Literature DB >> 34982790

Correction: Prevalence of limited health literacy among patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus: A systematic review.

Adina Abdullah, Su May Liew, Hani Salim, Chirk Jenn Ng, Karuthan Chinna.   

Abstract

[This corrects the article DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0216402.].

Entities:  

Year:  2022        PMID: 34982790      PMCID: PMC8726497          DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0261430

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  PLoS One        ISSN: 1932-6203            Impact factor:   3.240


There were errors in the extraction of numbers used to calculate the prevalence of limited health literacy, resulting in the incorrect extracted values for Souza, J. G., et al (2014), Kim, S. H. (2009), Chen, G. D., et al (2014), van der Heide, I., et al (2014), Aikens JE, Piette JD. (2009), Mancuso, J. M. (2010) and Wallace, A. S., et al (2010) in Table 1. Please see the corrected Table 1 here.
Table 1

Characteristics of included studies.

CountryAuthors (year)YearSample sizeMain aimsStudy designSettingToolParticipantsPrevalence: % (n/N)
Brazil De Castro, S. H., et al (2014)NR150To assess the frequency of full and functional health illiteracyCross-sectionalHospital outpatients-TOFHLAMean age = 58.5 years (SD 9.8), 52.4%, female, 28.4%—less than high school education.26.7% (40/150)
BrazilSouza, J. G., et al (2014) 2012 129 To investigate the relationship between functional health literacy and glycaemic control in a sample of older patients Cross-sectional Hospital outpatient SAHLPA-18 Mean age = 75.9 years (SD 6.2), 69.8%, female, 82.9%—having less than a high-school diploma.56.6%(73/129)
Canada Al Sayah, F., et al (2015)NR154To examine the relationship of inadequate health literacy (HL) with changes in depressive symptoms, health-related quality of life and cardiometabolic outcomes in patients recently screened positive for depression.LongitudinalPrimary care clinicsBHLSMean age = 58.1 years (SD 9.4), 55.8%, female, 13.7%—less than high school15.6% (24/154)
Canada Sayah, F. A., et al (2016)20131948To examine the association of health literacy (HL) with changes in health-related quality of life (HRQL)LongitudinalPrimary care clinicsBHLSMean age = 65.6 years (SD 11.4), 45%, female, 14.2%—less than high school education.12.5%(244/ 1948)
Marshall Island Bohanny, W. M., et al (2013)2009150To explore the relationships among health literacy, self-efficacy, and self-care behaviorsCross-sectional studyPrimary care clinicss-TOFHLAMean age = 52.7 years (SD 10.5), 53.3%, female, 44%—less than high school24%(36/150)
South Korea Kim, S. H. (2009) 2007 53 To investigate the relationships of health literacy to chronic medical conditions and the functional health status Cross-sectional study Community based Korean Functional Health Literacy test Mean age = 67.2 years, 63.3%, female with limited literacy.37.7%(20/53)
Switzerland Franzen, J., et al (2014)2011493To measure functional HL among persons having type 2 diabetes and to investigate the relationship between functional HL and health care costs and utilizationCross-sectional studyInsurer’s databaseBHLSMean age = 67.5 years, 51.5% belongs to 65-70-year-old group, n = 391, 32.7%, female7.3%(36/493)
Switzerland Mantwill, S., et al (2015)2012391To determine the relationship between health literacy and three years of medication costsCross-sectional studyInsurer’s databaseBHLSMean age = 63.8 years (SD 6.1), 32.2%, female, 13.1%—less than high school education.8.7%(34/391)
Taiwan Chen, G. D., et al (2014) 2012 467 To demonstrate the interaction of health literacy and understanding of health education and instructions in achieving glycemic control Cross-sectional study Hospital outpatient MHLS Mean age = 68.3 years (SD 7.4), 70.2%, female with limited literacy, 61.5%—less than compulsory education47.3% (221/467)
Taiwan Tseng, H.-M., et al (2017)NR232To explore the mechanisms through which HL is associated with the health outcome of diabetic careCross-sectional studyHospital outpatientNVSMean age = 58.1 years (SD 9.49), 44.8%, female, 90.1%—secondary education and less76.3% (177/232)
Netherlands van der Heide, I., et al (2014) 2010 1676 To investigate whether diabetes knowledge can account for part of the relation between health literacy and diabetes self-management behaviour Cross-sectional study Primary care clinics BHLS 65–74 years group (31.7%), 49.6%, female, 44.9% low level of education9.8% (164/1676)
United States of America (USA) Schillinger, D., et al (2002)2000408To examine the association between health literacy and diabetes outcomesCross-sectional studyPrimary care clinicss-TOFHLAMean age = 62.7 years (SD 10.9), 58%, female, 46%—some high school education or less51.5% (210/408)
United States of America (USA) Rothman, R., et al (2004)2000111To examine the role of literacy in patients with poorly controlled diabetes who were participating in a diabetes management program that included low-literacy-oriented interventionCross-sectional studyHospital internal medicine clinicREALMMean age = 60 years, 56%, female has limited health literacy, 82%—less than high school education55%(61/111)
United States of America (USA) Laramee AS, et al (2007)2005998To determine the prevalence of limited literacy in diabetic patients with heart failure (HF) compared to those with diabetes and no HFCross-sectional studyPrimary care clinicss-TOFHLAMean age = 65 years (22–93), 54%, female, 25%—less than high school graduate.17.1% (171/998)
United States of America (USA) DeWalt, D. A., et al (2007)2005268To examine the relationship between literacy and trust, self-efficacy, and participation in medical decision makingCross-sectional studyHospital outpatientREALMMean age = 62 years (SD 10), 57%, female with limited health literacy.19.8% (53/268)
United States of America (USA) Aikens JE, Piette JD. (2009) 2007 1376 To determine how patients’ beliefs about antihyperglycemic and antihypertensive medications relate to medication underuse and health status. Cross-sectional study Primary care clinics BHLS Mean age = 55.3 years (SD 11.8), 61.6%, female, 21.6%—less than high school38.2% (525/1376)
