| Literature DB >> 34836174 |
Nematullah Hayba1, Yumeng Shi1, Margaret Allman-Farinelli1.
Abstract
The unyielding obesity epidemic in adolescents from Middle Eastern (ME) backgrounds warrants culturally-responsive and co-designed prevention measures. This study aimed to capture the opinions of ME parents residing in Australia on the crisis and their enablers and barriers to healthy eating interventions given their influence on adolescent eating behaviors. Twenty-six semi-structured interviews were conducted with ME mothers, aged 35-59 years, and most residing in low socioeconomic areas (n = 19). A reflexive thematic analysis using the Capability, Opportunity, Motivation-Behaviour model and Theoretical Domain Framework was conducted. Parents expressed confidence in knowledge of importance of healthy eating, but were reluctant to believe behaviours were engaged in outside of parental influence. Time management skills are needed to support working mothers and to minimize reliance on nearby fast-food outlets, which was heightened during COVID-19 with home-delivery. Time constraints also meant breakfast skipping was common. A culture of feeding in light of diet acculturation and intergenerational trauma in this diaspora was also acknowledged. Parents pleaded for upstream policy changes across government and school bodies to support parental efforts in the form of increased regulation of fast-food and subsidization of healthy products. Opportunities for weight-inclusive programs including parenting workshops underpinned by culturally-responsive pedagogy were recommended.Entities:
Keywords: adolescents; culturally responsive; eating habits; ethnic minority; interviews; lifestyle; nutrition; obesity; overweight; parents
Mesh:
Year: 2021 PMID: 34836174 PMCID: PMC8624745 DOI: 10.3390/nu13113918
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Nutrients ISSN: 2072-6643 Impact factor: 5.717
Questions used in interviews to gather information on the capabilities, opportunities, and motivations of parents on adolescent food behavior and perception of the obesity pandemic.
| Study Topic | Questions |
|---|---|
| Introduction | To start, could you please tell me a bit about your experience as a parent to an adolescent? |
| Probe around role of parenthood in health of adolescent | |
| In general, do you have any concerns about his/her lifestyles? | |
| Probe for concerns about body weight. | |
| Probe for opinion on excess weight. | |
| Perception | The 2015 NSW School Physical Activity and Nutrition Survey (SPANS) revealed that adolescents from Middle Eastern Backgrounds have a much greater prevalence (41%) of overweight and obesity compared with children from English-speaking backgrounds (26%) especially amongst boys (45 to 27% respectively). |
| What do you think about these statistics? | |
| Probe for agreement/disagreement. | |
| If yes, why do you think this is the problem? | |
| Who do you think is responsible? | |
| Who do you think has a role in regulating this? | |
| Probe for schools, community groups, health professionals, government, parent themselves. | |
| What do you think should be done? | |
| Probe for education, lifestyle programs etc. | |
| Have you participated in any sort of health intervention for your child? | |
| Probe for education, lifestyle programs etc. | |
| Do you have any areas of improvements or suggestions for the intervention? | |
| Target Behaviour 1: Eating Breakfast | What do you think about eating breakfast? |
| Why/Why not? | |
| Is making breakfast something you usually do? | |
| Who usually makes breakfast? | |
| Does your child know how to cook breakfast? | |
| Does your child often skip breakfast? | |
| Do you know if your child has breakfast every day? | |
| Do you see preparing breakfast for your family as an important part of your role as a parent? | |
| If you were to rate from 1 to 10 on how important it is, what would you say? | |
| Do you have certain number of days they should have breakfast? | |
| What do you think will happen with your child’s nutrition, body weight if they skip breakfast? | |
| Does it upset you to worry about morning meal times with your child? | |
| Are there any emotional reactions from your child about eating breakfast? | |
| How does that affect you? | |
| Do you receive any emotional reward or satisfaction from your child for organising breakfast? | |
| How confident are you to ensure that your child knows the importance of eating breakfast? | |
| To what extent do the resources available affect your ability to prepare breakfast? | |
| How much do you think their friends influence whether or not they eat breakfast? | |
| How much do you think their friends influence what they eat for breakfast? | |
| Target Behaviour 2: Eating Fruits and Vegetables | What do you think about eating fruits and vegetables? |
| Does your child eat fruit and vegetables? | |
| Why/Why not? | |
| Are fruits and vegetables usually included in meals at home? | |
| Do you know how to prepare fruit and vegetables? | |
