| Literature DB >> 34566354 |
Blanca Miller-Kobisher1, Dubraska V Suárez-Vega2, Gladys J Velazco de Maldonado3.
Abstract
INTRODUCTION: Epidermal Growth Factor (rhEGF) is a promising skin antiaging agent that successfully promotes skin wound repair, and it has been investigated in the past decade for these purposes. However, there are no updated systematic reviews, in English or English, that support the efficacy of rhEGF as a regenerative skin treatment or systematic reviews that compile the uses of rhEGF as facial aesthetic therapy and regenerative medicine. AIM: To describe the current state of facial aesthetic and regenerative medicine treatments in which rhEGF has been effectively used.Entities:
Keywords: Epidermal growth factor; facial aesthetics; regenerative medicine; skin aging; skin ulcers; ✓ In both cases, it is necessary to biostimulate fibroblasts and keratinocytes, inducing dermal restructuring.; ✓ Similarities exist between the aging skin and wound healing, and mostly they involve the same oxidation and repair mechanisms; ✓ The EFG is more effectively applied by intradermal injections and using transdermal patches, thereby reducing the rhytids, folds, and hyperpigmentation and accelerating wound healing.
Year: 2021 PMID: 34566354 PMCID: PMC8423211 DOI: 10.4103/JCAS.JCAS_25_20
Source DB: PubMed Journal: J Cutan Aesthet Surg ISSN: 0974-2077
Figure 1Flowchart of literature search. Source: Prepared by the authors from the study results
Corpus according to sources and number of papers selected
| Information source | Number of articles | Reference |
|---|---|---|
|
| 28 | [ |
|
| 3 | [ |
|
| 7 | [ |
|
| 1 | [ |
|
| 2 | [ |
|
| 4 | [ |
|
| 4 | [ |
|
|
|
Source: Prepared by the authors from the study results.
Corpus according to the type of study and number of articles found
| Type of study | Number of articles | Reference |
|---|---|---|
| Randomized and controlled clinical trials | 15 | [ |
| Quasi-experimental or not controlled clinical trials | 9 | [ |
| Preclinical trials | 11 | [ |
| Meta-analysis | 2 | [ |
| Systematic review | 2 | [ |
| Traditional review | 9 | [ |
| Case series | 1 | [ |
| Total |
|
Source: Prepared by the authors from the study results.
Research designs under which rhEGF studies were conducted in the area of regenerative medicine
| Type of study | Number of articles | Reference |
|---|---|---|
| Clinical trials | 8 | [ |
| Preclinical trials | 6 | [ |
| Total |
|
Source: Prepared by the authors from the study results.
Applications of the rhEGF in regenerative medicine
| Authors and year of publication | Type of study | Country of origin | Number of participants | Intervention protocol | Follow-up period | Results | Adverse effects |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jeon YJ |
| Korea | Dermal cultures | Skin penetration study of CTP-EGF recombinant protein using fluorescent imaging techniques and synthesis of hyaluronic acid study by immunoblotting and ELISA | Between 6 and 48 hours according to the corresponding laboratory test | CTP-EGF has superior ability, compared with EGF alone, to penetrate the skin and induce hyaluronic acid synthesis and collagen formation. | - |
| Paik SH |
| Korea | 24 Mice | Four days before chemotherapy, topical pretreatment with EFG was performed on hair follicles. | Days 2 and 4 after chemotherapy | EGF is effective as an anagen inducer protecting against chemotherapy-induced alopecia. | - |
| Niiyama H And Kuroyanagi Y, 2014[ |
| Japan | Cell cultures | EGF wound dressing, wound dressing with Vit. C, and dressing with EGF + Vit. C have probed into cytokine production. Fibroblasts were assessed in vitro and cultured. | 7 Days for cell culture | The dressing with EGF and Vit. C improved the production of vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) and hepatocyte growth factor (HGF) compared with the dressing without EGF. | - |
| Yamamoto A |
| Japan | 40 Mice | The effectiveness of wound dressings with EGF, Vit. C, and EGF + Vit. C was assessed in diabetic mice. | 1 Week (clinical and histologic assessment) | The dressing with EGF promoted best granulation tissue and major angiogenesis being more effectively than the other wound dressings.. | No report |
| Esquirol-Caussa J and Herrero-Vila E. 2019[ |
| Spain | 77 Patients | Ulcers are cured by gel using rhEGF gel once per day. | 7 Weeks | The surrounding skin improved in 93.5% of cases. The appearance of the wound improved by 92.2%. The size of the wound was reduced from 66.7% in 43.3% in 4 weeks. | They were not found. |
| Martínez -Peñalver I and Cuevas -Pérez I. 1998[ |
| Cuba | 12 Patients | Topical application twice a day until healing or improvement that would allow successful reoperation | 7 Weeks | 8 cases of complete cicatrization and 4 partial closures. Closures are completed in 34 days. The EGF is an option for patients who cannot undergo pharyngoplasty or where it has not been effective. | They were not found. |
| Kim JW |
