Fen Wang1,2, Yirong Zhang1, Yixiang Wang1. 1. Department of Food Science and Agricultural Chemistry, McGill University, Ste Anne de Bellevue, Quebec H9X 3V9, Canada. 2. School of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, Sichuan University of Arts and Science, Dazhou, Sichuan 635000, China.
Abstract
Waste cotton sheets (WCS) are promising cellulose sources due to their high content of cellulose and large amount of disposal every year, which could be recycled and employed as low-cost structural materials. The present work aims at investigating the efficacy of hydrogel adsorbents prepared from regenerated WCS as the carriers of activated carbon (AC) for treating the dye-contaminated water. Activated WCS was directly dissolved in lithium chloride/N,N-dimethylacetamide (LiCl/DMAc) solvent and then regenerated into cellulose hydrogels, which were employed as three-dimensional biodegradable matrices for loading an extremely high content of AC (up to 5000%). The morphology and properties of resultant adsorbents were studied in detail. The results showed that different washing methods and contents of AC and cellulose had obvious effects on water contents, mechanical properties, and adsorption capacities of AC/WCS hydrogels. Especially, the hydrogels containing high AC content washed by gradient ethanol solvent exhibited outstanding compressive strengths of up to 3.0 MPa at 60% strain, while the adsorption capacity of 5000%AC/0.3CS toward a model dye methylene blue (MB, initial concentration of 200 mg/L) reached 174.71 mg/g at pH 6.9 and 35 °C. This was comparable to the adsorption capacity of original AC powders, while no AC powders were released from hydrogels to water. The adsorption of MB followed the Dubinin-Astakhov model and pseudo-first-order mechanism. Thermodynamic studies showed the spontaneous and endothermic nature of the overall physical adsorption process. Therefore, this work demonstrates the feasibility to recycle WCS into biodegradable carriers of functional compounds, and the AC/regenerated cellulose hydrogels have a high potential as a promising adsorbent with low-cost and convenient separation for dye removal from wastewater.
Waste cotton sheets (WCS) are promising cellulose sources due to their high content of cellulose and large amount of disposal every year, which could be recycled and employed as low-cost structural materials. The present work aims at investigating the efficacy of hydrogel adsorbents prepared from regenerated WCS as the carriers of activated carbon (AC) for treating the dye-contaminated water. Activated WCS was directly dissolved in lithium chloride/N,N-dimethylacetamide (LiCl/DMAc) solvent and then regenerated into cellulose hydrogels, which were employed as three-dimensional biodegradable matrices for loading an extremely high content of AC (up to 5000%). The morphology and properties of resultant adsorbents were studied in detail. The results showed that different washing methods and contents of AC and cellulose had obvious effects on water contents, mechanical properties, and adsorption capacities of AC/WCS hydrogels. Especially, the hydrogels containing high AC content washed by gradient ethanol solvent exhibited outstanding compressive strengths of up to 3.0 MPa at 60% strain, while the adsorption capacity of 5000%AC/0.3CS toward a model dye methylene blue (MB, initial concentration of 200 mg/L) reached 174.71 mg/g at pH 6.9 and 35 °C. This was comparable to the adsorption capacity of original AC powders, while no AC powders were released from hydrogels to water. The adsorption of MB followed the Dubinin-Astakhov model and pseudo-first-order mechanism. Thermodynamic studies showed the spontaneous and endothermic nature of the overall physical adsorption process. Therefore, this work demonstrates the feasibility to recycle WCS into biodegradable carriers of functional compounds, and the AC/regenerated cellulose hydrogels have a high potential as a promising adsorbent with low-cost and convenient separation for dye removal from wastewater.
About 25 million tons
of cotton cloth is produced and used throughout
the world every year, while a large amount of textile waste is generated
simultaneously.[1] Only a small portion of
waste cotton textile is used to produce mop, plush toys, and lower-grade
cotton textile, and the rest is disposed via landfill or incineration,
which cause serious environmental problems and are a great waste of
cotton resources. Therefore, the high value-added applications of
waste cotton textile have already become one of the hot topics in
the scientific field.[2] It is an interesting
objective to make use of cellulosic materials from such textile waste
to help reduce environmental problems. Because the content of cellulose
in cotton fibers is very high (upward 90%),[3−5] the recycle
of such cellulosic waste for the preparation of hydrogel adsorbents
is a suitable, low cost, and attractive substitute to conventional
disposal methods.[6]Every year, large
quantities of contaminated wastewater are released
into the environment by various industries, estimated to be around
70–200 tons per year.[7] Dyes are
an important source of pollution for the environment and aqueous solutions
for that they are used in a variety of industries such as textiles,
cosmetics, leather, food, plastic, rubber, and so forth. Discharged
dyes in wastewater pose significant threats to the aqueous environment
and human health and have an economic impact. Dyes, including their
degradation products, have complex structures that can be toxic to
humans and other living things and cause mutations and cancers.[8] Therefore, the removal of toxic dyes in wastewater
is an extremely urgent issue. Adsorption is considered a simple, low-cost,
and eco-friendly technology to remove such dyes.[9] Activated carbon (AC) is a porous carbon material produced
from raw vegetal or mineral materials by chemical or physical activation.
