Yanmiao Fan1, Soumitra Mohanty2,3, Yuning Zhang1, Mads Lüchow1, Liguo Qin1,4, Lisa Fortuin1, Annelie Brauner2,3, Michael Malkoch1. 1. School of Chemical Science and Engineering, Fiber and Polymer Technology, KTH Royal Institute of Technology, Teknikringen 56-58, SE-100 44 Stockholm, Sweden. 2. Department of Microbiology, Tumor and Cell Biology, Karolinska Institutet, SE-17165 Stockholm, Sweden. 3. Division of Clinical Microbiology, Karolinska University Hospital, Solna, Stockholm SE-17176, Sweden. 4. Institute of Design Science and Basic Components, Xían Jiaotong University, 710049 Xían, P. R. China.
Abstract
Infections caused by antibiotic-resistant bacteria are globally a major threat, leading to high mortality rates and increased economic burden. Novel treatment strategies are therefore urgently needed by healthcare providers to protect people. Biomaterials that have inherent antibacterial properties and do not require the use of antibiotics present an attractive and feasible avenue to achieve this goal. Herein, we demonstrate the effect of a new class of cationic hydrogels based on amino-functional hyperbranched dendritic-linear-dendritic copolymers (HBDLDs) exhibiting excellent antimicrobial activity toward a wide range of clinical Gram-positive and Gram-negative bacteria, including drug-resistant strains isolated from wounds. Intriguingly, the hydrogels can induce the expression of the antimicrobial peptides RNase 7 and psoriasin, promoting host-mediated bacterial killing in human keratinocytes (HaCaT). Moreover, treatment with the hydrogels decreased the proinflammatory cytokine IL-1β, reactive nitrogen species (NO), and mitochondrial reactive oxygen species (ROS) in S. aureus-infected HaCaT cells, conjunctively resulting in reduced inflammation.
Infections caused by antibiotic-resistant bacteria are globally a major threat, leading to high mortality rates and increased economic burden. Novel treatment strategies are therefore urgently needed by healthcare providers to protect people. Biomaterials that have inherent antibacterial properties and do not require the use of antibiotics present an attractive and feasible avenue to achieve this goal. Herein, we demonstrate the effect of a new class of cationic hydrogels based on amino-functional hyperbranched dendritic-linear-dendritic copolymers (HBDLDs) exhibiting excellent antimicrobial activity toward a wide range of clinical Gram-positive and Gram-negative bacteria, including drug-resistant strains isolated from wounds. Intriguingly, the hydrogels can induce the expression of the antimicrobial peptides RNase 7 and psoriasin, promoting host-mediated bacterial killing in human keratinocytes (HaCaT). Moreover, treatment with the hydrogels decreased the proinflammatory cytokine IL-1β, reactive nitrogen species (NO), and mitochondrial reactive oxygen species (ROS) in S. aureus-infected HaCaT cells, conjunctively resulting in reduced inflammation.
The overuse and misuse
of conventional antibiotics,[1,2] together with the accumulation
of nondegradable antibiotics, contribute
to the alarming evolution of resistant bacteria.[3] Emerging multidrug-resistant (MDR) bacteria escalate the
situation as there are few or no effective antibiotics left to use
against these bacteria.[4,5] It is therefore critical that
we develop alternative treatment strategies to combat infections caused
by such bacteria.[6]To fight invading
microorganisms, the body is equipped with antimicrobial
peptides (AMPs). These endogenously expressed host defense molecules
protect us from invading pathogens. AMPs including cathelicidin,[7] β defensin-2, RNase7,[8,9] and
psoriasin[10] serve as the first-line defense
to protect the keratinocytes from infection. Most AMPs are small and
cationic in nature with weak binding ability to eukaryotic cells.
