Shoulder Pain Treated by Manual Acupuncture and Pharmacopuncture Following Origin/Insertion Technique of Applied Kinesiology: A Case Series of Two Patients.

The aim of this study was to report on the improvement of shoulder pain resulting from disorders of the rotator cuff such as impingement syndrome and adhesive capsulitis, by manual acupuncture (MA) and pharmacopuncture (PA) following origin/insertion technique (OIT) of applied kinesiology (AK). Two patients were treated with MA and PA after OIT on shoulder muscles. The Numerical Rating Scale and the assessment of the Japanese Orthopedic Association scores were used to assess the pain, and ultrasound images were taken to compare treatment outcome. This study showed that MA and PA following OIT may be an effective treatment for impingement syndrome and adhesive capsulitis.

INTRODUCTION

Shoulder pain is due to the pathology of various sources such as neck, glenohumeraljoint, acromioclavicularjoint, rotator cuff, and other soft tissues around the shoulder joint. The most prevalent cause is disorders of the rotator cuff which include impingement syndrome and adhesive capsulitis [1].

Shoulder pain is diagnosed by radiological examination such as magnetic resonance imaging or ultrasound imaging, together with patient symptoms, and assessment of Japanese Orthopaedic Association score (JOAS) and Numerical Rating score (NRS) [2, 3].

Treatment of shoulder pain includes conservative therapies or surgery performed according to the degree of shoulder pain and radiological examination [4]. Acupuncture treatments include manual acupuncture (MA) and pharmacopuncture (PA) in Korean Medicine.

Origin/Insertion Technique (OIT) is a technique of strengthening muscles by firm, heavy, digital stimulation on the origin and insertion of muscle [5, 6]. Until recently, numerous clinical trials have been conducted investigating the effectiveness of MA and PA on shoulder pain [7-15]. However, few studies on shoulder pain have reported follow-up ultrasound changes after MA, PA, and OIT treatments. The objective of this case study was to report changes observed by JOA, NRS, and ultrasound images after treatments.

Informed consent for this case report was given by subjects for ethical approval.

CASE REPORT

1. Treatment methods

The whole process of diagnosis and treatment was done by Dr. Ahn who has over 50 years experience practicing Korean traditional medicine.

2. Diagnosis

Cervical movements, flexion, extension, bilateral bending, and rotation were tested.

3. Cervical-related muscles

Muscles were tested such as levator scapulae, rhomboids, trapezium, and scalene medius.

4. Shoulder joint movements

Movements were tested such as abduction, adduction, elevation, internal rotation, and external rotation.

5. Shoulder and scapularmuscles

Muscles were tested such as supraspinatus, infraspinatus, subscapularis, teres minor, deltoid, as well as serratus anterior, and biceps brachii muscles.

6. Other muscles

Muscles were often tested such as subclavius, coracobrachialis, and pectoralis minor when pain was not improved by over 10 treatments.

7. Origin/Insertion technique

The OIT is applied to the sites (coracoids process and upper aspect of the greater tubercle of the humerus) of origin/insertion of the weak muscle by heavy digital massage with bilateral thumbs for 30-60 seconds to strengthen the weak muscle.

8. Acupuncture interventions

1) Manual acupuncture

The patients underwent 20 sessions of acupuncture (usually 3 to 5 sessions per week, for 5 to 7 weeks) and the point locations were chosen according to WHO acupuncture locations. The acupuncture needles were 40 × 0.25 mm. Fifteen acupoints (such as LU1, LU3, LU4, LU11, LI14, LI15, LI16, SI11, SI9, SI10, SI12, SI13, SI14, SI15, and ST38) were applied [16-18]. Patients were needled to a depth of approximately 1 cm. Depending on symptoms, other points were also added such as GV16, BL10, GB21, and TW14. The retention time was 20 minutes.

2) Pharmacopuncture

Pharmacopuncture is a treatment that combines acupuncture and herbal medicine. In this study, it was performed with disposable Kovax-syringes (20 ml, 23G × 1”: Korea Vaccine, Ansan, Korea) and 6ccs of refrigerated Sweet BV PA solution prepared by Jaseng Namyangju Industrial Institute (Namyangju, Korea), which is an extramural facility.

3) Preparation of Sweet BV pharmacopuncture solution

Sweet BV pharmacopuncture solution was needled at coracoids process, which is around the LU1 as well as the upper aspect of the greater tubercle of the humerus during MA.

