Literature DB >> 34788098

Search for exotic spin-dependent interactions with a spin-based amplifier.

Haowen Su1,2,3, Yuanhong Wang1,2,3, Min Jiang1,2,3, Wei Ji4, Pavel Fadeev5,6, Dongdong Hu7, Xinhua Peng1,2,3, Dmitry Budker5,6,8.   

Abstract

Development of new techniques to search for particles beyond the standard model is crucial for understanding the ultraviolet completion of particle physics. Several hypothetical particles are predicted to mediate exotic spin-dependent interactions between standard-model particles that may be accessible to laboratory experiments. However, laboratory searches are mostly conducted for static spin-dependent interactions, with a few experiments addressing spin- and velocity-dependent interactions. Here, we demonstrate a search for these interactions with a spin-based amplifier. Our technique uses hyperpolarized nuclear spins as an amplifier for pseudo-magnetic fields produced by exotic interactions by a factor of more than 100. Using this technique, we establish constraints on the spin- and velocity-dependent interactions between polarized neutrons and unpolarized nucleons for the force range of 0.03 to 100 meters, improving previous constraints by at least two orders of magnitude in partial force range. This technique can be further extended to investigate other exotic spin-dependent interactions.

Entities:  

Year:  2021        PMID: 34788098      PMCID: PMC8597990          DOI: 10.1126/sciadv.abi9535

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  Sci Adv        ISSN: 2375-2548            Impact factor:   14.136


INTRODUCTION

Numerous theories extending beyond the standard model of particle physics predict the existence of new bosons that could mediate long-range interactions between two objects of the standard model (–). Such theories are related with the spontaneous breaking of continuous symmetries, yielding massless or light (pseudo) Nambu-Goldstone bosons, such as axions (, ), dark photons (), paraphotons (), familons (), and majorons (). The exchange of such particles results in exotic spin-dependent interactions that may be accessible to laboratory experiments (, ). Various experiments have been conducted to search for exotic spin-dependent interactions, making use of the torsion balance (, ), trapped ions (, ), geoelectrons (, ), spin-exchange relaxation-free magnetometers (, ), comagnetometers (, ), nitrogen-vacancy diamond (–), and other high-sensitivity techniques (–). Recently, the approach based on nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) (–) has been proposed to search for exotic interactions and could substantially improve current experimental limits set by astrophysics, such as axion resonant interaction detection experiment (ARIADNE) (). The exotic interactions mediated by light bosons were introduced by Moody and Wilczek (), extended by Dobrescu and Mocioiu () with the inclusion of the terms dependent on the relative velocity between the two interacting particles, and revised in (). In the latter work (), the potentials were sorted by types of coupling (scalar, vector, etc.), contact interactions were included, and coordinate-space representation was used. Sorting by spin-momentum form, there are 15 possible exotic interactions between ordinary particles that contain static spin-dependent operators, velocity-dependent operators, or combinations of these. Some of them may break the charge, parity, and time-reversal symmetries or their combinations (, ); they were introduced to understand the symmetries of charge conjugation and parity in quantum chromodynamics (). Many experiments have been performed to search for static spin-dependent interactions (, –, –, , , , , ), while the velocity-dependent interactions have been studied less extensively (, , , , ). Following the notation in (, ), the spin- and velocity-dependent interactions to be studied here arewhere f4+5 and f12+13 are dimensionless coupling constant, c is the speed of light in vacuum, is the spin vector and m is the mass of the polarized fermion, is the relative velocity between two interacting fermions, is the unit vector in the direction between them, and λ = ħ(m)−1 is the force range (or the boson Compton wavelength) with m being the light boson mass. In particular, apart from common interests on the interaction V4+5 mediated by new bosons described in (), the search for V4+5 could provide an experimental test for extensions of electrodynamics proposed by a recent study (). Moreover, the search for V12+13 could provide a new source for parity symmetry violation (, ). Careful investigations on those interactions may give clues for understanding fundamental physical questions such as the matter-antimatter asymmetry of the universe. Here, we demonstrate a search for the exotic spin- and velocity-dependent interactions with a spin-based amplifier (). The technique takes advantage of the resonant coupling between the rotation frequency of an unpolarized nucleon mass and a spin-based amplifier with a matching spin-precession frequency. The signal from the pseudo-magnetic field produced by the exchange of light bosons can be amplified by at least two orders of magnitude. Using such a spin-based amplifier, we establish constraints on the spin- and velocity-dependent interactions between polarized and unpolarized nucleons in the force range of 0.03 to 100 m. For f4+5, our work sets the most stringent constraints on f4+5 for the force range from 0.04 to 100 m. For λ=1.0 m, our work improves over existing constraints by about four orders of magnitude (, ). Moreover, our work sets the most stringent constraints on f12 + 13 in the force range from 0.05 to 6 m, at 0.45 m reaching 1.01 × 10−34 [95% confidence level (C.L.)], improving over previous laboratory limits by at least two orders of magnitude (, ). We would like to emphasize the difference of resonant searches between this work and other existing works. Although, recently, there have been many works that propose the NMR resonant searches of the exotic spin-dependent interactions (–), their experimental demonstrations are ongoing. In contrast, our work demonstrates an experiment of the resonance detection method to search for exotic spin-dependent interactions and places new constraints on them. Moreover, previous works all consider the situation where the nuclear spins are measured from a distance with atomic and superconducting quantum interference device magnetometers; in this case, it is experimentally challenging to prepare high nuclear-spin polarization and maintain readout sensitivity. In contrast, our work uses a different scheme in which polarized nucleons and the detector are spatially overlapping in the same vapor cell, offering two notable advantages (see section SIV): Nuclear spins can be directly hyperpolarized to achieve a polarization of 0.1 to 0.3 by spin-exchange optical pumping, reducing the polarization loss during transporting nuclear spins to detection region; nuclear spin signals can be enhanced due to large Fermi-contact enhancement (on the order of 600), measured in situ with an atomic magnetometer. Using such a sensor, we immediately obtain new constraints on the spin- and velocity-dependent interactions.

