| Literature DB >> 34925972 |
Juan Fernando Ortiz1, Jashank Parwani2, Paul W Millhouse3, Ahmed Eissa-Garcés4, Gashaw Hassen5,6, Victor D Cuenca7, Ivan Mateo Alzamora4, Mahika Khurana8, Domenica Herrera-Bucheli9, Abbas Altamimi10, Adam Atoot11, Wilson Cueva1.
Abstract
Fabry disease (FD) is an X-linked disorder involving multiple organs. Stroke is a serious and frequent complication of FD. Cryptogenic stroke is a common presentation of FD, especially in the young population. The etiology of cryptogenic stroke is highly variable and difficult to assess, frequently leaving patients without a primary diagnosis. We conducted a systematic review to investigate the pooled prevalence of FD among patients with cryptogenic stroke, or patients with FD in whom a stroke was the presenting condition. English-language studies involving humans published in the last 20 years were included in this systematic review. FD was more common in male patients and tended to present at an earlier age. The frequency of hemorrhagic and ischemic strokes in this population was similar to that in the general population. There was a high rate of stroke recurrence in the study sample, even among patients undergoing enzyme replacement therapy. We conclude that screening for FD in patients with cryptogenic stroke is low yield and not cost-effective. However, it may be worthwhile to screen for FD among patients with recurrent strokes.Entities:
Keywords: alpha-galactosidase; cryptogenic stroke; fabry disease; ischemic stroke; stroke
Year: 2021 PMID: 34925972 PMCID: PMC8654093 DOI: 10.7759/cureus.19358
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Cureus ISSN: 2168-8184
Figure 1PRISMA flowchart of the systematic review.
PRISMA: Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic reviews and Meta-Analyses
Study type, methods, and outcomes of the studies.
FD: Fabry disease; α-GAL-A: alpha-galactosidase-A; Gb3: globotriaosylceramide; TIA: transient ischemic attack; NIHSS: National Institutes of Health Stroke Scale; mRS: modified Rankin scale; GVUS: genetic variants of unknown significance; CT: computed tomography; MRI: magnetic resonance imaging
| Author, year of publication, country | Study type | Methodology | Outcome |
| Duboc et al., 2011, Canada [ | Single-center cohort study | Data were gathered from patients aged 16-55 years with cryptogenic stroke in a single center. α-GAL-A gene sequencing and plasma Gb3 levels were measured | Seven patients had a positive screening for FD (five women and two men) carrying mutations of undetermined pathogenicity. One patient had a mutation of unknown pathogenicity and another patient had confirmed pathogenic mutation and elevated levels of Gb3. Prevalence: 2/101 (1.9%) patients with cryptogenic stroke had FD |
| Lanthier et al., 2017, Canada [ | Prospective cohort study | Enrolled patients aged 18-55 with either ischemic stroke or TIA. α-GAL-A gene was measured. NIHSS was measured acutely and mRS at seven days and six months | There were 8/397 patients who had a positive screening for FD. Six patients had multiple neutral genetic variants of the gene. One patient presented with a single disease-neutral variant (p.D313Y). Another patient presented with GVUS (p.R118C). The prevalence of FD was 1 in 395 (0.3%) |
| Gündoğdu et al., 2017, Turkey [ | Prospective cohort study | 484 patients aged 18-55 were enrolled from the city of Sakarya with acute ischemic stroke. Ischemic stroke was confirmed by CT and MRI. α-GAL-A was measured. Low enzyme levels of <1.2 μmol/L/hour were indicative of FD. DNA sequencing for GAL missense mutation for those with low enzyme activity was also done | 484 patients with ischemic stroke were enrolled. 67 patients fulfilled the criteria of the study. 13 were lost to follow-up; hence, 54 patients were finally included in the study. Three (two males and one female) patients had low levels of α-GAL-A enzyme activity. The female had no gene mutation despite having low levels of the enzyme. The two male patients presented pathogenic mutation of FD (missense mutation). The prevalence of FD in this cohort was 2/67 (3.7%) |
| Malavera et al., 2020, Australia [ | Prospective multicenter cohort study | The study included 326 patients aged 18-55 with cryptogenic stroke during 2014-2015. The levels of α-GAL A enzyme activity followed by gene analysis and lyso-Gb3 levels was conducted on 58/326 patients who consented for participation in the study | Out of 326 patients who met the inclusion criteria, 58 provided consent. However, six failed the initial screening blood draw and two withdrew consent. There were 50 participants who underwent enzyme/genetic analysis. 47% (n = 23) were females and 53% (n = 27) were males. Although 7/27 males showed low enzyme levels, genetic analysis did not reveal FD. Among the 23 females, only one had a pathologic FD on genetic analysis. Overall, the prevalence of FD was 1.72% in this cohort 1/58 (1.72%) |
