Elena Solli1, Nicole A Colwell1, Christopher Markosian1, Anmol S Johal1, Rebecca Houston2, M Omar Iqbal1, Irene Say1, Joseph I Petrsoric3, Luke D Tomycz4. 1. Department of Neurological Surgery, Rutgers New Jersey Medical School, 90 Bergen Street, Suite 8100, Newark, NJ, 07103, USA. 2. Department of Neurological Surgery, Desert Regional Medical Center, Palm Springs, CA, USA. 3. Department of Neurology, Holy Name Medical Center, Teaneck, NJ, USA. 4. New Jersey Brain and Spine, 70 Park Avenue, Montclair, NJ, 07042, USA. tomyczluke@gmail.com.
Abstract
INTRODUCTION: Epilepsy surgery continues to be profoundly underutilized despite its safety and effectiveness. We sought to investigate factors that may contribute to this phenomenon, with a particular focus on the antecedent underutilization of appropriate preoperative studies. METHODS: We reviewed patient data from a pediatric epilepsy clinic over an 18-month period. Patients with drug-resistant epilepsy (DRE) were categorized according to brain magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) findings (lesional, MRI-negative, or multifocal abnormalities) and type of epilepsy diagnosis based on semiology and electroencephalography (EEG) (focal or generalized). We then analyzed the rates of diagnostic test utilization, surgical referral, and subsequent epilepsy surgery as well as vagus nerve stimulation (VNS). RESULTS: Of the 249 patients with a diagnosis of epilepsy, 138 (55.4%) were found to have DRE. Excluding the 10 patients with DRE who did not undergo MRI, 76 patients (59.4%) were found to be MRI-negative (non-lesional epilepsy), 37 patients (28.9%) were found to have multifocal abnormalities, and 15 patients (11.7%) were found to have a single epileptogenic lesion on MRI (lesional epilepsy). Positron emission tomography (PET) and single-photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) were each completed in nine patients (7.0%) and magnetoencephalography (MEG) in four patients (3.1%). Despite the low utilization rate of adjunctive studies, over half (56.3%) ultimately underwent VNS alone, and 8.6% ultimately underwent definitive intracranial resection or disconnection surgery. CONCLUSIONS: The underutilization of appropriate non-invasive, presurgical testing in patients with focal DRE may in part explain the continued underutilization of definitive, resective/disconnective surgery. For patients without access to a high-volume, multidisciplinary surgical epilepsy center, adjunctive presurgical studies [e.g., PET, SPECT, MEG, electrical source imaging (ESI), EEG-functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI)], even when available, are rarely ordered, and this may contribute to excessive rates of VNS in lieu of definitive intracranial surgery.
INTRODUCTION: Epilepsy surgery continues to be profoundly underutilized despite its safety and effectiveness. We sought to investigate factors that may contribute to this phenomenon, with a particular focus on the antecedent underutilization of appropriate preoperative studies. METHODS: We reviewed patient data from a pediatric epilepsy clinic over an 18-month period. Patients with drug-resistant epilepsy (DRE) were categorized according to brain magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) findings (lesional, MRI-negative, or multifocal abnormalities) and type of epilepsy diagnosis based on semiology and electroencephalography (EEG) (focal or generalized). We then analyzed the rates of diagnostic test utilization, surgical referral, and subsequent epilepsy surgery as well as vagus nerve stimulation (VNS). RESULTS: Of the 249 patients with a diagnosis of epilepsy, 138 (55.4%) were found to have DRE. Excluding the 10 patients with DRE who did not undergo MRI, 76 patients (59.4%) were found to be MRI-negative (non-lesional epilepsy), 37 patients (28.9%) were found to have multifocal abnormalities, and 15 patients (11.7%) were found to have a single epileptogenic lesion on MRI (lesional epilepsy). Positron emission tomography (PET) and single-photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) were each completed in nine patients (7.0%) and magnetoencephalography (MEG) in four patients (3.1%). Despite the low utilization rate of adjunctive studies, over half (56.3%) ultimately underwent VNS alone, and 8.6% ultimately underwent definitive intracranial resection or disconnection surgery. CONCLUSIONS: The underutilization of appropriate non-invasive, presurgical testing in patients with focal DRE may in part explain the continued underutilization of definitive, resective/disconnective surgery. For patients without access to a high-volume, multidisciplinary surgical epilepsy center, adjunctive presurgical studies [e.g., PET, SPECT, MEG, electrical source imaging (ESI), EEG-functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI)], even when available, are rarely ordered, and this may contribute to excessive rates of VNS in lieu of definitive intracranial surgery.