| Korea | 138 Patients | Spray rhEGF (experimental) or placebo was applied in oral mucosa twice a day from the day of chemotherapy until oral mucositis resolved. | 28 Days | The spray does not reduce grade 2 of oral mucositis in patients receiving chemotherapy. However, the oral spray reduces pain induced by mucositis. | Transient nausea |
| Shi HX, |
| China | 30 Rats | 1ml of EFG every 2 days in skin wounds; the control group received saline at 0.9% | 14 Days | EGF regulated the synthesis and degradation of the extracellular matrix. EGF regeneration was promoted in animals and in human cells in vitro. | - |
| Lee JH |
| Korea | 40 Animals | Once the burn was induced 14 days after laser irradiation, the gel was started with EFG once a day. | 22 Days | EGF stimulated granulation tissue with accelerated wound closure and minimization of scars, compared with the group without treatment. | It was not observed |
| Kong Mand Hong SE.2013[ |
| Korea | 40 Patients | EFG cream in the irradiated area thrice a day from the start of radiotherapy until 2 weeks after completion of radiotherapy | Weekly during radiotherapy and 6 weeks after completion | Cream with EGF has a beneficial role in preventing or minimizing radiation dermatitis in patients with breast cancer. | They were not recorded |
| Hwang IG |
| Korea | 52 Patients | Cream twice a day in skin lesions (ERSEs or skin-related effects of erlotinib) | 8 Weeks | It is effective in improving all types of ERSEs, regardless of the dose of erlotinib | They were not reported |
| Hernández-Cañete CM |
| Cuba | 17 Patients | Intralesional application thrice a week until complete granulation or healing | - | EGF avoided amputation in Wagner grade 4 diabetic foot ulcers, and 100% evolved to healing. | Muscle spasms |
| Kahraman M |
| Turkey | 34 Patients | Intralesional injections thrice per week for 8 weeks or until healing | 8 Weeks or until healing follow-up to 5 years | Wound closure in 87.9% of injuries. It is effective in reducing the recurrence of long-term ulcers. | Burning pain |
| Lou Z.2019[ |
| China | 24 Patients | Tympanic membrane application once a day | Twice per week for 6 months or until the closure of the tympanic perforation | The closing rate was 100% in 6 days | They were not recorded. |
Source: Prepared by the authors from the study results.
Research designs under which rhEGF studies were conducted in the area of aesthetics
| Type of study | Number of articles | Reference |
|---|---|---|
| Clinical trials | 17 | [ |
| Preclinical trials | 5 | [ |
| Total |
|
Source: Prepared by the authors from the study results.
Applications of the rhEGF in aesthetic medicine
| Authors and year of publication | Type of study | Country of origin | Number of participants | Intervention protocol | Follow-up period | Results | Adverse events |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| McKnight B |
| USA | - | Topical daily application of the human epidermal growth factor in the senile purpura | 6 Weeks | Topical rhEGF decreases the appearance of senile purpura by thickening the skin, and it prevents late-stage dermatoporosis. | They did not report. |
| Kwon SB |
| Korea | 40 Patients: 20 in the control group and 20 in the experimental group | Cream with phytosphingosine-1-phosphate and EGF twice a day for 4 weeks | 6 Weeks | Improved elasticity, density, and dermal hydration; reduction of periocular wrinkles; and phytosphingosine-1-phosphate showed synergistic effects with EGF. | They were not observed. |
| Vivó-Sesé I |
| Spain | 18 Patients in A or experimental group and in B or control group | Before peeling, A group received EGF HA product by digital transdermal introduction, and B group received treatment by manual mesotherapy in 2 sessions (day 7 and day 21). | Days 0, 21, and 35 | The product effectively attenuates wrinkles. The digital transdermal application produced effects faster, and it was the only one that had effects on the depth of wrinkles. | They were not observed. |
| Ha JM |
| Korea | 20 Patients on the left and right sides of the face | For 4 weeks, a patch of microspicles with EGF was applied on the experimental side and the control side. The EGF cream was applied on periocular wrinkles. | Days 0 and 1, 2, 4, and 8 weeks | The patch of EGF produced a statistical increase in dermal density compared with the control group at 4 and 8 weeks. | They were not observed. |
| Barone F |
| USA | 41 Patients | Serum with EGF twice per day for 12 weeks. Expert qualifications and evaluations with a corneometer and cutometer were made. | 12 Weeks | Improved the firmness and hydration of the skin; improved the appearance of periocular wrinkles. Ultrasound showed an increase in dermal restructuring. | They did not report. |
| TechapichethvanichT |
| Thailand | 19 Patients on the right and left side of the face for control and experimental groups | Patients received laser carbon dioxide fractional treatment on both cheeks. They applied EGF ointment daily on one side of the face and Vaseline on the other side. | The hyper pigmentation was evaluated at 2, 3 weeks and at 1, 2 months. | There were no statistically significant differences. However, topical EGF provides significant repair stimulation. | Pruritus |
