| Literature DB >> 34821965 |
Kanika Bhargava1,2, Gopal Nath2, Amit Bhargava3, G K Aseri1, Neelam Jain4.
Abstract
The rise in multi-drug resistant bacteria and the inability to develop novel antibacterial agents limits our arsenal against infectious diseases. Antibiotic resistance is a global issue requiring an immediate solution, including the development of new antibiotic molecules and other alternative modes of therapy. This article highlights the mechanism of bacteriophage treatment that makes it a real solution for multidrug-resistant infectious diseases. Several case reports identified phage therapy as a potential solution to the emerging challenge of multi-drug resistance. Bacteriophages, unlike antibiotics, have special features, such as host specificity and do not impact other commensals. A new outlook has also arisen with recent advancements in the understanding of phage immunobiology, where phages are repurposed against both bacterial and viral infections. Thus, the potential possibility of phages in COVID-19 patients with secondary bacterial infections has been briefly elucidated. However, significant obstacles that need to be addressed are to design better clinical studies that may contribute to the widespread use of bacteriophage therapy against multi-drug resistant pathogens. In conclusion, antibacterial agents can be used with bacteriophages, i.e. bacteriophage-antibiotic combination therapy, or they can be administered alone in cases when antibiotics are ineffective.Key points• AMR, a consequence of antibiotic generated menace globally, has led to the resurgence of phage therapy as an effective and sustainable solution without any side effects and high specificity against refractory MDR bacterial infections.• Bacteriophages have fewer adverse reactions and can thus be used as monotherapy as well as in conjunction with antibiotics.• In the context of the COVID-19 pandemic, phage therapy may be a viable option.Entities:
Keywords: Antimicrobial resistance (AMR); Bacteriophage therapy; Combination therapy; Extreme-drug resistance (XDR); Multi-drug resistance (MDR); Phage cocktail
Mesh:
Substances:
Year: 2021 PMID: 34821965 PMCID: PMC8852341 DOI: 10.1007/s00253-021-11695-z
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Appl Microbiol Biotechnol ISSN: 0175-7598 Impact factor: 4.813
Fig. 1Illustration of the mechanism of antimicrobial resistance in a bacterial cell
Fig. 2Mechanism of action of bacteriophage therapy: After bacteriophage infection (A), phage DNA (purple) is either conventionally replicated and processed as new virions at the cost of the host cell (virulent phage in the lytic cycle; left, A, E and F) or reproduces with host DNA (temperate phage in the lysogenic cycle; right, B, C and D) (Fabijan et al. 2020)
Fig. 3Current summary of phage therapy clinical trials targeting some major diseases
An overview of bacteriophage clinical studies for the treatment of bone and joint infections
| Case study | Description | Administration | Result | References |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bacteriophage therapy for chronic PJI infection of the knee and chronic femoral osteomyelitis | After a gunshot injury, an 80-year-old patient with T2DM2 and CKD was diagnosed with PJI and chronic Osteomyelitis due to MDR | Phage#- Local instillation Antibiotics (colistin, meropenem and ceftazidime) —Intravenous | Bacteria eradicated successfully following combination therapy | Tkhilaishvili et al. |
| Bacteriophage therapy for PJI during DAIR | An 80-year-old obese woman with T2DM2 and mild chronic kidney injury with a history of relapsing PJI of right hip resulted in a postoperative purulent discharge with MSSA and MDR | Phage (1493 & 1815)-Direct injection into joints Antibiotics (daptomycin, clindamycin and amoxicillin)—Oral | A successful clinical outcome resulted in complete eradication of infection | Ferry et al. |
Synergistic effect of bacteriophages and antibiotics on patient with trauma-related left tibial Infection | A 42-year-old patient with bacterial osteomyelitis infected with XDR | Phage (AbKT21phi3; MK278859 and KpKT21phi1; MK278861) and antibiotics (meropenem and colistin)—Intravenous | No positive culture was found after 8 months of combined therapy | Nir-Paz et al. |
