Linothele fallax (Mello-Leitão) (L. fallax) spider web, a potentially attractive tissue engineering material, was investigated using quantitative peak force measurement atomic force microscopy and scanning electron microscopy with energy dispersive spectroscopy both in its natural state and after treatment with solvents of different protein affinities, namely, water, ethanol, and dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO). Native L. fallax silk threads are densely covered by globular objects, which constitute their inseparable parts. Depending on the solvent, treating L. fallax modifies its appearance. In the case of water and ethanol, the changes are minor. In contrast, DMSO practically removes the globules and fuses the threads into dense bands. Moreover, the solvent treatment influences the chemistry of the threads' surface, changing their adhesive and, therefore, biocompatibility and cell adhesion properties. On the other hand, the solvent-treated web materials' contact effect on different types of biological matter differs considerably. Protein-rich matter controls humidity better when wrapped in spider silk treated with more hydrophobic solvents. However, carbohydrate plant materials retain more moisture when wrapped in native spider silk. The extracts produced with the solvents were analyzed using nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) and liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry techniques, revealing unsaturated fatty acids as representative adsorbed species, which may explain the mild antibacterial effect of the spider silk. The extracted metabolites were similar for the different solvents, meaning that the globules were not "dissolved" but "fused into" the threads themselves, being supposedly rolled-in knots of the protein chain.
Linothele fallax (Mello-Leitão) (L. fallax) spider web, a potentially attractive tissue engineering material, was investigated using quantitative peak force measurement atomic force microscopy and scanning electron microscopy with energy dispersive spectroscopy both in its natural state and after treatment with solvents of different protein affinities, namely, water, ethanol, and dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO). Native L. fallax silk threads are densely covered by globular objects, which constitute their inseparable parts. Depending on the solvent, treating L. fallax modifies its appearance. In the case of water and ethanol, the changes are minor. In contrast, DMSO practically removes the globules and fuses the threads into dense bands. Moreover, the solvent treatment influences the chemistry of the threads' surface, changing their adhesive and, therefore, biocompatibility and cell adhesion properties. On the other hand, the solvent-treated web materials' contact effect on different types of biological matter differs considerably. Protein-rich matter controls humidity better when wrapped in spider silk treated with more hydrophobic solvents. However, carbohydrate plant materials retain more moisture when wrapped in native spider silk. The extracts produced with the solvents were analyzed using nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) and liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry techniques, revealing unsaturated fatty acids as representative adsorbed species, which may explain the mild antibacterial effect of the spider silk. The extracted metabolites were similar for the different solvents, meaning that the globules were not "dissolved" but "fused into" the threads themselves, being supposedly rolled-in knots of the protein chain.
Natural spider silk
is an extremely strong, elastic, and flexible
material,[1−5] which was used for centuries in wound healing.[6−9] Spider silk shows reasonable biodegradability
and biocompatibility,[10−12] with only negligible inflammatory response. Since
this natural protein has combined charged residues and alternating
hydrophilic and hydrophobic regions,[13] it
may support the proliferation of different cell types, facilitating
cell growth and adhesion.[14−17] Thus, spider silk is a perspective material for the
development of many biomedical applications, such as tissue regenerating,
wound healing dressing, implant coatings, artificial tendons, surgical
threads, and blood vessel support.[14,18−21] Spider silk-based biopolymers show a slight antibacterial effect,
demonstrated in nature by spiders’ eggs and extra food wrapped
in silk fibers. The stored eggs and food are preserved for months
or even years unaffected by fungi and other microorganisms.[22,23] Although several reports attempted to decode the origin of the antimicrobial
properties of spider silk, the findings were unconvincing, or the
methods used were not accurate enough.[24−26] The evolutional antimicrobial
activity of spider silk is presumably based on surface or structural
qualities of the fibers, including physiologically important chemical
compounds and micro- and nanotopography features, determining the
material interaction with water.[27] Various
antifungal and antimicrobial agents, such as bisphosphonates, peptides,
phospholipid hydrates, and potassium nitrate, have been found in silk
fibers.[26] They define the bacteriostatic
efficiency of spider silk fibers and demonstrate that the development
of drug-free spider silk-based surgical biopolymers may improve antibacterial
properties of the biomedical materials by suppression of the microorganisms’
growth or reproduction.[28] As long as the
occurrence of postoperative inflammations composes one-fifth of post-transplant
complications, it is crucial to identify the material capable of firmly
connecting the places of tissue injuries, providing cell proliferation,
preventing formation of biofilms, and, consequently, restricting infections.[29,30] Several studies suggested that microorganisms are unable to grow
on spider silk due to its acidic nature.[31] Since acidic conditions have been proposed to inhibit the growth
of fungi, various pathogens, and silk protein-digesting bacteria,
spider silk is expected to be protected from bacterial attack and
degradation.[31,32] On the other hand, various studies
revealed that lipids in the spider silk contain several anteiso-fatty acids, such as 12-methyltetradecanoic acid and 14-methylhexadecanoic