RESULTS

Principle

Our experiment is to detect the pseudo-magnetic field produced by exotic spin- and velocity-dependent interactions. These interactions induce energy shift of 129Xe spins (), where μXe is the magnetic moment of 129Xe spin, V represents the potential that we measure (V4+5 or V12+13), and is the pseudo-magnetic field. As is typical (, ), we assume that the coupling to unpolarized fermions is the same for neutrons and protons and is 0 for electrons in the unpolarized mass. We note that the contribution of neutrons is 73% in 129Xe () and therefore set , where A is the numerical factor from the integration over all the nucleons in the bismuth germanate insulator Bi4Ge3O12 (BGO) crystal (see Materials and Methods), and f represents f4+5 and f12+13. The pseudo-magnetic field is resonantly measured with the spin-based amplifier consisting of the spatially overlapping ensembles of spin-polarized 87Rb and 129Xe, as shown in Fig. 1. 129Xe spins act as an amplifier for the signal from the oscillating pseudo-magnetic field. The field slightly tilts 129Xe spins and induces an oscillating 129Xe transverse magnetization that is read out by 87Rb spins. The spin dynamics can be described by the coupled Bloch equations (, , )where P (P) is the polarization of 87Rb electron (129Xe nucleus), γ (γ) is the gyromagnetic radio of the 87Rb electron (129Xe nucleus), Q is the electron slowing-down factor that originated from hyperfine interaction and spin-exchange collisions, is the applied bias field; () is the maximum magnetization of 87Rb electron (129Xe nucleus) associated with full spin polarizations, () is the equilibrium polarization of the 87Rb electron (129Xe nucleus), T is the common relaxation time of 87Rb electron spins, and T1 (T2) is the longitudinal (transverse) relaxation time of 129Xe spins. The Fermi-contact interaction between 87Rb and 129Xe pairs introduces an effective magnetic field , where β = 8πκ0/3 (, , ). The effective field generated by 129Xe spins is read out in situ with the 87Rb magnetometer.
Fig. 1.

Experimental setup.

