Xiaoxiao Kuai1, Ke Li2, Jianmei Chen3, Hao Wang4, Junyi Yao1, Chao-Lung Chiang5, Tingting Liu6, Hanzhang Ye6, Jianqing Zhao1, Yan-Gu Lin5, Labao Zhang4, Valeria Nicolosi2, Lijun Gao1. 1. Soochow Institute for Energy and Materials Innovations & Key Laboratory of Advanced Carbon Materials and Wearable Energy Technologies of Jiangsu Province, College of Energy, Soochow University, Suzhou 215006, China. 2. School of Chemistry, Centre for Research on Adaptive Nanostructures and Nanodevices (CRANN) & Advanced Materials and BioEngineering Research (AMBER), Trinity College Dublin, Dublin, Dublin 2, Ireland. 3. College of Electronic and Optical Engineering & College of Microelectronics, Nanjing University of Posts and Telecommunications, Nanjing, 210023, P. R. China. 4. Research Institute of Superconductor Electronics, School of Electronic Science and Engineering, Nanjing University, Nanjing 210023, China. 5. National Synchrotron Radiation Research Center, Hsinchu 30076, Taiwan, R.O.C. 6. School of Environmental Science and Engineering& Jiangsu Key Laboratory of Environmental Science and Engineering, Suzhou University of Science and Technology, Suzhou 215001, China.
Abstract
Potassium ion hybrid capacitors (KICs) have drawn tremendous attention for large-scale energy storage applications because of their high energy and power densities and the abundance of potassium sources. However, achieving KICs with high capacity and long lifespan remains challenging because the large size of potassium ions causes sluggish kinetics and fast structural pulverization of electrodes. Here, we report a composite anode of VO2-V2O5 nanoheterostructures captured by a 3D N-doped carbon network (VO2-V2O5/NC) that exhibits a reversible capacity of 252 mAh g-1 at 1 A g-1 over 1600 cycles and a rate performance with 108 mAh g-1 at 10 A g-1. Quantitative kinetics analyses demonstrate that such great rate capability and cyclability are enabled by the capacitive-dominated potassium storage mechanism in the interfacial engineered VO2-V2O5 nanoheterostructures. The further fabricated full KIC cell consisting of a VO2-V2O5/NC anode and an active carbon cathode delivers a high operating voltage window of 4.0 V and energy and power densities up to 154 Wh kg-1 and 10 000 W kg-1, respectively, surpassing most state-of-the-art KICs.
Potassium ion hybrid capacitors (KICs) have drawn tremendous attention for large-scale energy storage applications because of their high energy and power densities and the abundance of potassium sources. However, achieving KICs with high capacity and long lifespan remains challenging because the large size of potassium ions causes sluggish kinetics and fast structural pulverization of electrodes. Here, we report a composite anode of VO2-V2O5 nanoheterostructures captured by a 3D N-doped carbon network (VO2-V2O5/NC) that exhibits a reversible capacity of 252 mAh g-1 at 1 A g-1 over 1600 cycles and a rate performance with 108 mAh g-1 at 10 A g-1. Quantitative kinetics analyses demonstrate that such great rate capability and cyclability are enabled by the capacitive-dominated potassium storage mechanism in the interfacial engineered VO2-V2O5 nanoheterostructures. The further fabricated full KIC cell consisting of a VO2-V2O5/NC anode and an active carbon cathode delivers a high operating voltage window of 4.0 V and energy and power densities up to 154 Wh kg-1 and 10 000 W kg-1, respectively, surpassing most state-of-the-art KICs.
