Ali Ghamari1, Parviz Pakzad2, Ahmad Majd1, Marzieh Ebrahimi3, Amir Ali Hamidieh4. 1. Department of Cellular and Molecular Biology, Faculty of Biological Sciences, North Tehran Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran. 2. Department of Microbiology, Faculty of Biological Sciences, North Tehran Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran. 3. Department of Stem Cells and Developmental Biology, Cell Science Research Centre, Royan Institute for Stem Cell Biology and Technology, ACECR, Tehran, Iran. 4. Pediatric Cell and Gene Therapy Research Center, Gene, Cell and Tissue Research Institute, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran. Email: aahamidieh@tums.ac.ir.
Current research intends to redirect the immune system
for specific recognition of transformed cells to cure
cancers. The genetic engineering of protein structures
such as immune cell antigen receptors has led to the
production of chimeric antigen receptors (CARs) (1) and
bispecific CARs that could redirect T cells to interact with
specific targets on transformed cells (2, 3).Acute myeloid leukaemia (AML) is a poor prognosis
disease with a five-year survival rate below 50%. Although
the treatments cause remission in the majority of patients,
most relapse and require subsequent chemotherapy or
hematopoietic stem cell transplant (HSCT) (4). In this
setting, anti-CD19 CAR-T cells and anti-CD19/CD3
bispecific antibodies have achieved successful outcomes
in some clinical studies (5). Blinatumomab is a dual-specific structure that is a bispecific T lymphocyte engager.
Blinatumomab contains two different single-chain variable
fragments (scFv) derived from monoclonal antibodies
(mAb) against CD19 and CD3ε (6).The dual-specific mAb concept is extensively used for
B cell acute lymphoblastic leukaemia (ALL) (6, 7). The
fusion of scFv from a mAb with the intracellular signalling
domain of a T cell receptor (TCR) generates a CAR-T
cell for starting an immunotherapy process. Over the last
decade, dual-specific mAbs and CAR-T cells have proven
their potential to regress cancer in patients with poor
prognosis (8, 9). The Philadelphia Children’s Hospital of
the University of Pennsylvania report of their CTL019
CAR-T cell indicated that out of 59 patients, 93% were
in complete remission (CR) at one month. Patients had a
median follow-up of 12 months with a reported relapse-free survival of 55% and overall survival of 79%. Despite
the excellent responses of patients to CD19-directed T
lymphocytes, a significant number of patients relapse.
The data shows that of the 93% that have CR one month
after therapy, only 55% have disease-free survival (DFS)
after one year (10).Further investigations show that CD19-loss is a mechanism of transformed cell escape from
the CD19- directed immunotherapies (11). An alternative strategy to avoid antigen loss is
co-targeting of multiple markers of the transformed cells. Possible targets expressed in
B-cells and B-AML blasts include interleukin 3 (IL-3) receptor α (CD123) (12, 13) and folate
receptor beta (FRβ) (14). An important target that is expressed on CD19-negative blasts
relapsing after CAR-T cell therapy is CD123 (15). Studies show that the anti-CD123 CAR-T
cells can eradicate CD19-negative blasts in xenograft animal models (16). The results of
previous studies showed that the only CD123 targeting agent had limited efficacy against
leukaemia cells (17). On the other hand, FRβ is expressed in about 70% of AML cases
(18),thus making it an interesting target molecule for targeted immunotherapy (19). FRβ has
limited expression in normal tissues and increased expression in B-AML blasts (20). Here, we
sought to develop the first bispecific TanCAR that targets both CD123 and FRβ in order to
overcome the problems reported for other CARs. We generated and characterized fully human
CD123-FRβ bispecific CAR constructs that effectively expressed and targeted AML blast cell
lines in vitro.
Materials and Methods
This experimental study included in silico simulations and in vitro
studies to evaluate the function of a new bi-CAR-T cell against AML blasts. The methodology
of this study was based on previous tandem CAR designs (17, 21) and IL-3 receptor blockade
by an anticancer antibody PDB:4JZJ (13, 22).