| Rolfs et al., 2005, Germany [ | Multicenter prospective cohort study | Between February 2001 and December 2004, 721 German adults aged 18-55 in 27 clinical departments in Germany suffering from cryptogenic stroke were screened for FD. The plasma α-GAL-A activity in men was measured, followed by sequencing of the entire gene in those with low enzyme activity. By contrast, the entire α-GAL gene was genetically screened for mutations in women even if enzyme activity was normal | 32 patients had reduced activity of the enzyme (22 men 10 women). Out of them, 28 patients (21 men and 7 women) had a pathogenic mutation of the gene. Prevalence in males was 4.9%, and prevalence in females was 2.4%. Strokes were more common in the vertebrobasilar artery (42.9%). The total prevalence in this cohort was 28/721 (3.8%) |
| Kinoshita et al., 2012, Japan [ | Multicenter prospective cohort study | From April 2015 to December 2016, 516 young patients (<60 years) with either ischemic or hemorrhagic stroke were enrolled in the study. α-GAL enzyme activity and Gb3 levels were measured followed by α-GAL-A gene sequencing | 110 patients had cryptogenic strokes. Five patients (one woman and four men) had low α-GAL-A enzyme activity). Two patients had a mutation of unknown pathogenicity. No pathogenic mutation was found despite five patients having low levels of α-GAL-A activity. The prevalence of FD was 0/110 (0%) in this cohort |
| Alhazaa et al., 2020, Saudi Arabia [ | Single-center cohort study | 51 patients aged 18-55 with cryptogenic stroke were included in the study. α-GAL-A enzyme was measured, and genetic testing was performed in patients with abnormal results | 500 patients were screened in this study, but only 51 were included. One case had borderline levels of the enzyme, but the genetic test revealed no genetic mutation of FD. Prevalence in this cohort was 0/51 (0%) |
| Brouns et al., 2007, Belgium [ | Multicenter cohort Study | During January 2000 and December 2004, 103 patients with cryptogenic stroke aged 16-60 were screened for FD. Measurement of the α-GAL-A enzyme was followed by genetic testing in males with abnormal results | 103 patients were included in the cohort. Three patients (two women and one man) had abnormal levels of the α-GAL-A enzyme. The same three patients had normal genetic testing. No patient was identified with FD. The prevalence in this cohort was 0% |
| Sarikaya et al., 2012, Switzerland [ | Cohort study | Between January 2006 and October 2009, 150 patients were recruited, with a mean age of 43. Enzyme activity was measured in all patients. Genetic analysis was done in all females and males with low enzyme levels | 150 patients met the inclusion criteria of the study. Nine patients had low enzymes levels (six men and three women). A nonpathogenic mutation was found on genetic analysis of the nine patients with low enzyme activity. However pathogenic mutation was not found. Hence, the prevalence in this cohort was 0% |
| Reinsin et al., 2018, Argentina [ | Cohort study | Young patients in Argentina with TIA, ischemic stroke, or hemorrhagic stroke between 2011 and 2015 were enrolled. α-GAL-A levels were measured in all patients. Males with low levels of the enzyme and all females underwent genetic sequencing of the gene | 311 patients were enrolled in the study. Ischemic events occurred in 89%, and 11% had a hemorrhagic event. Only one patient had the pathogenic mutation of FD. Another patient had a mutation of unclear significance. Both were missense mutations. Prevalence in this cohort was 2/311 (0.64%) |
| Wozniak et al., 2010, United States [ | Cohort study. | 550 men aged 15-49 years with their first ischemic stroke were enrolled in the study. The levels of α-GAL-A were measured in all patients. Patients with lower levels of the enzyme underwent genetic analysis | 154 out of 550 patients with stroke had a cryptogenic stroke. 110 patients had low levels of the enzyme. Genetic testing on these patients showed a pathogenic mutation in one patient and a mutation of undetermined significance in another. Hence, the prevalence was 1/154 (0.65%) |
Characteristics of the patients with FD and stroke.