Because of its very high specific area (up to 2000 m2/g),
AC can be used as an adsorbent for various applications such as water
and gas treatments. Molecules belonging to different classes, such
as heavy metals and organics, can be removed by AC.[10] AC prepared from various precursors presented promising
adsorption performance in dye removal processes. For example, AC made
from rubber wood, oil palm waste, rubber wood sawdust, and sugar cane
bagasse showed a maximum adsorption capacity of 1176 mg/g for acid
blue 264,[11] 1845 mg/g for basic blue 1,[12] 1456 mg/g for Bismark Brown,[13] and 1060 mg/g for acid blue 25.[14] However, in practical application, AC powders cannot be easily handled
and separated from an aqueous solution, making subsequent operations
difficult and/or tedious.[15,16] When AC spreads into
the water, it could eventually turn into the secondary wastes. Adsorbents
with a suitable shape for easy operation are greatly required in industrial
applications. Therefore, embedding AC powders in a proper matrix could
maintain the high adsorption capacity of AC and restrict the mobility
of free powders.[9,15] Hydrogels may be good candidates
as matrices to fix AC by utilizing their characteristic features such
as good formability, good permeability, and ability of incorporation
of particles in their matrices.[9,17−19] In past decades, many researchers studied the combinations of polymers
with AC for water treatment, such as gelatin and AC (256.41 mg g–1 for Rhodamine B),[20] polyacrylonitrile
(PAN) and AC [187.79 mg g–1 for Cr(vi)],[21] chitosan and AC (1428 and 1370 mg g–1 for food blue 2 and food red 17, respectively),[22] and so forth. The AC powder can be immobilized in the hydrogels
without dispersing in the water. Hydrogels are crosslinked polymers
with a three-dimensional structure that can hold water in their structure.
The AC powder can be immobilized in the hydrogels without dispersing
in the water or impeding the adsorption of AC to the dyes.[23,24]For the purpose of sustainable development and environmental
protection,
the demand of renewable and biosustainable resources is increasing.[25,26] Hydrogels prepared from natural polymers have captured extensive
attention over the past decades because of their exceptional biocompatibility,
nontoxicity, ease of gelation, and low-cost.[17,27−29] Cellulose, the most abundant natural polymer on earth,
will become the main chemical resource in the future.[30] Cellulose having abundant hydroxyl groups can be used to
prepare hydrogels easily with fascinating structures and properties.
Therefore, cellulose hydrogels have been widely used in many applications
such as tissue engineering, agriculture, sensor, and water purification.[31] Compared with natural cellulose, waste cotton
fabrics are interestingly now on the rise due to the very high content
of cellulose in cotton fibers,[5] and it
is economical and eco-friendly to recycle such cellulosic wastes into
value-added products for a sustainable future.[2,32,33]In the past few decades, many researchers
have successfully prepared
hydrogel/additive composites for water purification; however, only
low levels of additives could be embedded in the hydrogels, probably
due to the poor network forming capacities. For example, AC powders
were 50% of total weight of polyacrylamide/AC hydrogel (PAAm-FAc);[34] the maximum weight ratio of powdered AC(PAC)
and carboxymethyl sago pulp (CMSP) in CMSP-PAC hydrogel was 10:1;[18] in cellulose acetate (CA) and AC composite membranes,
the highest AC content was 20% of CA content;[35] the AC content in cellulose/AC composite monolith was 50% of the
total composite;[9] in gelatin/AC composite
beads, the GC/AC weight ratio was 27:10;[20] and so forth. Regenerated cellulose can act as a reliable matrix
of AC.[15] To the best of our knowledge,
the research on recycling waste cotton sheets (WCS) as the carrier
of high amount of AC for dye removal has been seldom reported, which
will allow the improvement of adsorption capacity per unit volume
of adsorbents. This work aimed to develop cellulose hydrogels incorporated
with high AC content and evaluate their performances as adsorbents
for a model dye methylene blue (MB) adsorption from water, which could
promote the recycle of waste cotton textile and help reduce water
contaminants.In this work, WCS were selected as the raw material,
which was
dissolved in N,N-dimethylacetamide/lithium
chloride (DMAc/LiCl) solution and then regenerated into cellulose
hydrogels. This hydrogel matrix was used to fix AC powders for dye
adsorption from wastewater. Different regeneration baths were adopted
to investigate their effects on the morphology of hydrogels.[36] The obtained composite hydrogels were characterized
in relation to their structural characteristics and mechanical properties.
Adsorption experiments were conducted to examine the effects of adsorbent
dosage, pH, time, temperature, and initial dye concentration on the
adsorption of MB. Adsorption isotherms and kinetic parameters were
also evaluated in detail. Finally, the potential recyclability of
the hydrogels was also performed.