United States of America (USA) Jeppesen KM, et al (2009)2007225To identify questions that could best indicate to a clinician that a patient may have low or marginal health literacyCross-sectional studyPrimary care clinicss-TOFHLAMean age = 53.8 years (SD 12.8), 68.4%, female, 44.9%—less than high school education.15.1% (34/225)
United States of America (USA) Mancuso, J. M. (2010) NR 98 To examine if health literacy and patient trust in one’s health-care provider impact glycemic control in an uninsured population Cross-sectional study Primary care clinics TOFHLA Mean age = 52 years (SD 9.1), 60.8%, female, 33.3%—Less than high school education.37.8%(37/98)
United States of America (USA) Mbaezue N, et al (2010)2005189To examine the relationship between health literacy and self-monitoring of blood glucose (SMBG)Cross-sectional studyHospital-based clinics-TOFHLAMean age = 51.2 years (SD 10.0), 58.7%, female, 32.3%—less than high school education.39.2% (74/189)
United States of America (USA) Wallace, A. S., et al (2010) 2008 195 To examine whether demographic characteristics, insurance status, literacy, duration of diabetes, and intensity of care management were associated with PACIC ratings Cross-sectional study Hospital diabetes clinic s-TOFHLA Mean age = 58 years (range: 23–85), 64%, female, 34%—Less than high school education.31.3% (61/195)
United States of America (USA) Bauer, A. M., et al (2013)20061366To determine whether health literacy limitations are associated with poorer antidepressant medication adherence.Cohort studyInsurer’s databaseBHLSMean age = 58.7 years (SD 10.5), 59.9%, female with limited Health literacy, 28.1%—less than high school72% (984/1366)
United States of America (USA) Bowen, M. E., et al (2013)2009144To describe the association among numeracy, total energy, and macronutrient intakeCross-sectional studyPrimary care clinicsREALMMedian age = 56 years, 53%, female, 26%—high school education or less11.1% (16/144)
United States of America (USA) Morris, N. S., et al (2013)2007751To evaluate the stability of health literacy over timeLongitudinal studyPrimary care clinicss-TOFHLA12% belong to 70 years old age group, 53%, female with limited health literacy, 70%—Some high school education.12.8% (96/751)
United States of America (USA) Mayberry, L. S., et al (2014)2012183To assess whether obstructive family behaviors had a stronger relationship with worse glycemic control among patients with limited HL than among those with adequate health literacyCross-sectional studyHospital outpatients-TOFHLAMean age = 51.2 years (SD 10.6), 70%, female, 64%—less than high school education26.2% (48/183)
United States of America (USA) Thurston, M. M., et al (2015)2013192To determine (1) if a relationship exists between health literacy and self-reported or objectively measured medication adherence and (2) which aspect or aspects of medication nonadherence are most associated with health literacyCross-sectional studyPrimary care clinicss-TOFHLAMean age = 54.4 years (SD 10.3), 56.8%, female, 64.6%—less than high school education32.8% (63/192)
United States of America (USA) Sayah, F. A., et al (2015)2010343To examine the associations between inadequate health literacy and behavioral and cardiometabolic parametersCross-sectional studyPrimary care clinicsBHLSMean age = 57.4 years (SD 10.11), 68%, female, 25%—less than high school education23.9%(82/343)
United States of America (USA) Goonesekera, S. D., et al (2015)2012682To examine racial/ethnic differences in receipt of hypoglycaemicmedications and glycaemic controlCross-sectional studyCommunity baseds-TOFHLA56% belongs to less than 65 years old group, 51%, female, 18%—less than high school.51.5% (351/682)
United States of America (USA) Fan, J. H., et al (2016)2014208To investigate the relationship between health literacy and overall medication nonadherence, unintentional nonadherence, and intentional nonadherenceCross-sectional studyPrimary care clinicsBHLSMean age = 53 years (SD10.9), 70.9%, female, 19%—had less than a high school education63.5% (132/208)
United States of America (USA) Nelson, L. A., et al (2016)NR80To examine the relationship between patient factors and engagement in an mHealth medication adherence promotion intervention for low-income adultsIntervention studyHospital outpatientBHLSMean age = 50.1 years (SD 10.5), 54%, female, 56.3%—less than a high school degree46.3%(37/80)
The Results section has also been affected by the errors in the extracted values. In the Included Studies subsection of the Results, there are errors in the second paragraph. The corrected paragraph should read: The study with the highest reported prevalence of limited health literacy (76.3%) was conducted to determine the mechanism through with health literacy exerted its influence on health outcomes related to diabetes care. It was a cross-sectional study involving 232 patients with T2DM attending regional hospital in Northern Taiwan. Health literacy was assessed using NVS. The mean age of the participants was 58.02 years (SD 9.49), 44.8% of participants were female, and 38.4% had received primary education or below. [55] The Pooled prevalence of limited HL: A meta-analysis subsection of the Results has also been affected and have been updated as a result. The corrected section should read: The pooled global prevalence of limited health literacy was 32.5% (95% CI: 24.9–40.1). Meta-analysis of all included studies yielded high heterogeneity (I2 = 99.3%, p < 0.001); which could primarily be explained by the country in which the study was conducted (p<0.001), the health literacy tool used (p = 0.002), participants’ education levels (p<0.001), and the setting where the study was conducted (p<0.001). Most of the included studies (n = 18) were conducted in the USA. Thirteen of these studies measured functional HL specifically, these studies were included in a separate meta-analysis and presented in a forest plot in Fig 4. The pooled prevalence of functional, limited health literacy in the USA was 34.5% (95% CI: 24.1–45), with a heterogeneity score of 99.1%. Meta-regression analysis identified two factors that predicted this heterogeneity, the study setting (p = 0.005) and the proportion of participants with more the high school education (p = 0.009).
Fig 4