| Bacteriophage therapy for the treatment of implant-related infections (orthopaedic surgery) due antibiotic resistant bacteria | Implant related osteomyelitis was identified in a rat model due to MRSA and | Phage (Sb-1 and vB_PsaP PAT14)-direct injection into the medullary canal Antibiotics (teicoplanin, imipenem, cilastatin and amikacin)-Intraperitoneal | Biofilm dissolved for both types of bacteria | Yilmaz et al. |
| Phage therapy for chronic osteomyelitis in the experimental rabbit model | Chronic osteomyelitis was established on distal end of femur in a rabbit model due to MRSA | Phage cocktail (SA-BHU1, SA-BHU2, SA-BHU8, SA-BHU15, SA-BHU21, SA-BHU37, SA-BHU47)—Intra-lesionally | A successful clinical outcome resulted in wound healing and site sterilization | Kishor et al. |
| Bacteriophage therapy for the treatment of PKI | A 79-year-old female with a resistant | Phage (PM448)-intraarticular instillation Antibiotic (daptomycin)-Intravenous | The patient recovered via intraarticular bacteriophage therapy with no adverse effect and evidence of clinical recurrence | Doub et al. |
PJI prosthetic joint infection, PKI prosthetic knee infection, T2DM2 type 2 diabetes mellitus, CKD chronic kidney disease, DAIR debridement along with antibiotics and implant retention, MDR multi-drug resistant, XDR extreme drug resistance, MRSA methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus, MSSA methicillin-sensitive Staphylococcus aureus. Phage#: Collection (No identification given) received from George Eliava Institute of Bacteriophages, Microbiology and Virology (Tbilsi, Georgia)
An overview of bacteriophage clinical studies for the treatment of urinary tract infections
| Case study | Description | Administration | Result | References | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bacteriophage therapy for UTI: A randomised, placebo-controlled clinical trial | Patients with prostrate TUR were screened for UTI with recurrent bacteriuria ( | Phage cocktail (Pyo-bacteriophage)-Intravesical suprapubic | 7 days of phage treatment resulted in sterile urine culture | Leitner et al. | |
| Case study of effective treatment of chronic relapsing UTI via phage therapy | A 58-year-old renal transplant patient developed a post-transplant UTI due to ESBL | Phage#-Oral, Intravesical and bladder irrigation Antibiotic (meropenem)-Intravenous | Sterile urine culture obtained, following combination therapy | Kuipers et al. | |
| Bacteriophage and antibiotic efficacy in the inactivation of UTI-causing bacteria | In-vitro efficacy of combination therapy and alone was tested in the urine sample for the evaluation of | Phage (ECA2) and antibiotics (ampicillin, piperacillin, kanamycin, tetracycline, chloramphenicol and ciprofloxacin)- Direct inoculation | Significant bacterium inactivation was obtained after 8 h of treatment | Valerio et al. | |
| Treatment of refractory UTI by phage therapy | Intra-abdominal resection and pelvic irradiation for adenocarcinoma followed by bilateral ureteric stent placement resulted in | Phage (Pyophage #051,007)-Intravesical Antibiotic (meropenem and colistin)-Intravenous | Combined therapy resulted in sterile urine culture | Khawaldeh et al. | |
| Determination of intravesical phage therapy for the treatment of UTI | A placebo-controlled, double-blind clinical trial was conducted on men over the age of 18 who had acute UTI but no indications of systemic illness via uropathogens ( | Phage (Pyophage cocktail R-022600)-intravesical instillation | Intravesical phage therapy was non-inferior to antibiotic treatment but not superior to bladder irrigation (placebo) in terms of efficacy and safety | Leitner et al. | |
UTI urinary tract infection, TUR transurethral resection, ESBL extended-spectrum β-lactamase; Phage#: Solution (No identification given) received from Eliava Institute in Tbilisi, Georgia
Overview of bacteriophage clinical studies for the treatment of biofilm infections