The 87Rb magnetometer uses a 0.5-cm3 cubic cell consisting of 5 torr isotopically enriched 129Xe, 250 torr N2 as buffer gas, and a droplet of 87Rb. The vapor cell is placed inside a five-layer cylindrical μ-metal shield to reduce the ambient magnetic field. A bias field is applied along z to tune the 129Xe Larmor frequency to ν0 ≈ 4.995 Hz. The 87Rb spins are polarized by optical pumping with 795-nm D1 light. 87Rb-129Xe spin-exchange collisions polarize 129Xe spins to ~30% (, ). The x component of 87Rb spins is measured via optical rotation of a linearly polarized probe beam (–), which is blue-detuned 110 GHz to 87Rb D2 transition at 780 nm. The right inset shows the configuration of a bismuth germanate insulator [Bi4Ge3O12 (BGO)] mass and a motor. A single BGO mass at the end of an aluminum rod rotates with frequency ν0 ≈ 4.995 Hz to generate the spin- and velocity-dependent interactions. BE, beam expander; LP, linear polarizer; λ/4, quarter–wave plate; PD, photodiode; PEM, photoelastic modulator; DAQ, data acquisition; OS, optoelectronic switch.

Experimental setup.

The 87Rb magnetometer uses a 0.5-cm3 cubic cell consisting of 5 torr isotopically enriched 129Xe, 250 torr N2 as buffer gas, and a droplet of 87Rb. The vapor cell is placed inside a five-layer cylindrical μ-metal shield to reduce the ambient magnetic field. A bias field is applied along z to tune the 129Xe Larmor frequency to ν0 ≈ 4.995 Hz. The 87Rb spins are polarized by optical pumping with 795-nm D1 light. 87Rb-129Xe spin-exchange collisions polarize 129Xe spins to ~30% (, ). The x component of 87Rb spins is measured via optical rotation of a linearly polarized probe beam (–), which is blue-detuned 110 GHz to 87Rb D2 transition at 780 nm. The right inset shows the configuration of a bismuth germanate insulator [Bi4Ge3O12 (BGO)] mass and a motor. A single BGO mass at the end of an aluminum rod rotates with frequency ν0 ≈ 4.995 Hz to generate the spin- and velocity-dependent interactions. BE, beam expander; LP, linear polarizer; λ/4, quarter–wave plate; PD, photodiode; PEM, photoelastic modulator; DAQ, data acquisition; OS, optoelectronic switch. We first consider the resonant response of the spin-based amplifier to a single-frequency component, for example, of the pseudo-magnetic field . In this situation, the bias field is tuned to satisfy the resonant condition . Because of negligible and relatively strong bias field , 129Xe spins independently evolve without the influence of 87Rb spins. For small transverse excitations of 129Xe spins, we can derive the steady-state solution of 129Xe transverse polarization from Eq. 4. A detailed derivation can be found in the Supplementary Materials (section SIII) and (). The corresponding transverse magnetization generates a measurable oscillating effective magnetic field on 87Rb magnetometer. As a result, the amplitude of the effective field isWe define a factor that represents the amplification of the signal from the pseudo-magnetic field. This shows that the signal from the pseudo-magnetic field can be preamplified by the hyperpolarized long-lived 129Xe spins. Specifically, because of large Fermi-contact enhancement factor κ0 ≈ 540 for 129Xe-87Rb system, η is estimated to be more than 100 (). For 3He-K system, for which the spin-coherence time is much longer (∼1000 s) (, , ), η can reach 104. We note that the overlapping spin ensemble (e.g., 129Xe-87Rb) is also used in “self-compensating” comagnetometers (, , ); however, the present spin-based amplifier is quite different from them (see section SIV). In contrast to comagnetometers that should operate in a specific near-zero bias field, the spin-based amplifier operates in a broad range of bias fields, leading to the difference in the explored frequency range and sensitivity. For example, the self-compensating comagnetometer is insensitive to normal magnetic field and is usually used to search for low-frequency exotic signals, whereas the spin-based amplifier remains sensitive to both magnetic field and pseudo-magnetic field ranging from 1 Hz to 1 kHz, which makes them attractive in searching for new physics predicted by numerous theories beyond the standard model, for example, ultralight axion-like dark matter ().