However, they strongly bind to the negatively charged bacterial membrane,
leading to cell death by disrupting the bacterial surface. Resistance
to antimicrobial peptides seldom develops, and AMPs have shown great
potential not only against bacterial infections[11] but also as a promising means to prevent biofilm formation
and as anticancer agents.[12]Antibacterial
polymers are good alternatives to traditional small
molecule antibiotics when considering their high efficacy as well
as low toxicity and resistance, combined with their limited environmental
impact.[13−15] Chin and coauthors[16] synthesized
guanidinium-functionalized polycarbonates that do not lead to drug
resistance even after repeated exposure of the polymers to bacteria
for 30 times, and the biodegradability of the polymers further reduced
the accumulation of the polymers in that environment. Cationic macromolecules
such as antimicrobial peptides,[17,18] cationic peptidopolysaccharides,[19] cationic dendrimers,[20,21] and their hydrogels[22,23] have shown great promise as broad-spectrum
antibacterial materials. The primary bacterial membrane-disrupting
mechanism of the cationic materials not only leads to their efficient
bacterial killing ability but also reduces the potential to induce
drug resistance.[24,25] Cationic antimicrobial peptides
and dendrimers, however, display inherent cytotoxicity toward diverse
primary cells at high concentrations[26] or
at high generations of the dendrimers[27] that limit their therapeutic applications.[28,29] To reduce the cytotoxicity of the materials, synthetic cationic
polymers that mimic AMPs are attracting increasing attention due to
properties which can be tuned to meet the requirements of highly advanced
antibacterial materials that can mask the cytotoxicity of the active
unit.[30] Hyperbranched polymers with highly
branched three-dimensional (3D) architectures possess unique physicochemical
features such as abundant functional groups, intramolecular cavities,
low viscosities, and high solubility as well as the possibility of
large-scale production via facile methods.[31,32] Cationic hyperbranched polymers that mimic AMPs, in particular,
make excellent antibacterial materials[33] and hereby form the basis of this work.Herein, a library
of cationic dendritic hydrogels with inherent
antibacterial properties were developed with promising results for
treatment of skin wound infections. The hydrogels exhibit broad-spectrum
antibacterial activity as well as good biocompatibility and degradability
in a suitable time frame. Most importantly, the cationic hydrogels
can induce innate immune responses in HaCaT, keratinocytes, leading
to efficient bacterial killing both extracellularly and intracellularly
together with reduced inflammation. The present study demonstrates
that functional hydrogels can be carefully designed to achieve tuned
and optimal therapeutic effects.
Results and Discussion
Synthesis
and Characterization of Amino-Functional HBDLDs and
Hydrogels
A new class of amino-functional hyperbranched dendritic–linear–dendritic
copolymers (HBDLDs) based on poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG) and 2,2-bis(hydroxymethyl)propionic
acid (bis-MPA) were synthesized through the conventional pseudo-polycondensation
reaction.[22,34] Hydroxy-terminated HBDLDs were modified
with boc-protected β-alanine by using fluoride-promoted esterification
(FPE) chemistry,[35] followed by the removal
of boc groups by using trifluoroacetic acid (TFA). The amino-functional
HBDLDs are amphiphilic copolymers, composed of a linear hydrophilic
PEG core and dendritic hydrophobic components (Figure a) of fifth generation (G5; 64 amines per
molecule) or sixth generation (G6; 128 amines per molecule). N-Hydroxysuccinimide (NHS) was used to activate the
carboxyl-functional PEG (10 kDa) cross-linker (Figure b). Because of the rapid reaction rate of
the NHS-mediated amidation reaction, the hydrogels can easily be formed
in aqueous solution by simple mixing of the amino-terminated HBDLDs
and the cross-linkers (Figure c). Eight amino groups out of 64 or 128 amino groups per molecule
were used for the cross-linking, leaving sufficient pendant amine
groups that could provide the hydrogels with antibacterial activities.
Figure 1
Schematic
diagram describing the synthesis of (a) amino-functional
HBDLDs, (b) NHS-activated PEG cross-linker, and (c) and amino-functional
hydrogels.
