| Literature DB >> 34616550 |
Grace J Lee1, Keiji Oda2, Kelly R Morton1,3, Michael Orlich2,4, Joan Sabate2.
Abstract
Eggs contain important compounds related to enhanced cognition, but it is not clear if egg consumption, as a whole, has a direct impact on memory decline in older adults. This study aimed to determine whether egg intake levels predict the rate of memory decline in healthy older adults after sociodemographic and dietary controls. We conducted a secondary analysis of data from 470 participants, age 50 and over, from the Biospsychosocial Religion and Health Study. Participants completed a food frequency questionnaire, which was used to calculate egg intake and divide participants into Low (<23 g/week, about half an egg), Intermediate (24-63 g/week, half to 1½ eggs) and High (≥63 g/week, about two or more eggs) tertiles. Participants were administered the California Verbal Learning Test - 2nd Edition (CVLT-II) Short Form in 2006-2007, and 294 of them were again tested in 2010-2011. Using linear mixed model analysis, no significant cross-sectional differences were observed in CVLT-II performance between egg intake levels after controlling for age, sex, race, education, body mass index, cardiovascular risk, depression and intake of meat, fish, dairy and fruits/vegetables. Longitudinally, the Intermediate egg group exhibited significantly slower rates of decline on the CVLT-II compared to the Low egg group. The High egg group also exhibited slower rates of decline, but not statistically significant. Thus, limited consumption of eggs (about 1 egg/week) was associated with slower memory decline in late life compared to consuming little to no eggs, but a dose-response effect was not clearly evident. This study may help explain discrepancies in previous research that did not control for other dietary intakes and risk factors.Entities:
Keywords: AHS-2, Adventist Health Study-2; BMI, body mass index; BRHS, Biopsychosocial Religion and Health Substudy; CES-D, Center for Epidemiological Studies Depression Scale; CV, cardiovascular; CVLT-II, California Verbal Learning Test – 2nd Edition, Short Form; CVLT-PC, CVLT-II Principal Components Factor Score; Cognition; Cognitive aging; Diet; Eggs; FFQ, food frequency questionnaire; Memory; Older adults
Mesh:
Year: 2021 PMID: 34616550 PMCID: PMC8477346 DOI: 10.1017/jns.2021.76
Source DB: PubMed Journal: J Nutr Sci ISSN: 2048-6790
Baseline characteristics of participants across categories of egg consumption
| Low | Intermediate | High | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| <23 g/week | 24–63 g/week | ≥63 g/week | ||
| 119 (25⋅3 %) | 177 (37⋅7 %) | 174 (37⋅0 %) | ||
| Age, years | 68⋅18 (11⋅14) | 70⋅38 (11⋅44) | 68⋅58 (11⋅26) | 0⋅182 |
| Sex, female | 74 (62⋅2 %) | 109 (61⋅6 %) | 111 (63⋅8 %) | 0⋅908 |
| Race | ||||
| Non-black | 77 (64⋅7 %) | 116 (65⋅5 %) | 106 (60⋅9 %) | 0⋅641 |
| Black | 42 (35⋅3 %) | 61 (34⋅5 %) | 68 (39⋅1 %) | |
| Education | ||||
| High school or less | 3 (2⋅5 %) | 11 (6⋅3 %) | 9 (5⋅2 %) | 0⋅427 |
| Some college | 38 (32⋅2 %) | 53 (30⋅5 %) | 64 (36⋅8 %) | |
| College degree or higher | 77 (65⋅3 %) | 110 (63⋅2 %) | 101 (58⋅0 %) | |
| BMI | 25⋅85 (4⋅75) | 27⋅52 (5⋅11) | 27⋅75 (6⋅01) | 0⋅007 |
| CV risk | ||||
| No CV risks | 39 (33⋅1 %) | 45 (25⋅9 %) | 51 (29⋅3 %) | 0⋅310 |
| CV risks | 68 (57⋅6 %) | 117 (67⋅2 %) | 115 (66⋅1 %) | |
| History of CV event | 11 (9⋅3 %) | 12 (6⋅9 %) | 8 (4⋅6 %) | |
| CES-D | 2⋅66 (3⋅23) | 3⋅68 (3⋅49) | 2⋅80 (3⋅08) | 0⋅007 |
| Total energy (kcal/d) | 1740⋅91 | 1595⋅12 | 1742⋅10 | 0⋅138 |
| (Median [IQR]) | [1359⋅66, 2301⋅33] | [1239⋅38, 2229⋅08] | [1471⋅67, 2246⋅69] | |
| Egg intake (g/d) | 1⋅47 | 5⋅56 | 17⋅62 | <0⋅001 |
| (Median [IQR]) | [0⋅82, 2⋅20] | [4⋅62, 7⋅05] | [12⋅33, 22⋅87] | |
| Meat intake (g/d) | 0 | 0 | 8⋅68 | <0⋅001 |
| (Median [IQR]) | [0⋅00, 0⋅00] | [0⋅00, 9⋅65] | [ 0⋅00, 33⋅00] | |
| Fish intake (g/d) | 0 | 0 | 6⋅69 | <0⋅001 |
| (Median [IQR]) | [0⋅00, 3⋅28] | [0⋅00, 12⋅98] | [ 0⋅00, 17⋅51] | |
| Dairy intake (g/d) | 26⋅27 | 102⋅75 | 126⋅45 | <0⋅001 |
| (Median [IQR]) | [7⋅08, 104⋅63] | [34⋅50, 240⋅62] | [56⋅79, 256⋅50] | |
| Fruit/vegetable intake (g/d) | 699⋅65 | 589⋅41 | 515⋅11 | <0⋅001 |
| (Median [IQR]) | [512⋅99, 905⋅68] | [444⋅74, 805⋅32] | [384⋅42, 658⋅69] | |
CV, cardiovascular; CES-D, Center for Epidemiological Studies Depression Scale; IQR, interquartile range.