Entities:
Keywords:
3D structure; battery; capacitor; energy storage; potassium-ion
Large-scale and low-cost
energy storage systems are becoming increasingly
important in our society because of their ability to power industrial
manufacturing and electric vehicles, store renewable energies (e.g.,
solar, wind, and hydropower energies), and balance power grids.[1] Lithium-ion batteries and electrochemical capacitors
are the two typical energy storage devices,[1−5] and capacitors possess much higher power densities
and longer lifespans than batteries. By constructing hybrid capacitors
with battery-type anodes and capacitive-type cathodes, the limited
energy density of capacitors can be prominently enhanced, reaching
or even surpassing the levels of traditional batteries, meanwhile
maintaining high power density outputs.[6−8] Nonetheless, the rise
in the cost of lithium and the rapid depletion of lithium sources
prevent the large-scale deployment of lithium-ion hybrid capacitors
(LICs).As a potential alternative, potassium reserves in the
Earth’s
crust are nearly 1000 times greater than lithium sources. Meanwhile,
it also features a low reduction potential of −2.93 V vs SHE,
similar to the value of lithium (−3.04 V), promising for designing
KICs with electrochemical performance comparable to LICs.[9,10] However, most of the reported KICs suffer from moderate energy density
and electrochemical stability,[11−28] due to the large ionic radius of K+ (1.38 Å). In
KICs, only partial active sites of usual electrode materials can be
occupied by K+, and the insertion/extraction of large K+ also leads to significant and irreversible electrode pulverization
during charge–discharge processes. As a result, developing
electrode materials with high capacities and enhanced structural stability
throughout long-term cycling is critical to the application of KICs.[29]Among various potassium-ion storage electrode
materials, vanadium
oxides with wide diversity (e.g., VO2, V2O3, V2O5, and V3O7), high theoretical capacities,[30−33] and low cost have attracted great
research interests,[34] and some progress
has been achieved.[35−37] For instance, a surface-amorphized VO2 anode was reported to deliver a capacity of 177.1 mAh g–1 after 500 cycles at 0.5 A g–1.[35] More recently, heterojunctions are emerging as promising
electrode material candidates because of their striking interface
effects and the intrinsic generation of a built-in electric field
at the heterointerface induced by work function difference. These
features can remarkably alleviate interfacial stress and boost reaction
kinetics and electron/ion transport, thus leading to enhanced electrochemical
performance,[38−40] which may also suit vanadium oxides.Herein,
VO2–V2O5 heterostructures
with an ultrasmall size of ∼5 nm encapsulated on 3D N-doped
carbon networks are developed through a self-template strategy. Benefiting
from the ultrasmall size of VO2–V2O5 heterojunctions, favorable interfacial effect, high-conductive
3D carbon network, and distinctive K+ storage mechanism,
VO2–V2O5/NC demonstrates great
performance for potassium-ion storage, such as a reversible capacity
of 501 mAh g–1 at 0.1 A g–1 after
200 cycles and a rate capability with 108 mAh g–1 being retained at 10 A g–1 in a K-ion half battery.
Moreover, the constructed KICs comprising VO2–V2O5/NC anodes and commercial activated carbon (AC)
cathodes provide a maximum energy density and power density up to
154 Wh kg–1 and 10 000 W kg–1, respectively, as well as exceptional long-term stability during
10 000 cycles.
Results and Discussion
Synthesis and Characterization
of VO2–V2O5/NC
VO2–V2O5/NC was synthesized via
a self-template strategy (Figure S1). The
mixture precursor of oxalic acid,
dicyandiamide, and ammonium vanadate was first annealed at 550 °C
under a N2 atmosphere. During this process, dicyandiamide
was transformed into intermediate graphitic carbon nitride (g-C3N4) bulk, while ammonium vanadate
was reduced into VO2,[41] resulting
in a VO2/g-C3N4 composite
(Figure S2). Followed by annealing at 800
°C in N2 flow (VN/NC, Figure S3) and partially oxidizing at 280 °C in air, the final target
product VO2–V2O5/NC was obtained
(Figure b,d and Figure S4). Generally, dicyandiamide will be
transformed into g-C3N4 at
∼530 °C and then fully decomposed at temperatures above
700 °C.[42] However, in our case, because
of the electrostatic interaction between the protonation of lone-pair
electrons of pyridinic N in g-C3N4 and (VO)2(C2O4)32– pieces,[43]g-C3N4 was ultimately carbonized into
3D N-doped carbon networks at 800 °C (Figure S5), together with the formation of VN from VO2 (Figure S6). Meanwhile, in the later pyrolysis
process, the as-formed 3D carbon networks maintained and protected
VO2–V2O5 from irreversible
fusion and aggregation, which was distinctly different from the compact
and bulky VO2/g-C3N4 (Figure S7) and g-C3N4.[44] As confirmed by
the transmission electron microscopy (TEM) and scanning electron microscopy
(SEM) images of VO2–V2O5/NC
in Figure a and Figure S8a, a porous carbon framework is homogeneously
implanted with massive VO2–V2O5 nanocrystals (size: ∼5 nm). The lattice fringes with interlayer
spacings of 0.249 and 0.2 nm in the high-resolution TEM (HRTEM) image
(Figure b) correspond
to the (012) and (211) planes of VO2 and V2O5, respectively. High-angle annular dark-field scanning transmission
electron microscopy (HAADF-STEM) and corresponding elemental mapping
images (Figure c)
also confirm the uniform dispersion of ultrasmall VO2–V2O5 nanoheterostructures. To further investigate
the microstructure of VO2–V2O5/NC, N2 adsorption/desorption measurements were employed.