Experimental setup

Experiments are performed using a setup similar to that of (, ), depicted in Fig. 1. We experimentally calibrate the amplification factor η and the corresponding enhanced magnetic field sensitivity of 87Rb magnetometer. For example, the bias field is set as 423 nT, corresponding to 129Xe Larmor frequency ν0 ≈ 4.995 Hz. An oscillating magnetic field of 13.0 pT is applied along y to simulate the single-frequency pseudo-magnetic field . By scanning the oscillation frequency ν near the resonance, the maximum value on resonance is determined as the amplification factor. As shown in Fig. 2A, the signal amplitude is well described by a single-pole band-pass filter model (see inset) () (see section SIII), yielding the full width at half maximum (FWHM) of 24 mHz. The maximum η ≈ 116 is achieved at ν ≈ ν0 ≈ 4.995 Hz. By taking the response of the spin-based amplifier into account, the magnetic sensitivity of 87Rb magnetometer is enhanced to ≈22 fT/, whereas the off-resonance sensitivity of 87Rb magnetometer is only about 2 pT/. Moreover, the enhanced sensitivity is far beyond that of the state-of-the-art magnetometers demonstrated with nuclear spins (, ), which are usually limited to a few picotesla sensitivity. Therefore, an atomic magnetometer enhanced with a spin-based amplifier is well suited for resonantly searching for exotic spin- and velocity-dependent interactions.
Fig. 2.

Demonstration of the spin-based amplifier and basic principle of exotic interaction searches.

(A) Sensitivity of the spin-amplifier–based magnetometer. The inset exhibits the frequency dependence of the amplification factor. The experimental data (black dots) are obtained by applying a calibration field along y. As demonstrated in the Supplementary Materials (section SIII), the red solid line is a theoretical fit of the data with (), where the FWHM is mHz. The enhanced sensitivity of the spin-amplifier–based magnetometer reaches at 4.995 Hz. (B) Three-dimensional diagram of the enhanced signals from with the spin-based amplifier. The x axis represents the frequency dependence of the spin-based amplifier [see (A) inset]. The y axis represents the decomposition of the pseudo-magnetic field generated by the single rotating BGO crystal. By scanning the resonant frequency ν0 of the spin-based amplifier, there are three peaks of enhanced signals at harmonics of with matched frequency ν0 = v,2v,3v. The signal of the pseudo-magnetic field reaches maximum, colored with red, at 4.995 Hz.

Demonstration of the spin-based amplifier and basic principle of exotic interaction searches.

(A) Sensitivity of the spin-amplifier–based magnetometer. The inset exhibits the frequency dependence of the amplification factor. The experimental data (black dots) are obtained by applying a calibration field along y. As demonstrated in the Supplementary Materials (section SIII), the red solid line is a theoretical fit of the data with (), where the FWHM is mHz. The enhanced sensitivity of the spin-amplifier–based magnetometer reaches at 4.995 Hz. (B) Three-dimensional diagram of the enhanced signals from with the spin-based amplifier. The x axis represents the frequency dependence of the spin-based amplifier [see (A) inset]. The y axis represents the decomposition of the pseudo-magnetic field generated by the single rotating BGO crystal. By scanning the resonant frequency ν0 of the spin-based amplifier, there are three peaks of enhanced signals at harmonics of with matched frequency ν0 = v,2v,3v. The signal of the pseudo-magnetic field reaches maximum, colored with red, at 4.995 Hz. The pseudo-magnetic field, for example, is generated by the rotor (see Materials and Methods) in Fig. 1. For a source of unpolarized nucleons, we use a single 112.34-g BGO crystal with a high number density of nucleons (). Driven by a servo motor, the single BGO crystal connected to a 48.76-cm aluminum rod rotates with frequency ν ≈ 4.995 Hz in the xz plane. The rotation frequency can be measured through the triggered optoelectronic pulses. The center of the aluminum rod is located 58.32 cm away from the center of the 129Xe vapor cell. The rotating BGO crystal generates a pseudo-magnetic field along y. As demonstrated in the Supplementary Materials (section SII), the field can be decomposed intowhere Nν is the multiple frequency, and is the corresponding field strength. For example, we consider the case of λ = 1.0 m and for V4+5 generated by the BGO crystal (see Eq. 1). On the basis of our numerical simulation (see Materials and Methods), the ratios of the field strengths at harmonic frequencies are , as shown in Fig. 2B (y axis). Accordingly, we choose the dominant (N = 1) first harmonic at 4.995 Hz to be measured. To this end, we set the operation frequency of the spin-based amplifier at ν0 ≈ 4.995 Hz. In this situation, because of the relatively narrow bandwidth of the spin-based amplifier, only the signal at 4.995 Hz can be considerably amplified, and the other harmonics are negligible. Considerable effort is made to reduce undesirable noise, such as air vibration, spurious magnetic noise, electronic cross-talk, etc., before search experiments. For example, the rotating aluminum rod can cause air vibration on the spin-based amplifier, leading to a noise peak at 2ν. To solve this, an enclosure for the spin-based amplifier setup is used to reduce the air vibration effect. Moreover, a single BGO crystal is used, which generates the exotic signal at the frequency of ν and thus avoids the 2ν air vibration effect. While the rotor system is mostly symmetric, the small imbalance due to the single BGO crystal can cause some mechanical vibration. However, we found that this vibration can be neglected in our experiment. We note that the aluminum rod is also a source of unpolarized nucleons, which generates the pseudo-magnetic field consisting of even harmonics at 2Nν. The details are presented in the Supplementary Materials (section SII). Nevertheless, the potential pseudo-magnetic field from the aluminum rod can be neglected, because the sensitive frequency of the spin-based amplifier is set at the odd harmonics ν ≈ 4.995 Hz. A commercial miniaturized atomic magnetometer is mounted in the vicinity of the vapor cell and used to monitor the spurious magnetic noise (see section SI). To suppress the electronic cross-talk caused by the motor and its control system, all equipment related to the setup of the spin-based amplifier is powered from a different circuit to eliminate all connections between them.

