Stefan Thumser1, Laura Köttner1, Nadine Hoffmann2, Peter Mayer2, Henry Dube1. 1. Friedrich-Alexander Universität Erlangen-Nürnberg, Department of Chemistry and Pharmacy, Nikolaus-Fiebiger-Str. 10, 91058 Erlangen, Germany. 2. Ludwig-Maximilians Universität München, Department of Chemistry and Center for Integrated Protein Science CIPSM, Butenandtstr. 5-13, 81377 Munich, Germany.
Abstract
Red-light responsiveness of photoswitches is a highly desired property for many important application areas such as biology or material sciences. The main approach to elicit this property uses strategic substitution of long-known photoswitch motives such as azobenzenes or diarylethenes. Only very few photoswitches possess inherent red-light absorption of their core chromophore structures. Here, we present a strategy to convert the long-known purple indirubin dye into a prolific red-light-responsive photoswitch. In a supramolecular approach, its photochromism can be changed from a negative to a positive one, while at the same time, significantly higher yields of the metastable E-isomer are obtained upon irradiation. E- to Z-photoisomerization can then also be induced by red light of longer wavelengths. Indirubin therefore represents a unique example of reversible photoswitching using entirely red light for both switching directions.
Red-light responsiveness of photoswitches is a highly desired property for many important application areas such as biology or material sciences. The main approach to elicit this property uses strategic substitution of long-known photoswitch motives such as azobenzenes or diarylethenes. Only very few photoswitches possess inherent red-light absorption of their core chromophore structures. Here, we present a strategy to convert the long-known purple indirubin dye into a prolific red-light-responsive photoswitch. In a supramolecular approach, its photochromism can be changed from a negative to a positive one, while at the same time, significantly higher yields of the metastable E-isomer are obtained upon irradiation. E- to Z-photoisomerization can then also be induced by red light of longer wavelengths. Indirubin therefore represents a unique example of reversible photoswitching using entirely red light for both switching directions.
Photoswitches
have gained strong traction as a molecular basis
for responsive behavior at the smallest scales. The most prominent
photoswitches, stilbenes, azobenzenes, spiropyranes, and diarylethenes,
have already led to countless applications and uses in fields spanning
the molecular, material, or biomedical sciences. They represent fundamental
switching units for synthetic molecular machines,[1−10] photopharmacology,[11−16] light-controlled catalysts,[17−24] or materials research[25−30] to name only a few examples. In their wake, a number of novel molecular
photoswitch architectures have been developed,[31] which bring a suite of different geometrical and electronic
changes to the table, greatly expanding the toolbox of molecular engineering.
Important examples are azo-BF2[32] and hydrazone-based switches,[33,34] Stenhouse dyes,[35−37] imines,[9,38,39] or imidazole-based
biradicals.[40] Indigoid dyes[41−45] and foremost hemithioindigo (HTI)[46] have
emerged as a very promising class of chromophores for photoswitching
applications. HTI has been employed as a photopharmacological tool,[47−50] for responsive supramolecular systems,[51−54] catalysis,[24] and advanced molecular machine building.[10,56−62] The fundamental photochemistry of indigoid photoswitches has been
explored in some detail, establishing rational design principles to
consciously manipulate their properties.[59,63−68] Different to most other photoswitch motives, indigoid core chromophores
are highly colored, enabling visible-light photoswitching in both
switching directions. Such low-energy absorption properties are especially
important in the context of materials, biological applications, as
well as generating more complex integrated molecular behavior.[5,18,19,21,24] For biological applications, two aspects
are crucial in this regard: selectivity for addressing only the photoswitch
in the presence of a biological material, which itself absorbs up
to the visible range, and penetration of the irradiating light into
tissue, which is optimal at the “biooptical window”
between 650 and 850 nm.[11,15] In catalysis and materials
research, the photoswitching capacity again has to be compatible with
catalysts, reactants, products, or other components of functional
materials. Red-light responsiveness is therefore a critical property
in these fields and beyond if additional control via light irradiation
is to be implemented.[25,26,28] Despite many efforts to shift light responsiveness of established
photoswitches to the low-energy red part of the electromagnetic spectrum,[69−73] there is still an urgent need for simple and effective strategies
enabling proficient visible and especially red-light photoswitching.Indirubin is a constitutional isomer of indigo and has been known
as a colorant for a long time. More than 150 years ago, its synthesis
was described as a side product in the synthesis of indigo by Baeyer
and Emmerling.[74] It is a compound of deep
purple color that is produced in bacterial metabolism[75] and has been used in traditional Chinese medicine for hundreds
of years. It possesses anticancer activity as well as antiangiogenesis
and anti-inflammatory effects.[76] Despite
its prominence and vivid color, the possibility of photoisomerization
of indirubin has to the best of our knowledge not been explored so
far. In this work, we show that indirubin can be rendered into a red-light-responsive
photoswitch by substituting the acidic NH protons with alkyl substituents
(Figure ).