Schematic
diagram describing the synthesis of (a) amino-functional
HBDLDs, (b) NHS-activated PEG cross-linker, and (c) and amino-functional
hydrogels.The HBDLDs and cross-linkers were
characterized via NMR spectroscopy
(Supporting Information). NMR spectroscopy
was used to confirm that the HBDLDs had reached completion by the
absence of free carboxylic groups emanating from bis-MPA monomer or
their oligomers as well as comparing the theoretical and calculated
ratios of protons from the methyl groups of bis-MPA, methylene groups
of PEG, and the internal methylene group of bis-MPA (Figure S1). The full substitution of the hydroxy groups with
boc-protected β-alanine was confirmed by 13C NMR
spectroscopy; after the functionalization of boc-protected β-alanine
at the terminal of HBDLDs, the peak of bis-MPA at the terminal (50.2
ppm, (−COO–C–((CH2–OH)2) totally disappeared, and peak f (at 36.08 ppm) and peak
g (at 34.38 ppm) corresponding to β-alanine appeared in the 13C NMR spectroscopy (Figure S2). Figure showed the 1H NMR (Figure a) and 13C NMR (Figure b) spectra of amino-functional HBDLDs. Peak 9 in Figure a represented the
amine groups of β-alanine. The β-alanine peaks in 13C NMR (Figure b) were presented at 35.02 ppm (peak 7) and 30.83 ppm (peak 8), and
together with 19F NMR (Figure S3) spectra, the functionalization of HBDLDs with β-alanine had
occurred efficiently. The hydrogels were named based on the generation
and PEG length (e.g., H10K-G5 represents the hydrogel formed from
PEG10K-G5-NH3+). The hydrogel formation process
and their mechanical properties were analyzed by using rheology (Figure c). The precursor
solution was placed in the rheometer and premixed for 2 s before the
measurement. The storage moduli of the hydrogels increased rapidly
and reached a stable plateau within minutes, indicating that hydrogel
gelation is very efficient and fast. The storage moduli of the hydrogels
ranged from 638 to 2969 Pa. Different from most traditional wound
dressing materials, these hydrogels can be degraded within 24 h (Figure d) due to the rapid
hydrolysis of ester bonds of the dendritic component at physiological
pH of 7.4. As potential antibacterial wound dressing materials, it
is therefore no need to change the wound dressing, which could be
a cause of secondary damage to the wounds.[36] The degradability of the hydrogels is also beneficial in minimizing
the probability of developing drug-resistant strains because the antibacterial
materials do not have sufficient time to accumulate and cause resistance
in the environment.[37] Scanning electron
microscopy (SEM) images of the hydrogels are shown in Figure e and Figure S4 where the porous structure of the hydrogels is clearly observed.
Porosity is known to be highly beneficial in accelerating wound healing,
as it improves cell migration as well as water and oxygen transfer.[38]
Figure 2
Characterization of the amino-functional HBDLDs and hydrogels.
(a) 1H NMR spectroscopy spectrum of PEG10K-G5-NH3+ in DMSO-d6. (b) 13C NMR spectroscopy spectrum of PEG10K-G5-NH3+ in MeOD. (c) Gelation process monitored by rheology at room temperature;
time sweeps were performed by using strain (ϒ) = 1% and frequency
(ω) = 1 Hz. (d) Normalized storage modulus as a function of
time during hydrogel degradation measured by a time sweep in the rheometer
with the sample submerged in PBS (pH 7.4) buffer at 37 °C. (e)
SEM image of the hydrogel (H10K-G5) showing porous structure.
Characterization of the amino-functional HBDLDs and hydrogels.
(a) 1H NMR spectroscopy spectrum of PEG10K-G5-NH3+ in DMSO-d6. (b) 13C NMR spectroscopy spectrum of PEG10K-G5-NH3+ in MeOD. (c) Gelation process monitored by rheology at room temperature;
time sweeps were performed by using strain (ϒ) = 1% and frequency
(ω) = 1 Hz. (d) Normalized storage modulus as a function of
time during hydrogel degradation measured by a time sweep in the rheometer
with the sample submerged in PBS (pH 7.4) buffer at 37 °C. (e)
SEM image of the hydrogel (H10K-G5) showing porous structure.The intrinsically adhesive property of the wound
dressing materials
is highly advantageous in the healing process.[39] Proper adhesion of the material to the skin surface would
ensure minimal damage to the wound and surrounding skin by avoiding
extra fixation and secondary damage when removing the fixation.[36] The cationic hydrogels can adhere to raw porcine
skin and various other surfaces such as wood, metal, glass, plastic,
and aluminum foil (Figure ), confirming the adhesive property and their potential use
as antibacterial coating materials. The adhesive property of the hydrogels
is probably due to the presence of amine groups.[40] In addition, the adhesive force of the hydrogel can withstand
intense shaking and bending (Video S1),
indicating that the hydrogel can be applied on the skin without the
need of extra fixation.