New constraints on V4 and V12

In our experiment, extracting the weak signal with a known carrier frequency from noisy environment is crucial in obtaining the signal from the pseudo-magnetic field. To do this, we use a “lock-in” analysis scheme, similar to the similarity analysis method described in (). The signal is extracted through a reference signal cos (2πνt + ϕ) obtained from the simulated pseudo-magnetic field. The phase ϕ is the phase delay between the measured magnetic field and the output signal of the spin-based amplifier. The detailed calibration is presented in the Supplementary Materials (section SV). The extracted coupling strength of one period T iswhere α is the calibration constant, and S(t) is the experimental signal. Here, is the field strength corresponding to for the force range λ = 1.0 m. To obtain the coupling strength f4+5 at a different force range, should be accordingly recalculated (see Materials and Methods). Histogram of experimentally measured coupling strength for 1 hour at 4.995 Hz is shown in Fig. 3. The fit with Gaussian distribution to the histogram gives the mean value and the SE of the coupling strength for 1-hour data (9.98 ± 0.83stat) × 10−19. The coupling strength collected for 5 hours is for counterclockwise rotation. We note that the mean value of the coupling strength is about 20σ from 0, as shown in Fig. 3. To separate the signal from pseudo-magnetic fields from the spurious signal, we perform the velocity-dependent experiments, where three different frequencies ν ≈ {4.114,4.552,4.995} Hz are chosen. By extracting the velocity-dependent signal, the velocity-independent spurious signal is greatly suppressed. To further eliminate the velocity-independent spurious signal, we compare the results between clockwise and counterclockwise cycles. After averaging over all rotating circles, the coupling strength is obtained f4+5 ≈ (1.08 ± 2.48stat) × 10−20 and f12+13 ≈ (1.13 ± 2.24stat) × 10−35. The details are presented in the Supplementary Materials (section SV).
Fig. 3.

The histogram of the potential experimental coupling strength .

Distribution of the experimental coupling strength of 1-hour data at ν0 ≈ 4.995 Hz for counterclockwise rotation. The red solid line is a fit to a Gaussian distribution. The χ2 ≈ 1.07 represents a valid fitting.

The histogram of the potential experimental coupling strength .

Distribution of the experimental coupling strength of 1-hour data at ν0 ≈ 4.995 Hz for counterclockwise rotation. The red solid line is a fit to a Gaussian distribution. The χ2 ≈ 1.07 represents a valid fitting. Table 1 summarizes the systematic errors at λ = 1.0 m in our experiment. The details of calibrating the experimental parameters and obtaining the systematic errors are presented in the Supplementary Materials (section SV). In our experiments, there are two factors leading to the fluctuation of the calibration constant δα: (i) the intrinsic instability of the spin-based amplifier and (ii) the external instability of the rotor rotation frequency. The intrinsic instability caused by the fluctuation of the laser beam or temperature is ≈ ± 0.06 V/nT. Because of the narrow bandwidth of the spin-based amplifier, the instability of the rotation frequency is the dominant fluctuation of the calibration constant, reducing the amplification factor and the corresponding calibration constant. The frequency difference ≈0.004 Hz results in ≈14% of the reduction of the calibration constant ≈ − 0.28 V/nT. The overall systematic uncertainty is derived by combining all the systematic errors in quadrature. Accordingly, we quote the final total coupling strength f4+5 as (1.08 ± 2.48stat ± 0.82syst) × 10−20. Similarly, f12+13 ≈ (1.13 ± 2.24stat ± 0.94syst) × 10−35 is obtained.
Table 1.