| Case study | Description | Administration | Result | References |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bacteriophage therapy for the treatment of paranasal biofilm using an animal model | In sheep frontal sinuses, | Phage cocktail (CT-PA containing Pa193, Pa204, Pa222 and Pa223)- Intranasal | Statistically significant reduction in the bacterial community of biofilm was obtained | Fong et al. |
| Effect of combination therapy on resistant bacteria forming a biofilm | Combination treatment against In-vitro biofilm cultures of | Phage (T4-ATCC11303-B4 and PB-1-ATCC15692-B3) and antibiotic (tobramycin)—Direct inoculation | Significant biofilm reduction as 99% antibiotic-resistant cells of | Coulter et al. |
| Bacteriophages induce structural changes in biofilms that eradicate them effectively | Phage (KPO1K2 and NDP) and antibiotic (ciprofloxacin)—Direct inoculation | The highest reduction in bacterial load observed after 6 h of combined treatment | Verma et al. | |
| An experimental study for an anti-biofilm activity via antibiotic and bacteriophage | In microtiter plates, | Phage (SAP-26) and antibiotic (azithromycin, vancomycin and rifampicin)—Direct inoculation | Reduction of 65% with rifampicin, 60% with azithromycin and 40% with vancomycin when exposed to combined therapy | Rahman et al. |
| Synergistic effect of phages and antibiotics for the destruction of biofilms | In microtiter plates, | Phage (NP1 & NP3) and antibiotic (ceftazidime, ciprofloxacin, colistin, gentamycin & tobramycin)-Direct inoculation | As compared to other drugs, the synergistic effect of phages and drugs was highest with tobramycin | Chaudhry et al. |
Overview of bacteriophage clinical studies for the treatment of heart and pulmonary diseases
| Case study | Description | Administration | Result | References |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bacteriophage therapy for an aortic graft infection | A 76-year-old patient underwent surgery for an aortic aneurysm with Dacron graft, which resulted in MDR | Phage (OMKO1) and antibiotics (ceftazidime)-direct injection into the site (mediastinal fistula) | Infection eradicated with no signs of recurrence in 18 months | Chan et al. |
| Synergistic effect of bacteriophages and antibiotics for endocarditis | Experimental aortic endocarditis caused by | Phage cocktail (PP1131) and antibiotic (ciprofloxacin)-intravenous | Combination therapy resulted in killing bacterial vegetation within 6 h and treating 64% of rats | Oechslin et al. |
| Bacteriophage therapy for the treatment of pneumonia | Seven-week-old female mice were inoculated intra-nasally with MDR | Phage (1513)-intranasal | After therapy lung lesions improved and bacterial count decreased | Cao et al. |
| Evaluation of therapy and efficacy of bacteriophage cocktail in an in-vivo nasal and lung infections | In the six-week-old female mice, clinical MDR | Phage cocktail (PBAB08, PBAB25, PBAB68, PBAB80, PBAB93)-intranasal | Decreased bacterial concentration in lung resulted in a 60% survival rate of mice | Cha et al. |
| Phage therapy for critical Infections associated with Cardiothoracic surgery | Eight patients with immunosuppression after organ transplantation were infected via MDR | Phage (CH1, Enf1, PA5, PA10, KPV811, KPV15, Sa30, SCH1, SCH111, ECD7, V18)-local, intraoperatively, inhalation and intranasal Antibiotics (cefepime, daptomycin, linezolid, tobramycin, ceftazidime, colistin, meropenem, co-triamoxazole, rifampicin, flucloxacillin, sultamicillin and clindamycin)—oral and intravenous | No major adverse effects, seven out of eight people got their target bacteria eradicated | Rubalskii et al. |
MDR: Multi-drug resistant
Overview of bacteriophage clinical studies for the treatment of gastrointestinal infections
| Case study | Description | Administration | Result | References |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Clinical coliphage analysis in Bangladesh to treat acute bacterial diarrhoea | In the hospital, 6–24-month-old children with acute watery diarrhoea due to the pathogenic | Phage cocktail (T4 containing AB2, 4, 6, 11, 46, 50, 55; JS34, 37, 98, D1.4 and Microgen Coli Proteus)- Oral | 93% of patients treated with coliphage recovered from diarrhoea within 6 days | Sarker et al. |
