Literature DB >> 35003452

The "Magnificent Seven Errors" in Forensic Autopsy Practice: The Italian Context.

Roberto Scendoni, Piergiorgio Fedeli, Nunzia Cannovo, Mariano Cingolani.   

Abstract

According to the Italian legal system, forensic autopsies are performed by a medical doctor specialized in legal medicine, otherwise known as a medicolegal expert (MLE), who has a range of very complex responsibilities. Indeed, the quality of forensic autopsy activity is always questioned in courts of law; incorrect assessments are dangerous because they can jeopardize the validity of a criminal investigation and thus affect the outcome so that a real culprit may be acquitted or an innocent person convicted. Nonconformities also discredit the professionalism of the specialist who performs the autopsy. The work of a MLE implies a series of assignments and duties that should be given constant consideration, but when certain aspects of this activity are underestimated or overlooked, this can lead the expert to make mistakes with irreparable consequences for the judicial investigation. In this article, for the first time, we present a summary of seven known errors related to autopsy activity following death by unnatural causes, with the purpose of alerting MLEs who work under the Italian judicial system to the potential dangers of such errors. These relate to: oversights in autopsy technique, incorrect collection of photographic and video material, unauthorized attendance at the autopsy, missing/mistaken reporting at any stage of the forensic activity, failure to notify the party forensic consultant, using histological or toxicological nonaccredited laboratories for forensic activities, and lack of observance of the chain of custody.
© 2021 The Author(s).

Entities:  

Keywords:  Chain of custody; Forensic autopsy; Forensic pathology; Histological samples; Medicolegal errors; Toxicological analyses

Year:  2021        PMID: 35003452      PMCID: PMC8727839          DOI: 10.1177/19253621211056191

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  Acad Forensic Pathol        ISSN: 1925-3621


  12 in total

Review 1.  The autopsy: complete or not complete?

Authors:  E W Benbow; I S D Roberts
Journal:  Histopathology       Date:  2003-05       Impact factor: 5.087

2.  THE INVESTIGATION OF OBSCURE DEATHS.

Authors:  K SIMPSON
Journal:  Can Med Assoc J       Date:  1964-10-17       Impact factor: 8.262

3.  [Errors in autopsy in Germany. Results of a multicenter study (II)].

Authors:  B Brinkmann
Journal:  Arch Kriminol       Date:  1997 Mar-Apr

Review 4.  Postmortem Imaging: An Update.

Authors:  Francesco Pio Cafarelli; Gianpaolo Grilli; Giulio Zizzo; Giuseppe Bertozzi; Nicola Giuliani; Pasuk Mahakkanukrauh; Antonio Pinto; Giuseppe Guglielmi
Journal:  Semin Ultrasound CT MR       Date:  2018-10-28       Impact factor: 1.875

5.  The Mangalore aircrash of 22 May 2010: practical problems related to identification of the dead in a populous developing country.

Authors:  Ritesh G Menezes; B Suresh Kumar Shetty; Prateek Rastogi; Jagadish Rao Padubidri; Y P Raghavendra Babu; K R Nagesh; Deepak Herald D'Souza; Mahabalesh Shetty; Francis N P Monteiro; Haneil Larson Dsouza
Journal:  Med Leg J       Date:  2012

Review 6.  The role of histopathology in forensic practice: an overview.

Authors:  R B Dettmeyer
Journal:  Forensic Sci Med Pathol       Date:  2014-03-01       Impact factor: 2.007

Review 7.  Legal issues related to drug testing in the clinical laboratory.

Authors:  R T Chamberlain
Journal:  Clin Chem       Date:  1988-03       Impact factor: 8.327

8.  Photography in forensic medicine.

Authors:  A P Henham; K A Lee
Journal:  J Audiov Media Med       Date:  1994-01

9.  Viewing the body after bereavement due to a traumatic death: qualitative study in the UK.

Authors:  A Chapple; S Ziebland
Journal:  BMJ       Date:  2010-04-30

Review 10.  The value of postmortem experience in undergraduate medical education: current perspectives.

Authors:  Andrew R Bamber; Thelma A Quince
Journal:  Adv Med Educ Pract       Date:  2015-03-11
View more

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.