acid, that seem to regulate the water content of silk and protect
protein-rich silk from degradation by inhibiting the growth of microorganisms.[33−36] It is also worth noting that spiders can protect themselves from
natural predators by synthesizing specific compounds. For example, Nephila antipodiana spiders have been found to produce
silk containing an insecticide, 2-pyrrolidinone, which seems to promote
self-defense against ant attacks.[37]The antimicrobial activity observed in the abovementioned studies
arises from a combination of soluble/insoluble growth-restraining
factors in silk and surface or structural material properties. For
example, SCP-1 and SCP-2 small coating peptides have been found on
the fiber surface of aciniform and tubuliform spider silks. They perform
functions of antimicrobial agents that help to prolong the longevity
of the fibers.[38] Additionally, other components
of spider silk, including phosphorylated glycoprotein, inorganic salts,
pigments, sulfur-containing amino acids, ionic forms of amines, and
lipids, are physiologically important and act as a protection layer
in the fibers and enhance the adhesiveness of silk fibers.[39,40] Upon contact with a solvent, spider silk releases antibacterial
substances into the medium, inducing antimicrobial and inhibitory
effects on a diverse group of microorganisms.The properties
and composition of silk vary noticeably between
and within spider species.[41] Therefore,
some discrepancies in response to silk from different spider species
should be expected. Additionally, different types of silk have various
amino acid compositions.[42] Because of the
hygroscopic nature of these amino acids, they prevent silk from drying
out by absorbing moisture from the air and saving it within the fiber.[43] This unique peculiarity is observed in the structure
of silk produced by the Uloborus walckenaerius spider, featuring spindle-knots made of random and aligned nanofibrils,
forming superhydrophobic and superhydrophilic patterns. The latter
play a key role in water collecting from a humid atmosphere on a micro-
and macroscale.[44]Wettability (hydrophilicity/hydrophobicity)
is a material surface
property, which affects bacterial adhesion, inducing special qualities,
such as self-sterilization to a surface.[45] Both negatively charged superhydrophobic and superhydrophilic surfaces
have been reported to be self-cleaning and, therefore, unsusceptible
to bacterial adhesion.[46,47] Of particular note, surface wettability
is determined by micro- and nanoscale surface topography. Thus, surface
roughness influences superhydrophobicity that limits bacterial adhesion
to the surface.[45] In parallel, a lot of
other natural biomaterials exhibit similar remarkable surface characteristics.
For instance, brush-turkey eggshells are covered with calcium phosphate
nanospheres,[48] which create a rough superhydrophobic
topography that results in low bacterial adhesion, contributing to
the antimicrobial defense of the eggs.[49]Investigation of silk features as a nanocomposite material
contributed
to understanding complex architectural designs of nanocrystals (∼2–4
nm) and self-assembly of nanofibrils (∼20–80 nm).[50,51] Nanofibrillar organization is assumed to play an essential role
in the native spider silk “core” structure. However,
insights into its hierarchical “skin” architecture and
the full complexity of its constituents remain elusive. Investigation
of the hierarchical organization of the spider silk fiber into distinct
structural elements based on various morphological features of this
material demonstrates an inner core discriminated from outer skin
layers covered with nanosized fibrils.[52,53] The origin
and functions of the nanoscale patterns found on the surface of native
spider silk have remained undetermined. To date, five different silk
layers have been distinguished, which can essentially influence the
mechanical performance and distinctive properties of spider silk.
However, only two of them are core layers and contain known silk proteins.[54]The initial premise of this work assumed
that the biomedical properties
of spider silk could be explained by the presence of some specific
compounds in the skin layers of the fibers. Conversely, we observed
that upon contact of native spider silk with different solvents, fiber
morphology changed considerably, and the strength of surface interactions
increased. To understand this phenomenon, a comprehensive approach
was required. Previous attempts to understand structure–property
relations in spider silk utilized nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR),[55,56] mass spectrometry (MS)[57] and X-ray diffraction,[58,59] optical,[54,60] electron,[53,61−63] and atomic force microscopy (AFM).[52,64,65] Recently, AFM has been beneficial for understanding
the structure–property relationships in spider silks since
AFM allows us to investigate the surface structure, interactions,
and local mechanical properties.[66,67]While
research on the silk complex structure is relatively widespread,
the components which play a key role in enhancing the surface interactions,
including adhesion to bacteria or cells, remain elusive. Therefore,
the purpose of this work was to provide straightforward analytical
understanding of the chemical nature of the healing and antimicrobial
effects of native spider silk and to link morphologically defined
structural elements of spider silk’s surface to its biochemical
composition and physicochemical properties. In the present study,
we demonstrated that nanopatterns covering the native spider silk
surface are central for surface interactions. Additionally, we identified
the mechanisms of conformational changes, depending on the interaction
with solvents, which brought insights on the molecular level. Specifically,
the present study aims were to shed light on the mystery of the nature
of surface globules of spider silk threads and to get insights into
how their principal functional characteristics emerge. Explanation
of the relationship between the supramolecular organization of spider
silk and the origin of its outstanding biological properties is expected
to open avenues in the production of high-performance artificially
spun fibers.