As presented in Figure S9, a type-II isotherm
with a hysteresis loop and a narrow pore distribution centered at
3 nm are observed in VO2–V2O5/NC, indicating its mesoporous structure.[45] In addition, the Brunauer–Emmett–Teller (BET) surface
area of VO2–V2O5/NC was measured
to be 378.5 m2 g–1, much higher than
that of VO2/g-C3N4 (2.1 m2 g–1) (Table S1). Notably, the mesoporous structure and large surface area
will facilitate electrolyte ion diffusion and charge transfer, thus
enhancing the electrochemical performance of VO2–V2O5/NC.
Figure 1
Characterization of the prepared VO2–V2O5/NC sample. (a) TEM image of VO2–V2O5/NC, where the blue dashed
line shows the interface
of the VO2–V2O5 heterostructure.
(b) HRTEM image of a VO2–V2O5 nanoheterostructure anchored on N-doped carbon, and the corresponding
fast Fourier transformation patterns of VO2 (red) and V2O5 (yellow). (c) HAADF-STEM image and the corresponding
elemental mapping images of V, N, C, and O in VO2–V2O5/NC. (d) XRD patterns of VO2–V2O5/NC and VO2/g-C3N4. (e) High-resolution XPS spectra of V 2p of
VO2–V2O5/NC and VO2/g-C3N4. (f) V K-edge XANES
spectra of V, VO2, V2O3, V2O5, and VO2–V2O5/NC. (g) Linear regressions of vanadium valence derived from relevant
standards for VO2–V2O5/NC.
Characterization of the prepared VO2–V2O5/NC sample. (a) TEM image of VO2–V2O5/NC, where the blue dashed
line shows the interface
of the VO2–V2O5 heterostructure.
(b) HRTEM image of a VO2–V2O5 nanoheterostructure anchored on N-doped carbon, and the corresponding
fast Fourier transformation patterns of VO2 (red) and V2O5 (yellow). (c) HAADF-STEM image and the corresponding
elemental mapping images of V, N, C, and O in VO2–V2O5/NC. (d) XRD patterns of VO2–V2O5/NC and VO2/g-C3N4. (e) High-resolution XPS spectra of V 2p of
VO2–V2O5/NC and VO2/g-C3N4. (f) V K-edge XANES
spectra of V, VO2, V2O3, V2O5, and VO2–V2O5/NC. (g) Linear regressions of vanadium valence derived from relevant
standards for VO2–V2O5/NC.X-ray-based measurements were employed to finely
explore the crystal
structure, composition, phase, and valence information on the obtained
samples. In the XRD diffractogram (Figure d), the two peaks corresponding to g-C3N4 in VO2/g-C3N4 confirm the formation of g-C3N4 during the annealing process.[46] In contrast, the obtained VO2–V2O5/NC shows the highest crystallinity with a series
of sharp peaks, which match well with the simulated VO2 (PDF#44-0252) and V2O5 (PDF#41-1426) patterns.
The survey X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) spectrum also reveals
the presence of V, O, C, and N elements in VO2–V2O5/NC (Figure S10a).
The N 1s XPS spectrum of VO2–V2O5/NC (Figure S10b) can be deconvolved
into pyridinic N (398.8 eV), pyrrolic N (400 eV), and graphitic N
(401.2 eV). Notably, pyridinic N and pyrrolic N in N-doped carbon-based
materials have been demonstrated to contribute some capacities.[47,48] For the high-resolution V 2p spectrum of VO2–V2O5/NC (Figure e), the two group peaks corresponded to V 2p1/2 and 2p3/2, clearly demonstrating the existence of V4+ and V5+ in this composite. Figure f shows the vanadium K-edge X-ray absorption
near edge structure (XANES) spectra of relevant vanadium standards
(VO2, V2O3, V2O5) and VO2–V2O5/NC. These
samples with various vanadium valences were used as standards to estimate
the oxidation states of vanadium species by linear fitting the inflection
point position in the edge absorption region.[49] Once again, the existence of both V4+ and V5+ in VO2–V2O5/NC is confirmed,
and the average valence of vanadium is derived to be 4.58 (42 wt %
VO2 and 58 wt % V2O5) via the vanadium
oxide-derived linear regression line (Figure g). Moreover, on the basis of the thermogravimetric
analysis (Figure S11), the mass percentage
of VO2–V2O5 in VO2–V2O5/NC composite is 39.8%.