Figure 3
Adhesive property of the cationic hydrogels
on different surfaces.
Adhesive property of the cationic hydrogels
on different surfaces.
Antibacterial Study of
the Amino-Functional HBDLDs
The antibacterial properties
of the amino-functional HBDLDs, hydroxy-terminated
HBDLDs, and β-alanine were investigated by using minimum inhibitory
concentration (MIC) and minimum bactericidal concentration (MBC) assays.
MIC is the lowest concentration of an agent that will inhibit the
visible growth of a microorganism, while MBC is the lowest concentration
of a chemical needed to kill a microorganism. The antibacterial property
of the cationic polymers is related to the density of amino groups,
with respect to both configuration and the molecular weight of the
polymers.[22,41] Hydroxy-terminated HBDLDs and β-alanine
showed no obvious antibacterial activity, with MIC values above 2000
μg mL–1 (Table S1), while the amino-functional HBDLDs showed excellent broad-spectrum
antibacterial properties against wound-related bacteria including Staphylococcus aureus (S. aureus), methicillin-resistant S. aureus (MRSA), Group A streptococcus (GAS), Pseudomonas
aeruginosa (P. aeruginosa), and Escherichia coli (E. coli) (Table ). Some of the amino-functional HBDLDs inhibited the
growth of P. aeruginosa and E. coli at low concentrations in the nanomolar
range. For example, 6K-G6 has a MIC value of 15.6 μg mL–1 toward P. aeruginosa, with the molar concentration of 0.35 μM. MIC or MBC values
of 6K-G6 and 10K-G6 toward E. coli 208 are 15.6 μg mL–1 (0.35 μM) and
31.3 μg mL–1 (0.65 μM), respectively.
6K-G6 exhibits the best efficacy toward most tested bacteria primarily
due to its shorter PEG lengths (lower molecular weight compared with
PEG10K and PEG20K) and more concentrated amino groups at the higher
generation (G6). Furthermore, most MIC values are similar to MBC values,
evident of the remarkable bactericidal effects of the amino-functional
HBDLDs.
Table 1
MIC and MBC Values of the Amino-Functional
HBDLDsa
bacteria
E. coli 178
E. coli 208
S. aureus 2569
S. aureus 7920
MRSA
P. aeruginosa 22644
GAS
polymers
μg/mL
μM
μg/mL
μM
μg/mL
μM
μg/mL
μM
μg/mL
μM
μg/mL
μM
μg/mL
μM
MIC
6K-G5
15.6
0.63
15.6
0.63
125
5.02
125
5.02
125
5.02
62.5
2.51
125
5.02
6K-G6
31.3
0.71
15.6
0.35
62.5
1.42
125
2.84
125
2.84
15.6
0.35
125
2.84
10K-G5
62.5
2.16
62.5
2.16
250
8.64
125
4.32
125
4.32
62.5
2.16
125
4.32
10K-G6
31.3
0.65
31.3
0.65
62.5
1.30
125
2.60
125
2.60
31.3
0.65
125
2.60
20K-G5
125
3.21
250
6.42
125
3.21
125
3.21
125
3.21
20K-G6
125
2.14
125
2.14
62.5
1.07
125
1.07
250
4.28
62.5
1.07
250
4.28
MBC
6K-G5
15.6
0.63
31.3
1.76
125
5.02
125
5.02
125
5.02
62.5
2.51
125
5.02
6K-G6
31.3
0.71
15.6
0.35
62.5
1.42
125
2.84
125
2.84
15.6
0.35
125
2.84
10K-G5
62.5
2.16
62.5
2.16
250
8.64
125
4.32
125
4.32
62.5
2.16
125
4.32
10K-G6
62.5
1.30
31.3
0.65
62.5
1.30
125
2.60
125
2.60
31.3
0.65
125
2.60
20K-G5
125
3.21
250
6.42
250
6.42
250
6.42
125
3.21
20K-G6
125
2.14
125
2.14
125
2.14
125
2.14
250
4.28
62.5
1.07
250
4.28
S. aureus 2569, S. aureus 7920, MRSA, P. aeruginosa 22644,
and GAS (group A streptococcus)
are all isolated from wounds. The amino-functional polymers were abbreviated,
e.g., 6K-G5 represents PEG6K-G5-NH3+ with PEG
length of 6K and the fifth generation.