Figure 1
Red-light (only)
responsive photoswitching of N-alkylated indirubin
and improvement of photoisomerization upon supramolecular
complexation by Schreiner’s thiourea organocatalyst (STC).
Red-light (only)
responsive photoswitching of N-alkylated indirubin
and improvement of photoisomerization upon supramolecular
complexation by Schreiner’s thiourea organocatalyst (STC).Due to its rather moderate photochromism and particular
quantum
yields, isomer enrichment is however not very high in the photostationary
states (pss) and reaches up to 46% E-isomer in toluene
solution or 62% in CH2Cl2. The reverse photoreaction
can be induced by blue light, as indirubin possesses negative photochromism.
Full recovery of the thermodynamically stable Z-isomer
can additionally be achieved thermally. This promising photoswitching
behavior can significantly be improved with a straightforward supramolecular
strategy. After commercially available Schreiner’s thiourea
organocatalyst (STC)[77] is added, the photoswitching
capacity of indirubin under red-light illumination is significantly
enhanced. Selective binding of STC to the E-isomeric
indirubin state leads to a pronounced red-shift of its absorption
and thus to an actual reversal of the intrinsic negative photochromism
into a positive one. Now up to 84% E-isomer is formed
upon 625–650 nm irradiation and the reverse E to Z photoisomerization can be induced even with
730 nm light. Taken together, this simple implementation of supramolecular
photoisomerization control allows to establish efficient and red-light-only
responsiveness for an easy-to-prepare and -functionalize novel photoswitch
motive.
Results and Discussion
In this study, different indirubin
derivatives 1–5 are investigated
with respect to their photoswitching properties
(Figure a). Their
synthesis proceeds in two steps, condensation of (substituted) isatin
with indoxyl acetate and subsequent alkylation of both nitrogen atoms,
either concomitantly or sequentially with the first alkylation taking
place at the isatin fragment. Synthesis of substituted isatins started
from commercially available 5,6-difluorinated isatin, which undergoes
selective nucleophilic aromatic substitution at the 6-position. Details
of the synthesis are given in the Supporting Information. For differently substituted indirubins 1c, 2c, 3a, 4a, 5a, and 5b in their Z-isomeric state, single crystals suitable
for X-ray structural analysis were obtained (Figure b,c), evidencing the molecular structures
directly.
Figure 2
Indirubin derivatives investigated in this study. (a) Molecular
structures of indirubines 1–5 in
their thermodynamically most stable Z-isomeric form.
(b) Structures of Z-isomeric indirubins 1c, 2c, 3a, 4a, 5a, and 5b in the crystalline state. Structures are shown
as ellipsoids with 50% probability. (c) Photographs of the crystals
of indirubins Z-2c, Z-3a, and Z-5a.
Indirubin derivatives investigated in this study. (a) Molecular
structures of indirubines 1–5 in
their thermodynamically most stable Z-isomeric form.