Experimental Section
Materials
Ethanol (96.0–97.2%, Sigma-Aldrich),
dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) (VWR chemicals, Molecular Biology Grade),
and Milli-Q grade deionized water (18.2 MΩ·cm–1 resistivity) were used in all experiments. Materials used for antibacterial
tests included Luria–Bertani (LB) agar (microbiologically tested,
Sigma-Aldrich).Linothele fallax (Mello-Leitão) (L. fallax)
spider (see Figure S1) web harvesting was
done from individuals fed for 2–3 weeks prior to silk collection. L. fallax is a species of spiders from the family Dipluridae, known as curtain-web spiders in the suborder Mygalomorphae. They have very long
spinnerets and build silk-lined burrows instead of circular spider
web produced by many other orders of spiders.[68−70] An important
feature of spider species in the suborder Mygalomorphae is that this order possesses a comparatively undifferentiated spinning
apparatus consisting of uniform spigots that lead to homogeneous,
acinous-shaped silk glands and generate one single type of silk thread
woven into dense mats, making it an attractive model for studies.[71−73]Treatment with solvents was carried out on ca. 50 mg of spider
silk with 2 mL of solvent in glass vials by shaking overnight. The
web was then separated using tweezers and dried for 24 h in air on
a Petri dish and then again for 24 h on carbon tape for subsequent
scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and atomic force microscopy (AFM)
studies.
Methods
Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy (FTIR)
FTIR
analysis was used to investigate the silk’s secondary structure.
Spectra were acquired with a Nicolet iS10 FTIR spectrometer (Thermo
Fisher Scientific). The spectra were measured in the range from 4000
to 400 cm–1 in the absorbance mode. Dry samples
were treated with crystalline KBr (1 mg of sample:199 mg of KBr) and
then pressed into a disk. The data were obtained at a resolution of
0.5 cm–1 with 40 cumulated scans and a signal-to-noise
ratio of 40,000:1. The fitting of the amide I peak was performed using
Gaussian functions. The criteria employed for the determination of
the initial conditions of the fitting were based in the second derivative
of the experimental spectrum. The minima of the second derivative
were used to determine the number and position of the Gaussian functions
used for the fitting. The initial full width at half maximum was from
the beginning fixed to 8 cm–1 for every Gaussian
used to fit the spectrum. Finally, the fitting was performed after
applying a linear baseline. The fitting process was in all cases carried
out with Omnic 9 software; please see the example of the deconvolution
process in Figure S2. The areas of the
Gaussians were used to estimate the content of the different secondary
structures according to the band assignments, which are presented
in Table .
Table 1
Vibrational Band Assignment in the
Amide I Region
wavenumbera
assignment
references
1621–1627
intermolecular β-sheet
(74−77)
1628–1637
intramolecular β-sheet
(74, 76, 78−80)
1638–1655
random coil
(78, 79)
Unit in wavenumbers (cm–1).
Unit in wavenumbers (cm–1).
Atomic Force Microscopy
AFM studies were carried out
on a Bruker Advance FastScan Bio with a ScanAsyst microscope, equipped
with QPFM hardware (cantilever calibration readout unit) and software.
The cantilevers applied were precalibrated with a Bruker RTESPA-150-30
(Antimony(n)-doped Silicon). Calculations for analyzing peak force
curves were made using the Bruker AFM Analysis platform and the SPIP
program (Ref: Scanning Probe Image Processor software by ImageMet
A/S Denmark, https://www.imagemet.com/products/spip/).
Scanning Electron Microscopy with Energy Dispersive Spectroscopy
SEM–energy dispersive spectroscopy (EDS) investigation was
done using Hitachi TM-1000-μ-DeX and Flex-SEM-1000 II microscopes.
EDS analysis was carried out with an Oxford Instruments AZtec Live
system. The samples were produced by attaching a portion of a web
on a piece of thin carbon tape (Hitachi High-Tech Sweden) attached
in turn to a steel disc. Identical samples were used in both AFM and
SEM, but in the latter case, they were also sputtered with gold in
1 min. This explains the presence of traces of Fe in the analysis
and also of Au (removed from quantification).