S. aureus 2569, S. aureus 7920, MRSA, P. aeruginosa 22644,
and GAS (group A streptococcus)
are all isolated from wounds. The amino-functional polymers were abbreviated,
e.g., 6K-G5 represents PEG6K-G5-NH3+ with PEG
length of 6K and the fifth generation.The effects of the amino-functional HBDLDs on the
morphology of E. coli, P. aeruginosa, and S. aureus were investigated
by using SEM. As seen from Figure , distinct changes occurred in all strains of bacteria
that were treated with 250 μg mL–1 of PEG10K-G5-NH3+ and incubated for 6 h at 37 °C. Not only
did the amino-functional HBDLDs damage the cell membrane of E. coli, but the materials also had a large
impact on E. coli fimbriae (Figure a,b), forming particles
on the surface of the bacteria (arrows, Figure b). E. coli fimbriae play an important role in the attachment to the host cell
surface as the first step in the bacterial infection[42] and are a prerequisite to the formation of biofilms[43] and evading extracellular antibiotics.[44] The results suggest that the amino-functional
HBDLDs exhibit great potential in preventing the formation of E. coli biofilms. Compared with untreated P. aeruginosa cells (Figure c), treated bacteria exhibited small holes
in the cell membranes (Figure d). Obvious shrinkage occurred compared with the untreated P. aeruginosa, indicating leakage of the cell content
after incubation with the PEG10K-G5-NH3+. Treated S. aureus exhibited clear indications of damaged
cell membranes (Figure f) while untreated S. aureus cells
displayed the typical smooth, spherical shapes (Figure e). The amino-functional HBDLDs imparted
similar disrupting effects on the anionic bacterial membranes as compared
to other documented cationic polymers[45] and were able to target E. coli fimbriae. In addition, there was a marked decrease in the number
of attached E. coli and P. aeruginosa after treatment with PEG10K-G5-NH3+ (Figure S5).
Figure 4
SEM images
showing the morphological changes of bacteria with and
without treatment of 250 μg mL–1 PEG10K-G5-NH3+ for 6 h at 37 °C. (a) Untreated E. coli 178 with visible fimbriae. (b) Treated E. coli 178 with damaged cell surfaces and reduced
number of fimbriae. (c) Untreated P. aeruginosa 22644. (d) Treated P. aeruginosa 22644
with porosity on the cell surfaces. (e) Untreated S. aureus 7920. (f) Treated S. aureus 7920
with damaged cell surfaces.
SEM images
showing the morphological changes of bacteria with and
without treatment of 250 μg mL–1 PEG10K-G5-NH3+ for 6 h at 37 °C. (a) Untreated E. coli 178 with visible fimbriae. (b) Treated E. coli 178 with damaged cell surfaces and reduced
number of fimbriae. (c) Untreated P. aeruginosa 22644. (d) Treated P. aeruginosa 22644
with porosity on the cell surfaces. (e) Untreated S. aureus 7920. (f) Treated S. aureus 7920
with damaged cell surfaces.