Summary of systematic errors.

The corrections to at λ = 1.0 m are listed.

Parameter Value Δf4+5exp(×1020)
Mass of BGO (g)112.34 ± 0.02∓0.0002
Position of pivot x(mm)−3.4 ± 0.5 +0.01080.0114
Position of pivot y(mm)6.0 ± 0.3±0.0001
Position of pivot z(mm)583.2 ± 1.1±0.0051
Length of aluminumrod (mm)487.6 ± 0.7∓0.0025
Phase delay ϕ (°)79.1 ± 6.0 +0.65330.6648
Calib. const. α (V/nT) 1.910.28+0.06 +0.18370.0274
Final f4 + 5( × 10−20)1.08±2.48 (statistical)
(λ = 1.0 m)±0.82*

*The origin of coordinates was at the center of the vapor cell.

Summary of systematic errors.

The corrections to at λ = 1.0 m are listed. *The origin of coordinates was at the center of the vapor cell. Figure 4 shows the constraints on V4+5 and V12+13 set by this work. Dark areas represent excluded values with 95% C.L. corresponding to 1.96 times the quadrature of the statistical error and systematic error (see section SV). The previous constraints of f4+5 were established with a cold neutron reflectometer () (λ < 0.04 m) and a slow neutron polarimeter () (λ < 0.01 m). In contrast, our work sets the most stringent constraints on f4+5 for the force range from 0.04 to 100 m, as shown in Fig. 4A. For λ=1.0 m, our work improves over previous constraints by about four orders of magnitude. f4 + 5 can be the combination of the scalar neutron coupling with the scalar nucleon coupling. Our work constrains the axion mass 10−6 eV≲m ≲ 7 × 10−6 eV, which is within the important axion window (). In Fig. 4B, our work constrains f12 + 13 in the force range from 0.03 to 100 m. Recent works placed constraints with a cold neutron beam () (λ < 0.06 m) and polarized 3He () (λ > 4 m). Comparing with them, our work sets the most stringent constraints in the force range from 0.05 to 6 m, at 0.45 m reaching 1.01 × 10−34 (95% C.L.), improving over previous laboratory limits by at least two orders of magnitude.
Fig. 4.

Constraints (95% C.L.) on f4 and f12.

% In (A), the dashed lines represent bounds of f4 + 5 from (, ). Our work (solid line) sets the most stringent constraints on f4 + 5 for the force range from 0.04 to 100 m. In (B), the dashed lines are from (, ). The solid line is the constraint of f12 + 13 established by our work, which set the most stringent constraints in the force range from 0.05 to 6 m.

Constraints (95% C.L.) on f4 and f12.

% In (A), the dashed lines represent bounds of f4 + 5 from (, ). Our work (solid line) sets the most stringent constraints on f4 + 5 for the force range from 0.04 to 100 m. In (B), the dashed lines are from (, ). The solid line is the constraint of f12 + 13 established by our work, which set the most stringent constraints in the force range from 0.05 to 6 m.