| Do your children know how to prepare fruit and vegetables? | |
| What do you do to try and encourage your child to eat more fruits and vegetables? | |
| Does your child avoid having fruit and vegetables? | |
| Is there any routine at home with eating fruit and vegetables? | |
| Do you see including fruits and vegetables as part of meals for your family as an important part of your role as a parent? | |
| If you were to rate from 1 to 10 on how important it is, what would you say? | |
| Do you have certain number of days they should eat fruits and vegetables? | |
| What do you think will happen with your child’s nutrition, body weight if they do not have enough fruits and vegetables? | |
| Does it upset you to worry about fruits and vegetables with your child? | |
| Are there any emotional reactions from your child about eating fruits and vegetables? | |
| How does that affect you? | |
| Do you receive any emotional reward or satisfaction from your child for organising fruits and vegetables? | |
| How confident are you to ensure that your child knows the importance of eating fruits and vegetables? | |
| To what extent do the resources available affect your ability to prepare fruits and vegetables? | |
| How much do you think their friends influence whether or not they eat fruits and vegetables? | |
| How much do you think their friends influence how much fruits and vegetables they eat? | |
| Target Behaviour 3: Soft Drink Consumption | What do you think about soft drink consumption? |
| Does your child drink soft drink? | |
| How often does your child have soft drink? | |
| How much soft drink does your child have per day? | |
| Do you have any rules about how much soft drink your child can drink? | |
| What strategies have you used to reduce soft drink intake with your child? | |
| Do you impose any limits on how much soft drink your child can consume? | |
| Are there any times that you don’t allow soft drink? | |
| Do you believe you have an important role in moderating your child’s soft drink intake? | |
| If not, do you think that you should? | |
| What might be your plan in this area? | |
| If you were to rate from 1 to 10 on how important/relevant it is, what would you say? | |
| What do you think will happen to your child’s health if they were to consume excessive soft drink? | |
| What do you think is a reasonable amount of soft drink per day? | |
| Does your child’s soft drink intake affect you emotionally? | |
| Are there any conflicts regarding soft drink? | |
| How does this affect you and your child? | |
| Do you enforce any routine around soft drink? | |
| Do you give any punishments or rewards to your child for following any soft drink rules? | |
| How confident are you that regulating soft drink will have a benefit for your child? | |
| Do you believe your child’s environment affects his/her soft drink consumption? | |
| To what extent do the resources available to you affect your ability to regulate your child’s soft drink consumption? | |
| How important is soft drink amongst your children and their peers? | |
| How difficult does it make to regulate your child’s soft drink intake? | |
| Target Behaviour 4: Fast Food Consumption | What do you know about eating fast food? |
| Does your child eat fast food? | |
| How often does your child have fast food? | |
| How much fast food does your child have per day? | |
| What do you think your children know about eating fast food? | |
| Do you have any rules about how much fast food your child can eat? | |
| If you wanted to reduce fast food intake, how would you go about doing that? | |
| Do you know how to cook? | |
| Do you impose any limits on how much fast food your child can consume? | |
| Are there any times that you don’t allow fast food? | |
| Do you have any alternatives for fast food? | |
| If you wanted to cut down on fast food how would you do that? | |
| Do you believe you have a role in your child’s fast food intake? | |
| Do you think you should? | |
| On a scale of 1 to 10, how important is your child’s fast food intake to you? | |
| What do you believe will happen to your child’s health if they were to consume excessive fast food? | |
| How much fast food intake do you think is reasonable? | |
| Does your child’s fast food intake affect you emotionally? | |
| Does it affect you and your child? | |
| Do you enforce any routines around fast food intake? | |
| Do you give any punishments or rewards to your child for following any fast food rules? | |
| How confident are you that regulating food intake will benefit your child’s health? | |
| Do you believe your child’s environment affects his/her fast food consumption? | |
| To what extent do the resources available to you affect your ability to regulate your child’s fast food consumption? | |
| How important is fast food amongst your children and their peers? | |
| How difficult does it make to regulate your child’s fast food intake? |
Demographic information of interview participants (n = 26) *.
