| Literature DB >> 34946251 |
Emilia Moreno-Sánchez1, Estefanía Castillo-Viera2, Emilia Vélez-Moreno3, Francisco-Javier Gago-Valiente4.
Abstract
A systematic review of the literature was conducted to analyse the factors that affect the probability of the paediatric asthma population suffering from COVID-19 or SARS-CoV-2, such as asthma phenotypes, inhaled corticosteroids, and the effects of lockdown. This systematic review was based on PRISMA guidelines. A bibliographic search was conducted using BNE, BVS (LILAC), CSIC (IME, ISOC), IBECS, Scielo, Scopus, Medline, and PubMed, using the following search profile: (COVID-19 or 2019-NCOV or SARS-CoV-2 or COV-19) AND asthma AND (children or adolescents or youths or children or teenagers). The results were limited to those articles published between December 2019 and December 2020, selecting only articles published in Spanish, English and French that included the study population (children aged 0-18 years). Among the 1066 results of the bibliographic search and seven articles selected from a manual search, only 19 articles were found to fit our eligibility criteria. Most of the articles highlight the effects of lockdown on the paediatric asthma population, increased therapeutic compliance, and the role of inhaled corticosteroids and intrinsic factors such as ACE2 receptors as causes of the decreased prevalence of COVID-19 among the paediatric asthma population. This population has unique characteristics that serve as protective factors against COVID-19. The safety measures implemented during the lockdown period along with inhaled corticosteroid treatment also contributed to this protection.Entities:
Keywords: COVID-19; SARS-Cov-2; asthma; coronavirus; paediatric population; paediatrics
Mesh:
Year: 2021 PMID: 34946251 PMCID: PMC8706787 DOI: 10.3390/medicina57121306
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Medicina (Kaunas) ISSN: 1010-660X Impact factor: 2.430
Figure 1PRISMA flow diagram.
Summary ofsystematic review results.
| Name | Country | Date of Publication | Type of Study | Variables/Objectives | Results |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ciprandi G et al., 2020 [ | Italy | September 2020 | Letter to the Editor | n.s. a | Decreased prevalence of asthma in patients with COVID-19. |
| Krivec U et al., 2020 [ | Slovenia | August 2020 | Observational data analysis | Admissions for asthma andrespiratory infections, NO2 concentration and concentration of particulate matter in the air. | A decrease in the number of admissions for asthma and respiratory infections than other years in children is attributable to improved air quality due to confinement and compliance with safety measures. None of the children admitted were COVID19 positive. |
| Muñoz X et al., 2020 [ | Spain | n.s. a | Letter to the Editor | n.s. a | Asthma is not associated with the risk of contracting COVID-19. No relationship is found between the dose of inhaled corticosteroids and COVID-19 severity. A decrease in the severity of COVID-19 disease is observed in patients with a Th2 phenotype. |
| Morais Almeida M et al., 2020 [ | n.s. a | June 2020 | Systematic review | In patients with SARS-CoV-2: Asthma, comorbidities, hospitalisation, epidemiology. | Asthmatic children are not at risk for SARS-CoV-2. Inhaled corticosteroids are beneficial in protecting against the current coronavirus, as opposed to systemic corticosteroids. Th2 inflammation may be related to a better prognosis. |
| Halpin DMG and Cols, 2020 [ | n.s. a | April 2020 | Observational data analysis | Prevalence of asthmatic patients with COVID, inhaled corticosteroid use. | The underdiagnosis hypothesis and the modified immune response hypothesis are rejected in favour of inhaled corticosteroids. |
| Castro Rodriguez JA et al., 2020 [ | n.s. a | June 2020 | Systematic review | SARS-CoV-2, wheezing, asthma, children (0–18 years). | We identify an underrepresentation of children in the studies reviewed. Asthmatics could be protected against COVID for various reasons: inhaled corticosteroids, changes in the immune response, or underdiagnosis of this pathology. |