Electrochemical
Measurements of VO2–V2O5/NC
Electrode
Figure a shows the first four cyclic voltammetry
(CV) cycles of VO2–V2O5/NC
at a scan rate of 0.1 mV s–1. Two reduction peaks
centered at 1.41 and 0.63 V are observed in the first cathodic cycle,
which can be ascribed to the initial insertion of K+ into
VO2 and V2O5 lattices (Figure S12b, 13b), accompanied by the unavoidable
formation of SEI film and irreversible phase transition reactions,[23,24] and the subsequent reversible potassiation/depotassiation is corroborated
by the stable redox peaks at 1.08/0.67 V in the following cycles.
When cycling at a low current density of 0.1 A g–1, VO2/NC and V2O5/NC electrodes
both show some capacity decays, while VO2–V2O5/NC maintains a high capacity 501 mAh g–1 after 120 cycles, which is substantially greater than VO2/NC (399 mAh g–1), V2O5/NC
(388.9 mAh g–1), and NC (346.5 mAh g–1) (Figure b), indicating
the enhanced structural stability and higher electrochemical activity
of the VO2–V2O5/NC electrode.
Moreover, the capacity contributions of the VO2–V2O5 heterostructure and NC in VO2–V2O5/NC electrode at 0.1 A g–1 are
calculated to be 59.1% and 40.9%, respectively, according to their
mass contents determined by TGA (Figure S6). The increasing capacity of VO2–V2O5/NC during cycling mainly derives from the gradual activation
process of electrode materials, which happens in other metal oxide
materials as well.[50] The rate capabilities
of these electrodes and the charge/discharge behaviors at different
current densities of the VO2–V2O5/NC electrode were further investigated, as displayed in Figure c and Figure S14. The VO2–V2O5/NC electrode delivers highly reversible capacities
of 510, 431, 321, 259, 202, 142, and 108 mAh g–1 at current densities of 0.1, 0.2, 0.5, 1, 2, 5, and 10 A g–1, respectively, certainly surpassing VO2/NC, V2O5/NC, and NC. Moreover, when the current density goes
back to 0.1 A g–1, the specific capacity of VO2–V2O5/NC almost recovers (498
mAh g–1). Figure d shows the long-term cycling performance of different
electrodes at a current density of 1 A g–1. Remarkably,
the VO2–V2O5/NC electrode
exhibits a high reversible capacity of 256 mAh g–1 with 100% Coulombic efficiency (CE) even after 1600 cycles, much
better than VO2/NC, V2O5/NC and most
state-of-the-art K+ storage electrodes (Table S2). The improved cycle stability of VO2–V2O5/NC is expected to be due to the strong stress
migration ability at the interface of ultrasmall VO2–V2O5 heterostructures toward the volume fluctuation
and the effective strain release caused by the extremely small nanocrystalline
during charge–discharge processes;[26−28] meanwhile,
the N-doped carbon network may also help suppress particle pulverization.[50]
Figure 2
Electrochemical performance of VO2–V2O5/NC in a half-cell system. (a) CV curves of the
VO2–V2O5/NC electrode at a
scan
rate of 0.1 mV s–1. (b) Electrochemical performance
of electrodes at 0.1 A g–1. (c) Rate capabilities
of electrodes at different current densities. (d) Long cycle performance
of electrodes at 1 A g–1. (e) CV curves of VO2–V2O5/NC at different scan rates.
(f) b-values of the VO2–V2O5/NC electrode. (g) Capacitive and diffusion-controlled
contribution ratios in the VO2–V2O5/NC electrode at different scan rates. (h) Linear fit of Z′
against ω–1/2 for VO2–V2O5/NC, VO2/NC, and V2O5/NC electrodes, in which the values are derived from Figure S15a.
Electrochemical performance of VO2–V2O5/NC in a half-cell system. (a) CV curves of the
VO2–V2O5/NC electrode at a
scan
rate of 0.1 mV s–1. (b) Electrochemical performance
of electrodes at 0.1 A g–1. (c) Rate capabilities
of electrodes at different current densities. (d) Long cycle performance
of electrodes at 1 A g–1. (e) CV curves of VO2–V2O5/NC at different scan rates.
