Shiro Jimi1, Arman Saparov2, Seiko Koizumi3, Motoyasu Miyazaki4, Satoshi Takagi5. 1. Central Lab for Pathology and Morphology, Faculty of Medicine, Fukuoka University, Fukuoka 814-0180, Japan. 2. Department of Medicine, School of Medicine, Nazarbayev University, Nur-Sultan 010000, Kazakhstan. 3. R&D Center, Nitta Gelatin Inc., Osaka 581-0024, Japan. 4. Department of Pharmacy, Fukuoka University Chikushi Hospital, Fukuoka 818-0067, Japan. 5. Department of Plastic Reconstructive and aesthetic Surgery, Faculty of Medicine, Fukuoka University, Fukuoka 814-0180, Japan.
Abstract
Hypertrophic scars found on the human body rarely develop in experimental animals, possibly due to their looser skin structure. This makes it difficult to understand the genesis of scar lesions. Therefore, appropriate animal models are urgently needed. In this study, we established a novel experimental model of a scar-forming wound by resecting a small portion of the abdominal muscle wall on the lower center of the abdomen in C57BL/6N mice, which are exposed to contractive forces by the surrounding muscle tissue. As a low-tension control, a back skin excision model was used with a splint fixed onto the excised skin edge, and granulation tissue formed on the muscle fascia supported by the back skeleton. One week after the resection, initial healing reactions, such as fibroblast proliferation, occurred in both models. However, after 21 days, lesions with collagen-rich granulation tissues, which were also accompanied by multiple nodular/spherical-like structures, developed only in the abdominal wall model. These lesions were analogous to scar lesions in humans. Therefore, the animal model developed in this study is unique in that fibrous scar tissues form under physiological conditions without using any artificial factors and is valuable for studying the pathogenesis and preclinical treatment of scar lesions.
Hypertrophic scars found on the human body rarely develop in experimental animals, possibly due to their looser skin structure. This makes it difficult to understand the genesis of scar lesions. Therefore, appropriate animal models are urgently needed. In this study, we established a novel experimental model of a scar-forming wound by resecting a small portion of the abdominal muscle wall on the lower center of the abdomen in C57BL/6N mice, which are exposed to contractive forces by the surrounding muscle tissue. As a low-tension control, a back skin excision model was used with a splint fixed onto the excised skin edge, and granulation tissue formed on the muscle fascia supported by the back skeleton. One week after the resection, initial healing reactions, such as fibroblast proliferation, occurred in both models. However, after 21 days, lesions with collagen-rich granulation tissues, which were also accompanied by multiple nodular/spherical-like structures, developed only in the abdominal wall model. These lesions were analogous to scar lesions in humans. Therefore, the animal model developed in this study is unique in that fibrous scar tissues form under physiological conditions without using any artificial factors and is valuable for studying the pathogenesis and preclinical treatment of scar lesions.
The best outcome of wound healing is the replacement of damaged tissue foci with regenerative
tissue structures. The wound healing process is divided into four stages [27, 33]:
coagulation, inflammation, proliferation, and maturation. Proper healing can be accomplished
only by efficiently passing through all these stages sequentially. In particular, granulation
tissue formation and regeneration are fundamental cellular events during the proliferation
stage. Different types of cells participate in this stage [10]; fibroblasts produce extracellular matrix [28], myofibroblasts enable wound contraction [29], and endothelial cells establish a vascular network [30]. Self-forming collagen-rich scaffolds support the acceleration of
regenerative processes, in which granulation tissue finally regresses after the end of wound
healing. However, a decrease in the quantity and quality of granulation tissue due to
malnutrition and defects in neovascularization can cause severe problems in wound healing,
resulting in intractable wounds. Moreover, disorders that affect regeneration can lead to a
decrease in organ function and appearance of the newly formed tissue during healing.Collagen is an extracellular protein that plays a significant role in providing physical
tissue strength and repair and recovery of tissues [28]. Collagens produced by fibroblasts act as cellular scaffolds in granulation
tissue. In the matrix, endothelial cells contribute to neovascularization, and keratinocytes
induce epithelial healing. Granulation tissue develops after tissue damage not only in the
skin, but also in other organs. If the granulation tissue becomes fibrous with collagen
accumulation during wound healing, scarring may occur with collagen hyalinization by unknown
mechanisms. The factors responsible for the genesis of scar lesions include growth factors,
such as transforming growth factor-β (TGF-β) [20, 29], tensile forces, and intracellular SMAD pathway
activation via mechanisms involving mechanoreceptors [11]. In the skin, an elevated lesion accompanied by massive fibrosis is called a
hypertrophic scar [25], and it forms slowly in the
expanded skin around joints after wounding. The genesis of scar lesions is thus supposed to
involve the phenotypic modulation of tissue cells, including fibroblasts, under a hypertensile
force and delayed healing due to chronic inflammation.Keloid also appears as an elevated lesion [21];
however, its lesion invades the adjacent normal skin due to its higher proliferation potency.
