that play a significant role in the development of this issue by an in-depth study of selected reflection papers submitted in class. These texts were interpreted and analyzed using interpretative phenomenological analysis. Findings revealed three major themes: anxiety and depression as serious effects of the pandemic, God/Higher Being as the first and/or last source of support and, the essentiality of self-awareness and self-acceptance in improving mental health. These themes which are contextualized in nature hope to contribute to future research in formulating effective interventions and strategies in the war against the negative effects of the pandemic most especially for the welfare of college students.Entities:
Keywords: COVID-19 pandemic; God/higher being; Mental health; Self-acceptance; Self-awareness; Support
Mesh:
Year: 2022 PMID: 35034252 PMCID: PMC8761098 DOI: 10.1007/s10943-021-01476-3
Source DB: PubMed Journal: J Relig Health ISSN: 0022-4197
Spring 2020 College Student Survey Infographic Report on Mental Health
| Findings on some aspects of mental health | Statistics |
|---|---|
| Students with a mental health problem | • 20% of college students say their mental health has significantly worsened under COVID-19 |
| Students who reported the negative impact of the pandemic on their mental health | • 80% of college students report that COVID-19 has negatively impacted their mental health |
| The most common ways that COVID-19 has impacted students’ lives | • 91% stress or anxiety |
| • 81% disappointment or sadness | |
| • 80% loneliness or isolation | |
| • 48% financial setback | |
| • 56% relocation | |
| Self-care has been challenging for students | • 76% have trouble maintaining a routine |
| • 73% struggle to get enough physical activity | |
| • 63% find it challenging to stay connected with others | |
| Spending time together | • 85% say that focusing on schoolwork despite distractions has been the most difficult thing about the stay-at-home order |
| • More than talking, especially about COVID-19, students say that the #1 way parents can support them is simply spending time with them | |
| Resource needs | • More than half of students (55%) say that they would not know where to go if they or someone they knew needed professional mental health services right away |
| • Students are finding tools that promote social connection most helpful for caring for their mental health. These include video calls, digital social gatherings (i.e. games or Netflix watch parties), phone calls, and in-person conversations | |
| The hopefulness of students despite the pandemic | • 79% of college students feel hopeful about achieving their school-related goals and their future job prospects |
Participants’ demographic details
| Participant | Gender | Age | Nationality | Religion |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Participant #1 | Male | 19 | Filipino | Roman catholic |
| Participant #2 | Female | 20 | Filipino | Roman catholic |
| Participant #3 | Male | 22 | Filipino | Roman catholic |
| Participant #4 | Female | 20 | Filipino | Roman catholic |
| Participant #5 | Female | 21 | Filipino | Roman catholic |
| Participant #6 | Male | 21 | Filipino | Agnostic |
Basic Guidelines of IPA and Brief Descriptions
| Stages of Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis (IPA) | Brief Descriptions |
|---|---|
| Stage 1: Multiple reading and making notes | Close reading of the transcript several times to immerse in the data; Making notes about one’s observations and reflections about the interview experience or any other thoughts and comments of potential significance; Highlighting distinctive phrases and emotional responses |
| Stage 2: Transforming notes into Emergent Themes | Reflecting on the source material to transform notes into emerging themes; Formulating a concise phrase (themes) at a slightly higher level of abstraction which may refer to a more psychological conceptualization |
| Stage 3: Seeking relationships and clustering themes | Looking for connections between emerging themes, grouping them according to conceptual similarities, and providing each cluster with a descriptive label; Dropping of ‘unfit’ themes; Listing of major themes and subthemes, and relevant short extracts from the transcript |
| Stage 4: Writing a narrative account of the study | Taking the themes identified in the final table and writing them up one by one; Describing each theme and exemplifying it with extracts from interview, followed by analytic comments from the author/s |
| Original Transcript | Exploratory Notes / Comments | Emerging Themes | Clustered Themes |
|---|---|---|---|
| There was a time | Recognizes God’s guidance during crisis Refers to the pandemic as the cause of mental health decline Point to the pandemic as the source of stress from academics, poor government response, and losing friends Identifies parents’ high expectation to excel in academics despite the pandemic Feels worried about the effects of the virus on family and loved ones Expects the government to manage well the situation especially the many cases of deaths and financial burden Expresses sadness for causing separation from friends who give support | Attributing God’s support during the current pandemic Referring to the pandemic as the source of mental health problem, poor government response, stress, separation from friends Expressing being pressured by parents’ expectations to do well in academics amid the crisis Showing concern for family and loved ones Hoping for an effective response from the government in handling the crisis Longing for support from friends amid the pandemic | Mental Health problems such as anxiety/depression as a serious effect of the pandemic God/Higher Being as the first and/or last source of support/guidance Self-awareness/Self-acceptance helps improve mental health Family support (Parents and/or siblings) Government’s response to the pandemic Parental pressure to perform well in academics Friends/peer support |