| Demographic Characteristics | Number of Participants ( |
|---|---|
| Age group | |
| 35–39 | 6 |
| 40–44 | 8 |
| 45–49 | 9 |
| 50–54 | 2 |
| 55–59 | 1 |
| Female Gender | 26 |
| No. of Adolescents | |
| 1 | 11 |
| 2 | 10 |
| 3 | 3 |
| 4 or more | 0 |
| Age of Adolescents (years) | |
| 13–14 | 15 |
| 14–15 | 3 |
| 15–16 | 3 |
| 16–17 | 8 |
| 17–18 | 7 |
| Single Parent | |
| Yes | 5 |
| No | 21 |
| SEIFA 1 Rank within Australia—Decile [ | |
| <5 | 19 |
| ≥5 | 7 |
* n stands for sample size; 1 SEIFA: Socio-Economic Indexes for Areas (measure of socio-economic status) [21].
Exemplary quotes from parents by key theme.
|
|
|
“I think it’s a matter of teaching Middle Eastern people or parents or caretakers that they can’t smother them. They can’t feel sorry for them because they’re crying, because they want a bag of chips or they can’t go and do fitness with them and take him and feel good about aww he’s just worked out I’ll go get him Maccas. I think it’s about changing the parent’s mindset, about what they do and they turn around and Middle Eastern parents will say to you, I don’t you know, he doesn’t have this, but the whole pantry is full of things that child shouldn’t be eating because they’ve got other kids in the house that want all that stuff and they’re not obese, so they’ve probably got one out of three kids that are obese, And how do you change the lifestyle of that child if you’re not changing the whole house?”—P11, (F), 45 y, >1 adolescent “It’s very important you can’t start your day without eating healthy food to start your day and imagine a car you can’t start it without having petrol in it. So it’s the main thing. But I mean, X rarely eats breakfast, but I encourage her always to eat even if she drink a cup of milk and eat some cereal, anything. You start your day not to start it without food or healthy food. It’s very important”—P23, (F), 48 y, 1 adolescent “It’s crap for you. It’s very, very bad for you. But it’s cheap. It’s easy and it’s fast. When you’ve done a 12-h shift, you really don’t want to come home and cook”—P14, (F), 43 y, 1 adolescent “I think they’re absolutely essential I yeah, we make sure that, you know, there’s salad on the table pretty much every day, if there’s not a salad, you know vegetables cooked in another form, but they’re really, really important”.—P7, (F), 42 y, 1 adolescent “And I’m a hundred and ninety, four hundred percent against those drinks. And I said to him, why are you drinking this? Like what in the world? How many times have I told you not to not to drink it and not to have any of these energy drinks? They’re not good for you and you don’t know what your body reacts is going to react to them and he’s like it’s only a V you know. So it’s like, no, it’s not just only a V (branded energy drink) do you understand what goes in there. Like, seriously, you know, your body is like you’re young”—P8, (F), 46 y, 1 adolescent |
|
|
|
“I know on the weekends they have their breakfast; they make sure they have their breakfast but yeah during the week I make it as smooth as I can for them to have breakfast”—P1, (F), 49 y, 1 adolescent “Well, a lot of times that I know they’re eating vegetables because I blend it in the nutribullet. Yeah. And if I’m making like, for example, spaghetti is the best because you got the meat. So anything that has, like, little meat mince in it I actually put vegetables through it so they’ll be eating eggplant and zucchinis and everything, Mushrooms”—P19, (F), 45 y, 1 adolescent “Well, obviously you wouldn’t give them money to purchase it. You’re in control. They’re not in control. So if you want them to get McDonald’s then you’re driving, you’re paying. So ultimately you’re allowing me to do or eat unhealthy unless they have pocket money and they’re hiding and then they buy it, but otherwise they don’t have the funds they don’t have unless they go walking. But really, it’s, I think the parent and if you’ve made healthy food at home or some other alternatives, there’s no need for them to buy”—P10, (F), 43 y, >1 adolescent “…, the only soft drink I do bring. … my kids actually prefer it anyway Is the sparkling water so I get sparkling mineral water. I get it a little bit flavoured. That’s the only soft drink they do drink and they only get soft drink on that rare occasion where there It’s like a family barbecue … but it’s not something I go to the shop and say okay I need to buy coke every day I need to buy it on a weekly basis for that reason. Whereas for example, if I saw the mineral water on special I’ll buy by a box, because I know I like I said it’s the better alternative for them”—P21, (F), 39 y, >1 adolescent |
