| Literature DB >> 34869838 |
Hadley S Sauers-Ford1, James B Aboagye1, Stuart Henderson1, James P Marcin1, Jennifer L Rosenthal1.
Abstract
Pediatric patients experiencing an emergency department (ED) visit for a traumatic injury often transfer from the referring ED to a pediatric trauma center. This qualitative study sought to evaluate the experience of information exchange during pediatric trauma visits to referring EDs from the perspectives of parents and referring and accepting clinicians through semi-structured interviews. Twenty-five interviews were conducted (10 parents and 15 clinicians) and analyzed through qualitative thematic analysis. A 4-person team collaboratively identified codes, wrote memos, developed major themes, and discussed theoretical concepts. Three interdependent themes emerged: (1) Parents' and clinicians' distinct experiences result in a disconnect of information exchange needs; (2) systems factors inhibit effective information exchange and amplify the disconnect; and (3) situational context disrupts the flow of information contributing to the disconnect. Individual-, situational-, and systems-level factors contribute to disconnects in the information exchanged between parents and clinicians. Understanding how these factors' influence information disconnect may offer avenues for improving patient-clinician communication in trauma transfers.Entities:
Keywords: information; pediatric trauma; transfer
Year: 2021 PMID: 34869838 PMCID: PMC8640298 DOI: 10.1177/23743735211056513
Source DB: PubMed Journal: J Patient Exp ISSN: 2374-3735
Participant Characteristics.
| N (%) | |
|---|---|
| Sex | |
| Male | 10 (40) |
| Female | 15 (60) |
| Age, years | |
| 25-34 | 5 (20) |
| 35-44 | 14 (56) |
| 45-55 | 6 (24) |
| Role | |
| Parent | 10 (40) |
| Referring emergency department nurse | 3 (12) |
| Referring emergency department physician | 4 (16) |
| Accepting trauma nurse practitioner | 3 (12) |
| Accepting physician | 5 (20) |
| Years in profession | |
| N/A (parents) | 10 (40) |
| 0-4 | 6 (24) |
| 5-10 | 3 (12) |
| 10 + | 6 (24) |
Themes with Representative Quotes.
| Theme 1: Parents’ and clinicians’ distinct experiences result in a disconnect of information exchange needs |
|---|
| The gal who was going to take us out to the waiting area, it was almost like she was surprised. She was like, “Oh my god are you okay?” I’m like, “No! I’m not okay. This is horrible. This is terrible.” I think there's just a culture – and I get why it is – but I think there's a culture that gets built into medicine because that's what people are doing all day every day that they sometimes forget how incredibly stressful that moment is for the people who are experiencing it. [Parent, ID 12] |
| I’m sure he [the surgeon] told us what they had to do, but I was like, “Okay. When will we get to go home?” I was looking for more information. “When do we get to come home? What are the next steps?” He was just like, “I can't tell you that right now. I’ve got to go” and went back. It was very – even after the surgery was done and a social worker and the chaplain took me in a room to meet with him, he was very like, “This is what happened,” and not like – I was looking for the answer of is she going to be okay, what's this going to look like now, what's happening now. He's just like, “I can't tell you that. I can't tell you that. I can't tell you.” It was very – he seemed almost annoyed that I wanted to know what was going on. [Parent, ID 8] |
| It's kind of like when the kid gets there, and the parent gets there, you know, I — I feel like speaking with my colleagues everyone's kind of like, “It's not a big deal, it's not chaotic. We do it very calmly.” But in reality, I don't think that's the truth. I think it's kind of like it's — it is odd. The parents aren't used to this kind of situation. They’ve never done it before. So, it's very weird for them. [Trauma NP, ID 25] |
| We’ve tried to do that [send patients in a personal vehicle] a couple of times and have had the consult be, “No, absolutely not. They have to come, and that goes by air.” And at that point, then we just talk to the family like, we talked to the specialist. They’re the experts in this field. They don't feel safe with you driving down there because they’re worried for XYZ reasons, decompensation or whatever. And they recommend transport and I can't argue with that, because this is their recommendation and I have to abide by that. [Referring ED Physician, ID 3] |
| When they first told me [we were being transferred], it just kind of sounded like that was the way it was going to be and that was what we had to do kind of thing. I mean, I know we could have probably just taken her home, but I was like, “Okay, I don't understand exactly why we’re going or what's happening.” [Parent, ID 22] |
| Theme 2: Systems factors inhibit effective information exchange and amplify the disconnect |
| And I think that's a good thing that we’re [pediatric trauma facility] so open, we take everybody. But I don't think there's often like a huge dialogue. [Trauma NP, ID 5] |
| [O]ccasionally we’ll have someone get transferred over who is either brain dead or neurologically devastated to the point where there's nothing really, we can do. The family has been told, “Oh, we’re going to send you to [pediatric trauma facility]. They’re going to help you. Don't worry. They’re the experts.” They come all very hopeful…. Then, we walk in, and after our exam and we discussed imaging, we say, “I’m sorry, but there's just nothing we can do. [The family] gets very upset that they were kind of told different things. That can be a very difficult situation. [Neurosurgical resident, ID 7] |