Like hypertrophic scars, keloids occur in the skin areas under a higher tensile force [25]. In addition, there is a predisposition to keloids in
certain races and patients. The emergence of proliferation-prone or variant cells is essential
for keloid genesis, although its pathogenesis and the factors involved therein are not fully
understood.Wound-healing studies using animals have been conducted for several decades [3, 8, 26]. Abercrombie et al. (1960) [2] advocated that wounds created on the skin of animals
should be splinted to closely resemble human wound healing. Other investigators have also
indicated that skin mobility in animals affects wound contraction [6, 7, 9, 18, 31]. Therefore, the applicability of animal wounds as appropriate models to study
human wound healing has not yet been established beyond doubt.Animal models are crucial for the preclinical examination of drugs and/or therapies for human
diseases. Animal wound-healing models have been used to explore the pathogenesis and
effectiveness of treatments in vivo under physiological conditions. However,
it is challenging to produce scar lesions after skin excision in animals, especially in
rodents, owing to the looseness and low tensile strength of the tissue. Nevertheless,
researchers have tried to generate animal models with hypertrophic scars using mice, pigs, and
other animals [3, 4, 24, 32]. In 2007, Aarabi et al. [1] established a hypertrophic scar-forming mouse model using a biomechanical loading
device. Marchesini et al. (2020) [23]
created a foreign body reaction-associated fibromuscular granulation tissue in rats. Moreover,
Cameron et al. (2014) [5] created a
hypertrophic scar model using bleomycin infusion in mice. However, no model has been developed
for scarring after wounding in rodents under physiological conditions without using any
devices or chemicals.Therefore, the aim of this study was to develop a scar-forming mouse model that did not rely
on mechanical devices or chemicals to induce scars, and to compare the granulation tissue
developed in this model with that formed in the back skin excision model, which we have
previously established [13, 14, 16, 17].
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Animals
This animal study was approved by the Fukuoka University Animal Experiment Committee (No.
1812097), and the study protocols complied with the institution’s animal care guidelines.
C57BL/6N, female, 8- to 10-week-old mice (Japan SLC Inc., Shizuoka, Japan) were used.
Basic animal maintenance was performed according to previously described procedures [12,13,14, 16, 17]. All experimental procedures were conducted under
aseptic conditions (70% ethanol and povidone-iodine). Isoflurane (Wako Pure Chemical
Industries, Ltd., Osaka, Japan) or pentobarbital (Somnopentyl; Kyoritsu Seiyaku, Tokyo,
Japan) was used for anesthesia. The mice were monitored daily during the study period.
Blood was drawn from the venous plexus of the eyelids using a heparinized 75-µl capillary
(Hirschmann Laborgeräte GmbH & Co., Eberstadt, Germany), and hematological analyzes,
including the red blood cell (RBC) and white blood cell (WBC) counts, were performed using
an automatic cell counter (Celltac-α, NIHON KOHDEN, Tokyo, Japan). At the end of the
study, the mice were sacrificed by lethal pentobarbital injection and arterial hemorrhage,
and wound tissues were obtained.
Back skin excision model
Eighteen mice were used for the back skin excision model. Our previously established
internal splint method was used [12,13,14, 16, 17].
Briefly, under general anesthesia, a one-cm circle was marked at the middle lumbar area
and excised with scissors. Then, a doughnut-shaped flexible splint was placed beneath the
skin around the wound, and the splint and skin were sutured with thread (6 stitches). The
wound surface was treated with 70% ethanol for 1 min. Finally, the wound was shielded with
a polyurethane film dressing (Tegaderm, SUMITOMO 3M, Tokyo, Japan). A silicon vest was
used to prevent thread removal by the animals.