Nuclear Magnetic
Resonance
NMR spectra were acquired
on Bruker Advance III 600 MHz spectrometers with a 5 mm inverse detection
cryoprobe or a 5 mm broadband observe detection SmartProbe, both equipped
with a z gradient. Extracts for NMR were prepared
by treating spider silk (50 mg) with deuterium oxide (D2O), ethanol-d6, or DMSO-d6 in glass vials overnight. Spectra from the D2O extract were acquired with a 1D NOESY experiment with presaturation
(Bruker pulse sequence noesygppr1d) to suppress the
residual water signal. Spectra were recorded at 25 °C and were
processed with TopSpin 3.6.1. 1H chemical shifts were referenced
to solvent signals (HDO 4.77 ppm; ethanol-d6 1.11 and 3.56 ppm; and DMSO-d6 2.50
ppm). Signals were assigned with the help of TOCSY and HSQC experiments.
Liquid Chromatography–Mass Spectrometry
LC–MS
analysis was carried out on water and ethanol extracts. The chromatographic
separation was performed on an Agilent 1290 Infinity II (Agilent Technologies,
Santa Clara, CA) LC using a Waters Xbridge BEH amide column (3.5 μm,
4.6 × 100 mm). The aqueous phase consisted of 95:5 (vol/vol)
water/acetonitrile with 20 mmol/L ammonium acetate and ammonium hydroxide.
The separation was carried out using gradient elution. The following
gradient program was used (% organic phase): 0 min 85%, 3 min 30%,
12 min 2%, 15 min 2%, 16 min 85%, and 23 min 85%. A total of 10 μL
of the extract was injected onto the column thermostatted at 30 °C,
and the mobile-phase flow rate was 400 μL/min. The MS analysis
was performed on a Bruker maXis Impact (Bruker Daltonics, Bremen,
Germany) high-resolution time-of-flight mass spectrometer with an
electrospray ion source. The capillary voltage was set at 4 kV with
a plate offset of 500 V. Desolvation was done using 200 °C nitrogen
gas at 8 L/min and a nebulizer pressure of 2 bars. The sampling rate
was 4 GHz, and profile mass spectra were collected at a rate of 1
Hz. Mass-to-charge ratios (m/z)
corresponding to unsaturated, monounsaturated, and di-unsaturated
carboxylic acids and saturated and monounsaturated dicarboxylic acids
with chain lengths from 3 to 36 carbons were screened. The m/z was considered to be present in the
sample if the extracted ion chromatogram showed a local signal-to-noise
ratio > 3.
Cell Adhesion Experiments
Nonmalignant
hFB-hTERT6 human
skin fibroblasts were obtained via lentiviral transduction of the
full-length TERT gene under a cytomegalovirus promoter (donated by
Dr. E. Dashinimaev, Engelhardt Institute of Molecular Biology, Moscow).
Spider silk samples were exposed to UV light (250 nm) for 30 min before
cell seeding for sterilization. Glasses covered with silk were transported
in 6 well-plate Eppendorf 200,000 cells (fibroblasts) per well, with
samples on the cover glass added. Cells were cultured in Dulbecco’s
modified Eagle’s medium supplemented with 10% fetal bovine
serum, 50 U mL–1 penicillin, and 50 μg mL–1 streptomycin at 37 °C and 5% CO2 in
a humidified atmosphere for 24 h. It is time for cells to adhere to
the surface and not start actively proliferating. After that, the
cells were washed with 1× phosphate-buffered saline (PBS) (Gibco,
1×, pH = 7.4) and stained with acridine orange (0.005 mg/mL)
for 10 min. After washing, the samples were fixed in 4 wt % paraformaldehyde
solution in PBS for 10 min and mounted in the glycerol onto the glass
slides. The microscopy images were taken on an inverted Microscope
Leica DMi8 using 10× and 20× objectives. Acridine orange
was used as a stain for better cell visualizing. Fluorescent images
were obtained in a rhodamine filter (silk has its fluorescence in
every channel partly because of unspecific staining with acridine
orange and partly because of its natural properties; RNA molecules
in fibroblasts were visualized in a rhodamine filter). For each condition,
four distinct samples were analyzed from three independent experiments
(plus control samples, see Figure S3).
Biological Activity Tests
Biological activity tests
were performed in a Petri dish with LB agar. Bacterial culture Staphylococcus aureus (S. aureus) with a sample of natural spider silk was incubated for 24 h at
37 °C in liquid nutrient medium. The test substance was applied
with sterile discs (d = 6 mm) with further incubation
for 18 h at 37 °C. Later, the inhibition zone of bacterial growth
was measured.
Degree of the Food Product Freshness
The degree of
the food product freshness was determined by bacterioscopy. We used
initial sausage samples and samples wrapped in spider webs in square-shape
pieces with a 1 cm side. After removing the spider silk, we made uncontaminated
slices of the samples, which were applied three times to the slide
to obtain an imprint on the glass surface. The number of bacteria
was established on Gram-stained[81] samples
using a microscope.