4) Evaluation

(1) Ultrasound imaging

Taking ultrasound images of the rotating cuff muscle is the basic method to diagnose the causes of shoulder pain such as impingement of the cuff between the coracoacromial arch and humeral head as well as rotator cuff tears, and adhesive capsulitis. The images were taken before the 1st time and after the 20th time.

Numerical rating scale (NRS) is a scoring method to quantify the subjective severity of pain felt by the patient on a scale from 0 to 10. The worst imaginable pain is scored as 10 and the pain-free state is scored as 0 [3]. Evaluation was done before the 1st time and after the 20th time.

(2) Japanese Orthopaedic Association score (JOAS)

The JOAS is generally used to assess the treatment result of shoulder conditions and includes evaluation of pain (30 points). Function (overall function: 10 points, activities of daily living: 10 points), range of motion (active motion: 30 points), radiologic findings (5 points), and joint stability (15 points), amounting to a full score of 100 points [2] (Table 1). Evaluation was done before the 1st time and after the 20th time.

Table 1

Assessing shoulder outcomes based on the Japanese Orthopaedic Association Score (JOAS)

1. Pain (30 points)		3. Range of motion (30 points)
None	30	Elevation
Tenderness or minimal pain during sports or heavy labor	25	> 150°	15
Minimal pain during activities of daily living	20	> 120°	12
Moderate and tolerance pain (occasional night pain)	10	> 90°	9
Severe pain (frequent night pain)	5	> 60°	6
Totally incapacitated because of pain	0	> 30°	3
2. Function (20 points)	0°	0
Strength in abduction		External rotation
Normal	5	> 60°	9
Excellent	4	> 30°	6
Good	3	> 0°	3
Fair	2	> –20°	1
Poor	1	< –20°	0
Zero	0	Internal rotation
Endurance (time in seconds of holding 1 kg)		Above the T12 spinous process	6
> 10 seconds	5	Above the L5 spinous process	4
> 3 seconds	3	Gluteal	2
< 2 seconds	1	Below gluteal	0
0	0	4. Radiographic evaluation (5 points)
Activities of daily living (1 point each)		Normal	5
Combing the hair	Moderate changes		3
Making knot in the back	Advanced changes		0
Reaching the mouth		5. Joint stability (15 points)
Reaching the opposite axilla		Normal	15
Reaching an overhead shelf		Slight instability	10
Reaching a side pocket (jacket)		Severe instability	5
Putting on a jacket		Relevant history	0
Opening and closing a sliding door
Self-hygienic care
Sleeping on the involved side		Total	100

9. Case 1

1) Participant

Kim XX (Female, 58 years old)

2) Diagnosis by ultrasound

The diagnoses were as follows:

(1) Mild impingement on the supraspinatus (SST) tendon.

(2) Partial tear on the proximal SST (40-50%).

3) Chief complaint

Right neck pain, shoulder pain, limitation of movement, and severe night pain.

4) Onset and cause

Onset was July 22 due to contusion of shoulder to road while walking.

5) Present status

Hospitalized at an orthopaedic clinic on July 22 for two weeks.

6) Treatment period

The patient was treated between Aug. 2021 and Sep. 2021.

7) Progress (Fig. 1, Table 2)

Progress in the treatment (tx) of case 1

Shoulder pain 2021.08.10 (before treatment): 2021.09.30 (after 20 treatments)

JOAS: 43 points to 88 points.

NRS: 8 to 2.

8) Radiological findings

The shoulder ultrasound was taken on Aug. 10 2021, at Samse Medical Hospital. The image showed widening of the acromioclavicular (AC) joint cavity and partial narrowing of the glenohumeral (GH) joint cavity (Fig. 2). The image showed the deltoid muscle (DM), the humeral head (HH), and the supraspinatus tendon (SST).

Figure 2

Ultrasound (US) image before the first treatment of Case 1.

Afterwards, an ultrasound was taken on Sep. 10 2021, and showed recovery of the partial tear on the proximal SST (30%) (Fig. 3).

Figure 3

US image after 20 treatments of Case 1.

10. Case 2

Lee XX (Male, 63 years old)

2) Diagnoses

The diagnoses were as follows:

(1) Calcified tendinitis on SST.

(2) Partial adhesive gleno-humeral joint capsulitis.

3) Chief complaints

Left cervical pain radiating down to fingers, shoulder pain on movement, limitation of movement, and night pain.

Onset in Jun. 2021 with symptoms that worsened on Jul. 10, 2021.

Treatments of cervical traction, local injections at the orthopaedic clinic for two weeks.

The patient was treated between 14 Jul. 2021 and 30 Sep. 2021.