Results
and Discussion
Structure and Properties
of WCS/AC Hydrogels
Both 0.3 and 0.652 g of activated WCS
could be dissolved by 9%
DMAc/LiCl (30 mL), giving highly transparent solutions with good fluidity
(Figure c). The solution
formed with 0.3 g of WCS had a lower viscosity, and the fluidity decreased
when AC was added. The maximum amounts of AC that could be loaded
in the solutions were 2000% of 0.652 g of WCS and 5000% of 0.3 g of
WCS; otherwise, it was difficult to disperse the mixtures evenly by
a magnetic stirrer. Gels formed after regeneration (Figure e), and AC was fixed tightly
in the network. No AC powder was seen coming out from the gels when
washing or using the samples, which meant that the regenerated cellulose
hydrogels were a promising carrier. As far as we know, no other literature
has reported a matrix with such high content of additives.[15,23]
Figure 1
Photographs
of WCS (a), grinded WCS (b), transparent solution of
WCS dissolved in DMAc/LiCl (c), WCS/AC suspension (d), and WCS/AC
hydrogel (e).
Photographs
of WCS (a), grinded WCS (b), transparent solution of
WCS dissolved in DMAc/LiCl (c), WCS/AC suspension (d), and WCS/AC
hydrogel (e).Figure shows the
SEM images of hydrogel surfaces and cross section. AC powder with
various sizes and shapes was observed on the surfaces and interior
of hydrogels, which were glued together by regenerated cellulose.
The clump cavities resulted from rough surfaces could provide more
reactive sites and let the dye molecules penetrate to reach to internal
reactive sites during the adsorption process. The cross-sectional
images of AC2000%/WCS0.3 and AC1000%/WCS0.652 with low AC contents
are displayed in Figure a,e. The surface of AC particles was coated with WCS gel, and the
coating became thinner as the AC content increased or the WCS amount
reduced. The dye molecules are supposed to penetrate the thinner gel
coating more easily than the thick one to approach the internal reactive
sites.
Figure 2
SEM images of WCS/AC hydrogels (left – cross sections and
right - surfaces): AC2000%/WCS0.3 (a,b), AC5000%/WCS0.3 (c,d), AC1000%/WCS0.652
(e,f), and AC2000%/WCS0.652 (g,h).
SEM images of WCS/AC hydrogels (left – cross sections and
right - surfaces): AC2000%/WCS0.3 (a,b), AC5000%/WCS0.3 (c,d), AC1000%/WCS0.652
(e,f), and AC2000%/WCS0.652 (g,h).The X-ray diffraction patterns of AC, WCS, AC1000%/WCS0.652, and
AC5000%/WCS0.3 are shown in Figure . For AC powder, typical peaks appeared (one sharp
diffraction peak at 26° and one broad peak 43°), indicating
the turbostratic structure of disordered carbon.[37] It was noticed that WCS showed a sharp crystalline peak
at 22.7° (200) and two broad peaks at 14.8° (1 1(_) 0) and
16.4° (110), indicating a cellulose I crystalline structure.[25,38] The regenerated cellulose showed the characteristic diffraction
pattern of cellulose II at 2θ around 20–24° with
comparatively lower intensity and wider shape, which were attributed
to the (002) and (10 1(_)) lattice planes of cellulose II.[39] It was evident that the cellulose I structure
was completely lost during dissolution and regeneration. In AC5000%/WCS0.3
and AC1000%/WCS0.652, only diffraction pattern of AC was observed,
which may be because the characteristic peak of cellulose II was masked
by the high amount of AC embedded in the hydrogels. This was beneficial
for the adsorption because liquid was more likely to penetrate into
the cellulose II phase matrix.[40]
Figure 3
X-ray diffraction
patterns of AC, WCS, regenerated cellulose, and
AC1000%/WCS0.652 and AC5000%/WCS0.3 hydrogels.
X-ray diffraction
patterns of AC, WCS, regenerated cellulose, and
AC1000%/WCS0.652 and AC5000%/WCS0.3 hydrogels.During the cellulose regeneration process, DMAc and LiCl were replaced
by a cellulose nonsolvent that was miscible with the LiCl/DMAc solution
to trigger a phase separation. It was reported that polymer gels generally
shrink in the solvents with lower solubility parameters, and the use
of a solvent with high mutual affinity to the initial solvent can
retain the initial volume better in comparison with solvent with low
mutual affinity.[41] The utilization of water
and ethanol at different ratios can cause different degrees of shrinkage,
which will affect the structure and mechanical properties of hydrogels.
Therefore, the effect of three washing methods on water content and
mechanical properties was discussed. The water content defined here
can be seen as a measure for the efficiency of volume preservation
during the solvent washing. As shown in Figure a, all the samples treated with DI water
had the lowest water contents, while the water contents of hydrogels
treated by gradient ethanol washing were higher than those regenerated
in 20% ethanol solution. It was because of that ethanol has a higher
affinity to LiCl/DMAc solvent than water. In addition, regenerated
cellulose without AC [0.3WCS and 0.652WCS in Figure a (0.3 g or 0.652 g WCS dissolved in 60 mL
DMAc/LiCl solution)] had much higher water content than hydrogels
with AC, and hydrogels with low AC content had higher water content
than that with high AC content (AC1000%/WCS0.652 > AC2000%/WCS0.652,
AC2000%/WCS0.3 > AC5000%/WCS0.3). This may be because the AC powder
occupied more free volume of the gel matrix.