|
|
|
“Look, I don’t mind fast food but it’s got to be like I said, either Subway, Lewrap or like Douggies grill we like their salad We I mean, whenever we go there we only get the chicken salad and sweet potato. Like if I can’t cook for some reason, I would go for that kind of food. Like salad type, like salad, like things that are healthy and, you know, it’s healthy”—P3, (F), 39 y, 1 adolescent “Yeah I’ll make burgers at home. I’ll make like if they say they feel like burgers I’ll make it for them instead. And then I add the extra tomatoes and the lettuce and the stuff like that to it”—P12, (F), 48 y, >1 adolescent “but I know we are a lot busier than we were and takeaway is cheaper sometimes and getting all the ingredients. So I think as time management and by the time you’ve bought all the ingredients, I could have just bought a takeaway meal and then everyone will just have the meal and there’s no dishes and it’s done and…even if I’m making spaghetti, like, I’ll grate, it really finely. And they’ve got no idea it’s veggies in there, but if I get bolognaise sauce that’s already pre-made I’ll make sure to get one that has veggies So if I make a meal that doesn’t have a salad on the side…. Yeah, I can get myself organized and meal prep and all that. Then we probably would never have to. It will be like a treat. By your time factor here…”—P17, (F), 43 y, >1 adolescent “So I prefer to just do home cooked meals or we go to Thai food, I try to encourage, you know, the cuisines that have like more vegetables”—P19, (F), 45 y, 1 adolescent |
|
|
|
“Myself Yes. When I’m sick, I just can’t bear to get up or do anything. So sometimes it’s just having a little bit of reliance on the two older kids to do that for the younger ones, I do feel guilty that I’m unable to do so. But as you said, there are circumstances sometimes that arise that you’re unable to do that for them and things like that. So there is a little bit of guilt going through that. I could have done it. But yeah, I’ve got two other older ones that are able to help me out in that regards”—P4, (F), 32 y, >1 adolescent |
|
|
|
“They would be really overweight, especially you know fast food, soft drinks. I think they’re the two biggest culprits in making kids fat”—P19, (F), 45 y, 1 adolescent “As in not like not having breakfast oh yeah because you get the stomach grumbles, you get the dizzy spells, you can’t focus, you can’t concentrate, you know, you get, like, agitated because, you know, you’re hungry like your body tells you”—P14, (F), 43 y, 1 adolescent “Yeah. So I think obviously if they’re not having the right nutrition, then they’re putting on the weight because they’re going to eat all processed food… And obviously they’re gaining weight, because if you’re not having, you know, say five, four pieces of fruit, or sorry 5 pieces of veggies, seven, whatever it is that you’ve got to have intake, and then not having the proper fruit intake, then, you know, there’s not much nutrition going into the body, which sort of leads to other things like constipation or whatever”—P9, (F), 42 y, 1 adolescent “I think it would have a very negative effect on their health. I think weight gain is probably the first one. And just I think I don’t know if you really call it an addiction, but I think sugar is addictive. I think if it’s there they’re they’re going to they want they’re going to want it. Definitely. If we go to the supermarket, you know, my kids will still ask for lollies. They’ll still say, oh, can we get a bag of lollies or can we get these sweets or can we? And I’ve got to always kind of, you know, sometimes I’ll allow it, it’s most of the time I put my foot down and say no choose something alternative to that. I’m the boring mom, o you got to have fruit”—P7, (F), 42 y, 1 adolescent |
|
|
|