(f) b-values of the VO2–V2O5/NC electrode. (g) Capacitive and diffusion-controlled
contribution ratios in the VO2–V2O5/NC electrode at different scan rates. (h) Linear fit of Z′
against ω–1/2 for VO2–V2O5/NC, VO2/NC, and V2O5/NC electrodes, in which the values are derived from Figure S15a.To interpret the potassium ion storage kinetics in VO2–V2O5/NC electrode, CV tests at different
scan rates were conducted (Figure e and Figure S16). The peak
current (i) and scan rate (v) follow this formula: i = av, where a and b are coefficients: b = 0.5 means a semi-infinite diffusion control reaction, while b = 1 corresponds to a capacitive process.[51] As shown in Figure f, the calculated b-values of the two redox
peaks P1 and P2 are 0.84 and 0.87, respectively. They are both close
to the value of 1, revealing that the charge storage processes in
VO2–V2O5/NC are predominantly
capacitive[52−54] (b values of VO2/NC and
V2O5/NC are shown in Figure S17). Moreover, the contributions from surface capacitive effects
and diffusion-controlled reactions in the VO2–V2O5/NC electrode were measured using a voltammetric
sweep rate-dependent analysis:[55]where k1 and k2 are appropriate values. At a given potential,
the current (i) is composed of surface capacitive
effects (k1v) and diffusion-controlled
processes (k2v1/2). As shown in Figure S18, the surface
capacitive effect is the primary contributor at 2 mV s–1, which accounts for 79.4% of the total capacitance of the VO2–V2O5/NC electrode. Figure g summarizes the
capacitive contribution at different scan rates. The capacitive contribution
in VO2–V2O5/NC increases gradually
from 39% at 0.1 mV s–1 to 74.9% at 2 mV s–1, indicating that capacitive processes are dominant at high scan
rates, which is in line with the great rate capabilities of VO2–V2O5/NC.The electrochemical
process differences between VO2–V2O5/NC, VO2/NC, and V2O5/NC
(Figure S15a) were also evaluated
using electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS). Generally, Warburg
impedance is related to diffusion resistance. The Warburg factor (σ)
has a linear relation with Z′ and is inversely
proportional to the diffusion coefficient of electrolyte ions:[56]where Re is the
electrode-to-electrolyte resistance, Rct is the charge transfer resistance, and ω is the angular frequency.
As shown in Figure h, the slope of Z′ against ω–1/2 for VO2–V2O5/NC (22.8) is
smaller than those of VO2/NC (24.5) and V2O5/NC (31.4), suggesting a larger K+ diffusion coefficient
and faster diffusion efficiency in the VO2–V2O5/NC electrode.[57] In
addition, the diffusion kinetics of K+ in three electrodes
were also elucidated by the galvanostatic intermittent titration (GITT)
technique. As displayed in Figure S15b,
similar trends are found for VO2/NC, V2O5/NC, and VO2–V2O5/NC;
however, the K+ diffusion coefficient of VO2–V2O5/NC is higher than those of V2O5/NC and VO2/NC, which is consistent
with the EIS result.On the basis of the aforementioned considerations,
the outstanding
K+ storage performance of the VO2–V2O5/NC electrode can be attributed to the following
synergistic merits. First, ∼5 nm VO2–V2O5 heterocrystals anchored on a 3D carbon framework
expose a large surface area and thus abundant active sites for sufficient
electrochemical reactions. Second, compared with single-phase vanadium
oxide (VO2 or V2O5), the work function
difference between VO2 and V2O5 in
VO2–V2O5 heterojunctions will
induce the generation of electric fields at the heterointerface,[58] which can facilitate reaction dynamics and electron/ion
transport and strengthen electrochemical performance.[38,59] Third, ultrasmall VO2–V2O5 heterocrystals on high-conductive carbon sheets not only facilitate
electron transfer and high utilization of vanadium oxides but also
efficiently buffer their swelling and shrinking and mitigate the mechanical
stress during the charge–discharge process.[60] Fourth, the 3D porous structure of VO2–V2O5/NC benefits the diffusion of electrolyte into
pores as well as electron transport throughout the entire composite
framework.