Figure 4
Water content (a) and
compressive strength (b) of regenerated cellulose
hydrogels prepared by different washing methods. Different asterisks
on the top of columns represent significant differences among different
washing methods (p < 0.05).
Water content (a) and
compressive strength (b) of regenerated cellulose
hydrogels prepared by different washing methods. Different asterisks
on the top of columns represent significant differences among different
washing methods (p < 0.05).Good mechanical properties (such as compressive strength) of a
hydrogel are the prerequisites of an adsorbent with excellent recyclability
and wet stability.[42] The compressive strength
at 60% strain of the hydrogels prepared by three different washing
solvents is shown in Figure b. No fracture was observed when the samples were subjected
to 60% strain, which indicated that the regenerated cellulose matrix
could not only fix powder form additives but also provide necessary
flexibility for handling. The hydrogels treated with DI water had
the highest compressive strength, followed by the samples washed with
20% ethanol and gradient ethanol solutions. For hydrogels undergoing
the same washing method, the compressive strength of regenerated cellulose
without AC (0.3WCS and 0.652WCS) were much lower than hydrogels with
AC and it increased remarkably with the increase in AC content. For
example, the compressive strength of AC2000%/WCS0.652 (2.76 MPa) was
approximately 3 times as high as that of AC1000%/WCS0.652 (0.97 MPa),
while the compressive strength of AC5000%/WCS0.3 (3.01 MPa) was about
10 times as high as that of AC2000%/WCS0.3 (0.31 MPa). In addition,
when no AC or AC content was relatively low (0.3WCS, 0.652WCS, AC1000%/WCS0.652,
and AC2000%/WCS0.3), the hydrogels with higher WCS content had higher
compressive strength than those with lower WCS content. The regenerated
cellulose formed a three-dimensional network in the hydrogels that
could resist the compressive deformation, and the higher WCS content
resulted in a denser and stronger network. Furthermore, increasing
the AC content in the hydrogels also improved their compressive strength.[43] It could be explained that adding AC into cellulose
matrix improved the stress transfer properties between the hydrogels
and AC. Additionally, the resistance created by AC was also favorable
for reducing the hydrogel deformability.[17,44,45] However, the compressive strength of AC2000%/WCS0.652
and AC5000%/WCS0.3 had no significant difference, which indicated
that a large amount of AC played a crucial role in enhancing the strength
of hydrogels.[46]
Adsorption
of MB
Based on the consideration
of mechanical strength and amounts of cellulose and active adsorption
sites, AC5000%/WCS0.3 washed by gradient ethanol solutions was selected
for the dye adsorption tests. The effects of various parameters, such
as contact time, adsorption temperature, solution pH, and initial
dye concentration, on the removal efficiency of hydrogel toward MB
were investigated by batch experiments. An example is shown in Figure that a piece of
hydrogel could convert the dark blue solution into colorless.
Figure 5
Photograph
of dye solutions before (left) and after (right) the
adsorption process (0.16 g AC5000%/WCS0.3, 25 mL MB solution with
initial concentrate of 200 mg L–1, 38 h, 35 °C).
Photograph
of dye solutions before (left) and after (right) the
adsorption process (0.16 g AC5000%/WCS0.3, 25 mL MB solution with
initial concentrate of 200 mg L–1, 38 h, 35 °C).
Effect of pH on MB Adsorption
The
effect of pH on MB adsorption is shown in Figure . It was reported that the transition of
pH could change the net charge on the gel surface and affect the adsorption
capacity.[15] The qe values of hydrogels increased from 157.6 to 168.5 mg/g when
the pH value of solution changed from 4.0 to 7.0, and the pHzpc of cellulose hydrogels with AC was reported to be approximately
6.7.[15] It implied that the surface charges
of hydrogels became positive when the solution pH was lower than pHzpc, resulting in stronger repulsion toward cationic MB molecules
and lower MB removal.[15,47] However, the adsorption capacity
at pH 4 was still high, indicating that the electrostatic interaction
did not dominate the sorption mechanism of MB on the hydrogels.
Figure 6
Effect of pH
on MB adsorption with AC5000%/WCS0.3. Different asterisks
on the top of the columns indicate the significant difference (p < 0.05).
Effect of pH
on MB adsorption with AC5000%/WCS0.3. Different asterisks
on the top of the columns indicate the significant difference (p < 0.05).Because the effect of
pH values above 7.0 on the adsorption capacity
of hydrogel was negligible and the pH of the original MB solution
was around 7.0, no pH adjustment was performed in the subsequent experiments.
The removal rates were around 70% at different pH values, indicating
that the obtained qe values were the saturation
adsorption capacities of AC/WCS hydrogel.