(b) Structures of Z-isomeric indirubins 1c, 2c, 3a, 4a, 5a, and 5b in the crystalline state. Structures are shown
as ellipsoids with 50% probability. (c) Photographs of the crystals
of indirubins Z-2c, Z-3a, and Z-5a.After the synthesis of indirubins 1–5 was established, their thermal behavior was investigated
first.
For all indirubin derivatives, the Z-isomeric state
is the thermodynamically most stable one, which is exclusively populated
at ambient temperatures. After Z- to E-photoisomerization has taken place for the dialkylated derivatives 1a–5a, the reverse thermal E- to Z-isomerization could be followed in the dark
in either toluene(-d8) or CD2Cl2/CH2Cl2 solution using 1H NMR or UV/vis spectroscopy. The obtained Gibbs energies of activation
ΔG‡ are similar for the indirubins
studied and range between 20.3–22.7 kcal/mol, corresponding
to half-lives τ1/2 of the metastable E-isomers of 2.6 min–2.7 h at 20 °C. Interestingly the
thermal E- to Z-isomerization of
indirubin 1a is significantly dependent on the concentration
in solution. If the concentration is increased by a factor of about
100 (2.6 versus 0.028 mmol L–1) in toluene solution,
the Gibbs energy of activation ΔG‡ is reduced by 1.4 kcal/mol. Although dilution experiments did not
hint at significant aggregation, comparison with the behavior of indirubin 2a points in this direction. Indirubin 2a bears
a branched alkyl chain at the isatin N-atom, which
is expected to increase solubility and reduce self-aggregation. In
this case, the concentration effects on the thermal E- to Z-isomerization are significantly subdued,
and the Gibbs energy of activation ΔG‡ is reduced by only 0.7 kcal/mol upon a 100-fold (2.5 versus 0.025
mmol L–1) concentration increase. With these ΔG‡ values and resulting thermal stabilities
of the E-configured metastable isomers, indirubins
are fully addressable at ambient conditions.The photochemistry
of dialkylated indirubins 1a–5a (Figure ) was investigated
next using a combination of UV/vis absorption
and NMR spectroscopy in conjunction with a comprehensive theoretical
assessment. The obtained quantitative experimental data are summarized
in Table . All derivatives
show pronounced absorptions in solution with maxima close to or beyond
600 nm, which makes them appear blue to the human eye (Figure b). The molar absorptions at
those maxima are typically in the range of ε = 10 000–15 000
L mol–1 cm–1. In more polar CH2Cl2, a red-shift of the absorption is observed
by 4–7 nm with negligible effects on the molar absorption values.
When comparing the absorptions of dialkylated with unsubstituted indirubin,
a noticeable red-shift of 54 nm is observed for the absorption of
the former. This red-shifted absorption is reproduced in the theoretical
description and can be attributed to the electron donation properties
of the alkyl substituents at the nitrogen atoms.
Figure 3
Photoswitching of indirubins
and supramolecular control thereof.
(a) Molar absorption coefficients of the Z- and E-isomers of indirubin 2a in the absence (solid
lines) and presence (dotted lines) of STC. Molar absorptions of the
respective E-isomers are obtained from measuring
the absorption of an E-enriched solution and subtracting
the spectral components of the remaining Z-isomer.
(b) Photographs of toluene-d8 solutions
of indirubin 5a irradiated to the pss with 625 nm light.
Solutions for NMR and UV/vis measurements are shown in the absence
(left tube/cuvette) and in presence (right tube/cuvette) of STC. (c)
Indicative sections of 1H NMR spectra (400 MHz, i–iii
0 °C, iv 20 °C, toluene-d8)
showing the switching capacity of indirubins 1a and 2a in the absence or presence of STC. (i) Initially only Z-isomers are present; (ii) after irradiation with 625 nm
light to the pss; (iii) after irradiation with 450 nm light to the
pss; (iv) after thermal E- to Z-isomerization.
(d) UV/vis absorption spectra of toluene solution of 2a showing reversible photoswitching with two shades of red.