Gb3: globotriaosylceramide; GVUS: genetic variants of unknown significance; ERT: enzyme replacement therapy; TIA: transient ischemic attack; mRS: modified Rankin scale; MCA: middle cerebral artery; PCA: posterior cerebral artery; α-GAL-A: alpha-galactosidase-A; MRI: magnetic resonance imaging; WMHs: white matter hyperintensities; CKD: chronic kidney disease; GI: gastrointestinal; FD: Fabry disease
| Author, year | Age and sex | Mutation | Gb3 levels and enzyme activity | Infarct | Outcome (second stroke) | Outcome | Treatment |
| Dubuc et al., 2012 [ | 40 M | Unknown pathogenicity (GVUS) | Mildly elevated; Gb3 after the second stroke was normal | Nonlacunar vertebro basilar | 42 months later, he had an infarct in the carotid artery territory | Bad functional | No ERT, antiplatelet drugs |
| 41 F | Pathogenic | Not described | Lacunar ischemic stroke | Two TIAs and two recurrent nonlunar ischemic strokes in the subsequent 63 months of follow-up | Memory impairment | Aspirin, ERT after stroke | |
| Lanthier et al., 2017 [ | 55 M | GVUS (p.R118C) | Normal (Gb3) | Lacunar (left basal ganglia and subcortical infarctions). No leukoaraiosis | He had no further cerebrovascular events at seven months | mRS had improved from 3 at baseline to 1 at six months. | No information available |
| 39 F | Single disease-neutral | Normal (Gb3) | Lacunar (acute left thalamic lacune) | No recurrent cerebrovascular events on aspirin and atorvastatin prophylaxis | No information available | No information available | |
| Rolfs et al., 2005 [ | 38.4 M | α-GAL gene | Men: α-GAL-A high or low + Gb3 | MCA infarction: 28.6% (6/21). PCA infarction: 14.1% (3/21). Vertebrobasilar artery: 9/21 (42.9%). Hemorrhage: 5/7 (71.4%) | 10 cases of multiple cerebrovascular events | Hemiparesis, ataxia, dysarthria, pathologic nystagmus | No information regarding ERT |
| 40.3 F | Women: α-GAL-A high or normal + Gb3 | MCA infarction: 42.9% (3/7). PCA infarction: 14.3% (1/7). Vertebrobasilar artery: 4/7 (57.1%). Hemorrhage: 1/7 (14.3%). Vertebrobasilar infarction: 42.9% | Two cases of multiple cerebrovascular events | Information not available | Information not available | ||
| Malavera et al., 2020 [ | 49 F | Pathogenic | Normal levels of Gb 3 | Intraparenchymal hemorrhage | No recurrent cerebrovascular events | Information not available | Secondary prevention with antiplatelets and statins |
| Gündoğdu et al., 2017 [ | 24 M | Pathogenic | Low α-GAL-A activity (0.1 μmol/L/hour) | Right basal ganglia infarction. MRI revealed WMHs in both hemispheres and lacunar infarctions in the thalamus, brain stem, and parietal lobe | No further cerebrovascular events at six months | Cardiomyopathy, CKD, neuropathic pain, hypohidrosis, and GI disease | ERT |
| 43 M | Pathogenic | Low α-GAL-A activity (0.1 μmol/L/hour) | Lacunary infarction in the pons (same place as the previous stroke) | Second lacunar stroke | Remained with left-sided paralysis. | ERT | |
| Wozniak et al., 2010 [ | Information not available | Pathogenic | Low α-GAL-A activity (0.1 μmol/L/hour) | Information not available | Information not available | Information not available | Information not available |
| Information not available | Undetermined pathogenicity | Low α-GAL-A activity (0.1 μmol/L/hour) | Information not available | Information not available | Information not available | Information not available |
Bias analysis using ROBINS-I tool.
ROBINS-I: risk of bias in non-randomized studies of interventions
| Author, year | Confounding | Selection of participants | Classification | Deviations | Missing data | Measurements | Selection of reported results |
| Gündoğdu et al., 2017 [ | Medium risk | Moderate risk | Low risk | Low risk | Moderate risk | Low risk | Low risk |
| Dubuc et al., 2012 [ | Low risk | High risk | Low risk | Low risk | Low risk | Low risk | Low risk |
| Lanthier et al., 2017 [ | Low risk | Moderate risk | Low risk | Low risk | Low risk | Moderate risk | Low risk |
| Malavera et al., 2020 [ | Low risk | Moderate risk | Low risk | Low risk | Low risk | Moderate risk | Low risk |
| Rolfs et al., 2005 [ | Low risk | Low risk | Moderate risk | Low risk | Low risk | Moderate risk | Low risk |
| Kinoshita et al., 2018 [ | Low risk | Moderate risk | Low risk | Low risk | Low risk | Low risk | Low risk |
| Alhazzaa et al., 2020 [ | Low risk | High risk | Low risk | Low risk | Moderate risk | Low risk | Moderate risk |
| Brouns et al., 2007 [ | Low risk | Moderate risk | Low risk | Low risk | Low risk | Moderate risk | Low risk |
| Wozniak et al., 2010 [ | Low risk | High risk | Low risk | Low risk | Moderate risk | Low risk | Moderate risk |
Studies of all type of strokes and FD.
FD: Fabry disease; CVS: cardiovascular stroke; α-GAL-A: alpha-galactosidase-A
| Author, year, country | Number of cases | Prevalence of FD |
|
Lee et al., 2019, Taiwan [ | 1,000 stroke patients: 661 ischemic strokes and 339 hemorrhagic strokes. | Two male patients with ischemic stroke were found to have a pathogenic mutation of FD. Overall prevalence was 0.2 for all strokes and 0.3 for ischemic strokes |
|
Rolfs et al., 2013, Europe [ | 5,023 patients with CVS from 15 different countries were enrolled in this study. Ischemic stroke: 3,396, hemorrhagic stroke: 271, transient ischemic attack: 1,071 | Definitive FD was found in 0.5% of the sample (N = 27). Probable FD was found in 0.3% of patients (N = 18) |
|
Song et al., (2016), China [ | 357 patients underwent tests for α-GAL-A activity. 293 out of 357 patients with cerebral infarction and 64 out of 357 patients with transient ischemic stroke were screened for mutations in the enzyme | No patients with FD were found (prevalence: 0%) |