DISCUSSION

As demonstrated in (, ), the spin-dependent interactions between two fermions can be mediated by a massive spin-1 boson Z′. The effective Lagrangian of the light boson iswhere ψ is the fermion field, and γμ, γ5 are Dirac matrices. On the basis of the effective Lagrangian, we can link the coupling strength f4+5 and f12+13 to the appropriate property of the new bosons, i.e., the product of interaction coupling constants ()where () is the axial-vector interaction coupling constant, and () is the vector interaction coupling constant for neutrons (nucleons). We note that some spin-spin–dependent interactions (e.g., V11 and V3) could also constrain the spin-1 bosons. However, because of the difficulty in preparing polarized nuclear spins with large number and shielding itself from spurious dipole magnetic field, several experiments, so far, addressed the spin-spin–dependent interactions between nucleons, and their search sensitivity was limited (). In contrast, benefiting from the availability of the unpolarized nucleons, the search for V12+13 to constrain the spin-1 boson is of experimental interests. We can extract the most stringent limits from direct measurement using the interaction V12+13 for spin-1 bosons for the force range from 0.05 to 0.6 m, not yet competing with combined limits on () and () for these ranges. Although demonstrated for the spin- and velocity-dependent interactions, the spin-based amplifier is well suited to searching for other exotic interactions, for example, the spin-spin-velocity interactions (V6+7, V8, V14, V15, and V16). The resonantly oscillating pseudo-magnetic fields can be generated by modulating the relative speed between the source and 129Xe amplifier. Combining our current 129Xe-based amplifier and recently developed SmCo5 spin sources (, ), the sensitivity to ∣f6+7∣<10−20,∣f14∣<10−31,∣f15∣<10−4,∣f16∣<10−4 can potentially reach into unexplored parameter space for the force range from 0.01 to 100 m, while for ∣f8∣<10−23, this is the case for the force range from 0.01 to 1 m. A further improvement of the experimental sensitivity to spin-dependent interactions can be anticipated by using 3He noble gas as the spin-based amplifier, which has much longer spin-coherence time and larger gyromagnetic ratio than those of 129Xe (). Using 3He-K systems, the projected magnetic sensitivity to those spin-dependent interactions can be improved by four orders of magnitude (). The details are presented in the Supplementary Materials (see section SVI). In this work, we have reported new constraints, based on a spin-based amplifier, on exotic spin- and velocity-dependent interactions. Using our spin-based amplifier technique, we anticipate that our work will stimulate interesting new research for new nuclear physics predicted by numerous theories beyond the standard model, for example, the searches for axion-like particles () and dark photons ().

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The exotic spin- and velocity-dependent interactions V4+5 and V12+13 are generated by a single cube-shaped BGO crystal with 25.0 × 25.0 × 25.0 mm3 total volume. The 112.34-g BGO crystal is mounted in a box at one end of a symmetric aluminum rod (see Fig. 1). The center of the 48.76-cm aluminum rod is located 58.32 cm away from the center of the 129Xe vapor cell. The center of the aluminum rod is connected to a servo motor fixed on a stable aluminum platform, through a cylindrical titanium rod. Driven by the motor, the BGO cystal and the aluminum rod rotate with a frequency ν ≈ 4.995 Hz in the xz plane. To precisely determine the rotation frequency ν, a bronze needle is fixed on the titanium rod to trigger pulses when passing through the optoelectronic switch. Specific design details and the schematic figure of the rotor can be found in the Supplementary Materials (section SI).

Simulation of the pseudo-magnetic fields

To obtain the reference signal for lock-in analysis scheme, we simulate the pseudo-magnetic fields and before data analysis. The pseudo-magnetic field can be obtained by integrating over the whole volume of the BGO crystalwhere ρ() is the BGO crystal’s nucleon density at location , and m is the mass of a neutron. The pseudo-magnetic field is not a pure trigonometric function containing the harmonics of ν (i.e., ν, 2ν, and 3ν). In our experiment, because of the relatively narrow bandwidth ≈24 mHz of the spin-based amplifier, only the first harmonic [i.e., ] can be resonantly amplified, and other harmonics can be neglected. Hence, we filter the simulated signal and obtain the first harmonic as the reference signal, which is demonstrated in the Supplementary Materials (section SII). The pseudo-magnetic field can be derived by the same method demonstrated aboveIn contrast to , the pseudo-magnetic field contains two components along x and z. We note that the spin-based amplifier is insensitive to the oscillating field along z, because the oscillating field along z cannot induce 129Xe transverse magnetization. Therefore, only the x component of the pseudo-magnetic field should be considered. Considering the bandwidth of the spin-based amplifier, we filter the simulated signal and obtain the first harmonic as reference signal, which is demonstrated in the Supplementary Materials (section SII).