Table 1
(Photo)physical and Photochemical
Properties of Dialkylated Indirubins 1a–5a as Determined by 1H NMR (#) or UV/vis
Absorption Spectroscopy (*)
indirubin
solvent
STC presence
ϕZ/E/% (at irradiation nm)*
ϕE/Z/% (at irradiation nm)*
isomer yield
in the pss/% (nominal LED nm)
ΔG‡ (therm.E/Z)/kcal mol–1
half-life
of pure E-isomer at 20 °C
1a
toluene(-d8)
no
0.8 ± 2 (625)
1.8 ± 2 (625)
46% E (625
nm)#
21.3–22.7
15 min–2.7 h
83% Z (450
nm)#
toluene(-d8)
yes
0.7 ± 2 (625)
0.3 ± 2 (625)
84% E (625
nm)#
22.4
1.6 h
61% Z (450
nm)#
toluene(-d8)
yes
46% Z (730
nm)*
CD2Cl2/CH2Cl2
no
62% E (625
nm)#
22.5
1.9 h
72% Z (450
nm)#
CD2Cl2/CH2Cl2
yes
82% E (625
nm)#
22.3
1.4 h
59% Z (450
nm)#
2a
toluene(-d8)
no
40% E (625
nm)#
22.1–22.4
1–1.6 h
87% Z (450
nm)#
toluene(-d8)
yes
84% E (625
nm)#
22.5
1.9 h
72% Z (450
nm)#
toluene(-d8)
yes
50% Z (730
nm)*
CD2Cl2/CH2Cl2
no
59% E (625
nm)#
22.3
1.4 h
75% Z (450
nm)#
CD2Cl2/CH2Cl2
yes
76% E (625
nm)#
22.3
1.4 h
56% Z (450
nm)#
3a
toluene(-d8)
no
46% E (625
nm)#
21.9
42 min
86% Z (450
nm)#
toluene(-d8)
yes
69% E (625
nm)#
22.2
1.1 h
86% Z (450
nm)#
toluene(-d8)
yes
37% Z (730
nm)*
CD2Cl2/CH2Cl2
no
59% E (625
nm)#
22.6
2.3 h
72% Z (450
nm)#
CD2Cl2/CH2Cl2
yes
67% E (625
nm)#
21.5
21 min
79% Z (450
nm)#
4a
toluene(-d8)
no
40% E (625
nm)#
21.6
25 min
85% Z (450
nm)#
toluene(-d8)
yes
75% E (625
nm)#
21.5
21 min
88% Z (450
nm)#
CD2Cl2/CH2Cl2
no
51% E (625
nm)#
21.4
18 min
75% Z (450
nm)#
CD2Cl2/CH2Cl2
yes
67% E (625
nm)#
21.7
29 min
82% Z (450
nm)#
5a
toluene(-d8)
no
24% E (625
nm)#
20.5
3.7 min
90% Z (450
nm)#
toluene(-d8)
yes
64% E (625
nm)#
20.3
2.6 min
89% Z (450
nm)#
CD2Cl2/CH2Cl2
no
27% E (625
nm)#
20.5
3.7 min
85% Z (450
nm)#
CD2Cl2/CH2Cl2
yes
32% E (625
nm)#
20.4
3.1 min
88% Z (450
nm)#
Photoswitching of indirubins
and supramolecular control thereof.
(a) Molar absorption coefficients of the Z- and E-isomers of indirubin 2a in the absence (solid
lines) and presence (dotted lines) of STC. Molar absorptions of the
respective E-isomers are obtained from measuring
the absorption of an E-enriched solution and subtracting
the spectral components of the remaining Z-isomer.
(b) Photographs of toluene-d8 solutions
of indirubin 5a irradiated to the pss with 625 nm light.
Solutions for NMR and UV/vis measurements are shown in the absence
(left tube/cuvette) and in presence (right tube/cuvette) of STC. (c)
Indicative sections of 1H NMR spectra (400 MHz, i–iii
0 °C, iv 20 °C, toluene-d8)
showing the switching capacity of indirubins 1a and 2a in the absence or presence of STC. (i) Initially only Z-isomers are present; (ii) after irradiation with 625 nm
light to the pss; (iii) after irradiation with 450 nm light to the
pss; (iv) after thermal E- to Z-isomerization.