“regarding their health. Yep health is really, really important in our family. So I try and set an example with my children and the things that we eat in the way that I shop sometimes, the way that I even speak about food. And it’s really important for me as a mother to make sure that I set up a healthy, healthy relationship with food as well, because I’m cognizant of the fact that there are a lot of eating disorders... Frankly, I’m aware of the fact that with teenagers in general, this is something that even I witnessed as a teenager myself, that there’s an unhealthy relationship with food that comes from different sources. I think whether it’s, you know, the idealistic view of women and the way they’re portrayed in media and in fashion... Sometimes, you know, the parent or the way that, you know, attitudes towards food play out home. So I’ve always been really, really aware of that. And I just I try and make sure that I’m setting a good example for the children and setting them up for adulthood to enable them to make the right decisions when it comes to their diet and their lifestyle. Inshallah.”—P7, (F), 42 y, 1 adolescent “Yeah, I definitely think that the government has a huge role, obviously, by subsidizing, you know, fruits and vegetables and things like that, you know, putting taxes on unhealthy food. I think that’s a big part, obviously, at school as well, like some of the school canteens, are shocking in what they sell, you know, and then obviously in educating as well, the students and having programs, especially for them. Yeah. As community groups, I don’t know how they can do much. I mean, my kids have gone to the go4fun programs that are run, and they did benefit for it, you know, from for a little while. But I feel like, you know, it just like with anything, they go through phases. So they’ll be all into it for a little bit and then it just sort of dies out.”—P18, (F), 40 y, 1 adolescent “… educate them when they’re younger, like still in like before they even start high school when they first start primary school. That’s when they should be educated, but not when they’re older and it’s too late. They’ve got into a routine and in a habit with their food and stuff”—P12, (F), 48 y, >1 adolescent |
|
|
|
“for it to be my role. Now at their age I’d probably say a nine. If they were older and they knew and you know more aware and more responsibility and things like that obviously it would be less important for me to take on that role and more for them. But at this point, at this age, oh I’d probably say nine that it’s my responsibility”—P5, (F), 37 y, 1 adolescent |
|
|
|
“I think they totally do know the importance because they do it in school also in PDHPE and all that kind of stuff, but whether they follow through on it is another thing. I mean, so they know totally, but it’s just getting them to do it”—P19, (F), 45 y, 1 adolescent |
|
|
|
“I worry with the kids more than us. I don’t want them to get into the habit that we’re in where they’ll skip meals, because once you skip breakfast, you tend to skip lunch and then you’ll be like, I’ll just have a big dinner and then snacks throughout the night, which is not good.”—P14, (F), 43 y, 1 adolescent “And once the child gets a taste of it, basically it just becomes a obsession because it keeps them on a high because of the sugar intake and the sweetness of them”—P4, (F), 38 y, >1 adolescent “One hundred percent. I worry about his eating because he does not, he doesn’t make good choices. He will always go for the unhealthy option. He does not like vegetables. The only vegetable he will eat is a carrot or a cucumber and carrots that’s pushing it cucumbers every now and again.... Fruit, he loves all fruits of any fruit you put in front of him, he will eat, which is at least he likes fruit. And when it comes to making good choices with the food that he eats, no, I am quite concerned for his health. And if he was not a tall boy, I think he would fill out quite quickly. But I think his height helps him a lot in his appearance”—P16, (F), 38 y, 1 adolescent |
|
|
|
“Yeah, they know, because we talk a lot about, you know, the diet and we talk a lot about the importance of food and to keep yourself healthy. And also we do mention like eating. Now, when you are a teenager, it’s a reserve for when you get older”—P22, (F), 50 y, >1 adolescent |
|
|
|
“No. Definitely no reward or punishment. I have tried to stay away from reward and punishment with regards to food, because I think that sets up an unhealthy relationship with the food, though, but I just I just enforce it. It’s basically just mums would have to have breakfast, you’re not, leaving the house until you have something. So yeah”—P7, (F), 42 y, 1 adolescent “I just don’t buy it if they wanted to have it I don’t buy it or I just hide it. I had to actually hide the whole bottle, if I think they’ve had too much, I just I like I usually get more on Sundays if I think they’ve had it too excessively, my punishment, but without them realizing what I’d take away the whole soft drink and put it somewhere else completely where they can’t find”—P10, (F), 43 y, >1 adolescent |