Data analysis

In our experiment, the lock-in analysis scheme is applied to extract the coupling strengths f4+5 and f12+13. The experimental signal S(t) is filtered around the resonance frequency and separated into segments of one period S(t). The reference signal of one period is obtained by applying the same filter to the simulated pseudo-magnetic field. After performing the lock-in analysis scheme and extracting the coupling strength , the histogram of all the experimental coupling strengths is obtained. The fit with Gaussian distribution to the histogram gives the mean value and the SE of the coupling strength for 1-hour data. By averaging the five coupling strengths and calculating the uncertainty propagation, we obtain the coupling strength for 5-hour data. It is important to separate the exotic signal generated by spin-dependent interactions from the spurious signal. First, to eliminate the velocity-independent spurious signal, we perform velocity-dependent experiments by changing the rotation frequency ν of the BGO rotor. According to the mathematical structure of V4+5, V12+13, the signal from the pseudo-magnetic fields should be proportional to the rotation frequency. Therefore, after obtaining the coupling strength at different frequencies ν ≈ {4.114,4.552,4.995} Hz, the coupling strength fCCW for counterclockwise cycles is extracted by using a theoretical fit. After the fit, we extract the velocity-dependent signal including the signal from spin-dependent interactions and the velocity-dependent spurious signal. To further eliminate the spurious signal, we compare the results between clockwise and counterclockwise cycles. On the basis of the lock-in analysis scheme, the coupling strength is independent of rotation direction, whereas the velocity-dependent spurious signal is reversed for counterclockwise and clockwise cycles. If the velocity-dependent spurious signal dominates, we should observe that fCCW and fCW have reversed sign. The coupling strength of clockwise and counterclockwise cycles shows a reversed sign as expected, for example, fCW ≈ (2.41 ± 0.34stat) × 10−19 and fCCW ≈ (−2.19 ± 0.35stat) × 10−19 for the force range λ = 1.0 m. After averaging over all rotating circles, the coupling strength is obtained f4+5 ≈ (1.08 ± 2.48stat) × 10−20. In the same way, f12+13 ≈ (1.13 ± 2.24stat) × 10−35 can be obtained. The detailed process is presented in the Supplementary Materials (section SV).
  32 in total

1.  Limits on the axial coupling constant of new light bosons.

Authors:  Florian M Piegsa; Guillaume Pignol
Journal:  Phys Rev Lett       Date:  2012-05-01       Impact factor: 9.161

2.  Massless gauge bosons other than the photon.

Authors:  Bogdan A Dobrescu
Journal:  Phys Rev Lett       Date:  2005-04-22       Impact factor: 9.161

3.  Nuclear-Spin Comagnetometer Based on a Liquid of Identical Molecules.

Authors:  Teng Wu; John W Blanchard; Derek F Jackson Kimball; Min Jiang; Dmitry Budker
Journal:  Phys Rev Lett       Date:  2018-07-13       Impact factor: 9.161

4.  New limit on possible long-range parity-odd interactions of the neutron from neutron-spin rotation in liquid 4He.

Authors:  H Yan; W M Snow
Journal:  Phys Rev Lett       Date:  2013-02-22       Impact factor: 9.161

5.  Using the Earth as a polarized electron source to search for long-range spin-spin interactions.

Authors:  Larry Hunter; Joel Gordon; Stephen Peck; Daniel Ang; Jung-Fu Lin
Journal:  Science       Date:  2013-02-22       Impact factor: 47.728

6.  Constraints on spin-dependent short-range interaction between nucleons.

Authors:  K Tullney; F Allmendinger; M Burghoff; W Heil; S Karpuk; W Kilian; S Knappe-Grüneberg; W Müller; U Schmidt; A Schnabel; F Seifert; Yu Sobolev; L Trahms
Journal:  Phys Rev Lett       Date:  2013-09-03       Impact factor: 9.161

7.  Using geoelectrons to search for velocity-dependent spin-spin interactions.

Authors:  L R Hunter; D G Ang
Journal:  Phys Rev Lett       Date:  2014-03-06       Impact factor: 9.161

8.  Improved Limits on Spin-Mass Interactions.

Authors:  Junyi Lee; Attaallah Almasi; Michael Romalis
Journal:  Phys Rev Lett       Date:  2018-04-20       Impact factor: 9.161

9.  New Limits on Anomalous Spin-Spin Interactions.

Authors:  Attaallah Almasi; Junyi Lee; Himawan Winarto; Marc Smiciklas; Michael V Romalis
Journal:  Phys Rev Lett       Date:  2020-11-13       Impact factor: 9.161

10.  Experimental limit on an exotic parity-odd spin- and velocity-dependent interaction using an optically polarized vapor.

Authors:  Young Jin Kim; Ping-Han Chu; Igor Savukov; Shaun Newman
Journal:  Nat Commun       Date:  2019-05-21       Impact factor: 14.919

View more

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.