Cytotoxicity Evaluation of the Amino-Functional HBDLDs and Hydrogels
To confirm that the wound dressing materials did not cause cytotoxic
effects, two types of human skin cells, human keratinocytes (HaCaT)
and human dermal fibroblasts (hDF), were used to evaluate the in vitro cytotoxicity of the amino-functional HBDLDs and
the cationic dendritic hydrogels. The concentrations of the amino-functional
HBDLDs were chosen based on the MIC values, and the cells and the
amino-functional HBDLDs were incubated for 24 h at 37 °C. No
significant cytotoxicity toward either HaCaT (Figure a) or hDF (Figure b) cells was found, as made evident by cell
viability values above ∼80% (based on ISO 10993-5:2009)[46] which indicates that the amino-functional HBDLDs
are biocompatible at their MIC values. All cationic dendritic hydrogels
exhibited good biocompatibility toward HaCaT (Figure c) and hDF (Figure d) cells, with cell viability above 80% after
incubation with cells for 24 h. The G5 hydrogels exhibited better
biocompatibility than G6 hydrogels at comparable PEG lengths, likely
because the G6 hydrogels have greater cationic charges leading to
stronger interactions with the cells. The H10K-G5 hydrogel formed
from PEG10K-G5-NH3+ exhibited excellent biocompatibility
toward both HaCaT (cell viability 101%) and hDF (cell viability 108%)
cells. Potent and biocompatible, the H10K-G5 hydrogel was identified
and used for the in vitro cell infection study and
immunomodulation activities in HaCaT cells.
Figure 5
Cytotoxicity evaluation
of the amino-functional HBDLDs and hydrogels.
(a) The amino-functional HBDLDs toward HaCaT cells determined by XTT
assay and (b) hDF cells using the alamarBlue assay. (c) Cationic hydrogels
toward HaCaT cells determined by the XTT assay and (d) hDF cells using
the alamarBlue assay. All data are shown as a mean value ± SD
(n = 6).
Cytotoxicity evaluation
of the amino-functional HBDLDs and hydrogels.
(a) The amino-functional HBDLDs toward HaCaT cells determined by XTT
assay and (b) hDF cells using the alamarBlue assay. (c) Cationic hydrogels
toward HaCaT cells determined by the XTT assay and (d) hDF cells using
the alamarBlue assay. All data are shown as a mean value ± SD
(n = 6).
Antibacterial Activity of the Amino-Functional Hydrogels
Hydrogels are excellent materials for wound dressing because of their
soft and pliable tactile properties, which would provide ideal contact
on the skin and maintain the moist environment beneficial for optimal
wound healing. Hydrogels with inherent antibacterial properties are
beneficial to wound healing[47] because they
can combat bacterial infections without the addition of extra antibacterial
agents. The antibacterial properties of the cationic dendritic hydrogels
toward E. coli, P. aeruginosa, and S. aureus were explored to assess this, where it was found that H10K-G6 and
H10K-G5 exhibited 100% killing efficacy toward E. coli (Figure a), S. aureus (Figure c), and P. aeruginosa (Figure b) at all
bacterial concentrations ranging from 105 to 108 CFU mL–1. The bacterial killing efficacy of H20K-G6
against E. coli (Figure a) and P. aeruginosa (Figure b) was also
100% over these bacterial concentrations. More than 99% of S. aureus was killed at concentrations of 105 and 106 CFU mL–1 (Figure c), and 93% and 87% of S. aureus were killed at concentrations of 107 and 108 CFU mL–1, respectively.
These results suggest that the cationic dendritic hydrogels are effective
as antibacterial materials for treating serious bacterial infections.
As the hydrogels start to degrade within an hour, the effective antibacterial
performance is probably the combination of dual actions from the hydrogels
and their degradation products.
Figure 6
Antibacterial activity of hydrogels against
(a) E. coli 178, (b) P. aeruginosa 22644, and (c) S. aureus 7920
after incubation with different bacterial concentrations for 6 h at
37 °C. (d) In vitro cell infection assay in
HaCaT cells using H10K-G5 hydrogel and a commercial wound dressing
hydrogel as control.
