| Literature DB >> 34850966 |
Joseph K Han1, Claus Bachert2,3,4, Stella E Lee5, Claire Hopkins6, Enrico Heffler7, Peter W Hellings2,8,9, Anju T Peters10, Siddhesh Kamat11, Diane Whalley12, Shanshan Qin13, Lauren Nelson13, Shahid Siddiqui11, Asif H Khan14, Yongtao Li15, Leda P Mannent16, Isabelle Guillemin17, Chien-Chia Chuang18.
Abstract
OBJECTIVES/HYPOTHESIS: Clinical trials of biologics to treat chronic rhinosinusitis with nasal polyposis (CRSwNP) have evaluated objective outcomes (e.g., University of Pennsylvania Smell Identification Test [UPSIT], nasal polyps score [NPS], and computed tomography Lund-Mackay score [CT-LMK]) and patient-reported symptoms (e.g., nasal congestion/obstruction [NC], loss of smell [LoS], and total symptom score [TSS]). We estimated anchor-based thresholds for clinically meaningful change in objective and patient-reported outcomes in patients with CRSwNP using data from LIBERTY NP SINUS-24 and SINUS-52 trials (NCT02912468; NCT02898454).Entities:
Keywords: Adult rhinology; nose and paranasal sinuses; quality of life
Mesh:
Substances:
Year: 2021 PMID: 34850966 PMCID: PMC9299621 DOI: 10.1002/lary.29888
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Laryngoscope ISSN: 0023-852X Impact factor: 2.970
Target Outcomes and Anchor Measures.
| Measure | Recall Period and Response Scale | Scoring |
|---|---|---|
| Target outcomes | ||
|
Symptoms e‐diary Four items: NC, LoS, anterior rhinorrhea, and posterior rhinorrhea |
Past 24 hr 0 = No symptoms 1 = Mild symptoms 2 = Moderate symptoms 3 = Severe symptoms |
Items: 0–3 TSS: 0–9 (sum of NC, LoS, and average of anterior and posterior rhinorrhea) Higher scores indicate more severe symptoms |
|
UPSIT total 40 odorants |
Current Patient selects best description of odor out of 40 choices |
0–40 Higher scores indicate better olfactory function |
|
NPS Video recordings of nasal endoscopy |
Current 0 = No polyps 1 = Small polyps in the middle meatus not reaching below the inferior border of the middle turbinate 2 = Polyps reaching below the lower border of the middle turbinate 3 = Large polyps reaching the lower border of the inferior turbinate or polyps medial to the middle turbinate 4 = Large polyps causing complete obstruction of the inferior nasal cavity |
0–8 (sum of the right and left scores; average of 2 independent raters) Higher scores indicate more extensive or severe nasal polyps |
|
CT‐LMK scores Based on CT scans of each sinus area (maxillary, anterior ethmoid, posterior ethmoid, sphenoid, frontal sinus on each side) |
Current Extent of mucosal opacification (0 = Normal, 1 = Partial opacification, 2 = Total opacification) Patency of the ostiomeatal complex (0 or 2) |
0–24 (bilateral sum of all sinuses and the ostiomeatal unit) Higher scores indicate worse opacification |
| Anchor measures | ||
|
SNOT‐22 22 items: symptoms and social/emotional consequences of CRS Rhinologic symptoms domain: 6 items relating to nasal symptoms (need to blow nose, nasal blockage, sneezing, runny nose, thick nasal discharge, and decreased sense of smell/taste) |
Past 2 wk 0 = No problem 1 = Very mild problem 2 = Mild or slight problem 3 = Moderate problem 4 = Severe problem 5 = Problem as bad as it can be |
0–110 (sum of the 22 items) Higher scores indicate greater impacts of CRS on HRQoL |
| Rhinosinusitis VAS (cm): “How troublesome are your symptoms of rhinosinusitis?” |
Current 0 = Not troublesome to 10 = Worst thinkable troublesome (sic) |
0–10 Higher scores indicate more severe CRS Severity categories: 0–3 = mild, >3–7 = moderate, >7–10 = severe |
CRS = chronic rhinosinusitis; CT = computed tomography; CT‐LMK = computed tomography Lund‐Mackay score; HRQoL = health‐related quality of life; LoS = loss of smell; NC = nasal congestion/obstruction; NPS = nasal polyps score; SNOT‐22 = 22‐item sinonasal outcome test; TSS = total symptom score; UPSIT = University of Pennsylvania Smell Identification Test; VAS = visual analog scale.