Meta-analysis of functional HL studies in the USA.

(Refer Fig 4 Meta-analysis of functional HL studies in the USA.TIFF).

Figs 2 and 4 were also affected and have been updated as a result, please see the corrected figures here.
Fig 2

Worldwide prevalence of limited HL in patients with type 2 DM.

(Refer Fig 2_Worldwide prevalence of limited HL.TIFF).

Worldwide prevalence of limited HL in patients with type 2 DM.

(Refer Fig 2_Worldwide prevalence of limited HL.TIFF).

Meta-analysis of functional HL studies in the USA.

(Refer Fig 4 Meta-analysis of functional HL studies in the USA.TIFF).
  1 in total

1.  Prevalence of limited health literacy among patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus: A systematic review.

Authors:  Adina Abdullah; Su May Liew; Hani Salim; Chirk Jenn Ng; Karuthan Chinna
Journal:  PLoS One       Date:  2019-05-07       Impact factor: 3.240

  1 in total
  1 in total

1.  Psychometric properties of Persian version of diabetes health literacy scale (DHLS) in patients with type 2 diabetes.

Authors:  Mahdi Moshki; Ali Alami; Zohreh Zadehahmad; Mousa Ghelichi-Ghojogh; Mitra Dogonchi; Alireza Jafari
Journal:  Diabetol Metab Syndr       Date:  2022-09-27       Impact factor: 5.395

  1 in total

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.