Kai A Jones1, Karan H Jani1, Glenn W Jones2, Megan L Nye3, Jonathan P Duff4, Adam Cheng5,6, Yiqun Lin5, Jennifer Davidson5, Jenny Chatfield5, Nancy Tofil7, Stacy Gaither7, David O Kessler3. 1. Vagelos College of Physicians and Surgeons Columbia University New York New York USA. 2. Retired Physician Nashua New Hampshire USA. 3. Department of Emergency Medicine Columbia University New York New York USA. 4. Department of Pediatrics University of Alberta Edmonton Alberta Canada. 5. Department of Pediatrics University of Calgary Alberta Children's Hospital Calgary Alberta Canada. 6. Department of Emergency Medicine University of Calgary Calgary Alberta Canada. 7. Department of Pediatrics University of Alabama at Birmingham Birmingham Alabama USA.
Abstract
OBJECTIVES: Coaches improve cardiopulmonary (CPR) outcomes in real-world and simulated settings. To explore verbal feedback that targets CPR quality, we used natural language processing (NLP) methodologies on transcripts from a published pediatric randomized trial (coach vs. no coach in simulated CPR). Study objectives included determining any differences by trial arm in (1) overall communication and (2) metrics over minutes of CPR and (3) exploring overall frequencies and temporal patterns according to degrees of CPR excellence. METHODS: A human-generated transcription service produced 40 team transcripts. Automated text search with manual review assigned semantic category; word count; and presence of verbal cues for general CPR, compression depth or rate, or positive feedback to transcript utterances. Resulting cue counts per minute (CPM) were corresponded to CPR quality based on compression rate and depth per minute. CPMs were compared across trial arms and over the 18 min of CPR. Adaptation to excellence was analyzed across four patterns of CPR excellence determined by k-shape methods. RESULTS: Overall coached teams experienced more rate-directive, depth-directive, and positive verbal cues compared with noncoached teams. The frequency of coaches' depth cues changed over minutes of CPR, indicating adaptation. In coached teams, the number of depth-directive cues differed among the four patterns of CPR excellence. Noncoached teams experienced fewer utterances by type, with no adaptation over time or to CPR performance. CONCLUSION: NLP extracted verbal metrics and their patterns in resuscitation sessions provides insight into communication patterns and skills used by CPR coaches and other team members. This could help to further optimize CPR training, feedback, excellence, and outcomes.
OBJECTIVES: Coaches improve cardiopulmonary (CPR) outcomes in real-world and simulated settings. To explore verbal feedback that targets CPR quality, we used natural language processing (NLP) methodologies on transcripts from a published pediatric randomized trial (coach vs. no coach in simulated CPR). Study objectives included determining any differences by trial arm in (1) overall communication and (2) metrics over minutes of CPR and (3) exploring overall frequencies and temporal patterns according to degrees of CPR excellence. METHODS: A human-generated transcription service produced 40 team transcripts. Automated text search with manual review assigned semantic category; word count; and presence of verbal cues for general CPR, compression depth or rate, or positive feedback to transcript utterances. Resulting cue counts per minute (CPM) were corresponded to CPR quality based on compression rate and depth per minute. CPMs were compared across trial arms and over the 18 min of CPR. Adaptation to excellence was analyzed across four patterns of CPR excellence determined by k-shape methods. RESULTS: Overall coached teams experienced more rate-directive, depth-directive, and positive verbal cues compared with noncoached teams. The frequency of coaches' depth cues changed over minutes of CPR, indicating adaptation. In coached teams, the number of depth-directive cues differed among the four patterns of CPR excellence. Noncoached teams experienced fewer utterances by type, with no adaptation over time or to CPR performance. CONCLUSION: NLP extracted verbal metrics and their patterns in resuscitation sessions provides insight into communication patterns and skills used by CPR coaches and other team members. This could help to further optimize CPR training, feedback, excellence, and outcomes.
Authors: Peter A Meaney; Bentley J Bobrow; Mary E Mancini; Jim Christenson; Allan R de Caen; Farhan Bhanji; Benjamin S Abella; Monica E Kleinman; Dana P Edelson; Robert A Berg; Tom P Aufderheide; Venu Menon; Marion Leary Journal: Circulation Date: 2013-06-25 Impact factor: 29.690
Authors: Adam Cheng; David Kessler; Yiqun Lin; Nancy M Tofil; Elizabeth A Hunt; Jennifer Davidson; Jenny Chatfield; Jonathan P Duff Journal: Pediatr Crit Care Med Date: 2019-04 Impact factor: 3.624
Authors: Adam Cheng; Jonathan P Duff; David Kessler; Nancy M Tofil; Jennifer Davidson; Yiqun Lin; Jenny Chatfield; Linda L Brown; Elizabeth A Hunt Journal: Resuscitation Date: 2018-08-24 Impact factor: 5.262
Authors: Nancy M Tofil; Adam Cheng; Yiqun Lin; Jennifer Davidson; Elizabeth A Hunt; Jenny Chatfield; Laura MacKinnon; David Kessler Journal: Pediatr Crit Care Med Date: 2020-05 Impact factor: 3.624
Authors: Katherine M Berg; Jasmeet Soar; Lars W Andersen; Bernd W Böttiger; Sofia Cacciola; Clifton W Callaway; Keith Couper; Tobias Cronberg; Sonia D'Arrigo; Charles D Deakin; Michael W Donnino; Ian R Drennan; Asger Granfeldt; Cornelia W E Hoedemaekers; Mathias J Holmberg; Cindy H Hsu; Marlijn Kamps; Szymon Musiol; Kevin J Nation; Robert W Neumar; Tonia Nicholson; Brian J O'Neil; Quentin Otto; Edison Ferreira de Paiva; Michael J A Parr; Joshua C Reynolds; Claudio Sandroni; Barnaby R Scholefield; Markus B Skrifvars; Tzong-Luen Wang; Wolfgang A Wetsch; Joyce Yeung; Peter T Morley; Laurie J Morrison; Michelle Welsford; Mary Fran Hazinski; Jerry P Nolan Journal: Circulation Date: 2020-10-21 Impact factor: 29.690