| 1: Convenience and accessibility |
Quick and easy to use
| ‘You’d have to be pretty thick not to be able
to follow it. I think so, it’s very user
friendly.’ (nurse practitioner) |
| ‘I think the positive thing is the time saving and
we’re only talking…maybe it saves five minutes a
patient but you use it for six patients in a shift and
there’s half an hour. That’s the difference
between seeing another patient and not. So I like
it.’ (training grade doctor) |
Validates referral to specialists
| ‘I think it’s frustrating for microbiologists
if they get calls about quite easy questions that are clearly
answered by MicroGuide.’ (specialist trainee
doctor) |
| ‘It’s like calling Microbiology without
calling Microbiology.’ (specialist trainee
doctor) |
| ‘Maybe the time where I wouldn’t use it is in
complicated patients who have maybe had antibiotics before. I
think for almost any indication where someone has already had
antibiotics and its failed, that’s the time when
I’d probably talk to Microbiology directly rather than
using the app.’ (training grade doctor) |
Supports ‘in-the-moment’
decision-making
| ‘If there’s a question for example on a ward
round where someone says, oh is that the right antibiotic given
that we now think it’s not chest it’s more likely
to be urine or something? Normally there’s at least three
of us that pull out our phone and it will range between the
junior juniors, the registrar and the
consultant.’ (training grade doctor) |
| ‘It’s quite easy to access on a ward round so
it means that you’ve done the job that you’ve been
asked to do instantly rather than waiting to the afternoon where
you then have to maybe go through the guidelines or have a
discussion with micro about it.’ (training grade
doctor) |
Facilitates prompt initiation of treatment
| ‘If you’ve got someone acutely unwell needing
antibiotics quite urgently you are digging into their golden
hour quite considerably by having to go and find a computer
somewhere. If you can look at it at the bedside, a minute later
you’ve written a prescription and you can hand it to the
relevant person.’ (nurse practitioner) |
| 2: Confidence to validate prescribing decisions |
Support for decision-making outside area of expertise
| ‘I don’t know everything and I can’t
remember everything.’ (specialist trainee
doctor) |
| ‘I think right from a senior level on ward rounds
we’re encouraged to use it and it’s used as a
decision-making tool for choice and the fact that consultants
use it makes you use it as well.’ (training
grade doctor) |
Integration with existing clinical expertise
| ‘Actually probably eight or nine times out of ten if
I was prescribing an antibiotic I would probably look to make
sure we’re adhering to the guidelines.’
(consultant/attending physician) |
| ‘It means that if someone senior, for example, a
consultant is considering a particular antibiotic choice you can
then have a discussion because it’s then very easy to
then very quickly say well this is what the guideline would
be.’ (training grade doctor) |
Integration with specialist advice
| ‘From an antimicrobial guardianship that’s
important as well and also the microbiologists having knowledge
of what the local flora and fauna are, so what is the issue
around here, what are local urinary tract infections sensitive
to compared to what they might be in Southampton or wherever. I
think that’s useful.’
(consultant/attending physician) |
| 3: Trust in app content |
Use as a ‘pocket expert’
| ‘I guess my job is to diagnose what infection
they’ve got and then rely on the experts who have made
MicroGuide to tell me what antibiotics are most likely to be
helpful’ (specialist trainee doctor) |
| ‘MicroGuide puts all the information in one place
which can be useful. It does mean it’s a more wieldy
document which you couldn’t put on to a credit card sized
thing, but it does mean that all the information is in one
place.’ (consultant/attending physician) |
Faith in app content
| ‘The advantages are that it’s quite slick and
easy to use and I suppose I trust it because it’s
ratified by NHS organizations.’ (training grade
doctor) |
| ‘Everyone’s MicroGuide is unique to the local
population that the microbiologists have been having an input
into.’ (consultant/attending physician) |
Value as learning tool
| ‘We almost use it as a sort of test. If we turn
around and say, “What would you prescribe?” and if
they say something, we say, “Is that in line with what
our local protocol tells us? Why don’t we check on
MicroGuide?” so it almost acts as a back-up to almost
teach them—the junior doctor—and go from
there.’ (consultant/attending physician) |
| ‘For me its educating me about the
different—I’m still young in
prescribing—the different antibiotics for different
indications, different infections.’ (nurse
practitioner) |
| 4: Promotion of stewardship |
Value to organization
| ‘I would say that in the last few years the benefit
has been clearly a drop or reduction in the use of some of the
more expensive broad-spectrum antibiotics, for example,
tazobactam and piperacillin, vancomycin or even carbapenems, so
that has certainly been something which the app has probably
enabled.’ (consultant/attending physician) |
Role in antimicrobial stewardship
| ‘Obviously it’s better for the patient because
you are not throwing them the strongest antibiotics you think
about so it’s going to reduce resistance isn’t
it?’ (training grade doctor) |
| ‘I think it should be mandatory within the NHS. If
there is so much research going on about in particular in a time
where we are trying to preserve the antibiotics that we have I
think that people should be using something that works and this
is all research driven and it’s been proven that these
are the right doses that we should be using.’
(nurse practitioner) |
| 5: Limitations and concerns |
Over-reliance on guidelines
| ‘People blindly follow it and they don’t apply
context and they don’t apply the patient in front of
them, they just do what MicroGuide advises’
(specialist trainee doctor) |
| ‘I don’t even know who has put the information
on. No, I don’t know what the origin of that is, I have
no idea at all.’ (specialist trainee
doctor) |
| ‘I suppose if there was someone that relies on it
100% and it does then switch their brain off from
thinking then maybe that’s not great for them but
[…] it will still be fine for the patient, it would still
be fine for the hospital and it would still be fine for the
wider population, they just wouldn’t be
learning.’ (training grade doctor) |
Use of smartphones in clinical areas
| ‘You have to have a phone to do your job and yet the
NHS is not prepared to contribute to that. I think it would be
dead handy if there were better opportunities to be able to
charge your phone around the Trust.’
(consultant/attending physician) |
| ‘Clearly consultants and junior doctors have mobile
phones in their pockets and clearly look at them on a regular
basis so for them it’s fine, but for say the nurses and
therapists, that would be something which they wouldn’t
necessarily engage with.’ (consultant/attending
physician) |
Technical glitches
| ‘I’ve had a few issues with it not working.
There was a period of time where it didn’t work very well
and it kept crashing. I think it’s better now I’ve
got a newer phone.’ (training grade doctor) |
| ‘It does take a minute or two to come up. Really
that’s not a big issue except in our modern rushed world,
it’s like come on, come on.’
(consultant/attending physician) |