Baseline Descriptive Statistics for the Target Outcomes and Anchor Measures.
| Measure | Phase 3 Pooled (SINUS‐24 and SINUS‐52 Studies) | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| n | Mean Score (SD) | Median Score | |
| Target outcomes | |||
| NC | 696 | 2.40 (0.57) | 2.4 |
| LoS | 696 | 2.73 (0.54) | 3.0 |
| TSS | 696 | 7.15 (1.42) | 7.2 |
| UPSIT | 685 | 14.03 (8.22) | 11.0 |
| NPS | 693 | 5.98 (1.25) | 6.0 |
| CT‐LMK | 681 | 18.33 (4.10) | 19.0 |
| Anchor measures | |||
| SNOT‐22 rhinologic symptoms | 686 | 19.70 (5.03) | 20.0 |
| SNOT‐22 total | 686 | 50.57 (20.47) | 49.0 |
| Rhinosinusitis VAS | 682 | 7.87 (2.06) | 8.3 |
n: Number of patients with corresponding endpoint data at baseline among those who had both baseline and week 24 monthly scores for at least 1 symptoms e‐diary item. For NC, LoS, and TSS, baseline refers to the weekly averaged scores before randomization.
CT‐LMK = computed tomography Lund‐Mackay score; LoS = loss of smell; NC = nasal congestion/obstruction; NPS = nasal polyps score; SD = standard deviation; SNOT‐22 = 22‐item sinonasal outcome test; TSS = total symptom score; UPSIT = University of Pennsylvania Smell Identification Test; VAS = visual analog scale.
Correlation Between the Change in Target Outcome Scores and Change in Anchor Measure Scores.
| Target outcome | Correlation of Baseline to Wk 24 Change With Anchor Measures, | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| SNOT‐22 Rhinologic Symptoms | SNOT‐22 Total | Rhinosinusitis VAS | |
| NC | 0.65 (674) | 0.55 (674) | 0.47 (663) |
| LoS | 0.59 (674) | 0.46 (674) | 0.46 (663) |
| TSS | 0.73 (670) | 0.62 (670) | 0.52 (663) |
| UPSIT | −0.46 (660) | −0.35 (660) | −0.36 (650) |
| NPS | 0.51 (658) | 0.40 (658) | 0.38 (648) |
| CT‐LMK | 0.46 (653) | 0.35 (653) | 0.35 (641) |
For NC, LoS, and TSS, baseline refers to the weekly averaged scores before randomization; week 24 refers to the monthly averaged daily scores from day 142 to day 169.
CT‐LMK = computed tomography Lund‐Mackay score; LoS = loss of smell; NC = nasal congestion/obstruction; NPS = nasal polyps score; SNOT‐22 = 22‐item sinonasal outcome test; TSS = total symptom score; UPSIT = University of Pennsylvania Smell Identification Test; VAS = visual analog scale.
Interpretation of Change from Baseline to Week 24 in the NC Score, LoS Score, TSS, UPSIT, NPS, and CT‐LMK.
| Anchor | Estimate of Meaningful Change: Mean (SD), n | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| NC | LoS | TSS | UPSIT | NPS | CT‐LMK | |
| SNOT‐22 rhinologic symptoms domain score | ||||||
| Responder: score improvement ≥3.8 | −1.29 (0.9), 511 | −1.16 (1.0), 511 | −3.54 (2.2), 509 | 8.49 (10.1), 500 | −1.54 (1.8), 498 | −5.06 (4.9), 495 |
| SNOT‐22 total score | ||||||
| Responder: score improvement ≥8.9 | −1.28 (0.9), 501 | −1.13 (1.0), 501 | −3.52 (2.2), 498 | 8.44 (10.0), 490 | −1.51 (1.8), 488 | −4.95 (4.9), 485 |
| Rhinosinusitis VAS severity category (mild, moderate, and severe) | ||||||
| Improvement by 1 category | −0.99 (0.8), 260 | −0.91 (1.0), 260 | −2.75 (2.1), 260 | 6.40 (9.8), 253 | −1.11 (1.7), 254 | −4.37 (4.8), 249 |
CT‐LMK = computed tomography Lund‐Mackay score; LoS = loss of smell; NC = nasal congestion/obstruction; NPS = nasal polyps score; SNOT‐22 = 22‐item sinonasal outcome test; TSS = total symptom score; UPSIT = University of Pennsylvania Smell Identification Test; VAS = visual analog scale.