(d) UV/vis absorption spectra of toluene solution of 2a showing reversible photoswitching with two shades of red.Upon irradiation with different wavelengths of light, no spectral
changes are observed for unsubstituted indirubin 1c at
ambient temperatures under continuous irradiation. This behavior resembles
the behavior of unsubstituted indigo, which undergoes a very rapid
excited-state proton transfer (ESPT) that outcompetes the slower photoisomerization
processes.[78] Upon replacement of at least
one NH proton of indigo by carbon-based substituents, reversible photoswitching
is observed, since no (efficient) ESPT can take place in these cases.[44,45,79] In a related approach, we show
here that replacement of both NH protons of indirubin by alkyl substituents
(1a–5a) allows photoisomerization
behavior to be elicited. If, however, only the NH proton of the isatin
fragment is replaced by alkyl substituents in, for example, 1c, again no photoisomerization is observed at ambient temperatures
under steady-state irradiation. This behavior strongly suggests that
the NH proton of the indigo fragment is a crucial feature inhibiting
productive photoswitching of indirubins.For dialkylated indirubins 1a–5aZ- to E-photoisomerization takes
place upon 625 nm irradiation, leading to a reduction of the maximum
at around 600 nm and a blue-shift of the absorption (see Figure a and the Supporting Information). This behavior establishes
negative photochromism for indirubins. At the same time, absorption
increases at around 450 nm. Despite a sizable photochromism in toluene
solution, photoisomerization does not lead to a very strong accumulation
of the metastable E-isomer in the pss. This can be explained by the higher quantum
yield for the “backwards” E- to Z-photoisomerization (ϕ = 1.8%) as opposed to the opposite Z- to E-photoisomerization (ϕ = 0.8%). As judged by NMR spectroscopy, between
24% (indirubin 5a) and 46% (indirubin 1a) of E-isomer is obtained upon 625 nm irradiation
in toluene-d8. When changing the solvent
to the more polar CH2Cl2/CD2Cl2, photochswitching is enhanced. As a result, higher E-isomer accumulations are achieved in the pss in this solvent
ranging from 27% (indirubin 5a) to 62% (indirubin 1a). Because of the increased absorption at 450 nm, E- to Z-photoisomerization can be induced
by blue light of this wavelength, which restores high Z-isomer content in the range of 83% (indirubin 1a) to
90% (indirubin 5a) in the pss in toluene solution. The
photoswitching is highly reversible, showing only a miniscule deterioration
of the performance after 10 full switching cycles (see Supporting Information). In CH2Cl2/CD2Cl2, a similar behavior is observed.
In this way, reversible photoswitching using red (625 or 660 nm) and
blue (450 nm) light is possible with alkylated indirubins. Quantitative
reversion of the metastable E- to the Z-isomeric state is possible thermally for all derivatives.Although dialkylated indirubins showed already
sizable red-light-induced
photoisomerization capacity, there was still room to improve the photoswitching
especially with regard to accumulation of metastable E-isomers in the pss. Typically, substitution approaches are followed
for this purpose. However, it became quickly apparent that substitution
changes at the isatin fragment were not very effective, as all dialkylated
derivatives 1a–5a provided a similar
photoswitching capacity. We therefore tested a different approach,
which relies on supramolecular interactions with an external hydrogen
bond donor. A similar idea has been introduced recently to influence
the thermal isomerizations of Stenhouse adduct (DASA) photoswitches,[80] but to the best of our knowledge, no strongly
beneficiary effects in the context of photoswitching have been shown
so far (for related intramolecular hydrogen bonding effects, see,
for example, refs (81−83) and for a covalently
linked thiourea–Stenhouse adduct to photoswitch solubility
see ref (55)). Upon
addition of STC, photochromism changed significantly for dialkylated
indirubins 1a–5a in solution. The
reason for this effect is a stronger recognition of the metastable E-isomer as opposed to the Z-isomer as
evidenced by significant induced shifts of the former’s 1H NMR signals (see Supporting Information). No significant changes for the Z-isomer signals
were observed upon STC addition. As a result of this selective recognition,
the absorption of the E-isomer is red-shifted such
that the initial negative photochromism is now turned into a positive