Abdominal muscle wall excision model
For the abdominal wall excision model, 20 mice were used in the study for 21 days, and 10
mice were used for 87 days. One day before surgery, mice were anesthetized with
pentobarbital (Somnopentyl; KYORITU SEIYAKU, Tokyo, Japan), and the hair on the abdomen
was removed using an electric clipper and a commercially available hair-removal cream.On the day of surgery, mice under general anesthesia were placed in a supine position,
and their four limbs were fixed on a corkboard. The cross point of the rectus abdominis
and linea alba abdominis was marked with a dot using a marker pen. Then, a line was marked
1 cm above and 0.5 cm below the marked dot alongside the midline (Fig. 1A). Iodine was applied to the abdominal area, and the skin was resected along the
marked line. After separating the skin around the cut line from the abdominal muscle wall
with scissors, the fascia at the umbilicus spot was pulled up, and a needle with a suture
was inserted. The tissue was then lifted with the thread, and the spot where the suture
had been inserted was grasped with round-top tweezers (Fig. 1A). The tissue was cut away with a curved scissor (Fig. 1A). The tissue weight was calculated, and wound area was
measured.
Fig. 1.
Abdominal muscle wall excision model. A: Surgery was carried out, in
which skin excision and abdominal muscle resection were performed (upper panel). The
inner wound appearance changed over time (lower). B: To analyze the
tensile force loaded on the abdominal muscle wall, the wall was excised horizontally
or vertically along a one-cm straight line, and the tensile force was measured using
the method described in the Materials and Methods section.
Abdominal muscle wall excision model. A: Surgery was carried out, in
which skin excision and abdominal muscle resection were performed (upper panel). The
inner wound appearance changed over time (lower). B: To analyze the
tensile force loaded on the abdominal muscle wall, the wall was excised horizontally
or vertically along a one-cm straight line, and the tensile force was measured using
the method described in the Materials and Methods section.The opened skin was placed together and sutured at the upper and lower positions to avoid
attachment to the wound of the abdominis to avoid any side effects from foreign body
reactions and to allow for determining abdominal wound healing only. The abdominal area of
the wound was covered with a film dressing (Tegaderm).The mice could not survive without the wounds being protected because of their tendency
to kick their abdomen, leading to possible expulsion of their abdominal organs, when they
feel uncomfortable. Therefore, after the surgery, a silicon vest was placed on the mice,
which consisted of a thin silicon sheet that was cut to mount the lower body with two
holes for the lower limbs, and the upper portion of the silicon vest was stapled. The mice
could move freely to drink and eat without being restricted by the vest. The vests were
kept on the mice for one week for skin healing.
Tissue samples
On days 0, 7, 14, 21, and 87, the mice were sacrificed under an overdose of general
anesthesia, and the abdominal wall, including the wound tissue, was excised and fixed in
10% buffered formalin (Sigma-Aldrich Japan), and paraffin blocks were prepared. The center
of the wound cross-section was determined by sectioning the wound tissue embedded in
paraffin. Ten serial sections of 4-μm thickness were initially prepared for staining with
hematoxylin–eosin (H&E) stain, Masson’s trichrome (MT) stain, and
immunohistochemistry. To detect neovessels and myofibroblasts, rabbit anti-mouse CD31
antibody (Dianova GmbH, Hamburg, Germany) and rabbit anti-mouse α-smooth muscle actin
(SMA) antibody (Abcam plc, Tokyo, Japan), respectively, were used. After treatment with an
enhancing reagent (EnVision Kit, DAKO Japan, Inc., Tokyo, Japan), immunohistochemical
localization of α-SMA was visualized using 3,3′-diaminobenzidine. Hematoxylin was used for
counterstaining. For collagen distribution, paraffin sections were stained with 0.1%
Sirius red in saturated picric acid solution for 1 hr and examined by polarization
microscopy.
Measurement of tension in the resected abdominal muscle wall
The extent of tensile force in the abdominal muscle wall was measured by our manufactured
conversion machinery of the tensile force to the weight. After removing the skin, the
abdominal muscle was cut 1 cm in the transverse or longitudinal plane (Fig. 1B). After resection, the edge of the opened
wound was hooked using a three-headed needle with a thread. Thereafter, the thread was
pulled until the wound edge returned to the equator line, and the pulling weight was
measured using a scale. The measured weight was converted to Newtons to obtain the tensile
force on the wounds. Six mice were used in the tensile force study.