Results and Discussion
Morphological
Characteristics
The thickness of the L. fallax web silk threads varies from 0.2 to just
below 2 μm according to SEM imaging (Figure ) and is not visibly affected by treatment
with solvents. Its chemical composition, determined by EDS, consists
of carbon, nitrogen, and oxygen and shows glycine, alanine, and serine
as the major building units of the spider silk protein threads.[45]
Figure 1
SEM images of the L. fallax spider
silk: (A) native spider silk and (B) spider silk after treatment with
water, (C) ethanol, and (D) DMSO.
SEM images of the L. fallax spider
silk: (A) native spider silk and (B) spider silk after treatment with
water, (C) ethanol, and (D) DMSO.A common feature of the threads is their dense coverage by globules,
practically forming uniform hexagonal packing on their surface. The
size of the globules on the surface of native silk is ca. 40–80
nm, with an average of 56.5 nm (Figure A). Submersion in water or ethanol does not change
the general appearance of the threads. The size of the globules is,
however, greatly affected by the treatment. After immersion in ethanol,
the size of the globules increases to ca. 80–110 nm, with an
average of 85.5 nm (Figure B). After longer exposure to water, the average globule size
was 70–120 nm, with an average of about 105 nm (Figure C). Conversely, the spider
silk threads basically completely lose the globular features after
treatment with DMSO (Figure D).
Figure 2
AFM images and size distribution for surface globules in (A) native
spider silk and (B) spider silk after treatment with ethanol, (C)
water, and (D) DMSO.
AFM images and size distribution for surface globules in (A) native
spider silk and (B) spider silk after treatment with ethanol, (C)
water, and (D) DMSO.The changes in surface
appearance are closely connected to the
surface forces emerging when interacting with a cantilever. The forces
were measured on top of the globules and averaged statistically. For
force mapping, please see Figure S4. Native
silk displays minimal interactions, with a snap-in force of 27 ±
6 nN. The interaction increases after treatment with ethanol (50 ±
9 nN), becomes even stronger after treatment with water (71 ±
12 nN), and is strongest after treatment with DMSO (121 ± 11
nN).
Chemical Composition of the Surface
The infrared (IR)
spectrum of natural untreated silk showed that vibrational C=O
stretching affected the amide I (1600–1700 cm–1), and N–H bending belonged to the amide II (1600–1500
cm–1) regions of proteins. The bands in the range
of 1640–1650 cm–1 appear because of stretching
vibrations within the C–O and N–H groups that are defined
by the conformational structure of the protein backbone.[78,79] The amide I mode connected with the random coil conformations provides
bands in the range of 1640–1650 cm–1, and
the peak between 1620 and 1640 cm–1 represents the
β-sheet conformation. After treatment with the DMSO solvent,
a new strong band at 1626 cm–1 appeared in the spectra
instead of the main amide I peak 1652 cm–1 of the
native spider silk. Because the absorbance at 1626 cm–1 is related to the β-sheet conformation of spider silk, the
development of the amide I band shows a drastic increase with the
changing of solvents from water and ethanol to DMSO. This occurs because
solvents are disrupting intramolecular hydrogen bonds between peptide
groups, resulting in partial unfolding of globular structures. Despite
the lack of hydrogen bonding in organic solvents, they also have electrostatic
polar interactions, which contribute to the detected amide I intensity.
The intensity variations can be caused by dielectric interactions
with the solvent, not by hydrogen bonding alone. The methylene groups
(CH2) in fatty acids stretch asymmetrically and symmetrically
in the range of 2920–2850 cm–1 (precisely
at 2926 and 2853 cm–1, respectively, for asymmetrical
and symmetrical stretching) after treatment with ethanol.The
C–N stretching vibration depending on the N–H in-plane
bending vibration reveals amide III. The strong O–H absorption
of hydroxyl residues of serine and threonine amino acids significantly
overlaps the N–H stretching absorption of amide groups with
the spectrum at 3300 cm–1. The 1394 and 1065 cm–1 peaks are assigned with C–OH stretching vibration
and C–H and O–H bond vibrations because of the prevalence
of hydroxyl amino acid side chains.The transmission band at
2900–3000 cm–1 appears to correlate to alkyl
fragments (−CH3 and
−CH2), whereas the peaks of medium intensity at
3330–3070 cm–1 in the IR spectrum of the
sample appeared to refer to the bending vibration of the imide group
(−CONHR). A comparison between native silk and the one treated
with ethanol is provided in Figure , showing the absence of changes in both the position
of bands and their relative intensity. EDS analysis of the samples
(see Figure S5a–d) confirms the
constant total elemental composition of the web through all kinds
of treatment, featuring C, N, and O in the ratio, corresponding to
the average for the constituting amino acids (mostly, glycine, alanine,
and serine). Elemental maps for these three elements show the same
features following the location of spider web threads. It is important
to mention that no significant mass fraction of heavy metals was found
on the surface of silk thread, eliminating their possible effect on
the antibacterial properties of the web.