In silico design of the structural functionality of a
TanCAR FRβ-CD123
In order to redirect the specificity of T lymphocytes
toward both CD123 and FRβ simultaneously using a
CAR molecule, we constructed a tandem CAR. This is a
bivalent CAR molecule that can engage two determinants
with a single exo-domain (Fig .1A). The pattern of the
TanCAR exo-domain was composed of the CD123- and
FRβ-scFv fragments in tandem and separated by a linker.
It was assembled on Clone Manager (3), modified to
remove unwanted restriction enzyme sites, and optimized
for maximum protein production using GeneOptimizer
software, as previously described (23). The CAR exo-domain consisted of a CD8 leader sequence, followed by
a CD123 scFv, and was joined to the FRβ-specific scFv by
a five amino acid sequence [glycine (4)-serine (1)] linker.
The cellular binding domain has an IgG1 hinge moiety.
A CD8 transmembrane region connected the exo-domain
to a second generation endodomain that incorporated the
4-1BB and CD3ζ signalling domain (Fig .1B).
Fig.1
The CD123-FRβ bi-TanCAR structure, its encoding transgene, and in silico design. A.
A computational rendition of the TanCAR structure. The CD123-scFv (left) and
folate receptor beta (FRβ) (right) are shown in blue. The glycine/serine linker is
highlighted in yellow. B. The pSFG vector construct that encodes the
bispecific TanCAR. C. Schematic figure depicts the TanCAR docking to its
respective targets. The structure prediction shows that the two designed chimeric
single-chain variable fragment (scFv) chimeras are well-separated and capable to
engage their own specific antigens.
Chimeric antigen receptor construction
The cassette encoded a single-chain antibody, the 4-1BB endodomain. The ζ chain of the
TCR complex was cloned into the pSFG retroviral backbone (Fig .1B). The cassette was
chemically synthesized (Biomatik, Canada). The synthesized cassette in pUC19 was amplified
in an Escherichia coli TOP10 strain. The amplified plasmid was extracted
and the insert was isolated by the double digestion of the Xho I and Cla I restriction
enzymes. The entire sequence of the insert was amplified via polymerase chain reaction
(PCR), which was conducted using F: GATGGATCAACGCTGGCAAT and R: GCCCCAGTAGTCAAACGAAC
primers. The PCR product was digested and ligated into a second generation pSFG retroviral
vector (Addgene, US) that contained 4-1BB and CD3ζ signalling chains (Fig .1B).
Production of the retroviral vector and T cell
transduction
The vectors were produced in HEK293T cells as previously described by the Lanitis group
(24). Briefly, a high-titre retroviral vector was produced in HEK293T cells that were
seeded at 107 cells per T175 cell culture flask, 24 hours before transfection.
All plasmid DNA were purified using the QIAGEN Maxi Prep Kit (Qiagen, Germany). The pELNS
transfer plasmid by Express Inn (Open Biosytems, CA, US) was used for the transfection
system. Cells were transfected with pVSV-G, pRSV.REV, pMDLg/p.RRE, and transfer plasmid
(Open Biosytems, CA, US). The viral supernatant was harvested at 48 hours after the
transfection. The viral particles were concentrated by centrifugation for three hours at
6000 g (Beckman Coulter, CA, US). Peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) were obtained
from three healthy donors. The T lymphocytes were enriched by CD3+ Ab (Miltenyi Biotec,
Bergisch Gladbach, Germany). The lymphocytes were taken from a healthy donor that signed a
written informed consent according to the Ethical Committee of the Life Sciences, Faculty
of North Tehran Branch of Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran (IR.IAU.TNB.REC.1397.65).