Morphometrical analysis
After resecting a part of the abdominal wall, wound pictures were taken with a ruler
placed adjacent to the wound, and the wound areas were measured (VH-analyzer: Keyence,
Osaka, Japan). Using histological images stained by H&E and MT stains, the area of
granulation tissue developed between the abdominal muscle wall and the length of
granulation tissue expanded in the lateral direction were morphometrically measured with a
computer-assisted software BZ-II (Keyence). To measure the area of collagenous matrix and
cellular elements in the granulation tissue, images of the representative lesions were
taken using the 20× objective lens in the Bio-Zero microscope (Keyence). In MT-stained
sections, blue-stained collagenous matrix and red-stained cellular elements were
highlighted, binarized, and morphometrically measured using a VH-analyzer, and the
percentages of collagen distribution and cellular element distribution in the granulation
tissue were calculated.
Statistical analysis
To compare two values, the Student’s t-test or Mann–Whitney
U test was performed. Linear regression analysis was performed to
examine the relationship between the two factors. Statistical significance was set at
P<0.05. Data are expressed as mean ± standard deviation.
RESULTS
Wound contraction and tensile force
Two different wound models were utilized, which included the back skin excision model
(Fig. 2A), where granulation tissue formed after skin excision on the back muscle fascia
supported by the back skeleton. The tension on the developing granulation tissue was
minimized by not only the back skeleton, but also the splint (blue dotted line) fixed
under the edge of the skin. The other model was the abdominal wall excision model (Fig. 1A). The abdominal muscle wall has no skeletal
support. A small portion of the abdominal muscle wall was resected and covered with skin.
After wounding, no statistical differences were found in body weight, WBC, and RBC between
mice of the two models during the study (Supplementary Table 1), and wounds visually
contracted in both the back skin model (Fig. 2A)
and in the abdominal wall model (Fig. 1A). On
day 7, the wound had a vertical oval shape appearance along the abdominal wall, but
apparent ulcerated lesions were scarcely visible after 21 days of the study.
Fig. 2.
Back skin wound model. A: The appearance of the outer wound over time
in the back skin wound model. The excised skin was fixed with a splint (blue dotted
line) under the dermis, and granulation tissue was formed on the muscle fascia
supported by the back skeleton. Granulation tissues developed for 21 days in the
back skin splint model (Masson’s trichrome (MT) stain). Images of representative
granulation tissues were taken under epithelial regeneration. The granulation
tissues maintained a zonal structure with parallel fibroblasts during the study
(left panel). Bars=100 μm. B: The collagenous area in granulation
tissues was measured using MT stain for 21 days after tissue excision.
C: Representative immunohistochemical images of CD31 and α-smooth
muscle actin (SMA) in granulation tissue on day 14. CD31-positive vessels in the
circular area are indicated by arrows. α-SMA-positive cells are distributed zonally
between parentheses, and vessel walls are also positive for α-SMA (arrows). Bars=100
μm.
Back skin wound model. A: The appearance of the outer wound over time
in the back skin wound model. The excised skin was fixed with a splint (blue dotted
line) under the dermis, and granulation tissue was formed on the muscle fascia
supported by the back skeleton. Granulation tissues developed for 21 days in the
back skin splint model (Masson’s trichrome (MT) stain). Images of representative
granulation tissues were taken under epithelial regeneration. The granulation
tissues maintained a zonal structure with parallel fibroblasts during the study
(left panel). Bars=100 μm. B: The collagenous area in granulation
tissues was measured using MT stain for 21 days after tissue excision.
C: Representative immunohistochemical images of CD31 and α-smooth
muscle actin (SMA) in granulation tissue on day 14. CD31-positive vessels in the
circular area are indicated by arrows. α-SMA-positive cells are distributed zonally
between parentheses, and vessel walls are also positive for α-SMA (arrows). Bars=100
μm.The tensile force in the abdominal muscle wall without skin was analyzed as a static
physical force in mice under general anesthesia. The abdominal muscle wall was resected 1
cm horizontally or vertically. The vertical cut revealed a tensile force, which was more
than four times lesser than that in the horizontal cut (P<0.01) (Fig. 1B). On the other hand, no tensile force was
detected in the abdominal skin that was similarly cut in size and direction (data not
shown).