Figure 3
FTIR spectra of L. fallax spider
silk and percentage of secondary structures in spider silk proteins:
(A) native silk, (B) after treatment with ethanol, (C) after treatment
with water, and (D) after treatment with DMSO.
FTIR spectra of L. fallax spider
silk and percentage of secondary structures in spider silk proteins:
(A) native silk, (B) after treatment with ethanol, (C) after treatment
with water, and (D) after treatment with DMSO.
Composition of Extracts by Different Solvents
NMR spectroscopy
was used to trace the species removed from the web by applied solvents.
The water extract contained miniscule amounts of low-molecular weight
compounds, where choline, glycerol, succinate, and betaine could be
detected (Figures and S6). These are most probably residual
components of the silk,[88] partly removed
from it by base pretreatment prior to extraction. The ethanol extract,
on the other hand, contained mainly saturated fatty acids. The presence
of fatty acids in spider silk and spider web droplets has previously
been demonstrated.[36,89] Finally, the DMSO extract showed
the presence of saturated fatty acids and small amounts of taurine
and acetate.
Figure 4
Selected region of 1H NMR spectra from (A)
water, (B)
ethanol, and (C) DMSO extracts of L. fallax spider silk. Assigned signals are highlighted with numbers that
refer to the different compounds: (1) betaine, (2) glycerol, (3) choline,
(4) succinate, (5) fatty acids, (6) unassigned impurity, (7) residual
ethanol signals, (8) water, (9) taurine, (10) residual DMSO signal,
and (11) acetate. The intensity scale of spectrum A is considerably
increased compared to the other two spectra.
Selected region of 1H NMR spectra from (A)
water, (B)
ethanol, and (C) DMSO extracts of L. fallax spider silk. Assigned signals are highlighted with numbers that
refer to the different compounds: (1) betaine, (2) glycerol, (3) choline,
(4) succinate, (5) fatty acids, (6) unassigned impurity, (7) residual
ethanol signals, (8) water, (9) taurine, (10) residual DMSO signal,
and (11) acetate. The intensity scale of spectrum A is considerably
increased compared to the other two spectra.MS was used to further investigate the spider silk extracts. NMR
analysis indicated the presence of fatty acids in the extracts. A
range of mass-to-charge ratios corresponding to saturated and unsaturated
carboxylic acids with carbon chain lengths between 3 and 36 comprising
saturated, monounsaturated, and dicarboxylic acids were thus investigated.
Mass-to-charge ratios corresponding to saturated carboxylic acids
of all chain lengths from 3 to 26 carbons could be detected. For monounsaturated
carboxylic acids, all chain lengths from 4 to 26 carbons could be
detected, and for di-unsaturated carboxylic acids, mass-to-charge
ratios corresponding to all chain lengths from 5 to 24 carbons could
be seen. Signals corresponding to dicarboxylic acids were also detected,
with signals corresponding to saturated dicarboxylic acids with chain
lengths from 3 to 34 and monounsaturated dicarboxylic acids with 4–24
carbon atom chains being detected. No significant differences in fatty
acid species distribution between the water and ethanol extracts could
be detected. For details, please see Table S1.
Biological Characteristics of Materials
Contact antibacterial
properties were tested by following the cultivation of S. aureus Gram-positive bacteria on Petri dishes.
No pronounced clearing zone could be observed around the pieces of
the spider web. However, the pressed pieces themselves were not colonized
by S. aureus Gram-positive bacteria,
while single threads were overgrown by them (Figure S7). As almost no bacterial colonies formed on LB medium in
the presence of the pieces of the spider web, slight antibacterial
activity of the silk threads could be expected.In the search
to distinguish the effects of altered surface chemistry on biological
systems, we aimed to follow the influence of spider web wrapping on
the storage of fresh materials representing animal and plant tissues.
The target samples were selected as a 5 × 5 × 5 mm freshly
cut piece of Varionaya cooked sausage supplied by the Vostryakovo-2
company, which includes the following ingredients: pork, beef, pork
fat, water, egg product (mélange), skimmed milk powder, salt,
and extracts of natural spices (black pepper, ginger, and nutmeg).
The samples of fresh ripe raspberry, grown in Morocco and produced
by Driscoll’s Du Maroc company, were approximately 12 mm in
diameter. The surface of each sample was entirely covered by several
layers of the spider silk treated with different solvents and native
spider silk, and the comparison samples were maintained uncovered.
The appearance of animal samples was documented after 10 h (Figure A). Sample weight
of the model animal and plant tissues was measured every 24 h for
10 days. The tests included a set with five replicates for each product.