Antibacterial activity of hydrogels against
(a) E. coli 178, (b) P. aeruginosa 22644, and (c) S. aureus 7920
after incubation with different bacterial concentrations for 6 h at
37 °C. (d) In vitro cell infection assay in
HaCaT cells using H10K-G5 hydrogel and a commercial wound dressing
hydrogel as control.An in vitro cell infection study was performed
by using HaCaT cells to assess the ability of the cationic dendritic
hydrogels to treat infected skin cells. Keratinocytes, like HaCaT
cells, are located at the outermost layer of the skin and constitute
∼90–95% of the epidermal cell population.[48] Analyses of the intracellular and extracellular
bacteria after treatment with H10K-G5 for 6 h was conducted and compared
with a commercial hydrogel wound dressing. The extracellular and intracellular
bacteria treated with H10K-G5 significantly decreased for both S. aureus and MRSA strains (Figure d). Bacterial survival percentages
of above 100% were found for the commercial hydrogel wound dressing
for both S. aureus and MRSA, suggesting
that the commercial wound dressing is not able to kill or inhibit
the growth of these bacteria (Figure d). Remarkably, intracellular and extracellular MRSA
survival percentages were 1% and 6%, respectively, when HaCaT cells
were infected at the same time that the cationic hydrogel was applied.
When HaCaT cells were infected with bacteria 2 h before applying the
cationic hydrogel, the intracellular and extracellular MRSA survival
percentages were 9% and 51%, respectively. MRSA survival increased
due to the proliferation of bacteria during the 2 h preinfection time,
but the efficiency for treating the preinfected HaCaT is supposed
to be improved by increasing the volume of the cationic hydrogel used
to treat the bacteria. Other types of bacterial strains such as E. coli, P. aeruginosa, and GAS were also tested, and a significant decrease in the bacterial
numbers after treatment with the H10K-G5 hydrogel (Figure S6) was found. These results serve to validate the
ingenuity of these materials and their capacity to treat skin infections
caused by various kinds of bacteria.
Inhibition of E. coli Biofilm
Formation
Inspired by the SEM images showing decreased E. coli fimbriae after treatment with amino-functional
HBDLDs, we hypothesized that these cationic materials may be successful
in affecting the formation of biofilms. To test this, the effects
of the H10K-G5 hydrogel on biofilm formation using E. coli #12 and its isogenic strain lacking curli,
a major biofilm forming fimbriae, were investigated.[49] A significant reduction of new E. coli biofilm formation was found when they were treated with H10K-G5
using crystal violet assay (Figure S7).
To further confirm the association of H10K-G5 with E. coli curli, an E. coli strain expressing curli, WE1bcsA (curli +/cellulose
−), was used for the biofilm assay. The results show that treatment
with H10K-G5 significantly reduces initial biofilm formation in curli
positive strains (Figure S7). Although
bacteria can attach on the cationic hydrogels due to the attraction
of the opposite charges, the degradability of the hydrogels can efficiently
prevent the formation of biofilm on the surface of the gels.
Immune
Modulation in HaCaT Cells
When considering that
the cationic hydrogels are primarily interacting with negatively charged
bacterial surfaces, we hypothesized that bacteria within the cells
might be killed by the antimicrobial peptides secreted by HaCaT cells
themselves. The effects of cationic dendritic hydrogels on the immunomodulation
activity of HaCaT cells were therefore investigated. Antimicrobial
peptides RNase7 (gene: RNASE7) and psoriasin (gene: S100A7) are predominantly
present in human skin. The expressions of RNASE7 and S100A7 were detected
by using quantitative polymerase chain reaction (qPCR) with and without
treatment of H10K-G5. The expressions of RNASE7 and S100A7 were constitutively
expressed in the steady state and significantly upregulated when H10K-G5
was added (Figure S8a). Similarly, a significant
increase in the expression of RNase7 and psoriasin occurred at the
protein levels. Representative confocal microscopy images are shown
in Figure a, and both
the fluorescence of the RNase7 (Alexa 488, green fluorescence dye)
and psoriasin (Alexa 647, bright, far-red fluorescent dye) within
the cells were clearly enhanced after contact with H10K-G5 as verified
by densitometric analysis (Figure b). The results suggest that cationic dendritic hydrogels
not only kill bacteria through direct interaction but also trigger
HaCaT cells to secret antimicrobial peptides to efficiently kill bacteria
intracellularly. This alteration in gene expression could be due to
a probable dual effect of cationic hydrogels and its degradation products.