Effect
of Temperature on MB Adsorption
The effect of temperature
on adsorption capacity is displayed in Figure . It was found that
both the qe values and dye removal rates
obviously increased when the temperature changed from 15 to 35 °C,
which suggested that dye adsorption became more favorable at higher
temperatures. It is widely known that the increment of temperature
may accelerate the mobility of dye molecules and enhance the interactions
between adsorbate and adsorbent by giving sufficient energy.[48] Moreover, at a higher temperature, the internal
structure of hydrogels might swell to enable the passage of dye molecules,
resulting in an increase of MB adsorption.[49] However, there was no significant difference when the temperature
further increased to 45 °C.
Figure 7
Effect of temperature on MB adsorption
with AC5000%/WCS0.3. Different
asterisks on the top of the columns indicate the significant difference
(p < 0.05).
Effect of temperature on MB adsorption
with AC5000%/WCS0.3. Different
asterisks on the top of the columns indicate the significant difference
(p < 0.05).
Thermodynamic Study
To further
understand the effect of temperature on the adsorption process, thermodynamic
parameters, such as standard free energy (ΔG°), enthalpy (ΔH°), and entropy (ΔS°), were determined using the following equationswhere R (J/mol K) is the
gas constant, T (K) is the absolute temperature,
ΔG° (kJ/mol) is Gibbs free energy changes, ΔS° (J/mol K) is entropy changes, and ΔH° (kJ/mol) is enthalpy changes. k (L mg–1) is the ratio of qe to Ce(50)As reported in Table , the negative values of ΔG° implied
that the adsorption process of hydrogels happened spontaneously and
was thermodynamically favorable. In addition, the changes in free
energy could predict the adsorption behavior. The physisorption takes
place when the ΔG° value is within the range
between −20 and 0 kJ/mol, while chemisorption occurs in the
range of −400 to −80 kJ/mol.[50,51] Therefore, physical interactions were mainly involved in the adsorption
of MB on AC/WCS hydrogels. With the rise in temperature, ΔG° decreased accordingly, illustrating more driving forces
and thereby resulting in higher adsorption capacity.[52] Typically, ΔH° for physical adsorption
ranges from 4 to 40 kJ/mol, while that of chemical adsorption varies
from 40 to 800 kJ/mol.[53] The positive ΔH° value also dictated that the adsorption was physical
and endothermic.[54] The value of ΔS° was positive, revealing an increment of randomness at
the adsorbent/adsorbate interface during the adsorption of MB on hydrogels.
All these results were consistent with the other reported dye adsorption
on AC,[52,55−59] which indicated that the incorporation of high amount
of AC in regenerated cellulose matrix did not affect the adsorption
behavior.
Table 1
Thermodynamic Parameters of MB Adsorption
on AC5000%/WCS0.3
ΔG° (kJ mol–1)
ΔH° (kJ mol–1)
ΔS° (J mol–1 K–1)
288 K
298 K
333 K
–2.257
–3.027
–3.738
19.081
74.080
Effect
of Contact Time and Kinetic Studies
The plots of adsorption
capacity and removal rate of AC1000%/WCS0.652,
AC2000%/WCS0.652, AC2000%/WCS0.3, and AC5000%/WCS0.3 against contact
time are displayed in Figure . The adsorption of MB on four hydrogels was all fast in the
beginning and then gradually reached equilibrium after 15 h. The initial
adsorption rates of AC5000%/WCS0.3 and AC2000%/WCS0.652 were faster
than those of AC2000%/WCS0.3 and/WCSAC1000%/WCS0.652, respectively,
suggesting that the adsorption rate increased with the AC content.
In addition, the adsorption rate of AC5000%/WCS0.3 was also faster
than that of AC2000%/WCS0.652, showing that the higher ratio of cellulose
in the hydrogels slowed down the adsorption of MB. It might be because
the AC particles were wrapped with the cellulose gel matrix, which
affected the efficient contact of dye molecules to the adsorption
sites of AC, and the higher cellulose ratio in the hydrogels enlarged
this effect.
Figure 8
Effect of contact time on MB adsorption with AC/WCS hydrogels.
Effect of contact time on MB adsorption with AC/WCS hydrogels.In order to elucidate the adsorption mechanism,
three kinetic models,
pseudo-first order (PFO), pseudo-second order (PSO), and intraparticle
diffusion (IPD) models were used to analyze the MB adsorption behavior
on AC/WCS hydrogels. The fitting curves of experimental data are shown
in Figure a,b, and
the kinetic models’ parameters of MB adsorption are summarized
in Table . Although
the experimental data were fitted well with both PFO and PSD models
(R2 > 0.98), the PFO model showed higher R2 value than the PSO model, and the qe values calculated by the PFO model were closer
to the measured qe,exp values, indicating
that the PFO model better explained the adsorption process. The IPD
constants kid1, kid2, and kid3 describe the diffusion
rates at different stages of the adsorption process (Table ), which followed the trend kid1 > kid2 > kid3. The first stage corresponded to the rapid
diffusion (kid1) of large amounts of dye
molecules (>50%) from the bulk dye solution to the surface of the
adsorbent. The second subdued portion was the slow adsorption stage,
where IPD was rate-controlled.[60] However,
it could be found that none of the plots gave a linear straight line
passing through the origin (C≠0). Therefore, the IPD was involved
but not the only rate-controlling step for the adsorption of MB onto
AC/WCS hydrogels. As discussed above, the adsorption process was also
affected by the transport of dye molecules through the regenerated
cellulose gel matrix, where the higher ratio of cellulose in the hydrogels
resulted in a slower adsorption rate.