Development of granulation tissues
Granulation tissues formed on the wounds in both models. In the back skin model, the
granulation tissue started under the edge of the excised skin and formed on the fascia
(Fig. 2A, left). On the other hand, in the
abdominal model, granulation tissue started to form from the excised abdominal rectus
muscle (Fig. 3A). On day 7, fibroblasts were
arranged parallel to the wounds in the abdominal model (Fig. 3A, upper yellow square), similar to the observation in the back skin model (Fig. 2A). In the back skin model, the zonal growth
pattern was maintained during the study (Fig.
2A, yellow squares), which was accompanied by an increase in collagen matrix
accumulation (Fig. 2B). On the other hand, in
the abdominal model, granulation tissue was arranged in a rippling pattern on day 14
(Fig. 3A, middle). The lesions changed to a
fibrous nodular/spherical-like structure on day 21 (Fig. 3A, bottom). The area of collagenous matrix stained by MT stain increased
with time in both models (Figs. 2B and 3B), and was approximately 10-fold greater in the
abdominal model than in the back skin model. Moreover, in the abdominal model, collagen
quantity reached a plateau (Fig. 3B), but
collagen bundles became thicker on day 21 (Fig.
3A, right). We also checked the distribution of CD31-positive endothelial cells
and α-SMA-expressing cells, including myofibroblasts, in the well-developed granulation
tissues in both models on day 14 (Figs. 2C and
3C). CD31-positive neovessels were distributed
to a lesser extent in the abdominal granulation tissue in the abdominal wall model than in
the back skin model. However, α-SMA-expressing cells were densely distributed along with
wavy extracellular matrix in nodular granulation tissue in the abdominal model (Fig. 3C, right).
Fig. 3.
Granulation tissue developed in the abdominal-muscle wall excision model.
A: Representative cross-sectioned granulation tissues developed for
21 days (Masson’s trichrome (MT) stain). The granulation tissue changed from a zonal
structure (day 7) to a wavy nodular/spherical-like structure (days 14 and 21).
Bars=100 μm. B: The collagenous area in the MT stain was measured in
granulation tissues for 21 days after tissue excision. **:
P<0.01. C: Representative images of CD31 and α-SMA
in granulation tissue on day 14. CD31-positive vessels in the circular area are
indicated by arrows. α-SMA-positive cells are distributed zonally between
parentheses, and vessel walls are also positive for α-SMA (arrows). Bars=100 μm.
Granulation tissue developed in the abdominal-muscle wall excision model.
A: Representative cross-sectioned granulation tissues developed for
21 days (Masson’s trichrome (MT) stain). The granulation tissue changed from a zonal
structure (day 7) to a wavy nodular/spherical-like structure (days 14 and 21).
Bars=100 μm. B: The collagenous area in the MT stain was measured in
granulation tissues for 21 days after tissue excision. **:
P<0.01. C: Representative images of CD31 and α-SMA
in granulation tissue on day 14. CD31-positive vessels in the circular area are
indicated by arrows. α-SMA-positive cells are distributed zonally between
parentheses, and vessel walls are also positive for α-SMA (arrows). Bars=100 μm.
Excised tissue weight and wound area
After excising a part of the abdominal muscle wall in the abdominal model (Fig. 4A), the tissue weight and wound area were measured. The distributions of wound areas
and tissue weights were 4.8–25.1 mm2 and 2.2–7.8 mg, respectively (Fig. 4B). There was a significant correlation
between these parameters (P<0.0001; Fig. 4C). Thus, tissue weight could be used as a reliable indicator of the
extent of wounding damage.
Fig. 4.
Wound area and tissue weight after resecting the abdominal walls. In 20 mice, a
part of the abdominal wall was resected on day 0 in the abdominal wall excision
model. A: Small and large areas of excised wounds: approximately 5
mm2 and 25 mm2, respectively. B: Frequency
distributions of the wound area (left) and tissue weights (right). C:
At the time of wounding, the obtained tissue weight significantly correlated with
the area of the wounds.
Wound area and tissue weight after resecting the abdominal walls. In 20 mice, a
part of the abdominal wall was resected on day 0 in the abdominal wall excision
model. A: Small and large areas of excised wounds: approximately 5
mm2 and 25 mm2, respectively. B: Frequency
distributions of the wound area (left) and tissue weights (right). C:
At the time of wounding, the obtained tissue weight significantly correlated with
the area of the wounds.