one with better spectral separation between the isomers’ absorption
spectra in the long-wavelength region. Additionally, the quantum yields
for the two photoreactions (Z- to E- and E- to Z-photoisomerizations
measured at 625 nm irradiation where both isomers absorb well) are
changed significantly upon STC binding. Without the presence of STC,
ϕ = 0.8% and
ϕ = 1.8%; however,
after addition of STC, the former remains essentially unaffected,
ϕ = 0.7%, while
the latter drops to ϕ = 0.3%. This behavior could be explained by a stabilization
of the E-isomeric state via association with STC
and a resulting hampering of productive photoisomerization. In favor of this explanation is the observation that
upon heating in the dark, a maximum of 2% E-isomeric
indirubins 1a and 2a remains in solution
in the presence of STC, while in the absence of STC, no E-isomer remains (Figure c). However, the kinetics of the thermal E- to Z-isomerization is not affected by addition
of STC, and the same half-lives of the respective E-isomers are observed in the presence or absence of STC (see Table for the exact values
quantified). The indifference of the thermal E-to Z-isomerization kinetics to the presence of STC suggests
also a more direct and possibly electronic influence of the thiourea
on the quantum yield. As a result of mainly the quantum yield changes,
highly improved E-isomer enrichment in the pss at
625 nm irradiation (where photochromism remains mediocre) is possible
in the presence of STC. From the initial 24% (indirubin 5a) to 46% (indirubin 1a) of obtained E-isomers in toluene solution, an improvement to 64% (indirubin 5a) to 84% (indirubin 1a) can now be achieved.
The reverse E- to Z-photoisomerization
can still be affected with blue light leading up to 72% Z-isomer enrichment despite lower quantum yields for this reaction
in the presence of STC. Almost complete reversal to the Z-isomer (100% for indirubins 3a–5a and at least 98% for indirubins 1a and 2a) is also still possible in all cases by a brief heating step. In
CH2Cl2/CD2Cl2, the effects
are lesser owing to the higher polarity of the surrounding solvent.
However, sizable improvements are still observed for the photoswitching
in this solvent. Because of the now positive photochromism, the reverse E- to Z-photoisomerization can also be
induced with red light of longer wavelengths. For example, starting
from 75% E-1a or 74% E-2a in in toluene solution irradiation with 730 nm light
delivers 46% and 50% of the corresponding Z-1a and Z-2a isomers, respectively
(Figure c). Therefore,
reversible photoswitching with two shades of red is achieved, one
of which resides close to the near-infrared (NIR) spectral region
without the need for high-intensity two-photon processes or sensitizing.
Because of the supramolecular nature of inducing such unusual light
addressability, it is possible to use the recognition process as an
additional control element. Without the thiourea, blue- and red-light
responsiveness is obtained in a negatively photochromic system. In
the presence of the thiourea, blue and red or dual red-light responsiveness
is obtained in a positively photochromic system with the very same
photoswitch. Also in this case, we observe high reversibility of the
all-red-light photoswitching and no significant deterioration of the
performance after 10 full switching cycles (see Supporting Information).To gain deeper insights into
the reason for the observed supramolecular
induction of photochromism change, we conducted a theoretical study
for indirubin 1 with a combination of methods, which
are described in detail in the Supporting Information. First, the structures of the Z- and E-isomers of indirubin 1a were optimized on the B3LYP/6-311G(d,p)
level of theory. Afterward, a preliminary screening of different supramolecular
interaction geometries for the complex between E-isomeric
indirubin 1a and 1 equiv of STC (other stoichiometries
could not reliably be described by theory owed to the significantly
increased complex size) was conducted using the MMFFs force field
and the MCMM algorithm for conformational analysis implemented within
the MacroModel program package of the Schroedinger suite. The variety
of obtained complex structures was scrutinized for structural redundancies,
and unique structures (up to 50 different conformers) were optimized
first on the B3LYP-D3BJ/6-31G(d)-PCM(tol) level of theory. Afterward,
again, redundant structures were discarded, and preoptimized unique
structures were reoptimized with a greater basis (6-311++G(d,p)).