|
|
|
“I probably have to agree, to be honest, because growing up here in Australia, I was also born and raised here, but I’m from the Middle Eastern background. Everything revolved around food, everything. Our parents, it was all about food you had eating was equal to being happy. I think that’s what our parents instilled in us. And I when I started to have my children started to see it that way. But then as they got older and I got wiser and I thought, no, but it’s you know, food does not equal happiness. It also equals overweight and obesity and the health problems and all these other things that come along with it. So I have to I tend to agree with those statistics, I think”—P16, (F), 38 y, 1 adolescent “And I think a big part of it also comes from culturally, you know, you can’t starve your kid, you know what I mean? You don’t want him to be upset or, you know, or like it’s slack to let them be hungry and that sort of thing. So it doesn’t surprise me, but I didn’t think it would be that big a difference”—P18, (F), 40 y, 1 adolescent “Yes, 100 percent. He always wants to eat the stuff that his friends like, they’re always sending each other snapshots on the latest place that’s opened up and what’s on the menu. And they should go try this and should go try that and he harasses me relentlessly he wants me to drive to woop woop to get a burger or a kebab. I’m like, I’m not driving like forty-five minutes from home, So you can try a new burger flavor or new chips dipped in you know, caramel or whatever it is like I’m not doing that. But yeah, they do, they play a massive role, she’s the same. She wants to go to all these weird places that her friends, have told her about where they can try all these new sweets and desserts. And I’m like, you know, it’s not happening”—P14, (F), 43 y, 1 adolescent “I guess at the moment I’m having a conflict with my fourteen-year-old son. He wants to try having a V. Even he doesn’t really drink soft drinks so that because the influence of his friends they are drinking that drink that he should be able to drink that drink too. And like it’s no its not working that way”—P4, (F), 38 y, > 1 adolescent |
|
|
|
“No, no, and neither they’ve never outreached to us, have not in high schools, Oh they had Oh no Crunch and Sip was in primary school. They don’t do that in high school. I was going to say that they do a program called Crunch and Sip in primary school, which is where they take a piece of fruit and they physically have fifteen-minute break. But they don’t do that in high school”—P14, (F), 43 y, 1 adolescent “I think they should crack down on Uber eats at school time for school kids… I think teachers need to keep more of an eye on things like that. … You can get schools around shops, and they’ve got all those junkie shops like as in Kebabs and Pizza and KFC and Maccas. But when they’re far away from those kind of things, they’re not going to be tempted to go eat it from there. These days they can do Uber eats”—P3, (F), 39 y, 1 adolescent “Well schools really tick me off because I never knew that, Like, I know a lot of schools would ban it but then I found out that the high school actually sold soft drinks to the students so I mean, like, that’s so wrong. So, yeah, schools should definitely play a part. It’s very important…You can regulate as much as you can. But like I told you, what they choose to do. Like my daughter, if she chose to walk to Maccas it’s right next to her school …. So do you get what I mean, like, it’s always there next to you. The temptation is there, I guess for them, like I would say, it’s harder to regulate”—P19, (F), 45 y, 1 adolescent “…The kids lose trust in their parents because they see that the only mother is acting this way and the whole environment are the opposite. So that’s why I say it’s a big struggle…Yes, sometimes tight with the money, because the food is not cheap. The vegetables is not cheap you cannot provide every single day everything now…, I think time for working Mother even for working, Mother. It’s just it’s too much commitment, but it’s more think financially you feel that you cannot provide every single day.”—P22, (F), 50 y, > 1 adolescent |