Morphometrical analysis of granulation tissue
Figure 5A shows a cross-sectional image of a representative wound of the abdominal wall 21
days after abdominal muscle wall resection. Granulation tissue developed between the
abdominal muscle wall and the wound surface exposed to the parietal peritoneum of the
abdominal cavity. The granulation tissue area, shown by a yellow line, and lateral wound
length, shown by a green line, were morphometrically measured to determine the granulation
tissue area and wound width. Moreover, using MT staining, the collagenous matrix area
stained in blue by aniline blue, and the cellular area stained in red by acid fuchsine
were morphometrically measured in the granulation tissue (Fig. 5B). On day 21, the granulation tissue area and collagenous
matrix area in blue were well correlated (P<0.0001) (Fig. 5C).
Fig. 5.
The histological evaluation of granulation tissue, including collagen and cellular
elements, in scaring. A: In the case of the abdominal wound, a
cross-section on day 21 was stained by Masson’s trichrome (MT) stain, and the
granulation tissue that developed between the abdominal muscle wall was estimated
morphometrically by its area (yellow line) and the surficial length of the abdominal
cavity (green line). B: Representative granulation tissue stained by MT
stain, in which the collagenous matrix is stained blue, and the cells are stained
red. These elements were binarized and morphometrically measured. C: In
the abdominal wall model, a positive correlation was found between the granulation
tissue area and collagenous matrix area (%) in the granulation tissue on day 21.
The histological evaluation of granulation tissue, including collagen and cellular
elements, in scaring. A: In the case of the abdominal wound, a
cross-section on day 21 was stained by Masson’s trichrome (MT) stain, and the
granulation tissue that developed between the abdominal muscle wall was estimated
morphometrically by its area (yellow line) and the surficial length of the abdominal
cavity (green line). B: Representative granulation tissue stained by MT
stain, in which the collagenous matrix is stained blue, and the cells are stained
red. These elements were binarized and morphometrically measured. C: In
the abdominal wall model, a positive correlation was found between the granulation
tissue area and collagenous matrix area (%) in the granulation tissue on day 21.
Initial tissue values at the time of tissue excision and subsequent developed
lesions
The lesion parameters on day 21 were correlated with the initial excised tissue weight
and wound area on day 0 (Fig. 6). The vertical granulation tissue length and cellular area were significantly
correlated with tissue weight (P<0.005 and P<0.01,
respectively). The granulation tissue area and the collagenous area tended to be related
with the tissue weight (P<0.1 for both). Granulation lesion length and
cellular area were correlated with the wound area (P<0.05 and
P<0.01, respectively), but no correlation with the granulation
tissue area or the collagenous area was detected. These results showed that the values of
wound parameters on day 0, especially tissue weight, strongly reflected subsequent scar
lesion formation in the granulation tissue on day 21.
Fig. 6.
The tissue weight and wound area on day 0 and subsequent histological alterations
on day 21. Correlation analysis between the original wound values (tissue weight and
wound area) on day 0 and the lesion length, granulation tissue area, and collagenous
area (%) on day 21. The original wound values strongly reflected subsequent scar
lesions in the granulation tissue on day 21.
The tissue weight and wound area on day 0 and subsequent histological alterations
on day 21. Correlation analysis between the original wound values (tissue weight and
wound area) on day 0 and the lesion length, granulation tissue area, and collagenous
area (%) on day 21. The original wound values strongly reflected subsequent scar
lesions in the granulation tissue on day 21.
Histological characteristics of the granulation tissue and scar tissue
In the abdominal wall excision model, nodular/spherical-like structures in the
granulation tissue were observed (Fig. 7A), and such lesions developed in approximately 80% of mice. In advanced fibrous
lesions with less cellularity, collagen matrices were hyalinized, showing
eosinophilic-hazy staining (Fig. 7B). Collagens
in the granulation tissue were further examined using the samples stained by picrosirius
red stain and observed under polarization microscopy; the fibrous lesion that developed in
the abdominal wall model formed a storiform pattern (Fig. 7C, left), and thickened collagen bundles in orange color (type I collagen)
were primarily observed, which differed from the thin collagens in green color (type III
collagen) that accumulated in the granulation tissue, especially in the back skin model
(Fig. 7C, right). Collagen-rich scar lesions
remained for approximately 3 months (day 87) after abdominal wall resection (Fig. 7D), in which fibrous scar tissue with
thickened collagen fiber deposition remained in the matrix and was severely deformed. On
the other hand, no granulation tissues or scar lesions remained in the back skin model
after two months.