Subsequent frequency analyses confirmed the obtained structures as
minima on the potential energy hypersurface. As can be seen from Figure a, the supramolecular
structure with lowest energy exhibits hydrogen bonding to STC via
both carbonyl oxygen atoms of indirubin’s isatin fragment.
Additional aromatic interactions are observed between the aromatic
surface of the upper isatin fragment and one electron-deficient aromatic
fragment of STC. There are also some possible dispersive interactions
occurring between the n-propyl chain of 1a’s isatin fragment and the other aromatic fragment of STC.
Figure 4
Theoretical
description of indirubin 1a photoswitching
and its supramolecular control. (a) Structure of the complex between E-1a and STC as optimized on the B3LYP-D3BJ/6-311++G(d,p)-PCM(tol)
level of theory. (b) Calculated (PBE0/6-311+G(d,p)-PCM(tol)//B3LYP-D3BJ/6-311G(d,p)-PCM(tol)
level of theory) UV/vis absorption of E-1a (solid black line) and of the complex between E-1a and STC (solid red line, the Boltzmann-averaged
spectrum of different complex structures is shown) and comparison
to the corresponding experimental spectra in toluene solution (dashed
black line for E-1a and dashed red line
for the complex between E-1a and STC).
Theoretical UV/vis absorptions taking into account two different binding
constants Ka = 1000 (solid pink line)
or Ka = 100 (solid blue line) are also
shown. (A reference concentration of 1 mmol L–1 was
assumed for the calculation of E-1a/E-1a–STC equilibrium ratios.) (c) Orbitals
involved in the electronic excitation of Z-1a (left), E-1a (middle), and
the E-1a–STC complex (right).
HOMO and LUMO are depicted together with a schematic representation
of the most important orbitals involved in the transition and the
resulting sum-excitation energies (purple numbers).
Theoretical
description of indirubin 1a photoswitching
and its supramolecular control. (a) Structure of the complex between E-1a and STC as optimized on the B3LYP-D3BJ/6-311++G(d,p)-PCM(tol)
level of theory. (b) Calculated (PBE0/6-311+G(d,p)-PCM(tol)//B3LYP-D3BJ/6-311G(d,p)-PCM(tol)
level of theory) UV/vis absorption of E-1a (solid black line) and of the complex between E-1a and STC (solid red line, the Boltzmann-averaged
spectrum of different complex structures is shown) and comparison
to the corresponding experimental spectra in toluene solution (dashed
black line for E-1a and dashed red line
for the complex between E-1a and STC).
Theoretical UV/vis absorptions taking into account two different binding
constants Ka = 1000 (solid pink line)
or Ka = 100 (solid blue line) are also
shown. (A reference concentration of 1 mmol L–1 was
assumed for the calculation of E-1a/E-1a–STC equilibrium ratios.) (c) Orbitals
involved in the electronic excitation of Z-1a (left), E-1a (middle), and
the E-1a–STC complex (right).