| My | Acknowledges mental health decline brought by the pandemic Feels ashamed of opening up regarding the mental health issue Points to God as the source of guidance and support since the start and during this pandemic Regains mental health Expresses gratitude for doing well in academics and having trusted friends Thank God again for being there always | Identifying again the pandemic as the source of mental health problem Showing lack of self-acceptance for the condition which prevents getting professional help Acknowledging God as the initial and last source of support Expressing gratitude for regaining strength and getting help from friends Being thankful for God’s guidance | |
| I think | Acknowledges hardship during the pandemic Cites understanding professors Points out the difficulty in complying with the requirements of online class as time passes by Feels disappointed about the integration of home with work activities Maximizes time to finish all requirements without actually feeling relaxed Feels pressured and stressed so much by requirements Admits the loss of focus during synchronous classes; short attention span | Emphasizing the negative effects of the pandemic most especially in shifting to online classes Acknowledging understanding professors Stressing the difficulty of attending online class most especially the many requirements Missing the old routine of having a healthy home and schedule Utilizing the allotted time to complete all tasks Expressing too much pressure and stress from the academic requirement Emphasizing inattentiveness in the online class | Mental Health problems such as anxiety/depression as a serious effect of the pandemic Stressed out in academics (online class requirements) Self-awareness/Self-acceptance helps improve mental health Difficulty in dealing with online classes Family support (Parents and/or siblings) Friends/peer support Professor’s concern and understanding Separation of home and work activities Self-relaxation as a must for self-care Low self-esteem and unmotivated |
| Canvas notifications made me | Anticipates anxiety because of another task Stresses again over the difficulty of attending an online class Tries to relax oneself and breathe fresh air Describes the uncertainty of finishing the academic tasks Feels unmotivated and pressured to excel in academics Reminisces about the last time when there was no pressure yet Blames the pandemic for ruining a healthy schedule Feels being lost in everything Finds the timely support of a father Expresses gratitude for the father’s encouragement and advice Acknowledges too the support of friends for the restored faith | Asserting the feeling of anxiety and being stressed out for another given task Finding a way to be in control of the difficult situation Doubting one’s capability to continue the online class Claiming the need for motivation to proceed with the academic requirements Missing the old routine of not feeling pressured Pointing again to the pandemic as the source of hardship Manifesting low level of self-esteem Acknowledging parental support Adding the necessity of support from friends | |
As a third-year college engineering student, third-year subjects are the core of my course, hence the | Feels a lot of pressure during the current academic level Identifies directly being anxious and depressed due to the volume of academic requirements Points to isolation at home given the voluminous tasks as the cause of depression Signifies losing hope to proceed with the online class set up Longs for the physical presence of friends for support Points out the importance of human contact to college life Admits one’s financial shortage which brings uncertainty to finish the degree Expresses the presence of God for support since the beginning Believes that God is still there to support despite moments of doubting His intervention Reiterates the loving care of God and still hopes for His support during this crisis Admits experiencing mental challenges due to the isolation and change of environment as brought by the pandemic Hopes that this trial will end with God’s continuous support | Expressing feelings of pressure, anxiety, and depression from many academic requirements especially during this pandemic Reiterating ‘isolation’ brought by the pandemic as the cause of depression Running out of motivation to continue participating in the online class Confirming the necessity of direct communication from friends as a source of support Affirming the necessity of human interaction during college life Facing the reality of family’s financial problem which doubts finishing the degree Conveying the loving support of God at all times from the beginning despite occasional feelings of doubt Acknowledging the effect of the pandemic on one's mental health Never losing hope for the end of these challenges | Mental Health problems such as anxiety/depression as a serious effect of the pandemic Pressured/Stressed out in academics (online class requirements) God/Higher Being as the first and/or last source of support/guidance Self-awareness/Self-acceptance helps improve mental health Isolation and change in environment as causes of depression Friends/peer support as a source of motivation Family’s financial inadequacy to support one’s needs Human interaction is a necessity to college life A temporary feeling of God's absence in trying times |