The CD8+ lymphocytes were isolated from a population of mononuclear cells via a MACS
Isolation Kit (130-096-495, Miltenyi Biotech, Germany). The T lymphocytes were activated
with CD3/4-1BB Dynabeads (Thermo Fisher, US) and transduced at 48 hours after activation
in plates coated with recombinant fibronectin fragments (RetroNectin, Takara, Japan). The
T cells were cultured in complete medium that contained RPMI 1640 (Gibco, UK), GlutaMAX
(Gibco, UK), MEM NEAA (Gibco, UK), 10% foetal bovine serum (FBS, Gibco, UK), 100 U/ mL of
penicillin-100 μg/mL of streptomycin (Pen-Strep, Gibco, UK), with 50 IU/mL of recombinant
human IL-2 (Biolegend, UK).
Cell lines
Human AML cell lines THP1 (12) and MV4-11 were purchased from the Persian Type Culture Collection
(PTCC), Pasture Institute, Tehran, Iran. All cells were
grown at 37°C in complete media, as previously described.
The CD123 and FRβ cells were previously transduced
with a retroviral vector.
T cell activation and cytokine release assays
CAR-T cells (2×105) were co-cultured with 2×105 target cells (1:1
ratio) in 500 μL of complete media in triplicate. After 24 hours, the supernatants were
tested for the presence of IL-2 and interferon gamma (IFN-γ) by enzyme-linked
immunosorbent assay (ELISA) (BioLegend, UK).
T cell proliferation
In order to evaluate the growth of the T cells, we
cultured the control and CAR-T cells and stimulated them
once a week with B-AML cell lines (ratio 2:1) without
the addition of any exogenous cytokines. The cell cultures
were performed for five weeks. Finally, the cells were
counted weekly using Trypan blue (Merck, Germany)
staining.
Cytotoxicity
The 51Cr assay was used to detect cytolytic activity of the T lymphocytes as
previously described. The percentage of specific lysis in the wells (in triplicate) was
calculated based on the following formula: (test release-spontaneous release)/(maximal
release-spontaneous release)×100 (25).
Flow cytometry
All of the cells were washed and suspended in FACS
buffer that contained PBS with 0.1% sodium azide and
0.4% human serum albumin. The cells were stained with
fluorescein isothiocyanate (FITC)- and phycoerythrin
(PE)-conjugated mAbs. We used CD19, CD123, and
FRβ (Becton Dickinson, Mountain View, CA, US) to
stain the AML blasts. CD3, CD4, CD8, CD56, CD45RA,
CD45RO, CD62L, CD27, CCR7, and PD-1 (Becton
Dickinson, Mountain View, CA, US) were used to stain
the T lymphocytes. PD-1 was the exhaustion marker of
the T cells. In order to detect CAR expression, the cells
were incubated at 4o
C for 20 minutes with biotin-labelled
polyclonal goat anti-mouse F(ab)2 antibodies (Santa Cruz
Biotechnology Dallas, Texas, USA) and then washed
twice with FACS buffer. Apoptosis was measured using
Annexin V and 7AAD staining (Becton Dickinson, US).
Cells were analysed by FACSCalibur (Becton Dickinson,
US) equipped with a triple fluorescence signal filter.
Statistical analysis
The data are reported as mean ± standard error. Statistical
analysis was performed using the unpaired 2-tailed Student’s t
test. GraphPad Prism 6.0 software (GraphPad Software
Inc., USA) was used for statistical calculations. A 'single-step Tukey’s range test' was used to test for statistical
significance. P≤0.05 was considered significant.
Results
In silico design of the TanCAR
Docking of the tandem CAR to the cognate receptors
was modelled for the CD123 and the FRβ-scFv (Fig .1A).
The TanCAR recombinant vector was designed and
constructed (Fig .1B). Models for CD123 (Protein Data
Bank ID: 4JZJ) and FRβ-scFv were optimized for each
molecule with PatchDock, then gathered in the context of
a bispecific TanCAR (Fig .1C). The arrangement structure
of the TanCAR domains allowed for simultaneous binding
of both receptors.The CD123-FRβ bi-TanCAR structure, its encoding transgene, and in silico design. A.
