| Literature DB >> 34622709 |
Abstract
PRACTICAL RELEVANCE: Cats have become increasingly common as companion animals, and in many countries their popularity now exceeds that of dogs. At the same time, human allergies (including allergy to cats) have been increasing and it has been estimated that globally up to 10-20% of human adults are sensitised to cats. AIM: This review summarises the available published data on how human allergy to cats affects cat ownership and considers the implications of the findings on the wider human-cat bond and how adverse effects can be minimised. EVIDENCE BASE: Online databases were searched for all original studies up to December 2020 that had quantified the impact of human allergy to cats on ownership or relinquishment. Objective quantifiable data appeared to fall into three broad outcomes - (1) choosing to avoid cat ownership; (2) relinquishment of owned cats; and (3) return of cats after acquisition from a rehoming centre. The data retrieved on these topics are the focus of this review. In some studies, data from cats and dogs were combined and these have also been included in the review.Entities:
Keywords: Allergy; human; ownership; relinquishment
Mesh:
Year: 2021 PMID: 34622709 PMCID: PMC8721548 DOI: 10.1177/1098612X211013016
Source DB: PubMed Journal: J Feline Med Surg ISSN: 1098-612X Impact factor: 2.015
Reasons for avoiding cat (or cat and dog) ownership
| Study | Study overview | Number of people in study | Proportion citing allergy as a reason | Other, more common reasons cited | Other, equally or less common reasons cited (not necessarily
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Leslie et al (1994)
| Reasons for not owning either a cat or a dog, Canada | ~160 | 36% | ✜ Problems when I go away (82%)
| ✜ Too expensive (35%)
|
| American Humane Association (2012)
| Reasons for never owning a cat, USA | 500 | 18% | ✜ Do not like cats (35%)
| ✜ Veterinary expenses (18%)
|
| American Humane Association (2012)
| Reason for not owning a cat for ≥12 months, USA | 500 | 16% | ✜ Problems when I travel (28%)
| ✜ Do not like cats (12%)
|
| Bibbo et al
| Reasons for not owning either a cat or a dog for ≥12 months, USA | 668 | 6% | ✜ Insufficient time (32%)
| ✜ Health risks (2%) |
Reasons for relinquishing a pet cat (or pet cat or dog)
| Study | Study overview | Number of people in study | Proportion citing allergy as a reason | Other, more common reasons cited | Other, equally or less common reasons cited (not necessarily
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Miller et al (1996)
| Main reasons owners relinquished cats to Humane Society in Ohio, USA | 74 | 15% | ✜ Moving house (29%) | ✜ Behavioural problems (14%)
|
| DiGiacomo et al (1998)
| Main reasons for relinquishment of cats (n = 26) or dogs (n = 27) to shelter in Boston, USA | 38 | 18% | ✜ Behavioural problems (32%) | ✜ Moving (18%)
|
| Salman et al (1998)
| NCPPSP survey of relinquished cats at 12 centres, USA | 1409 | 19% | ✜ Behavioural problems (33%)
| ✜ Moving house (18%)
|
| American Humane Association (2012)
| Reasons for rehoming or surrendering a pet cat, USA | 105 | 11% | ✜ Not allowed to have a cat (21%) | ✜ Death/divorce in family (8%)
|
| Weiss et al (2015)
| Telephone survey following up on cats (n = 199) or dogs (n = 391) rehomed to family, friends, shelters and other places, USA | 590 | 6% | ✜ Pet-related problems (46%)
| ✜ Cost issues (5%)
|
| Alberthsen et al (2016)
| Reasons for relinquishment of owned cats to 39 RSPCA shelters, Australia | 49,393 | 3% | ✜ Accommodation-related (19%)
| ✜ Cat’s health (2%)
|
| Zito et al (2016)
| Cats surrendered to three RSPCA shelters, Australia | 55 | 18% | ✜ Accommodation-related (57%)
| ✜ Human health (12%)
|
| Hazel et al (2018)
| Online rehoming of cats in Australia | 7 | 14% | ✜ Not getting on with other pets
| ✜ Expecting a baby (14%)
|
| Casey et al (2009)
| Cats surrendered to 11 Cats Protection centres, UK | 6089 | 5% | ✜ Stray/abandoned (31%)
| ✜ Multiple factors (5%)
|
NCPPSP = National Council of Pet Population Study and Policy; RSPCA = Royal Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals
Study showed 15% reported owner health issues, ‘especially allergies’
Reasons for failure of cat (or cat and dog) rehoming
| Study | Study overview | Number of people in study | Proportion citing allergy as a reason | Other, more common reasons cited | Other, equally or less common reasons cited (not necessarily
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Neidhart and Boyd (2002)
| Failure of cat adoptions from two shelters and two adoption campaigns, USA | 42 | 10% | ✜ Cat had died (36%)
| ✜ Behavioural problems (10%)
|
| Shore (2005)
| Reasons for returning a cat or dog to a Midwestern rehoming centre, USA | 78 | 10% | ✜ Problems with other pets (14%)
| ✜ Elimination problems (10%)
|
| DiGangi et al (2006)
| Reasons rehoming failed in cats from a research programme, USA | 18 | 17% | ✜ Problems with other pets (22%) | ✜ Inappropriate urination (17%) |
| Hawes et al (2020)
| Reasons for returning cats to a rehoming centre in Texas, USA | 72 | 8% | ✜ Moving house (19%)
| ✜ Medical reasons (6%)
|
| Casey et al (2009)
| Cats returned to 11 Cats Protection centres after being homed, UK | 166 | 18% | ✜ Behavioural problems (38%)
| ✜ Stray/abandoned (5%)
|
Reason provided was ‘Human allergies, human illness’ and the two were not separated
Figure 1From published data, human allergy to cats appears to be a common cause of cat relinquishment. However, many cat-allergic owners choose to continue to live with their cats despite the impact it may have on the human-cat bond. Image by Annette Meyer from Pixabay