Figure 9
Adsorption kinetic of MB on AC/WCS hydrogels:
(a–d) pseudo-first-order
and pseudo-second-order, and (e) intraparticle diffusion.
Table 2
Kinetic Parameters of MB Adsorption
on AC/WCS Hydrogels
samples
pseudo-first-order
pseudo-second-order
intraparticle diffusion model
experimental
qe (mg g–1)
k1 (h–1)
R2
qe (mg g–1)
k2 (g mg–1 h1)
R2
kip
cip
R2
qe,exp(mg g–1)
AC5000%/WCS0.3
145.2
0.2007
0.9903
173.1
0.0013
0.9922
25.32
25.30
0.8585
148.6
AC2000%/WCS0.3
141.5
0.1611
0.9946
173.8
0.0010
0.9893
26.12
13.07
0.8769
141.9
AC2000%/WCS0.625
135.6
0.1792
0.9953
164.3
0.0012
0.9897
24.60
17.20
0.8580
137.1
AC1000%/WCS0.625
102.1
0.2072
0.9924
121.6
0.0019
0.9835
17.74
18.40
0.8145
101.9
Table 3
Kinetic Parameters
of the Intraparticle
Diffusion Model
samples
intraparticle diffusion model
C1 (mg g–1)
kip1 (mg g–1 h–1)
R12
C1 (mg g–1)
kip2 (mg g–1 h–1)
R22
C3 (mg g–1 h–1)
kip3 (mg g–1 h–1)
R32
AC5000%/WCS0.3
–1.54
38.91
0.9823
116.85
5.73
0.9875
-
-
-
AC2000%/WCS0.3
–12.17
38.86
0.9843
104.55
6.73
0.9852
-
-
-
AC2000%/WCS0.625
–16.15
42.34
0.9928
52.63
19.33
0.9966
106.51
5.15
0.9576
AC1000%/WCS0.625
–10.42
33.21
0.9614
17.99
21.87
0.9604
96.58
0.88
0.9208
Adsorption kinetic of MB on AC/WCS hydrogels:
(a–d) pseudo-first-order
and pseudo-second-order, and (e) intraparticle diffusion.
Adsorption Isotherm
Generally,
at fixed dye concentrations, the removal rate (%) of adsorption increased
with adsorbent dose (Figure ), and mainly hinged on the availability of adsorption sites.
A dramatic positive impact of adsorbent dosage was indicated on the
MB removal with approximately a linear relationship. However, when
the dosage increased, the adsorption capacity (mg/g) deceased significantly,
consequence of the unsaturation of adsorption sites during the adsorption
process.[54] Cellulose has interactions with
ionic dyes,[61,62] but the adsorption capacity of
regenerated cellulose toward MB (Figure f) was much lower compared to WCS/AC hydrogels
(Figure a–d).
The maximum qe within the range of experimental
conditions was 8.35 mg/g and the removal rate was 6.66% at an initial
concentration of 10 mg/L (Figure f). It was worth noting that, although the existence
of regenerated cellulose matrix affected the efficient contact of
MB molecules to the adsorption sites, the adsorption capacity of AC5000/WCS0.3
was close to that of original AC powders (Figure b,e). This small difference
indicated that the regenerated cellulose hydrogels from WCS could
be used as an effective matrix to immobilize AC to treat dye-contaminated
water.
Figure 10
Effect of adsorbent dose on qe (mg/g)
and removal rate of MB adsorption on hydrogels, AC, and regenerated
cellulose.
Effect of adsorbent dose on qe (mg/g)
and removal rate of MB adsorption on hydrogels, AC, and regenerated
cellulose.Least-square plots of the (a) Langmuir,
(b) Freundlich, (c) Redlich–Peterson,
(d) Sips, (e) Dubinin–Radushkevich, and (f) Dubinin–Astakhov
isotherm for the adsorption of MB on AC/WCS hydrogels.The values of maximum adsorption capacities (qm), correlation coefficients (R2), and other constant parameters for the six isotherm model equations
for the adsorption process at 35 °C are summarized in Table . In general, R2 obtained by the adsorption data fitting of
Redlich–Peterson (R–P), Sips, and Dubinin–Astakhov
(D–A) models were superior to the other three models [Langmuir,
Freundlich, and Dubinin–Radushkevich (D–R)]. Sips isotherm
is a combined form of Langmuir and Freundlich expressions and their
high values of R2 (>0.94) indicated
the
heterogeneous adsorption systems of MB-hydrogels.[63] The R–P model integrates elements from the Langmuir
and Freundlich equations and their good fitting inferred that the
adsorption did not follow an ideal monolayer mechanism.[64,65] The D–A isotherm model has the same basis as the D–R
model and is more flexible than the DR equation. The excellent fitting
of D–A indicated that the hydrogels had a high degree of heterogeneity
due to their main adsorption component of carbonaceous solids.[66] The value of E obtained in
the D–R isotherm was found to be lower than 3 kJ mol–1 for all the hydrogels. It suggested that the adsorption mechanism
was physical in nature.[67] The qm values of AC5000%/WCS0.3 obtained from Sips and D–A
models were very close to that of original AC powders and were the
highest among four hydrogels. It indicated that the regenerated cellulose
matrix was capable to hold a high amount of AC powders while not affecting
their adsorption capacity.