Investigation of K+ Storage Mechanism
To
reveal the in-depth K+ storage mechanism and understand
the local structure evolution, ex situ XRD and XAS
measurements of VO2–V2O5/NC,
V2O5/NC, and VO2/NC electrodes during
charge–discharge processes were conducted (Figure a, Figure S19). For the V2O5/NC electrode, V2O5 transforms into KVO3 when discharged
to 1 V, and the peaks of KVO3 shift slightly to lower angles
upon discharging to 0.01 V, indicating the further potassiation and
the generation of K1+VO3.
KVO2 is also obtained at 0.01 V. During the charging process,
K+ ions extract from K1+VO3 and KVO2, and V2O5 partially
recovers, resulting in the coexistence of K1+VO3 (x′ < x), K1–VO2 (y < 1), and V2O5 at 3 V (Figure S19a). On the contrary, only peak shifting
occurs in the VO2/NC electrode during the charge–discharge
processes (Figure S19b), suggesting a reversible
K+ intercalation/deintercalation energy storage mechanism
(VO2 ↔ KVO2). VO2–V2O5/NC inherits the
main charge-storage characteristics of both V2O5/NC and VO2/NC, but differences exist (Figure b). During the discharge process,
K+ ions also react with V2O5 and
intercalate into VO2, forming K1+VO3, KVO2, and KVO2, but no V2O5 is detected
after being recharged to 3 V, differing from V2O5/NC. This significant distinction suggests that there should be some
interfacial interactions among the produced K1+VO3, KVO2, and KVO2 in the VO2–V2O5/NC electrode, which prevent the regeneration of V2O5 during charging. Notably, the absence of V2O5 would be capable of reducing phase transition reactions
during the following charge–discharge processes, and thus,
improved cycle stability for VO2–V2O5/NC is achieved (Figure d). Meanwhile, the ex situ XRD results
also indicate that phase transition reactions and intercalation-induced
volume changes should be responsible for the poor cycling stability
of the V2O5/NC and VO2/NC electrodes,
respectively.[61,62]
Figure 3
K+ storage mechanism of VO2–V2O5/NC electrode. (a) Galvanostatic
charge–discharge
(GCD) curve in the first cycle (left) and XRD patterns (right) of
the VO2–V2O5/NC electrode
at different voltage states. (b) Schematic diagram of the potassium
storage mechanism of VO2–V2O5/NC, V2O5/NC, and VO2/NC. (c) Normalized
vanadium K-edge XANES spectra of the VO2–V2O5/NC electrode discharged to 1 and 0.01 V and then recharged
to 0.6 and 3 V in the first cycle. (d) Vanadium oxide-derived linear
regressions of vanadium valence at different voltage stages (D1, D2,
C1, and C2 indicate the states of VO2–V2O5/NC being discharged to 1, 0.01 V, and charged to 0.6,
3 V, respectively).
K+ storage mechanism of VO2–V2O5/NC electrode. (a) Galvanostatic
charge–discharge
(GCD) curve in the first cycle (left) and XRD patterns (right) of
the VO2–V2O5/NC electrode
at different voltage states. (b) Schematic diagram of the potassium
storage mechanism of VO2–V2O5/NC, V2O5/NC, and VO2/NC. (c) Normalized
vanadium K-edge XANES spectra of the VO2–V2O5/NC electrode discharged to 1 and 0.01 V and then recharged
to 0.6 and 3 V in the first cycle. (d) Vanadium oxide-derived linear
regressions of vanadium valence at different voltage stages (D1, D2,
C1, and C2 indicate the states of VO2–V2O5/NC being discharged to 1, 0.01 V, and charged to 0.6,
3 V, respectively).The valence shift of
vanadium in VO2–V2O5/NC throughout
the discharge–charge process was
investigated using XANES, which has been shown to be a powerful tool
for precisely analyzing transition metal elements (e.g., Mo, Co, Ti).[63−65]Figure c (left)
shows the normalized vanadium K-edge XANES profiles of VO2–V2O5/NC at selected discharge–charge
potentials. During the discharge process, the entire edge position
shifted to a lower photon energy level, indicating a decrease of the
average vanadium valence state in the VO2–V2O5/NC electrode. In addition, the structural symmetry
and geometry of vanadium oxides can be analyzed by the pre-edge peak
(∼5470 eV) in XAS spectra. Theoretically, the electrical dipole