A computational rendition of the TanCAR structure. The CD123-scFv (left) and
folate receptor beta (FRβ) (right) are shown in blue. The glycine/serine linker is
highlighted in yellow. B. The pSFG vector construct that encodes the
bispecific TanCAR. C. Schematic figure depicts the TanCAR docking to its
respective targets. The structure prediction shows that the two designed chimeric
single-chain variable fragment (scFv) chimeras are well-separated and capable to
engage their own specific antigens.
Generation of chimeric antigen receptor-expressing T
cells with detectable lytic activity
We evaluated the persistence expression and cytolytic activity of our bispecific CAR
FRβ-CD123 in vitro. CARs expression persisted for more than 10 weeks
in vitro before turning down toward baseline non-expressing T cells.
The markers associated with memory (e.g., CD27, CD28, CD62L, and CCR7) were expressed by
CAR-T cells (Fig .2A). Flow cytometry results showed that a transduction efficiency of up
to 54% with a multiplicity of infection of 1.0. The ability to react with both CD123 and
the FRβ could provide an advantage to CAR-T cells over their monospecific counterparts by
increasing the overall avidity to their targets. We detected the surface expression of the
TanCAR using a Fab-specific antibody and specific FRβ protein on THP1 leukaemia cells and
on the tandem CAR-T cells (Fig .2B). We assessed the cytolytic ability of our designed
TanCAR FRβ-CD123, CD123-CAR, and FRβ CAR-expressing cells. All CAR-T cells had specific
cytotoxic activity against THP1 and MV4-11 cells (66 ± 11% and 62 ± 14% specific lysis for
bispecific Tan CAR; 61 ± 12% and 52 ± 15% specific lysis for FRβ CAR-T cells; and 62 ± 14%
and 51 ± 11% specific lysis for CD123 CAR-T cells at a ratio of 10:1 for the THP1 and
MV4-11 cells, respectively, **P≤0.005, P≤0.05). Control T cells showed no significant
cytotoxic activity against any of these target cell lines (Fig .3). Hyperstimulation of T
cells, which we induced in TanCAR-T cells upon co-simultaneous excitation with both CD123
and FRβ, could result in a drained phenotype. In order to compare the activity period of
bispecific TanCAR and monospecific CAR-T cells, we calculated the density of AML cell
lines at 10 days after transduction (Fig .3A, B). At first, all CAR-T cell products
significantly lysed the tumour cell lines. However, at and beyond 72 hours, bispecific
TanCAR-T cells were significantly better able to cytolyse tumour cell lines compared with
the other cells (*P≤0.05 at 72 hours and **P≤0.005 at five days). In all of the
experiments, the transduction rate of the TanCAR was normalized to the CD123-CAR and FRβ
CAR-T cell populations. Significantly higher cytotoxicity ratios were seen with TanCAR-T
cells compared with monospecific CAR-T cells. There was very weak cytolytic activity by NT
primary T cell blasts (Fig .3) and no significant cytotoxicity of the TanCAR-T cells
against CD123-FRβ-non-expressing targets (data not shown).
Fig.2
Surface expressions of the T cell determinants and TanCAR molecule. A. Expression of
cell surface markers associated with T cells as gated on CD3+CAR+ cells by flow
cytometry. B. Detection of the surface expression of the TanCAR using a
CD123 Fab-specific antibody and specific FRβ protein on THP1 leukaemia cells (top) and
using anti-Fab and FRβ protein on tandem CAR-T cells (bottom). FRβ; Folate receptor
beta and CAR; Chimeric antigen receptor
Fig.3
Activity of bispecific TanCAR-T cells against THP1 and MV4-11 leukaemia cell lines.
51Cr-release assays of bispecific TanCAR-CD123-FRβ T cells against
leukaemia lines A. THP-1 and B. MV4-11 compared with the
monospecific CAR-T cells and non-transduced T cells that were all generated from a
healthy donor. The two-tailed t test was performed between TanCAR CD123-FRβ and the T
cell product that exhibited the highest cytotoxic degree. CAR; Chimeric antigen
receptor, *; P≤0.05, and h; Hours.