A distinct difference was observed between the model protein and the
plant tissue. Figure B,C demonstrates reducing product weight of animal and plant origin
with and without wrapping within 10 days. It is important to mention
that silk coverage retained its initial appearance and prevented formation
of the mold in the case of strawberry, as shown in Figure S8. The view of the internal state of samples was not
indicative because of too long storage with the following excessive
leakage of water.
Figure 5
(A) Images of drying of model animal tissue samples, loss
of humidity
in (B) sausage and (C) fresh raspberry piece weight loss without spider
silk and wrapped into native spider silk and into spider web treated
with different solvents.
(A) Images of drying of model animal tissue samples, loss
of humidity
in (B) sausage and (C) fresh raspberry piece weight loss without spider
silk and wrapped into native spider silk and into spider web treated
with different solvents.For the pieces of sausage,
the loss of humidity on drying was distinctly
dependent on the nature of treatment for the spider web. The unwrapped
material lost over 60% of its weight within a day of storage. Being
wrapped in the untreated web led to a loss of about 50%, while using
DMSO-treated silk only retained a bit over 10%. However, most notable
was that the water- and ethanol-treated webs managed to preserve almost
half the moisture content for the entire duration of the experiment
(10 days). On the contrary, for the plant material, moisture loss
was analogous within the experimental error for both wrapped and unwrapped
samples, independent of the solvent treatment.The degree of
product freshness preservation was evaluated using
bacteriostatic analysis (Figure S9). Corresponding
to the humidity retention, the number of bacteria detected on the
pieces of sausage during storage was influenced by the nature of treatment
for the spider web. The highest content of bacteria was observed in
unwrapped samples. Being wrapped in untreated and water-treated spider
silk, the sausage pieces remained the freshest, contaminated almost
half as much as unwrapped pieces on the fourth day. Wrapping of samples
with ethanol- and DMSO-treated spider webs also reduced the contamination,
keeping food fresh, in contrast to unwrapped products.Finally,
biocompatibility and cell adhesion tests were carried
out for nonmalignant hFB-hTERT6 human skin fibroblast cell cultivation
on the untreated and solvent-treated spider silk scaffolds. Cell attachment
was observed for samples of native silk and silk after treatment with
ethanol, after treatment with water, and after treatment with DMSO,
in contrast to control tests (see Figures and S3).
Figure 6
Images of fibroblast
cell adhesion tests on scaffolds made from
(A) native spider silk and (B) spider silk after treatment with ethanol,
(C) water, and (D) DMSO.
Images of fibroblast
cell adhesion tests on scaffolds made from
(A) native spider silk and (B) spider silk after treatment with ethanol,
(C) water, and (D) DMSO.
Discussion
L. fallax was chosen as the producer of the model
material in this work because
its silk was recently demonstrated to be attractive as a tissue engineering
material with beneficial biointernalization characteristics.[82] It is a Bolivian curtain-web spider with an
enlarged abdomen that makes up half of the spider’s body. Thus,
the amount of silk produced is substantially larger than that of typical
orb-web spiders.Apparently, treatment with a solvent does not
lead to any noticeable change in the chemical structure, as shown
by FTIR investigation, but the availability of different fragments
and residues becomes influenced. It can be concluded that the solvating
ability of the solvent[74] and general protein
solubility in the said solvent led to an increase in the size of the
globules and their eventual disappearance in the case of DMSO.[83,84]Figure illustrates
a plausible explanation for the nature of the observed globule morphological
structure represented in rolled-in loops of a protein chain, which
change in sizes and roll out with varying degrees due to the type
of the solvent. This supposition is well in line with the hypothesis
proposed recently by Wang and Schniepp[67] that the single-protein chains in the spider silk are forming knots
which contribute to the increased mechanical strength of the threads.
Treatment with different solvents influences the ability of threads
to interact with other materials. More solvating media render them
stickier, which may have importance in surgical thread and tissue
engineering applications. Dragline silk transformation on different
treatments is a topic of special attention in modulating its properties
for biomedical applications.[58]
Figure 7
Illustration
of protein loops rolling in, forming surface knots.
Illustration
of protein loops rolling in, forming surface knots.It can also be concluded that the globules in the case of L. fallax spider silk are not glued particles or external protein crystals on the surface
of a thread but loops of the threads themselves. The globules were
thus not dissolving and releasing some content but supposedly rolling
out, forming more open loops with increased capacity for surface interactions,
guided apparently by hydrogen bonding. Based on FTIR and NMR analysis,
the dissolved content mainly consisted of different anteiso-fatty acids and low-molecular weight compounds, including choline,
glycerin, succinate, and betaine, supposedly adsorbed on the whole
surface of protein threads (for details, please see Table S1). The amount of the material that is dissolved is
rather minor, and it mainly contains saturated and unsaturated fatty
acids, contributing potentially to the minor antibacterial effect
of spider silk. In the view that the material used in this work was
pretreated first with a base and then with an acid, the amount of
this natural antiseptic was apparently decreased, leading to the absence
of a clearing zone in experiments with S. aureus bacteria.The differences between cell attachments were minor
and within
the margin of error. The reason for the small influence of treatment
on cell attachment is the absence of specific amino acid adhesion
motifs native for the fibroblast’s environment such as arginyl–glycyl–aspartic
acid (fibronectin)[85] and GFOGER (collagen
I)[86] in most naturally derived silks. The
adhesion which we could observe in this experiment depends only on
quite weak cell–silk interactions: silk surface charge, wettability,
and fibrous topology.[87] This phenomenon
can also be explained by the amphiphilic properties of the globules.