transition to the p-component in the d–p orbital hybridization
order is proportional to the pre-edge peak intensity in 3d transition
metal complexes.[50] With the different electrical
distributions in octahedral shape of the d-orbitals, these octahedral
vanadium oxides with a 6-coordinated vanadium site have different
symmetric distortion orders. Other main feature peaks at 5488 and
5504 eV are attributed to the dipole-allowed 1s–4p transitions
from the multiple edge-resonances scattering of the core electrons
from higher np states.[66,67] Herein, the structural symmetry
variation of the vanadium site in VO2–V2O5/NC during the discharge–charge cycle can be
identified on the basis of these concepts. Figure c (right) shows a gradual change in absorbance
intensity in the prepeak area, showing that structural symmetry is
strengthened and weakened in the discharge and charge processes, respectively,
when compared with the pristine condition. With the apparent variations
in the structural symmetry and vanadium valence of VO2–V2O5/NC, the occurrences of potassiation and depotassiation
are demonstrated. The K+ ions in the electrolyte react
with vanadium oxides along the crystal planes, thus forming K1+VO3 and KVO2 species
with a higher vanadium coordination number and longer V–O bond
distance in the duration of discharge.[68] In the charging process, the entire edge position slightly shifts
to higher photon energy, which arises from the partial depotassiation
of the vacancy-rich and lattice-distorted K1+VO3 and KVO2, thus reducing back to K1+VO3/K1–VO2 (x′ < x, y < 1) with a higher valence,[35,69] As depicted in Figure S20, the oscillation
amplitude in K2-weighted XAS spectra gradually increases
with the same frequency during discharging, indicating that the coordination
environment of vanadium in the VO2–V2O5/NC electrode varies due to potassiation. Once the charging
process occurs, the oscillation amplitude gradually increases, revealing
the reduction of vanadium coordination number in the VO2–V2O5/NC electrode toward the original
state.The quantified average valence shift of VO2–V2O5/NC at different voltage stages
can be fitted
with the vanadium oxide-derived linear regression line (Figure d, 1g) with a reliable equation (y = 5468.3 + 3.1x, R2 = 0.949). As expected,
the average valence state of vanadium in VO2–V2O5/NC decreases during the discharge process. In
contrast, the average vanadium valence state increases to a value
below the original state during the charging process. This result
is in line with K-edge XANES analyses.
Demonstration of KIC Device
Based on VO2–V2O5/NC
To match the performance of the
VO2–V2O5/NC anode and construct
a high-performance KIC, AC
was chosen as the cathodic material (Figure S21a). It shows an working voltage window of 2.5–4 V vs. K+/K, a capacity of 39.8 mAh g–1 at 0.1 A
g–1, and an acceptable rate capability (8.3 mAh
g–1 at 5 A g–1) (Figure S21b,c). Moreover, it delivers exceptional cycling
stability up to 1200 cycles at 1 A g–1 (Figure S21d). The further assembled KICs consisting
of VO2–V2O5/NC anode, AC cathode,
and KPF6 electrolyte are schematically illustrated in Figure a. Upon charging,
PF6– anions are adsorbed to the AC surface,
while K+ ions are inserted into the VO2–V2O5/NC anode, and these processes reverse during
discharge.
Figure 4
Electrochemical performance of VO2–V2O5/NC//AC KIC. (a) Schematic configuration of the VO2–V2O5/NC//AC KIC device. (b)
CV profiles of VO2–V2O5/NC
and AC in half cells (top) and VO2–V2O5/NC//AC KIC (bottom). (c) GCD curves of the VO2–V2O5/NC//AC KIC device at different
current densities. (d) Ragone plots of VO2–V2O5/NC//AC KIC in comparison with other representative
KICs (Prussian blue//AC,[11] K2TP//AC,[12] Ca0.5Ti2(PO4)3@C//AC,[13] K2Ti6O13//AC,[14] carbon foam//AC,[15] K–V2C//KMnFe(CN)6,[16] NbSe2/NSeCNFs//AC[17]). (e) Long cyclic performance of VO2–V2O5/NC//AC KIC at 1 A g–1. Insets
are the GCD curves from 5000 to 5010, and from 9990 to 10 000
cycles.