HOMO and LUMO are depicted together with a schematic representation
of the most important orbitals involved in the transition and the
resulting sum-excitation energies (purple numbers).TDDFT calculations allowed the corresponding theoretical
UV/vis
absorption spectra to be obtained for the isolated indirubins Z-1a (see Supporting Information) and E-1a as well as for the complex
between E-1a and STC (Figure b). In each case, 10 states
were taken into account to describe the absorption. When comparing
the absorption of Z-1a and E-1a, almost no difference in the overall transition
energies is observed, which is in general agreement with the experimentally
observed small negative photochromism. However, a full account of
negative photochromism is not found in the theoretical description
of the pure indirubin structures. For both isomers, Z-1a and E-1a, the main
contribution to the absorption stems from a HOMO–LUMO transition,
which can roughly be described as a π–π* transition
(Figure c). Here,
the double-bond character of the central isomerizable double bond
is lost upon transition to the LUMO, which is a prerequisite for indirubin
photoswitching capacity. Nevertheless, there are significant contributions
of lower-lying orbitals such as HOMO–2 or HOMO–3. The
absorption of the complex between E-1a and STC is found to be strongly red-shifted as compared to E-1a alone, which reproduces the experimentally
observed positive photochromism. When taking into account different
possible binding constants for complex formation (Figure b), the experimentally observed
spectral shifts are reproduced well for binding constants ranging
between 100 and 1000 M–1. For the E-1a–STC complex, the HOMO–LUMO π–π*
transition in indirubin is more dominant as a result of the hydrogen
bonding interaction with STC, which explains why the photochromism
now is positive (Figure c). Such a supramolecular influence of the environment on photoswitching
is frequently used in biological systems to tune photochemical properties
as most eminent for retinal photoswitching (see for example ref (84)). Different to many natural
systems (e.g., in natural retinal[85] or
bilin[86]) however, the mechanism at hand
does not involve a pronounced twisting of the chromophore structure
by the supramolecular interaction. Instead, polarity changes and polarization
play a more crucial role here.In summary, we present indirubin
as versatile red-light-responsive
photoswitch together with an effective supramolecular strategy to
significantly enhance its photoresponse. Alkylation of the NH protons
was found to be a fundamental prerequisite to elicit photoswitching
capacity and negative photochromism in the first place. Up to 62%
of the metastable E-isomer was obtained for alkylated
indirubins when irradiating with 625 nm red light, and up to 90% of
the Z-isomer is accumulated upon 450 nm blue-light
irradiation. After addition of the hydrogen bonding STC, the photochemistry
of indirubin is improved significantly via supramolecular interactions.
Up to 84% of the E-isomer is now obtained upon 625
nm irradiation, while at the same time, the negative photochromism
is turned into a positive one. The latter makes it possible to use
a different wavelength of red light, i.e., 730 nm, to induce the reverse E- to Z-photoisomerization. As a result,
indirubins can be photoswitched with two shades of red light, a highly
sought-after responsiveness for many applications. Conversion back
to the Z-isomer is also achieved thermally in all
cases. These results open up a new structural space for low-energy
light-driven photoisomerization reactions of double bonds within a
rigid and geometrically well-defined molecular framework. The advantage
of a supramolecular approach is compatibility with a variety of different
photoswitches (either the same class as shown in this work or in different
classes, which we will explore in the future) without the need for
additional substitution approaches on the photoswitch itself to adjust
its light response. Future elaboration of the herein presented supramolecular
principle by, for example, flexible covalent attachment of STC to
indirubin, will allow the observed beneficiary effects to be significantly
increased, which will be of importance for, for example, biological
applications requiring high dilutions and competitive environments.
Applications in responsive molecular and supramolecular systems are
currently under investigation in our laboratory and will be reported
in due course.
Authors: Alexander Sailer; Franziska Ermer; Yvonne Kraus; Ferdinand H Lutter; Carsten Donau; Maximilian Bremerich; Julia Ahlfeld; Oliver Thorn-Seshold Journal: Chembiochem Date: 2019-04-12 Impact factor: 3.164
Authors: Roland Wilcken; Ludwig Huber; Kerstin Grill; Manuel Guentner; Monika Schildhauer; Stefan Thumser; Eberhard Riedle; Henry Dube Journal: Chemistry Date: 2020-09-24 Impact factor: 5.236
Authors: James A Shriver; Kaylie S Kaller; Ally L Kinsey; Katelyn R Wang; Summer R Sterrenberg; Madison K Van Vors; Joshua T Cheek; John S Horner Journal: RSC Adv Date: 2022-02-15 Impact factor: 3.361