Surface expressions of the T cell determinants and TanCAR molecule. A. Expression of
cell surface markers associated with T cells as gated on CD3+CAR+ cells by flow
cytometry. B. Detection of the surface expression of the TanCAR using a
CD123 Fab-specific antibody and specific FRβ protein on THP1 leukaemia cells (top) and
using anti-Fab and FRβ protein on tandem CAR-T cells (bottom). FRβ; Folate receptor
beta and CAR; Chimeric antigen receptorActivity of bispecific TanCAR-T cells against THP1 and MV4-11 leukaemia cell lines.
51Cr-release assays of bispecific TanCAR-CD123-FRβ T cells against
leukaemia lines A. THP-1 and B. MV4-11 compared with the
monospecific CAR-T cells and non-transduced T cells that were all generated from a
healthy donor. The two-tailed t test was performed between TanCAR CD123-FRβ and the T
cell product that exhibited the highest cytotoxic degree. CAR; Chimeric antigen
receptor, *; P≤0.05, and h; Hours.
Cytokine release by TanCAR-T cells
We co-cultured the B-AML blast lines with bispecific
TanCAR, CAR-CD123, and CAR-FRβ T cells at a
ratio of 10:1 (CAR:blast). The supernatants of the co-cultures were collected after 24 to 72 hours and tested
by ELISA for the presence of IFN-γ and IL-2. There
were significantly more cytokines in supernatants of
the TanCAR-T cells and the amounts were compared in
all groups. Neither non-transduced T lymphocytes, nor
control blasts had detectable levels of IL-2 and IFN-γ
cytokines (Fig .4).
Fig.4
Cytokine expression of bi-TanCAR-T cells against the THP1 leukaemia
cell line. Cytokine production of T cells detected in the supernatant of
24- to 72-hour co-culture with the THP1 cell line. Analysis of IFN-γ and
IL-2 from supernatants of the co-cultures of bispecific TanCAR CD123-FRβ
T cells, CD123CAR-T cells, FRβ chimeric antigen receptor (CAR)-T cells,
and non-transduced cells detected by enzyme-linked immunosorbent
assay (ELISA). The data are pooled from three independent experiments,
each done in triplicate. A single-step Tukey’s range test was used. IFN-γ;
Interferon gamma, IL-2; Interleukin 2, FRβ; Folate receptor beta, ELISA;
Enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay, *; P≤0.05, and h; Hours.
Cytokine expression of bi-TanCAR-T cells against the THP1 leukaemia
cell line. Cytokine production of T cells detected in the supernatant of
24- to 72-hour co-culture with the THP1 cell line. Analysis of IFN-γ and
IL-2 from supernatants of the co-cultures of bispecific TanCAR CD123-FRβ
T cells, CD123CAR-T cells, FRβ chimeric antigen receptor (CAR)-T cells,
and non-transduced cells detected by enzyme-linked immunosorbent
assay (ELISA). The data are pooled from three independent experiments,
each done in triplicate. A single-step Tukey’s range test was used. IFN-γ;
Interferon gamma, IL-2; Interleukin 2, FRβ; Folate receptor beta, ELISA;
Enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay, *; P≤0.05, and h; Hours.
In vitro proliferation and exhaustion of chimeric antigen
receptor-T cells
We observed continuous proliferation of all CAR-T
cell groups (Fig .5A). In order to compare the period of
TanCAR FRβ-CD123 antitumour activity, we assessed
the expression of the exhaustion marker PD-1 after co-culture with leukemic blasts for one week at a ratio of
10:1 (T cells to blasts). The THP1 cells were checked at 72
hours after continuous stimulation of T lymphocytes. The
T cells were subsequently gated for CAR expression and
compared with unstimulated CAR-T cells. The CD8+ part
of all the CAR products showed significant upregulation
of surface PD-1 following co-culture with THP1. All
CAR-T cells exhibited a close increase in PD-1 (Fig .5B).