As we assume, the globules are similar in nature to the top layer
of silk threads, which, according to the data obtained, can bear adsorbed
lipids. Untight distribution of globules on the native spider silk
suggests that the knot coat will not significantly contribute to the
mechanical performance of the fibers. However, rolling out of knots
may increase the hydrophobicity of the silk surface, thereby impairing
the adhesion of cells, leading to their slithering from the surface
of the fibers.This property also can partially explain the
effect of retaining
humidity. No influence on the plant tissue rich in and protected by
carbohydrate polymers could be observed. On the contrary, preservation
of freshness of the protein-rich animal model tissue was more efficient
when samples were wrapped with spider silk. The most significant effect
on product preservation was achieved by wrapping protein tissues with
spider silk fibers after the ethanol treatment. Almost the same strong
effect was observed when silk threads were treated with water due
to still enlarged sizes of protein knots. Wrapping with the sticky
DMSO-treated material protected samples slightly worse. The most inconsiderable
influence on protein product saving was observed after wrapping with
native spider silk. These effects may be important for tissue scaffolds
in wound healing, where humidity balance is crucial, and for the development
biodegradable natural food packaging Furthermore, we suppose that
spider silk can be used as a coating to enhance the freshness of perishable
protein products by deceleration of their respiration, extending protein
firmness and preventing dehydration. Wrapping food with silk mats
is a potential alternative for preservation, exploiting naturally
generated material, permitting water-based processing of comestibles.
According to slight antibacterial properties of spider silk, this
material can be applicable in packaging without applying other antimicrobial
agents. The property of spider silk polymorphism may be applied to
modify the coating’s characteristics, altering the effect of
silk fibroin on water evaporation and food degradation. Other advantages
of spider silk-based packaging are the edibility of silk and possibility
to improve coatings with stable biomacromolecules. This expands the
usability of functional coatings, which may be used even to provide
therapeutic functions to consumable items without resorting to complicated
chemistries and enabling preservation.
Conclusions
In
the present work, the surface properties of spider silk were
quantitatively characterized in its natural state and after treatment
with solvents of different protein affinities—water, ethanol,
and DMSO. Native silk threads are densely covered by globular objects,
which constitute their inseparable parts. Treatment with the solvents
modifies their appearance and adhesive properties, dependent on the
solvent. In the case of water and ethanol, changes were minor. In
contrast, DMSO practically removed the globules and fused the threads
into dense bands.Most importantly, treatment with the solvents
altered the surface
chemistry of the threads. The extracted metabolites were similar for
the different solvents according to NMR and LC–MS data, implying
that the globules were “fused into” the threads themselves,
being supposedly rolled-in knots of a protein chain. Treatment with
different solvents influences the ability of threads to interact with
other materials. These results make an important contribution to the
fundamental study of natural scleroprotein-based biopolymers and the
development of promising biocompatible materials for medical applications,
especially for wound healing. Complete comprehensive wound management
usually includes the following aspects: protection of the wound against
bacterial activity, control of humidity balance and inflammation,
and supporting the growth of the new epithelium. Nevertheless, modern
methods of therapy cannot simultaneously provide for all these needs.
Since solvating media rendered spider silk fibers stickier and enlarged
the size of the globules that regulate humidity balance and cell adhesion,
the obtained data may cause a great interest in the development of
wound healing dresses and in creation of surgical threads and for
tissue engineering. Spider silk-based surgical materials not only
meet mechanical and functional application requirements and induce
an immune response but also overcome the formation of bacterial biofilms
because of a slight antibacterial effect, reducing the risk of infections.
Authors: Heliana C Salles; Evelyn Cristina F R Volsi; Maurício R Marques; Bibiana M Souza; Lucilene D dos Santos; Cláudio F Tormena; Maria A Mendes; Mario S Palma Journal: Chem Biodivers Date: 2006-07 Impact factor: 2.408
Authors: Albina R Franco; Emanuel M Fernandes; Márcia T Rodrigues; Fernando J Rodrigues; Manuela E Gomes; Isabel B Leonor; David L Kaplan; Rui L Reis Journal: Acta Biomater Date: 2019-09-07 Impact factor: 8.947