Fig. 7.
Developed and residual scar lesions in the abdominal wall model. A:
Multi-nodular/spherical-like structured lesions in the abdominal wall model
developed on day 21. B: The scar lesion on day 21 shows massive
collagen deposition, which is hazy and hyalinized in hematoxylin and eosin staining.
C: Picrosirius red staining: The fibrous lesion that developed in the
abdominal wall model forms a storiform pattern (left), in which thick collagen
bundles are primarily stained in orange color, showing type 1 collagen. In the back
skin splint model (right), thin collagen bundles were deposited in the granulation
tissue on day 21, many of which were stained green, showing type 3 collagen.
D: In the abdominal wall model, an apparent collagen-rich scar lesion
(arrows) remained after 87 days of the study, which was deformed and different from
that in the normal control in a similar tissue site (left).
Developed and residual scar lesions in the abdominal wall model. A:
Multi-nodular/spherical-like structured lesions in the abdominal wall model
developed on day 21. B: The scar lesion on day 21 shows massive
collagen deposition, which is hazy and hyalinized in hematoxylin and eosin staining.
C: Picrosirius red staining: The fibrous lesion that developed in the
abdominal wall model forms a storiform pattern (left), in which thick collagen
bundles are primarily stained in orange color, showing type 1 collagen. In the back
skin splint model (right), thin collagen bundles were deposited in the granulation
tissue on day 21, many of which were stained green, showing type 3 collagen.
D: In the abdominal wall model, an apparent collagen-rich scar lesion
(arrows) remained after 87 days of the study, which was deformed and different from
that in the normal control in a similar tissue site (left).
The relationship between the initial tissue damage and developed scar lesions
Finally, to obtain a higher reproducibility for the developed scar lesions in the
abdominal muscle wall model, it would be necessary to analyze the excised tissue on day 0.
Scarring in the granulation tissue by collagen deposition was examined using the size of
the initial wound and the tissue weight. The area and tissue weight values on day 0 showed
a similar distribution with scarring on day 21 (Fig. 8), and a significant positive relationship was detected between
scarring and tissue weight.
Fig. 8.
Correlation analysis between the initial pathological values and collagen area.
Correlation analysis was performed between the wound area and excised tissue
weight on day 0 and collagen accumulation in the granulation tissue on day 21. A
significant positive correlation was noted between tissue weight and collagen
accumulation.
Correlation analysis between the initial pathological values and collagen area.
Correlation analysis was performed between the wound area and excised tissue
weight on day 0 and collagen accumulation in the granulation tissue on day 21. A
significant positive correlation was noted between tissue weight and collagen
accumulation.
DISCUSSION
This study reports a newly developed experimental model with a novel and reproducible
approach for creating scar lesions in mice without the use of any devices or chemicals. It
is very challenging to develop scar lesions on the skin of animals. Therefore, the tensile
force of tissue surrounding a wound was used to generate scar lesions. We created a wound on
the abdominal muscle wall, which possesses contraction capacity, and scar lesions
subsequently developed on the abdominal wall.Scar lesions in humans develop not only on the skin, but also in other organs. The major
pathological factors for scar lesion formation include higher tensile force of surrounding
tissue and chronic inflammation [11, 25]. However, only a few models of scar tissue formation
are available in rodents. Aarabi et al. [1] established a hypertrophic scar-forming model in mice using a tension-loading
device, showing that scar tissues in the skin can develop even in mice. In other cases,
fibrous granulation lesions were induced by prolonged inflammation by talc [23] and bleomycin [5, 22]. However, inflammation may be an
additive factor for fibrosis in scarring.In this study, we excised a small portion of the abdominal muscle wall in mice on which
overlaid skin was used as a shield against air-drying and any additional inflammation to the
wounded abdominal muscle wall. No general inflammatory responses, including an increase in
WBC count or body weight loss, were detected in the mice after surgery. Furthermore, only a
few NIMP-positive neutrophils and Mac-1-positive macrophages infiltrated the tissue (data
not shown).The skin wounds healed quickly within seven days after wounding in mice. The abdominal
muscle wall may be potentially/physiologically under longitudinal static tension to some
extent. In free physiological motion after surgery, mice twisted and stretched their body
during their daily activities. Therefore, in addition to the potential muscle tension in the
abdominal muscle wall, variable and complex forces could be loaded on the developing
granulation tissues in the thin and soft abdominal wall with no skeletal support. Developed
lesions showing a fibrous nodular/spherical-like structure may be the result of such
inconsistent forces.Initially, we histologically compared the granulation tissues formed in the abdominal wall
excision model and splinted back skin excision model. After totally excising the back skin,
a round and flexible splint was placed under the dermis, and the skin margin was fixed.