Figure 7
(a) Detection
of the antimicrobial peptides, RNase7 and psoriasin
using confocal microscopy, (b) relative densitometric analysis of
RNase7 and psoriasin in HaCaT cells, (c) expression of proinflammatory
cytokine IL-1β in HaCaT cells, (d) nitrite, and (e) mitochondrial
ROS levels in S. aureus-infected
HaCaT cells. All data are shown as mean values ± SD (n = 9 for b and c, n = 6 for d and e).
Significance levels mentioned as **P < 0.01 and
****P < 0.0001.
(a) Detection
of the antimicrobial peptides, RNase7 and psoriasin
using confocal microscopy, (b) relative densitometric analysis of
RNase7 and psoriasin in HaCaT cells, (c) expression of proinflammatory
cytokine IL-1β in HaCaT cells, (d) nitrite, and (e) mitochondrial
ROS levels in S. aureus-infected
HaCaT cells. All data are shown as mean values ± SD (n = 9 for b and c, n = 6 for d and e).
Significance levels mentioned as **P < 0.01 and
****P < 0.0001.In addition, the proinflammatory cytokine IL-1β and free
radical species were also analyzed in S. aureus infected HaCaT cells (infected for 4 h). IL-1β was downregulated
at both mRNA levels (Figure S8b) and the
secreted protein (Figure c) after interaction with H10K-G5, as confirmed with ELISA
from the supernatants. Free radical formation by the host cell is
a host mechanism used to combat bacterial infections; however, an
excess of free radicals also induces apoptotic cell death. A regulation
of the balance between free radical species is therefore required
for physiological activity of the cells. To verify the effect of H10K-G5
on free radical species in HaCaT cells after infection with S. aureus for 4 h, both reactive nitrogen species
(NO) and reactive oxygen species (ROS) were analyzed. The infected
HaCaT cells treated with H10K-G5 showed reduced NO (Figure d) and mitochondrial ROS (Figure e) levels in comparison
to the untreated infected cells as the control, and relative densitometry
analyses of mitochondrial ROS showed lower fluorescence levels upon
hydrogel treatment (Figure S8c,d), suggesting
minimal imposed adverse effects as increased mitochondrial ROS in
keratinocytes might cause cell death via the induction of apoptosis.[50,51] The decreased NO and mitochondrial ROS levels also correspond with
less severe bacterial infections for HaCaT cells treated with H10K-G5.
In addition, the total ROS level (Figure S9) increased after treatment with H10K-G5, likely due to the increased
expression of antimicrobial peptide psoriasin in keratinocytes.[52,53] The decreased IL-1β indicates that the cationic dendritic
hydrogels could likely prevent inflammatory responses, while the decreased
free radical species suggests that the cationic materials could probably
prevent oxidative stress in S. aureus-infected HaCaT cells.
Conclusion
In summary, a new class
of cationic dendritic hydrogels with inherent
antibacterial properties were developed and tested against both Gram-positive
and Gram-negative clinical strains. The hydrogels performed outstandingly
at eliminating bacterial infections caused by clinical drug-resistant
bacteria and were able to inhibit E. coli biofilm formation. With their excellent biocompatibility, degradability,
anti-inflammatory properties, and the ability to induce host-mediated
bacterial killing by enhancing the expression of the antimicrobial
peptides in HaCaT cells, these cationic dendritic hydrogels present
themselves as promising wound dressing materials to treat skin infections
caused by wound-isolated MDR bacteria.
Authors: David J Payne; Linda Federici Miller; David Findlay; James Anderson; Lynn Marks Journal: Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci Date: 2015-06-05 Impact factor: 6.237
Authors: Oliver C J Andrén; Tobias Ingverud; Daniel Hult; Joakim Håkansson; Yalda Bogestål; Josefin S Caous; Kristina Blom; Yuning Zhang; Therese Andersson; Emma Pedersen; Camilla Björn; Peter Löwenhielm; Michael Malkoch Journal: Adv Healthc Mater Date: 2019-02-08 Impact factor: 9.933
Authors: Ima Avalos Vizcarra; Vahid Hosseini; Philip Kollmannsberger; Stefanie Meier; Stefan S Weber; Markus Arnoldini; Martin Ackermann; Viola Vogel Journal: Sci Rep Date: 2016-01-05 Impact factor: 4.379