Fig.5
Assessment of TanCAR-T cell proliferation and expressions of their exhaustion markers PD-1.
A. Flow cytometry output during incubation of TanCAR CD123-FRβ,
monospecific chimeric antigen receptor (CAR-T) cells, and non-transduced cells with
the THP1 leukaemia cell line after 10 days of co-culture. B. Median
fluorescence intensity results for expression of PD-1 on the CD8+ CAR-T cells before
and after repeated stimulation with the leukaemia cell line for one week.
Representative data are from three independent experiments, each done in triplicate. A
single-step Tukey’s range test was used. *; P≤0.05.
Assessment of TanCAR-T cell proliferation and expressions of their exhaustion markers PD-1.
A. Flow cytometry output during incubation of TanCAR CD123-FRβ,
monospecific chimeric antigen receptor (CAR-T) cells, and non-transduced cells with
the THP1 leukaemia cell line after 10 days of co-culture. B. Median
fluorescence intensity results for expression of PD-1 on the CD8+ CAR-T cells before
and after repeated stimulation with the leukaemia cell line for one week.
Representative data are from three independent experiments, each done in triplicate. A
single-step Tukey’s range test was used. *; P≤0.05.
Discussion
CARs have human leukocyte antigen (HLA)-unrestricted
activity when compared to the nature of TCRs (26). This
is important in tumours, which adopt immune evasions
by affecting major histocompatibility complex (MHC)
processing and presentation (27). Most antigens targeted
by CARs are not actually tumour-specific, but simply
tumour-associated. This means the antigens are shared
with normal tissues. This problem could be lessened by
the use of dual-specific CARs. A single CAR that targets
two antigens affects a broader variety of haematologic malignancies, and targets them more efficiently. In this
experiment, we used predictive molecular modelling to
interrogate the TanCAR structure and provide evidence
for synthesis of a functional structure. We described,
for the first time, the design and production of an anti-CD123 and FRβ linkage into a single TanCAR-T cell
specific for two AML blasts-associated antigens. There
are many studies that used each of the CD123 and FRβ
determinants (12-15, 17, 28) as the CAR-T cell specific
targets. The CAR construct is able to be activated via the
binding of either CD123 or FRβ tumour molecules. Four
structural templates with more than 60% identity were
recognized, from which a model for residues 41-279 of
TanCAR was constructed. We confirmed that TanCAR-transduced cells effectively recognize antigen epitopes in
a distinctive manner and have a sustainable activity after
simultaneously targeting them. This bivalent targeting
of the TanCAR also counteracts antigen escape of the
target cell and could eliminate them more efficiently in
comparison with monospecific CAR-T cells. As seen with
chemotherapy and HSCT, B-AML treatment requires
conjunctive use of multiple agents to avoid relapse
(29). So, the same concept would be true for CAR-T
cell therapies. The use of a single target on transformed
cells can lead to the specific escape mechanisms and it is
undoubtedly the use of dual-directed approaches that will
reduce these events.The expression of the exo-domain of CARs in its entirety was confirmed by flow cytometry,
which was specific for both the CD123 and FRβ domains. The specific function of the TanCARs
toward the targets indicated that the correct folding of this complex exo-domain was
achieved in our designing process. Because cytokine secretion is important for in
vivo efficacy of CAR-T cells, we conducted the cytokine assay for both the IL-2
and IFN-γ molecules. T lymphocyte activation, which was measured by IL-2 and IFN-γ cytokine
secretion, was proportional to the density of the target cells cultured in the plate. The
bispecific interaction to both targets caused a significantly higher cytokine secretion by
TanCAR-T cells than monospecific CAR-T cells. Furthermore, while exposure to a single
antigen leads to a decline in cytokine release over a certain antigen density in
monospecific CAR-T cells, the TanCAR-T cells continued to secrete elevated levels of
cytokines. This extra IL-2 and IFN-γ cytokine production increases the functional capacity
of the TanCAR-T cells due to its simultaneous engagement. However, Schneider et al. (30)
reported that the CD20- specific CAR was superior to tandem CAR constructs in the production
of T cell cytokines such as IFNγ, IL-2, and TNF-alpha, but their co-culture of TanCAR with