| Combined bacteriophage treatment for septic peritonitis | Female mice inoculated with a lethal dose of VRE disseminated intraperitoneally to intra-and extra-peritoneal organs | Phage (EFDGI and EFLK1) and antibiotics (ampicillin)-Intraperitoneal | 100% successful treatment via bacteriophage cocktail alone for critically ill mice and 60% the success rate for combination therapy | Gelman et al. |
| Bacteriophage therapy for intestinal MDR bacteria eradication | Due to increased antimicrobial resistance in gut bacteria, the effect of single-dose of bacteriophage on MDR | Phage#-Oral | The colony-forming unit of | Chaturvedi and Nath |
| Bacteriophage therapy against MDR strain for the treatment of bacteremia | An immunocompromised mouse model was developed where colonised MDR | Phage (HP3)-Intraperitoneal | Gastrointestinal bacteremia decreased dramatically after phage therapy relative to untreated mice | Green et al. |
MDR multi-drug resistant, VRE vancomycin-resistant Enterococcus faecalis; Phage#: Customized Phage cocktail (No identification given)
Overview of bacteriophage clinical studies for the treatment of septicemia/bloodstream infections
| Case study | Description | Administration | Result | References |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A case report of bacteriophage therapy for the treatment of septicaemia in a patient | A 61-year-old man with peritonitis infection and other complications developed large necrotic pressure sores by MDR | Phage (BFC1)-Intrevenous and Topical | Fever disappeared, CRP level dropped, and blood culture turned negative for | Jennes et al. |
| Experimental phage therapy for the treatment of liver abscesses and bacteremia | The mice intragastrical inoculation of | Phage (NK5)-Oral or Intraperitoneal | The bacterial count was eliminated virtually from both blood and liver tissues | Hung et al. |
| Bacteriophage therapy for the treatment of septicaemia | One-month-old BALB / c mice were intraperitoneally inoculated to mimic in-vivo neonatal septicaemia with clinical MDR | Phage (CSV-31)-Intraperitoneal | 100% survival rate with minimal signs of illness after 24 h of treatment | Vinodkumar et al. |
| Treatment of bacteremia by phage therapy in an immunocompromised and stable host | A diabetic and non-diabetic six-week-old BALB/c mouse was induced with | Phage (GRCS)-Intraperitoneal | 90% survival rate for diabetic and 100% survival rate for non-diabetic after treatment | Sunagar et al. |
| Efficacy of bacteriophage therapy for sepsis in mice model | Each mouse was inoculated orally and intraperitoneally with | Phage (KPP10)-Oral, Intravenous and Intraperitoneal | 92.3% of phage treated mice survived as compared to 41.7% phage untreated mice | Watanabe et al. |
MDR: Multidrug-resistant; CRP: C-reactive protein
Overview of bacteriophage clinical studies for the treatment of skin and soft tissue infections
| Case study | Description | Administration | Result | References |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Transfersomal phage cocktail treatment against SSTIs in a rat model | The posterior portion of both thighs of 4–6 week old female rats was intramuscularly injected with | Phage (MR-5 & MR-10)-Intramuscular | 100% survival rate was observed for both 30 min and 12 h post-infection | Chhibber et al. |
| Comparison of bacteriophage and antibiotics for the treatment of burn wound infection | A BALB/c mouse was infected with | Phage (Kpn5) or antibiotic (silver nitrate and gentamycin)-Topical | Survival rate (63.3%) via phage was higher than other two agents (56.66% & 53.33%) and untreated phage group | Kumari et al. |
| A clinical trial for the treatment of wounds via a bacteriophage cocktail | Patients aged between 12 to 60 years with chronic non-healing wounds caused by | Phage#-Topical | Seven patient infections eradicated, while the remaining 13 wound sizes decreased significantly | Gupta et al. |
| Bacteriophage therapy against abscess induced in a rabbit model | Phage (LS2a)-subcutaneous | Abscess in 90% of rabbits cured completely | Wills et al. |
SSTIs: Skin and soft tissue infections; Phage#: Cocktail of phages (No identification given)