Granulation tissue developed from the cutting edge of the fixed skin and on the fascia of
the back muscle. Therefore, loading of external physical forces on the granulation tissue
developed on the wound may be minimal due to the support of the splint and back skeleton. In
the early phase of granulation tissue formation on day 7, granulation tissue that developed
in both models showed proliferated fibroblasts distributed in parallel. Subsequently, this
lesion structure continued until day 21 of the study in the splinted skin excision model,
whereas collagenous fibrosis progressed and a wavy nodular structure appeared after 14 days
of the study in the abdominal wall excision model. Granulation tissues comprise many
myofibroblasts and endothelial cells. Myofibroblasts were more densely accumulated in the
abdominal model than in the back skin model. The density of the collagenous matrix increased
during the 21 days of the study regardless of the model, although the collagen deposited in
the abdominal wall excision model was approximately 10-times denser than that in the back
skin splint model. Moreover, collagen fibers were hyalinized in the abdominal model and
formed fibrous tissues consisting primarily of thickened bundles of collagen type I. These
features are the signatures of scar tissues [19]. The
described morphology and characteristics found in mice are distinct and consistent with
hypertrophic scar lesions in humans [19].In the abdominal wall model, granulation tissue comprised neovessels, fibroblasts, and
regenerative muscles in the collagen matrix. For the reproducibility of the study, we tried
to identify a predictor for scar lesion formation using the available indexes at the time of
surgery, such as the excised tissue weight and the size of wounds on the abdominal wall.
Although both were significantly correlated, tissue weight may be a valuable predictive
factor for scar lesions. Correlation analysis revealed that tissue weight was significantly
interrelated with the granulation length on day 21, and tended to be related to the
granulation tissue area, indicating that tissue weight may be used as a predictor of
granulation tissue development after abdominal wall injury.We also investigated, using MT staining, whether the extent of collagen deposition in the
granulation tissue is linked to scar tissue formation. The blue-stained areas highlighted
were binarized and measured (Fig. 5B). The
correlation analysis indicated that the granulation tissue area was significantly related to
the wound length and collagenous area, showing that granulation tissue size increased with
fibrosis progression. Furthermore, the developed collagenous matrix in tissue was highly
hyalinized, providing evidence for scar tissue [19].
Interestingly, the developed lesions showed distinct multiple nodular structures, which is a
dominant signature for human hypertrophic scar lesions [19]. Moreover, such fibrous lesions lasted for an extended period, even 87 days
after initial wound formation.These results indicated that excised tissue weight at the time of surgery was a reliable
predictive factor for granulation tissue development and consequent fibrosis on day 21 of
the study. Our data indicate that when using a female C57BL6/N mouse, an abdominal muscle
wall tissue excision of approximately 8 mg or more is desirable to obtain a consistent and
apparent scar lesion with advanced fibrosis.Since the surgical procedure has been performed on normal mice, active healing reactions
could have occurred, even though the abdominal wall wound healing exacerbated the scarring
reactions. Therefore, scar lesions developed in mice may not last as long as they do in
humans. In conclusion, the abdominal wall wound model is the first of its kind to be
established for scar lesions developed under physiological conditions without any devices.
The technique is simple and reliable for studying the pathogenesis and treatment of
proliferative scar lesions that develop in humans. We have currently shown a scar-less
muscle regenerative healing can induce by Pro-Hyp, a collagen dipeptide, using this model
[15]. With this technique, we could clarify the
molecular mechanisms of the development of scar lesions and examine the methods that can be
utilized to inhibit scar lesions in patients after surgery, including cesarean section.
CONFLICT OF INTEREST
The authors disclose no potential conflicts of interest with respect to the research,
authorship, and/or publication of this article.
Authors: Shahram Aarabi; Kirit A Bhatt; Yubin Shi; Josemaria Paterno; Edward I Chang; Shang A Loh; Jeffrey W Holmes; Michael T Longaker; Herman Yee; Geoffrey C Gurtner Journal: FASEB J Date: 2007-05-15 Impact factor: 5.191