… Afterward that faithful day, | Admits having negative thoughts of doing self-harm amid the pandemic Thinks of not involving one’s family and friends in sharing about the unfortunate condition Manifests a lot of stress but prefers not to share it with anybody Pointing out to God as the only confidant in what is going on Questions the presence of suffering in life Feels the gentle presence of God that brings calmness, relaxation, and clarity of thoughts Decides to approach parents for whatever words will be spoken Feels happy for the parents’ reaction and encouragement/support Compares the show of comfort from parents and God Realizes that pain is necessary to become stronger Self-examination to study oneself Renews one’s open communication to family and friends Determined to move forward and start a new beginning in life | Manifesting a feeling of hopelessness during the crisis Deciding on the exclusion of support from family and friends for them not to be affected Stressing having mixed feelings of anxiety and depression that greatly affect mental health Singling out God as the source of lone strength and support Conveying weary/confused mind Expressing great awe in the healing presence of God during crisis Building up one’s confidence in opening up to parents Appreciating with gladness the support of parents, as well as of God Developing a feeling of acceptance of the reality of pain as part of life Reflecting on one’s internal struggles Understanding the importance of family and friends as sources of support Preparing oneself to have a fresh start in facing life’s challenges | God/Higher Being as the first and/or last source of support/guidance Mental Health problems such as anxiety/depression as a serious effect of the pandemic Pressured/Stressed out due to numerous trials Lack of communication to parents/friends for support Hopelessness during crisis Hesitancy to reach out to family and friends for support Doubting the presence of suffering in life Pain is necessary to become stronger in battling challenges in life Self-examination to determine a possible solution in addressing one’s problems |
In the early days of the As time passed by, | Develops worry, anxiety, and fear during the pandemic Feels anxious about getting infected with the virus Confirms being vulnerable to any disease due to family history Expresses fear of getting sick but turns to social media for distraction Calls out to God for healing Tries to calm oneself to lessen anxiety Considers the bible as the main source of guidance and healing at the same time Makes a habit of reading the Bible Reiterates God as a best friend who never leaves our side Accepts the fact that personal effort is not enough to maintain a good life but it comes from trusting God | Admitting having mental health disturbances during the pandemic Getting anxious as the lockdown progresses Adding the heredity factor which resulted in being immunocompromised Turning to social media to divert one’s fear from the virus Finding God as a source of healing Making fun of the situation as a way of distracting oneself to manage anxiety Directing one’s attention to the role of the bible as an effective guide to handle mental health problems Finding the habitual reading of the Bible as a solution to alleviate fear Highlighting one’s relationship to God as the ultimate source of support Positing the role of God as the one that completely turns a bad life into a good one | Mental Health problems such as anxiety/depression as a serious effect of the pandemic God/Higher Being as the first and/or last source of support/guidance Praying using the bible as the tool for alleviating fear Worry due to being immunocompromised Social media as a distraction from fear from the virus Jokes as a means to manage anxiety Bible as the most effective source of strength in dealing with the crisis |
It started when the A few months | Takes lightly the effect of the virus but still practices precautionary measures to protect oneself Acknowledges anxiety as a result of the rising cases of people infected with the virus Sees the lack of face-to-face connection with friends as also a factor that causes a lot of stress during the pandemic Enumerates the serious effects of the lockdown on academics, schedule, and physical health Confesses incapability to battle against the effects of the lockdown Resorts to sleep to avoid facing the challenges posed by the lockdown Realizes that “sleep” is not a permanent solution to the negative effects of lockdown Acknowledges the essential presence of a Higher Being in one’s life Accepts the difficulty of dealing with the current situation Becomes aware or conscious of oneself Connects with friends for support Feels happy for being able to cope with the situation despite one’s limitations | Taking an initial light treatment of the virus until it is proven serious, thus, exercising safety protocols Pointing out the pandemic as the cause of anxiety and dwindling mental health Highlighting the importance of physical contact and communication with friends as a stress reliever Concluding that the lockdown has ruined the everyday schedule and affecting much of one's general wellbeing Exhibiting having not enough confidence to face the effects of lockdown Treating “sleep” as a way to forget the challenges temporarily Believing in the existence of a Higher Being despite not being affiliated with any religion Being able to accept the current situation Manifesting an adequate level of self-acceptance and self-awareness Emphasizing the importance of connecting with friends during this crisis Building up enough self-confidence to be in control of the difficult situation | Mental Health problems such as anxiety/depression as a serious effect of the pandemic Physical contact and communication with friends as a stress reliever Pressured/Stressed out due to numerous trials Higher Being as a source of support/guidance during this pandemic Self-awareness/Self-acceptance helps improve mental health Bonding time with friends is an important factor for mental health Lockdown disrupts the overall well-being of the person Sleep is a way to temporarily escape the effects of lockdown Friends/peer support Belief in a personal capacity to handle difficult situations |