| Schouest JM |
| USA | 21 Patients | Topical application twice a day for 3 months | Every 30 days up to 3 months | Statistical improvement was found in the rhytids, in the reduction of pore size and pigmentary alterations by photodamage. | Mild inflammation controlled |
| Gawdat HI |
| Egypt | 20 Patients on the experimental side (EGF) and the control side (PRP autologous) | Intradermotherapy every 2 weeks for 3 months, EGF side, and PRP side. The thickness of the epidermis and dermis was evaluated by tomography. | 1 Month to 6 months after the previous session. | Both procedures increased skin turgidity and vitality. The thickness of the epidermis and dermis increased in both groups without differences. | Transient burning sensation in both groups |
| Park GH |
| Korea | 25 Patients | A 532 nm laser was applied. In addition, the experimental group applied the cream with growth factor and the control group applied the control cream. | Days 0, 3, 7, and 35 | The cream with EGF showed statistically significant differences at the end of the study, being more effective in preventing inflammatory hyper pigmentation after laser treatment. | They did not report. |
| Draelos ZD 2016[ |
| USA | 60 Patients | Daily application of serum hyaluronic acid with serum growth factor | Weeks 2, 4, 8, and 12 | Both products improved the skin, with statistically greater differences in serum AH + EGF | They did not report. |
| Lee DH |
| Korea | 23 Patients | EGF serum and hyaluronic acid were applied to the entire face. Photo damage was assessed with photographs and skin and rhytids with a visiometer. | Days 0, 4, and 8 weeks | Periorbital wrinkles improved with statistically significant differences, captured by both the physician and the visiometer. | They were not observed. |
| An JH |
| Korea | 50 Patients divided into experimental and control groups | Patches with acetyl hexapeptide, control patch, and patch with EGF were applied in the nasolabial fold and periorbital area, once a week. | Days 0, 1, 3, 5, 8, and 29 | On day 29, there were statistically significant improvements in wrinkles and skin hydration with the microneedle patch / AHP-8. | They were not observed. |
| Ruri P.2018[ |
| Indonesia | 8 Patients | rhEGF gel using microneedling, 3 sessions every 10 days | Before and after 4 weeks of treatment | Seven patients showed improvement in texture, fine lines, and wrinkles, especially in the periorbital region, reducing the signs of photoaging | Erythema associated with the microneedling |
| Seidel R and Moy RL 2015[ |
| USA | 8 Patients | Application twice a day of serum with EGF in the areas of atrophic acne scars for 12 weeks | Before and after, 3 times at 4-week intervals | Overall, 25% of patients improved their hypertrophic scars mid-level Goodman scale. Researchers surveyed a perceived improvement of 49% in 6 patients. | They were not recorded. |
| Kim J | Korea | 32 Mice | Application of the EGF once a day in the photodamaged and hyperpigmented area for 4 weeks. Previously applied microporation twice a week | 28 Days | Hyperpigmentation improved with EGF. EGF decreased wrinkles, and in-depth and histological analysis indicated re-densification. | - | |
| Kim D | Korea | Cell cultures of young fibroblasts and aged fibroblasts in collagen 3d matrices | Later cultivation was made: Proliferation assay (72h); migration assay (4h); contractility assay (2h); immunohistochemicals (3h) | EGF increased migration and contraction of aged fibroblasts. It improved the collagen matrix more efficiently than young fibroblasts. | - | ||
| Park B | Korea | 12 Rabbits | The inguinal fat was grafted with EGF or with saline (control) solution in the auricular pavilion to observe the volume and changes of adipose tissue. | The grafted fat was collected 3 months later. | In EGF, the survival rate was higher than in the control, increased neovascularization, and maintained fat cell morphology. | - | |
| Draelos ZD |
| USA | 40 Patients | Serum EGF obtained from a culture in dextran to low-tension oxygen tension for 8 weeks was applied daily for 90 days. | At 90 days | Statistically significant improvements were found in skin hydration through corneometry, as well as in the global evaluations of researchers and patients. | Not reported |
| Yamamoto A | Japan | The proliferation of fibroblasts in culture cells with the product HA, Col, EGF, Vit. C, PGA, and Arg | The amount of vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) and hepatocyte growth factor (HGF) produced by fibroblasts was evaluated in an in vitro wound model (cultured dermal substitute: CDS) with cultured EGF for 7 days | The media were prepared and stored at 4 ° C or 37 ° C for a different period of 1 day, 2 weeks, and 4 weeks, respectively. | The effectiveness of EGF remained even after 4 weeks. CDS fibroblasts released more VEGF and HGF in culture with EGF. Fibroblast density increased more in the medium with EGF than in the control medium without EGF. | - |
Source: Prepared by the authors from the study results.