Authors: Anne T Berg; Barbara G Vickrey; John T Langfitt; Michael R Sperling; Thaddeus S Walczak; Shlomo Shinnar; Carl W Bazil; Steven V Pacia; Susan S Spencer Journal: Epilepsia Date: 2003-11 Impact factor: 5.864
Authors: Christian G Bien; Anna L Raabe; Johannes Schramm; Albert Becker; Horst Urbach; Christian E Elger Journal: J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry Date: 2012-10-10 Impact factor: 10.154
Authors: Carmen Barba; Judith Helen Cross; Kees Braun; Massimo Cossu; Kerstin Alexandra Klotz; Salvatore De Masi; Maria Angeles Perez Jiménez; Eija Gaily; Nicola Specchio; Pedro Cabral; Joseph Toulouse; Petia Dimova; Domenica Battaglia; Elena Freri; Alessandro Consales; Elisabetta Cesaroni; Oana Tarta-Arsene; Antonio Gil-Nagel; Ioana Mindruta; Giancarlo Di Gennaro; Marco Giulioni; Martin M Tisdall; Christin Eltze; Muhammad Zubair Tahir; Floor Jansen; Peter van Rijen; Maurits Sanders; Laura Tassi; Stefano Francione; Giorgio Lo Russo; Julia Jacobs; Thomas Bast; Giulia Matta; Marcelo Budke; Concepción Fournier Del Castillo; Eeva-Liisa Metsahonkala; Atte Karppinen; José Carlos Ferreira; Krasimir Minkin; Carlo Efisio Marras; Alexis Arzimanoglou; Renzo Guerrini Journal: Epilepsia Date: 2019-12-26 Impact factor: 5.864
Authors: Verena Brodbeck; Laurent Spinelli; Agustina M Lascano; Claudio Pollo; Karl Schaller; Maria I Vargas; Michael Wissmeyer; Christoph M Michel; Margitta Seeck Journal: Epilepsia Date: 2010-02-26 Impact factor: 5.864
Authors: D C Chugani; H T Chugani; O Muzik; J R Shah; A K Shah; A Canady; T J Mangner; P K Chakraborty Journal: Ann Neurol Date: 1998-12 Impact factor: 10.422
Authors: Maxime O Baud; Thomas Perneger; Attila Rácz; Max C Pensel; Christian Elger; Bertil Rydenhag; Kristina Malmgren; J Helen Cross; Grainne McKenna; Martin Tisdall; Herm J Lamberink; Sylvain Rheims; Philippe Ryvlin; Jean Isnard; François Mauguière; Alexis Arzimanoglou; Serdar Akkol; Kaancan Deniz; Cigdem Ozkara; Morten Lossius; Ivan Rektor; Reetta Kälviäinen; Lotta-Maria Vanhatalo; Petia Dimova; Krassimir Minkin; Anke Maren Staack; Bernhard J Steinhoff; Adam Kalina; Pavel Krsek; Petr Marusic; Zsofia Jordan; Daniel Fabo; Evelien Carrette; Paul Boon; Saulius Rocka; Rūta Mameniškienė; Serge Vulliemoz; Francesca Pittau; Kees P J Braun; Margitta Seeck Journal: Neurology Date: 2018-06-13 Impact factor: 9.910