Table 4
Isotherm Values for
the Adsorption
of MB onto AC/WCS Hydrogels
samples
Langmuir
Freundlich
Redlich–Peterson
qm (mg g–1)
KL (L mg–1)
R2
KF (mg g–1)
n
R2
Q0 (L mg–1)
KRP (L g–1)
β
R2
AC5000%/WCS0.3
167.61
0.740
0.9607
96.72
7.92
0.9322
196.63
1.497
0.942
0.9878
AC2000%/WCS0.3
157.53
1.339
0.8794
113.19
13.96
0.8077
331.23
2.407
0.968
0.9202
AC2000%/WCS0.625
151.76
0.8672
0.9268
96.18
9.59
0.8893
230.16
1.891
0.948
0.9674
AC1000%/WCS0.625
100.42
0.708
0.9111
80.70
22.57
0.8812
122.72
1.353
0.980
0.9381
Comparison with Other
Adsorbents
The adsorption capacity of MB by AC5000%/WCS 0.3
and other reported
composite adsorbents are listed in Table . The hydrogel prepared in this work was
found to be competitive with other forms of adsorbents. This clearly
indicated that the coupling of regenerated cellulose from WCS with
a high amount of AC could produce a promising adsorbent for MB removal
from aqueous solution, because it possessed a dominant adsorption
performance and was easy to recover and reuse.
Table 5
Maximum Adsorption Capacities of MB
with Various Composite Adsorbents
WCS was successfully recycled into a three-dimensional
matrix to
fix a high amount of AC by a simple and facile method. The obtained
hydrogel was an efficient adsorbent with a good handling property
for wastewater treatment. The water content and compressive strength
of AC/WCS hydrogels with relatively low AC content were affected obviously
by regeneration methods, where the regeneration bath with higher affinity
to LiCl/DMAc resulted in higher water content and lower strength.
However, these properties of AC/WCS hydrogels with high AC content
were mainly determined by the incorporation of AC powder because a
large amount of AC was filled in the free volume of cellulose hydrogel
and supported the matrix. The regenerated cellulose hydrogel matrix
could hold and prevent the release of AC powder during adsorption
process but also slightly affected the efficient contact of MB molecules
to the adsorption sites. The maximum MB adsorption capacity of AC5000%/WCS
0.3 hydrogel reached 174.71 mg/g with the dye concentration of 200
mg/L, original solution pH of 6.9, at 35 °C for 24 h, which was
comparable to the adsorption capacity of free AC powder. Adsorption
of MB was best described by the Dubinin–Astakhov model and
pseudo-first-order mechanism. Thermodynamic studies showed the spontaneous
and endothermic nature of the overall physical adsorption process.
Materials and Methods
Reagents and Materials
WCS were collected
from a second-hand market located in Montreal, Canada. The white old
bed sheet contains 90–95% cellulose and a few percent of hemicellulose.[3,4] AC, MB trihydrate, LiCl, DMAc, acetone, and ethanol were purchased
from Fisher Scientific (Mississauga, Canada). LiCl was dried at 200
°C for 1 h and DMAc was heated at 110 °C for 10 min to remove
water before use.
Preparation of WCS/AC Hydrogels
LiCl
(5.2 g) was added into 60 mL of water-free DMAc and stirred at 110
°C until dissolved, and then, the solution was cooled down to
80 °C. WCS was smashed into short floss without further purification
or bleaching. For a better dissolution in DMAc/LiCl, WCS was activated
by solvent exchange (H2O, acetone, and DMAc). After that,
activated WCS (0.652 and 0.3 g) was added into a 60 mL DMAc/LiCl solution
and stirred overnight until transparent solutions were formed. Desired
amounts of AC were added into WCS/DMAc/LiCl solutions, stirred evenly,
and casted into cylindrical molds to form hydrogels by replacing DMAc/LiCl
with water and ethanol at different ratios. The gels were regenerated
in three different baths: deionized water, 20% ethanol aqueous solution,
and gradient ethanol solutions (a multistep soaking in ethanol/water
mixtures with increasing concentrations of ethanol: water = 10:0,
8:2, 6:4, 4:6, 2:8, and 0:10, v/v). The hydrogels regenerated with
ethanol were further soaked in water to remove ethanol. The hydrogels
were coded as AC2000%/WCS0.3, AC5000%/WCS0.3, AC1000%/WCS0.652, and
AC2000%/WCS0.652. For example, AC2000%/WCS0.3 was prepared by adding
6 g of AC (2000% of WCS dry weight) and 0.3 g of WCS.