the target resulted in fewer remaining cells.The docking process of TanCAR-T cells to both targets,
which was supported by the in silico design model helped
us in the production of TanCAR-T cells that had enhanced
cytotoxicity against target cells. The potential to recruit
target tumor-associated antigens (TAAs) to the T cell-AML blast interface was revealed by the mass clustering
at the dual TAA IS, with robust T cell activation.The innate robust activity of the TanCAR-T cells is
attributed to its bi-directional functionality. Regular
CAR-T cells recognize only one antigen. For instance,
when B-AML blasts are treated with CD19 CAR-T cells,
CD19 under-expressing or non-expressing cells survive
and they will be selected to generate a new population that
is unresponsive to CAR-T cell therapy or other therapies
(31). The TanCAR molecule allows T lymphocytes to
capture both single- and double-positive determinant
populations. The general applicability of the TanCARs to
other antigens or extracellular binding domains remains
to be determined and should be studied more precisely.
We do not know if conformational changes induced after
binding of the primary antigen in the TanCAR-T cells
change the specificity of the secondary epitope for its
antigen.Gene transfer by the viral vectors typically requires
cell division for stable transfer. The CARs introduced
into T cells should be expanded effectively. Thus, stable
expression of CAR can be achieved without prior T cell
propagation. Despite the long-time antigenic stimulation
in our assay, TanCAR-T cells preserved their cytolytic
strength. Lymphocyte exhaustion is a condition of
their dysfunction, which would be determined by their
sustained expression of the inhibitory surface receptors
(ISRs) (32). The ISRs that include TIM3, LAG3, and
PD-1 contribute to T lymphocyte exhaustion (33, 34).
Impairment of immunity due to T cell exhaustion is
the main cause of death in patients with sepsis after the
acute phase (34). Expressions of these ISRs were not
significantly different between the bispecific TanCAR-T
cell and other cells, and suggested the same levels of
susceptibility to the ISRs. The robust activation without
exhaustion of this bispecific TanCAR-T cell enables this
structure to have the potential to become ubiquitous.However, our work lacks an animal preclinical study. Two long-term follow-up preclinical
animal studies have shown that some tumours re-emerged when the doses of CAR-T cells were
small (35). These re-emerged tumours were double-negative, which indicated that TanCAR-T
cells could overcome just a single antigen escape (8, 36). The late aspect of
double-negative tumour cells raise the question about the threshold number of TAAs to be
targeted. The previous work by Hegde et al. (35) partly answered this question in a
mathematical model built in data sets from a primary glioblastoma multiform model (GBM) that
predicted complete tumour elimination. They are currently substantiating this discovery in a
larger cohort of primary GBM. This profile includes TAAs as well as components from the
tumour microenvironment and vasculature (1). However, the current in vitro
investigation provides us a proof of principle of the improved functionality and
effectiveness of dual-targeting T cells that exert their effector function by means of a
bispecific CAR structure.Until now, the safety of CAR-T cells remains an important concern. CARs off-targets, cross-reactivity,
and unintentional T cell stimulation remain to be solved.
Bispecific TanCAR-T cells exhibit reactivity against two
antigens with conditional extra activation. It is predictable
that targeting two antigens could increase the risk to the
normal cells. Therefore, to reduce the risk, "gated" activation
of CAR-T cells has been described. In this way, an individual
TAA-specific CAR structure mediates signalling adequate
to induce cytolysis and a second CAR with specificity to
another TAA mediates a costimulatory signal that promotes
the full activation of the T lymphocytes (37). In cases where
a TAA is same as the normal tissue, a CAR molecule that
provides a costimulatory receptor domain that identifies
the second antigen could selectively lyse tumour cells that
express dual antigens but do not affect malignant cells that
express either antigen alone (38-40). The robust T cell
functionality through tandem repeat has many advantages
in tumour suppression and better activation dynamics (3).