| Oreskovic NM et al., 2020 [ | United States | May 2020 | n.s. a | ED visits by paediatric asthmatic patients, air quality, therapeutic adherence. | Decrease in emergency room visits of paediatric asthmatic patients. |
| Chavasse RJ et al., 2020 [ | United Kingdom | July 2020 | Letter to the Editor | n.s. a | Decreased asthmatic attendance to emergency departments due to therapeutic adherence, improved air quality, and confinement. |
| To T et al., 2020 [ | n.s. a | June 2020 | n.s. a | Proposed actions to address COVID-19 for people with respiratory pathologies. | Decrease in Prevalence ofCOVID19in asthmatics. Proposal for improving the health care of this group. |
| Farne H et al., 2020 [ | United Kingdom | n.s. a | Letter to the Editor | n.s. a | Asthmatic children have a specific phenotype that protects from SARS-CoV-2. |
| Papadopoulos NG et al., 2020 [ | n.s. a | September 2020 | Online survey | To describe the impact of COVID-19 on asthmatic patients and hospital services. | Asthmatic children are notdisproportionately affected. No support for stringent confinement measures in this population. |
| Creese H y cols, 2020 [ | United Kingdom | November 2020 | n.s. a | n.s. a | In favour of inhaled corticosteroids. Rhinoviruses associated with the majority of asthmatic exacerbations. |
| Hanon S et al., 2020 [ | Belgium | n.s. a | Observational study | To evaluate the incidence of COVID-19 in patients with severe asthma. | Asthmatic patients are not at risk of SARS-CoV2. |
| Hepkaya E et al., 2020 [ | Turkey | September 2020 | Population survey | To assess the current status of asthmatics during the pandemic. | Evidence in favour of decreased prevalence of COVID19 in the asthmatic population and the beneficial use of inhaled corticosteroids. |
| Kabesch M, 2020 [ | Germany | July 2020 | Letter to the Editor | n.s. a | There is no justification for extreme safety measures in asthmatic children. |
| Abrams EM et al., 2020 [ | n.s. a | September 2020 | State-of-the-art | Paediatric asthma review and COVID-19. | A lower concentration of ACE2 receptors protects asthmatics. |
| Camiolo M et al., 2020 [ | United States | May 2020 | Cohort Study | Use of various clinical parameters relevant to the study of ACE2 receptors. | Increased ACE2 receptors are associated with a worse prognosis. |
| Ruano FJ et al., 2020 [ | Spain | October 2020 | n.s. a | n.s. a | Asthmatic children have milder forms of COVID-19 disease. |
| Schultze A et al., 2020 [ | United Kingdom | September 2020 | Cohort Study | Patients with asthma or COPD, treatment with corticoids or longacting Beta agonists or LAMA/LABA. | Increased mortality was found in patients taking inhaled corticosteroids, attributed to confounding variables. |
a n.s.: not specified.The data shown in the table are grouped into four dimensions, described below.
Prevalence of paediatric asthma in COVID-19 studies.
| Location/Name of Study | Country | Results |
|---|---|---|
| South Lombardy and Liguria Hospitals [ | Italy | Of 52 paediatric patients, only 1 had asthma (2%). |
| Ljubljana Children’s Hospital [ | Slovenia | 71% to 78% decrease in asthma admissions compared to previous years. |
| Servei de Pneumologia Hospital Valld’Hebron [ | Spain | Of 2226 hospitalised patients, only 3.2% were asthmatic. |
| Children’s Hospital, Wuhan [ | China | Of 171 paediatric patients with COVID, none were asthmatic. |
| Hubei Province [ | China | Of 25 paediatric patients with COVID, none were asthmatic. |
| Confidence Study [ | Italy | Of 100 paediatric patients with COVID, none were asthmatic. |
| COVID-19 in Children [ | USA | Asthma was the most frequent comorbidity. |
| Massachusetts General Hospital [ | USA | The number of emergency department visits by asthmatic patients decreased by 38.8% and 84.8% during March and April 2020, respectively. |
| St George’s University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust [ | United Kingdom | 90% decrease in asthma admissions. |