7) Progress (Fig. 4, Table 3)

Progress in the treatment of Case 2

Shoulder pain: 2021.07.14 (before treatment): 2021.09.30 (after 20 treatment)

JOAS: 63 versus 93

NRS: 5 versus 1

The ultrasound was taken on Aug 13 2021, and showed mild tendinopathy on the bicep tendon and subscapularis tendon (Fig. 5).

Figure 5

US image before the first treatment in Case 2.

Afterwards, an ultrasound image was taken on Oct. 1, 2021 with no interval change shown (Fig. 6).

Figure 6

US image after 20 treatments in Case 2.

DISCUSSION

Shoulder pain is mostly derived from disorders of the rotator cuff which consists of supraspinatus, infraspinatus, teres minor, and subscapular tendon, though sometimes due to cervical nerve compression and referral of visceral diseases. Supraspinatus acts in conjunction with the other cuff muscles during GH movement to bring the head into the glenoid fossa, exerting minimal rotary action and the remaining cuff muscles, by their origin and insertion, have more of a downward pull and thus depress the head of humerus in a downward rotary direction [19]. Rotator cuff problems lead to impingement tendonitis and adhesive capsulitis also known as frozen shoulder with a weakening of abduction, external rotation, and night pain. Frozen shoulder gets less painful depending on the stage over several months [1, 2].

Many Western conventional treatments for shoulder pain are used such as oral drug treatment, local injections, and non-drug physiotherapy treatment, but surgical decompression must be done if joint distension, sustaining symptoms, and continued functional disability follows after 6 months of physical therapy [4, 11, 20-23]. Jason et al. recommended acupuncture as a nonsurgical treatment though Kim et al. asserted that the efficacy of acupuncture on AC was not accurately assessed [11, 12]. However, Park et al. suggested that acupuncture may be an effective and safe treatment for impingement syndrome, and MacPherson claimed that the effect of acupuncture lasts over 12 months [13, 24]. In order to effectively treat shoulder pain, many methods have been used such as electro-acupuncture, rehabilitation, trigger point dry needling with manual pressure technique, and conservative Korean Medicine treatments such as MA, PA, herbal drugs, moxibustion, and Chuna manipulation along with AK’s manipulation [25-29].

OIT was developed in 1964 by Goodheart, the inventor of AK, and was practiced in shoulder treatments. He postulated that the muscle weakness was due to a microavulsion of the tendon from the periosteum, and that heavy digital massage in the sites of origin/insertion of the weak muscle can strengthen it [5, 6]. OIT was stimulated mostly on insertion site of supraspinatus, which is the superior facet of greater tuberosity of humerus as well as on coracoid process (around LU1), which is the origins of the short head of biceps brachii and coracobrachialis as well as the insertion of pectoralis minor.

Its characteristics are that OIT stimulates origins/insertions of corresponding muscles different from muscle massage, which stimulates muscle belly or golgi tendon organs.

After taking into consideration the various treatments, MA and PA treatments were practiced following OIT with JOAS and NRS being assessed. The JOAS was applied to compare the pre- and post-treatment outcomes. Takagishi et al. regarded a JOAS of >90, 81-90, 71-80, and <71 to indicate excellent, good, fair, and poor outcome, respectively [30]. The score of the first patient was improved from 43 to 88 while that of the second patient from 63 to 93. The NRS of the first patient changed from 8 to 2 and that of the second patient 5 to 1.

The impingement of the rotator cuff is the result of anomalies or abnormalities in the coracoacromial arch and features of impingement may be identified on a routine radiograph, ultrasound, computerized tomography, and magnetic resonance imaging [17, 31]. Case 1 showed changes in the ultrasound image from 40/50% to 30% in partial tear on SST, but case 2 showed no change in partial adhesive GH capsulitis. The reason for these ultrasound results must be pursued in the future.

CONCLUSION

The combined MA, PA, and OIT treatments were effective against shoulder pain such as impingement syndrome and partial adhesive capsulitis.

Table 2

JOAS of Case I

	Before tx.	After 20 times tx.
Pain (30)	5	20
Function (20)	6	20
Range of motion (30)	19	30
Radiograph evaluation (5)	3	3
Joint stability (15)	10	15
Total (100)	43	88

Table 3

JOAS of Case 2

	Before tx.	After 20 times tx.
Pain (30)	20	25
Function (20)	11	20
Range of motion (30)	19	30
Radiograph evaluation (5)	3	3
Joint stability (15)	10	15
Total (100)	63	93