| The Transfer Center usually requests that the images be placed in our outside server, so that we can view them beforehand. It doesn't work very smoothly, and I’m not sure like why, and I’ve asked a bunch of times, why can't this work more smoothly? We have the ability to have images placed, and we should be doing that for every patient. [Trauma NP, ID 5] |
| Theme 3: Situational context disrupts the flow of information contributing to the disconnect |
| They were presumably transferred because they’re told that they might need surgery or this and that. And so I think that there's a lot of parent anxiety that gets worked up even more just because they get multiple messages that aren't always consistent. [Orthopedic Surgery Resident, ID 2] |
| I kept asking, “What's happening? What's going on?” They kept saying they were going to check; they were going to go check. Now I know looking back on it, they weren't sure she was going to live, so obviously they were waiting to see how a surgery went and whatnot. But still not easy for me just sitting there going, “What's going on?"“ [Parent, ID 8] |
| There was no way to just know how she was going [to be] – you can't just give a prognosis on day one, like you hear on TV or something, right? Like, they were providing the information that they knew. But to us, it always felt very cagey. Like, well, okay – is she going to be okay or not? Is she going to walk or not? Is she going to be able to talk? Is she going to wake up? How long until she wakes up? When are these things going to happen, right? And no one knew anything. It was always, “Well, we’ll see how she does.” [Parent, ID 11] |
Interview Guide for Clinicians.
| Topic | Example probing question |
|---|---|
| General Experience/Perspectives
with pediatric traumas System? Culture? Habits? |
Tell me about your thoughts and opinions in caring for pediatric trauma patients who require interfacility transfers. What things are working, what things aren't working? |
| Referring Providers Experience/Perspectives
Services/specialists not present (admit?) Time of day? Comfort Busy |
In your experience, what factors contribute to initiating a transfer request for a pediatric trauma patient? Do you feel that your system is equipped to manage pediatric trauma patients? What could be improved in your system? Tell me a bit about a recent pediatric trauma transfer Did you feel that the physicians taking your transfer request calls are able to get an adequate understanding of the patient's clinical scenario (injuries, physiology, needs) from your conversation? How satisfied are/were you with the transfer request conversation? If [tertiary center] had not accepted the transfer, what would the next steps have been at your institution? |
| General Experience/ Perspectives
with Telehealth |
Have you ever used telehealth before? Tell me about the last time or a recent time you used telehealth for a consultation, even if it wasn't for a pediatric trauma patient. What worked well? Please elaborate. Anything about the technology, or interaction with the family? What would you do differently next time? Please explain why. |
| Outcomes
communication experience (if they don't talk about distress/anxiety, probe about this) transfers cost |
Tell me about a time where the communication with a family regarding a transfer went well? What about a time when communication went poorly? Tell me about a time where a family was really anxious about a transfer? Tell me about a time was unnecessarily transferred? Have you ever had a family talk to you about their concerns about costs? |
| Closing |
Is there something that you might not have thought about before that occurred to you during this interview? |
Interview Guide for Family.
| Topic | Example probing question |
|---|---|
| General Experience
Emergency department (ED) experience |
Tell me about your experience when you took your child to the ED. What went well? What could have gone better? |
| Outcome
Communication experience Anxiety Transfer Cost |
How would you describe the communication you received from the care team about your child's care while in the ED? Potential probes: what type of information did you receive? Any other information you would have liked that you didn't receive? Do you remember some of the feelings and emotions you had during the experience? Probe: what were some of the things that helped with the feelings? Made them stronger? Did your child get transferred to another hospital? If yes, describe what the transfer experience was like. What understanding do you have about how the decision was made to transfer? What went well with the transfer process? What could have gone better? What do you wish you would have known about the transfer process? Describe how the transfer affected the rest of the family (travel to [hospital], time from work / school, out of pocket costs, other children and childcare, etc.). What, if any, follow-up care was needed for your child after the ED visit? Where, types of care / visits, etc.? |
| Closing |
Is there something that you might not have thought about before that occurred to you during this interview? Is there something else you think I should know to understand your experience better? |