Characterization
The morphologies
of hydrogels were observed by scanning electron microscopy (SEM, Hitachi
TM-1000, Japan) and the samples were gold/platinum coated (Leica EM
ACE200, Germany). The crystal phases of AC, AC1000%/WCS0.652 and AC5000%/WCS0.3,
were studied and compared using an X-ray diffractometer (D8 Discovery,
Bruker, Germany) equipped with Cu Kα radiation (λ = 0.1542
nm). The compressive test was performed on cellulose hydrogels (cylinder
with diameter of 4.0 mm and thickness of 4.0 mm, three replicates
per each sample) at a rate of 0.4 mm/min by a compact tabletop universal
tester (Instron 5965, USA) with a 10 N load cell. The water contents
of hydrogels were determined gravimetrically by freeze-drying, which
were defined as the ratios of the differences in weights of original
hydrogel mw and dry hydrogel md relative to the original hydrogel weight mwwhere mw (g) is
the weight of the wet gel, and md (g)
is the weight of the dried gel.
Dye Adsorption
The adsorption efficiency
of AC/WCS hydrogels toward methylene blue (MB) was investigated by
batch methods. Kinetic experiments were carried out with 0.35 g of
hydrogels and 300 mL of MB solutions (200 mg L–1) in a magnetically stirring-beaker at room temperature. At desired
time intervals (0–38 h), the remaining amounts of MB in the
aqueous solutions were determined by using a UV–vis spectrometer
(GE Ultrospec 2100 pro, USA) at the wavelength of
663 nm. In the adsorption experiments of regenerated cellulose to
MB, the original MB concentration was set to 10 mg/L. To evaluate
the thermodynamic properties, adsorption isotherms were determined
at 288, 298, 308, and 318 K, respectively, in a thermostatic orbital
shaker for 38 h. The effect of pH (pH 4–9) on the adsorption
of MB was investigated with the initial MB concentration of 200 mg
L–1. The pH values of MB aqueous solutions were
adjusted by 0.1 M HNO3 or 0.1 M NaOH solutions. The adsorption
isotherm was measured by adding different amounts of hydrogels (0.02–0.16
g) in 25 mL of MB (200 mg L–1) solutions. Both tests
were performed at 35 °C in a thermostatic orbital shaker for
38 h. All the adsorption tests were conducted in triplicates.The amounts of MB absorbed were calculated by the following equationwhere qe (mg g–1) is the amount of MB adsorbed
per gram of the dry
adsorbent, V (mL) is the MB solution volume, C0 (mg L–1) and Ce (mg L–1) are the initial and equilibrium
concentrations of MB in the solution, respectively, and m (g) is the weight of the dry adsorbent.Removal rate of MB
was calculated by the following equationThe adsorption isotherms of MB were fitted by nonlinear equations
of Langmuir (eq ), Freundlich
(eq ), Redlich–Peterson
(eq ), Sips (eq ), Dubinin–Radushkevich
(eq ), and Dubinin–Astakhov
(eq ) models which
are presented as follows:where qm (mg g–1) is the maximum amount of the adsorption, kL (L mg–1) is the Langmuir
adsorption constant, and n and kF (mg g–1) are the Freundlich adsorption
constants. KRP (L mg–1), αRP, and β are the Redlich–Peterson
parameters. ks is the Sips isotherm model
constant and ms is the Sips isotherm model exponent.
βD is a constant related to the mean free energy
of adsorption per mole of the adsorbate (mol2 J–2), ε is the Polanyi potential given by the relation ε
= RTln(1 + 1/Ce), R (J mol–1 K–1) is the
gas constant, and T (K) is the absolute temperature.
The constant βD gives an idea about the mean free
energy E (kJ mol–1) of adsorption
per molecule of the adsorbate when it is transferred to the surface
of the solid from the relationshipED (kJ/mol) is
the characteristic energy associated to the given working pair. b
is a heterogeneity parameter, considering the surface structure of
the sorbent material. When b = 2, the Dubinin–Astakhov
equation is referred to as the Dubinin–Radushkevich equation.Kinetics data were represented by the PFO model, PSO model, and
IPD model, given as followswhere k (h–1) is the PFO model rate constant, k2 (g
mg–1 h–1) is the PSO model rate
constant, kid (mg g–1 h–0.5) is the IPD rate
constant, and C (mg g–1) is the
intercept and related to the thickness of the boundary layer.
Statistical Analysis
Statistical
evaluation was carried out by analysis of variance (ANOVA), followed
by multiple-comparison tests using Duncan’s multiple-range
test at the 95% confidence level. All the analyses were conducted
using SPSS statistical software (version 22.0, IBM, New York, USA)
with a probability of p < 0.05 considered to be
significant.
Authors: Soumitra Ghorai; Asish Sarkar; Mohammad Raoufi; Asit Baran Panda; Holger Schönherr; Sagar Pal Journal: ACS Appl Mater Interfaces Date: 2014-03-21 Impact factor: 9.229