Electrochemical performance of VO2–V2O5/NC//AC KIC. (a) Schematic configuration of the VO2–V2O5/NC//AC KIC device. (b)
CV profiles of VO2–V2O5/NC
and AC in half cells (top) and VO2–V2O5/NC//AC KIC (bottom). (c) GCD curves of the VO2–V2O5/NC//AC KIC device at different
current densities. (d) Ragone plots of VO2–V2O5/NC//AC KIC in comparison with other representative
KICs (Prussian blue//AC,[11] K2TP//AC,[12] Ca0.5Ti2(PO4)3@C//AC,[13] K2Ti6O13//AC,[14] carbon foam//AC,[15] K–V2C//KMnFe(CN)6,[16] NbSe2/NSeCNFs//AC[17]). (e) Long cyclic performance of VO2–V2O5/NC//AC KIC at 1 A g–1. Insets
are the GCD curves from 5000 to 5010, and from 9990 to 10 000
cycles.Based on the CV profiles of the
VO2–V2O5/NC anode and AC cathode,
a high and stable operating
voltage window up to 4 V was achieved for the constructed VO2–V2O5/NC/AC KIC (Figure b, Figure S22).
In addition, different anode-to-cathode mass ratios were also examined
to maximize the performance of full devices, and the optimal mass
ratio of VO2–V2O5/NC anode
to AC cathode in our work was determined to be 1:4.5 (Figure S23). Figure c presents the GCD curves of VO2–V2O5/NC//AC KIC at different current
densities (0.05–5 A g–1). All the GCD profiles
show high symmetry and deviate from the linear characteristics of
ideal supercapacitors, indicating efficient and complex K+ storage processes in our device.[6,7] According to
the GCD curves, the maximum gravimetric energy (power) density of
the as-fabricated VO2–V2O5/NC//AC KIC reaches 154 Wh kg–1 (100 W kg–1) (based on the total active mass of two electrodes, a high gravimetric
energy density of 22 Wh kg–1 still maintains at
an ultrahigh power density of 10 000 W kg–1; Figure d). The
energy/power densities of our device outperform the most high-performance
KICs ever reported (Table S3). In addition,
the VO2–V2O5/NC//AC KIC device
also exhibits exceptional cycling stability with high capacity retention
of 85.1% after 5000 cycles and 72.1% even after 10 000 cycles
(Figure e), demonstrating
its great potential for mid/large-scale practical applications.
Conclusion
To conclude, a high-energy and long-term stable
K-ion storage anode
with ultrasmall VO2–V2O5 nanoheterostructures
anchored on 3D porous N-doped carbon networks was successfully developed.
Because of the ultrasmall size of VO2–V2O5 heterocrystals, favorable interfacial effect, high-conductive
3D carbon network, and distinctive K-ion storage mechanism, the VO2–V2O5/NC electrode exhibits high
K-ion storage performance, such as a high reversible capacity of 510
mAh g–1 and significant long-term stability with
a capacity of 252 mAh g–1 after 1600 cycles. Furthermore,
a KIC device consisting of VO2–V2O5/NC anode and commercial AC cathode delivers a high gravimetric
energy density of 154 Wh kg–1 at 100 W kg–1, as well as a long lifespan, retaining 85.1% capacity after 5000
cycles and 72.1% capacity even after 10 000 cycles. This study
provides a pathway for designing high-energy and long-term potassium-ion
storage electrodes and devices for practical applications.
Methods
Preparation of VO2–V2O5/NC
A self-template strategy
is employed to synthesize ultrasmall
VO2–V2O5 nanoheterojunctions
fixed on 3D N-doped carbon network (VO2–V2O5/NC). First, a homogeneous solution was prepared by
dissolving 0.36 g of oxalic acid (Alfa Aesar) and 0.23 g of ammonium
vanadate (Aladdin) in 80 mL of deionized water. Then 2 g of dicyandiamide
(Sigma-Aldrich) was added in and dried at 80 °C. The as-collected
precursor was then calcined at 800 °C for 2 h in N2 atmosphere with a heating rate of 2 °C min–1 to produce the VN/NC composite. After that, the as-obtained VN/NC
was reheated to 280 °C in air at a heating rate of 1°C min–1 and maintained for 4 h, VO2–V2O5/NC was finally obtained. For comparison, VO2/g-C3N4 was prepared
by annealing the ammonium vanadate/dicyandiamide precursor at 550
°C for 2 h in a N2 atmosphere at a heating rate of
2 °C min–1. N-doped carbon (NC) was prepared
by calcining an oxalic acid (0.1 g)/dicyandiamide (1 g) mixture at
800 °C for 2 h in a N2 atmosphere at a heating rate
of 2 °C min–1. For comparison, VO2/NC was prepared by heating VN/NC at 260 °C in air for 6 h with
a heating rate of 1 °C min–1, while V2O5/NC was formed by annealing VN/NC at 280 °C in
air for 8 h.