However, the risk of insertional mutagenesis is less with a
single transgene, which can destabilize the T cell genome.
There are reports about the development of CD19 escape
variants after CD19 CAR-T cell therapy (8, 9); therefore,
we are in need of the production of bispecific TanCAR.
Finally, our particular choice of antigens, CD123 and FRβ,
allows for a T cell product that is effective in AML therapy.
Conclusion
CAR-T cells are an emerging, efficient tool for cancer
therapy. Numerous molecules, however, present as the
antigenic aspect of heterogeneous malignancies. Hence,
redirecting tumour-specific profiles rather than a single
marker could strength the efficacy of anticancer therapies.
We have confirmed that a dual-specific tandem CAR
FRβ-CD123 molecule can target cytotoxic T lymphocytes
toward two different antigenic epitopes and result in
significant control of B-AML blasts.
Authors: Tania Jain; Merav Bar; Ankit J Kansagra; Elise A Chong; Shahrukh K Hashmi; Sattva S Neelapu; Michael Byrne; Elad Jacoby; Aleksandr Lazaryan; Caron A Jacobson; Stephen M Ansell; Farrukh T Awan; Linda Burns; Veronika Bachanova; Catherine M Bollard; Paul A Carpenter; John F DiPersio; Mehdi Hamadani; Helen E Heslop; Joshua A Hill; Krishna V Komanduri; Craig A Kovitz; Hillard M Lazarus; Justin M Serrette; Mohamad Mohty; David Miklos; Arnon Nagler; Steven Z Pavletic; Bipin N Savani; Stephen J Schuster; Mohamed A Kharfan-Dabaja; Miguel-Angel Perales; Yi Lin Journal: Biol Blood Marrow Transplant Date: 2019-08-22 Impact factor: 5.742
Authors: Max S Topp; Nicola Gökbuget; Anthony S Stein; Gerhard Zugmaier; Susan O'Brien; Ralf C Bargou; Hervé Dombret; Adele K Fielding; Leonard Heffner; Richard A Larson; Svenja Neumann; Robin Foà; Mark Litzow; Josep-Maria Ribera; Alessandro Rambaldi; Gary Schiller; Monika Brüggemann; Heinz A Horst; Chris Holland; Catherine Jia; Tapan Maniar; Birgit Huber; Dirk Nagorsen; Stephen J Forman; Hagop M Kantarjian Journal: Lancet Oncol Date: 2014-12-16 Impact factor: 41.316
Authors: Ralf Bargou; Eugen Leo; Gerhard Zugmaier; Matthias Klinger; Mariele Goebeler; Stefan Knop; Richard Noppeney; Andreas Viardot; Georg Hess; Martin Schuler; Hermann Einsele; Christian Brandl; Andreas Wolf; Petra Kirchinger; Petra Klappers; Margit Schmidt; Gert Riethmüller; Carsten Reinhardt; Patrick A Baeuerle; Peter Kufer Journal: Science Date: 2008-08-15 Impact factor: 47.728
Authors: Meenakshi Hegde; Malini Mukherjee; Zakaria Grada; Antonella Pignata; Daniel Landi; Shoba A Navai; Amanda Wakefield; Kristen Fousek; Kevin Bielamowicz; Kevin Kh Chow; Vita S Brawley; Tiara T Byrd; Simone Krebs; Stephen Gottschalk; Winfried S Wels; Matthew L Baker; Gianpietro Dotti; Maksim Mamonkin; Malcolm K Brenner; Jordan S Orange; Nabil Ahmed Journal: J Clin Invest Date: 2019-07-02 Impact factor: 14.808