Baseline characteristics of participants who completed both baseline and follow-up visits
| Baseline | Follow-up | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Age, years | 69⋅16 (11⋅32) | 68⋅4 (10⋅90) | 0⋅093 |
| Sex | |||
| Female | 294 (62⋅6 %) | 181 (61⋅6 %) | 0⋅636 |
| Male | 176 (37⋅4 %) | 113 (38⋅4 %) | |
| Race | |||
| Non-black | 299 (63⋅6 %) | 201 (68⋅4 %) | 0⋅008 |
| Black | 171 (36⋅4 %) | 93 (31⋅6 %) | |
| Education | |||
| High school or less | 23 (4⋅9 %) | 10 (3⋅4 %) | 0⋅005 |
| Some college | 155 (33⋅3 %) | 86 (29⋅5 %) | |
| College degree or higher | 288 (61⋅8 %) | 196 (67⋅1 %) | |
| BMI | 27⋅18 (5⋅42) | 26⋅84 (5⋅28) | 0⋅075 |
| CV risk | |||
| No CV risks | 135 (29⋅0 %) | 70 (25⋅4 %) | 0⋅087 |
| CV risks | 300 (64⋅4 %) | 184 (66⋅7 %) | |
| History of CV event | 31 (6⋅7 %) | 22 (8⋅8 %) | |
| CES-D | 3⋅09 (3⋅30) | 3⋅00 (3⋅35) | 0⋅280 |
CV, cardiovascular; CES-D, Center for Epidemiological Studies Depression Scale.
Follow-up visit was completed 3⋅3 years after baseline assessment (range = 2⋅7–4⋅4 years).
Linear mixed model analysis of the effect of egg intake on CVLT-PC scores
| β | 95 % CI | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Age (centred at 50) | −0⋅050 | 0⋅007 | [−0⋅0628, −0⋅0354] | <0⋅0001 |
| Egg intake | ||||
| Intermediate | −0⋅184 | 0⋅204 | [−0⋅5930, 0⋅2049] | 0⋅368 |
| High | −0⋅040 | 0⋅206 | [−0⋅4990, 0⋅3139] | 0⋅845 |
| Age × egg intake | ||||
| Intermediate | 0⋅018 | 0⋅009 | [0⋅0000, 0⋅0342] | 0⋅043 |
| High | 0⋅011 | 0⋅009 | [−0⋅0044, 0⋅0304] | 0⋅195 |
N 470.
Results are adjusted for sex, race, education, body mass index, cardiovascular risk score, Center for Epidemiological Studies Depression Scale, total energy intake, meat intake, fish intake, dairy intake, and fruit/vegetable intake.
CVLT-PC, California Verbal Learning Test-II Short Form First Principal Components Factor.
Estimated rates of CVLT-PC decline and estimated scores at each decade by the egg intake group
| Estimate | 95 % CI | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Estimated rates of CVLT-PC decline | |||
| Low egg intake | −0⋅0501 | 0⋅0069 | [−0⋅0637, −0⋅0366] |
| Intermediate egg intake | −0⋅0325 | 0⋅0057 | [−0⋅0436, −0⋅0214] |
| High egg intake | −0⋅0388 | 0⋅0056 | [−0⋅0499, −0⋅0278] |
| Estimated CVLT-PC score at age 50 | |||
| Low egg intake | 0⋅515 | 0⋅171 | [0⋅179, 0⋅850] |
| Intermediate egg intake | 0⋅331 | 0⋅154 | [0⋅029, 0⋅632] |
| High egg intake | 0⋅474 | 0⋅148 | [0⋅185, 0⋅764] |
| Estimated CVLT-PC score at age 60 | |||
| Low egg intake | 0⋅013 | 0⋅126 | [−0⋅234, 0⋅260] |
| Intermediate egg intake | 0⋅006 | 0⋅114 | [−0⋅217, 0⋅228] |
| High egg intake | 0⋅086 | 0⋅111 | [−0⋅132, 0⋅304] |
| Estimated CVLT-PC score at age 70 | |||
| Low egg intake | −0⋅488 | 0⋅110 | [−0⋅703, −0⋅273] |
| Intermediate egg intake | −0⋅319 | 0⋅093 | [−0⋅500, −0⋅138] |
| High egg intake | −0⋅302 | 0⋅096 | [−0⋅491, −0⋅114] |
| Estimated CVLT-PC score at age 80 | |||
| Low egg intake | −0⋅990 | 0⋅133 | [−1⋅251, −0⋅728] |
| Intermediate egg intake | −0⋅644 | 0⋅103 | [−0⋅846, −0⋅442] |
| High egg intake | −0⋅690 | 0⋅112 | [−0⋅909, −0⋅471] |
N 470.
CVLT-PC, California Verbal Learning Test-II Short Form First Principal Components Factor.